XIII .
The supposed Effect of boiling upon Water , in disposing it to freeze more readily , ascertained by Experiments .
By Joseph Black , M. D. Professor of Chemistry at Edinburgh , in a Letter to Sir John Pringle , Bart. P. R. S. TO SIR JOHN PRINGLE , BART .
P. R. S. DEAR SIR , Edinburgh , Feb. 11 , 1775 .
WE had lately one day of a calm and clear frost ; and I immediately seized the opportunity , which I missed before , to make some experiments relative to the freezing of boiled water , in comparison with that of water not boiled .
I ordered some water to be boiled in the tea kettle four hours .
I then filled with it a Florentine flask , and immediately applied snow to the flask until I cooled it to 48~ of FAHRENHEIT , the temperature of some unboiled water which stood in my study in a bottle ; then putting four ounces of boiled , and four of the unboiled water , separately , into two equal tea cups , I exposed them on the outside of a north window , where a thermometer pointed to 29~ .
The consequence was , that ice appeared first upon the boiled water ; and this , in several repetitions of the experiment , with the same boiled water , some of which Red , Feb. 23 , which were made nine hours after it was poured out of the tea kettle .
The length of time which intervened between the first appearance of ice upon the two waters was different in the different experiments .
One cause of this variety was plainly a variation of the temperature of the air , which became colder in the afternoon , and made the thermometer descend gradually to 25~ .
Another cause was the disturbance of the water ; when the unboiled water was disturbed now and then by stirring it gently with a quill tooth-pick , the ice was formed upon it as soon , or very nearly as soon , as upon the other ; and from what I saw , I have reason to think , that were it to be stirred incessantly , provided at the same time the experiment were made with quantities of water , not much larger or deeper than these , it would begin to freeze full as soon .
In one of these trials , having inspected my tea cups when they had been an hour exposed , and finding ice upon the boiled water , and none upon the other , I gently stirred the unboiled water with my tooth-pick , and saw immediately , under my eye , fine feathers of ice formed on its surface , which quickly increased in size and number , until there was as much ice in this cup as in the other , and all of it formed in one minute of time , or two at most .
And in the rest of the trials , though the congelation began in general later in the unboiled water than in the other ; when it did begin in the former , the ice quickly increased so as , in a very short time , to equal , or nearly equal in quantity , that which had been formed more gradually in the boiled water .
The opinion , therefore , which I have formed from what I have hitherto seen is , that the boiled and common water differ from one another in this respect ; that whereas the common water , when exposed in a state of tranquillity to air that is a few degrees colder than the freezing point , may easily be cooled to the degree of such air , and still continue perfectly fluid , provided it still remain undisturbed : the boiled water , on the contrary , cannot be preserved fluid in these circumstances ; but when cooled down to the freezing point , if we attempt to make it in the least colder , a part of it is immediately changed into ice ; after which , by the continued action of the cold air upon it , more ice is formed in it every moment , until the whole of it be gradually congealed before it can become as cold as the air that surrounds it .
From this discovery it is easy to understand , why they find it necessary to boil the water in India , in order to obtain ice .
The utmost intensity of the cold which they can obtain by all the means they employ , is probably not greater than 31~ or 30~ of FAHRENHEIT'S thermometer .
Common water , left undisturbed , will easily descend to this degree without freezing ; and , if they have not the means of making it colder , may continue fluid for any time , provided it be not disturbed : the refrigerating causes of that part of the world when they have done so much , have done their utmost , and can act no further upon the water .
But this cannot happen to the boiled water ; when the refrigerating causes have cooled it to 32~ , the next effect they produce , is to occasion in it the beginning of congelation , while the the water is afterwards gradually assuming the form of ice , we know , by experience , that the temperature of it must remain at 32~ ; it cannot be made colder , so long as any considerable part of it remains unfrozen ( a ) .
The refrigerating causes continue , therefore , to have power over it , and to act upon it , and will gradually change the whole into ice , if their action be continued sufficiently long .
The next object of investigation may be the cause of this difference between the boiled and the common water .
In considering this point , the following idea was suggested .
As we know from experience , that by disturbing common water , we hasten the beginning of its congelation , or render it incapable of being cooled below 32~ , without being congealed ; may not the only difference between it and boiling water , when they are exposed together to a calm frosty air , consist in this circumstance : that the boiled water is necessarily subjected to the action of a disturbing cause , during the whole time of tis exposure , which the other is not ?
One effect of boiling water long , is to expel the air which it naturally contains ; as soon as it cools , it begins to attract and absorb air again , until it hath recovered its former quantity ; but this probably requires a considerable time .
During the whole of this time , the air entering into it must occasion an agitation or disturbance in the water , which , though not sensible to the eye , may be very effectual in ( a ) Common water , when cooled in a state of tranquillity to several degrees below the freeing point , will suddenly rise up to it again , if disturbed in such a manner as to occasion in it a beginning of congelation .
preventing it to become , in the least , colder than the freezing point , without beginning to freeze , in consequence of which its congelation must begin immediately after it is cooled to that point .
When I reflect upon this idea , I remember a fact which appears to me to support it strongly .
FAHRENHEIT was the first person who discovered that water , when preserved in tranquillity , may be cooled some degrees below the freezing point without freezing .
He made the discovery while he was endeavouring to obtain ice from water that had been purged of its air : with this intention he had put some water into little glass globes , and having purged it of air , by boiling and the air-pump , he suddenly sealed up the globes , and then exposed them to the frosty air .
He was surprised to find the water remain unfrozen much longer than he expected , when at last he opened some of his globes , in order to apply a thermometer to the water , or otherwise examine what state it was in .
The immediate consequence of the admission of the air was a sudden congelation which happened in the water ; and in the rest of his globes , a similar production of ice was occasioned by shaking them .
The inference that may be drawn from these experiments of FAHRENHEIT'S is sufficiently obvious ; it appears to me to remove all doubt with regard to the above supposition .
Before these experiments of FAHRENHEIT occurred to my memory , I had planned a few , suggested by the above supposition , that might have led to the same conclusion ; but the short duration of the frost , for one day only , did not give me time to put them in execution .

