III .
Discoveries on the Sex of Bees , explaining the Manner in which their Species is propagated ; with an Account of the Utility that may be derived from those Discoveries by the actual Application of them to Practice .
By Mr. John Debraw , Apothecary to Addenbrook 's Hospital at Cambridge , and Member of an Oeconomical Society in the Principality of Liege in Westphalia .
Communicated by the Rev. Nevil Maskelyne , B. D. F. R. S. and Astronomer Royal .
THE republic of bees has at all times gained universal esteem and admiration : their culture , an object so worthy of our attention , has attracted and still does engage that of many of the learned , and has arrived at a considerable degree of improvement of late years ; but their mode of propagating their species seems to this day to have baffled the ingenuity of ages in their attempts to discover it .
The most skilful naturalists have been strangely misled in their opinion , that the bees , as well as the other tribes of animals , are perpetuated by copulation ; though they acknowledge Read Nov. 21 , acknowledge that they have never been able to detect them in the act .
PLINY , who was likewise of the same opinion , that in this particular they do not differ from other animals , observes , ` ` Apium coitus visus est nunquam .
' ' SWAMMERDAM , that sagacious observer , having never been able to discover it , entertained a notion , that the female or queen bee was fecundated without copulation ; that it was sufficient for her to be near the males ; that a vivifying aura , exhaling from the body of the males , and absorbed by the female , might impregnate her eggs .
At last the incomparable REAUMUR thought he had in a great measure removed the veil , and brought their manner of generating nearly to a proof .
This part of physics has been the principal object of my researches for several years past , having been insensibly engaged in it by the pleasure I took in so curious an inquiry ; and although this pursuit has been attended with more difficulties and embarassments than can be well imagined , I have not been discouraged , and have carefully avoided launching into conjectures .
To introduce a new system in the doctrine of bees , which in a great measure contradicts all former received opinions , requires , previous to its appearance , every sanction the various experiments , successfully repeated , can possibly give it .
The results of those experiments , ments , made all in glass-hives , which carry with them an entire evidence , afford sufficient reasons to assert , that bees belong to that class of animals among which , although they have sexes , a true copulation cannot be proved ; and that their ova , like the spawn of fishes , most probably owe their fecundation to an impregnation from the males , as will appear in the sequel of this narrative .
I am not a little pleased to find that the celebrated MARALDI had such a notion , and I lament his neglecting to confirm it .
He says , in his Observations upon Bees , in the History of the Academy of Sciences for the year 1712 , ~ 332 : Nous n'avons avons pu decouvrir jusqu ' a present de quelle maniere se fait cette fecondation , si c'est dans le corps de la femelle , ou bien si c'est a la maniere des poissons , apres que la femelle a pose ses aeuss : la matiere blanchatre dont l'aeuf est environne au fond de l'alveole peu de temps apres sa naissance , semble conforme a la derniere opinion , aussibien que les remarques faites plusieurs fois d'un grand nombre d'aeuss qui sont rests infeconds au fond de l'alveole autour desquels nous n'avons point vu cette matiere .
We never yet were able to discover in what manner this fecundation is performed ; whether it is in the body of the female , or whether it is after the manner of fishes , after the female or queen-bee has deposited her eggs : that liquid whitish substance , with which each egg is surrounded at the bottom of the cell a little while after its being laid , seemingly establishing this last opinion , as well as the frequent remarks made of a great number of eggs remaining barren in the cell , round which we could not see the above-mentioned whitish substance .
' ' This ingenious naturalist , by a nice examination of the structure of the drones , had , as well as SWAMMERDAM , discovered some resemblances to the male organs of generation ; and from thence conjectured , they were the males of the bee-insect ; but he owns , with the rest , that he never could discover them in the act of copulation .
Having stood the trials of so many prying eyes in every age , the bees , as has been observed by an ingenious author , had gained the character of an inviolable chastity , till REAUMUR blasted their reputation .
He makes the queen no better than a MESSALINA ( a ) ; though he could see no more than what would raise a mere jealousy or generate suspicions .
In order to be the better understood in the relation of my own experiments on the fecundation of bees , I here premise the outlines of the opinions adopted by the abovementioned naturalists on that head .
They assert that the [ a ] Vid. JUVENAL , Sat. vi .
ver .
128 .
queen is the only female in the hive , and the mother of the next generation ; that the drones are the males by which she is fecundated ; and that the working bees , or bees that collect wax on the Howers , that knead it and form from it the combs and cells which they afterwards fill with honey , are of neither sex .
But of late Mr. SCHDRACH , a German naturalist , has given us a very different view of the classes that constitute the republic of bees , in an ingenious publication in his own language , under the title of The Natural History of the Queen of the Bees , which has been since translated into French ; an account of which has been given in the Monthly Review , from which I beg leave to relate the author 's doctrine with regard to the working-bees only ; the quality and functions of the drones being points which do not appear to be yet settled by Mr. SCHIRACH himself .
He affirms , that all the common bees are females in disguise , in which the organs that distinguish the sex , and particularly the ovaria , are obliterated , or at least , through their excessive minuteness , have not yet been observed : that every one of those bees in the earlier period of its existence is capable of becoming a queen-bee , if the whole community should think proper to nurse it in a particular manner , and raise it to that rank .
In short , that the queen-bee lays only two kinds of eggs ; viz. those that are to produce the drones , and those from which the working-bees are to proceed .
The trials made by Mr. SCHIRACH seem to evince the truth of his conclusions in the most satisfactory manner , singular as they appear to be at first sight ; and indeed in my own judgement , from the constant happy result of my numerous experiments , which I began near two years before Mr. SCHIRACH'S publication , and repeated every season since .
I am enabled to pronounce on their reality .
Chance I own befriended me in that discovery , whilst I was most anxiously endeavouring to ascertain the use of drones .
It was in the spring of the year 1770 , that I for the first time discovered what MARALDI had only conjectured , I mean the impregnation of the eggs by the males , and that I was made acquainted with the difference of size in the drones or males observed by MARALDI in his Observations upon Bees , inserted in the History of the Royal Academy of Sciences for the year 1712 , p. 333 .
in these words : Nous avons trouve depuis peu un grande quantite de bourdons , beaucoup plus petits que ceux que nous avions remarque aupar avaunt , et qui no surpassent point la grandeur des petites abeilles ; de sort qu'il n'auroit pas ete aise de les distinguer dans cette ruche de abeilles ordinaires , sans le grand nombre que nous y en avons trouve .
Il se pourroit bien fair que dans les ruches ou l'on n'a pas trouve de gros bourdons , il y en eut de ces petits , et qu'ils y aient ete confondus avec le rest des abeilles , lorsque nous no savions pas encore qu'il y en eut de cette taille .
` ` We have of late found a great quantity of drones much smaller than those we had formerly observed , and which do not exceed in size the common bees ; so that it would not have been easy to distinguish them in that hive from the common bees , had not the quantity of them been very considerable .
It might certainly have happened that in those hives , where we have not been able to discover large drones , there were a great number of those little ones , which may have been intermixed among common bees when we were yet ignorant that any such small drones were existing .
' ' REAUMUR himself , p. 591 .
of his Natural History of Insects , says , ` ` We have likewise found drones that were no bigger than the common bees .
' ' They have notwithstanding escaped the observation of Mr. SCHIRACH , and of his friend Mr. HATTORF member of an Academy in Lusatia , who , in a memoir he presented in the year 1769 , annihilates entirely the use of drones in a hive ; and advances this singular opinion , that the queen-bee of a hive lays eggs which produce young ones , without having any communication with the drones .
For what purpose should wise nature then have furnished the drones with that large quantity of seminal liquor ?
To what use so large an apparatus of fecundating organs , so well described by REAUMUR and MARALDI ?
But I beg leave to remark , that those gentlemen seem to have drawn too hasty conclusions from their experiments , in rejecting the drones as bearing no share in the propagation of those insects .
Their observations , that hives are peopled at a time of the year when there are no drones in being , is no ways conclusive ; as it is evident , that they had seen none but drones of a large size , their silence on the difference in the size of them justifying my remark .
But to resume the narrative of my experiments : I had watched my glass-hives ( b ) with indefatigable attention from the moment the bees , among which I had taken care to leave a large number of drones , were put into them , to the time of the queen laying her eggs , which generally happens the fourth or fifth day .
I observed the first or second day ( always before the third ) from the time the eggs are placed in the cells , that a great number ( b ) Glass-hives were used in preference to boxes , for a purpose too obvious to need explaining .
of bees , fastening themselves to one another , hung down in the form of a curtain from the top to the bottom of the hive , in a similar manner they had done before at the time the queen deposited her eggs ; an operation which ( if we may conjecture at the instincts of insects ) seems contrived to hide what is transacting : be that as it will , it answered the purpose of informing me that something was going forward .
In fact , I presently after perceived several bees , the size of which through this thick veil ( if I may so express myself ) I could not rightly distinguish , inserting the posterior part of their bodies each into a cell , and sinking into it , where they continued but a little while .
After they had retired , I saw plainly with the naked eye a small quantity of a whitish liquor left in the angle of the basis of each cell , containing an egg : it was less liquid than honey , and had no sweet taste at all .
Within a day after , I found this liquor absorbed into the embrio , which on the fourth day is converted into a small worm , to which the working-bees bring a little honey for nourishment , during the first eight or ten days after its birth .
After that time they cease to feed them ; for they shut up the cells , where these embrios continue enclosed for ten days more , during which time they undergo various changes too tedious here to describe .
To evince the reality of this observation , and to prove that the eggs are fecundated by the males , and that their presence is necessary at the time of breeding , I proceeded to the next experiments .
They consisted in leaving in a hive the queen with only the common bees , without any drones , to see whether the eggs she laid would be prolific .
I accordingly took a swarm , shook all the bees into a tub of water , and left them in it till they were quite senseless , which gave me an opportunity to distinguish the drones without any danger of being stung After I had recovered the working-bees and their queen from the state they were in , by spreading them on brown paper in the sun , I replaced them in a glass-hive , where they soon began to work as usual : the queen laid eggs , which I little suspected to be impregnated , as I thought I had separated all the drones or males , and therefore omitted watching the bees ; but at the end of twenty days ( the usual time of their hatching ) I found to my surprise some of the eggs hatched into bees , others withered away , and severalof them covered with honey .
I immediately inferred that some of the males , having escaped my notice , had impregnated only part of the eggs ; but , in order to convince myself of the truth of my supposition , I thought it necessary to take away all the brood-comb that was in the hive , in order to oblige the bees to provide a fresh quantity , being fully determined to watch narrowly their motions after new eggs should be deposited in the cells .
This was done accordingly , and at last the mystery was unravelled .
On the second day after the eggs were placed in the cells , I perceived the same operation which I have related in a former experiment ; I mean , the bees hung down in the form of a curtain , while others thrust the posterior part of their body into the cells : I then introduced my hand into the hive , broke off a piece of the comb containing two of those insects , and kept them for examination .
I found in neither of them any sting ( a circumstance peculiar to drones only ) and upon dissection , by the help of a DOLLOND'S microscope , discovered in them the four cylindrical bodies , which contain the glutinous liquor of a whitish colour , observed by MARALDI in the large drones .
Having till then never observed any difference in the size of drones , I immediately perused the Memoirs on Bees published by Mess .
MARALDI and REAUMUR , and found that they had remarked it frequently .
I have inserted in a preceding page the substance of their observations on that head , as taken from their writings .
The reason of that difference must I doubt be placed amongst other arcana of nature .
I found myself therefore under a necessity in my next experiments to be more particular in destroying the males , even those which might be suspected to be such .
I once more immersed all the same bees in water ; and , when they appeared to be in a senseless state , I gently pressed every one of them between my fingers , in order to distinguish those armed with stings from those that had none , which last I might suspect to be males .
Of these I found fifty-seven , exactly of the size of common bees , yielding a little whitish liquor on being pressed between the fingers .
I killed every one , and replaced the swarm in a glass-hive , where they immediately applied again to the work of making cells ; and on the fourth or fifth day , very early in the morning , I had the pleasure to see the queen-bee depositing her eggs in those cells , which she did by placing the posterior part of her body in each of them .
I continued on the watch most part of the ensuing days , but could discover nothing of what I had seen before .
The eggs , after the fourth day , instead of changing in the manner of caterpillars , were found in the same state they were in the first day , except that some of them were covered with honey .
But a very singular event happened the next day about noon : all the bees left their own hive , and were seen attempting to get into a neighbouring common hive , on the stool of which I found their queen dead , having no doubt been slain in the engagement .
The manner in which I account for this event is as follows : the great desire of perpetuating their species , which is most observable in these insects , and to which end the concurrence of the males seems so absolutely necessary , made them desert their own habitation where no males were left , in order to fix their residence in a new one , in which , there being a good stock of males , they might the better accomplish their purpose .
If this does not yet establish the reader 's faith of the necessity of the males bearing a share in the fecundation of the ova , the next experiment cannot I presume fail to convince him .
I took the brood-comb which , as I observed before , had not been impregnated ; I divided it into two parts ; one I placed under a glass-bell No 1 .
with honey-comb for the bees ' food ; I took care to leave a queen , but no drones , among the common bees I confined in it .
The other piece of brood-comb I placed under another glass-bell No 2 .
with a few drones , a queen , and a number of common bees proportioned to the size of the glass ; the rest I disposed of as before .
The result was , that in the glass No 1 .
no impregnation happened ; the eggs remained in the same state they were in when put into the glass ; and , upon giving the bees their liberty on the seventh day , they all flew away , as was found to be the case in the forE 2 mer mer experiment : whereas in the glass No 2 .
I saw , the very day after the bees had been put under it , the impregnation of the eggs by the drones in every cell containing eggs ; the bees did not leave their hive on receiving their liberty ; and , in the course of twenty days , every egg underwent all the above-mentioned necessary changes , and formed a pretty numerous young colony , in which I was not a little startled to find two queens .
Fully satisfied concerning the impregnation of the eggs by the males , I desisted for the present from any further experiments on that head , being exceedingly anxious to endeavour to account for the presence of this new queen .
I conjectured that either two queens , instead of one , must have been left among the bees I had placed under that glass ; or else that the bees could , by some particular means of their own , transform a common subject into a queen .
In order to put this to the test , I repeated the experiment with some variation .
I got four glass-hiyes blown flat , which I thought preferable to the bell-shaped ones I had used before , as I could with those better examine what was going forward .
I took a large brood-comb from an old hive , and , after having divided it into several pieces , I put some of them , containing eggs , worms , and nymphs , with food , viz. honey &amp;c. under each of the glasses ; and confined within each a sufficient number of common bees , among which I left some drones , but took care that there should be no queen .
The bees finding themselves without a queen , made a strange buzzing noise , which lasted near two days ; at the end of which they settled and betook themselves to work : on the fourth day I perceived in each hive the beginning of a royal cell , a certain indication that one of the enclosed worms would soon be converted into a queen .
The construction of the royal cell being nearly accomplished , I ventured to leave an opening for the bees to get out , and found that they returned as regularly as they do in common hives , and showed no inclination to desert their habitation .
But , to be brief , at the end of twenty days , I observed four young queens among the new progeny .
On relating the result of these experiments to a member of this university , well conversant in the natural history of bees , he deemed it necessary , that they should be repeated , in order the better to establish the truth of a fact seemingly so improbable , that the eggs destined by nature to produce neutral or common bees , should be transformed into females or queens .
He started an objection to me , which by the publication of Mr. SCHIRACH appearing a little time after , seems to have been pointed out to that author also by Mr. WITHELMI , his brother-in-law , namely , that the queen-bee of a hive , besides the eggs which she deposits in the royal cells , might also have laid royal or female eggs either in the common cells , or indiscriminately throughout the different parts of the hive .
He further supposed , that in the pieces of brood-comb , which had been successfully employed in the last experiments for the production of a queen , it had constantly happened , that one or more of these royal eggs , or rather the worms proceeding from them , had been contained .
But the force of his objection was removed soon after by the same success having attended a number of other experiments which I since made , an account of which would take up too much room here ; and this gentleman , together with Mr. SCHIRACH'S brother-in-law , was at last brought to admit , that the working-bees are invested with a power of raising a common subject to the throne , when the community stands in need of a queen ; and that accordingly every worm of the hive is capable , under certain circumstances , of becoming the mother of a generation : that it owes its metamorphosis into a queen , partly to the extraordinary size of the cell , and its particular position in it ; but principally to a certain nourishment appropriated to the occasion , and carefully administered to it by the working-bees while it is in the worm-state , by which , and possibly other means as yet unknown , the development and expansion of the germ of the female organs , previously existing in the embryos , is effected , and those differences in its form and size are produced , which afterwards so remarkably distinguish the queen from the common working-bees .
And finally it appears evident , from the experiments made by Mr. SCHIRACH and myself , that the received opinion , that the queen lays a particular kind of eggs , appropriated to the production of other queens , is erroneous .
I am not a little flattered with the similarity of my discoveries with those of the ingenious German naturalist , in proving the sex of the common bees : although we so widely differ in what relates to the use of the males , whom , as we have seen before , he imagines to be quite useless .
I am also not a little pleased to find , that our experiments on the production of a queen from a common embryo agree so well .
I shall now beg leave to point out the advantage that may accrue to the public from these observations , which is that of forming artificial swarms or new colonies ; or in other words , of furnishing the means to bring on a numerous increase of those useful insects : an object of some importance to this kingdom , as being the only means to prevent the annual exportation of considerable sums in the purchase of wax , a great quantity of which is lost every season for want of keeping up a sufficient stock of bees to collect it .
The practice of this new art , Mr. SCHIRACH tells us , has already extended itself through Upper Lusatia , the Palatinate , Bohemia , Bavaria , Silesia , and even in Poland .
In some of those countries it has excited the attention and patronage of government ; and even the Empress of Russia has thought it of such importance , that she has sent a person to Klein Bautzen , to be instructed in the general principles , and learn all the minutiae of this new art .
The narrow limits of this paper do not permit me here to give an account of Mr. SCHIRACH'S ingenious observations .
I beg leave to refer the curious reader to the work itself , which , with the reviewers , I wish was translated into the English language , as it contains many particulars highly deserving the notice of the speculative naturalist , as well as of those who cultivate bees either for profit or amusement .

