VIII .
Account of a Woman who had the Small Pox during Pregnancy , and who seemed to have communicated the same Disease to the Faetus .
By John Hunter , Esq. F. R. S. Read January 17 , 1780 .
MR. GRANT'S ACCOUNT .
ON the 5th of December , 1776 , Mrs. FORD had been seized with shivering and the other common symptoms of fever , to which were added great difficulty of breathing and a very hard cough .
Mr. GRANT saw her on the 7th ; and he took from her eight ounces of blood , and gave her a composition of the saline mixture with spermaceti and magnesia every six hours .
This had operated by the 8th two or three times very gently , when most of the complaints were relieved ; but the cough still shaking her violently , bleeding seemed necessary to be repeated , more particularly as she looked upon herself to be in the sixth month of her pregnancy .
The medicine was continued without the magnesia .
In the evening ( viz. the 8th ) the small pox appeared , which proved of a mild kind , and moderate in quantity .
Its progress was rather slower than might have been expected ; but the woman passed through the disease in great spirits , sitting up the greatest part of the day during the whole time , and taking only a paregoric at night , and , as occasion required , a little magnesia : thus the symptoms were mitigated , and the cough at last became very little troublesome .
On the 25th she complained of a pain in her side .
Eight ounces of blood were taken away .
The next day she was quite free from pain , and thought herself as well on the 27th as her particular situation would admit of ; after which she was not visited by Mr. GRANT till the 31st , when she was in labour .
Mr. WASTALL'S letter on the same subject .
December 30 , 1776 , I was sent for to Mrs. FORD , a healthy woman , about twenty-two years of age , who was pregnant with her first child .
She had come out of the country about three months before .
Soon after her arrival in town she was seized with the small pox , and had been under the care of Messieurs HAWKINS and GRANT , who have favoured me with the particulars here annexed .
I called upon her in the afternoon ; she complained of violent griping pains in her bowels , darting down to the pubes .
On examining I found the os tinsae a little dilated , with other symptoms of approaching labour .
I sent her an anodyne spermaceti emulsion , and desired to be called if her pains increased .
I was sent for .
The labour advanced very slowly ; her pains were long and severe ; she was delivered of a dead child , with some difficulty .
Observing an eruption all over the body of the child , and several of the pustules filled with matter , I examined them more particularly ; and recollecting , that Dr. LEAKE , in his Introductory Lecture to the Practice of Midwifry , had observed , that it might be necessary to inquire , whether those adults who are said totally to escape the small pox have not been previously affected with it in the womb , I sent a note to Dr. LEAKE , and likewise to Dr. HUNTER , in hopes of ascertaining a fact hitherto much doubted .
Dr. LEAKE came the same evening , and saw the child .
Dr. HUNTER came afterwards , with Mr. CRUICKSHANKS , and examined it ; also Mr. JOHN HUNTER and Mr. FALCONER ; who all concurred with me , that the eruption on the child was the small pox .
Dr. HUNTER thought the eruption so like the small pox that he could hardly doubt ; but said , that in all other cases of the same kind , that he had met with , the child in utero had escaped the contagion .
From Mr. GRANT'S notes .
The eruption appeared on Mrs. FORD in the evening of the 8th of December , and she was delivered the 31st , that is , twenty-three days after the appearance of the eruptions .
Reflections by Mr. JOHN HUNTER .
The singularity of the above case , with all its circumstances , has inclined me to consider it with some attention .
There can be no doubt but that the mother had the small pox , and that the eruption began to appear on the 8th of December : also , that it went through its regular stages , and that on the 31st , viz. twenty-three days after the first appearance of the eruption , the woman was delivered of the child , who is the subject of this paper .
Secondly , The distance of time when she had the small pox before delivery , joined with the stage of the disease in the child when born , which probably was about the sixth or seventh day of the eruption , viz. about fifteen or sixteen days after the beginning of the eruption on the mother , perfectly agrees with the possibility of the infection 's being caught from the mother .
Thirdly , The external appearance of the pustules in the child was perfectly that of the small pox , as must have appeared from the relation given in Mr. WASTALL'S letter .
Most of the pustules were distinct , but some were blended or united at their base .
The face had the greatest number ; and these were in general the most indistinct .
They were somewhat flattened with a dent in the middle(a ) .
So far were the leading circumstances and external appearances in favour of their being the variolous eruption ; but although these leading circumstances and external appearances were incontrovertible , yet they were not an absolute proof of this being the genuine small pox ; therefore I must be allowed to consider this subject a little further , and see how far all the circumstances correspond or are similar to the true small pox .
In the small pox we have a previous fever , in place of which , in the present case , we have no information but that of the mother 's having had the small pox within such a limited time as may favour the possibility of infection in the womb ; yet we may presume , that the child must have had considerable fever preceding such an eruption , of whatsoever kind it was .
In the small pox the eruption goes through pretty regular stages in its progress and declension , which circumstances we know nothing of in the present case ; but ( a ) I endeavoured to take some matter upon the point of two lancets ; but not having an opportunity of making an experiment myself , I gave them to two gentlemen , who , I imagine , were afraid of inoculating with them .
even this fever , the eruptions , and their progress , are not absolutely proofs that the disorder is the small pox when it is caught in the common and natural way : and in proof of this assertion it may be observed , that practitioners every now and then are mistaken .
It may be asked , what is the true characteristic of the small pox ?
That by which it differs from all other eruptions that we are acquainted with ?
The most certain character of the small pox , that I know , is the formation of a slough , or a part becoming dead by the variolous inflammation ; a circumstance which hitherto , I believe , has not been taken notice of .
This was very evident in the arms of those who were inoculated in the old way , where the wounds were considerable , and were dressed every day ; which mode of treatment kept them from scabbing , by which means this process was easily observed ; but in the present method of inoculation it is hardly observable : the sore being allowed to scab , the slough and scab unite and drop off together .
The same indistinctness attends the eruptions on the skin ; and in those patients who die of , or die while in , the disease , where we have an opportunity of examining them while the part is distinct , this slough is very evident .
This slough is the cause of the pitt after all is cicatrized ; for it is a real loss of substance of the surface of the cutis : and in proportion to this slough is the remaining depression .
The chicken pox comes the nearest in external appearance to the small pox ; but it does not commonly produce a slough .
As there is generally no loss of substance in this case , there can be no pitt .
But it sometimes happens , although but rarely , that there is a pitt in consequence of a chicken pock ; then ulceration has taken place on the surface of the cutis , a common thing in sores .
In the present case , besides the leading circumstances mentioned in the case of the mother , corresponding with the appearances on the child , and the external appearances themselves , we have in the fullest sense the third and real or principal character of the small pox , viz. the slough in every pustule ; from all which , I think , we may conclude , that the child had caught the small pox in the womb ; or at least a disease , the effects of which were similar to no other known disease .
In opening the bodies of those who had either died of , or died while under , the small pox , I always examined carefully to see whether any internal cavity , such as the oesophagus , trachea , stomach , intestines , pleura , peritoneum , neum , &amp;c. had eruptions upon them or not , and never finding any in any of those cavities , I began to suspect , that either the skin itself was the only part of the body susceptible of such a stimulus ; or that the skin was subject to some influence to which the other parts of the body were not subject , and which made it alone susceptible of the variolous stimulus .
If from the first cause , I then concluded it must be an original principle in the animal oeconomy .
If from the second , I then suspected , that external exposure was the cause ; and I was the more led into this idea , from finding that these eruptions often attack the mouth and throat , two exposed parts ; add to which , that we generally find the eruptions most on the exposed parts of the body , as the face , &amp;c. With these ideas in my mind , I thought I saw the most favourable opportunity of clearing up this point .
I therefore very attentively examined most of the internal cavities of this child ; such as the peritoneum , pleura , trachea , inside of the oesophagus , stomach , intestines , &amp;c. but observed nothing uncommon .
I have already observed , that in this child the face and extremities were the fullest , similar to what happens in common ; from all which I may be allowed to draw this conclusion , that the skin is the principal part which is susceptible of the variolous stimulus , and is not affected by any external influence whatever .
The communication of the small pox to the child in the womb may be supposed to happen in two ways ; one by infection from the mother , as is supposed in the above case ; the other by the mother 's having absorbed the small pox matter from some other person , and the matter being carried to the child from the connection between the two , which we may suppose done with or without first affecting the mother .
Testimonies and opinions are various with respect to these two facts .
BOERHAAVE seems to have been led by his experience to think that such infection was not communicable : for we find that he attended a lady , who having , in the sixth month of her pregnancy , had the confluent small pox , brought forth at the regular period a child , who showed not the least vestige of his mother 's disease .
His commentator , however , VAN SWIETEN , supports a different opinion ( see his Comment , vol. V. ) .
He quotes a case from the Philosophical Transactions , vol. XXVIII .
No 337 .
p. 165 .
of a woman , who , having just gone through a mild sort of small pox , was , by means of a strong dose of purging physic , thrown into a miscarriage , and brought forth a dead female child , whose whole body was covered with variolous pustules full of ripe matter ; but this history is founded only on the relation of a a midwife to a clergyman , and therefore not absolutely to be depended upon as accurately stated : however , it is more than probable , that there was a case as described ; and that there were really eruptions on the skin of the child similar to the small pox .
VAN SWIETEN likewise mentions what MAURICEAU relates of himself .
This author testifies , that he had often heard his father and mother say , that the latter , when big with him , and very near her time of delivery , had a painful attendance on one of her children , who died of the small pox on the seventh day of the eruption ; and that on the day following the death of this child , MAURICEAU came into the world , bringing with him five or six true pustules of the small pox .
It does not appear , however , from this recital , whether or not MAURICEAU passed through life free from any posterior infection ; but admitting that this eruption of MAURICEAU'S was truly the small pox , yet I should very much doubt his having caught it from the child who died of it : as it should seem that the pustules of MAURICEAU were of the same date with those of the child who died .
VAN SWIETEN appeals to a more recent case , which had been reported to him by persons of great credit , and is recorded in the Phil. Trans. vol. XLVI .
p. 235 .
A woman , big with child , having herself long ago had the small pox , very assiduously nursed a maid servant during the whole process of this disease .
At the proper time she brought forth a healthy female child , in whose skin Dr. WATSON asserted , that he discovered evident marks of the small pox , which she must have gone through in the womb ; and the same physician pronounced , that this child would be free from future infection .
After four years her brother was inoculated ; and Dr. WATSON obtained permission of the parents to try the same experiment on the girl .
The operation was performed on both children in the same manner ; and the pus used in both cases was taken from the same patient .
The event , however , was different ; for the boy had the regular eruption , and got well ; but the girl 's arm did not inflame nor suppurate .
On the tenth day from the insertion of the matter , she turned pale suddenly , was languid for two days , and afterwards was very well .
In the neighbourhood of the incision there appeared a pustule like those pustules that we sometimes observe in persons who , having had the disease , attend patients ill of the small pox .
In the epistles of T. BARTHOLINUS , cent. II .
p. 682 .
there is the following history .
` ` A poor woman , aged thirty-eight years , pregnant , and now near the time of delivery , was seized with the symptoms of the small pox , and had a very numerous eruption .
In this state she was delivered of a child , as full of variolous pustules as herself .
The child died soon after birth ; the mother three days afterwards .
' ' VAN SWIETEN infers , that the mother and the child were in this case infected at the same time ; therefore , the child not infected by the mother .
Dr. MEAD asserts , that when a woman in the small pox suffers an abortion , the faetus is generally full of the contagion ; but that this does not happen always .
This variety , he says , depends on the state of the mother 's pustules when the child is born ; that is , whether they are or are not in a state of purulence .
Whence he has observed it sometimes to happen , that on the second day from the birth , or the third , or any day before the eighth , the disease caught from the mother shows itself in eruptions on the child .
Dr. MEAD here relates the history of a lady of quality , of which this is the substance .
A lady , in the seventh month of her pregnancy , had the confluent small pox , and on the eleventh day of the disease brought forth a son , having no signs of the disease on his body ; and she died on the fourteenth day .
The infant having lived four days , was seized with convulsions , and , the small pox appearing , died .
The doctor infers from hence , that the suppuration being in some measure completed on the eleventh day , the mother 's disease was communicated then to the faetus , and made its appearance on the child after eight days .
If there be no abortion , Dr. MEAD pronounces , that the child will ever be free from the disease , unless the birth should happen before the maturation of the pustules .
He brings a case to prove , that the faetus in the womb may be infected by the contagion of which the mother does not partake .
` ` A woman , who had long before suffered the small pox , nursed her husband , under that disease , towards the end of her pregnancy ; and was brought to bed at the due time .
The child was dead , and covered all over with variolous pustules .
With respect to the case quoted from MAURICEAU , it has been proved by Sir GEORGE BAKER ( Med. Transact. vol. II .
p. 275 .
) that Dr. MEAD drew a conclusion from it directly contrary to the author 's meaning .
The negative opinion appears evidently to be supported by that history .
Sir GEORGE BAKER mentions in the same paper the case of two pregnant women who were inoculated at Hertford .
They both had the small pox favourably , and afterwards brought forth their children perfectly healthy at the usual time .
Both these children , at the age of three years , were inoculated with effect .
Sir GEORGE BAKER likewise mentions a case which fell under the observation of Dr. CLARKE of Epsom .
` ` A woman towards the end of her pregnancy had the small pox , from which she narrowly escaped .
Five weeks after the crisis she was delivered of an healthy female child , who having numerous marks on her skin was judged by all who saw her to have undergone the same distemper before her birth .
However , at the end of twelve months she had the small pox in a very severe manner .
Both the mother and child were lately living at Epsom .
' ' Since then we see that it is very probable , that the small pox may be caught from the mother when she is infected , it may be asked , why does not this happen oftener ?
In answer to this we may suppose , that this is not so ready a way as when the child is exposed to catch it after the birth , as we find too that a difference can be produced after birth ; viz. inoculation is a much readier way of catching it than what is called the natural way .
It may likewise be said , that many women who are with child , and have the small pox during pregnancy , do not recover ; therefore both mother and child die before the disease can have time to produce eruptions upon the child .
Finally in many of those cases , where the mother recovers , there is sometimes produced a miscarriage , which also hinders the infection from taking place in the child .
However , many women go through the whole disease , and the child shows no marks of the small pox .
Thus have I stated facts relative to the present subject , with some of the best authorities on both sides of the question ; and shall now leave the reader to form his

