XXX .
An Account of an extraordinary acephalous Birth .
By W. Cooper , M. D. in a Letter to William Hunter , M. D. F. R. S. DEAR SIR , I TAKE the liberty to remit you an account of the delivery of a very curious acephalous monster , accompanied with a short description of its anatomical structure .
If , after a perusal of it , you should apprehend it may be acceptable to the Royal Society , I beg that you will do me the honour to lay it before them .
Mrs. BRACKETT , of Clerkenwell Close , aged twentythree years , was , at the end of her first pregnancy , by a natural labour , delivered of a perfect female child , on Friday the 8th of October , 1773 , at seven o'clock in the morning .
The attending midwife , Mrs. AIRS , soon perceived by the abdominal tumour that there was another child .
After waiting about three hours , a flooding came on ; but without pain , or any advancement of the second delivery .
The haemorrhage producing faintness , debility , and danger , the attendants and midwife were alarmed , and I was sent for .
When I came , I found her in the situation above described ; and therefore VOL. LXV .
Uu thought Red , April 27 , thought it my duty to accomplish the remaining part of the labour , as soon as I could , consistently with the safety of the mother .
Upon all occasions , when the concomitant circumstances render it necessary to turn a child in utero , it is of the utmost consequence , to understand , as nearly as we can , its general situation , in order to deliver with the greater ease , safety , and expedition .
And to an experienced accoucheur , if the breech , knees , or feet , do not immediately present themselves , the head and face of the child will , in most cases , be a sufficient index to the position of the other parts of its body .
This circumstance arises from the faetus commonly coiling itself up into an oblong , oval , snug , compact figure , with its knees towards its chain , in order to take up as little room as possible , by being adapted to the cavity of the uterus .
In the present case , when the patient was placed in a proper situation , having introduced my hand as gently as possible through the vagina , cervix uteri , and enveloping membranes , and no part of the inferior extremities , or breech , presenting itself , I examined carefully for the head of the child , as usual , but without success .
This disappointment somewhat embarrassed me .
But as the woman 's situation was become very serious by the increasing uterine haemorrhage , I attempted without delay to get at the feet .
I easily secured one of them ; but though I made use of very little force in bringing it towards the os externum , the structure was so very tender that the tibia began to give way at its superior epiphysis .
On this account I was reduced to the disagreeable neces2 sity sity of again introducing my hand into the uterus ; and as one leg had thus unexpectedly failed me , I thought it extremely futile to attempt any thing with the other .
The most eligible resource which I apprehended I had now left , was to fix a blunt hook upon one groin , and , when it was brought low enough , to assist gently at the other , with the two fore-fingers of my right hand .
By these means I happily accomplished the delivery of the remaining faetus , which proved to be a very singular kind of monster .
And as the late ingenious Mr. HEWSON injected its blood vessels , and dissected it , I am enabled to attempt a short anatomical description of it , for the satisfaction of the curious in philosophy and physiology .
This extraordinary animal production is of the size and appearance of a common twin child at its full time , excepting the particularities now to be pointed out .
When first born it was very plump , but soft and flabby , and the bones remarkably small and tender .
It has neither head , neck , hands , or arms .
In the place where the neck should originate , is a little mamilla , somewhat larger than a woman 's nipple , but quite soft .
And on each side , in the place where the arm should begin , there is a small papilla , about the bigness , and very much like the extremity , of a common quill .
The spine seems perfect , but ends abruptly at the upper vertebrae colli .
Below the navel the parts are nearly entire , except the feet , where the toes are of an irregular form and size , and some of them united together .
The external parts of generation , which indicate it a female , are also perfect .
Upon a careful inspection internally , there is evidently no brain nor spinal marrow .
A few nerves , however , are scattered about the abdomen ; but their origin , for fear of destroying the preparation , is not traced .
The uterus is perfect ; but only one ovarium could be found .
There is also the appearance of a bladder ; but it is so contracted as to have no cavity .
A large intestine arises from the anus ; is a good deal convoluted when it gets above the brim of the pelvis , and ends in a blind pouch or cul de sac , on the left side of the abdomen .
This viscus appears to be about six or seven inches in length , varies its size in different parts , gradually becomes smaller towards its superior extremity , and seems fully distended with a colourless mucus(a ) .
All above the navel is extremely defective .
There is no heart , lungs , diaphragm , stomach , liver , kidnies , spleen , pancreas , nor small intestines .
However , there are three small glands in the place of the thymus , whose substance , when examined with a microscope , Mr. HEWSON remarked , exactly resembled that of the thymus itself .
And on each side of the vena cava , just under the navel , are two little glandular substances , which seem to be somewhat like capsulae renales , only very small to what are commonly ( a ) Does not this circumstance almost amount to a proof , that the meconium , universally found in the bowels of new-born children , is nothing more than the mucus naturally secreted by the intestinal glands , mixed with bile , and perhaps a small portion of the pancreatic juice ?
In the present instance , as there is no liver there could be no bile , and consequently the meconium , if I may so call it , is colourless .
found(b ) .
There is a large artery running upon the spine , which may be called the aorta .
As this approaches the upper extremity of the little animal , it is divided into smaller and smaller branches ; and in its course it distributes lateral ones also to the contiguous parts of the trunk .
Below the navel it sends off two branches that constitute the umbilical arteries , one of which is considerably larger than the other .
And then below these , two other branches descend to the inferior extremities .
A large umbilical vein comes in at the navel , and is immediately divided into two considerable branches ; one ascending , the other descending .
Each of these is again sub-divided into smaller and smaller branches , which , as they pass upwards and downwards , seem to correspond with the different ramifications of the ascending and descending aorta .
The funis umbilicalis was only about two inches in length(c ) , and so very tender also , that it unavoidably separated near the navel of the child during the delivery .
Whether , therefore , there was any pulsation in this short funis I am not able to determine .
The placenta was not particularly examined .
( b ) Mr. HEWSON , some time before his death , seemed to be confirmed in the opinion , that whenever children are born with little or no brain , the capsulae renales are always very much diminished .
This is certainly the case in one or two almost brainless children which I have by me , and whose renal capsulae he examined , with a view of being further satisfied upon this subject .
( c ) An exactly similar circumstance to this I took particular notice of , in the delivery of another almost brainless monster .
Here are evidently in this faetus two distinct systems of vessels , arteries and veins(d ) , that carried red blood(e ) .
It is plain also , that the blood passed from the internal iliac arteries , through the hypograstrics and umbilicals to the placenta , and was returned from it by the umbilical vein to the navel , and thence distributed in the manner before observed .
But as there is no heart , nor any thing analogous to one , it becomes extremely difficult to ascertain the powers by which the circulation was carried on through this curious physiological phenomenon .
May we not however venture to advance a conjecture , that the peristaltick , or living muscular power of the arteries , was principally subservient to this important end ?
Many examples are to be met with in the collections of the curious and learned in the different parts of Europe(f ) , which ( d ) Mr. HEWSON attempted to inject the whole blood vessels by the umbilical vein as usual .
To his great surprise , no part of the injection returned by the umbilical arteries .
He could not account for this singularity at that time : but as only a part of the vessels were filled , he injected afresh by one of the hypogastric arteries .
Upon dissection afterwards , this mystery was unravelled by the heart 's being totally absent .
It then appeared also , that by the first inspection he had filled the venal system , and by the latter the arterial .
( c ) See a very curious case related by Mons. WINSLOW , in the Memoires de L'Academie des Sciences for 1740 , p. 586 .
and 604 .
Among other remarkable singularities in this little monstrous abortion of six months , that excellent anatomist particularly takes notice , that there was no appearance of one drop of red blood in any of its vessels , which were universally filled with a serous lympth ; and that there were no vestiges of any veins at all .
( f ) F. LICETUS , de Monstris , p. 300 .
et seq. PALFYN , Traite des Monstres , p. 325 .
CHESELDEN'S Anatomy , 5th ed. p. 379 .
Philosophical Transactions , 1739.40 , No 456 .
p. 303 .
Ibid. 1767 , p. 1 .
L'Academie des Sciences , Hist. which are somewhat similar to that now related .
When carefully examined , however , excepting a very few instances , they are generally found either essentially to differ , or else their structure has not been , with any tolerable precision , explained .
The present history affords also an exception to a frequent remark among authors , ` ` That brainless children are always very brisk before they are born(g ) ; ' ' for the mother has frequently told me , ` ` That she felt no motion at all within her after the first birth ; and that she had not the least suspicion of there being a second child till it was delivered .
' ' This circumstance may however , perhaps , be attributed to the medulla spinalis being totally deficient , as well as the cerebrum and cerebellum .
Physiologists and philosophers have spent a great deal of time in attempting to investigate the causes of these extraordinary phenomenon .
With this view many opinions have been started ; but most , if not all of them , as far as I am able to judge , being built upon the tottering basis of conjecture only , afford , upon an attentive inspection , but little satisfaction to a dispassionate enquirer after truth .
The particular hypothesis , which has been almost universally adopted , is , that monstrosity and marks in children depend upon the imagination and 1720 , p. 13 .
Ibid. Mem. 1720 , p. 8 .
Ibid. 1740 , p 586 .
and p. 592 .
Miscellania Curiosa Ephemeridum Germanicarum Ann. XIX .
p. 258 .
Acta Eruditorum Lipsiae , Ann. 1724 , p. 501 .
( g ) Philosophical Transactions , 1674 , No XCIX .
p. 6157 .
Ibid. 1767 , p. 18 .
longing of the mother .
Such pernicious a principle as this ought to have very rational evidence , and the most striking facts to support it .
But is it not directly the contrary ?
Indeed a great many ridiculous stories have been related to the world(b ) , which , however , upon a little reflection either obviate themselves , or else are contradicted by those facts that occur .
May we not exemplify this observation by the case of twins now related ?
One of the children was perfect , and is still living ; the other proves to be remarkably defective .
Does not the question naturally arise here , how could one child be affected by the disturbed imagination of the mother and not the other ?
But the mother , upon repeated examination , recollects no fright in particular while she was pregnant .
Neither , if she did , would it all invalidate the force of our argument upon this subject ; for she could not possibly see any child without a head : and more especially , because other parts , as the viscera and medulla spinalis , were equally defective , which are entirely out of the reach of the eye or imagination of the mother to form any idea about them .
To elucidate this point still further , can any candid person possibly suppose , that the casual agitation of mind of a pregnant woman , should either produce or destroy a whole system of blood-vessels , nerves , and fibres , which are indispensable constituents of almost every part of the ( h ) MAURICEAU , p. 53 .
Obs. 64 .
Ibid. p. 63 .
Obs. 118 .
SMELLIE'S Midwisry , vol. III .
p. 402 .
Philosophical Transactions , 1684 , No 160 .
p. 599 .
Ibid. 1739-40 , No 456 .
p. 303 .
and 306 .
body ?
And may we not adduce one proof more , in support of our argument , from what happens to animals and vegetables ?
Among these also , such extraordinary deviations from the general course of nature are by no means uncommon : yet the former are possessed of a much less share of imagination than is generally allotted to the human species ; and the latter have none at all .
Reasoning in the same manner upon several occasions of this kind in which I have been concerned , my conclusions have always been similar ; viz. that the usually assigned cause of the mother 's imagination is by no means equal to the manifold effects produced .
And on the other hand , this injurious doctrine is pregnant with continual mischief to society .
It frequently makes women very unhappy .
And the fear of mutilating or marking their infants often affects them so much , that they at last miscarry .
Having therefore indubitable facts to go upon , and the cause of humanity so powerfully coinciding with the truth , is it not right to affirm and maintain with confidence , that neither the longing nor frighted imagination of the mother appears to have any power at all to imprint marks or monstrosity upon children ?
That this is a very weak supposition , entirely void of foundation , directly contrary to all philosophy and experience , and has nothing to support it but a vulgar opinion , transmitted to us from the ages of anatomical ignorance ?
And is it not more reasonable to conclude with you , SIR , in your extensively useful lectures , that whatever be the defect or deformity in a monstrous birth , it can never be occasioned by accidents of any kind during pregnancy ; but probably has its existence always originating , causa adhuc incognita , in the first stamina of the embryo(i ) ?
Thus , SIR , I have faithfully related the particulars of this singular phenomenon among the human species , which , to a demonstration , confirms your opinion , that the nourishment of the faetus in utero is principally by means of the funis umbilicalis .
M. MERRY observes , that defective monsters are more instructive than others that have redundancies(k ) .
If this be true , here is still an ample field for speculation , notwithstanding the few very obvious remarks which I have already ventured to make .
In conformity to the general language of authors , I have in this essay occasionally adopted the use of the term monster .
There is , however , something in that word extremely repugnant to our common feelings , and very apt to leave a terrifying impression upon the mind .
Why may not the Author of Being sometimes produce variations in the human species , as well as in the animal and vegetable kingdoms(l ) , and equally exempt too from such frightful appellations ?
Would it not , therefore , be more eligible in the present instance , and every similar one , to explode the common term , and call it simply ( i ) The great baron HALLER is of opinion also , that this is evidently the case in that species of monsters to which parts are added .
Vide Opera Minora HALLERI , tom .
III .
p. 148 .
( k ) L'Academie des Sciences , Hist. 1720 , p. 13 .
( l ) See F. LICETUS .
J PALFYN des Monstres , &amp;c. in which are many instances of each kind .
a lusus naturae ; or with PLINY to say , ` ` Hoc nobis miraculum , sibi ludibrium , ingeniosa finxit natura .
' ' The peculiar share of your friendship , with which you are pleased to honour me , makes me flatter myself that you will give me credit for the truth of any facts advanced in the course of the detail , that are not irrefragably evidenced by a recourse to the preparation in its present state .
I am , &amp;c. Norfolk-street , June 6 , 1774 .

