XXXIX .
Of the electric Property of the Torpedo .
In a Letter from John Walsh , Esq ; F. R. S. to Benjamin Franklin , Esq ; LL. D. , F.R.S. , Ac .
R. Par. Soc. Ext. , &amp;c. Chesterfield-Street , July 1 , 1773 .
DEAR SIR , I Am concerned that other engagements have prevented me from giving to the Royal Society , before their recess , a complete account of my experiments on the electricity of the Torpedo ; a subject not only curious in itself , but opening a large field for interesting inquiry , both to the electrician in his walk of physics , and to all who consider , particuarly or generally , the animal oeconomy .
Read July 1 , 1773 .
To supply the deficiency in the best manner I am now able , I will request the favour of you to lay before the Society my letter from la Rochelle , of the 12th July 1772 , and such part of the letter I afterwards wrote from Paris , as relates to this subject .
Loose and imperfect as these informations are , for they were never intended for the public eye , they are still the most authentic , and so far the most satisfactory I can at present offer , since the notes I made of the experiments themselves remain nearly , I am sorry to say it , in that crude and bulky state in which you had the trouble to read them .
Letter from Mr. WALSH to Dr. FRANKLIN , dated la Rochelle , 12th July 1772 .
It is with particular satisfaction I make to you my first communication , that the effect of the Torpedo appears to be absolutely electrical ; by forming its circuit through the same conductors with electricity , for instance metals , and water ; and by being intercepted by the same non-conductors , for instance glass , and sealing-wax .
I will not at present trouble you with the detail of our experiments , especially as we are daily advancing in them ; but only observe , that we have discovered the back and breast of the animal to be in different states of electricity : I mean in particular the upper and lower surfaces of those two assemblages of pliant cylinders , of which you have seen engravings in Lorenzini * .
By the knowledge of this circumstance we have been able to direct his shocks , though they were very small , through a circuit of four persons , all feeling them ; likewise through a considerable length of wire held by two insulated persons , one touching his lower surface , and the other his upper .
When * Observazioni intorno alle Torpedini di Stef .
Lorenzini 1678 .
Redi appears to be the first who remarked these singular parts of the Torpedo in 1666 .
Franc .
Redi , Exper .
Not .
the wire was exchanged for glass , or sealing-wax , no effect could be obtained : but as soon as it was resumed , the two persons became liable to the shock .
These experiments have been varied many ways , and repeated times without number , and they all determined the choice of conductors to be the same in the Torpedo as in the Leyden Phial .
The sensations likewise , occasioned by the one and the other in the human frame , are precisely similar .
Not only the shock , but the numbing sensation which the animal sometimes dispenses , expressed in French by the words engourdissement and fourmillement , may be exactly imitated with the Phial , by means of Lane 's I lectrometer ; the regulating rod of which , to produce the latter effect , must be brought almost into contact with the prime conductor which joins the Phial .
We have not yet perceived any spark to accompany the shock , nor the pith balls to be ever affected .
Indeed all our trials have been on very feeble subjects , whose shock was seldom sensible beyond the touching finger : I remember but one , of at least two hundred , that I myself must have received , to have extended above the elbow .
Perhaps the Isle of Re , which we are about to visit , may furnish us with Torpedos fresher taken and of more vigour , by which a farther insight into these matters may be had .
Our experiments have been chiefly in the air , where the animal was more open to our examination than in water .
It is a singularity that the Torpedo , when insulated , should be able to give to us , insulated likewise , forty or fifty successive shocks from nearly the same part ; and these with little , if any diminution in their force : indeed they were all very minute .
Each effort in the animal to give the shock is conveniently accompanied with a depression of his eyes , by which even his attempts to give it to non-conductors can be observed .
The animal , with respect to the rest of his body , is in a great degree motionless , but not wholly so .
You will please to acquaint Dr. Bancroft , of our having thus verified his suspicion concerning the Torpedo * , and make any other communication of this matter you may judge proper .
Here I shall be glad to excite , as far as I am able , both electricians and naturalists , to push their inquiries concerning this extraordinary animal , whilst the summer affords them the opportunity .
' ' Extracts of a Letter from Mr. WALSH to Dr. FRANKLIN , dated Paris , 27th August , 1772 .
I spent a complete week in my experiments at the Isle of Re , and had there every convenience for prosecuting them to their extent , except that I was restrained by the jealousy of the government from making them where the animal was caught .
At my return to la Rochelle , I communicated to the members of the Academy of that place , and to many of the principal inhabitants , all that I had observed concerning the Torpedo , in the intention of stirring * Bancroft 's Natural History of Guiana , p. 194 .
up a spirit of inquiry , both as to its electricity and general oeconomy .
The vigour of the fresh taken Torpedos at the Isle of Re , was not able to force the torpedinal fluid across the minutest tract of air ; not from one link of a small chain , suspended freely , to another ; not through an almost invisible separation , made by the edge of a penknife , in a slip of tinsoil pasted on sealing-wax .
The spark therefore ( of course the attendant snapping noise ) was denied to all our attempts to discover it , not only in day-light , but in complete darkness .
I observed to you , in my last , the singularity of the Torpedo being able , when insulated , to give to an insulated person a great number of successive shocks : in this situation I have taken no less than fifty from him in the space of a minute and an half .
All our experiments confirmed , that his electricity was condensed , in the instant of its explosion , by a sudden energy of the animal ; and as there was no gradual accumulation , nor retention of it , as in the case of charged glass , it is not at all surprising that no signs of attraction or repulsion were perceived in the pith balls .
In short , the effect of the Torpedo appears to arise from a compressed elastic fluid , restoring itself to its equilibrium in the same way , and by the same mediums , as the elastic fluid compressed in charged glass .
The skin of the animal , bad conductor as it is , seems to be a better conductor of his electricity , than the thinest plate of elastic air .
Notwithstanding the weak spring of the torpedinal electricity , I was able able , in the public exhibitions of my experiments at la Rochelle , to convey it through a circuit , formed from one surface of the animal to the other , by two long brass wires , and four persons , which number , at times , was increased even to eight .
The several persons were made to communicate with each other , and the two outermost with the wires , by means of water contained in besins , properly disposed between them for the purpose ; each person dipping his hands in the nearest basins , connectively with his neigbour on either side .
` ` The effect produced by the Torpedo , when in air , appeared , on many repeated experiments , to be about four times as strong as when in water .
' ' A clear and succinct narrative of what passed at one of the public exhibitions , alluded to in the last letter , appeared in the French Gazette of the 30th October 1772 .
As it came from a very respectable quarter , not less so from the private character of the gentleman , than from the public offices he held , I must desire leave of the Society to avail myself of such a testimony to the facts I have advanced , by giving a translation of that narrative .
Extract of a Letter from the Sieu~ SEIGNETTE , Mayor of la Rochelle , and second perpetual Secretary of the Academy of that City , to the publisher of the French Gazette .
In the Gazette of the 14th August , you mentioned the discovery made by Mr. Walsh , Member ber of the parliament of England , and of the Royal Society of London .
The experiment , of which I am going to give you an account , was made in the presence of the Academy of this city .
A live Torpedo was placed on a table .
Round another table stood five persons insulated .
Two brass wires , each thirteen feet long , were suspended to the ceiling by silken strings .
One of these wires rested by one end on the wet napkin on which the fish lay ; the other end was immersed in a basin full of water placed on the second table , on which stood four other basins likewise full of water .
The first person put a finger of one hand in the basin in which the wire was immersed , and a finger of the other hand in the second basin .
The second person put a finger of one hand in this last basin , and a finger of the other hand in the third ; and so on successively , till the five persons communicated with one another by the water in the basins .
In the last basin one end of the second wire was immersed ; and with the other end Mr. Walsh touched the back of the Torpedo , when the five persons felt a commotion which differed in nothing from that of the Leyden experiment , except in the degree of force .
Mr. Walsh , who was not in the circle of conduction , received no shock .
This experiment was repeated several times , even with eight persons ; and always with the same success .
The action of the Torpedo is communicated by the same mediums as that of the electric fluid .
The bodies which intercept the action of the one , intercept likewise the action of the other .
The effects produced by the Torpedo resemble in every respect a weak electricity .
' ' This exhibition of the electric powers of the Torpedo , before the Academy of La Rochelle , was at a meeting , held for the purpose in my apartments , on the 22d July 1772 , and stands registered in the journals of the Academy .
The effect of the animal was , in these experiments , transmitted through as great an extent and variety of conductors as almost at any time we had been able to obtain it , and the experiments included , nearly , all the points , in which its analogy with the effect of the Leyden Phial had been observed .
These points were stated to the gentlemen present , as were the circumstances in which the two effects appeared to vary .
It was likewise represented to them , That our experiments had been almost wholly with the animal in air : That its action in water was a capital desideratum : That indeed all as yet done was little more than opening the door to inquiry : That much remained to be examined by the Electrician as well as by the Anatomist : That as artificial electricity had thrown light on the natural operation of the Torpedo , this might in return , if well considered , throw light on artificial electricity , particularly in those respects in which they now seemed to differ : That for me , I was about to take leave of the animal , as nature had denied it to the British seas ; and that the prosecution of these researches rested in a particular manner with them , whose shores abounded with it .
The Torpedo , on this occasion , dispensed only the distinct , instantaneous stroke , so well known by the name of the electric shock .
That protracted but lighter sensation , that Torpor or Numbness which he at times induces , and from which he takes his name , was not then experienced from the animal ; but it was imitated with artificial electricity , and shown to be producible by a quick consecution of minute shocks .
This , in the Torpedo , may perhaps be effected by the successive discharge of his numerous cylinders , in the nature of a running fire of musketry : the strong single shock may be his general volley .
In the continued effect , as well as in the instantaneous , his eyes , usually prominent , are withdrawn into their sockets .
The same experiments , performed with the same Torpedos , were on the two succeeding days repeated before numerous companies of the principal inhabitants of La Rochelle .
Besides the pleasure of gratifying the curiosity of such as entertained any on the subject , and the desire I had to excite a prosecution of the inquiry , I certainly wished to give all possible notoriety to facts , which might otherwise be deemed improbable , perhaps by some of the first rank in science .
Great authorities had given a sanction to other solutions of the phenomenon of the Torpedo ; and even the Electrician might not readily listen to assertions , which seemed , in some respects , to combat the general principles of electricity .
I had reason to make such conclusions from different conversations I had held on the subject with eminent persons both at London and Paris .
It is but justice to say , that of all in that class you gave me the greatest encouragement to look for success in this research , and even assisted me in forming hypotheses , how the Torpedo , supposed to be endued with electric properties , might use them in so conducting an element as water .
After generally recommending to others an examination of the electric powers of these animals when acting in water , I determined , before I took my final leave of them , to make some farther experiments myself with that particular view ; since , notwithstanding the familiarity in which we may be said to have lived with them for near a month , we had never detected them in the immediate exercise of their electric faculties against other fish , confined with them in the same water , either in the circumstance of attacking their prey , or defending themselves from annoyance : and yet that they possessed such a power , and exercised it in a state of liberty , could not be doubted .
A large Torpedo , very liberal of his shocks , being held with both hands by his electric organs above and below , was briskly plunged into water to the depth of a foot , and instantly raised an equal height into air ; and was thus continually plunged and raised , as quick as possible , for the space of a minute .
In the instant his lower surface touched the water in his descent , he always gave a violent shock , and another still more violent in the instant of quitting the water in his ascent ; both which shocks , but particularly the last , were accompanied with a writhing in his body , as if meant to force an escape : Besides these two shocks from the surface of the water , which may yet be considered as delivered in the air , he constantly gave at least two , when wholly in the air , and constantly one and sometimes two , when wholly in the water .
The shocks in water appeared , as far as sensation could decide , not to have near a fourth of the force of those at the surface of the water , nor much more than a fourth of those entirely in air .
The shocks received in a certain time were not , on this occasion , counted by a watch , as they had been on a former , when fifty were delivered , in a minute and a half , by the animal in an insulated and unagitated state : But from the quickness , with which the immersions were made , it may be presumed there were full twenty of these in a minute ; from whence the number of shocks , in that time , must have amounted to above an hundred .
This experiment , therefore , while it discovered the comparative force between a shock in water and one in air , and between a shock delivered with greater exertion on the part of the animal and one with less , seemed to determine , that the charge of his organs with electricity was effected in an instant , as well as the discharge .
The Torpedo was then put into a flat basket , open at top , but secured by a net with wide meshes , and , in this confinement , was let down into the water , about a foot below the surface ; being there touched , through the meshes , with only a single finger , on one of his electric organs , while the other hand was held , at a distance , in the water , he gave shocks , which were distinctly felt in both hands .
The circuit for the passage of the effect being contracted to the finger and thumb of one hand , applied above and below to a single organ , produced a shock , to our sensation , of twice the force of that in the larger circuit by the arms .
The Torpedo , still confined in the basket , being raised to within three inches of the surface of the water , was there touched with a short iron bolt , which was held , half above and half in the water , by one hand , while the other hand was dipped , as before , at a distance in the water ; and strong shocks , felt in both hands , were thus obtained through the iron .
A wet hempen cord being fastened to the iron bolt , was held in the hand above water , while the bolt touched the Torpedo ; and shocks were obtained through both those substances .
A less powerful Torpedo , suspended in a small net , being frequently dipped into water and raised again , gave , from the surface of the water , slight shocks through the net to the person holding it .
These experiments in water manifested , That bodies , immersed in that element , might be affected by immediate contact with the Torpedo ; That the shorter the circuit in which the electricity tricity moved , the greater would be the effect ~ And that the shock was communicable , from the animal in water , to persons in air , through some substances .
How far harpoons and nets , consisting of wood and hemp , could in like circumstances , as it has been frequently asserted , convey the effect~ was not so particularly tried as to enable us to confirm it .
I mention the omission in the hope that some one may be induced to determine the point by express trial .
We convinced ourselves , on former occasions , that the accurate Kaempfer * , who so well describes the effect of the Torpedo , and happily compares it with lightning , was deceived in the circumstance , that it could be avoided by holding in the breath , which we found no more to prevent the shock of the Torpedo , when he was disposed to give it , than it would prevent the shock of the Leyden Phial .
Several persons , forming as many distinct circuits , can be affected by one stroke of the animal , as well as when joined in a single circuit .
For instance , four persons , touching separately his upper and lower surfaces , were all affected ; two persons likewise , after the electricity had passed through a wire into a basin of water , transmitted it from thence , in two distinct channels , as their sensation convinced them , into another basin of water , from whence it was conducted , probably in an united state , by a single wire .
How * Kaempf .
~ .
Exot .
1712 , p. 514 .
much further the effect might be thus divided and subdivided into different channels , was not determined ; but it was found to be proportionably weakened by multiplying these circuits , as it had been by extending the single circuit .
Something may be expected to be said of the parts of the animal immediately concerned in producing the electrical effect .
The engraving , which accompanies this letter , while it shows the general figure of the Torpedo , gives an internal view of his electric organs .
The Society will , besides , have a full anatomical description of these parts from the ingenious Mr. John Hunter , in a paper he has expressly written on the subject at my request .
It would therefore be superfluous for me to say any thing either in regard to their situation or structure .
I have to observe , however , That in these double organs resides the electricity of the Torpedo , the rest of his body appearing to be no otherwise concerned in his electrical effect than as conducting it : That they are subject to the will of the animal ; but whether , like other double parts so controlable , they are exercised , at times , singly as well as in concert , is difficult to be ascertained by experiment : That their upper and under surfaces are capable , from a state of equilibrium with respect to electricity , of being instantly thrown , by a mere energy , into an opposition of a plus and minus state , like that of the charged Phial : That , when they are thus charged , the upper surfaces of the two are in the same state of electricity ; as are the under surfaces of the two , though in a contrary to that of the upper ; for no shock can be obtained by an insulated person touching both organs above , or both below : And that the production of the effect depends solely on an intercourse being made between the opposite surfaces of the organs , whether taken singly or jointly .
All the parts bordering on the organs act , more or less , as conductors , either through their substance or by their superficies .
While an insulated person , placing two fingers on the same surface of one or both organs , cannot be affected ; if he removes one of his fingers to any such contiguous part , he will be liable to a shock : but this shock will not be near , perhaps not half , so violent , as one taken immediately between the opposite surfaces of the organ ; which shows the conduction to be very imperfect .
The parts , which conduct the best , are the two great lateral fins bounding the organs outwardly , and the space lying between the two organs inwardly .
All below the double transverse cartilages scarcely conduct at all , unless when the fish is just taken out of water and is still wet , the mucus , with which he is lubricated , showing itself , as it dries , to be of an insulating nature .
The organs themselves , when uncharged , appeared to be , not interiorly we might suppose , but rather exteriorly , conductors of a shock .
An insulated person touching two Torpedos , lying near one another on a damp table , with fingers placed , one on the organ of one fish , and another on the organ of the other , was sensible of shocks , sometimes delivered by one fish , and sometimes by the other , as might be discovered by the respective winking of their eyes .
That the organs , uncharged , served some way or other as conductors , was confirmed with artificial electricity , in passing shocks by them ; and in taking sparks from them , when electrified .
The electric effect was never perceived by us to be attended with any motion or alteration in the organs themselves , but was frequently accompanied with a little transient agitation along the cartilages which surround both organs : this is not discernible in the plump and turgid state of the animal , while he is fresh and vigorous ; but as his force decays , from the relaxation of his muscles , his cartilages appear through the skin , and then the slight action along them is discovered .
May we not from all these premises conclude , that the effect of the Torpedo proceeds from a modification of the electric fluid ?
The Torpedo resembles the charged Phial in that characteristic point of a reciprocation between its two surfaces .
Their effects are transmitted by the same mediums ; than which there is not perhaps a surer criterion to determine the identity of subtle matter : They , besides , occasion the same impression on our nerves .
Like effects have like causes .
But it may be objected , that the effects of the Torpedo , and of the charged Phial , are not similar in all their circumstances ; that the charged Phial occasions attractive or repulsive dispositions in neighbouring bodies ; and that its discharge is obtained through a portion of air , and is accompanied with light and sound ; nothing of which occurs with respect to the Torpedo .
The inaction of the electricity of the animal in these particulars , whilst its elastic force is so great as to transmit the effect through an extensive circuit and in its course to communicate a shock , may be a new phenomenon , but is no ways repugnant to the laws of electricity ; for here too , the operations of the animal may be imitated by art .
The same quantity of electric matter , according as it is used in a dense or rare state , will produce the different consequences .
For example , a small Phial , whose coated surface measures only six square inches , will , on being highly charged , contain a dense electricity capable of forcing a passage through an inch of air , and afford the phenomenon of light , sound , attraction , and repulsion .
But if the quantity condensed in this Phial , be made rare by communicating it to three large connected jars , whose coated surfaces shall form together an area 400 times larger than that of the Phial ( I instance these jars because they are such as I use ) ; it will , thus dilated , yield all the negative phenomenon , if I may so call them , of the Torpedo ; it will not now pass the hundredth part of that inch of air , which in its condensed state it sprung through with ease ; it will now refuse the minute intersection in the strip of tinfoil ; the spark and its attendant sound , even the attraction or repulsion of light bodies , will now be wanting ; nor will a point brought however near , if not in contact , be able to draw off the charge : and yet , with this diminished elasticity , the electric matter will , to effect its equilibrium , instantly run through a considerable circuit of different conductors , perfectly continuous , and make us sensible of an impulse in its passage .
Let me here remark , that the sagacity of Mr. Cavendish in devising and his address in executing electrical experiments , led him the first to experience with artificial electricity , that a shock could be received from a charge which was unable to force a passage through the least space of air .
But , after the discovery that a large area of rare electricity would imitate the effect of the Torpedo , it may be inquired , where is this large area to be found in the animal ?
We here approach to that veil of nature , which man cannot remove .
This , however , we know , that from infinite division of parts infinite surface may arise , and even our gross optics tell us , that those singular organs , so often mentioned , consist like our electric batteries of many vessels , call them cylinders or hexagonal prisms , whose superficies taken together furnish a considerable area .
I rejoice in addressing these communications to You .
He , who predicted and showed that electricity wings the formidable bolt of the atmosphere , will hear with attention , that in the deep it speeds an humbler bolt , silent and invisible : He , who analysed the electrified Phial , will hear with pleasure that its laws prevail in animate Phials : He , who by Reason became an electrician , will hear with reverence of an instinctive electrician , gifted in his birth with a wonderful apparatus , and with the skill to use it .
However I may respect your talents as an electrician , it is certainly for knowledge of more general import , that I am impressed with that high esteem , with which I remain , Dear Sir , Your affectionate and obedient servant , John Walsh .
EXPLANATION of the PLATE OFTHE Male and Female Torpedo , or Electric Ray .
TA B. XIX .
FI G. I. A view of the under surface of the female .
a. An exposure , on flaying off the skin , of the right electric organ , which consists of white plaint columns , in a close and for the most part hexagonal arrangement , giving the general appearance of a honey-comb in miniature .
These columns have been sometimes denominated cylinders ; but , having no interstices , they are all angular , and chiefly six-cornered .
b. The skin which covered the organ , showing on its inward side an hexagonal net work .
c. The nostrils in the form of a crescent .
d. The mouth in a crescent contrary to that of the nostrils , furnished with several rows of very small hooked teeth .
e. The branchial apertures , five on each side .
f. The place of the heart .
g. g. g. The place of the two anterior transverse cartilages , which , passing one above and the other below the spine , support the diaphragm , and uniting towards their extremities , form on either side a kind of clavicle and scapula .
h. h. The outward margin of the great lateral fin .
i. i. Its inner margin , confining with the electric organ .
k. The articulation of the great lateral fin with the scapula .
l. The abdomen .
m. m. m. The place of the posterior transverse cartilage which is single , united with the spine , and supports on each side the smaller lateral fins .
n. n. The two smaller lateral fins .
n. n. o. The anus .
p. The fin of the tail .
FI G. II .
A view of the upper surface of the female .
a. a. An exposure of the upper part of the right electric organ .
b. The skin which covered the organ .
c. The eyes , prominent and looking horizontally outwards , but capable of being occasionally withdrawn into their sockets .
d. Two circular apertures communicating with the mouth , and furnished each with a membrane , which in air , as well as in water , plays regularly backwards and forwards across the aperture in the office of inspiration .
e. The place of the right branchia .
f. The two fins of the back .
g. g. The place of the anterior transverse cartilages .
FI G. III .
A view of the under surface of the male , whose size , as here represented , is , in general , smaller than that of the female .
a. a. Two appendices , distinguishing the male species .
The Male &amp; Female TORPEDO or ELECTRIC frequenting the sea shores in the Neighbourhood of LA Fig. 1 .
Fig. 3 .
Under surface of the Female ?
Under surface of the Male , ~ bah which is generally smaller than the Female .
d e e f g gg k l h mmm nn nn aa p TRIC RAY , of LA ROCHELLE .
Philos Trans. Vol. LXIII .
Tab. XIX .
p. 480 .
Fig. 2 .
Upper surface of the Female .
a b f ~ .
Roberts sculpsit .

