XXVII .
An Experimental Examination of the Quantity and Proportion of Mechanic Power necessary to be employed in giving different Degrees of Velocity to Heavy Bodies from a State of Rest .
By Mr. John Smeaton , F. R. S. ABOUT the year 1686 Sir ISAAC NEWTON first published his Principia , and , conformably to the language of mathematicians of those times defined , that ` ` the quantity of motion is the measure of the same , arising from the velocity and quantity of matter conjointly .
' ' Very soon after this publication , the truth or propriety of this definition was disputed by certain philosophers , who contended , that the measure of the quantity of motion should be estimated by taking the quantity of matter and the square of the velocity conjointly .
There is nothing more certain , than that from equal impelling powers , acting for equal intervals of time , equal increases of velocity are acquired by given bodies , when unresisted by a medium ; thus gravity causes a body , in obeying its impulse during one second of time , to acquire a velocity which would carry it uniformly forward , without any additional impulse , at the rate of 32 ft. 2 in .
per second ; and if gravity is suffered to act upon it for two seconds , it 3 will R. April 25 , will have , in that time , acquired a velocity that would carry it , at an uniform rate , just double of the former ; that is , at the rate of 64 ft. 4 in .
per second .
Now , if in consequence of this equal increase of velocity , in an equal increase of time , by the continuance of the same impelling power , we define that to be a double quantity of motion , which is generated in a given quantity of matter , by the action of the same impelling power for a double time ; this will be co-incident with Sir ISAAC NEWTON'S definition abovementioned ; whereas , in trying experiments upon the total effects of bodies in motion , it appears , that when a body is put in motion , by whatever cause , the impression it will make upon an uniformly resisting medium , or upon uniformly yielding substances , will be as the mass of matter of the moving body , multiplied by the square of its velocity : the question , therefore , properly is , whether those terms , the quantity of motion , the momenta of bodies in motion , or forces of bodies in motion , which have generally been esteemed synonymous , are with the most propriety of language to be esteemed equal , double , or triple , when they have been generated by an equable impulse , acting for an equal , double , or triple time ; or that it should be measured by the effects being equal , double , or triple , in overcoming resistances before a body in motion can be stopped ?
For , according as those terms are understood in this or that way , it will necessarily follow , that the momenta of equal bodies will be as the velocities , or as the squares of the velocities respectively ; it being certain , that , whichever we take for the proper definition of the term quantity of motion , by paying a proper regard to the collateral circumstances that attend the application of it , the same conclusion , in point of computation , will result .
I should not , therefore , have thought it worth while to trouble the Society upon this subject , had I not found , that not only myself and other practical artists , but also some of the most approved writers , had been liable to fall into errors , in applying these doctrines to practical mechanics , by sometimes forgetting or neglecting the due regard which ought to be had to these collateral circumstances .
Some of these errors are not only very considerable in themselves , but also of great consequence to the public , as they tend greatly to mislead the practical artist in works that occur daily , and which often require very great sums of money in their execution .
I shall mention the following instances .
DESAGULIERS , in his second volume of Experimental Philosophy , treating upon the question concerning the forces of bodies in motion , after taking much pains to show that the dispute , which had then subsisted fifty years , was a dispute about the meaning of words ; and that the same conclusion will be brought out , when things are rightly understood , either upon the old or new opinion , as he distinguishes them ; among other things , tells us , that the old and new opinion may be easily reconciled in this instance : that the wheel of an undershot water-mill is capable of doing quadruple work when the velocity of the water is doubled , instead of double work only ; ` ` because ( the adjutage being the same ) , says he , we find , that as the water 's velocity is double , there are twice the number of particles of water that issue out , and therefore the ladle-board is struck by twice the matter , which matter moving with twice the velocity that it had in the first case , the whole effect must be quadruple , though the instantaneous stroke of each particle is increased only in a simple proportion of the velocity .
' ' See vol. II .
Annotations on lecture 6th , p. 92 .
Again , in the same volume , lecture 12th , p. 424 .
referring to what went before , he tells us , ` ` The knowledge of the foregoing particulars is absolutely necessary for setting an undershot wheel to work ; but the advantage to be reaped from it would be still guesswork , and we should be still at a loss to find out the utmost it can perform , if we had not an ingenious proposition of that excellent mechanic M. PARENT , of the Royal Academy of Sciences , who has given us a maximum in this case , by showing , that an undershot wheel can do the most work , when its velocity is equal to the third part of the velocity of the water that drives it , &amp;c. because then two-thirds of the water is employed in driving the wheel with a force proportionable to the square of its velocity .
If we multiply the surface of the adjutage or opening by the height of the water , we shall have the column of water that moves the wheel .
The wheel thus moved will sustain on the opposite side only four-ninths of that weight , which will keep it in equilibrio ; but what it can move with the velocity it goes with , will be but one-third of that weight of equilibrium ; that is , 4/ 27ths of the weight of the first column , &amp;c. -This is the utmost that can be expected .
' ' The same conclusion is likewise adopted by MACLAURIN , in art .
907 .
p. 728 .
of his Fluxions , where , giving the fluxionary deduction of M. PARENT'S proposition , he says , ` ` that if A represents the weight which would balance the force of the stream , when its velocity is a ; and U represents the velocity of the part of the engine , which it strikes when the motion of the machine is uniform , &amp;c. the machine will have the greatest effect when U is equal toa/ 3 ; that is , if the weight that is raised by the engine be less than the weight which would balance the power , in the proportion of 4 to 9 , and the momentum of the weight is 4Aa/ 27 .
' ' Finding that these conclusions were far from the truth ; and seeing , from many other circumstances , that the practical theory of making water and wind-mills was but very imperfectly delivered by any author I had then an opportunity of consulting ( a ) ; in the year 1751 I began a course ( a ) BELIDOR , Architecture Hydraulique , greatly prefers the application of water to an undershot mill , instead of an overshot ; and attempts to demonstrate , that water applied undershot will do six times more execution than the same applied overshot .
See vol I. p. 286 .
While DESAGULIERS , endeavouring to invalidate what had been advanced by BELIDOR , and greatly preferring an overshot a course of experiments upon this subject .
These experiments , with the conclusions drawn from them , have already been communicated to this Society , who printed them in vol. LI .
of their Transactions for the year 1759 , and for this communication I had the honour of receiving the annual medal of Sir GODFREY COPLEY , from the hands of our very worthy President the late Earl of MACCLESFIELD .
Those experiments and conclusions stand uncontroverted , so far as I know , to this day ; and having since that time been concerned in directing the construction of a great number of mills , which were all executed upon the principles deduced from them , I have by that means had many opportunities of comparing the effects actually produced with the effects which might be expected from the calculation ; and the agreement , I have always found between these two , appears to me fully to establish the truth of the principles upon shot to an undershot , says , Annotat .
on lecture 12 .
vol. II .
p. 532 .
that from his own experience , ` ` a well-made overshot mill ground as much corn in the same time with ten times less water ; ' ' so that betwixt BELIDOR and DESAGULIERS here is a difference of no less than 60 to 1 .
Again , BELIDOR , vol. II .
p. 72 .
says , that the center of gravity of each sail of a wind-mill should travel in its own circle with one-third of the velocity of the wind ; so that , taking the distance of this center of gravity from the center of motion at 20 feet , as he states it p. 38 .
art .
849 .
the circumference will be exceeding 126 feet English measure : a wind , therefore , to make the mill go twenty turns per minute , which they frequently do with a fresh wind and all their cloth spread , would require the wind to move above eighty miles an hour ; a velocity perhaps hardly equalled in the greatest storms we experience in this climate .
which they were constructed , when applied to great works , as well as upon a smaller scale in models .
Respecting the explanatory deduction of DESAGULIERS in the first example abovementioned , which , indeed , I have found to be the commonly received doctrine among theoretical mechanics , it is shown , Phil. Trans. vol. LI .
p. 120 , 121 , and 123 .
part 1 .
maxim 4 .
that , where the velocity of water is double , the adjutage or aperture of the sluice remaining the same , the effect is eight times ; that is , not as the square but as the cube of the velocity ; and the same is investigated concerning the power of the wind arising from difference of velocity , p. 156 .
being part 3 .
maxim 4 .
The conclusion in the second example abovementioned , adopted both by DESAGULIERS and MACLAURIN , is not less wide of the truth than the foregoing ; for if that conclusion were true , only 4/ 27ths of the water expended could be raised back again to the height of the reservoir from which it had descended , exclusively of all kinds of friction , &amp;c. which would make the actual quantity raised back again still less ; that is , less than one-seventh of the whole ; whereas it appears , from table 1 .
p. 115 .
of the said volume , that in some of the experiments there related , even upon the small scale on which they were tried , the work done was equivalent to the raising back again about one quarter of the water expended ; and in large works the effect is still greater , approaching towards half , which seems to be the limit for the undershot mills , as the whole would be the limit for the overshot mills , if it were possible to set aside all friction , resistance from the air , &amp;c. see p. 130 .
The velocity also of the wheel , which , according to M. PARENT'S determination , adopted by DESAGULIERS and MACLAURIN , ought to be no more than one-third of that of the water , varies at the maximum in the abovementioned experiments of table 1 .
between one third and one half ; but in all the cases there related , in which the most work is performed in proportion to the water expended , and which approach the nearest to the circumstances of great works , when properly executed , the maximum lies much nearer to one half than one third ; one half seeming to be the true maximum , if nothing were lost by the resistance of the air , the scattering of the water carried up by the wheel , and thrown off by the centrifugal force , &amp;c. all which tend to diminish the effect more , at what would be the maximum if these did not take place , than they do when the motion is a little flower .
Finding these matters , as well as others , to come out in the experiments , so very different from the opinions and calculations of authors of the first reputation , who , reasoning according to the Newtonian definition , must have been led into these errors from a want of attending to the proper collateral circumstances ; I thought it very material , especially for the practical artist , that he should make use of a kind of reasoning in which he should not be so liable to mistakes ; in order , therefore , to make this matter perfectly clear to myself , and possibly so to others , I resolved to try a set of experiments from whence it might be inferred , what proportion or quantity of mechanical power is expended in giving the same body different degrees of velocity .
This scheme was put in execution in the year 1759 , and the experiments were then shown to several friends , particularly my very worthy and ingenious friend Mr. WILLIAM RUSSELL .
In my experimental inquiry concerning the powers of water and wind before referred to , I have , p. 105 .
part 1 .
defined what I meant by power , as applied to practical mechanics , that is , what I now call mechanical power ; which , in terms synonymous to those there used , may be said to be measured by multiplying the weight of the body into the perpendicular height from which it can descend ; thus the same weight , descending from a double height , is capable of producing a double mechanical effect , and is therefore a double mechanical power .
A double weight descending from the same height is also a double power , because it likewise is capable of producing a double effect ; and a given body , descending through a given perpendicular height , is the same power as a double body descending through half that perpendicular ; for , by the intervention of proper levers , they will counter-balance one another , conformably to the known laws of mechanics , which have never been controverted .
It must , however , be always understood , that the descending body , when acting as a measure of power , is supposed to descend slowly , like the weight of a clock or a jack ; for , if quickly descending , it is sensibly compounded with another law , viz. the law of acceleration by gravity .
DESCRIPTION OF THE MACHINE .
AB is the base of the machine placed upon a table .
AC is a pillar or standard .
CD is an arm , upon the extremity of which is fixed a plate fg , which is here seen edge-ways , through which is a small hole for receiving a small steel pivot e , fixed in the top of the upright axis eB ; the lower end of this axis finishes in a conical steel point , which rests upon a small cup of hard steel polished at B. HI is a cylinder of white fir , which passes through a perforation in the axis , and therein fixes ; and , upon the two arms formed thereby , are capable of sliding KL two cylindric weights of lead of equal size , which are capable of being fixed upon any part of the cylindric arms , from the axis to their extremities , by means of two thin wedges of wood .
The two weights , therefore , being at equal distances from the center , and the axis perpendicular , the whole will be balanced upon the point at B , and moveable thereupon by an impelling power , with very little friction .
Upon the upper part of the axis are formed MN , two cylindrical barrels , whereof M is double the diameter of N ; they have a little pin stuck into one side of each at o , p. Q is a piece capable of sliding higher or lower , as occasion requires ; and carries Ra light pulley of about three inches diameter , hung upon a steel axis , and moveable upon two small pivots .
The plane of the pulley , however , is not directed to the middle of the upright axis , but a little on one side , so as to point ( at a mean ) between the surface of the bigger barrel and the less .
S is a light scale for receiving weights , and hangs by a small twine , cord , or line , that passes the pulley , and terminates either upon the bigger barrel or the less , as may be required ; the sliding-piece Q being moved higher or lower for each , that the line , in passing from the pulley to the barrel , may be nearly horizontal .
The end of the line , that is furthest from the scale , is terminated by a small loop , which hangs on upon the pin o , or the pin p , according as the bigger or the lesser barrel is to be used .
Now , having wound up a certain number of turns of the line upon the barrel , and having placed a weight in the scale s , it is obvious , that it will cause the axis to turn round , and give motion to its arms , and to the weights of lead placed thereon , which are the heavy bodies to be put in motion by the impulse of the weight in the scale ; and when the line is wound off to the pin , the loop slips off , and the scale then falling down , the weight will cease to accelerate the motion of the heavy bodies , and leave them revolving , equably forward , with the velocity they have acquired , except so far as it must be gradually lessened by the friction of the machine and resistance of the air , which being small , the bodies will revolve sometime before their velocity is apparently diminished .
CD e fg Np o M R Q KHL MEASURES OF SOME PARTS OF THE MACHINE .
inches .
Diameter of the cylinders of lead , or the heavy bodies , 2,57 Length of ditto , 1,56 Diameter of the hole therein , ,72 Weight of each cylinder 3 lbs. Avoirdupois .
Greater distance of the middle of each body from the center of the axis , 8,25 The smaller distance of ditto , 3,92 10 turns of the smaller barrel raises the scale , 5 ditto of the bigger ditto , 25,25 When the bodies are at the smaller distance above specified from the axis of rotation , they are then in effect at half the greater distance from that axis ; for , since the axis itself , and the cylindric arms of wood , keep an unvaried distance from the center of rotation , the bodies themselves must be moved nearer than half their former distance , in order that , compounded with the unvariable parts , they may be virtually at the half distance .
In order to find this half distance nearly , I put in an arm of the same wood , that only went through the axis , without extending in the opposite direction ; one of the bodies being put upon the end of this arm , at the distance of 8,25 inches , the whole machine was inclined till the body and arm became a kind of pendulum , and vibrated at the rate of 92 times per minute ; and as a pendulum of the half length vibrates quicker in the proportion of ~1 to ~2 ; that is , in the proportion of 92 to 130 nearly ; therefore , keeping the same inclination of the machine , the weight was moved upon the arm till it made 130 vibrations per minute ; which was found to be , when it was at 3,92 inches distance from the center as above stated , which is about 2/ 10ths of an inch nearer than the half distance .
The double arm was then put in , and marked accordingly , and the bodies being mounted thereon , the whole was adjusted ready for use ; and with it were tried the following experiments , each of which was repeated so many times as to be fully satisfactory .
TABLEOFEXPERIMENT S. Ounces Barrel used , The Arms , Number of Time of the Time in makAvoirduM the bigger , W the whole , Turns of the Descent of the ing 20 RevoluNo pois in the N the smaller .
H the Half .
Line wound on Weight in the tions with equaScale .
length .
the Barrel .
Scale .
ble Motion .
~~ 18MW5 141/ 4 29 28NW 10 281/ 4 291/ 4 38NW 21/ 2 141/ 4 581/ 2 4 32 MW57 14 5 32 NW 10 14 143/ 4 6 32 NW 21/ 2 7 283/ 4 78MH57 143/ 4 88NH 10 14 15 98NH 21/ 2 7 301/ 4 1234567 The 58~1/ 2 in number 3 , column 7 , was determined in fact from 29~1/ 4 , being the time of making 10 equable revolutions , after the weight was dropped off , in order to prevent the sensible retardation that might take place , and affect the observation , if continued for 20 revolutions made so slowly .
FURTHERDEFINITION S. I have already defined what I mean by mechanic power ; but , before I proceed further , it will be necessary also to define the following terms : Impulse or Impulsion , By all which , I underImpulsive Force or Power , stand the uniform enImpelling Force or Power , deavour that one body exerts upon another , in order to make it move ; and that , whether it produces or generates motion by this endeavour or not ; and the quantity of this impelling power may be measured either by its being a weight of itself , or by being counter-balanced by a weight .
It may also act either immediately upon the body to be moved , so that if motion is the consequence , they move with the same velocity ; and that , either by a simple contact , or by being drawn as by a cord , or pushed as by a staff : or it may act by the intervention of a lever or other mechanic instrument , in which the velocity of the body to be moved may be very different from the velocity of the impelling power or mover ; but in comparing them , the impelling powers must be reduced according to the proportional velocities of the mover and moved ; or , in levers of different lengths , they may be compared by a standard length of lever , which is the method taken in the subsequent reasoning upon the preceding experiments .
An impelling power , therefore , consisting of a double weight , or requiring a double weight to counter-balance it , when acting with equal levers , is a double impelling power , or an impelling power of double the intensity .
OBSERVATIONS AND DEDUCTIONS FROM THE PRECEDING EXPERIMENTS .
1st , By the first experiment it appears , that the mechanic power employed , consisting of 8 ounces in the scale , deliberately descending ( by 5 turns of the bigger barrel ) through a perpendicular space 251/ 4 inches , will represent the quantity of mechanic power which causes the two heavy bodies , from a state of rest , to acquire a velocity , such as to carry them equably through 20 circumferences of their circle of revolution in the space of 29~ ; and that the time in which the mechanic power produced this effect was 14~1/ 4 , as appears by column 6th .
And this mechanic power we shall express by the number 202 , the product of the number of ounces in the scale multiplied by the inches in its perpendicular descent , for 8x 251/ 4 = 202 .
2d , By the second experiment , as 10 turns of the smaller barrel are equal to the same perpendicular height as 5 turns of the bigger , it follows , that the same mechanic power , viz. 202 , acting upon the same heavy bodies to accelerate them , produces the very same effect in generating motion in the bodies as it did before , viz. 20 revolutions in 29~1/ 4 , the small difference of 1/ 4 of a second being no more than may reasonably be attributed to the unavoidable errors arising from friction of the machine , want of perfect accuracy in its measures , resistance of the air , and imperfections in the observations themselves , which must not only be allowed for in this , but the rest ; but as the impelling power is acting here upon a lever of but half the length , and , consequently , but half the intensity , when referred to the bodies to be moved , it takes just double the time to generate the same velocity therein .
DEDUCTION .
It appears from hence , that the same mechanic power is capable of producing the same velocity in a given body , whether it is applied so as to produce it in a greater or a lesser time ; but that the time taken to produce a given velocity , by an uniformly continued action , is in a simple inverse proportion of the intensity of the impulsive power .
3dly , The third experiment being made with 21/ 2 turns of the lesser barrel , the same weight in the scale of 8 ounces descending only one quarter part of the former perpendicular , the mechanic power employed will be only one quarter part of the former , viz. 501/ 2 ; but as one quarter part of the mechanic power produces half of the former velocity in the heavy bodies ; that is , they make 20 revolutions in 58~1/ 2 ; that is , nearly 10 revolutions in 29~ ; we may conclude , in this instance , that the mechanic power , employed in producing motion , is as the square of the velocity produced in the same body ; and that the velocity produced is as the time that an impelling power , of the same intensity , continues to act upon it , as appears by the near agreement of numbers 2 and 3 , column 6th .
4thly , In the fourth experiment , the apparatus is the same as the first , only here the weight in the scale is 32 ounces ; that is , the impelling power is the quadruple of the first , and hereby a double velocity is given to the bodies ; for they make 20 revolutions in 14~ , which is a small matter less than half the time taken up in making 20 revolutions in the first experiment .
It also appears , that the velocity acquired is simply as the impelling power compounded with the time of its action ; for a quadruple impulsion acting for 7~ instead of 14~ generates a double velocity , while the mechanic power employed to generate it is quadruple , for 32 x 251/ 4=808 .
And here the mechanic power employed being four times greater than the first , it holds here also , that the mechanic power , to be necessarily employed , is as the square of the velocity to be generated ; that is , in the same proportion as turned out in the third experiment , where the mechanic power employed was only a quarter part of the first .
5thly , The fifth and sixth experiments were made with a mechanic power four times greater than those employed in numbers 2 and 3 respectively ; and since the same deductions result from hence as from numbers 2 and 3 , they are additional confirmations of the conclusions drawn from them and from the last article .
6thly , In the seventh experiment , the disposition of the apparatus is the same as number 1 , only here the bodies are placed upon the arms at the half-length ; from whence it appears , that the same mechanic power still produces the same velocity in the same bodies ; for though 20 revolutions were performed in 143/ 4~ ( see column 7 ) which is nearly half the time that 20 revolutions were performed in the first experiment ; yet , since the circles in which the bodies revolved in the seventh are only of half the circumference as those of number 1 , it is obvious , that the absolute velocity acquired by the moving bodies in the two cases is equal .
But , by column 6th , the time in which it was generated is only half ; yet , notwithstanding , this will coincide with the former conclusions , if the intensity of the impelling power is compounded therewith ; for , though the barrel was the same with the same number of turns as in number 1 , and therefore the lever the same , by which the impelling power acted , yet , as the bodies , upon which this lever was to act , were placed upon a lever of only half the length from the center , the impelling power , acting by the first lever , would act upon the second with double the intensity , according to the known laws of mechanics ; that is , it would require a double weight opposing the bodies , to prevent their moving , in order to balance it .
An impulsive power , therefore , of double the intensity , acting for half the time , produces the same effect in generating motion , as an impulsive power , of half the intensity , acting for the whole time .
7thly , The eighth and ninth experiments afford the same deductions and confirmations relative to the seventh experiment , that the fifth and sixth do respecting the fourth , and that the second and third do respecting the first ; and from the near agreement of the whole , when the necessary allowances before mentioned are made , together with some small inequality arising from the mechanical power lost by the difference of the motion given by gravity to the weight in the scale : I say , from these agreements , under the very different mechanical powers applied , which were varied in the proportion of 1 to 16 , we may safely conclude , that this is the universal law of nature , respecting the capacities of bodies in motion to produce mechanical effects , and the quantity of mechanic power necessary to be employed to produce or generate different velocities ( the bodies being supposed equal in their quantity of matter ) ; that the mechanic powers to be expended are as the squares of the velocities to be generated , and vice versa ; and that the simple velocities generated are as the impelling power compounded with , or multiplied by , the time of its action , and vice versa .
We shall , perhaps , form a still clearer conception of the relation between velocities produced , and the quantities of mechanic power required to produce them ; together with the collateral circumstances attending , by which these propositions , seemingly two , are reconciled and united , by stating the following popular elucidation , which , indeed , was the original idea that occurred to me on considering this subject ; to put which to an experimental proof gave birth to the foregoing apparatus and experiments .
Suppose then a large iron ball of 10 feet diameter , turned truly spherical , and set upon an extended plane of the same metal , and truly level .
Now , if a man begins to push at it , he will find it very resisting to motion at first ; but , by continuing the impulse , he will gradually get it into motion , and having nothing to resist it but the air , he will , by continuing his efforts , at length get it to roll almost as fast as he can run .
Suppose now , in the first minute he gets it rolled through a space of one yard ; by this motion , proceeding from rest ( similar to what happens to falling bodies ) it would continue to roll forward at the rate of two yards per minute , without further help ; but supposing him to continue his endeavours , at the end of another minute he will have given it a velocity capable of carrying it through a space of two yards more , in addition to the former , that is , at the rate of four yards per minute ; and at the end of the third minute , he has again added an equal increase of velocity , and made it proceed at the rate of six yards per minute ; and so on , increasing its velocity at the rate of two yards in every minute .
The man , therefore , in the space of every minute exerts an equal impulse upon the ball , and generates an equal increase of movement correspondent to the definition of Sir ISAAC NEWTON .
But let us see what happens besides : the man , in the first minute , has moved but one yard from where he set out ; but he must in the second minute move two yards more , in order to keep up with the ball ; and as he exerted an impulse upon it , so as at the end of second minute to have given it an additional velocity of the two yards , he must also in this time have gradually changed its velocity from the rate of two yards per minute to that of four , and the space , that he will of conse3 quence quence have actually been obliged to go through in the second minute , will be according to the mean of the extremes of velocity at the beginning and end thereof , that is , three yards in the second minute ; so that being one yard from his original place at the beginning of the second minute , at the end of it he will have moved the sum of the journies of the first and second minute , that is , in the whole four yards from his original place .
As he has now generated a velocity in the ball of four yards per minute , in the third minute he must travel four yards to keep up with the ball , and one more in generating the equal increment of velocity ; so that in the third minute , he must travel five yards to keep up the same impelling power upon the ball that he did in the first minute in travelling one , so that these five yards in the third minute , added to the four yards that he had travelled in the two preceding minutes , sets him at the end of the third minute nine yards from whence he set out , having then given the ball a velocity capable of carrying it uniformly forward at the rate of six yards per minute , as before stated .
We may now leave the further pursuit of these proportions , and see how the account stands .
He generated a velocity of two yards per minute in the first minute , the square of which is four , when he had moved but one yard from his place ; and he had generated a velocity of six yards per minute , the square of which is thirty-six , at the end of the third minute , when he had travelled nine yards from his place .
Now , since the square of the velocity , generated at the end of the first minute , is to that of the velocity generated at the end of the third minute , as 4 : 36 , that is , as 1 : 9 ; and since the spaces , moved through by the man to communicate these velocities , are also as 1 : 9 , it follows , that the spaces through which the man must travel , in order to generate these velocities respectively ( preserving the impelling power perfectly equal ) , must be as the squares of the velocities that are communicated to the ball ; for , if the man was to be brought back again to his original place by a mechanical power , equally exerted upon the man equally resisting , this would be the measure of what the man has done in order to give motion to the ball .
It therefore directly follows , conformably to what has been deduced from the experiments , that the mechanic power that must of necessity be employed in giving different degrees of velocity to the same body , must be as the square of that velocity ; and if the converse of this proposition did not hold , viz. that if a body in motion , in being stopped , would not produce a mechanical effect equal or proportional to the square of its velocity , or to the mechanical power employed in producing it , the effect would not correspond with its producing cause .
Thus the consequences of generating motion upon a level plane exactly correspond with the generating of motion by gravity ; viz. that though in two seconds of time the equal impulsive power of gravity gives twice the velocity to a body that it does in one second , yet this collateral circumstance attends it , that at the end of the double time , in consequence of the velocity acquired in the first half , the body has fallen from where it set forward through four times the perpendicular ; and , therefore , though the velocity is only doubled , yet four times the mechanical power has been consumed in producing it , as four times the mechanical power must be expended in bringing up the fallen body to its first place .
This then appears to be the foundation , not only of the disputes that have arisen , but of the mistakes that have been made , in the application of the different definitions of quantity of motion ; that while those , that have adhered to the definition of Sir ISAAC NEWTON , have complained of their adversaries , in not considering the time in which effects are produced , they themselves have not always taken into the account the space that the impelling power is obliged to travel through , in producing the different degrees of velocity .
It seems , therefore , that , without taking in the collateral circumstances both of time and space , the terms , quantity of motion , momentum , and force of bodies in motion , are absolutely indefinite ; and that they cannot be so easily , distinctly , and fundamentally compared , as by having recourse to the common measure , viz. mechanic power .
From the whole of what has been investigated , it therefore appears , that time , properly speaking , has nothing to do with the production of mechanical effects , otherwise than as , by equally flowing , it becomes a common measure ; so that , whatever mechanical effect is found to be produced in a given time , the uniform continuance of the action of the same mechanical power will , in a double time , produce two such effects , or twice that effect .
A mechanical power , therefore , properly speaking , is measured by the whole of its mechanical effect produced , whether that effect is produced in a greater or a lesser time ; thus , having treasured up 1000 tuns of water , which I can let out upon the over-shot wheel of a mill , and descending through a perpendicular of 20 feet , this power applied to proper mechanic instruments , will produce a certain effect , that is , it will grind a certain quantity of corn ; and that , at a certain rate of expending it , it will grind this corn in an hour .
But suppose the mill equally adapted to produce a proportionable effect , by the application of a greater impulsive power as with a less , then , if I let out the water twice as fast upon the wheel , it will grind the corn twice as fast , and both the water will be expended and the corn ground in half an hour .
Here the same mechanical effect is produced ; viz. the grinding a given quantity of corn , by the same mechanical power , viz. 1000 tuns of water descending through a given perpendicular of 20 feet , and yet this effect is in one case produced in half the time of the other .
What time , therefore , has to do in the business is this : let the rate of doing the business , or producing the effect , be what it will , if this rate is uniform , when I have found by experiment what is done in a given time , then , proceeding at the same rate , twice the effect will be produced in twice the time , on supposition that I have a supply of mechanic power to go on with .
Thus 1000 tuns of water , descending through 20 feet of perpendicular , dicular , being , as has been shown , a given mechanic power , let me expend it at what rate I will , if when this is expended , I must wait another hour before it be renewed , by the natural flow of a river , or otherwise , I can then only expend twelve such quantities of power in 24 hours ; but if , while I am expending 1000 tuns in one hour , the stream renews me the same quantity , then I can expend 24 such quantities of power in 24 hours ; that is , I can go on continually at that rate , and the product or effect will be in proportion to time , which is the common measure ; but the quantity of mechanic power arising from the flow of the two rivers , compared by taking an equal portion of time , is double in the one to the other , though each has a mill , that , when going , will grind an equal quantity of corn in an hour .

