XXXVI .
Reasons for dissenting from the Report of the Committee appointed to consider of Mr. Wilson 's Experiments ; including Remarks on some Experiments exhibited by Mr. Nairne .
By Dr. Musgrave , F. R. S. I DO not find that Dr. FRANKLIN , in any of the passages where he speaks of the efficacy of sharp-pointed conductors to prevent electrical explosions , has expressed any doubt of their being universally preferable for this purpose to those which have a blunt or spherical termination .
The same observation may be made of the other gentlemen who are the advocates for his doctrine .
It may therefore be assumed , that both he and they mean to assert an universal proposition , ` ` That sharp points will , in all cases , draw off the electrical fluid silently within the distance at which rounded ends will explode ; or , at least , that the former sort will in no case receive an explosion at a greater distance than the latter .
' ' I think it necessary to observe , that , though I dissent from this doctrine , I do not mean to assert the contrary universal proposition , but only to deny the universality of that asserted by Dr. FRANKLIN , which VO L. LXVIII .
5GI appreRead June 25 , I apprehend to be sometimes true , and sometimes also false .
But before I attempt to specify the particular cases in which the sharp and the blunt terminations are respectively more liable to electrical explosions , it may be of use to show ( what many gentlemen seem not to be thoroughly aware of ) that sharp points having the most perfect communication with the earth , are not wholly exempt from receiving them .
My first authority shall be Dr. FRANKLIN himself .
` ` Let a person , ' ' says he , p. 60 .
standing on the floor , present the point of a needle at twelve or more inches from it [ the prime conductor ] , and while the needle is so presented , the conductor cannot be charged , the point drawing off the fire as fast as it is thrown on by the electrical globe .
Let it be charged , and then present the point at the same distance , and it will suddenly be discharged .
' ' The word suddenly means , I suppose , that it will receive an explosion ; that being the most natural and obvious proof of the suddenness of the discharge .
The same thing is more directly asserted by Mr. HENLY , in vol. LXIV .
of the Phil. Trans. p. 138 .
where he informs us , that in discharging three of his large jars , to the coating of which he had connected a wire nicely tapered to a point , the fire flew to the point , and the jars were discharged with a full and loud explosion .
A third , and equally decisive , proof is furnished by Mr. NAIRNE'S own experiments , though seemingly made with a contrary view .
For when the double or interrupted conductor was used , and the second conductor fixed down by screws at about three inches distance from the first , the point presented to the contrary end of the second conductor was found to receive a strong and loud explosion , with a white light at the distance of at least three inches .
If we compare this experiment with another , very common one , exhibited at the same time by Mr. NAIRNE , the comparison will , perhaps , lead us to the discovery of a principle upon which electrical explosions very frequently depend .
Though the point , in the circumstances above described , received so strong an explosion , yet when it was presented directly to the prime conductor , it received no explosion whatever at any distance , unless a succession of weak sparks , at the distance of about a quarter of an inch , can be called so .
To what must this difference be attributed ?
Plainly to the different quantity of electric fluid accumulated on the prime conductor in the one and the other case .
Where the point is presented to the prime conductor , from the time the machine begins to work , the property which is attributed to them , and which , in some cases , they really possess , of stealing away the electricity silently ; this property , I say , operating from the very beginning , prevents the electric fluid from being accumulated in the prime conductor , and of course the quantity of it will always be small .
But when a double or interrupted conductor is used , the second conductor receives no electricity till the prime conductor is pretty highly charged , and , if put at the greatest striking distance , not till it is fully charged , and consequently the sharp point presented to the opposite end can carry away none of it till that time ; when the whole quantity is thrown off at once .
It should seem then , that the explosion in one case , and the non-explosion in the other , depended wholly upon the different quantities to be thrown off : whence it will follow , that though a small quantity of electricity will pass off silently upon a point , yet that this power is very limited ; for that if a somewhat greater quantity be applied suddenly to a sharp point , it will not pass off silently , but create an explosion in proportion to its density .
The facts above related are a sufficient answer to that other experiment of Mr. NAIRNE'S , in which he exhibited a sharp point , that when perfectly communicating with the earth drew off the electricity silently from the prime conductor ; but received explosions freely , when the communication was broken by interposing little isthmuses of sealing wax .
This experiment , it is true , demonstrates that a broken communication will occasion the sharp point to receive an explosion ; and so far it must be owned to be conclusive .
But if it was intended to suggest , that whenever sharp points do receive an explosion , it is owing to this circumstance , and , consequently , that Mr. WILSON'S experiments at the Pantheon were unfairly made ; in this view it has no weight , because we have already seen that an interrupted communication is not the only circumstance that will produce an explosion , for that increasing the quantity of electricity will have the same effect .
I cannot omit the opportunity here offered me , of remarking the unfairness of the insinuations that have been thrown out to the prejudice of Mr. WILSON .
Had there been any juggle in making his experiments , it would certainly have been detected by the committee appointed to examine them .
And in case of such a detection , it was the duty of the committee to lay open the imposture both to the Society and the Public .
Instead of which , instead of disputing or even doubting the fairness of them , they have in a manner admitted it , by only saying in their report , that they appear to be inconclusive .
This , I say , is admitting the facts to be fairly stated : unless we could suppose their regard for Mr. WILSON , and tenderness for his reputation , had induced them , after detecting the fallacy of his experiments , to pass it over in silence ; of which improper partiality I do not know that they are so much as suspected .
What therefore the committee , after a strict scrutiny of the matter , did not think themselves warranted to say , I take for granted they would not insinuate ; and that therefore such insinuations can only arise from the levity of more obscure persons , puzzled perhaps by the seeming contradiction between Mr. WILSON'S experiments and those of Mr. NAIRNE , and too impatient to investigate the real causes of that difference .
I am persuaded , however , that the known property of sharp points to carry off electricity silently , when the quantity is small , together with that other principle , which I apprehend I have here established , that they cease to do so when the quantity is large ; that these two ( taken together ) will clear up the whole difficulty , and account for Mr. NAIRNE'S experiments , without any impeachment to those of Mr. WILSON .
I have already had occasion , in the course of this argument , to consider two of those experiments , of which therefore I shall say no more ; but proceed , without further digression , to examine those that remain .
The first I shall mention is that , in which the prime conductor , being previously charged with electricity , a sharp point is presented to it within the attracting , and without the exploding distance , and then brought slowly on towards it .
In this case no explosion follows ; neither is there any reason to expect it should , because the quantity of electricity is gradually diminished by the approach of the point , so that when it comes within the striking distance there is not enough left to make an explosion .
It is equally easy to explain what happens when a transverse arm is hung so as to oscillate freely upon the prime conductor , and two equal cylinders of tin-foil are suspended , one at each end of this arm in perfect equilibrio with each other .
The apparatus being in this state , if the machine be worked , the two cylinders will remain stationary , neither of them ascending or descending .
They will also remain stationary , if a point be presented to one , and a rounded end to the other .
In the first case they are electrified , but remain motionless , because there is no conducting body within the sphere of their action .
In the second , the result is the same ; because , making in fact part of the prime conductor , the point presented to one of them prevents any accumulation of electricity .
When the point is withdrawn , and the rounded end suffered to remain , an accumulation takes place , because there is nothing now to steal it away ; and the consequence is , that the cylinder descends towards the rounded end , and explodes as soon as that accumulation arrives at a certain period .
Thirdly , when an intermediate conductor is used , terminated at each end with a ball , and the middle of it resting in equilibrio upon a pivot , on which it has a free oscillation upwards and downwards ; if in this state a point is placed under the end most distant from the prime conductor , the machine being then worked , the other end will approach so near the prime conductor , as that the stream of electricity will flow freely into it , as fast as it is produced by the action of the wheel .
In this case there will be no explosion ; and the reason is obvious , because the second conductor , when it approaches so near the first as to form an uninterrupted channel for the electric stream , becomes virtually a part of the first .
Hence the point operates upon both together , just as it does when presented directly to the prime conductor , that is , it steals away the electricity by little and little , leaving not enough to give an explosion .
When instead of the point a polished ball is placed under the same end as before , this being less disposed to receive the electric fluid , conveys away none of it ; so that accumulating to a certain degree upon the prime conductor , it explodes upon the contiguous end of the second , which , having a free oscillation , flies up with the stroke , and carries the opposite end towards the ball , where , being saturated , it gives a snap ; the recoil of which snap throws that end up , and the contrary end back towards the conductor , and so on alternately , as long as the machine continues working .
The event , however , is widely different when the second conductor , instead of having a free oscillation , is screwed down in one place , and at such a distance from the prime conductor , as not to receive the electric fluid till considerably accumulated .
For then the sharp point , previously opposed to its other end , discharges it , as was before observed , not in a continued stream and silently , but at intervals , and with a strong explosion .
The last of Mr. NAIRNE'S experiments , and the only one yet unconsidered , is that of the sharp point , which , being fixed to a kind of inverted pendulum , oscillated with great velocity under the prime conductor , without receiving any explosion .
Now from this experiment I do not comprehend how any general conclusion can possibly be drawn .
It has been already shown , from the acknowledgement of Dr. FRANKLIN , and the experiments of Mr. HENLY and Mr. NAIRNE , that electricity , accumulated to a certain degree , will explode upon a point .
If , therefore , in any particular instance it does not explode , what can we infer from it , but that the accumulation in every such instance was not sufficiently great ; which may happen either from the smallness of the apparatus , or from want of care in making the experiment .
And now if we look back upon Mr. NAIRNE'S experiments ( which , by the by , have not all of them the merit of novelty ) we shall find them to be nothing more than different exemplifications of this well-known principle , that sharp points giving less resistance to the ingress of the electric fluid will draw it off at a greater distance than blunt or spherical terminations , and where the quantity is small will draw it off silently .
This , I say , is the whole amount of his experiments ; the only one of them in which the electric fluid had time to accumulate , being attended with a different event from the rest , and producing , as might reasonably be expected , a strong explosion .
It is not , however , this single property of sharppointed conductors , which must decide the question .
We have already seen , that there are two properties inseparable from them , both of which must be taken into the account , before we can determine the propriety of affixing them to buildings , particularly powder magazines , as preservatives from lightning : first , their greater propensity to admit the electric fluid , in consequence of which they act upon electrified bodies at a greater distance than rounded ends will ; and , secondly , their incapacity to draw away more than a certain quantity of electricity without an explosion .
The first quality enables them , when electricity is accumulated gradually , or when they are brought gradually towards the electrified body , to steal away the fluid by little and little , till there is not enough left to give an explosion .
And hence , in common experiments , the point , placed at a greater distance than the ball , will prevent the electricity from exploding , as it otherwise would do , upon the latter .
But if we combine this quality with the second , the superior propensity to admit , with the incapacity in certain circumstances of discharging silently , it will be evident , a priori , that the phenomena must in such cases be reversed , just as they appear to be in Mr. WILSON'S experiments ; that the point must strike at a greater distance , and the rounded end at a lesser .
What puts this matter beyond a doubt is , that when the double or interrupted conductor is used , the experiment may be so managed , as that the ball shall receive an explosion at a greater distance than the point , or the point at a greater distance than the ball , at the pleasure of the operator .
If care be taken , at the beginning of the experiment , to set the second conductor at the greatest distance from the first , compatible with its giving a full and smart explosion , the point in that case will receive the explosion at a much greater distance than the ball .
I was myself once present at an experiment , when the difference was as 6 to 1 , that is , the ball would receive no explosion at a greater distance than 7/ 8ths of an inch , when the point received it at six times that distance .
On the contrary , if the second conductor be put considerably within the distance above described , the ball will receive an explosion much farther off than the point .
Upon repeating both these experiments lately with a small machine , I found the result to be as follows .
When the distance between the first and second conductor was 15/ 8th of an inch , the point was struck at 21/ 16th of an inch ; but a ball of 15/ 8ths of an inch in diameter would not take the stroke at more than one inch .
But when the distance between the conductors was only 5/ 8ths of an inch , the point could not be struck at more than 7/ 8ths , whereas a ball of the same diameter as before was struck at 7 inches and 3/ 4 , and a lesser ball 3/ 10ths of an inch in diameter at 6 inches and 3/ 16ths .
I have been told also , but have not yet had time to verify it , that a medium distance may be found , at which if the second conductor be set , the point and ball presented to the other end will be exactly upon a par with respect to the exploding distance .
These phenomena , to persons who have not carefully considered them , must appear so extraordinary , that unless the cause of the diversity is explained , they will perhaps be led to suspect some unfairness in making the experiment .
The truth , however , is this ; that when the two conductors are set at the greater of the two distances , the absolute quantity of electricity collected before the explosion is exactly the same in each experiment ; and therefore the distances of the ball and point from the second conductor being equal , and the greatest at which either of them will be struck , the explosion will go to the point , as being more susceptible , and giving less resistance than the ball .
But in the second supposed case , when the second conductor is set considerably within the former distance , the quantity of electricity which explodes upon the point and the ball is not the same ; the point in this case exerting its known property of stealing away the electricity silently , which the ball from its greater resistance is incapable of doing .
The consequence is , that the quantity accumulated to give an explosion upon the ball is greater than that which explodes upon the point , and being greater will very naturally explode to a greater distance .
I might safely have rested the matter upon this ground ; but another proof , equally decisive , having since occurred , it is but doing justice to my argument to insert it here .
In the experiments made with a view to settle this dispute , and published by Mr. HENLY about four years ago , there is one , the fifth of that set , which it is difficult to reconcile with the doctrine here laid down , that electricity strongly accumulated , and moving with great velocity , will explode upon a sharp point rather than a ball .
He describes it thus : ` ` Having insulated the jar , and connected by chains with the external coating , on one side a knob , and on the other side a sharp-pointed wire , both being insulated and standing five inches from each other , I placed a large copper ball , eight inches in diameter ( insulated also ) so as to stand exactly at half an inch distance both from the knob and the point .
The jar being fully charged , I delivered it upon the copper ball by my discharging rod , whence it leaped to the knob , which was three quarters of an inch in diameter , and the jar was discharged by a loud and full explosion , and the chain was very luminous .
' ' Phil. Trans. vol. LXIV .
p. 136 .
It must be obvious to any careful electrician , and Mr. WILSON had in his answer observed , that an experiment thus loosely and unphilosophically made , was not greatly to be relied upon ; because two chains being made use of , one to connect the ball , and another to connect the sharp point with the coating of the phial , a different number of links , or different degree of tightness in the two chains , would produce a difference in the result : for it bing a known property of electricity to pass most readily where it has the fewest and the smallest intervals to leap over , the explosion would naturally pass that way , where the links were drawn tightest ; or if both chains were lest loose , as from the plate they appear to have been , then where they were fewest in number , instead of being determined by the circumstances of bluntness and sharpness .
It was however possible , that Mr. HENLY might be right in attributing it to the sharpness of the point ; and therefore , in order to settle this doubt , I desired that the experiment might be tried over again in somewhat different circumstances .
Mr. CAVALLO accordingly tried it in the following manner .
Upon an insulated stand he placed a ball , about 6/ 10ths of an inch in diameter , and a sharp point , directly opposite to the place where a Leyden phial , when charged , was to be set down .
Both of these , the ball and point , were connected to his discharging rod by copper wire .
He then took the phial , which held about a quart , and having charged it , set it down before the ball and point , took his discharging rod , and completed the circuit .
After the explosion the distances were measured .
In the experiments which I saw the phenomena were as follows : in the first , the distance of the ball was 19/ 20 of an inch , that of the point 26/ 20 ; in the second , distance of the ball 16/ 20 , of the point 27/ 20 ; in the third , distance of the ball 15/ 20 , of the point 26/ 20 ; in the fourth , distance of the ball 18/ 20 , of the point 29/ 20 .
In all these experiments the point , though considerably farther off from the coating of the phial , was struck in preference to the ball .
In a fifth experiment , when the point stood at double the distance , the ball was struck , and not the point .
The result of these experiments being so widely different from the result of that made by Mr. HENLY , is a clear proof that he formed his conclusions too hastily , having attributed to sharpness and bluntness a phenomenon caused by the unequal resistances of the chains .
As this experiment may be made with almost any machine , those who do not chuse to repeat it will have no right to plead the want of a sufficient apparatus , and must look out for some other reason to evade the force of it .
I come now to consider more particularly the practical question , whether the sharp-pointed or the blunt conductors are most proper to be affixed to buildings , as preservatives from lightning .
And here it is necessary to observe , that buildings may be exposed to a stroke of lightning in several different ways .
The lightning which , to avoid prolixity , I shall only speak of as positive electricity : the lightning , I say , may accumulate directly over the building ; or it may be brought towards the building by a small cloud fetching it in several successive trips from a large cloud at some distance ; or a large electrified cloud may be carried rapidly towards it by the wind : a circumstance this by no means rare , there being no less than four instances of it upon record in the Phil. Trans. vol. XLIX .
p. 16 .
and p. 309 .
vol. LXI .
p. 72 .
and vol. LXIV .
p. 351 .
In the first of these supposed cases a sharp-pointed conductor might possibly drain the cloud of its lightning as fast as it began to accumulate , and thereby prevent any explosion whatever .
In the second , as the cloud , by supposition , not being driven in one direction by the wind , could not move with any remarkable velocity , it is reasonable to imagine , that in this case also there might be no explosion ; and that the electricity of the larger cloud might be gradually exhausted .
But if , according to the third supposition , a cloud of great extent and highly electrified should be driven with great velocity in such a direction , so as to pass directly over the sharp-pointed conductor , there can be no doubt but that such a point , from its superior readiness to admit electricity , would take the explosion at a much greater distance than a rounded end , and in proportion to the difference of that striking distance would do mischief instead of good .
But perhaps it will be said , that every stroke of lightning falling upon a sharp point is previously diminished by that point , and therefore may more easily be transmitted through the conductor , than when it falls undiminished upon a rounded end .
Upon this supposition I must observe , that it not only contradicts Mr. WILSON 's experiments at the Pantheon , but also Mr. HENLY'S expement already referred to in this paper , where the fire flew to a very taper point , and melted the end with a strong and loud explosion .
So also the sharp-pointed conductors affixed in America to the houses of Mr. WEST , Mr. RAVEN , and Mr. MAYNE , do not seem to have diminished the force of the explosion , if we may judge from the violence of its effects as related at large in Dr. FRANKLIN'S works .
It should seem , therefore , that the power of diminishing a stroke , like that of preventing it , is only contingent , and depends , as we said before , upon the degree of velocity with which the lightning moves .
The sum of the whole is , that conductors , terminated by sharp points , are sometimes advantageous , and at other times prejudicial .
Now as the purpose for which conductors are fixed upon buildings is , not to protect them from one particular sort of clouds only , but , if possible , from all , it cannot surely be adviseable to use that kind of conductors , which if they diminish danger on one hand , will increase it on the other .
It is the duty of a pilot to keep out of the way of rocks ; but it is also incumbent upon him , in avoiding the rock , not to take so large a compass as to run his ship upon a quicksand .
When I say that sharp-pointed conductors may in some cases diminish danger , I speak of them , perhaps , rather too favourably : for their power of stealing away the electric fluid being confined to cases where the accumulation is small , it follows , that they only operate where their operation is not wanted .
The cases against which we wish principally to provide , are the explosions of extensive and highly electrified clouds ; and here we have seen , that blunted ends , as acting to a much smaller distance , are entitled to the preference .
If it be admitted , that sharp-pointed conductors are attended with any , the flightest degree of danger , how much must that danger be augmented by carrying them high up into the air , by fixing them upon every angle of a building , and making them project in every direction ?
Ought this to be advised while there is still a doubt of the possibility of their doing mischief ?
And can the committee , therefore , be perfectly justified for giving such a decided preference to the use of sharp conductors , in defiance of numerous experiments , not one of which they have attempted to controvert ?
I have now done with the report of the committee , and shall next proceed to enquire whether , as some gentlemen apprehend , the termination of conductors is a matter of indifference : but this I must reserve for the subject of a future paper .
APPENDI X. I think it necessary to apprize the reader , that the foregoing remarks were drawn up before Mr. NAIRNE'S paper appeared , and are therefore to be considered as relating only to his experiments .
I must at the same time observe , that , in stating the different circumstances in which lightning may be collected so as to affect a building , I have supposed a case which possibly may never exist .
I have said , that lightning may accumulate directly over a building , and admitted , that in that case the cloud might be drained of it by a pointed conductor .
Now we have no evidence , that the accumulation of lightning is confined to a single cloud , or small circumscribed spot in the heavens .
On the contrary , the numerous explosions , which in most thunder storms happen nearly at one and the same instant , rather lead us to imagine that a great part of the horizon is at those times full of lightning , and therefore incapable of being drained .
I would therefore wish to have my supposition understood as a mere imaginary supposition , for the sake of rendering the argument more perspicuous , and not as the admission of a real fact .
Lastly , I beg leave to correct an expression I have used with respect to pointed conductors , that they only operate where their operation is not wanted .
Now this is not accurately true : for if by operating upon a quantity of electricity too small in itself to do mischief , they prevent its growing to a great and dangerous quantity , this would , as far as it goes , be a very considerable advantage .
I ought therefore to have said only , that pointed conductors afford no protection where the danger is great and imminent , and only obviate that which is distant and problematical ; and that these last are not the cases against which we principally wish to provide .

