XXIX .
Astronomical Observations relating to the Mountains of the Moon .
By Mr. Herschel of Bath .
Communicated by Dr. Watson , Jun. of Bath , F. R. S. Read May 11 , 1780 .
AT the time when the telescope was first invented this noble instrument was immediately applied to astronomical observations with the most surprising success .
Several very eminent persons have given us an account of their discoveries ; and , notwithstanding the imperfect state of telescopes in those times , we still owe a great deal of our knowledge of the heavenly bodies to the observations that were made by those first telescopic observers , who made amends for the deficiencies of their instruments by their uncommon diligence and attention .
It may , perhaps , be esteemed to be a mere matter of curiosity to search after the height of the lunar mountains .
I grant that there are more necessary and more useful objects of inquiry in the science of astronomy ; but when we consider that the knowledge of the construction of the Moon leads us insensibly to several conVOL .
LXX .
Xxx sequences , sequences , which might not appear at first ; such as the great probability , not to say almost absolute certainty , of her being inhabited , we shall soon agree , that these researches are far from being trifling .
My reason for repeating observations that have been made by very good astronomers was not that I doubted either their veracity or diligence .
The names of GALILEO , HEVELIUS , KIRCHER , and several more , will always deserve to be mentioned with particular respect for the eminent services they have rendered to astronomy ; but as we know that their instruments were far from being arrived to that degree of perfection we have now obtained , I thought it by no means improper or useless to repeat their observations on the lunar mountains , and to extend them to other parts of the Moon 's visible hemisphere , and thereby to establish this theory on the firmest evidence of a survey taken by a very excellent instrument .
The method used by HEVELIUS and others to find the height of a mountain in the Moon is this .
Let a ray of light SLM ( fig. 1 .
) proceeding from the Sun , pass by the Moon at L , and touch the top of a mountain at M : then the space between L and M will appear dark , and the top of the mountain will be seen to stand at some distance from the illuminated part of the Moon 's disk .
With a good micrometer let the distance LM be taken by observation(a ) .
Draw LC perpendicular to LM ; draw also MC from the top of the lunar mountain to the center of the Moon : then in the triangle MLC , rectangled at L , we have given the side LC , which is the Moon 's radius , and the side LM taken by observation .
Therefore , by trigonometry , we can find the hypothenuse MC(b ) , from which , subtracting the part pC or radius , there remains the perpendicular height of the mountain M p. I have followed the same method , as being the least liable to error .
GALILEO takes the distance of the top of a lunar mountain from the line that divides the illuminated part of the disk from that which is in the shade to be equal to a 20th part of the Moon 's diameter ; but HEVELIUS affirms , that it is only the 26th part of the same .
When we calculate from thence the height of such a mountain it will be found , in English measure , according to GALILEO , almost 51/ 2 miles ; and , according to HEVELIUS , something more than 31/ 4 miles , admitting the Moon 's diameter to be 2180 miles .
( a ) I do not recollect that HEVELIUS mentions in what manner he took the distance LM ; but I am apt to believe it was by a micrometer .
( b ) ~ LC~2 + LM~2 = MC .
He says , in his Selenography , p. 266 .
` ` Vera distantia illustratarum cuspidum , a confinio luminis et umbrae , praesertim tempore quadraturae , invenitur , una vigesima sexta part , totius Lunae dimetientis constare ; quando nimirum sunt remotissimae : quemadmodum hoc ex phasi trigesima secunda , monteque Apennino ; ex phasi trigesima prima , monteque Didyme ; et trigesima phasi , monteque Tauro et Antitauro , manifestissime demonstratur .
' ' Having afterwards mentioned that GALILEO makes the distance LM to be the 20th part of the Moon 's diameter , HEVELIUS proceeds , ` ` Quamobrem , cum distantiae a nobis designatae , paululum sint minores , idcirco et montes aliquantulum depressiores inveniuntur , quam GALILAEUS aestimavit : neque non tamen illi terrenis nostris montibus , quoad altitudinem , non solum aequiparari possunt meritissimo ; sed et multo certe sunt excelsiores , quam nostri omnium maximi ; prout confestim , ex adjecto diagrammate patebit .
' ' He gives us then his calculation according to German and Italian measure ; and having found , in the manner above mentioned , the hypothenuse MC , he adds : ` ` Semidiameter Lunae erit 1976 octav .
part .
Si igitur haec a tota hypothenusa auferetur , restabunt adhuc sex , hoc est sex octavae unius milliaris , vel tres quartae unius milliaris Germanici , sive tria milliaria Italica : quae est vera , et genuina altitudo istius montis .
' ' As a German mile in the time of HEVELIUS was a very uncertain measure , we may suppose that he meant geographical miles , 15 of which make a degree of latitude .
The observations of HEVELIUS have always been held in great esteem ; and this is most probably the reason why later astronomers have not repeated them .
M. DE LA LAND , who is one of our most eminent modern astronomers , agrees to the sentiments above cited .
In his Abrege d'Astronomie , p. 435 .
he says , ` ` Je terminerai ce qui concern la felenographie , en disant un mot de la hauteur des montagnes de la lune , qui etoient quelquefois eclairees , quoiqu ' eloignees de la ligne de lumiere de la treizieme party du rayon de la Lune ; de la on peut conclure que ces montagnes ont de hauteur la 338ieme party du rayon Lunaire , ou un lieue de France .
He then gives us a particular calculation , and the result is : ` ` Avec ces donnees on trouve la hauteur de 2643 toises , c'est a dire , plus d'une lieue commune .
' ' He also mentions the opinion of GALILEO , and adds : Mais on doit preferer a cet egard les observations d'HEVELIUS , qui ont ete plus repetees , plus detaillees et plus exactes .
' ' Mr. FERGUSON says ( Astronomy explained , ~ 252 .
) Some of her mountains , by comparing their height with her diameter , are found to be three times higher than the highest hills on our earth .
' ' KEILL , in his Astronomical Lectures , has calculated the height of St. Katherine 's hill , according to the observations of RICCIOLUS , and finds it nine miles .
Before I report my own observations , it will be necessary to explain by what method I have found the height of a lunar mountain from observations that were made when the Moon was not in her quadrature ; for the method laid down by HEVELIUS will only do in that one particular case : in all other positions the projection of the hills must appear much shorter than it really is .
Let SLM , or slm ( fig. 2 .
) be a line drawn from the Sun to the mountain , touching the Moon at L or l , and the mountain at M or m. Then , to an observer at E or e the lines LM , lm , will not appear of the same length , though the mountains should be of an equal height ; for LM will be projected into on , and lm into ON .
But these are the quantities that are taken by the micrometer when we observe a mountain to project from the line of illumination .
From the observed quantity on , when the Moon is not in her quadrature , to find LM we have the following analogy .
The triangles o OL , r ML , are similar ; therefore , LO : LO : : Lr : LM , or LO ~ on/ Lo = LM ; but LO is the radius of the Moon , and Lr , or on , is the observed distance of the mountain 's projection ; and Lo is the sine of the angle ROL=oLS , which we may take to be the distance of the Sun from the Moon without any material error , and which therefore we may find at any given time from an ephemeris .
I will now give an account of my own observations relating to the mountains in the Moon ; but , perhaps , it may not be amiss to mention the instrument they were made with , and a few of the circumstances , that it may appear how far their accuracy may be depended upon .
The telescope I used was a Newtonian reflector of six feet eight inches focal length , to which a micrometer was adapted consisting of two parallel hairs , one of which was moveable by means of a fine screw .
The value of the parts shown by the index was determined by a trigonometrical observation of a known object at a known distance , and was verified by several trials .
The power I always used , except when another is mentioned , was 222 times , also determined by experiment , which I have often found to differ somewhat from theory , on account of some little errors in the data , hardly to be avoided .
The moon having sufficient light , I used no more aperture of the object speculum than four inches ; and , I believe , that for distinctness of vision this instrument is perhaps equal to any that was ever made .
OBSERVATION S. November 30 , 1779 , six o'clock in the morning , a rock , situated near what HEVELIUS calls Lacus niger major , was measured to project 41~,56 .
To reduce this quantity into miles , put R for the semi-diameter of the Moon in seconds , as given by the Nautical Almanac at the time of observation , and Q for the observed quantity , also in seconds and centesimals ; then it will be in general R : 1090 : : Q : 1090 Q/ R=o n , in miles .
Thus it is found that 41~,56 is 46,79 miles .
This distance of the Sun and Moon at the same time was , by the Nautical Almanac , about 93~ 57~1/ 2 .
The sine of which to the radius 1 is.9985 , &amp;c. and on/ Lo in this case , is LM = 46,85 miles .
Then , by HEVELIUS'S method the perpendicular height of the rock is found to be about one mile .
The same morning , a great many rocks , situated about the middle of the disk , projected from 25~,93 to 26~56 .
This gives on about 29,3 miles , and these rocks are all less than half a mile high .
January 13 , 1780 , 7 o'clock , I examined the mountains in the Moon ; but there was not one of them that was fairly placed on level ground , which is a condition very necessary for an exact measurement of the projection .
If there should be a declivity on the Moon before the mountains , or a tract of hills placed so as to cast a shadow on that part before them which would otherwise be illuminated , it is plain that the projection would appear too large ; and , on the contrary , should there be a rising ground before them , it would appear too little .
As far as I was able to judge of the direction of the line of illumination , the highest hill projected 25~ 31 , or 30,36 miles : from thence we find , as before that the perpendicular height is ( .42 mile ) less than half a mile .
January 14 , 11 o'clock , I took the projection of the highest mountain which was situated at the Western edge .
It measured 24~ , 68 , or about 27 miles ; and the perpendicular height comes out less than half a mile .
There was not one mountain in the edge of the disk so high as this .
January 17 , 7 o'clock , a very high mountain projected no less than 4~'',625 .
Its situation is in the Southeast quadrant .
The Moon 's semi-diameter , at the time of observation , by the Nautical Almanac , was 16~ 2~,6 ; therefore , 1090 Q/ R = 45,98 miles =o n. so ' ' ' Sun 's longitude at 7h ... 9 27 39 0 Moon 's longitude at 7. .
22 46 52 Their nearest distance,. .
457 52 or about 125~ 8~ ; the sine of which is.8104 : thence we find LM 56,73 miles ; and the perpendicular height of the mountain is 1m .
47 , or less than a mile and a half .
January 22 , 8h .
20~ .
the highest mountain , situated near Snell or Petavius , projected 11~,437 , which is 12~,34 ; and LM comes out to be 35,3 mile : threfore the perpendicular height is,57 mile .
Another , just behind Mare Crisium , measured only 7~ , therefore is less than half a mile high .
January 25 , 7h .
30~ .
in the morning , a mountain near Aristoteles measured 18~,59 which gives 20,6 miles ; and LM is found 28,53 miles ; the perpendicular height is therefore only,37 mile .
Other mountains about Mare Nectaris measured about 23~,5 ; but they had hills before them , and their situation was not so proper for my purpose .
However , it is evident they were of no considerable height .
January 28 , 6 o'clock in the morning , the highest mountain in the disk measured 30~,937 ; the Moon 's semi-diameter at that time 15~ 40~ ; and on therefore equal 31,37 miles : but as the Moon is within four hours of her quadrature we may be assured that this mountain is less than half a mile high .
February 19 , Mons Sinopium projected 5~,781 ; therefore on= 6,26 miles , and the quantity LM 56,54 miles ; and consequently the height of this mountain , which it seems proves to be a very high one , is not much less than a mile and a half .
However , my journal observes , that the measure was very full ; therefore the mountain in all probability does not exceed a mile and a quarter .
Moreover , I think that observations made so near the full or new Moon are less to be depended upon , because a small error in measuring will produce a great one in the height of a mountain .
From these observations I believe it is evident , that the height of the lunar mountains in general is greatly over-rated ; and that , when we have excepted a few , the generality do not exceed half a mile in their perpendicular elevation .
It is not so easy to find any certain mountain exactly in the same situation it has been measured in before ; therefore some little difference must be expected in these measures .
Hitherto I have not had an opportunity of particularly observing the three mountains mentioned by HEVELIUS ; nor that which RICCIOLUS found to project a sixteenth part of the Moon 's diameter .
If KEILL had calculated the height of this last mentioned hill according to the theorem I have given , he would have found ( supposing the observation to have been made , as he says , on the fourth day after new Moon ) that its perpendicular could not well be less than between eleven and twelve miles .
I shall not fail to take the first opportunity of observing these four , and every other mountain of any eminence ; and if other persons , who are furnished with good telescopes and micrometers , would take the quantity of the projection of the lunar mountains , I make no doubt , but that we should be nearly as well acquainted with their heights as we are with the elevation of our own .
One caution I would beg leave to mention to those who may use the excellent 31/ 2 feet refractors of Mr. DOLLOND .
The admirable quantity of light , which on most occasions is so desirable , will probably give the measure of the projection somewhat larger than the true , if not guarded against by proper limitations placed before the object glass .
I have taken no notice of any allowance to be made for the refraction a ray of light must suffer in passing through the atmosphere of the Moon , when it illuminates the top of the mountain , whereby its apparent height will be lessened , as we are too little acquainted with that atmosphere to take it into consideration .
It is also to be observed , that this would equally affect the conclusions of HEVELIUS , and therefore the difference in our inferences would still remain the same .
Bath , February 28 , 1780 .
Continuation of the same observations .
March 11 , 1780 , 7h .
Promontorium Archerusia projected 17~,187 .
It is very properly situated for measuring .
By a proper deduction from the Moon 's semidiameter , as given by the Nautical Almanac , at the time of observation , we find the quantity on= 20.1 miles , and LM 22,6 miles ; from which it appears , that the perpendicular height of this mountain is a little less than a quarter of a mile .
Antitaurus , the mountain measured by HEVELIUS was badly situated , because Mount Moschus and its neighbouring hills cast a deep shadow , which may be mistaken for the natural convexity of the Moon .
A good , full , but just measure , 25~,105 ; in miles 29,27 : therefore ; LM 31,7 miles , and the perpendicular height not quite half a mile .
7h .
45~ .
I was desirous of being very exact in this measure , therefore I repeated it .
I took two different observations .
A narrow measure 21~ , 562 ; quite full enough 24~,062 .
These measures give the perpendicular height less than half a mile .
8h .
I measured Lipulus , 19~063 .
It is also badly situated , though rather better than Antitaurus .
I found that the projection increased , therefore concluded that this was not the highest part of the mountain , and waited some time when I measured it again .
9h .
Lipulus now projected 28~,75 .
10h .
It measured 28~,75 : this gives on = 33,64 miles .
Distance of Sun and Moon about 63~ 23~ : therefore , LM 37,54 miles .
From hence we find the perpendicular height , 64 mile , or very near two-thirds of a mile .
March 12 , 1780 , 7h .
One of the Apennine mountains , between Lacus Trasimenus and Pontus Euxinus projected 44~,062 .
This gives us on = 51,11 miles ; and LM = 52,9 miles : therefore the perpendicular height of these mountains , which I know to be very high , comes out to be 1 1/ 4 mile .
Mons Armenia ( near Taurus ) projected 31~ 406 = 36,43 miles ; LM = 38 miles nearly , and the height two-thirds of a mile .
Mons Leucopetra 34~479 or 40 miles ; LM = 41,4 miles , and the perpendicular height three quarters of a mile .
There was a very fine shade of a high rock near it , which showed the direction of the illuminating ray , and thereby assisted me in measuring to a great exactness ; but the mountain itself is not very favourably situated .
March 16 , 10h .
30~ .
Mons Lacer projected 45~,625 ; but I am almost certain that there are two very considerable cavities or places where the ground descends below the level of the convexity , just before these mountains , so that these measures must of course be a good deal too large : but supposing them to be just , it follows , that on is 50 , 193 miles , LM = 64 miles , and the perpendicular height above 13/ 4 miles .
Another of the same mountains situated on the borders of S. Sirbonis measured 41~,875 .
This ridge of mountains is the same of which I measured one on January the 17th , which was then found to be 1,47 miles high .
The following additional Memoranda of the Manner in which Mr. HERSCHEL made his Observations are taken from a Letter of his to the rev .
Dr. MASKELYNE , Astronomer Royal .
IN the second figure of my observations , the points L , S , E , r , are all supposed to be in one plane ; and as the illuminating ray SL is also in this plane , it follows , that the line Ln ( = on ) will always be perpendicular to the right line which joins the cusps of the Moon ( c ) ; and the truth of the theorem there delivered depends upon this circumstance .
For this reason I have taken care in all my observations to measure the line , which in fig. 3 .
( taken from your letter to Dr. WATSON ) is marked on , parallel to the line CD , or perpendicular to AB , and not the line r n , perpendicular to the elliptical curve Aro B. The manner of taking it is easy enough : however , I have occasionally used three different methods , and will de(c ) It is here supposed , that rays from the Sun s , and the eye of the observer E , to any part of the Moon L , may be taken for parallel ; and therefore , that different planes , made by several sections of the Moon , according as the point L is taken North or South of the diameter of the Moon , which is at rectangles to the line joining the cusps , may also be taken to be parallel to that diameter .
scribe them all , which I should have done in the paper delivered by Dr. WATSON , had I not feared to be too particular .
The first method I used was to set the immovable hair hh ( fig. 4 .
) of my micrometer parallel to a line AB , joining the cusps of the Moon ; then , by opening the moveable parallel hair till it included the projection o n , intended to be taken , I marked that down as the measure of o n. As this method required some attention ( that part of the ellipsis of illumination AVB which is the vertex v of the lesser axis may serve as a direction ) and took up some time , on account of the small field of view of my telescope , I used occasionally these two following ways .
When there was any remarkable figure on the disk of the Moon near the line of illumination , I put on a compound eye-piece whose magnified field of view is full 40~ , and power about 90 times , so that it takes in the greatest part of the whole Moon ; by this means I was enabled to view the projection intended for measuring at the same time with the rest of the Moon , and to fix upon some mark in the disk very near to its edge towards which I judged the line on should be directed ; then putting on the eye-piece which carries the micrometer I took the distance according to this judgment as well as I could .
The third method I took was the following , which , indeed , I look upon as the best of all , and which I therefore most frequently put in practice .
I took a view of some neighbouring shades of rocks or mountains , if there happened to be any near , and directed the measure of the micrometer by them , as they plainly pointed out the direction of the illuminating ray ; or , which is the same thing , indicated the line perpendicular to a line joining the cusps .
Mons Leucopetra was measured by this last method , which circumstance I have mentioned in my observations of the 12th of March , where I saw the whole rock and its highest point , as well as the whole shade , and its last termination , upon very even ground , at the same time that I directed my micrometer in that line , to take the projection o n , of the above mentioned mountain .
Sometimes I compared together a measure taken in the direction o n , and one taken in the direction r n ; but as most of my observations were made upon mountains not situated near the cusps or limb of the Moon , I never found so much difference between these two measures , that it could have occasioned any very material error , if I had entirely neglected it .
By the nature of the ellipsis it will appear , that , when we do not come too near the limb or cusps of the Moon , a tangent drawn to a point in the curve of illumination will seldom make with the subtangent an angle that exceeds ( or is so much as ) 26~ ; and in all such cases the error that can arise from taking the line rn instead of on will be less than the tenth part of the whole measure : but , if the angle the tangent makes with the subtangent is only about 18~ , the error will be less than a 20th part ; and all the measures I have taken , I believe , will be found to be much within these last-mentioned limits .
From this consideration it will appear , that if I had not been aware of this circumstance , my observations would still be sufficiently accurate to disprove the usually assigned great height of the lunar mountains ; but as I took all the precaution the situation of each mountain would afford , by using any one of the above mentioned three methods , which suited best , I believe there can hardly be a possibility of any error that should amount to a 40th part of the whole height of any mountain I have measured .
The figure ABCD ( fig. 5 .
) contained by the diameter AB , the arch CD , and the two curve AD , BC , shows in what portion of the Moon 's semi-disk we may safely measure the line r n , instead of o n , without being liable to so great an error as one tenth part of the whole , and the figure ABcd contains that part wherein the measure rn being taken instead of o n , the error will be less than the 20th part of the whole measure .
In a portion something more confined the error will soon vanish , so that the difference may be safely neglected entirely .
Thus in the space ABxy the error cannot amount to a hundredth part .
These figures may be constructed by taking the several points D , d , y , and C , c , x , 26~ , 18~ , 8~ , respectively , from the vertex , the curves AD , Ad , Ay , BC , Bc , Bx , being the loci of those points of the tangents which touch the several ellipses of illumination that may be contained in the semi-disk of the Moon , when these tangents make those several angles of 26~ , 18~ , 8~ , with p Fig. 1 .
C AAA Fig. 3 .
Fig. 4 .
h r no no h CDV B~ B S NOnoR Fig. 2 .
rL M s ml D d y x eE c C

