XXIII .
On the Degree of Salubrity of the common Air at Sea , compared with that of the Sea-shore , and that of Places far removed from the Sea .
In a Letter from John Ingen Housz , M. D. F. R. S. to Sir John Pringle , Bart. F. R. S. Dated Paris , Jan. 22 , 1780 .
Read April 24 , 1780 .
SIR , AS you had recommended to me the examination of the air at sea by the nitrous test , I followed your advice in my return to the Continent in the beginning of November last : and I embraced that opportunity with the more eagerness , as I knew that you had given credit to the account of several consumptive people having recovered their health by going on sea voyages , after the common means for curing that distemper had failed .
I was in hopes likewise to find in this inquiry , a confirmation of what you conjectured in your Anniversary Discourse in the year 1773 , viz. that great bodies of water , such as seas and lakes , are conducive to the health of animals , by purifying and cleansing the air contaminated nated by their breathing in it : so that the salutary gales , by which this infected air is conveyed to the waters , and by them returned again to the land , though they do rise now and then to storms and hurricanes , must nevertheless induce us to trace and to revere in them the ways of a beneficent Being , who , not fortuitously , but with design , not in wrath , but in mercy , thus shakes the waters and the air together , to bury in the deep those pestilential effluvia which the vegetables upon the face of the earth are insufficient to consume .
I was not without hope , that such experiments might tend to throw a new light upon the cause of that almost universal effect of the sea air , to wit , its increasing the powers of life , and giving a keener appetite by hastening the digestion of food .
I shall now give you an account of the experiments I made in consequence of your suggestion , in the same order as they were made ; and beg you to present them to the Royal Society , if you think them worthy the attention of that learned body .
I must first , however , premise , that as I wrote this paper in noisy inns , on ship-board , and places little adapted to philosophical application , I hope you will make some allowance for the inaccuracies which you may find in it .
I began my experiments at Gravesend , where I was obliged to wait two days for a favourable wind .
I found the air of that place , on Nov. 1 , of a tolerable good quality , as one measure of it with one of nitrous air occupied , in several trials , about 104 , or one measure and 4/ 100 of a measure ; so that I took it to be nearly of the same quality as the air of London .
The ship in which I went from London to Ostend happened to be becalmed about two or three miles from shore , in the mouth of the Thames , between Sheerness and Margate .
The weather was very agreeable , warm , and the sun shone very bright , on the 3d of November .
I was provided with a travelling apparatus , made on purpose by Mr. MARTIN , the whole of which was packed up in a box about ten inches long , five broad , and three and an half high .
The glass tube or great measure , which was sixteen inches long , and divided in two separate pieces , lay in a small compass , and could be put together by brass screws adapted to the divided extremities .
Instead of a water trough , such as is used commonly , I made use of a small round wooden tub , which I found on board the ship , and which I filled with sea-water , fixing to the edge of this tub , by means of a screw , the brass funnel , through which the air was to be let up into the glass tube .
After having exercised myself during some time in performing the experiment in a water tub much too small for the purpose , I at last acquired a habit of doing it tolerably well .
I then began to make my experiments regularly at about eleven o'clock ; and I have the pleasure to inform you , that I found the sea air at the place indicated of a superior purity to any common air I ever met with since the month of June last ( when I began to engage in the course of experiments which have afforded me the materials of my work lately published upon Vegetables ) either in my country retirement , or in London .
In six different trials made one after another in the short manner described in my book , p. 278 .
et seq.(a ) I found , that the two measures of air ( one of common and one of nitrous air ) occupied from 0.91 to 0.94 ; which difference in the result , though but small in itself , was owing to the disadvantage of not having a vessel deep enough to move the glass tube in with ease , for the purpose of mixing the two airs together , and to my not having yet acquired the habit of using the portable apparatus .
I tried also the air of this spot in the manner used by Abbe FONTANA , which I have described in my book , ( a ) It consists in letting up into the glass tube one measure of common air , and after this one measure of nitrous air , and shaking the tube forcibly in the water trough just at the moment the two airs come into contact with each other .
p. 155(b ) ; the result of which trial was , that after the first measure of nitrous air was let up , the column of both airs occupied 1.86 , or one measure and 86/ 100 of a measure ; after the second measure of nitrous air was let up , the bulk of both airs occupied 202 , or two measures and 2/ 100 of a measure : and after the third measure of nitrous air was let up , the remaining bulk of both airs occupied 2.96 , or 96/ 100 of a measure : so that the remaining bulk of both airs employed in the experiment ( viz. two measures of common and three of nitrous air , each making 100 sub-divisions of the glass tube ) amounted to two measures and 96/ 100 of a third measure , or to 296 sub-divisions , which being subtracted from the five measures , or from the 500 sub-divisions employed , the remainder was 2.04 , which was exactly the quantity of both airs destroyed .
Give me leave , before I proceed farther , to recall to your memory some of the experiments relative to this subject , made in my country retreat in the course of last summer , and related in my book , principally in p. 155 .
and 282 .
together with some further ones I made just ( b ) It consists in letting up into the divided glass tube two measures of common air , and afterwards three measures of nitrous air , one after another , shaking the tube in the water trough after each measure of nitrous air , and beginning constantly this motion exactly at the moment the two airs come into contact with each other , or even before they meet , which is still better .
before my setting out for the continent : this recapitulation will make the nature of the experiments just mentioned , and their result , much more easily understood .
The different degrees of salubrity of the atmosphere , as I found it in general in my country house at Southall Green , ten miles from London , from June to September , lay between 103 and 109 , that is to say , that of the two measures of air , viz. one of common and one of nitrous air , the remaining bulk or column occupied between 103 or 109 sub-divisions in the glass tube .
I was somewhat surprised , when upon my return to town to my former lodgings in Pall Mall Court , I found the common air purer in general in October than I used to find it in the middle of summer in the country ; for on the 22d of October , at nine o'clock in the morning , the weather being fair and frosty , I found , that one measure of common air and one of nitrous air occupied 100 sub-divisions in the glass tube , or exactly one measure .
It gave by the Abbe FONTANA 's method above mentioned the following result , 184 , 208 , 304 ; so that the quantity of both airs destroyed in this trial was exactly one measure and 96/ 100 of a measure , or 196 sub-divisions .
That very day , at two o'clock in the afternoon ( it being then rainy weather ) the air was somewhat altered for the worse ; for at that time one measure of common and one of nitrous air occupied 102 .
The next day , October 23 , it being rainy weather , the state of the atmosphere was the same in the morning as it was the day before in the afternoon : for one measure of common and one of nitrous air occupied 102 ; and the result of Abbe FONTANA 's method was as follows , 1841 2 , 211 , 307 , so that the quantity of both airs destroyed amounted to 193 .
October the 24th , I again examined the state of the atmosphere at nine o'clock in the morning , the weather being serene ; I found it restored to its former goodness ; for one measure of common and one of nitrous air occupied 100 , or exactly one measure ; and the result of Abbe FONTANA 's method was 184 , 207 , 304 .
At seven o'clock in the evening of the same day the air was again grown worse ; for one measure of common and one of nitrous air occupied 103 .
October 25th , I examined the air at eleven o'clock in the morning , the sky being cloudy , and found , that one measure of common and one of nitrous air occupied 102 .
I put it again to the test at eleven o'clock at night , and found , from five different trials , that one measure of it with one of nitrous air occupied 105 .
October 26th , the weather being very dark and rainy , I found that one measure of common and one of nitrous air occupied 105 .
You know , SIR , that the situation of my lodgings was such , that the back part of the house was contiguous to the garden of Carleton House , which is amply furnished with lofty elm trees , so as to make the garden appear from my windows like a forest .
As I had discovered , in the course of last summer , the great power which the leaves of trees possess of improving the atmosphere , by pouring down an invisible shower of purified or dephlogisticated air , during the day-time , in clear weather ; I could not forbear ascribing in some measure the purity of the common air of that spot to the happy situation of the place just by so many trees , which had all kept their leaves in full vigour till that time .
But I only give this as a conjecture ; for I am really sorry that I cannot prove it by a direct experiment .
To put out of all controversy such a powerful influence of neighbouring trees upon the circumambient and unconfined air(c ) , the air of different and distant ( c ) I say unconfined , for I am not quite sure that the influence of trees and other vegetables , though in reality very great ( as I think I have put beyond all doubt in my book ) can be more sensible near trees in the open air than at some distance ; in the same manner as some distilled water , poured gradually among an immense mass of common water , would diffuse itself soon through the whole mass equally .
places should be examined at the same time as the air near the trees .
I was desirous of doing it , and gave orders to my servant to gather air from different parts of London ; but the hurry of business , occasioned by our approaching departure , made him forget or overlook my orders ; and for the same reason I myself forgot to perform the task .
After all , the best , and perhaps only good way to clear up this matter would be , if several philosophers , each provided with an exactly similar apparatus , and living in different parts of the town , and in different parts of the country , should at the same time put the air of the place of their abode to the test , and afterwards compare their notes .
I conceived some flattering hopes before I set out from London , that ere long such eudiometers , as I have described in my book , will come into the hands of many good philosophers who will take upon them with pleasure to perform this task , as I heard that some of them were already ordered to be made for many persons , among the rest for Dr. HEBERDEN .
Though I have some reason to believe , that the vicinity of the trees did really contribute somewhat to render the air purer at the above mentioned place ; yet I believe also , that the frosty weather of itself contributes to purify the atmosphere ( perhaps by checking a great many causes of corruption of various substances ) ; and that the liveliness we commonly enjoy in frosty weather is in a great measure owing to the superior degree of purity of our common element at that time .
I must now return from this digression to the nature of the sea air .
From what I have already related it appears , that the difference between the best atmospheric air I have yet found and the sea air , as I found it by the first examination upon the spot where chance carried me , is as 91 to 100 , the lesser number indicating the best quality .
Now , as I found the sea air of such a pure quality so near land , I thought it might , with some degree of probability , be expected , that the common air , at a distance from land , would prove of a still superior quality ; for I could scarce believe , that in the first trial , made without choice of place or time , I had just hit upon a time and a place where the sea air is of the first quality .
I would have repeated the same experiment next day , November the 4th , when we were in the middle of the channel between the English coast and Ostend ; but the motion of the ship , which was very great , made it impracticable .
Not entirely , however , to lose the opportunity which the voyage afforded me , I filled three phials , made on purpose for such use , with air , when we were in the middle of the sea ( the wind blowing pretty hard , and the weather being rainy ) .
I kept these bottles shut till next day , November 5th , when I examined the air confined in them at Ostend , and found it of an inferior quality to that which I had tried on the 3d of November , in the mouth of the Thames ; for one measure of it with one of nitrous air occupied , in three different trials , 097 .
I found the common air at Ostend near as good the same day at ten o'clock in the morning ( the weather being cloudy ) ; for one measure of it with one of nitrous air occupied 098 .
In the afternoon ( the weather being very rainy ) the common air of the place was become worse , though still of a very good quality ; for one measure of it with one of nitrous air occupied 100 , or exactly one measure .
About five o'clock in the evening , the weather continuing rainy , and the wind blowing at that time very hard from the sea , I went to the sea-shore on purpose to gather in a phial , fitted for the purpose , the sea air just as it blew towards the land .
When I had got it I went immediately home , and put it directly to the nitrous test .
I found , by several trials of such good quality , that it was nearly as good as that which I had met with in the mouth of the Thames ; for one measure of it with one of nitrous air occupied 094 and 095 ; whereas the common air of the inn ( as I found by trial at the time ) was somewhat of an inferior quality , though still remarkably pure ; for one measure of it with one of nitrous occupied 097 in five repeated trials .
As the difference in the quality of the sea air examined on the spot in the mouth of the Thames , November 3d , and that which I gathered in the middle of the sea in rainy and windy weather , was so remarkable , I suspected the reason of this difference to be , that the air , put to the test November 3d , had been exposed during several days to the influence of the sea without any mixture of land air , as it had been remarkably calm all that time ; and that the air gathered on the sea in windy weather was mixed with air driven from the land by the wind , and incorporated with the sea air .
This suspicion was afterwards strengthened when I found the air gathered at the sea shore , on the evening of November 5th , near as good as that which I gathered on a fair day in the mouth of the Thames , November 3d ; for the wind being N. W. the air driven upon the coast was to be considered as true sea air , without any mixture of land air .
But after I had made up my mind about the difference of the above related experiments , a doubt rose in me about a circumstance to which this difference might have been owing , at least in some measure ; the circumstance I mean was this : I had made use of sea water for the experiment on the 3d of November , whereas I had made use of pump water in examining the sea air kept in bottles at Ostend .
I thought I had no right to draw any conclusion from the fact till I was convinced that the making this experiment in common or in sea water would make no difference in the result .
This consideration made me stay one day longer at Ostend , on purpose to satisfy my mind on this head , lest I should never find another opportunity of doing it .
I immediately ordered a pail full of sea water to be brought to my lodging , and made several comparative trials with atmospheric air in common water and in this sea water ; but I could not observe any real difference in the result .
Thus all degree of suspicion about the difference of the result from this cause was now at an end .
There now only remained some little suspicion that the air gathered on the sea , and kept in phials , might have undergone some alteration ; this might have been the case , as I had found in some former experiments made in England , that air kept in bottles was sometimes liable to alterations , which I think is partly to be ascribed to the difficulty of finding bottles so well secured by a ground stopper as to shut out every communication with the external air , and partly , perhaps , to the nature of air , which is not in itself an unalterable substance , as I have attempted to prove in my book upon Vegetables , p. 107 : in the present case , however , I rather incline to think , that the reason why the air , gathered in rainy and windy weather on the sea , was found of an inferior quality , is to be ascribed chiefly to the land air being driven by the wind upon the sea , and thus to the mixture of both airs .
November the 6th , about nine o'clock in the morning , the weather being cold , windy , and cloudy , I again put the common air of Ostend , which I gathered in my inn , to the test , and found it of near as good a quality as that in the mouth of the Thames ; for one measure of it with one of nitrous air occupied 0941/ 2 in three repeated trials .
The same morning , about eleven o'clock , the wind blowing very hard from the sea , I went to the shore on purpose to gather some air just as it came from the sea .
I found its quality inferior to that which I had examined two hours before , though still superior to any air I have yet found in England ; for one measure of it with one of nitrous air occupied 097 .
The common air , as I found it in my lodging , was at 098 .
The wind had not shifted much , though I cannot ascertain the exact point from which it then blew .
It seems probable from the foregoing experiments , that though in general the sea air surpasses the land air in purity , yet there are the same inconstancies in its degree of goodness as in the land air .
I will not attempt to give any reason for this inconstancy , as I have no experiments to support any ; but I think it highly deserving the attention of philosophers to attempt the discovery of this phenomenon .
This experiment being finished , I closed my inquiries at Ostend , and set off for Bruges .
We arrived at dark , and about seven o'clock in the evening I tried the common air of that place , and found it inferior in purity to that of Ostend in above ten experiments : one measure of it with one of nitrous air occupied 105 , or thereabout .
I had the mortification to find the stoppers of the phials in which I had kept the air of Ostend all loosened , so that I could not make any comparative trial with both airs .
November 8th , I set out for Ghent , where I spent the next day , November 9th .
I tried the air of that place about three in the afternoon , and found it better than that of Bruges ; for one measure of it with one of nitrous air occupied 103 , or thereabout , in several experiments .
As all the following trials with common air are made in the same way as the foregoing , viz. by mixing one measure of common with one of nitrous air , I will hereafter only mention the numbers of the result , for the sake of abridging the paper by avoiding continual repetitions .
November 12 .
At Brussels , I found the air , at seven o'clock in the evening , at 1051/ 2 .
November 13 .
I found the air of the lower part of the city at 106 , that of the highest part at 104 ; the weather was rainy and damp .
It is a common opinion at Brussels , that the air in the lower parts of the city is more unwholesome than in the higher parts , and that people of bad constitutions cannot stand it unless they go to live in the higher parts .
November 14 .
I found the air of the lower and higher parts of the city of the same goodness , each being at 103 .
The weather was fair and frosty .
November 15 .
The air was the same as yesterday in both parts of the city ; the weather fair and cold .
November 22 .
I arrived at Antwerp , where I found the air in the evening at 1091/ 2 ; the weather was rainy , damp , and cold .
November 23 .
I set out for Breda .
I filled a phial with air , when I set out from Antwerp at eight o'clock in the morning .
I also filled a phial with air on the middle of the heath or common called De Lange Hey : the weather was remarkably close and damp .
I tried these two airs at night , at Breda ; that of Antwerp was found at 106 ; that of Breda the same ; that of the heath at 1051/ 2 .
November 24 .
I examined the air at Breda in the morning , about eleven o'clock , the weather being fair , cold , and inclining to frost ; it was at 102 .
At seven o'clock in the evening it was at 103 .
November 25 .
The air at Breda was at 104 ; the weather rainy and cold .
November 26 .
The air was in the morning and in the evening 103 ; the weather very rainy , cold , and stormy .
November 27 .
I set out from Breda for Rotterdam , and crossed the water at the Moordyke .
I tried the air at the Moordyke close to the water , and found it at 1011/ 2 ; the weather was fair and cold , but not frosty .
This spot is reckoned very healthy ; the inhabitants have a sound look , and live to a great age in general .
November 28 .
I examined the air at Rotterdam , it was at 103 ; the weather rainy and cold .
November 29 .
Being at Delpht , I gathered some air in the middle of the day , the weather being stormy and rainy .
I examined it next day at the Hague , and found it at 103 ; and that of the Hague 104 .
November 30 .
I examined the air at the Hague , and found it at 104 ; the weather cold , the wind Northerly .
December 1 .
Being still at the Hague , the weather underwent a sudden and remarkable change .
The wind was southerly and stormy ; the air was become so warm that upon going out of the house into the street , I felt the same sensation as upon coming from a cold air into a room heated by a German stove .
I suspected that this sudden change would alter the constitution of the atmosphere in point of salubrity .
Having no time to make any experiment , I contented myself with filling some phials with this air , and sending my servant to Schevelingen to gather some air close to the sea .
December 2 .
The wind and weather remained the same as yesterday .
In the evening , about eight o'clock , when FAHRENHEIT'S thermometer stood at 54~ , I put the common air to the nitrous test , and found it at 116 ; the air gathered the day before at 117 ; and that gathered close to the sea at 115 .
As I had never found the common air near so bad , I had some apprehension that my eudiometer was out of order , or that something was the matter with the nitrous air .
I made therefore fresh nitrous air , and repeated the experiment many times , but the result was nearly the same .
In the mean time , I had the following accidental meeting .
The father of the landlady of the house having been informed by the servant , that I was about some extraordinary pursuit , of which he could have no conception , was led to come and see what I did .
He had scarce been a minute with me but I perceived he laboured under a severe asthma He explained his case to me , knowing me to be a physician , and told me , that he had passed these two days very uncomfortably , finding the air so uncommonly heavy that he could scarce draw his breath : which convinced me , that the element was in reality become of an inferior quality .
December 4 .
Being at Amsterdam , I found the air of that place at 103 ; the weather being rainy , windy , and cold .
December 5 .
The air was at 102 ; the weather nearly as yesterday .
December 10 .
I returned to Rotterdam , and found the air at 101 ; the weather rainy .
In the beginning of last year they made an end of draining a large mere ( about half the size of the Haerlemmer Mere ) situated in the neighbourhood of Rotterdam , which was tursed out in former ages .
It was now laid into arable land , and turned out to be very fruitful .
When this land was quite cleared of the water , an uncommon epidemical disease broke out in all the places situated upon the borders of this lake ; it began about August , and abated when the winter season set in .
This distemper broke out afresh last summer , and was now again upon its decline .
It carried off a great number of inhabitants .
It appeared chiefly under the habit of an irregular intermittent , a bilious remitting , and a putrid fever .
There was scarce a single house to be found in which there were not some persons sick .
The villages at a quarter of a league distance from the former lake were free from it .
This distemper was ascribed to the putrid exhalations of this newly uncovered land ; which exhalations were very offensive to the smell .
This was so much the more probable , as the disease abated when the stench , checked by the cold , abated .
I tried the air of this former lake upon the spot , in company with my learned friend Dr. DE MONCHY , professor of physic , and found it as good as that of Rotterdam ; but there was a great deal of wind that day , and no perceptible stench .
However , Dr. BICKER , an eminent physician of that city , got me a phial filled with air of this lake , which he took from a spot where he still perceived some of the former bad smell .
This air proved to be in reality of an inferior quality to that of the city .
December 12 .
Being in the middle of the water between Dort and the Moordyke , I found the air upon what is called Holland 's Diep of an inferior quality , the weather being remarkably dark , rainy , and windy ; it was at 109 .
December 13 .
Being returned to Breda I found the air of that place at 109 in the morning , the weather continuing as it was yesterday .
In the afternoon it was somewhat better , viz. at 1061/ 2 , the weather having cleared up .
December 16 .
Having returned to Antwerp , I found the air of the lower part of that city at 105 ; and that of the higher part at 104 , the weather being rainy and temperate .
December 17 .
The air at Antwerp was 107 , the weather continuing to be nearly as it was the day before .
December 19 .
Being returned to Brussels , I found the air at 109 , the weather being rainy , windy , and rather warm .
December 21 .
I found the air at Brussels at 106 , the weather being dry and cold .
December 22 .
The air of Brussels was the same as yesterday ; the weather was nearly the same also .
December 23 .
I arrived at Mons , and found the air of that place at 104 ; the weather rainy and cold .
December 24 .
Being near Bouchain , I found the air at 1041/ 2 ; the weather was cloudy and cold .
December 25 .
I tried the air at Peronne , and found it at 1021/ 2 ; the weather was frosty .
December 26 .
Being at Cuvilli , a village four leagues from Roy , I examined the air of that place , and that which I had gathered on the road about twelve o'clock in the day-time ; I found them both at 103 ; the weather was frosty .
December 27 .
I examined the air at Senlis , and that which I had gathered in the middle of the day on the road ; both were at 1021/ 2 ; the weather continued frosty .
December 29 .
Being at Paris , I found the air in that capital at 103 ; the weather frosty .
1780 , January 8 , the air of Paris was at 100 ; the weather very frosty .
January 13 .
The air of Paris was 98 ; it froze very hard .
This paper being already too long , I will only add some few deductions , which seem to follow of themselves from the above related experiments .
It appears from these experiments , that the air at sea and close to it is in general purer and fitter for animal life than the air on the land , though it seems to be subject to the same inconstancy in its degree of purity with that of the land ; so that we may now with more confidence send our patients , labouring under consumptive disorders , to the sea , or at least to places situated close to the sea , which have no marshes in their neighbourhood .
It seems also probable , that the air will be found in general much purer far from the land than near the shore , the former being never subject to be mixed with land air .
It appears also , that the air in frosty weather is in general wholesomer than it is in winter when it does not freeze ; and that uncommon warm weather , happening in the winter season , is apt to render the atmosphere very unwholesome : the reason of which I apprehend to be , that the frost totally checks that general tendency to corruption , which being revived by warmth again increases the infection of the common air , which at that time is so much the greater , because the plants ( which are deprived of their leaves in winter ) have no power in them to counteract it .
It seems also probable , that those countries which are , by their local situation , exposed to noxious exhalations , are in general much wholesomer in the winter ; and that it is much safer to cross such countries in summer time when it is windy weather than in a calm , &amp;c. How far these deductions are founded upon experience may appear by applying them to such places as they may be found to have a relation to .
My old friend Dr. DAMMAN , an eminent physician and professor royal in midwifry at Ghent , told me , that when he was formerly a practitioner at Ostend , during seven years , he found the people there remarkably healthy ; that nothing was rarer there than to see a patient labouring under a consumption or asthma , a malignant , putrid , or spotted fever ; that the disease to which they are the most subject , is a regular intermittent fever in autumn , when sudden transitions from hot to cold weather happen .
People are in general very healthy at Gibraltar , though there are very few trees near that place ; which , I think , is owing to the purity of the air , arising from the neighbourhood of the sea .
Most small islands are very healthy .
At Malta people are little subject to diseases , and live to a very advanced age .

