XXXVIII .
Experiments on Ignited Substances .
By Mr. John Whitehurst , in a Letter to James Stuart , Esquire , F. R. S. TO JAMES STUART , ESQ .
SIR , London , Nov. 29 , 1775 .
THE experiments of Mr. BUFFON upon ignited bodies seem to prove , that , when heated to the degree he mentions , they are more ponderous than when cold .
The experiments which I have made on heated metals , suggest a different idea , and contradict the fact he relates ; so that I am induced to believe , that some circumstance , not attended to , has introduced a mistake in the relation this learned philosopher has published as the result of his inquiry .
R. May 23 , 1776 .
His experiment stands thus recorded ( Suppl. Not .
Hist. vol. II .
p. 11 .
) : a mass of iron , after receiving a white heat , weighed 49 lbs. 9 oz. ; when restored again to the temperature of the atmosphere 49 lbs. 7 oz. Hence he concluded , that the igneous particles , contained in the heated iron , increased its absolute weight 2 ounces .
My experiments are as follows : 1st , One pennyweight of gold , made red-hot , became apparently lighter ; but , when restored again to the temperature of the atmosphere , its former weight was perfectly restored .
2d , One pennyweight of iron , heated as above , was also apparently lighter ; but , when it became cool again , its weight was visibly augmented .
It is now several years since I made these experiments ; but I well remember to have repeated them several times , and that the results were always the same .
It may be necessary to remark , that the beam used in these experiments was sensibly affected by the 1/ 2000th part of a grain ; and likewise , that each of the metals was heated upon charcoal , by means of a candle and a blow-pipe , and both were brought nearly to a state of fusion .
It seems needless to observe , that the apparent levity of the gold and of the iron , when hot , was owing to the ascent of the rarefied air above the scale , and to the tendency of that underneath to restore the equilibrium of its pressure .
The increase of weight in the iron might probably arise from its having , in some degree , acquired the property of steel , by means of the flame and charcoal .
I am at a loss to account for the fallacy which seems to have attended M. BUFFON 's experiment ; but it seems probable , that the heat of the mass of iron employed by him , had a greater effect on that arm of the beam from which it hung than on the other , which being less heated , would consequently be less expanded ; and this difference of expansion might produce the error in M. BUFFON 's account of the weight of heated iron .
If these observations afford you any satisfaction , it will give me pleasure .
I am , &amp;c.

