XVI .
On the Arithmetic of Impossible Quantities .
By the Rev. John Playfair , A. M. Communicated by the Rev. Nevil Maskelyne , D. D. F. R. S. and Astronomer Royal .
THE paradoxes which have been introduced into algebra , and remain unknown in geometry , point out a very remarkable difference in the nature of those sciences .
The propositions of geometry have never given rise to controversy , nor needed the support of metaphysical discussion .
In algebra , on the other hand , the doctrine of negative quantities and its consequences have often perplexed the analyst , and involved him in the most intricate disputations .
The cause of this diversity , in sciences which have the same object , must no doubt be sought for in the different modes which they employ to express our ideas .
In geometry every magnitude is represented by one of the same kind ; lines are represented by a line , and angles by an angle .
The genus is always signified by the individual , and a general idea by one of the particulars which fall under it .
By this means all contradiction is avoided , and 2 the Read Feb. 26 , the geometer is never permitted to reason about the relations of things which do not exist , or cannot be exhibited .
In algebra again every magnitude being denoted by an artificial symbol , to which it has no resemblance , is liable , on some occasions , to be neglected , while the symbol may become the sole object of attention .
It is not perhaps observed where the cennection between them ceases to exist , and the analyst continues to reason about the characters after nothing is left which they can possibly express : if then , in the end , the conclusions which hold only of the characters be transferred to the quantities themselves , obscurity and paradox must of necessity ensue .
The truth of these observations will be rendered evident by considering the nature of imaginary expressions , and the different uses to which they have been applied .
2 .
Those expressions , as is well known , owe their origin to a contradiction taking place in that combination of ideas which they were intended to denote .
Thus , if it be required to divide the given line AB ( fig. 1 .
) =a in c , so that ACXCB may be equal to a given space b2 , and if AC=x , then x=1/ 2a ~ ~1/ 4a2-b2 ; which value of x is imaginary when b2 is greater than 1/ 4a2 ; now to suppose that b2 is greater than 1/ 4a2 , is to suppose that the rectangle AC X CB is greater than the square of half the line AB , which is impossible .
The same holds wherever expressions of this kind occur .
Thus , when it is asserted that unity has the three cube roots 1 , 1+~ 3/ 2 , 1 -~ -3/ 2 , no more is meant than that when the general equation x3-ax2 + bx-r=o is , by a change in the data , reduced to the particular state x3-1=o , x is then equal to unity only , and admits not of any other value , as it does in more general forms of the equation .
The natural office of imaginary expressions is , therefore , to point out when the conditions , from which a general formula is derived , become inconsistent with each other ; and they correspond in the algebraic calculus to that part of the geometrical analysis , which is usually styled the determination of problems .
3 .
This , however , is not the only use to which imaginary expressions have been applied .
When combined according to certain rules , they have been put to denote real quantities , and though they are in fact no more than marks of impossibility , they have been made the subjects of arithmetical operations ; their ratios , their products , and their sums , have been computed , and , what may seem strange , just conclusions have in that way been deduced .
Nevertheless , the name of reasoning cannot be given to a process into which no idea is introduced .
Accordingly geometry , which has its modes of reasoning that correspond to every other part of the algebraic calculus , has nothing similar to the method we are now considering ; for the arithmetic of mere characters can have no place in a science which is immediately conversant with ideas .
But though geometry rejects this method of investigation , it admits , on many occasions , the conclusions derived from it , and has confirmed them by the most rigorous demonstration .
Here then is a paradox which remains to be explained .
If the operations of this imaginary arithmetic are unintelligible , why are they not also useless ?
Is investigation an art so mechanical , that it may be conducted by certain manual operations ?
or is truth so easily discovered , that intelligence is not necessary to give success to our researches ?
These are difficulties which it is of some importance to resolve , and on which much attention has not hitherto been bestowed .
Two celebrated mathematicians , BERNOULLI and MACLAURIN , have indeed touched on this subject ; but being more intent on applying their calculus , than on explaining the grounds of it , they have only suggested a solution of the difficulty , and one too by no means satisfactory .
They allege ( a ) , that when imaginary expressions are put to ( a ) Op. J. BERN .
tom .
l. No 70 .
MACLAUR .
Flux .
art .
699-763 .
denote real quantities , the imaginary characters involved in the different terms of such expressions do then compensate or destroy each other .
But beside that , the manner in which this compensation is made , in expressions ever so little complicated , is extremely obscure , if it be considered that an imaginary character is no more than a mark of impossibility , such a compensation becomes altogether unintelligible : for how can we conceive one impossibility removing or destroying another ?
Is not this to bring impossibility under the predicament of quantity , and to make it a subject of arithmetical computation ?
And are we not thus brought back to the very difficulty to be removed ?
Their explanation cannot of consequence be admitted ; but , on attempting another , it behoves us to observe , that a more extensive application of this method , than had been made in their time , has now greatly facilitated the inquiry .
We begin then with considering the manner in which the imaginary expressions , supposed to denote real quantities , are derived ; and the cases in which they prove useful for the purposes of investigation .
4 .
Let a be an arch of a circle of which the radius is unity , and let c be the number which has unity for its hyperbolic logarithm , then the sine of the arch a , or sin. a=ca~-1-c-a~-1/ 2~-1 ; and cos. a=ca~-1+c-a~-1/ 2 .
These exponential and imaginary values of the sine and cosine are already well known to geometers ; and the investigation of them , according to the received arithmetic of impossible quantities , may be as follows .
Let sin. a=z , then a=z/ ~1-z .
To bring this fluxion under such a form that its fluent may be found by logarithms , both numerator and denominator are to be multiplied by ~ 1 ; then a=~ 1X z/ ~z2-1 , and ( by form .
6 .
HARM .
Men .
) a=~ 1X log.z+~z2-1/ ~-1 .
Hence a/ ~-1 , or 1X a/ ~ 1= log.z+~z2-1/ ~-1 , and because 1 is the log .
of c , a/ c~-1=z+~z2-1/ ~-1 ; wherefore , if both parts of the fractional index of c be multiplied by ~ 1 , c-a~-1=z+~z2-1/ ~-1 .
Again , if the arch a be considered as negative , its sine becomes also negative , and therefore -a=~ 1X log .
-z+~z2-1/ ~-1 , or , -a~ 1=-log .
-z+~z2-1/ ~-1 , and a~ -1= log.-z+~z2-1/ ~-1 ; whence also , ca~-1=-z+~z2-1/ ~-1 .
If from this equation the former be taken away , there remains -2z/ ~-1=ca~-1-c-a~-1 , whence dividing by 2~ 1 we have z= sin. a=ca~-1-c-a~-1/ 2~-1 .
By adding together the equations a value of the cosine may be sound in the same imaginary terms which were assigned above .
Now by means of these expressions many theorems may be demonstrated ; it may , for example , be shown , that if a and b are any two arches of a circle , of which the radius is unity , then sin. aXcos .
b=sin .
a+ b/ 2 + sin. a-b/ 2 .
For sin. a= ca~-1-c-a~-1/ 2~-1 , and cos. b=cb~-1 + c-b~-1/ 2 , therefore , sin.a X cos. b= ca+bX~-1 c-a-bX~-1 + ca-bX~-1 cb-aX~-1/ 4~-1 = sin. a+b/ 2 + sin. a-b/ 2 .
5 .
Now it may be observed , that the imaginary value which has been found for sin. a was obtained by bringing a fluxion , properly belonging to the circle , under the form of one belonging to the hyperbola .
It may , therefore , be worth while to inquire , whether a similar expression may not be derived from the hyperbola itself .
Let BAD be a rectangular hyperbola ( fig. 2 .
) of which the center is C , and the semi-tranverse axis AC = 1 ; let B be any point in the hyperbola , join BC , and let BE be an ordinate to the transverse axis .
Then , if the sector ACB=1/ 2a , and BE=z , it is known that a=z/ ~1+z2 ; whence a=log .
z+~1 + z2 , and ca =z+ ~1 + z2 .
But if the sector be taken on the other side of the transverse axis , a and z become negative , and c-a= z+ ~1 + z2 .
Hence z= ca c-a/ 2 ; in like manner the absciss belonging to ACB , that is CE = ca + c-a/ 2 .
These values of the ordinates and abscissae differ in nothing from those of the sines and cosines already found , except in being free from impossible quantities ; for it is evident , that the quantity a is related in the same manner both to the circular and hyperbolic sectors .
If now ord. a and abs .
b denote the ordinate and absciss belonging to the sectors 1/ 2a , 1/ 2b respectively , ord. ax abs .
b=ca-c-a/ 2 x cb+c-b/ 2 = ca+b c-a-b + ca-b-cb-a/ 4 = ord. a+b/ 2 + ord. a-b/ 2 .
6 .
The conclusions in both the foregoing cases are perfectly coincident , and the methods by which they have been obtained are similar ; though with this difference between them , that in the first all the steps are unintelligible , but in the last significant .
If then , notwithstanding a difference which might be expected so materially to affect their conclusions , they have been equally successful in the discovery of truth , it can be ascribed only to the analogy which takes place between the subjects of investigation ; an analogy so close , that every property belonging to the one may , with certain restrictions , be transferred to the other .
Accordingly , every imaginary expression , which has been found to belong to the circle in the preceding calculation , is by the substitution of real for impossible quantities , or of ~1 for ~ -1 , converted into a proposition which holds of the hyperbola .
The operations , therefore , performed with the imaginary characters , though destitute of meaning themselves , are yet notes of reference to others which are significant .
They point out indirectly a method of demonstrating a certain property of the hyperbola , and then leave us to conclude from analogy that the same property belongs also to the circle .
All that we are assured of by the imaginary investigation is , that its conclusion may , with all the strictness of mathematical reasoning , be proved of the hyperbola ; but if from thence we would transfer that conclusion to the circle , it must be in consequence of the principle which has been just now mentioned .
The investigation , therefore , resolves itself ultimately into an argument from analogy ; and , after the strictest examination , will be found without any other claim to the evidence of demonstration .
Had the foregoing proposition been proved of the hyperbola only , and afterwards concluded to hold of the circle , merely from the affinity of the curves , its certainty would have been precisely the same as when a proof is made out by the intervention of imaginary symbols .
8 .
Though it might readily be concluded , that the same principle on which the foregoing investigation has been found to proceed , extends itself to all those in which imaginary expressions are put to denote real quantities , it may yet be proper to make trial of its application in some other instances .
Let AB , AC , AD , AE ( fig. 3 .
) be any arches of a circle in arithmetical progression , and let m be their number ; it is required to find the sum of the sines BC , CH , &amp;c. of those arches .
Let the radius AF=1 , AB=a , and the common difference of the arches , or BC=x : the sum of the series sin. a+sin .
a+x + sin. a+ 2x + ... . .
( m ) is to be found .
Now , because sin. a= ca~-1-c-a~-1/ 2~-1 , and sin. a+x= ca+xx~-1-c-a-xx~-1/ 2~-1 , &amp;c. ; the series sin. a+ sin. a+x+ sin. a+ 2x ... . .
( m ) = ca~-1/ 2~-1 x 1+ cx~-1 + c2x~-1 ... . .
( m ) ca~-1/ 2~-1 x 1+ c-x~-1 + c-2x~-1 ... . .
( m ) .
But these series are both geometrical progressions , and the sum of the first is ca~-1/ 2~-1 x 1-cmx~-1/ 1-cx~-1 ; and of the second , c-a~-1/ 2~-1 x 1-c-mx~-1/ 1-c-x~-1 .
The sum of the proposed series therefore = ca~-1/ 2~-1 x 1-cmx~-1/ 1-cx~-1 c-a~-1/ 2~-1 x 1-c-mx~-1/ 1-c-x~-1 = 1/ 2~-1 x ca~-1-ca+mxx~-1-ca-xx~-1+ca+mx-xx~-1/ 1-cx~-1-c-x~-1+1 + 1/ 2~-1 x -c-a~-1 + c-a-mxx~-1 + c-a+xx~-1-c-a-mx+xx~-1/ 1-cx~-1-c-x~-1+1 ; in which expression , if the sines be substituted for their imaginary values , we have sin. c sin. a+ mx sin. ax+ sin. a+ mx x/ 2 x1 cos. x sin. a+ sin. a+x+sin .
a+ 2x ... . .
( m ) .
Q. E. I. When AB=BC , or a=x , the proposed series becomes sin. x+ sin. 2x + sin. 3x ... . .
( m ) , and its value = sin x sin. m+1xx+ sin. mx/ 2 x1 col .
x. In like manner it will be found , that the sum of the cosines of the same arches , or cos. a+cos .
a+x+cos.a+2x + ... . .
( m)=cos .
a cos. a+ mx cos. ax+ cos. a+ mx x/ 2 x1 cos. x : and when a=x , cos. x+ cos. 2x + cos. 3x ... . .
( m ) = cos. mx cos. m+1x x/ 2 x1 cos. x 1/ 2 .
9 .
To solve the same problem , in the case of the hyperbola , we must follow the steps which have been traced out by these imaginary operations .
Let ABE be an equilateral hyperbola ( fig. 4 .
) of which the center is F , and the transverse axis AF=1 ; let ABF , ACF , ADF , &amp;c. be any sectors in arithmetical progression , and let m be their number ; it is required to find the sum of all the ordinates BG , CH , DK , &amp;c. belonging those sectors .
Let the sector AFB=1/ 2a , and the sector BFC , which is the common difference of the sectors , =1/ 2x : then BG , or ord. a= ca c-a/ 2 , and CH , or ord. a+ x= ca+x c-a-x/ 2 , by art .
5 .
Therefore the series of ordinates , that is , BG + CH + DK + ... . .
( m ) = ca/ 2 x1+ cx + c2x + ... . .
( m ) c-a/ 2 x1+ c-x + c-2x + ... . .
( m ) = ca/ 2 x1 cmx/ 1 cx c-a/ 2 x 1-c-mx/ 1 c-x = 1/ 2 x ca-ca+mx-ca-x+ca+mx-x-c-a + c-a-mx+c-a-x-c-a-mx+x/ 1 -cx-c-x+1= ord. a ord. a+ mx ord. ax+ ord. a+ mx x/ 2 x1 abs .
x. When a= x , ord. x+ ord. 2x + ord. 3x + ... . .
( m ) = ord. x ord. m+1xx+ ord. mx/ 2 x1 abs .
x. In like manner it is proved , that the sum of the abscissae , that is , FG + FH + FK + ... . .
( m ) = abs a-abs a+mx-abs a-x+abs .
a+mx-x/ 2 x1 abs .
x ; and when a=x , this expression becomes abs .
mx abs .
m+1x x/ 2 x1 abs .
x 1/ 2 .
10 .
The coincidence of the theorems deduced in the two last articles is obvious at first sight , and if the methods by which they have been obtained be compared , it will appear , that the imaginary operations in the one case were of no use but as they adumbrated the real demonstration , which took place in the other .
This will be rendered more evident by considering that the resolution of the series of hyperbolic ordinates , into two others 330 Mr. PLAYFAIR on the of continual proportionals , can be exhibited geometrically .
For , from the points A , B , C , and D , let AM , BN , CO , DP , be drawn at right angles to the assymptote FP ; let GB produced meet FP in Q , and let BR be perpendicular to the conjugate axis FR .
Then , because the triangles FRS , FMA , are equiangular , AF : FM : : FS : FR ; hence FR= FM/ FA x FS = FM/ FA x FN NB .
For the same reason CH = FM/ FA x FO OC , and DK=FM/ FAxFP-PD .
Therefore , BG+CH+DK =FM/ FAxFN + FO + FP FM/ FA x BN + CO + DP ; now , FN , FO , FP , are continual proportionals , and so also are BN , FO , FP , because the sectors FBC , FCD , are equal .
But in the circle no such resolution of the proposed series of sines can take place , that series being subject to alternate increase and diminution ; on which account it is , that imaginary characters enter into the exponential value of the sine .
Those characters are therefore so far from compensating each other in the present case , as they ought to do , on the supposition of BERNOULLI and MACLAURIN , that they manifestly serve as marks of impossibility .
There remains , of consequence , the affinity between circular arches and hyperbolic areas , or between the measures of angles and of ratios , as the only principle on which the imaginary investigation can proceed .
It need scarcely be observed , that the exponential value of the hyperbolic ordinate may be deduced from what has been proved in this article .
11 .
But as the arithmetic of impossible quantities is no where of greater use than in the investigation of fluents , it is of consequence to inquire , whether the preceding theory extends also to that application of it .
Let it then be required to find the fluent of the equation y/ z2 ~ a2y=Q , where Q denotes any function whatever of x. For this purpose , the following lemma is premised : let x be any arch , and p any flowing quantity ; then , if the sign ~ , be taken to denote the fluent of the quantity to which it is prefixed , sin. x ~p cos. x-cos .
x ~p sin. x= cx~-1/ 2~-1 ~ pc-x~-1 c-x~-1/ 2~ 1~ pcx~-1 ; or if 1/ 2x be a hyperbolic sector , ord. x ~p abs .
x abs .
x ~p ord. x= cx/ 2 ~pc-x c-x/ 2 ~pcx .
Because sin. x ~p cos.x=cx~-1-c-x~-1/ 2~-1 ~p x cx~-1+c-x~-1/ 2 , by separating the terms we have sin. x ~p cos. x= cx~-1/ 4~-1 ~p cx~-1 + cx~-1/ 4~-1 ~pc-x~-1 c-x~-1/ 4~-1 ~pcx~ 1 c-x~-1/ 4~-1 ~ pc-x~-1 , for the same reason cos. x~p sin. x= cx~-1/ 4~-1 ~ pcx~-1 + cx~-1/ 4~-1 ~ pc-x~-1 c-x~-1/ 4~-1 ~pcx~-1 + c-x~-1/ 4~-1 ~pc-x~-1 .
Wherefore , by collecting the sum of all the terms , we have sin. x~p cos.x-cos.x ~p sin. x= cx~-1/ 2~-1 ~pc-x ~1 c-x~-1/ 2~-1 ~pcx~-1 .
The demonstration in the case of the hyperbola is free from imaginary expressions ; but , in other respects , is exactly similar to that which has now been given in the case of the circle .
12 .
Let the co-efficient of y in the proposed equation be first supposed negative , that is , let y/ x2 a2y = Q , and if we multiply by cnxx , n being a constant but indeterminate quantity , it becomes cnxy/ x a2cnxyx = cnx Qx .
Let cnx x Ay/ x By be assumed for the fluent , A and B being indeterminate , and let its fluxion be taken , then , ACnxy/ x +n ACnxy n BCnxyx = cnx Qx .
BCnxy .
Hence , by comparing the terms , we get A=1 , nA B=o , n B=a2 ; therefore , n= ~a , and B= ~a : for n and B let the value +a be substituted , and for A , its value , unity ; and the assumed equation becomes y/ x ay x cax= ~ caxQx , or y/ x ay=c-ax ~ caxQx .
Let this equation be multiplied by cmxx , m being indeterminate as before , and cmxy-acmxyx=cm-a xxx ~caxQx .
The fluent of the first member of this equation is evidently of the form Dcmxy , the fluxion of which , viz. Dcmxy+Dmcmxyx being compared with the former gives D=1 , and m=-a ; wherefore , c-ax y= ~c-2axx ~caxQx , or y=cax x ~c-2axx ~caxQx .
Let cxxQx=z , and c-2axx=v ; then ~c-2axx ~caxQx = ~zv=zv-~vz ; but v=1/ 2a c-2ax/ 2a , supposing that v and x vanish at the same time ; therefore vz ~vz= 1/ 2a~caxQx-c-2ax/ 2a ~caxQx 1/ 2a ~caxQx+1/ 2a ~c-axQx = 1/ 2a ~c-ax Qx c-2ax/ 2a ~caxQx .
Hence y= cax/ 2a ~c-axQx c-ax/ 2a ~caxQx .
This value of y is sufficient for the construction of the fluent , because the quantities ~c-axQx , and ~caxQx depend on the quadrature of the hyperbola ; but if we would introduce into it the ordinates and abscisses of that curve , we need only have recourse to the foregoing lemma , from which it appears , that y= 1/ a ord. ax ~Qx abs .
ax 1/ a abs .
ax ~Qx ord. ax .
13 .
Let the co-efficient of y be now supposed affirmative , or let y/ x~+a2y=Q .
In this case imaginary expressions are introduced into the fluent , and the construction by the hyperbola becomes impossible .
For we have then , n=~a~-1 , from which , by proceeding as above , we get y= cax-~-1/ 2a~-1 ~c-ax~-1Qx-c-ax/ 2a~-1 ~cax~-1 Qx ; hence also , by the lemma , y= sin. ax ~Qx cos. ax cos. ax ~Qx sin. ax .
Here the quantities , ~ Qx cos. ax , and ~ Qx sin. ax , are assignable by the quadrature of the circle , in the same manner as ~ Qx abs .
ax , and ~ Qx ord. ax , by the quadrature of the hyperbola ; but the method of investigating them , though an illustration of the principles which we have laid down , is too well known to need to be inserted here .
In like manner might the fluents of innumerable fluxionary equations , comprehended under the general form Q=y+ ay/ x + by/ x2 + die / x3 + &amp;c. be deduced , and all of them would tend to prove that the arithmetic of impossible quantities is no more than a method of tracing the analogy between the measures of ratios and of angles .
M. M. EULER(b ) and D'ALEMBERT(c ) were the first to integrate such equations as the preceding , and the method employed here differs from theirs only by being better adapted to illustrate the principle which is common to them all .
( b ) Nov. Com. Petrop .
tom .
III .
( d ) Theory de la Lune .
14 .
The forms in the Harmonia Mensurarum might also be brought to confirm this theory ; but , without accumulating instances any farther , it may be sufficient to remark two consequences that follow from it : 1 .
That the only cases in which imaginary expressions may be put to denote real quantities , are those in which the measures of ratios or of angles are concerned .
2 .
That the property of either of those measures , so investigated , might have been inferred from analogy alone .
Now both these conclusions are agreeable to experience .
It does not appear , that any instance has yet occurred where imaginary characters serve to express real quantities , if circular arches or hyperbolic areas are not the subjects of investigation ; and if the conclusion obtained may not be transferred from the one to the other , by a mere substitution of corresponding magnitudes ; that is , of sines for ordinates , cosines for abscisses , and circular arches for the doubles of hyperbolic sectors .
The affinity between the circle and hyperbola is not however so close , but that it is subject to certain limitations , from considering which , the truth of what is here asserted will be rendered more evident .
1 .
Any proposition demonstrated of hyperbolic sectors may be transferred to circular arches by substitution alone , without any change in the signs , when only abscissae and their products enter into the enunciation , and conversely .
Thus abs .
ax abs .
b=abs a+b/ 2+abs a-b/ 2 .
; and cos. ax cos. b=cos , a+b/ 2 + cos. a-b/ 2 .
The same holds when the simple power of the ordinate is combined with any power whatever of the absciss : so in the theorems of art .
5 .
and 4 .
ord. ax abs .
b=ord .
a+b/ 2 + ord. a-b/ 2 ; and sin. ax cos. b=sin .
a+b/ 2 + sin. a-b/ 2 .
2 .
When an expression containing any property of hyperbolic sectors , involves in it the rectangle of two ordinates , the value of that rectangle must have a contrary sign , when a transition is made to the circle .
Thus ord. ax ord. b= abs .
a+b/ 2 abs .
a-b/ 2 ; but sin. ax sin. b= cos. a+b/ 2 + cos. a-b/ 2 .
The difference which according to this rule is found between the powers of ordinates and of sines may be seen in the following examples .
If 1/ 2x denote any hyperbolic sector , then , by involving cx c-x/ 2 , and again substituting for the exponential quantities as in art .
5 .
we have , ord. x2 = abs .
2x-1/ 2 ; ord. x3 = ord. 3x-3 ord.x/ 4 ; ord. z4 = abs .
4x-4 abs .
2 x+3/ 8 ; ord. x5 = ord. 5x-5 ord. 3x+10 ord. x/ 16 ; and universally , if n be any number ; a the co-efficient of the second term of a binomial raised to the power n , b the coefficient of the third , &amp;c. and p the greatest co-efficient : when n is an even number , ord. xn = abs .
nx-a abs .
n-2 X x+b abs .
n-4 X x ... ... ~p/ 2n-1 ~ p/ 2n ; but when n is an odd number , ord. xn = ord. nx-a ord. n-2 X x+b ord. n-4 X x ... ... .
~p ord. x/ 2n-1 .
If now x denote an arch of a circle , by substituting and changing the signs as oft as ord. x occurs in any of the preceding expressions , we get sin. x2 = 1-cos .
2 x/ 2 ; sin. x3 =3 sin. x-sin .
3 x/ 4 : sin. x4 = 3-4 cos. 2x+cos .
4x/ 8 ; sin. x5 = 10 sin. x-5 sin. 3x+sin .
5x/ 16 : and universally , if n be any number , p the greatest co-efficient of a binomial raised to the power n , A the co-efficient next less than p , B the co-efficient next less than A , and so on : when n is an even number , sin. xn = 1/ 2p-A cos. 2x+B cos. 4x- &amp;c. / 2n-1 ; but when n is an odd number , sin. xn =p sin. x-A cos. 3x+B cos. 5x- &amp;c. / 2n-1 .
These series differ from the former only in the signs , and the arrangement of the terms ; and when either n , or n 1 , is divisible by 4 , the signs remain the same in both .
16 .
The reason of the foregoing rule for changing the signs 13 , that the rectangle under two ordinates to the hyperbola is always expressed by the difference of two abscissae : and that if from the absciss belonging to a greater sector , be substracted the absciss belonging to a less , the remainder will be affirmative ~ whereas , if from the cosine of a greater arch be substracted the cosine of a less , the remainder will be negative .
Therefore , that the rectangles , expressed by these remainders , may have the same sign , in both cases , the signs of the remainders must be different .
It appears then , that the second rule , as well as the first , is founded on the principle of analogy when taken with the necessary limitations , and it is likewise evident from the instances which have been produced , that those rules lead to the very same conclusions which are obtained from the imaginary values of the sine and cosine .
There are , however , instances in which the analogy between the circular and hyperbolic areas being wholly interrupted , neither the foregoing rules , nor any of the same kind , can be applied ; but this occasions no ambiguity , guity for the construction required in such cases is by its nature restricted to one of the curves only .
Of this kind is the Cotesian theorem , which requires the whole circle to be divided into a given number of equal parts , and therefore cannot be extended to the hyperbola where a similar division is impossible .
Others of a like nature may be derived from the general theorems already investigated ; for the circle , by returning into itself , often reduces them to a simplicity to which there is nothing analogous in the hyperbola .
Many examples of this might be adduced , but the two following may suffice .
1 .
Let ABCDE ( fig. 5 .
) be a regular polygon inscribed in a circle , and let m be the number of its sides ; it is required to find the sum of the lines FA , FB , FC , &amp;c. drawn from any point F in the circumference , to all the angles of the polygon .
By the method which in art .
8 .
was employed to obtain the sum of the sines of a series of arches in arithmetical progression , it will be found , that the sum of the chords of the arches a , a+ x , a+ 2x , ... .
( m ) , that is , ( making FA=a , and AB=x ) the sum of the chords of the arches FA , FB , FC , &amp;c. = cho .
a-cho .
a+mx-cho .
a-x+cho .
a+mx-x/ 2 X 1-cos .
1/ 2x ; but , in the present case , mx is equal to the circumference , and therefore -cho.a+mx = +cho.a ( the chord of an arch greater than the circumference being negative ) ; and , for the same reason , cho .
a+mx-x=-cho .
a-x=+cho .
x-a .
Hence the general expression becomes cho .
a+cho .
x-a/ 1 cos. 1/ 2x = FA + FB + FC + ... .
( m ) .
If therefore GK be drawn from the center , bisecting the chord AB in H , and meeting the circumference in K , the sum of the chords , that is , FA + FB + FC + FD + FE = AF + FB/ FK X GK .
2 .
Let n be an even number , the rest remaining as above , and let it be required to find the sum of the n powers of the chords , that is , the sum of FAn + FBn + FCn ... . .
( m ) .
By reasoning , as in the case of the sines , it will appear that , if p be the greatest co-efficient of a binomial raised to the power n ; A the co-efficient next less than p ; B the co-efficient next less a. and so on , then , cho .
an = p-2 A cos. a+2 B cos. 2a+2 D cos. 3a+ &amp;c. cho .
a+xn = p-2 A cos. a+x+2 B cos. 2Xa+x+2 D cos. 3Xa+x , &amp;c. cho .
a+2xn = p-2 A cos. a+x+2 B cos. 2Xa+2x+2 D cos. 3Xa+2x , &amp;c. &amp; C. Each of these vertical columns is to be continued downward , till the number of terms be equal to m , and therefore the sum of the second is mp .
The sum of the third , or of 2A x cos. a+cos .
a+x+cos .
a+2x ... ... ( m ) , by art .
8 .
is -2 Ax cos. a-cos .
a+mx-cos .
a-x+cos .
a+mx-x/ 2 X 1-col.x = ( because mx=the circumference ) -A x cos. a-cos .
a-cos .
a-x+cos .
a-x/ 1-cos .
x= 0 .
In like manner do the sums of all the subsequent columns vanish ; and therefore , cho .
a+cho .
a+x+cho .
a+2x ... . .
( m)=mp .
But when n is an even number , p=1/ 2n+1/ 1/ 2n-1 x 1/ 2n+2/ 1/ 2n-2 ... ... x n/ 1/ 2n = 1.3.5.7 ... ... n-1/ 1.2.3.4 ... . .
1/ 2n x 21/ 2n .
If therefore the radius be put = r , and the expression made homogeneous , we have FAn + FBn + FC-n ... ... ( m ) =mx 1.3.5.7 ... .
n-1/ 1.2.3.4 ... ... 1/ 2n x 21/ 2n rn .
Q. E. I. This last coincides with the forty-first of the curious and difficult propositions published by Dr. STEWART , under the title of general theorems : it is given there without a demonstration , but appears plainly to have been investigated , in a manner altogether rigorous , by that profound geometer .
It may therefore be regarded as one of the instances , in which the conclusions of this imaginary arithmetic are verified by the geometrical analysis .
17 .
The two foregoing propositions being confined to the circle , and yet having been investigated by the help of imaginary expressions , may , at first sight , seem exceptions to the rule , which we have been endeavouring to establish .
But it needs only to be remarked , that they are particular cases of certain theorems belonging both to the circle and hyperbola , and that it was into the investigation of those theorems , that the imaginary expressions were introduced .
The conclusions therefore from the whole are these : that imaginary expressions are never of use in investigation but when the subject is a property common to the measures both of ratios and of angles ; that they never lead to any consequence which might not be drawn from the affinity between those measures ; and that they are indeed no more than a particular method of tracing that affinity .
The deductions into which they enter are thus reduced to an argument from analogy , but the force of them is not diminished on that account .
The laws to which this analogy is subject ; the cases in which it is perfect , in which it suffers certain alterations , and in which it is wholly interrupted , are capable , as may be concluded from the specimens above , of being precisely ascertained .
Supported on so sure a foundation , the arithmetic of impossible quantities will always remain an useful instrument in the discovery of truth , and may be of service when a more rigid analysis can hardly be applied .
For this reason , many researches concerning it , which in themselves might be deemed absurd , are nevertheless not destitute of utility .
M. BERNOULLI has found , for example , that if r be the radius of a circle , the circumference Fig : 1 .
EB ACB D A Fig : 2 .
Fig : 3 .
CDC BEE Fig : 4 .
AP GHFKLD Q O NC M RB S F AGH KL K A H FB Fig : 5 .
EG C =4 log .
~-1/ ~-1 r ; and the same may be deduced from art .
4 .
Considered as a quadrature of the circle , this imaginary theorem is wholly insignificant , and would deservedly pass for an abuse of calculation ; at the same time we learn from it , that if in any equation the quantity log .
~-1/ ~-1 should occur , it may be made to disappear , by the substitution of a circular arch , and a property , common to both the circle and hyperbola , may be obtained .
The same is to be observed of the rules which have been invented for the transformation and reduction of impossible quantities(e ) : they facilitate the operations of this imaginary arithmetic , and thereby lead to the knowledge of the most beautiful and extensive analogy which the doctrine of quantity has yet exhibited .
( e ) The rules chiefly referred to are those for reducing the impossible roots of an equation to the form A+B~-1 .

