XXXI .
Experiments and Observations on the Singing of Birds , by the Hon. Daines Bar rington , Vice Pres. R. S. In a Letter to Matthew Maty , M. D. Sec. R. S. Read April 22 , May 6 , and May 13 , 1773 .
January 10 , 1773 .
DEARSI R , AS the experiments and observations I mean to lay before the Royal Society relate to the singing of birds , which is a subject that hath never before been scientifically treated of * , it may not be improper to prefix an explanation of some uncommon terms , which I shall be obliged to use , as well as others which I have been under a necessity of coining .
To chirp , is the first sound which a young bird utters , as a cry for food , and is different in all nestlings , if accurately attended to ; so that the hearer may distinguish of what species the birds are , though the nest may hang out of his sight and reach .
* Kircher , indeed , in his Musurgia , hath given us some few passages in the song of the nightingale , as well as the call of a quail and ~uckow , which he hath engraved in musical characters .
These instances , however , only prove that some birds have in their song , notes which correspond with the intervals of our common scale of the musical octave .
This This cry is , as might be expected , very weak and querulous ; it is dropped entirely as the bird grows stronger , nor is afterwards intermixed with its song , the chirp of a nightingale ( for example ) being hoarse and disagreeable .
To this definition of the chirp , I must add , that it consists of a single sound , repeated at very short intervals , and that it is common to nestlings of both sexes .
The call of a bird , is that sound which it is able to make , when about a month old ; it is , in most instances ( which I happen to recollect ) , a repetition of one and the same note , is retained by the bird as long as it lives , and is common , generally , to both the cock and hen * .
The next stage in the notes of a bird is termed , by the bird-catchers , recording , which word is probably derived from a musical instrument , formerly used in England , called a recorder ~ .
This attempt in the nestling to sing , may be compared to the imperfect endeavour in a child to babble .
I have known instances of birds beginning to record when they were not a month old .
* For want of terms to distinguish the notes of birds , Bellon applies the verb chantent , or sing , to the goose and crane , as well as the nightingale .
` ` Plusieurs oiseaux chantent la nuit , comme est l'oye , la grue , &amp; le rossignol .
' ' Bellon 's Hist. of Birds , p. 50 .
~ It seems to have been a species of flute , and was probably used to teach young birds to pipe tunes .
Lord Bacon describes this instrument to have been strait , to have had a lesser and greater bore , both above and below , to have required very little breath from the blower , and to have had what he calls a fipple , or stopper .
See his second Century of Experiments .
This first essay does not seem to have the least rudiments of the future song ; but as the bird grows older and stronger , one may begin to perceive what the nestling is aiming at .
Whilst the scholar is thus endeavouring to form his song , when he is once sure of a passage , he commonly raises his tone , which he drops again when he is not equal to what he is attempting ; just as a singer raises his voice , when he not only recollects certain parts of a tune with precision , but knows that he can execute them .
What the nestling is not thus thoroughly master of , he hurries over , lowering his tone , as if he did not wish to be heard , and could not yet satisfy himself .
I have never happened to meet with a passage in any writer , which seems to relate to this stage of singing in a bird , except , perhaps , in the following lines of Statius : -Nunc volucrum novi Questus , inexpertumque carmen , Quod tacita statuere bruma .
' ' Stat. Sylv. L. iv .
Ecl .
5 .
A young bird commonly continues to record for ten or eleven months , when he is able to execute every part of his song , which afterwards continues fixed , and is scarcely ever altered .
When the bird is thus become perfect in his lesson , he is said to sing his song round , or in all its varieties of passages , which he connects together , and executes without a pause .
I would therefore define a bird 's song to be a succession of three or more different notes , which are continued without interruption during the same interval with a musical bar of four crotchets in an adagio movement , or whilst a pendulum swings four seconds .
By the first requisite in this definition , I mean to exclude the call of a cuckoo , or clucking of a hen * , as they consist of only two notes ; whilst the short bursts of singing birds , contending with each other ( called jerks by the bird-catchers ) , are equally distinguished from what I term song , by their not continuing for four seconds .
As the notes of a cuckoo and hen , therefore , though they exceed what I have defined the call of a bird to be , do not amount to its song , I will , for this reason , take the liberty of terming such a succession of two notes as we hear in these birds , the varied call .
Having thus settled the meaning of certain words , which I shall be obliged to make use of , I shall now proceed to state some general principles with regard to the singing of birds , which seem to result from the experiments I have been making for several years , and under a great variety of circumstances .
Notes in birds are no more innate , than language is in man , and depend entirely upon the master under which they are bred , as far as their organs will enable them to imitate the sounds which they have frequent opportunities of hearing .
* The common hen , when she lays , repeats the same note very often , and concludes with the sixth above , which she holds for a longer time .
1 Most of the experiments I have made on this subject have been made with cock linnets , which were fledged and nearly able to leave their nest , on account not only of this bird 's docility , and great powers of imitation , but because the cock is easily distinguished from the hen at that early period , by the superior whiteness in the wing * .
In many other sorts of singing birds the male is not at the age of three weeks so certainly known from the female ; and if the pupil turns out to be a hen , ibi omnis Effusus labor .
' ' The Greek poets made a songster of the ~ , whatever animal that may be , and it is remarkable that they observed the female was incapable of singing as well as hen birds : ~ , ~ ; Comicorum Graecorum Sententiae , p. 452 .
Ed. Steph .
I have indeed known an instance or two of a hen 's making out something like the song of her species ; but these are as rare as the common hen 's being heard to crow .
I rather suspect also , that those parrots , magpies , &amp;c. which either do not speak at all , or very little , are hens of those species .
* The white reaches almost to the shaft of the quill feathers , and in the hen does not exceed more than half .
I have educated nestling linnets under the three best singing larks , the skylark , woodlark , and titlark , every one of which , instead of the linnet 's song , adhered entirely to that of their respective instructors .
When the note of the titlark-linnet * was thoroughly fixed , I hung the bird in a room with two common linnets , for a quarter of a year , which were full in song ; the titlark-linnet , however , did not borrow any passages from the linnet 's song , but adhered steadfastly to that of the titlark .
I had some curiosity to find out whether an European nestling would equally learn the note of an African bird : I therefore educated a young linnet under a vengolina ~ , which imitated its African master so exactly , without any mixture of the linnet song , that it was impossible to distinguish the one from the other .
This vengolina-linnet was absolutely perfect , without ever uttering a single note by which it could have been known to be a linnet .
In some of my other experiments , however , the nestling linnet retained the call of its own species , or what the bird* I thus call a bird which sings notes he would not have learned in a wild state ; thus by a skylark-linnet .
I mean a linnet with the skylark song ; a nightingale robin , a robin with the nightingale song , &amp;c. ~ This bird seems not to have been described by any of the ornithologists ; it is of the finch tribe , and about the same size with our aberdavine ( or siskin ) .
The colours are grey and white , and the cock hath a bright yellow spot upon the rump .
It is a very familiar bird , and sings better than any of those which are not European , except the American mocking bird .
catchers term the linnet 's chuckle , from some resemblance to that word when pronounced .
I have before stated , that all my nestling linnets were three weeks old , when taken from the nest ; and by that time they frequently learn their own call from the parent birds , which I have mentioned to consist of only a single note .
To be certain , therefore , that a nestling will not have even the call of its species , it should be taken from the nest when only a day or two old ; because , though nestlings cannot see till the seventh day , yet they can hear from the instant they are hatched , and probably , from that circumstance , attend to sounds , more than they do afterwards , especially as the call of the parents announces the arrival of their food .
I must own , that I am not equal myself , nor can I procure any person to take the trouble of breeding up a bird of this age , as the odds against its being reared are almost infinite .
The warmth indeed of incubation may be , in some measure , supplied by cotton and fires ; but these delicate animals require , in this state , being fed almost perpetually , whilst the nourishment they receive should not only be prepared with great attention , but given in very small portions at a time .
Though I must admit , therefore , that I have never reared myself a bird of so tender an age , yet I have happened to see both a linnet and a goldfinch which were taken from their nests when only two or three days old .
The first of these belonged to Mr. Matthews , an apothecary at Kensington , which , from a want of other sounds to imitate , almost articulated the words pretty boy , as well as some other short sentences : I heard the bird myself repeat the words pretty boy ; and Mr. Matthews assured me , that he had neither the note or call of any bird whatsoever .
This talking linnet died last year , and many people went from London to hear him speak .
The goldfinch I have before mentioned , was reared in the town of Knighton in Radnorshire , which I happened to hear , as I was walking by the house where it was kept .
I thought indeed that a wren was singing ; and I went into the house to inquire after it , as that little bird seldom lives long in a cage .
The people of the house , however , told me , that they had no bird but a goldfinch , which they conceived to sing its own natural note , as they called it ; upon which I staid a considerable time in the room , whilst its notes were merely those of a wren , without the least mixture of goldfinch .
On further inquiries , I found that the bird had been taken from the nest when only two or three days old , that it was hung in a window which was opposite to a small garden , whence the nestling had undoubtedly acquired the notes of the wren , without having had any opportunity of learning even the call of the goldfinch .
These facts which I have stated seem to prove very decisively , that birds have not any innate ideas of the notes which are supposed to be peculiar to each species .
But it will possibly be asked , why in a wild state they adhere so steadily to the same song , in so much that it is is well known , before the bird is heard , what notes you are to expect from him .
This , however , arises entirely from the nestling 's attending only to the instruction of the parent bird , whilst it disregards the notes of all others , which may perhaps be singing round him .
Young Canary-birds are frequently reared in a room where there are many other sorts ; and yet I have been informed that they only learn the song of the parent cock .
Every one knows , that the common house-sparrow , when in a wild state , never does any thing but chirp : this , however , does not arise from want of powers in this bird to imitate others ; but because he only attends to the parental note .
But , to prove this decisively , I took a common Sparrow from the nest when it was fledged , and educated him under a linnet : the bird , however , by accident heard a goldfinch also , and his song was , therefore , a mixture of the linnet and goldfinch .
I have tried several experiments , in order to observe from what circumstances birds fix upon any particular note when taken from the parents ; but cannot settle this with any sort of precision , any more than at what period of their recording they determine upon the song to which they will adhere .
I educated a young robin under a very fine Nightingale ; which , however , began already to be out of song , and was perfectly mute in less than a fortnight .
This robin afterwards sung three parts in four nightingale ; and the rest of his song was what the bird ~ catchers call rubbish , or no particular note whatsoever .
I hung this robin nearer to the nightingale than to any other bird ; from which first experiment I conceived , that the scholar would imitate the master which was at the least distance from him .
From several other experiments , however , which I have since tried , I find it to be very uncertain what notes the nestling will most attend to , and often their song is a mixture ; as in the instance which I before stated of the sparrow .
I must own also , that I conceived , from the experiment of educating the robin under a nightingale , that the scholar would fix upon the note which it first heard when taken from the nest ; I imagined likewise , that , if the nightingale had been fully in song , the instruction for a fortnight would have been sufficient .
I have , however , since tried the following experiment , which convinces me , so much depends upon circumstances , and perhaps caprice in the scholar , that no general inference , or rule , can be laid down with regard to either of these suppositions .
I educated a nestling robin under a woodlark-linnet , which was full in song , and hung very near to him for a month together : after which , the robin was removed to another house , where he could only hear a skylark-linnet .
The consequence was that the nestling did not sing a note of woodlark ( though I afterwards hung him again just above the wood-lark-linnet ) but adhered entirely to the song of the skylark-linnet .
Having Having thus stated the result of several experiments , which were chiefly intended to determine , whether birds had any innate ideas of the notes , or song , which is supposed to be peculiar to each species , I shall now make some general observations on their singing ; though perhaps the subject may appear to many a very minute one .
Every poet , indeed , speaks with raptures of the harmony of the groves ; yet those even , who have good musical ears , seem to pay little attention to it , but as a pleasing noise .
I am also convinced ( though it may seem rather paradoxical ) , that the inhabitants of London distinguish more accurately , and know more on this head , than of all the other parts of the island taken together .
This seems to arise from two causes .
The first is , that we have not more musical ideas which are innate , than we have of language ; and therefore those even , who have the happiness to have organs which are capable of receiving a gratification from this sixth sense ( as it hath been called by some ) require , however , the best instruction .
The orchestra of the opera , which is confined to the metropolis , hath diffused a good stile of playing over the other bands of the capital , which is , by degrees , communicated to the fiddler and ballad-singer in the streets ; the organs in every church , as well as those of the Savoyards , contribute likewise to this improvement of musical faculties in the Londoners .
If the singing of the ploughman in the country is therefore compared with that of the London blackV O L. LXIII .
Mm guard , guard , the superiority is infinitely on the side of the latter ; and the same may be observed in comparing the voice of a country girl and London house-maid , as it is very uncommon to hear the former sing tolerably in tune .
I do not mean by this , to assert that the inhabitants of the country are not born with as good musical organs ; but only , that they have not the same opportunities of learning from others , who play in tune themselves .
The other reason for the inhabitants of London judging better in relation to the song of birds , arises from their hearing each bird sing distinctly , either in their own or their neighbours shops ; as also from a bird continuing much longer in song whilst in a cage , than when at liberty ; the cause of which I shall endeavour hereafter to explain .
Those who live in the country , on the other hand , do not hear birds sing in their woods for above two months in the year , when the confusion of notes prevents their attending to the song of any particular bird ; nor does he continue long enough in a place , for the hearer to recollect his notes with accuracy .
Besides this , birds in the spring sing very loud indeed ; but they only give short jerks , and scarcely ever the whole compass of their song .
For these reasons , I have never happened to meet with any person , who had not resided in London , whose judgement or opinion on this subject I could the least rely upon ; and a stronger proof of this cannot be given , than that most people , who keep Canary nary-birds do not know that they sing chiefly either the titlark , or nightingale notes * .
Nothing , however , can be more marked than the note of a nightingale called its jug , which most of the Canary-birds brought from the Tyrol commonly have , as well as several nightingale strokes , or particular passages in the song of that bird .
I mention this superior knowledge in the inhabitants of the capital , because I am convinced , that , if others are consulted in relation to the singing of birds , they will only mislead , instead of giving any material or useful information ~ .
Birds in a wild state do not commonly sing above ten weeks in the year ; which is then also confined to the cocks of a few species ; I conceive , that this last *I once saw two of these birds which came from the Canary islands ; neither of which had any song at all ; and I have been informed , that a ship brought a great many of them not long since , which sung as little .
Most of those Canary-birds , which are imported from the Tyrol , have been educated by parents , the progenitor of which was instructed by a nightingale ; our English Canary-birds have commonly more of the titlark note .
The traffic in these birds makes a small article of commerce , as four Tyroleze generally bring over to England sixteen hundred every year ; and though they carry them on their backs one thousand miles , as well as pay 20~ .
duty for such a number , yet upon the whole it answers to sell these birds at 5s .
a piece .
The chief place for breeding Canary-birds is Inspruck and its environs , from whence they are sent to Constantinople , as well as every part of Europe .
~ As it will not answer to catch birds with clap-nets any where but in the neighbourhood of London , most of the birds which may be heard in a country town are nestlings , and consequently cannot sing the supposed natural song in any perfection .
circumstance arises from the superior strength of the muscles of the larynx .
I procured a cock nightingale , a cock and hen blackbird , a cock and hen rook , a cock linnet , as also a cock and hen chaffinch , which that very eminent anatomist , Mr. Hunter , F. R. S. was so obliging as to dissect for me , and begged , that he would particularly attend to the state of the organs in the different birds , which might be supposed to contribute to singing .
Mr. Hunter found the muscles of the larynx to be stronger in the nightingale than in any other bird of the same size ; and in all those instances ( where he dissected both cock and hen ) that the same muscles were stronger in the cock .
I sent the cock and hen rook , in order to see whether there would be the same difference in the cock and hen of a species which did not sing at all .
Mr. Hunter , however , told me , that he had not attended so much to their comparative organs of voice , as in the other kinds ; but that , to the best of his recollection , there was no difference at all .
Strength , however , in these muscles , seems not to be the only requisite ; the birds must have also great plenty of food , which seems to be proved sufficiently by birds in a cage singing the greatest part of the year , when the wild ones do not ( as I observed before ) continue in song above ten weeks .
The food of singing birds consists of plants , insects , or seeds , and of the two first of these there is infinitely the greatest profusion in the spring .
As for seeds , which are to be met with only in the autumn , I think they cannot well find any great quantities of them in a country so cultivated as England is ; for the seeds in meadows are destroyed by mowing ; in pastures , by the bite of the cattle ; and in arable , by the plough , when most of them are buried too deep for the bird to reach them * .
I know well that the singing of the cock-bird in the spring is attributed by many ~ to the motive only of pleasing its mate during incubation .
Those , however , who suppose this , should recollect , that much the greater part of birds do not sing at all : why should their mate therefore be deprived of this solace and amusement ?
The bird in a cage , which , perhaps , sings nine or ten months in a year , cannot do so from this inducement ; and , on the contrary , it arises chiefly from contending with another bird , or indeed against almost any sort of continued noise .
Superiority in song gives to birds a most amazing ascendency over each other ; as is well known to the bird-catchers by the fascinating power of their callbirds , which they contrive should moult prematurely for this purpose .
But , to show decisively that the singing of a bird in the spring does not arise from any attention to its mate , a very experienced catcher of nightingales hath informed me , that some of these birds have jerked the instant they were caught .
He hath also brought * The plough indeed may turn up some few seeds , which may still be in an eatable state .
~ See , amongst others , M. de Buffon , in his lately-published ~ .
to me a nightingale , which had been but a few hours in a cage , and which burst forth in a roar of song .
At the same time this bird is so sulky on its first confinement , that he must be crammed for sever or eight days , as he will otherwise not feed himself : it is also necessary to tie his wings , to prevent his killing himself against the top or sides of the cage .
I believe there is no instance of any bird 's singing which exceeds our blackbird in size ; and possibly this may arise from the difficulty of its concealing itself , if it called the attention of its enemies , not only by bulk , but by the proportionable loudness of its notes * .
I should rather conceive , it is for the same reason that no hen-bird sings , because this talent would be still more dangerous during incubation ; which may possibly also account for the inferiority in point of plumage .
I shall now consider how far the singing of birds resembles our known musical intervals , which are never marked more minutely than to half notes ; because , though we can form every gradation from half-note to half-note , by drawing the finger gently over the string of a violin , or covering by degrees the hole of a flute ; yet we cannot produce such a minute interval at command , when a quarter-note for example might be required .
Ligon , indeed , in his history of Barbadoes , hath the following passage : ` ` The next bird is of the co* For the same reason , most large birds are wilder than the smaller ones .
lour lour of the fieldfare ; but the head is too large for the body ; and for that reason she is called a counsellor .
She performs that with her voice , which no instrument can play , or voice can sing ; and that is quarter-notes , her song being composed of them , and every one a note higher than another .
' ' Hist. Barb .
p. 60 .
Ligon appears , from other parts of his work , to have been musical ; but I should doubt much whether he was quite sure of these quarter intervals , so as to speak of them with precision .
Some passages of the song in a few kinds of birds correspond with the intervals of our musical scale ( of which the cuckoo is a striking and known instance ) : much the greater part , however , of such song is not capable of musical notations .
This arises from three causes : the first is , that the rapidity is often so great , and it is also so uncertain when they may stop , that we cannot reduce the passages to form a musical bar , in any time whatsoever .
The second is , that the pitch of most birds is considerably higher * than the most shrill notes of those instruments which contain even the greatest compass .
* Dr. Wallis is mistaken in part of what he supposes to be the cause of shrillness in the voice , ` ` Nam ut tubus , sic trachea longior , &amp; strictior , sonum efficit magis acutum .
' ' Grammar , p. 3 .
The narrower the pipe is , the more sharp the pitch as he rightly observes ; but the length of the tube hath just the contrary effect , because players on the flute always insert a longer middle-piece , when they want to make the instrument more flat .
I have before said , that our ideas of a voice , or instrument , being perfectly in tune or not , arise from comparing it with the musical intervals to which we are most accustomed .
As the upper and lower parts of every instrument , however , are but seldom used , we are not so well acquainted with the intervals in the highest and lowest octaves , as we are with those which are more central ; and for this reason the harpsichord-tuners find it more difficult to tune these extreme parts .
As a bird 's pitch , therefore , is higher than that of any instrument , we are consequently at a still greater loss when we attempt to mark their notes in musical characters , which we can so readily apply to such as we can distinguish with precision .
The third , however , and unsurmountable difficulty is , that the intervals used by birds are commonly so minute , that we cannot judge at all of them from the more gross intervals into which we divide our musical octave .
It should therefore be recollected , by those who have contended that the Greeks and Romans were acquainted with such more minute intervals of the octave , that they must insist the ancients had organs of sensation , with which their degenerate posterity are totally unprovided .
Though we cannot attain the more delicate and imperceptible intervals in the song of birds * , yet many of them are capable of whistling tunes with our more gross intervals , as is well known by the * There have been instances indeed of persons who would whistle the notes of birds , but these are too rare to be argued from .
common instances of piping Bullfinches * , and Canary-birds .
This , however , arises from mere imitation of what they hear when taken early from the nest ; for if the instrument from which they learn is out of tune , they as readily pipe the false , as the true notes of the composition .
The next point of comparison to be made between our music and that of birds is , whether they always sing in the same pitch .
This , however , I will not presume to answer with any precision , for the reason I have before suggested ; I shall , however , without reserve , give the best conjectures I can form on this head .
If a dozen singing birds of different kinds are heard in the same room , there is not any disagreeable dissonance ( which is not properly resolved ) , either to my own ear , or to that of others , whose judgement on such a point I can more rely .
At the same time , as each bird is singing a different song , it is extraordinary that what we call harmony should not be perpetually violated , as we experience , in what is commonly called a Dutch concert , when several tunes are played together .
The first requisite to make such sounds agreeable to the ear is , that all the birds should sing in the same key , which I am induced to believe that they do , from the following reasons .
I have long attended to the singing of birds , but if I cannot have recourse to an instrument very soon , * These Bullfinches also form a small article of commerce , and are chiefly brought from the neighbourhood of Cologne .
I cannot carry the pitch of their notes in my memory , even for a very short time .
I therefore desired a very experienced harpsichordtuner ( who told me he could recollect any particular note which he happened to hear for several hours ) , to mark down when he returned home what he had observed on this head .
I have lately received an account from him of the following notes in different birds .
F. natural in woodlarks .
A. natural in common cocks .
C. natural in Bantam cocks .
B. flat in a very large cock .
C. falling to A. commonly in the cuckoo .
A. in thrushes .
D. in some owls .
B. flat in some others .
These observations furnish five notes , viz. A. B. flat , C. D. and F. to which I can add a sixth , ( viz. G. ) from my own observations on a nightingale which lived three years in a cage .
I can also confirm these remarks of the harpsichord-tuner by having frequently heard from the same bird C. and F. As one should speak of the pitch of these notes with some precision , the B. flat of the spinet I tried them by , was perfectly in tune with the great bell of St. Paul 's .
The following notes , therefore , having been observed in different birds , viz. A. B. flat , C. D. F. and G. the E. is only wanting to complete the scale ; the six other notes , however , afford sufficient data for making some conjectures , at least , with regard to the key in which birds may be supposed to sing , as these intervals can only be found in the key of F. with a sharp third , or that of G. with a flat third .
I must own , I should rather suppose it to be the latter , and for the following reasons .
Lucretius says ( and perhaps the conjecture is not only ingenious but well founded ) , that the first musical notes were learned from birds : At liquidas avium voces imitarier ore Ante fuit multo , quam laevia carmina cantu Concelebrare homines possent , cantuque juvare .
' ' Now , of all the musical tones which can be distinguished in birds , those of the cuckoo have been most attended to , which form a flat third , not only by the observations of the harpsichord tuner I have before mentioned , but likewise by those of Kircher , in his Musurgia .
I know well that there have been some late compositions , which introduce the cuckoo notes in a sharp third ; these composers , however , did not trouble themselves with accuracy in imitating these notes , and it answered their purpose sufficiently , if there was a general resemblance .
Another proof of our musical intervals being originally borrowed from the song of birds , arises from most compositions being in a flat third , where music is simple , and consists merely of melody .
The oldest tune I happen to have heard is a Welsh one , called Morvar Rhydland * , which is * Or Rhydland Marsh , where the Welsh received a great defeat ; Rhydland is in Flintshire .
We find also , by the Orpheus Britannicus , that even so late as the time of Purcel , two parts in the three of his compositions are in the flat third .
composed in a flat third ; and if the music of the Turks and Chinese is examined in Du Halde and Dr. Shaw , half of the airs are also in a flat third .
The music of two centuries ago is likewise often in a flat third , though ninety-nine compositions out of a hundred are now in the sharp third .
The reason , however , of this alteration seems to be very clear : the flat third is plaintive , and consequently adapted to simple movements , such as may be expected in countries where music hath not been long cultivated .
There is on the other hand a most striking brilliancy in the sharp third , which is therefore proper for the amazing improvements in execution , which both singers and players have arrived at within the last fifty years .
When Corelli 's music was first published , our ablest violinists conceived that it was too difficult to be performed ; it is now , however , the first composition which is attempted by a scholar .
Every year also now produces greater and greater prodigies upon other instruments , in point of execution .
I have before observed , that by attending to a nightingale , as well as a robin which was educated under him , I always found that the notes reducible to our intervals of the octave were precisely the same ; which is another proof that birds sing always in the same key .
In this circumstance , they differ much from the human singer ; because those who are not able to sing at sight , often begin a song either above or below the compass of their voice , which they are not therefore able to go through with .
As birds , however , form the same passages with the same notes , Compositions for two piping Bull~inches Allegretto 1st .
B. 2d .
B. 1st .
B. 2d .
B. Allegro 1st .
B. 2d .
B. Allegro 1st .
B. Philos. Trans Vol. ~ .
Tab. XI .
p. 271 .
Bullfinches at all times , this mistake of the pitch can never happen in them .
Few singers again can continue their own part , whilst the same passages are sung by another in a different key ; or if the same or other passages are sung , so as not to coincide with the musical bar , or time of the first singer .
As birds however adhere so steadfastly to the same precise notes in the same passages , though they never trouble themselves about what is called time in music ; it follows that a composition may be formed for two piping bulfinches , in two parts , so as to constitute true harmony , though either of the birds may happen to begin , or stop , when they please .
I have therefore procured such an ingenious composition , by a very able musician * , which I send herewith ; and it need scarcely be observed , that there cannot possibly be much variety in the part of the second bulfinch .
[ See TA B. XI .
] Though several birds have great musical powers , yet they seem to have no delicacy of sensations , as the human singer hath ; and therefore the very best of them cannot be taught to exceed the insipidity of the upper part of the flute stop of an organ ~ , which hath not the modern improvement of a swell .
* Mr. Zeidler , who plays the violincello at Covent Garden theatre .
~ Lord Bacon mentions , that in the instrument called a regal ( which was a species of portable organ ) , there was a nightingale stop , in which water was made use of to produce the stronger imitation of this bird 's tone .
See Cent. ii .
exper .
172 .
Though this instrument , as well as its Nightingale stop , is now disused , I have procured an organ pipe to be immersed partly in water , which , when blown into , hath produced a tone very similar to that of birds .
They are also easily imposed upon by that most imperfect of all instruments , a bird-call , which they often mistake for the notes of their own species .
I have before observed , that perhaps no bird may be said to sing which is larger than a blackbird , though many of them are taught to speak : the smaller birds , however , have this power of imitation ; though perhaps the larger ones have not organs which may enable them , on the other hand , to sing .
We have the following instances of birds being taught to speak , in the time of the Greeks and Romans , upon which we never try the same experiment .
Moschus addresses nightingales and swallows which were thus instructed : ~ , ~ .
Moschi Idyl .
iii .
Pliny mentions both a cock , thrush , and nightingales , which articulated * : Habebant &amp; Caesares juvenes turdum ~ , item luscinias Graeco atque Latino sermon dociles , praeterea meditantes in diem , &amp; assidue nova loquentes longiore etiam contextu .
' ' Statius also takes notice of some birds speaking , which we never attempt to teach in this manner : * Lib. x. c. 21 &amp; 42 .
~ Ibid. The other turdus belonged to the Empress Agrippina .
Huc doctae stipentur aves , queis nobile fandi Jus natura dedit , plangat Phaebeius ales , Auditasque memor penitus demittere voces Sturnus , &amp; Aonio versae certamine picae ; Quique refert jungens iterata vocabula perdix , Et quae Bistonio queritur soror orba cubili * .
' ' Stat. Sylv. lib. ii .
ecl .
4 .
* Amongst the five birds mentioned in these lines of Statius , there are four which are never taught to speak at present , viz. the cock , the nightingale , the common , and the red legged partridge .
As I suppose , however , that perdix signifies this last bird , and not the common partridge ( as it is always translated ) , it is proper I should here give my reasons why I dissent from others , as also why I conceive that sturnus , in this passage , is not a starting , but the common partridge .
None of the ancients have described the plumage of the perdix ; but Aristotle , Ovid , and Pliny , inform us of what materials the nest of this bird is composed , as well as where it is placed .
Aristotle says , that the nest is fortified with wood~ ; and in another chapter ~ , with thorns and wood ; neither of which are used by the common partridge , which often builds in a country where they cannot be procured .
On the contrary , M. de Buffon informs us , that the red legged partridge , ` ` se tiennent sir les montagnes qui produisent beaucoup de bruyeres , &amp; de brossailles c. ~~ ~ .
Lib. v. c. ~ .
Which Stephens renders making a covering of wood .
b Lib. ix .
c. 8 .
The common partridge , however , makes its nest with hay and straw .
c Orn .
T. II .
p. 433 .
Silius Italicus also describes the pernix as being found in the same sort of country , Ceu pernix , quam densa vagis latratibus implet~ Venator dumeta Lacon .
' ' Lib. iii .
l. 29 .
As we find , from these citations , that so many different sorts of birds have learned to speak , and as I have shown that a sparrow may be taught to Ovid , therefore , speaking of the perdix , says , ponitque in sepibus ova d , ' ' where the common partridge is seldom known to build .
Pliny again informs us , ` ` perdices spina &amp; frutice sic muniunt receptaculum , ut contra feras abunde valentur ~ ' ' , as also in the 52d chapter of his tenth book , that the perdix lays white eggs , which is not true of the common partridge .
But there are not wanting other proofs of the conjecture I have here made .
Aristotle , speaking of this same bird , says , ~~ ~ , ~~ ~ , ~~~ ~ .
Now , the word ~ is clearly formed from the call of the bird alluded to , which does not at all resemble that of the common partridge .
Thus also the author of the Elegy on the Nightingale , who is supposed by some to be Ovid , hath the following line : Caccabat hinc perdix , hinc gratitat improbus anser .
' ' so that the call of the bird must have had something very particular , and have answered nearly , to the words ~ and caccabat .
I find , indeed , that M. de Buffon contends ~ that the ~ of Aristotle does not mean the common partridge , but the bartavel , with regard to which , I shall not enter into any discussion , but only observe , that most of his references are inaccurate , and that he entirely mistakes the materials of which the nest is composed , according to Aristotle 's sixth book , and first chapter .
~ Ovid .
Met .
lib. viii .
l. 258 .
I shall also refer to l. 237 , of the same book : Garrula ramosa prospexit ab ilice perdix : ' ' as it is well known that the common partridge never perches upon a tree .
~ Lib. x. c. 23 .
~ Lib. iv .
c. 9 .
~ Orn .
T. II .
p. 422 .
sing the linnet 's note , I scarcely know what species to fix upon , that may be considered as incapable of such imitations ; for it is very clear , from several experiments before stated , that the utmost endeavours will not be wanting in the bird , if he is endowed with the proper organs .
It can therefore only be settled by educating a bird , under proper circumstances , whether he is thus qualified or not ; for if one was only to determine this point by conjecture , one should suppose If , indeed , M. de Buffon had not been thus inaccurate , the grass and leaves , of which he says it is made , would prove that Aristotle speaks of the common partridge , contrary to what he himself supposes .
But the strongest proof that perdix signifies the red legged partridge is , that the Italians to this day call this bird pernice h , and the common sort starna l. This also now brings me to the proofs , of sturnus in this passage of Statius signifying the common partridge , and not the starling , which I must admit are not so strong as with regard to the import of the word perdix .
If my arguments are not therefore so convincing on this head , the number of birds taught to speak by the Romans , and not by us , must be reduced to three , as the starling is frequently learned to talk in the present times .
As I cannot argue from the description of the habits of the sturnus , or the materials of its nest , as in the former instance , I must rest my conjecture ( such as it is ) on the two birds , almost following each other in these lines of Statius ; on the common partridge being called starna to this day by the Italians , and upon the Romans having had otherwise no name for our partridge ( which is a very common bird in Italy ) , if sturnus is supposed to signify only a starling .
hI cannot therefore but think that pernix , according to the reading in the passage of Silius Italicus , which I have before cited , is the true Latin name for this bird , and that it was called perdix by those only who understood Greek .
~ See Olina .
that a sparrow would not imitate the song of the linnet , nor that a nightingale or partridge could be taught to speak .
And here it may not be improper to explain what I mean by birds learning to imitate the notes of others , or the human speech .
If the birds differ little in shape or size ( particularly of the beak * ) , the imitation is commonly so strong , that * It seems very obvious why the form and size of the beak may be material ; but I have also observed , that the colour of a bird 's bill changes , when in or out of song ; and I am informed that a cock seldom crows much , but when his comb is red .
When most of the finch tribe are coming into song , there is such a gradual change in the colour of their bill ; thus , those of the chaffinch and linnet are then of a very deep blue , which fades away again , when the bird ceases to be in song .
This particular should be attended to by the ornithologist , in his description ; because otherwise he supposes the colour of the bill to be permanent , which is by no means so .
This alteration , however , rather seems to be the symptom than the cause of a bird 's coming into song , or otherwise , and I have never attended to this circumstance in the soft billed birds sufficiently , to say whether it holds also with regard to them .
A very intelligent bird-catcher , however , was able to prognosticate , for three winters together , when a nightingale , which I kept so long , was coming into song ( though there was no change in the colour of the bill ) , by the dung 's being intermixed with large bloody spots , which before was only of a dead white .
This same bird-catcher was also very successful in his prescriptions for sick birds , with regard to the ingredients of which he was indeed very mysterious .
He said , that as he could not feel their pulse , the circumstances which he chiefly attended to were their weight , as well as both the consistence and colour of their dung .
He always frankly said what he expected from his prescriptions , and that if such and such changes did not soon take place , Mire sagaces falleret hospites Discrimen obscurum .
' ' Horat .
for , in such instances , the passages are not only the same , but the tone .
Such was the event of the experiment I have before mentioned of the linnet educated under a vengolina .
In my experiment , however , of teaching the sparrow the notes of the linnet , though the scholar imitated the passages of its master , yet the tone of the sparrow had by no means the mellowness of the original .
The imitation might therefore be , in some measure , compared to the singing of an opera song by a black-guard , when , though the notes may be precisely the same , yet the manner and tone would differ very much .
Thus also the linnet , which I heard repeat the words pretty boy , did not articulate like a parrot or a mino , though , at the same time , the words might be clearly distinguished .
The education I have therefore been speaking of will not give new organs of voice to a bird , and the instrument itself will not vary , though the notes or passages may be altered almost at pleasure .
I tried once an experiment , which might indeed have possibly made some alteration in the tone of a bird , from what it might have been when the animal the case was desperate .
He frequently also refused to prescribe , if the bird felt too light in the hand , or he thought that there was not sufficient time to bring about an alteration in the dung .
was at its full growth , by procuring an operator who caponised a young blackbird of about six weeks old ; as it died , however , soon afterwards , and I have never repeated the experiment , I can only conjecture with regard to what might have been the consequences of it .
Both Pliny * and the London poulterers agree that a capon does not crow , which I should conceive to arise from the muscles of the larynx never acquiring the proper degree of strength , which seems to be requisite to the singing of a bird , from Mr. Hunter 's dissections .
But it will perhaps be asked , why this operation should not improve the notes of a nestling , as much as it is supposed to contribute to the greater perfection of the human voice .
To this I answer , that castration by no means insures any such consequence ; for the voices of much the greater part of Italian eunuchs are so indifferent , that they have no means of procuring a livelihood but by copying music , and this is one of the reasons why so few compositions are published in Italy , as it would starve this refuse of society .
But it may be said , that there hath been a Farinelli and a Manzoli , whose voices were so distinguishedly superior .
To this I again answer , that the catalogue of such names would be a very short one ; and that we attribute those effects to castration , which should rather be ascribed to the education of these singers .
* Lib. x. c. 21 .
Castration commonly leaves the human voice at the same pitch as when the operation is performed ; but the eunuch , from that time , is educated with a view only to his future appearance on the opera stage ; he therefore manages his voice to greater advantage , than those who have not so early and constant instruction .
Considering the size of many singing birds , it is rather amazing at what a distance their notes may be heard .
I think I may venture to say , that a nightingale may be very clearly distinguished at more than half a mile * , if the evening is calm .
I have also observed the breath of a robin ( which exerted itself ) so condensed in a frosty morning , as to be very visible .
To make the comparison , however , with accuracy , between the loudness of a bird 's and the human voice , a person should be sent to the spot from whence the bird is heard ; I should rather conceive that , upon such trial , the nightingale would be distinguished further than the man .
It must have struck every one , that , in passing under a house where the windows are shut , the singing of a bird is easily heard , when , at the same time , a conversation cannot be so , though an animated one .
Most people , who have not attended to the notes of birds , suppose that those of every species sing * Mons. de Buffon says , that the quadruped which he terms the huarine , may be heard at the distance of a league .
Ornith .
Tom. I. exactly the same notes and passages , which is by no means true , though it is admitted that there is a general resemblance .
Thus the London bird-catchers prefer the song of the Kentish goldfinches , but Essex chaffinches ; and when they sell the bird to those who can thus distinguish , inform the buyer that it hath such a note , which is very well understood between them * .
Some of the nightingale fanciers also prefer a Surry bird to those of Middlesex ~ .
These differences in the song of birds of the same species cannot perhaps be compared to any thing more apposite , than the varieties of provincial dialects .
The nightingale seems to have been fixed upon , almost universally , as the most capital of singing birds , which superiority it certainly may boldly challenge : one reason , however , of this bird 's being * These are the names which they give to some of the nightingale 's notes : Sweet , Sweet jug , Jug sweet , Water bubble , Pipe rattle , Bell pipe , Scroty , Skeg , Skeg , skeg , Swat swat swaty , Whitlow whitlow whitlow , from some distant affinity to such words .
~ Mr. Henshaw informs us , that nightingales in Denmark are not heard till May , and that their notes are not so sweet or various as with us .
Dr. Birch 's History of the Royal Society , Vol. III .
p. 189 .
Whilst Mr. Fletcher ( who was minister from Q. Elizabeth to Russia ) says , that the nightingales in that part of the world have a finer note than ours .
See Fletcher 's Life , in the Biographia Britannica .
I never could believe what is commonly asserted , that the Czar Peter was at a considerable expense to introduce singing birds near Petersburgh ; because it appears , by the Fauna Suecica , that they have in those latitudes most of the same birds with those of England .
more attended to than others is , that it sings in the night * .
Hence Shakespeare says , The nightingale , if she should sing by day , When every goose is cackling , would be thought No better a musician than the wren .
' ' The song of this bird hath been described , and expatiated upon , by several writers , particularly Pliny and Strada .
As I must own , however , that I cannot affix any precise ideas to either of these celebrated descriptions , and as I once kept a very fine bird of this sort for three years , with very particular attention to its song ; I shall endeavour to do it the best justice I am capable of .
In the first place , its tone is infinitely more mellow than that of any other bird , though , at the same time , by a proper exertion of its musical powers , it can be excessively brilliant .
When this bird sang its song round , in its whole compass , I have observed sixteen different beginnings and closes , at the same time that the intermediate notes were commonly varied in their succession with such judgment , as to produce a most pleasing variety .
The bird which approaches nearest to the excellence of the nightingale , in this respect , is the skylark ; but then the tone is infinitely inferior in point of mellowness : most other singing birds have not above four or five changes .
* The woodlark and reedsparrow sing likewise in the night ; and from hence , in the neighbourhood of Shrewsbury , the latter hath obtained the name of the willow-nightingale .
Nightingales , however , and these two other birds , sing al~o in the day , but are not then distinguished in the general concert .
The next point of superiority in a nightingale is its continuance of song , without a pause , which I have observed sometimes not to be less than twenty seconds .
Whenever respiration , however , became necessary , it was taken with as much judgment as by an opera singer .
The skylark again , in this particular , is only second to the nightingale * .
*I shall here insert a table , by which the comparative merit of the British singing birds may be examined , the idea of which I have borrowed from Mons. de Piles , in his Course de Peinture par Principes .
I shall not be surprised , however , if , as he suggests , many may disagree with me about particular birds , as he supposes they will do with him , concerning the merits of painters .
As I have five columns instead of the four which M. de Piles uses , I make 20 the point of absolute perfection , instead of 16 , which is his standard .
MellowSprightly Plaintive Compass .
Execuness of notes .
notes .
tion .
tone .
Nightingale ... .
19 14 19 19 19 Skylark ... . .
4 19 4 18 18 Woodlark ... . .
18 4 17 12 8 Titlark ... . .
12 12 12 12 12 Linnet ... ... 12 16 12 16 18 Goldfinch ... . .
4 19 4 12 12 Chaffinch ... . .
4 12 488 Greenfinch ... .
44446 Hedge-sparrow ... 60644 Aberdavine ( or Siskin ) .
24044 Redpoll ... ... 04044 Thrush ... ... 44444 Blackbird ... . .
44022 Robin ... ... 6 16 12 12 12 Wren ... ... 0 12 044 Reed-sparrow ... .
04022 Black-cap , or the Norfolk Mock nightingale k. 14 12 12 14 14 k Brit. Zool. p. 262 .
And here I must again repeat , that what I describe is from a caged nightingale , because those which we hear in the spring are so rank , that they seldom sing any thing but short and loud jerks , which consequently cannot be compared to the notes of a caged bird , as the instrument is overstrained .
I must also here observe , that my Nightingale was a very capital bird ; for some of them are so vastly inferior , that the bird-fanciers will not keep them , branding them with the name of Frenchmen * .
But it is not only in tone and variety that the Nightingale excells ; the bird also sings ( if I may so express myself ) with superior judgement and taste .
I have therefore commonly observed , that my Nightingale began softly like the ancient orators ; I have made no mention of the bulfinch in this table , which is commonly considered as a singing bird ; because its wild note , without instruction , is a most jarring and disagreeable noise .
I have likewise omitted ~ the redstart ( which is called by the French le Rossignol de Muraille ) , as I am not sufficiently acquainted with its song , though it is admired by many ; I should rather conceive , however , with Zinanni , that there is no very extraordinary merit in the notes .
The London bird-catchers also sell sometimes the yellow hammer , twite and brambling m as singing birds ; but none of these will come within my definition of what may be deemed so .
* One should suppose from this , that the nightingale-catchers had heard much of the French music ; which is possibly the case , as some of them live in Spittal-fields .
~ Il culo ranzo e un ucello , ( per quanto dicono ) molto canoro , ma io tale non lo stimo .
Dell uova e del nidi , p. 53 .
m They call this bird a kate .
reserving its breath to swell certain notes , which by this means had a most astonishing effect , and which eludes all verbal description .
I have indeed taken down certain passages which may be reduced to our musical intervals ; but though by these means one may form an idea of some of the notes used , yet it is impossible to give their comparative durations in point of musical tune , upon which the whole effect must depend .
I once procured a very capital player on the flute to execute the notes which Kircher hath engraved in his Musurgia , as being used by the nightingale ; when , from want of not being able to settle their comparative duration , it was impossible to observe any traces almost of the nightingale 's song .
It may not be improper here to consider , whether the nightingale may not have a very formidable competitor in the American mocking-bird * ; though almost all travellers agree , that the concert in the European woods is superior to that of the other parts of the globe ~ .
As birds are now annually imported in great numbers from Asia , Africa , and America , I have frequently attended to their notes , both singly and in concert , which are certainly not to be compared to those of Europe .
Thomson , the poet , ( whose observations in natural history are much to be depended upon ) makes * Turdus Americanus minor canorus .
Ray 's Syn .
It is called by the Indians Contlatolli ; which is said to signify four hundred tongues .
See also Catesby .
~ See Rochefort 's Hist des Antelles , T. I.p. 366-Ph .
Tr. Abr .
VO .
III .
p. 563.-andCatesby .
this superiority in the European birds to be a sort of compensation for their great inferiority in point of gaudy plumage .
Our goldfinch , however , joins to a very brilliant and pleasing song , a most beautiful variety of colours in its feathers * .
It must be admitted , that foreign birds , when brought to Europe , are often heard to a great disadvantage ; as many of them , from their great tameness , have certainly been brought up by hand , the consequence of which I have already stated from several experiments .
The soft-billed birds also cannot be well brought over , as the succedaneum for insects ( their common food ) is fresh meat , and particularly the hearts of animals .
I have happened , however , to hear the American mocking-bird in great perfection at Mess .
Vogle 's and Scott 's , in Love-lane , Eastcheap .
This bird is believed to be still living , and hath been in England these six years .
During the space of a minute , he imitated the woodlark , chaffinch , blackbird , thrush , and sparrow .
I was told also , that he would bark like a dog ; so that the bird seems to have no choice in his imitations , though his pipe comes nearest to our nightingale of any bird I have yet met with .
With regard to the original notes , however , of this bird , we are still at a loss ; as this can only be *I cannot but think , that there would be a demand for these birds in China , as the inhabitants are very sedentary , and bird cages are commonly represented as hanging in their rooms .
have been informed , by a Tyroleze , that his best market for Canary birds was Constantinople .
known by those who are accurately acquainted with the song of the other American birds .
Kalm indeed informs us , that the natural song is excellent * ; but this traveller seems not to have been long enough in America to have distinguished what were the genuine notes : with us , mimics do not often succeed but in imitations .
I have little doubt , however , but that this bird would be fully equal to the song of the Nightingale in its whole compass ; but then , from the attention which the mocker pays to any other sort of disagreeable noises , these capital notes would be always debased by a bad mixture .
We have one mocking bird in England , which is the skylark ; as , contrary to a general observation I have before made , this bird will catch the note of any other which hangs near it ; even after the skylark note is fixed .
For this reason , the bird-fanciers often place the skylark next one which hath not been long caught , in order , as they term it , to keep the caged skylark honest .
The question , indeed , may be asked , why the wild skylark , with these powers of imitation , ever adheres to the parental note ; but it must be recollected , that a bird when at liberty is for ever shifting its place , and consequently does not hear the same notes eternally repeated , as when it hangs in a cage near another .
In a wild state therefore the skylark adheres to the parental notes ; as the parent cock attends the young ones , and is heard by them for so considerable a time .
* Vol. I. p. 219 .
I am aware also , that it may be asked , how birds originally came by the notes which are peculiar to each species .
My answer , however , to this is , that the origin of the notes of birds , together with its gradual progress , is as difficult to be traced , as that of the different languages in nations .
The loss of the parent-cock at the critical time for instruction hath undoubtedly produced those varieties , which I have before observed are in the song of each species ; because then the nestling hath either attended to the song of some other birds ; or perhaps invented some new notes of its own , which are afterwards perpetuated from generation to generation , till similar accidents produce other alterations .
The organs of some birds also are probably so defective , that they cannot imitate properly the parental note , as some men can never articulate as they should do .
Such defects in the parent bird must again occasion varieties , because these defects will be continued to their descendants , who ( as I before have proved ) will only attend to the parental song .
Some of these descendants also may have imperfect organs ; which will again multiply varieties in the song .
The truth is , as I before observed , that scarcely any two birds of the same species have exactly the same notes , if they are accurately attended to , though there is a general resemblance .
Thus most people see no difference between one sheep and another , when a large flock is before them .
The shepherd , however , knows each of them , and can swear to them , if they are lost ; as can the Lincolnshire gosherd to each goo~e .
As I now draw towards a conclusion of both my experiments and observations on the singing of birds ; it may be possibly asked , what use results either from the trouble or expense which they have cost me ; both of which I admit to have been considerable .
I will readily own , that no very important advantages can be derived from them ; and yet I shall not decline suggesting what little profit they may possibly be of , though at best they should rather be considered as what Lord Bacon terms , experiments of light , than of fruit .
In the first place , there is no better method of investigating the human faculties , than by a compari~on with those of animals ; provided we make it without a most ungrateful wish of lowering ourselves , in that distinguished situation in which we are placed .
Thus we are referred to the ant for an example of industry and foresight , because it provides a magazine of food for the winter , when this animal is in a state of torpidity during that season ; nor are we less willing to suppose the song of birds to be superior to our own musical powers .
The notes of many birds are certainly very pleasing , but can by no means stand in competition either with the human voice or our worst musical instruments ; not only from want of the striking effects of harmony in many excellent compositions ; but because , even when compared to our simple melody , expression is wanting* , without which music is so languid and inanimate .
* The nightingale , indeed , is perhaps an exception to this general observation .
But to return to the uses ( such as they are ) which may arise from attending to the song of birds , or from the experiments which I have given an account of .
The first of these is too much neglected by the naturalist ; for , if the bird is not caught , the only means often by which either the sex or the species can be determined is the song .
For example , if Mons. Adanson had informed us whether the European swallows , which he conceived were to be seen during the winter at Senegal , had the same notes with those of Europe , it would have been going one step further in proof of the facts which he and others so much rely upon .
These experiments , however , may be said to be useful to all those who happen to be pleased with singing birds ; because it is clear , that , by educating a bird under several sorts , we may often make such a mixture , as to improve the notes which they would have learned in a wild state .
It results also from the experiment of the linnet being educated under the Vengolina , that we may introduce the notes of Asia , Africa , and America , into our own woods ; because , if that linnet had been set at liberty * , the nestlings of the next season would have adhered to the Vengolina song , who would again transmit it to their descendants .
*I know well , that it is commonly supposed , if you set a caged bird at liberty , it will neither be able to feed itself , nor otherwise live long , on account of its being persecuted by the wild ones .
There is no foundation , however , for this notion ; and I take it to arise from an excuse for continuing to keep these birds in confinement .
But we may not only improve the notes of birds by a happy mixture , or introd~ce those which were never before heard in Great-Britain ; as we may also improve the instrument with which the passages are executed .
If , for example , any bird-fancier is particularly fond of what is called the song of the Canary bird , which however must be admitted to be inferior in tone to the linnet , it would answer well to any such person , if a nestling linnet was brought up under a Canary bird , because the notes would be the same , but the instrument which executes them would be improved .
We learn also , from these experiments , that nothing is to be expected from a nestling brought up by hand , if he does not receive the proper instruction from the parent cock : much trouble and some cost is therefore thrown away by many persons in endeavouring to rear nestling nightingales , which , when they are brought up and fed at a very considerable expense , have no song which is worth attending to .
If a woodlark , or skylark , was educated , however , under a nightingale , it follows that this charge ( which amounts to a shilling per week * ) might be in a great measure saved , as well as the trouble of chopping fresh meat every day .
A nightingale , again , when kept in a cage , does not live often more than a year or two ; nor does he sing more than three or four months ; whereas the * Olina speaks of a pasle which is used in Italy for nightingales ; but I cannot find that it ever answers with us ; perhaps , they bring their nightingales up by hand , and so accuslom them from their earliest infancy to such food .
scholar pitched upon may not only be more vivacious , but will continue in song nine months out of the twelve .
I fear , however , that I have already dwelt too long upon these very minute and trifling advantages which may result from my experiments and observations ; I shall therefore no longer defer subscribing myself , Dear Sir , Your most faithful , Humble Servant , Daines Barrington :

