quickly-converging Series ; by which the Proportion of the Diameter of a Circle to its Circumference may easily be computed to a great Number of Places of Figures .
By Charles Hutton , Esq. F. R. S. TO THE REV .
DR. HORSLEY , SEC .
R. S. Royal Mil .
Acad. SIR , Jan. 25 , 1776 .
IN a late examination of the methods of Mr. MACHINE and others , for computing the proportion of the diameter of a circle to its circumference , I discovered the method which is explained in the paper accompanying this letter .
This method you , SIR , will perceive is very general , and discovers many series which are very fit for the abovementioned purpose .
If you think it has sufficient merit to entitle it to the honour of being offered to the Royal Society , I have taken the liberty to enclose it to you , requesting the favour of you to present it accordingly , from , &amp;c. R. May 1 , 1776 .
P. S. In the course of the last year , I attended some very interesting experiments on the effects of the force of fired gun-powder ; as they seem to lead to many important conclusions , I believe I shall , in a short time , have the honour of submitting to your inspection an account of some of them , for the like purpose as the following paper .
THE excellency of this method is primarily owing to the simplicity of the series by which an arc is found from its tangent .
For if t denote the tangent of an arc a , the radius being I , then it is well known , that the arc a will be equal to the infinite series , t/ 1 t3/ 3 + t5/ 5 t7/ 7 + t9/ 9 t11/ 11 + &amp;c. where the form is as simple as can be desired .
And it is evident , that nothing farther is required than to contrive matters so , as that the value of the quantity t in this series may be both a small and a very simple number .
Small , that the series may be made to converge sufficiently fast ; and simple , that the several powers of t may be raised by easy multiplications , or easy divisions .
Since the first discovery of the above series , many have used it , and that after different methods , for determining the length of the circumference to a great number of figures .
Among these were Dr. HALLEY , Mr. ABRAHAM SHARP , Mr. MACHINE , and others , of our own country ; and M. DE LAGNY , M. EULER , &amp;c. abroad .
Dr. HALLEY used the arc of 30~ , or 1/ 12th of the circumference , the tangent of which being=~1/ 3 , by substituting ~1/ 3 in the above series , and multiplying by 6 , the semi circumference is=6 ~1/ 3 x : 1 1/ 3.3 + 1/ 5.32 1/ 7.33 + 1/ 9.34 , &amp;c. which series is , to be sure , very simple ; but its rate of converging is not very great , on which account a great many terms must be used to compute the circumference to many places of figures .
By this very series , however , the industrious Mr. SHARP computed the circumference to 72 places of figures ; Mr. MACHINE extended it to 100 ; and M. DE LAGNEY , still by the same series , continued it to 128 places of figures .
But although this series , from the 12th part of the circumference , does not converge very quickly , it is , perhaps , the best aliquot part of the circumference which can be used for this purpose ; for when smaller arcs , which are exact aliquot parts , are used , their tangents , although smaller , are so much more complex , as to render them , on the whole , more operose in the application ; this will easily appear , by inspecting some instances , that have been given by Mr. GARDINER , in his editions of SHERWIN'S Tables .
One of these methods is from the arc of 18~ , the tangent of which is ~12 ~1/ 5 ; another is from the arc of 22~1/ 2 , the tangent of which is ~ 2-1 ; and a third is from the arc of 15~~ the tangent of which is 2-~ 3 .
All of which are evidently too complex to afford an easy application to the general series .
In order to a still farther improvement of the method by the above general series , Mr. MACHINE , by a very singular and excellent contrivance , has greatly reduced the labour naturally attending it .
His method is explained in Mr. MASERES'S Appendix to his Dissertation on the Use of the Negative Sign in Algebra ; and I have given an analysis of it , or a conjecture concerning the manner in which it is probable Mr. MACHINE discovered it , in my Treatise on Mensuration ; which , I believe , are the only two books in which that method has been explained , as I never had seen it explained by any , till I met with Mr. MASERES'S book abovementioned on the Use of the Negative Sign .
For though the series ' discovered by that method were published by Mr. JONES , in his Synopsis Palmariorum Matheseos , which was printed in the year 1706 , he has given them merely by themselves , without the least hint of the manner in which they were obtained .
The result shows , that the proportion of the diameter to the circumference is equal to that of 1 to quadruple the sum of the two series ' , 4/ 5 x : 1-1/ 3.52+1/ 5.54-1/ 7.56+1/ 9.58 , &amp;c. 1/ 239 x : 1-1/ 3.2392+1/ 5.2394-1/ 7.2396+1/ 9.2398 , &amp;c. The slower of which converges almost thrice as fast as Dr. HALLEY'S raised from the tangent of 30~ .
The latter of these two series converges still a great deal quicker ; but then the large incomposite number 239 , by the reciprocals of the powers of which the series converges , occasions such long , tedious division , as to counter-balance its quickness of convergency ; so that the former series is summed , with rather more ease than the latter , to the same number ber of places of figures .
Mr. JONES , in his Synopsis , mentions other series ' besides this , which he had received from Mr. MACHINE for the same purpose , and drawn from the same principle .
But we may conclude this to be the best of them all , as he did not publish any other besides it .
M. EULER too , in his Introductio in Analysin Infinitorum , by a contrivance something like Mr. MACHIN'S , discovers , that 1/ 2 and 1/ 3 are the tangents of two arcs , the sum of which is just 45~ ; and that , therefore , the diameter is to the circumference as I to quadruple the sum of the two series ' , 1/ 2 x : 1 1/ 3.4 + 1/ 5.42 1/ 7.43 + 1/ 9.44 , &amp;c. 1/ 3 x : 1 1/ 3.9 + 1/ 5.92 1/ 7.9 + 1/ 9.94 , &amp;c. Both which series ' converge much faster than Dr. HALLEY'S , and are yet at the same time made to converge by the powers of numbers producing only short divisions ; that is , divisions performed in one line , or without writing down any thing besides the quotients .
I come now to explain my own method , which , indeed , bears some little resemblance to the methods of MACHINE and EULER ; but then it is more general , and discovers , as particular cases of it , both the series ' of those gentlemen and many others , some of which are fitter for this purpose than theirs are .
This method then consists in finding out such small arcs , as have for tangents some small and simple vulgar fractions ( the radius being denoted by 1 ) , and such also that some multiple of those arcs shall differ from an arc of 45~ , the tangent of which is equal to the radius , by other small arcs , which also shall have tangents denoted by other such small and simple vulgar fractions .
For it is evident , that if such a small arc can be found , some multiple of which has such a proposed difference from an arc of 45~ , then the lengths of these two small arcs will be easily computed from the general series , because of the smallness and simplicity of their tangents ; after which , if the proper multiple of the first arc be increased or diminished by the other arc , the result will be the length of an arc of 45~ , or 1/ 8th of the circumference .
And the manner in which I discover such arcs is thus : Let T , t , denote any two tangents , of which T is the greater , and t the less ; then it is known , that the tangent of the difference of the corresponding arcs is equal toT-t/ 1 + Tt , Hence , if t , the tangent of the smaller arc , be successively denoted by each of the simple fractions 1/ 2 , 1/ 3 , 1/ 4 , 1/ 5 , &amp;c. the general expression for the tangent of the difference between the arcs will become respectively 2T-1/ 2+T , 3T-1/ 3+T , 4T-1/ 4+T , 5T-1/ 5+T , &amp;c. ; so that if T be expounded by any given number , then these expressions will give the tangent of the difference of the arcs in known numbers , according to the values of t , severally assumed respectively .
And if , in the first place , T be equal to 1 , the tangent of 45~ , the foregoing expressions will give the tangent of an arc , which is equal to the difference between that of 45~ and the first arc ; or that , of which the tangent is one of the numbers 1/ 2 , 1/ 3 , 1/ 4 , 1/ 5 , &amp;c. Then if the tangent of this difference , just now found , be taken for T , the same expressions will give the tangent of an arc , which is equal to the difference between the arc of 45~ and the double of the first arc .
Again , if for T we take the tangent of this last found difference , then the foregoing expressions will give the tangent of an arc , equal to the difference between that of 45~ and the triple of the first arc .
And again taking this last found tangent for T , the same theorem will produce the tangent of an arc equal to the difference between that of 45~ and the quadruple of the first arc ; and so on , always taking for T the tangent last found , the same expressions will give the tangent of the difference between the arc of 45~ and the next greater multiple of the first arc ; or that , of which the tangent was at first assumed equal to one of the small numbers 1/ 2 , 1/ 3 , 1/ 4 , 1/ 5 , &amp;c. This operation , being continued till some of the expressions give such a fit , small , and simple fraction as is required , is then at an end , for we have then found two such small tangents as were required , viz. the tangent last found , and the tangent first assumed .
Here follow the several operations adapted to the several values of t. The letters a , b , c , d , &amp;c. denote the several successive tangents .
1 .
Take t= 1/ 2 , then the theorem 2T-1/ 2+T gives a= 1/ 3 b= -1/ 7 Therefore the arc of 45~ , or 1/ 8th of the circumference , is either equal to the sum of the two arcs of which 1/ 2 and 1/ 3 are the tangents , or to the difference between the arc of which the tangent is 1/ 7 , and the double of the arc of which the tangent is 1/ 2 ; that is , putting A=the arc of 45~ .
+1/ 2 x : 1-1/ 3.4+1/ 5.42-1/ 7.43+1/ 9.44- &amp;c. A= +1/ 3 x : 1-1/ 3.9+1/ 5.92-1/ 7.93+1/ 9.94- &amp;c. + 1-1/ 3.4+1/ 5.42-1/ 7.43+1/ 9.44- &amp;c. Or , A= -1/ 7 x : 1-1/ 3.49+1/ 5.492-1/ 7.493+1/ 9.494- &amp;c. And the former of these values of A is the same with that before mentioned as given by M. EULER ; but the latter is much better , as the powers of 1/ 49 converge much faster than those of 1/ 9 .
COROL .
From double the former of these values of A subtracting the latter , the remainder is , +2/ 3x : 1 1/ 3.9 + 1/ 5.92 1/ 7.93 + 1/ 9.94 &amp;c. A= +1/ 7x : 1 1/ 3.49 + 1/ 5.492 1/ 7.493 + 1/ 9.494 &amp;c. which is a much better theorem than either of the former .
2 .
If t be taken =1/ 3 , then the expression 3T-1/ 3 +T gives , a= 1/ 2 b=17 Here the value of a=1/ 2 gives the same expression for the value of A as the first in the foregoing case , and the value of b=1/ 7 gives the value of A the very same as in the corollary to the case above .
3 .
Taking t=1/ 4 , the expression 4T -1/ 4+T gives a= 3/ 5 b= 7/ 23 c= 5/ 99 d= -79/ 401 Here it is evident , that the value of c=5/ 99 is the fittest number afforded by this case ; and from it it appears , that the arc of 45~ is equal to the sum of the arc of which the tangent is 5/ 99 , and the triple of the arc of which the tangent is 1/ 4 .
+ 3/ 4 x : 1 1/ 3.16 + 1/ 5.162 1/ 7.163 + 1/ 9.164 &amp;c. Or that A= +5/ 99 x : 1 52/ 3.992 + 54/ 5.994 56/ 7.996 + 58/ 9.998 &amp;c. Which is the best theorem that we have yet found , because that the number 99 resolves into the two easy factors 9 and 11 .
4 .
Let now t be taken =1/ 5 , and the expression 5T-1/ 5+T will give a= 2/ 3 b= 7/ 17 c= 9/ 46 Where it is evident , that the last number , or the value of d , is the fittest of those produced in this case , and from which it appears , that the arc of 45~ is equal to the difference between the arc of which the tangent is 1/ 239 , and quadruple the arc of which the tangent is 1/ 5 .
Or that +4/ 5 x : 1-1/ 3.52+1/ 5.54-1/ 7.56+1/ 9.58- &amp;c. A= -1/ 239 x : 1-1/ 3.2392+1/ 5.2394-1/ 7.2396+1/ 9.2398- &amp;c. Which is the very theorem that was invented by Mr. MACHINE , as we have before mentioned .
5 .
Take now t=1/ 6 , and the expression 6T-1/ 6+T will give a= 5/ 7 b= 23/ 47 c= 91/ 305 d= 241/ 1921 e= -475/ 11767 Of which numbers none , it is evident , are fit for our purpose .
6 .
Again , take t=1/ 7 , and the expression 7T-1/ 7+T will give a= 3/ 4 b= 17 31 c= 11/ 28 d= 49 205 e= 69/ 742 f= -259/ 5263 Neither are any of these fit numbers for our purpose .
7 .
In like manner take t=1/ 8 , so shall 8T-1/ 8+T give a= 7/ 9 b= 47/ 79 c= 297/ 679 d= 1697/ 5729 e= 7847/ 47529 f= 14047/ 388079 8 .
And if t be taken =1/ 9 , the expression 9T-1/ 9+T will give a= 4/ 5 b= 31/ 49 c= 115/ 236 d= 799/ 2239 e= 2467/ 10475 f= 11809/ 96751 g= 4765/ 441284 9 .
Also , if we take t=1/ 10 , the expression 10T-1/ 10+T will give a= 9/ 11 b= 79/ 119 c= 671/ 1269 d= 5441/ 13361 e= 41049/ 139051 f= 271439/ 1431559 g= 1282831/ 14587029 10 .
Farther , if we take t=1/ 11 , the expression 11T-1/ 11+T will give a= 5/ 6 b= 49/ 71 c= 234/ 415 d= 2159/ 4799 e= 9475/ 27474 f= 76751/ 311689 g= 266286/ 1752665 h= 1176481/ 19545601 11 .
Lastly , if we take t=1/ 12 , the expression 12T-1/ 12+T gives a= 11/ 13 b= 113/ 167 c= 41/ 73 d= 419/ 917 e= 4111/ 11423 f= 37909/ 141187 g= 313721/ 1732153 h= 2032499/ 21099557 i= 3290431/ 255227183 Here Here it is evident , that none of these latter cases afsord any numbers that are fit for this purpose .
And to try any other fractions less than 1/ 12 for the value of t , does not seem likely to answer any good purpose , especially , as the divisors , after 12 , become too large to be managed in the easy way of short division in one line .
By the foregoing means it appears , that we have discovered five different forms of the value of A , or 1/ 4th of the semi-circumference , all of which are very proper for readily computing its length ; viz. three forms in the first case and its corollary , one in the third case , and one in the fourth case .
Of these , the first and last are the same as those invented by EULER and MACHINE respectively , and the other three are quite new , as far as I know .
But another remarkable excellency attending the first three of the before mentioned series is , that they are capable of being changed into others which not only converge still faster , but in which the converging quantity shall be 1/ 10 , or some multiple or sub-multiple of it , and so the powers of it raised with the utmost ease .
The series ' , or theorems , here meant are these three : + 1/ 2 x : 1 1/ 3.4 + 1/ 5.42 1/ 7.43 + 1/ 9.44 , &amp;c. 1st , A= + 1/ 3 x : 1 1/ 3.9 + 1/ 5.92 1/ 7.93 + 1/ 9.94 , &amp;c. +1 1/ 3.4 + 1/ 5.42 1/ 7.43 + 1/ 9.44 , &amp;c. 2dly , A= 1/ 7 x : 1 1/ 3.49 + 1/ 5.492 1/ 7.493 + 1/ 9.494 , &amp;c. + 2/ 3 x : 1 1/ 3 9+ 1/ 5.92 1/ 7 93 + 1/ 9.94 , &amp;c. 3dly , A= + 1/ 7 x : 1 1/ 3.49 + 1/ 5.492 1/ 7.493 + 1/ 9.494 , &amp;c. Now if each of these be transformed , by means of the differential series in cor .
3 .
p. 64 .
of the late Mr. THOMAS SIMPSON'S Mathematical Dissertations , they will become of these very commodious forms , viz. + 4/ 10 x : 1+ 4/ 3.10 + 8~/ 5.10 + 12~/ 7.10 + 16~/ 9.10 , &amp;c. 1st , A= + 3/ 10 x : 1+ 2/ 3.10 + 4~/ 5.10 + 6~/ 7.10 + 8~/ 9.10 , &amp;c. + 4/ 5 x : 1+ 4/ 3.10 + 8~/ 5.10 + 12~/ 7.10 + 16~/ 9.10 , &amp;c. 2dly , A= 7/ 50 x : 1+ 4/ 3.100 + 8~/ 5.100 + 12~/ 7.100 + 16~/ 9.100 , &amp;c. + 6/ 10 x : 1+ 2/ 3.10 + 4~/ 5.10 + 6~/ 7.10 + 8~/ 9.10 , &amp;c. 3dly , A= + 7/ 50 x : 1+ 2/ 3.50 + 4~/ 5.50 + 6~/ 7.50 + 8~/ 9.50 , &amp;c. Where ~ , ~ , ~ , &amp;c. denote always the preceding terms in each series .
Now it is evident , that all these latter series , are much easier than the former ones , to which they respectively correspond ; for , because of the powers of 10 here concerned , we have little more to do than to divide by the series of odd numbers 1 , 3 , 5 , 7 , 9 , &amp;c. Of all these three forms the second is the fittest for computing the required proportion ; because that , of the two series ' of which it consists , the several terms of the one 6 are found from the like terms of the other , by dividing these latter by 10 and its several successive powers 100 , 1000 , &amp;c. ; that is , the terms of the one consist of the same figures as the terms of the other , only removed a certain number of places farther towards the right , in the decuple scale of numbers ; and the number of places , by which they must be removed , is the same as the distance of each term from the first term of the series , viz. in the second term the figures must be moved one place lower , in the third term two , in the fourth term three , &amp;c. so that the latter series will consist of but about half the number of the terms of the former .
Thus , then , this method may be said to effect the business by one series only , in which there is little more to do , than to divide by the several numbers 1 , 3 , 5 , 7 , &amp;c. ; for as to the multiplications by the numbers in the numerators of the terms , after they become large , they are easily performed by barely multiplying by the number two , and subtracting one number from another : for since every numerator is less by two than the double of its denominator , if d denote any denominator ( exclusive always of the powers of 10 ) then the co-efficient of that term is 2d-2/ d , or 2-2/ d , by which the preceding term is to be multiplied ; to do which , therefore , multiply it by two , that is double it , and divide that double by the divisor d , and subtract the quotient from the said double .
By a pretty exact estimate , which I have made , of the proportion of the trouble or time in computing the circumference by this middle form of the value of A , and by Mr. MACHIN'S theorem , I have found , that the computation by his method requires about 1/ 8th or 1/ 10th more time than by mine .
And its advantage over any of the series ' invented by EULER or others , is still much more considerable .

