XVIII .
Observations on the Limits of Algebraical Equations ; and a general Demonstration of Des Cartes 's Rule for finding their Number of affirmative and negative Roots .
By the Rev. Isaac Milner , M. A. Fellow of Queen 's College , Cambridge .
Communicated by Anthony Shepherd , D. D. F. R. S. and Plumian Professor at Cambridge .
Read February 26 , 1777 .
~ 1 .
THE investigations of the limits of equations is considered as one of the most important problems in algebra .
The knowledge of them not only enables us to demonstrate many useful theorems in that science , but is also of material service in discovering the roots themselves .
Mr. MACLAURIN has treated this subject very fully , both in his Algebra and in the Philosophical Transactions .
The substance of what he has delivered may be briefly expressed in the two following propositions .
1st .
That any equation xn p xn-1 +q xn-2 &amp;c. =0 being proposed , if you take the fluxion of this equation , and divide it by x , the resulting equation will have all its roots limits of the roots of the given equation .
2dly , If the terms of the proposed equation be multiplied into the terms of any arithmetical series , the resulting equation will also have its roots limits of the roots of the original equation .
~ 2 .
This second proposition , though admitted by all the eminent authors whom I have had an opportunity of consulting , certainly requires some restrictions .
For example , the roots of the quadratic equation x2 2x 3=0 are 3 , &amp;c. -1 ; multiply the terms of this equation into the terms of the arithmetical progression 1 , 2 , 3 , respectively , and the resulting equation is 1x x2 2x 2x 3x3= 0 , the roots of which are 2 ~~ 13 , neither of which are between the roots of the given quadratic .
Again , suppose the roots of the cubic equation x3 px2 + qx r=0 to be a , b , c , and it is possible that the equation l+ 3m x x3 l+ 2m x px2 +l+mx qx lr =0 may have no root between the quantities b and c ; and in general , if the roots of the equation ( A ) xn pxn-1 + qxn-2 , &amp;c. =0 be supposed a , b , c , -d , -e , -f , &amp;c. where a is the greatest root , b the next , and so on in order , the equation ( B ) l+ nm x xn l+n 1 .
mpxn-1 +l+n 2 .
mqxn-2 , &amp;c. =0 will not necessarily have any of its roots between the roots c and d of the original equation .
~ 3 .
It will not be difficult to see the reason of this , if we examine the demonstration , which is usually given us of this second proposition .
The roots of the biquadratic equation x4 A x3 +B x2 cx+D=0 are supposed to be a , b , c , d , and the results which arise by successively substituting them for x in 4x3 3A x2 +2BxC are supposed to be R , + S , T , + Z. From which MACLAURIN concludes , that when abed are substituted for x in the quantity l+ 4m x x4 l+ 3m xA x3 +l+2mB x2 l+mCx+ lD , the quantities that result will become -m R x , +m S x , -mTx , +m Z x , where , says he , the signs being alternately negative and positive , it follows , that a , b , c , d , must be limits of the equation l+ 4m x x4 lx 3m A x3 + &amp;c. = 0 .
Here it is taken for granted , that the quantities -m R x , +m S x , -m T x , +m Z x , are alternately negative and positive , which is not true , unless the roots a , b , c , d , be either all positive or all negative .
For suppose a , b , c , to be positive ( a ) quantities , and da ( a ) Philosophical Transactions , vol. XXXVI .
Mr. MACLAURIN , who is here very diffuse upon this subject , never mentions any exception of this sort .
In his Algebra , art .
44 .
part 2 .
he says , he shall only treat of such equations as have their roots positive ; but it may be observed , that his reasoning from art .
45 .
to 50 .
holds in all equations , the roots of which are real .
The theorem in p. 182 .
of that treatise is not general , though applied in the eleventh chapter to the demonstration of NEWTON'S rule for finding impossible roots in all equations .
negative one ; and then the four results will be -m R a , +m S b , -m T c , -m Z d. ~ 4 .
In general , the roots of the equation nxn-1 n 1 .
pxn-2 +n 2 .
qxn-3 , are always between the roots of the equation ( A ) because the roots of this last equation substituted successively for x in nxn-1 n 1 .
pxn-2 + &amp;c. always give the resulting quantities alternately negative and positive ; but when the least of the ~ roots , and the greatest of the negative roots of the equation ( A ) are substituted in ( B ) the quantities that result will necessarily have the same sign , and therefore it is possible , that no root of the equation ( B ) may lie between the least of the affirmative and the greatest of the negative roots of the equation ( A ) .
~ 5 .
It is possible even , that the equation ( B ) may have imaginary roots , at the same time that all the roots of the equation A are real , which is contrary to what all algebraical writers have thought .
For instance , the roots of the equation x2 +6x7=0 are 7 and 1 , and if the terms of this equation be multiplied by 1 , -1 , 3 ( an arithmetical series where the common difference of the terms is equal to 2 ) the resulting equation will be x2 6x + 21 , the roots of which are evidently impossible .
~ 6 .
However , the equation(B ) can never have more than two imaginary roots , when the roots of the equation ( A ) are real .
For suppose these last roots to be +a , +b , +c , +d , -e , -f , &amp;c. in their order from the greatest to the least , and since the results which arise from the successive substitution of these quantities are always alternately negative and positive , that case only excepted where d and -e are substituted , it is manifest , that we shall always have n-2 of the roots of the equation ( B ) which will be limits of the equation ( A ) .
~ 7 .
It is remarkable , that whenever the equation A has all its terms complete , its roots real , and some of them positive , and others negative , if l+nm be assumed equal to 0 , the equation B will always have one of its roots either greater than the greatest affirmative root , or less than the least negative root of the equation ( A ) .
Thus , in the quadratic x2 + 6x 7= 0 , assume any arithmetical progression 0 , 1 , 2 , the first term of which is equal to nothing , and the equation B in this case is 6x-14=0 and x=14/ 6 , which is greater than 1 , the greatest affirmative root of the assumed equation .
~ 8 .
The roots of the equation ( A ) being still supposed a , b , c , d , -e , -f , &amp;c. let m be taken equal to unity , and l any positive integer whatsoever , and in that case , two of the roots of the equation B will lie between the roots d and -e , and one of them will be positive , and the other negative .
For example , the quadratic equation x2+6x-7=0 has its roots 1 and -7 ; and if the terms of this equation be multiplied into 3 , 2 , 1 ; 4 , 3 , 2 ; or 5 , 4 , 3 , successively , the resulting quadratic in every case will have its two roots between the roots of the given equation , and one of them will be positive , and the other negative .
~ 9 .
The equation B , which in the last article was deduced from the equation A by taking m equal to 1 , and l any positive integer , may itself be treated in the same way , and the resulting equation will , a fortiori , have two of its roots between the roots d and -e of the original equation , and one of them will be positive , and the other negative .
~ 10 .
Let x2-px+q=0 represent any quadratic equation , the real roots of which are ~ and ~ ; suppose x=1/ y , and we shall have 1-py+qy2=0 , the roots of which equation are 1/ ~ , 1/ ~ .
Let the root of the equation 2 qy-p=0 be equal to 1/ A , and 1/ A will always lie between the quantities 1/ ~ , 1/ ~ , and therefore one would think at first sight that the quantity A must always lie between ~ and ~ .
But this would be contrary to what is proved in art .
7 .
In the present case A can never lie between ~ and ~ , unless these two quantities have the same sign , and it is obvious , that the same reasoning holds in equations of higher dimensions .
These observations , as far as I know , are entirely new .
The fundamental proposition ( ~ 4 .
) was , in the year 1775 , communicated to Dr. WARING , Lucasian professor of mathematics in this university , and by him inserted among the additions to his Meditationes Algebraicae(b ) .
~ 11 .
M. EULER , at the conclusion of his 13th chap .
Calcul .
Different .
has given a demonstration of DES CARTES'S rule for finding the number of affirmative and of negative roots in any equation , the roots of which are real .
From what I have already said , his reasonings will appear inconclusive , though I freely own , that what he has done suggested the following different method .
Suppose ( D ) L+mx+nx2+Px3 ... +xn=0 , and the roots of the equation ( E ) m+2nx ... ... +nxn-1=0 will be limits of the roots of the equation ( D ) ; and therefore there must be at least as many positive roots in the equation ( D ) as there are in the equation ( E ) .
The same may be said of the negative roots : for since every root of the equation ( E ) lies between the different roots of the equation ( D ) , it is impossible that the number of roots should be less in either case .
Suppose L and Mx to be both positive , and since the last term in ( c ) See the end of Proprietates Curv .
any equation is always the product of all the roots with their signs changed , the number of positive roots in each of the equations ( D ) and ( E ) must be even : therefore , the number of positive roots in ( D ) cannot exceed the number of those in ( E ) by unity ; but there is in ( D ) one root more than in ( E ) , and consequently it must be negative .
If both the terms L and mx are negative , because then the number of positive roots in ( E ) and ( D ) are even , it follows in the same way , that there is one negative root more in ( D ) than there is in ( E ) .
And lastly , if the terms L and mx have different signs , for the same reasons there must be one positive root more in the equation ( D ) than there is in ( E ) .
DES CARTES ' rule is , that there are as many positive roots in any equation as there are changes in the signs of the terms from + to - , or from to + , and that the remaining roots are negative .
From what has been demonstrated it appears , that if this rule be true in the equation ( E ) , it must hold also in the next equation ( D ) of superior dimensions ; and as we know that it is true in simple and quadratic equations , it must therefore be true in cubics , in biquadratics , and so on .
This is one of the best rules we have in algebra .
Dr. SAUNDERSON ( c ) saw such an infinity of cases in equa(c ) Vol. II .
p. 683 .
Algebra .
tions of high dimensions , that he scarcely hoped for a general proof .
MACLAURIN'S(d ) method is plainly impracticable when the roots are numerous , and therefore this concise demonstration will perhaps be acceptable to mathematicians .
( d ) Page 145 .
Algebra .

