XXXII .
Comparison between Sir George Shuckburgh and Colonel Roy 's Rules for the Measurement of Heights with the Barometer ; in a Letter to Col. Roy , F. R. S. from Sir George Shuckburgh , Bart. F. R. S. TOCOLONELRO Y. SIR , Welbeck Street , April 20 , 1778 .
SINCE the printing of your ingenious memoir on the subject of measuring heights with the barometer , I have been naturally led to a comparison of your rules and observations with my own(a ) ; and herein am not more pleased than surprised at the general correspondency of our results , which carries with it the appearance of one and the same series of experiments , rather than of distinct observations made with different instruments , in different countries , and by different persons .
That the standard temperature or zero on the scale of the thermometer should be found by each of us to fall in the same point to within one-third of a degree is , I think , truly surprising ; and I doubt not will evince to Mr. DE LUC the strong probability there is of ( a ) Vide Phil. Trans. vol. LXVII .
VO L. LXVIII .
4P the Read May 7 , the necessity of correcting his rules .
But although in this essential and fundamental part of the inquiry we agree , there are , nevertheless , some little circumstances wherein we differ ; it is the subject of this letter , SIR , to point out to you the degree of our differences , a comparison that I had the pleasure slightly to exhibit to you a few days ago , and which I trust will not be found unimportant to those who may be engaged in these pursuits : if , therefore , you judge these remarks of sufficient moment , I will beg the favour of you to lay them before the Royal Society , as the best means of communicating them to the public .
The two chief causes of our difference are , the expansion of quicksilver and the expansion of air .
I shall begin with the equation for quicksilver .
The mean temperature of ordinary barometrical observations , I apprehend , will generally be found to lie between 40~ and 70~ on FAHRENHEIT'S thermometer ; now the mean expansion in this range , according to your observation , is,0323 inch on a column of 30 inches for 10~ of heat ; by my table it is only,0304 inch , the difference,0019 inch is equal to about 20 inches in the result of the height , when the temperature of the two barometers differs 10~ , and this may reasonably be expected only in a height of 3000 or 4000 feet .
In an observation on Mount AEtna , one of the greatest accessible heights in Europe , the difference of temperature at the top and bottom might amount to 30~ , and this would occasion a difference of about five feet , which , I apprehend , may be reckoned inconsiderable in a height of 11,000 feet .
In fact , in an observation on this mountain by Mr. DESSAUSSURE it amounted to only 31/ 2 feet .
I may add , that your equation makes the computed height less than mine .
I proceed to the expansion of air .
Your equation is various according to the circumstances , the difference therefore of our results will , according to the circumstances , be various .
The following table will give the quantity of this difference , viz. it shows how much your result is + or mine upon one thousand feet , according to different pressures of the atmosphere and different temperatures .
The first column to the left hand contains the mean heat of the column of air between the two barometers ; the figures in the horizontal line at top are the mean height of the two barometers , or mean pressure of the atmosphere ; the common point of meeting in the different columns gives the difference of our result in feet , according to the respective circumstances .
Mean heat .
Mean height of the two barometers in inches .
0 30 29 28 27 26 25 24 23 22 21 20 32 00000000000 42 +1 0 -1 -2 -3 -4 -5 -6 -7 -8 -9 52 +2 0 -2 -4 -6 -8 -10 -12 -14 -16 -17 62 +5 +2 -1 -4 -7 -10 -13 -16 -19 -22 -25 72 +8 +4 0 -4 -10 -12 -17 -21 -25 -29 -33 Thus , if the mean height of the barometer were 27 inches , and the temperature 52~ , the difference of the results would be four feet in a thousand ; how far , therefore , this is of moment is left to the judgement of the observer .
I conclude lastly , SIR , with a comparison of your actual observations made in Great Britain computed after my tables , deduced from a series of observations made in Savoy .
I have indeed only collected sixteen of your observations ; but as I have chosen such as presented themselves as most proper , either on account of their heights or temperatures , I imagine these will be very satisfactory .
By my tables , By Col. ROY'S tables , True height in feet geometrically .
Mean temp. of the obs .
Place of observation .
Computed Error Error on Computed Error Error on height .
in feet .
1000 feet .
height .
in feet .
1000 feet .
o Station at Weem and top of Bol1076.5 1074.2 2.3 2.1 1075.5 1.0 0.9 581/ 2 frack 's Cairn , Ditto station and 1244.5 1240.6 3.9 3.1 1244.4 0.1 0.0 56 top of Dull-craig , Ditto station and South obs .
on 2098.0 2096.0 2.0 0.9 2091.3 6.7 3.2 521/ 2 Schehallien , Ditto station and 3281.0 3292.5 + 11.5 + 3.5 3279.0 2 0.6 501/ 2 West summit of 3261.3 19.7 6.1 3252.5 29.5 8.9 461/ 3 Schehallien , Carmichael-well 1642.5 1653.6 + 11.1 + 6.7 1646.9 + 4.4 + 2.7 541/ 2 and top of Tinto , 1645.0 + 3.5 + 2.1 1642.7 + 0.2 + 0.1 48 Level of Hawkhill and small 702.4 704.2 + 1.8 + 2.5 703 .
+ 1.3 + 1.9 201/ 2 rock on Arthur 's Seat , Base of Hawkhill Observatory and 684.0 684.1 + 0.1 + 0.1 686.7 + 2.7 + 3.9 17 bottom of the 685.4 + 1.4 + 2.0 687.0 + 3.0 + 4.4 681/ 2 small rock , Hawkhill gardendoor and bottom 730.8 723.0 7.8 10.7 721.8 9.0 11.3 291/ 2 of the rock on 745.8 + 15.0 + 20.6 748.4 + 17.6 + 24.2 71 Arthur 's Seat , Linhouse and East Cairn hill , 1176.6 1182.5 + 5.9 + 5.0 1180.0 + 3.4 + 2.9 301/ 2 Carnarvon Quay and Moel Eilio , 2371 .
2397.4 + 26.4 + 11.2 2393.3 + 22.3 + 9.4 623/ 8 Carnarvon Quay and Peak of 3555 .
3563.1 + 8.1 + 2.3 3551.3 3.7 1.0 561/ 2 3551.5 3.5 1.0 3548.4 6.6 1.9 53 Snowdon , Mean error + 2.0 Mean error + 14 Thus it seems , that the error of my tables , from a mean of all these observations , amounts to + 20/ 10000 ; of yours , to + 14/ 10000 : but it must be remarked , that the standard temperature , from whence I compute , is 31~ , 24 of FAHRENHETT , whereas in your computations it is assumed at 32~,0 ; this difference of 0~,76 is equal to 18/ 10000 in the correction for the expansion of the air : if then we were to set out from the same zero , viz. 32~ ( which I have proposed , see p. 569 .
of my memoir , Phil. Trans. vol. LXVII .
) the error of my tables , according to your observations , would become only 2/ 10000 , that of yours remaining 14/ 10000 .
I would by no means from hence conclude , that any preference is to be given to the former , but would say , that in most practical observations , in these countries at least , it is indifferent which method is used .
These same comparisons also afford us another piece of information , viz. that under similar conditions the density of the atmosphere is the same , whether under the parallel of 46 or 56 degrees of latitude .
Till , therefore , more accurate observations than those of Mr. BOUGUER ( a ) can be obtained in the neighbourhood of the ( a ) Mr. BOUGUER'S observations I hold inadequate in such an inquiry , not only on account of their incorrectness ( for they are related only to the 1/ 4 of a French line ) , but particularly inconclusive , allow them all the precision you please , as they were not synchronous ; insomuch , that we are uncertain whether those observations , which should be corresponding in point of time , were made within six months of each other : and with regard to the temperature of some of the equator , I should be extremely cautious how I admitted a latitudinal equation ; nor do I think the single observation , related in The Voyage towards the North Pole , of sufficient authority itself to establish such a theory upon ( b ) .
them we are still more at a loss , having a range of no less than 38~ to assume it in ( vide Voyage au Perou , p. 29 .
) .
The mean , however , of his five o ' sertions , according to my computation , would bring the zero of the scale to about 40~ of FAHRENHEIT : but till it can be proved , that in this uncertainty of 38~ we have , in fixing upon the mean , got the true temperature to within 8~ ; and also , that during many months the barometer in the same place had never altered a single line : till then , I say , no fair conclusion , in point of theory , can be drawn from these experiments , for with such supposed errors or variations the Peruvian observations will agree exactly with those in this climate .
( b ) It seems extraordinary , that the heights of the quicksilver , observed on the sea-shore with one of Mr. RAMSDEN'S barometers , should differ a quarter of an inch from the height of the same observed the same day , and almost at the same hour , with Mr. NAIRNE'S marine barometer on board a ship ( vide p. 135 and 148 .
of The Voyage towards the North Pole ) .
This difference , therefore , I think remains to be explained , if the experiment is to be made use of in this inquiry ; for this same marine barometer , compared a few days ago at Mr. IBBETSON'S , secretary to the board of longitude , with one of my own , that I used in Savoy , agreed with it to within 0,04 inch .
It may also be remarked , that Lord MULGRAVE'S observation in lat. 79~ 44~ brings the zero to about 64~ ; so that between the lat. 56~ and 79~ ( equal 23~ ) the zero of the scale moves through a space of no less than 32~ ; whereas , between the lat. 46~ and 56~ it is perfectly stationary , at least as to sense , having ~ only one-third of a degree : which great want of proportion , I think , is of itself some argument against the existence of such a latitudinal equation .
Moreover , Mr. BOUGUER'S observations brings the zero of the scale on the same side of 32~ with Lord MULGRAVE'S , viz. to about 40~ , so that , if any deduction is to be drawn from these observations , it is , that the air , both at the equator and at the pole is heavier than in middle latitudes .
which is no very probable conjecture , and , I apprehend , more than is intended to be proved .
I should have asked pardon for the freedom with which I have discussed this inquiry , were I not assured that the acquaintance and friendship of my Lord MULGRAVE , which I have experienced for some years , will lead him to attribute it to its proper motive .
I shall now beg leave to conclude with what I flatter myself will not here appear improper , a new rule for reducing the observations , and which I hope will be found particularly commodious , as it requires no logarithms , nor any other than the following short table , which may be engraven upon the scale of a thermometer , and therefore , always accompanying the instrument , will serve for computing the observations upon the spot , ( if the height should not exceed 4000 or 5000 feet ) which , I apprehend , will frequently be found very satisfactory .
The adjoined table gives the value of 1/ 10th of an inch on the barometer in feet in the atmosphere , when the quicksilver stands at 30 inches , for every five degrees of temperature from 32~ to 80~ ; and for any other height of the barometer it will be in the inverse ratio of that height to 30 inches .
Thus , let A be the mean height of the two barometers in inches ; ~ the difference of the two barometers in 10ths of an inch ; ~ the number taken out of the adjoined table ; x the height in feet ; we have then the following expression , 30 ~~/ A = x , the height required .
I have the honour to be , &amp;c. There .
o Feet .
32 85.86 35 87.49 40 88 54 45 89.60 50 90.66 55 91.72 60 92.77 65 93.82 70 94.88 75 95 93 80 96 99 The value of one-tenth of an inch of quicksilver on the barometer , expressed in feet in the atmosphere when the barometer stands at 30 inches , according to the different

