XLVIII .
A Proposal for measuring the Attraction of some Hill in this Kingdom by Astronomical Observations .
By the Rev. Nevil Maskelyne , B. D. F. R. S. and Astronomer Royal .
IF the attraction of gravity be exerted , as Sir ISAAC NEWTON supposes , not only between the large bodies of the universe , but between the minutest particles of which these bodies are composed , or into which the mind can imagine them to be divided , acting universally according to that law , by which the force which carries on the celestial motions is regulated ; namely , that the accelerative force of each particle of matter towards every other particle decreases as the squares of the distances increase , it will necessarily follow , that every hill must , by its attraction , alter the direction of gravitation in heavy bodies in its neighbourhood from what it would have been from the attraction of the earth alone , considered as bounded by a smooth and even surface .
For , as the tendency of heavy bodies downwards perpendicular to the earth 's surface is owing to the combined attraction of all the parts of the earth upon it , so a neighbouring mountain ought , though in a far less degree , to attract the heavy body towards its centre of attraction , which cannot be placed far from the middle of the mountain .
Hence the plumb-line of a quadrant , or any other astronomical instrument , must be deflected from its proper situation by a small quantity VOL. LXV .
Uuu stars , Red in the year towards the mountain ; and the apparent altitudes of the stars , taken with the instrument , will be altered accordingly .
It will easily be acknowledged , that to find a sensible attraction of any hill from undoubted experiment would be a matter of no small curiosity , would greatly illustrate the general theory of gravity , and would make the universal gravitation of matter palpable , if I may so express myself , to every person , and fit to convince those who will yield their assent to nothing but downright experiment .
Nor would its uses end here ; as it would serve to give us a better idea of the total mass of the earth , and the proportional density of the matter near the surface compared with the mean density of the whole earth .
The result of such an uncommon experiment , which I should hope would prove successful , would doubtless do honour to the nation where it was made , and the society which executed it .
Sir ISAAC NEWTON gives us the first hint of such an attempt , in his popular Treatise of the System of the World , where he remarks , ` ` That a mountain of an hemispherical figure , three miles high and six broad , will not , by its attraction , draw the plumb-line two minutes out of the perpendicular .
' ' It will appear , by a very easy calculation , that such a mountain would attract the plumb-line 1~ 18~ from the perpendicular .
But the first attempt of this kind was made by the French Academicians , who measured three degrees of the meridian near Quito in Peru , and who endeavoured to find the effect of the attraction of Chimboraco , a mountain in that neighbourhood , which is elevated near four miles above the sea , though only about two miles above the general level of the province of Quite .
By their observations of the altitudes of fixed stars taken with a quadrant of 21/ 2 feet radius , they found the quantity of 8~ in favour of the attraction of the mountain , by a mean of their observations .
This , indeed , was much less than they expected ; but then it is to be considered , that their instrument was too small and imperfect for the purpose ; and that they themselves were subject to great inconveniences , being sheltered from the wind and weather by nothing but a common tent , and placed so high up the mountain as the boundary where the snow begins to lie unmelted all the year round .
And indeed their observations , doubtless owing to these causes of error , differ greatly from one another , and are therefore insufficient to prove the reality of an attraction of the mountain Chimboraco , although the general result from them is in favour of it .
Accordingly , one of the French gentlemen themselves , M. BOUGUER , who drew up the account of their experiment , expresses his wishes , that a like experiment might be made , to find the attraction of a mountain in France or England , where he thinks some might be found of sufficient bulk for the purpose .
This experiment and these remarks were made in the year 1738 , or above thirty years ago , yet I believe no similar experiment has ever been made in Europe .
I have made inquiries after a proper hill in this kingdom , for the trying of such a curious experiment , and have been informed of two places in particular , extremely convenient for the purpose .
The one is situated on the consines of Yorkshire and Lancashire ; where , within the compass of twenty miles , are situated four very remarkable hills , called Pendle-hill , Pennygant , Ingleborough , and Whernside , which have been estimated to be from 600 to 750 yards elevated above the plane of the vales between them .
By calculation on these data , it should follow , that the sum of the contrary attractions of Whernside , the largest of these hills , on the plumb-line placed half-way up the hill , would not be less than 30~ , and might amount to 46~ , which it is evident is a very considerable quantity , and sufficient to give us room to hope for a favourable and satisfactory success of the experiment .
The other place pointed out for this purpose , is a valley two miles broad , between the hills Helwellin and Skidda , in Cumberland ; which hills , according to a plan of them and the adjacent country , communicated by Mr. SMEATON , F.R.S.are elevated above 1000 yards above the intermediate valley .
By a calculation made according to this plan , the sum of the contrary attractions of the plumb-line , placed alternately on the North-side of Helwellin and the Southside of Skidda , amounts to about 20~ , which is like wise a quantity large enough for the experiment .
And although the density of the earth near the surface should be five times less than the mean density , as there is some reason to suspect , and the attractions , as here stated , should consequently be diminished in the proportion of five to one , still the sum of the contrary attractions of Whernside side would be 6~ or 9~ , and the sum of the contrary attractions of Helwellin and Skidda would be 4~ ; which quantities are not too small to be measured and demonstrated by an accurate zenith sector , such as that belonging to the Royal Society , which I made use of at St. Helena , would be , if the fault in the suspension of the plumb-line , which I there discovered , was corrected , in the manner suggested in the Philosophical Transactions , vol. LIV .
p. 351 .

