XXXIX .
Chemical Experiments and Observations on Lead Ore. By Richard Watson , D. D. F. R. S. in a Letter to Sir John Pringle , Bart. P. R. S. TO SIR JOHN PRINGLE , BART .
P. R. S. Cambridge , SIR , June 13 , 1777 .
THE following experiments and observations , it is apprehended , will not be thought uninteresting by persons versed in chemistry .
May I beg the favour of you to communicate them to the Royal Society ?
Read July 9 , 1778 .
I am , &amp;c. LEAD ORE , as dug out of the mine , is generally much mixed with spar , lime-stone , and other substances , bulk for bulk , heavier than the ore itself .
It undergoes various dressings before it becomes a merchantable commodity , the general tendency of which is to free it , as much as possible , from every heterogeneous impurity .
Suppose that a cubic foot of lead ore , which contained no spar or other extraneous matter , would weigh 7800 ounces , and that a cubic foot of spar , which contained no lead ore or other foreign substance , would weigh 2700 ounces , then would a mixture , consisting of a cubic foot of pure lead ore and a cubic foot of pure spar , weigh 10500 ounces , and one cubic foot of such a mixture would weigh 5250 ounces .
It is obvious that , according to the different proportions in which the particular kinds of spar and lead ore here assumed are supposed to be mixed together , a cubic foot of the mixture will have different weights , the limits of which are on the one hand 7800 , and on the other 2700 ounces ; it never can weigh so little as 2700 ounces , for then it would consist entirely of spar without any lead ore ; nor can it ever weigh so much as 7800 ounces , for then it would consist entirely of lead ore without any spar .
From this view of the matter it is evident , that the purchasing of lead ore by the measure , which is the general though not the universal custom in Derbyshire , is a mode liable to some exception ; since a dish , containing any definite measure , must have different weights , according as the ore with which it is filled is more or less free from spar .
And it is scarce possible , by repeated dressings , to separate all the spar from an ore , or equal portions of it from equal portions of ore .
There is a diversity , however , in the weights of equal measures of lead ore , which probably does not arise from sparry or other heterogeneous accretions , but from the nature of the ore itself .
I have carefully taken the specific gravities of many of the Derbyshire lead ores ; the weight of a cubic foot of the lightest which I met with was 7051 ounces , and the weight of a cubic foot of the heaviest was 7786 ounces ; the difference amounting to between a ninth and a tenth part of the weight of the lightest .
There are probably other ores of lead which differ more in their specific gravities than these here mentioned ; but the difference between these is sufficient to show the great uncertainty of purchasing lead ore by the measure , since ten dishes of one sort of ore may not weigh more than nine dishes of another sort , though both the sorts be equally well dressed .
Lead ore is not always of the same goodness in the same mine , nor even in the same part of the same mine ; and , what is more remarkable , the different parts of the same lump of ore have different specific gravities .
I could not easily have believed this , unless a variety of experiments had convinced me of the fact .
They were employed this year at Holywell in smelting a lead ore from the Isle of Man ; the ore was rich in silver .
A lump of this ore , weighing about ten ounces , was broken into several pieces , and such of the pieces were selected as appeared to the eye to be wholly pure .
By taking the specific gravities of six of these pieces I found , that a cubic foot of the lightest kind would have weighed 6565 ounces , and a cubic foot of the heaviest kind would have weighed 7636 ounces .
Supposing the specific gravity of water to be denoted by 1,000 , the mean specific gravity of the six different pieces of this ore may be expressed by 7.115 .
A very pure specimen of tessellated lead ore , from a mine near Ashover in Derbyshire , was broken into six pieces , weighing near one ounce each .
A cubic foot of the lightest of these pieces would have weighed 7326 ounces , and a cubic foot of the heaviest would have weighed 7786 ounces .
The mean specific gravity of the six pieces was 7.566 .
At the same mine they frequently meet with small quantities of steel-grained lead ore .
Six different pieces of the same lump of this kind of ore were chosen , each of which appeared quite free from spar and every other impurity .
A cubic foot of the lightest of these pieces would have weighed 7188 ounces , and a cubic foot of the heaviest would have weighed 7442 ounces .
The mean specific gravity of the six pieces was 7.342 .
Other lumps of ore , from different mines , were respectively broken into different pieces , and scarcely any two pieces of the same lump were observed to agree in their specific gravities .
This diversity in the specific gravities of the several pieces of the same lump of ore may be owing , either to the different proportions in which the constituent parts of the ore are combined in the several pieces ; or to the different quantities of extraneous substances imperceptibly mixed with them , or , which seems most probable , to a diversity in the size or configuration of these pores .
But be the cause of the diversity in the specific gravities of different pieces of the same lump of ore what it may , the fact , I believe , is certain , and by no means singular ; for not to mention the varieties observable in the specific gravities of different pieces of roll brimstone , of corrosive sublimate , of cast steel , and other factitious substances , the natural spars generally found along with lead ore are subject to a similar diversity , though not perhaps in an equal degree .
A piece of rhomboidal , otherways called refracting or lantern spar , was broken into four smaller pieces , the specific gravities of which were 2.675 , 2.687 , 2.715 , 2.723 ; the medium of the four is 2.700 .
Mr. COTES fixes the specific gravity of Iceland crystal at 2.720 , and WALLERIUS fixes it at 2.700 .
The specific gravities of four pieces of the same lump of cubical spar were 3.204 , 3.218 , 3.222 , 3.231 ; the medium of the four is 3.219 .
Six ounces of fine tessellated lead ore were put into a crucible and exposed , at first , to a gentle , afterwards to a strong fire : the ore grew red , and emitted fumes which smelled of sulphur ; at length it melted , and the fumes became very copious ; they were accompanied with a yellowish flame upon the surface of the melted ore , and when collected had a whitish appearance .
The crucible after the ore had continued a full hour in perfect fusion was taken from the fire , and when it was cold it was broken .
The mass which it contained weighed five ounces and an half ; there were no scoria observable on its surface , nor were any particles of metal formed , it was still an ore of lead .
The mass remaining from the last experiment was put into a fresh crucible , and exposed to a strong melting heat ; the fumes which arose from it seemed to be heavy ; they brooded over the surface of the melted mass in undulating flames , which now and then appeared like burning zinc .
The lead was now formed , and many particles of it were sublimed to at least six inches above the surface of the liquid in the crucible .
After letting the crucible continue two hours in this state , I poured out its contents , and found them consisting partly of lead , partly of lead ore , and partly of a very minute portion of brownish scoria .
These experiments prove , that some substance or other is contained in lead ore , which must be dispersed before the ore can be formed into lead ; and they show too , that it requires a considerable time to effect the dispersion of this substance , since six ounces of ore , though kept three hours or more in complete fusion , were not wholly brought into the form of lead ; and , lastly , they render it probable , that the fumes , arising from melted ore , carry off with them no inconsiderable portion of the lead itself .
At the great smelting houses in Derbyshire , they put a ton of ore at a time into the furnace , and work it off in eight hours ; the ore might be wholly melted in one hour , but the lead perhaps is not formed in the greatest possible quantity in eight hours .
Some fine tesselated lead ore from Derbyshire was pounded into small lumps , each about the size of a pea , and carefully picked from spar and other impurities .
Sixteen ounces of this ore , thus previously cleansed , were distilled in an earthen retort ; as soon at the ore felt the fire , the stopple of the quilled receiver had a strong smell resembling that of the inflammable air separable from some metals by solution in acids ; soon after a small portion of a liquid came over into the receiver ; the fire was then raised till the retort was of a white heat , when a black matter began to be sublimed into the neck of the retort ; the operation was then discontinued .
This experiment was undertaken with a view of seeing whether sulphur could be separated from lead ore , as it may be from some species of the pyrites , by distillation , and it appears from the issue of the experiment that it cannot .
What might have been the event of the experiment if it had been conducted with a very gentle heat for a long time , I cannot pretend to say .
Upon breaking the retort I found , that the ore had been melted during the operation , for there was a consistent cake of ore of the figure of the bottom of the retort ; the weight of this cake was fifteen ounces and an half , the weight of the liquid in the receiver , and of the black matter which had been sublimed , did not together amount to one quarter of an ounce , so that a quarter of an ounce or more had been dispersed , probably in the form of air , or some elastic fluid .
The ore by this process had lost one thirty-second part of its weight ; but I am of opinion , that if the operation had been conducted with a less degree of heat and continued for a longer time , the quantity of liquid would have been augmented .
The liquid did not effervesce with either acids or alkalies ; nor did it produce any change in the colour of blue paper , though I am certain , from experiment , that one drop of oil of vitriol , though diluted with two ounces of water , would have produced a sensible redness on the blue paper which I used .
The liquid , notwithstanding , had an acid taste , and a pungent smell , resembling that of the volatile vitriolic acid .
The experiment ought to be repeated with a larger quantity of ore , in order to ascertain the quantity and quality of the liquid , separable therefrom by simple distillation .
The black matter which had been sublimed into the neck of the retort , was examined with a microscope , and it appeared to be pure lead ore ; hence it is probable , that by a due degree of heat in close vessels , lead ore might be entirely sublimed without being decomposed ; for the melted ore which was found at the bottom of the retort , had not any appearance of either scoria , or of lead , upon its surface .
Finding that sulphur could not be separated from lead ore by distilling it without addition , and yet being much disposed to think , that it contained a considerable portion of sulphur , I first thought of distilling it with charcoal dust , iron filings , sand , and other additions ; but recollecting that sulphur might be separated from antimony money by solutions in acids , I thought it not improbable , that it might be separated from lead ore by the same means , and the success of the following experiment abundantly justified the conjecture .
Upon ten ounces of lead ore , cleansed as in the preceding experiment , I poured five ounces of the strongest fuming spirit of nitre ; this strong acid not seeming to act upon the ore , I diluted it with five ounces of water ; a violent ebullition , accompanied with red fumes , immediately took place ; the solution of the ore in this menstruum became manifest , and when it was finished , there remained floating upon the surface of the menstruum a cake of fine yellow sulphur , perfectly resembling common sulphur .
I repeated this experiment a great many times , in order to ascertain the quantity of sulphur contained in lead ore , and separable therefrom by solution in acid of nitre .
The results of different experiments were seldom the same : the matter separable from the ore by solution , after being repeatedly washed in large quantities of hot water , in order to free it from every saline admixture , sometimes amounted to more , sometimes to less than one-third the weight of the ore .
This matter may , for the sake of distinction , be called crude sulphur .
Its apparent purity might induce a belief that it contained no heterogeneous mixture , yet the following experiments show how much we should be deceived in forming such a conjecture , and how rightly it is denominated crude sulphur .
From one hundred and twenty parts , by weight , of lead ore , I obtained , by solution in acid of nitre , subsequent washing in hot water , and drying by a gentle fire , forty parts of a substance which looked like sulphur : these forty parts were put on a red-hot iron , the sulphur was made manifest by a blue flame and pungent smell .
When the flame went out , there remained upon the iron unconsumed twenty-six parts of a greyish calx ; the weight of the sulphur which was consumed must therefore have amounted to fourteen parts , or between one eighth and one ninth part of the weight of the ore .
It has been observed , that the weight of the matter , separable from lead ore by solution in acid of nitre , sometimes exceeded , and sometimes fell short of , one third part of the weight of the ore ; this variety , as far as I have been able to observe , does not extend to the quantity of sulphur contained in a given quantity of ore , but depends upon the quantity of calx remaining after the burning of the sulphur .
Different lead ores will , doubtless , contain different quantities of sulphur ; but that the sulphur contained in the lead ore which I examined constitutes between one eighth and one ninth part of the weight of the ore , is a conclusion upon which , from a variety of experiments , I am disposed to rely .
There are annually smelted in Derbyshire about ten thousand tons of lead ore : now if means could be invented ( which I think very possible ) of saving the sulphur contained in ten thousand tons of ore , supposing that the ore should only yield one tenth of its weight of sulphur , though it unquestionably contains more , Derbyshire alone would furnish annually one thousand tons of sulphur , the value of which would annually be about fifteen thousand pounds .
I mention this circumstance thus publicly , in hopes that the lead smelters may be induced to prosecute the object .
If the sulphur contained in lead ore could be collected , it would not only be a lucrative business to the smelters , but a great saving to the nation .
We at present import the sulphur we use , and the consumption of this commodity is exceeding great , in the making of gunpowder , in forming the mixture for covering the bottom and sides of ships , and in a great variety of arts .
The smelters need not be apprehensive lest the quality of the ore should be injured by extracting the sulphur .
Eighteen hundred weight of ore , from which the sulphur has been extracted , will certainly yield as much lead as twenty hundred weight of ore , from which the sulphur has not been extracted , and it will probably yield more .
Arsenic is extracted from a particular ore in Saxony , by roasting the ore in a furnace , which has a long horizontal chimney ; the chimney is large , has many windings and angles , that the arsenical vapour which arises from the ore may be the more easily condensed : the arsenic attaches itself like soot to the sides of the chimney , and is from time to time swept out .
It is very probable , that by some such contrivance the sulphur contained in lead ore might be collected .
The smelters call every thing sulphur which is volatilized during the roasting or fluxing of an ore ; but none of those with whom I have conversed had any notion that common sulphur could be separated from lead ore .
The greyish calx which remained upon the iron after the sulphur was consumed , was put upon a piece of lighted charcoal ; the heat of the charcoal being quickened by blowing upon it , a great number of globules of lead were formed upon its surface .
From hence it appears , that this calx is not an unmetallic earth contained in the ore , which the acid of nitre could not dissolve ; but a calx of lead , probably produced by the violent action of the acid , and which , by the addition of phlogiston , may be exhibited in its metallic form .
The quantity of this calx depends much upon the action of the acid upon the ore ; if that action is violent , the calx is in greater abundance than if it be moderate ; and I am not certain whether the experiment might not be so managed , that there would be little or no calx remaining ; that is , a given quantity of ore might be so dissolved in the acid of nitre , that nothing would remain undissolved except the sulphur .
But I have not yet perfectly satisfied myself as to the constituent parts of lead ore .
I am certain that it contains lead and sulphur , a liquid and air : of the existence of the three first there can be no doubt , from what has been said , and the air is rendered beautifully apparent by the following experiment .
Let some lead ore be reduced into a fine powder , put it into a narrow-bottomed ale glass , fill the glass three parts with water , drop into the water a portion of the strong acid of nitre , you may judge of the requisite quantity by seeing the solution commence , and you will observe the ore universally covered with bubbles of air , these will buoy the ore up in large tufts to the surface , and the air will continue to be separated from the ore till the acid becomes saturated with the lead .
The salt arising from the union of the nitrous acid to the lead often appears crystallized upon the surface of the menstruum in this experiment ; and if , when the menstruum is in that state , a little fresh acid be added , the salt instantly crystallizes and falls down to the bottom of the glass , the acid having absorbed the water which held it in solution .
When lead is dissolved in the manner here mentioned , by a very diluted acid of nitre , there is no appearance of sulphur upon the surface of the menstruum , there is found at its bottom a black matter which is the sulphur .
But though lead and sulphur , a liquid and air , are unquestionably constituent parts of lead ore , I do not take upon me to say , that they are the only constituent parts : it is well known , that , during the smelting of lead ore , a third part or more of its weight is somehow or other lost , since from one and twenty hundred weight of ore they seldom obtain above fourteen hundred weight of lead .
What is lost partly consists of a scoria which floats upon the surface of the lead during the operation of smelting , and partly of what is sublimed up the chimney and dissipated in the air .
The scoria , I apprehend , would be very little even from a ton of ore , if the ore was quite free from spar : it is the spar which is mixed with the ore that constitutes the main portion of the scoria .
I have in my possession a solid mass of scoria , which accidentally flowed out from a smelting furnance , and which in colour and consistency perfectly resembles grey lime-stone ; it receives a polish as fine as marble , and it might , perhaps , with advantage be cast into molds for paving stones , chimney pieces , and other matters .
It arises from the spar mixed with the ore , and , by the addition of fusible spar to the ore during its fusion , its quantity might be increased at no great expense , in any proportion .
That part of the ore which is sublimed and dispersed in the air , consists partly of the sulphur which is consumed , and partly of lead ; this sublimed lead attaches itself in part to the sides of the chimney of the smelting furnace ; the rest of it flies up into the air , from whence it falls upon the ground , poisoning the water and herbage upon which it settles .
This sublimed lead might be collected either by making it meet with water , or with the vapour of water during its ascent , or by making it pass through an horizontal chimney of a sufficient length .
It is not easy to determine with precision the quantity of this sublimed lead ; a general guess , however , may throw some light upon the subject .
They usually at a smelting house work off three tons , or sixty hundred weight , of lead ore every twenty-four hours ; the sulphur contained in sixty hundred weight of ore we will suppose to be seven hundred weight , and the lead to be forty hundred weight ; the air , liquid , scoria , and sublimed lead , must together , upon this supposition , amount to thirteen hundred weight ; now , admitting three hundred weight of the thirteen to be sublimed lead , it is evident that , could it be collected , there would be an annual saving at each smelting house of above fifty tons , which , supposing it to be worth four pounds per ton , would amount to above two hundred pounds a year .
The price and quantity of lead.sublimate here assumed are probably both of them below the truth ; but my end is answered in giving this hint to persons engaged in the smelting business .
The following experiments , though upon a different subject , may not be unacceptable to the lovers of chemistry , as I do not remember to have any where met with them .
I trouble the Society with a relation of them at this time , that I may not hereafter intrude upon their leisure .
It is commonly known , that the surface of melted lead becomes covered with a pellicle of various colours .
I undertook some experiments in the course of last winter , with a view to ascertain the order in which the colours succeeded each other .
The lead which lines the boxes in which tea is imported from China happening to be at hand , some of it was melted in an iron ladle ; but I was much surprised to find that its surface , though it was presently covered with a dusky pellicle , did not exhibit any colours .
Imagining that the heat was not sufficiently strong to render the colours visible , the fire was urged till the ladle became red-hot , the calcined pellicle upon the surface of the lead was red-hot also , but it was still without colour .
The same parcel of lead was boiled in a crucible for a considerable time ; during the boiling a copious steam was discharged , and the surface of the lead , as is usual , became covered with a half vitrified scoria .
The lead which remained unvitrified was then examined , and it had acquired the property of forming a succession of coloured pellicles during the whole time of continuing in a state of fusion .
Another portion of the same kind of lead was exposed to a strong calcining heat for a long time ; the part which remained uncalcined did , at length , acquire the property of exhibiting colours sufficiently vivid .
These experiments induced me to conclude , that the Chinese lead was mixed with some substance from which it was necessary to free it , either by sublimation or calcination , before it would exhibit its colours .
It would be useless to mention all the experiments which I made before I discovered the heterogeneous substance with which I supposed the Chinese lead was mixed .
At last I hit upon one which seems fully sufficient to explain the phenomenon .
Into a ladle full of melted Derbyshire lead , which manifested a succession of the most vivid colours , I put a small portion of tin , and observed , that as soon as the tin was melted , and mixed with the lead , no more colours were to be seen .
I do not know precisely the smallest possible quantity of tin , which will be sufficient to deprive a given quantity of lead of its property of forming coloured pellicles , but I have reason to believe , that it does not exceed one five thousandth part of weight of the lead .
Derbyshire lead , which has lost its property of exhibiting colours by being mixed with tin , acquires it again , as is mentioned of the Chinese lead , by being exposed to a calcining heat for a sufficient time ; the tin it is supposed being separated from the lead by calcination before all the lead is reduced to a calx .
Some calcined Chinese lead was reduced to its metallic form by burning some tallow over it .
The reduced lead gave , when melted , coloured pellicles ; the calx of tin , which we suppose to have been mixed with the calcined lead , not being so easily reducible as that of lead .
I find that zinc is another metallic substance which has the same property as tin with respect to the depriving lead of its power of forming coloured pellicles ; but it does not , I think , possess this power in so eminent a degree as tin .
I put small portions of bismuth also into melted lead , but the lead still retained its quality of forming colours .
I melted together some silver and lead , but the lead did not thereby lose its power of forming colours .
A little tin added to a mixture of lead and bismuth , or to a mixture of silver and lead , immediately takes away from the respective mixtures the faculty of forming coloured pellicles .
This quality of tin has hitherto , as far as I know , been unobserved ; but every new fact , relative to the actions of bodies one upon another , ought to be recorded .
The change produced in lead by the admixture of a small portion of tin is much felt by the plumbers , as it makes the metal so hard and harsh , that it is not without difficulty they can cast it into sheet lead .
If their old lead does not work so willingly , nor exhibit colours so readily , as new lead , they may refer the difference to the small quantity of tin contained in the solder , from which old lead can seldom be thoroughly freed .
With respect to the order in which the colours succeed one another upon the surface of melted lead , it seems to be the following one ; yellow , purple , blue , yellow , purple , green , pink , green , pink , ~ green .
Upon exhibiting the bright surface of melted lead to the air , I have often observed these ten changes to follow one another in a more or less rapid succession , according to the degree of heat prevailing in the lead .
If the heat is but small , the succession stops before it has gone through all the changes ; but with the greatest heat I did not observe any further variation .
All the colours are very vivid , and each seems to go through all the shades belonging to it before it is changed into the next in order .
The formation of these colours may be explained from what has been advanced by Sir ISAAC NEWTON , and illustrated by the very ingenious experiments of Mr. DELAVAL , relative to the size of the particles constituting coloured bodies .

