XXVIII .
Observations on the Lagopus , or Ptarmigan ; in a Letter from the Hon. Daines Barrington , V. P. R. S. to Matthew Maty , M. D. F. R. S. DEAR SIR , THE many different specimens of Lagopi , both in their winter and summer plumage , which have lately been presented to the Royal Society , from Hudson 's Bay , enable us to correct many mistakes that have hitherto been made in the description of this bird ; as well as the unnecessarily multiplying the species of the Tetrao genus .
As that able and ingenious naturalist , M. de Buffon , is the last ornithologist who hath made any observations on this bird , it may not be improper to take notice of some of his supposed inaccuracies .
The Lagopus , of which M. de Buffon gives an engraving , is in its winter plumage ; and the feet of the bird are consequently covered very thick with feathers .
M. de Buffon , however , from not having examined the specimens of the Lagopus with proper attention , says , that Aristotle could not have been acquainted with this bird , because the under parts of the claws are entirely covered with feathers ; which circumstance is so very striking and peculiar , that it could not have escaped this father of natural history .
If a winter specimen , however , of the Lagopus , or ~ , is accurately examined , it will be found , that no feathers grow precisely under the claws ; though , by wrapping very thickly round them , they have very strongly that appearance : and , in a summer specimen , not only the feet , but even the legs , are rather bare of plumage .
If Aristotle , therefore , had procured the bird in its summer dress , he could not have observed this very striking circumstance , which M. de Buffon relies upon as so strongly characteristic .
The same difference between the plumage in summer and winter is experienced in each of the three species of Tetrao , which have ( according to one of Linnaeus 's subdivisions ) feathered feet ; and it is usually said with us , that they have in winter their snow-boots .
M. de Buffon , therefore , unjustly charges the author of the British Zoology for supposing , that this is a wife provision of Nature against the inclemency of the season , when he says , [ a ] that the vrogallus Minor , or our Black Cock , hath not the same protection for its feet , though it buries itself under the snow , and , becoming torpid , equally wants such additional warmth .
With regard to the torpidity of this bird , M. de Buffon relies upon Linnaeus 's asserting , that saepe sepelitur in nive [ b ] ; which by no means signifies that the bird is torpid , but only that it buries itself , sometimes , under the snow ; as sheep do with us in the more rigorous seasons , when it lies very deep in the mountains .
[ a ] T. ii .
p. 216 .
[ b ] Linn. S. Not .
p. 159 .
This circumstance is also observed by Pontoppidan , Pt. ii , p. 75 .
Engl .
Transl .
The The Black Cock , however , is so far from being torpid in the winter , that it even approaches the habitation of man when distressed for food ; and I shall likewise conclude , till I see a specimen which proves the contrary , that , like the other Tetraos , whose feet are covered low with feathers , this part of the plumage becomes thicker in winter .
M. de Buffon also seems to be mistaken in supposing , that the thick plumage round the feet is peculiar to the Lagopus ; as it is believed , that Linnaeus 's first division of this genus have all of them the same additional cloathing for the winter ; nor is this extraordinary warmth confined merely to this genus , as the noble specimen of the large White Owl , which hath lately been presented to the Royal Society from Hudson 's Bay , is covered about the claws with a plumage of perhaps an equal thickness .
The next remarkable circumstance in this bird is , that the shafts of many of the wing-feathers are black ; which M. de Buffon supposes to be only six ; whereas they are eight in the specimens from Hudson 's Bay ; the two last are , indeed , of a fainter colour .
M. de Buffon next says [ c ] , that Brisson counts eighteen feathers in the tail ; and Willoughby , sixteen ; which he reduces himself to fourteen .
It seems to me , however , that Willoughby 's number is the more accurate ; and , by examining the difference between the summer and winter specimens , I find that the black feathers of the tail are covered by two upper ones , which in summer are brown , and in winter white .
[ c ] T. ii .
p. 264 .
I cannot also discover , in any of the specimens , the two white feathers in the tail , according to Linnaeus 's description , rectricibus nigris apice albis , intermediis albis , as the two covering feathers beforementioned cannot , with propriety , be termed intermedii ; nor are they white in the summer , but brown : so that Linnaeus makes a circumstance , which varies with the season , to be a permanent characteristic of the bird .
M. de Buffon next supposes [ d ] , that Willonghby and Frisch speak of different birds under the name of Lagopus ; because the first says , that the feet are covered with soft , and the latter , with harsh and bristly feathers .
The remarks , however , of these ornithologists , are easily reconciled ; for , if the finger is drawn according to the course of the feathers , they feel soft ; and , if in the contrary direction , harsh and bristly .
The difference also between Belon , Gesner , and Linnaeus , with regard to the call of this bird , is as easily accounted for ; because most male birds differ from the female in this respect , and sometimes the young birds from those which are full-grown .
This naturally brings me to show , that M. de Buffon ( who hath great merit in other parts of his Natural History , by not unnecessarily multiplying the species of animals , ) hath , in this kind of Tetrao , considered as two species what , when properly examined , will turn out to be only the La gopus , or Ptarmigan .
His chief reason for considering the Lagopus of Hudson 's Bay , as being distinct from the Ptarmi[d ] T. ii .
p. 271 .
gan , arises from his asserting , that Mr. Edwards , in his description of that bird , says , that it is twice as large .
Mr. Edwards , however , only considers the size of the Hudson 's Bay Lagopus as between that of a Pheasant and a Partridge ; in which he is very accurate : the bird is not only evidently so to the eye , but weighs three ounces more than a common Partridge [ e ] .
M. de Buffon likewise seems to make an unnecessary species of Tetrao , under the name of le petit Tetras , a plumage variable ; as his principal argument for this opinion is , that they are not found on the mountains , as the Lagopi are .
Now , it is very clear , from the name given in the catalogue from Hudson 's Bay to this bird , of the Willow Partridge , that it lives entirely in that part of the world on the plains ; nor are there ( it is believed ) any very high mountains in the neighbourhood of our forts .
When M. de Buffon , therefore , conceives , that the Lagopus is always endeavouring to find out snow and ice , and that it carefully avoids the glare of the sun [ f ] ; it should seem , that the observation is by no means generally true ; because , though the rigour of a Hudson 's Bay winter is great , yet the summer is very pleasant , and the snow soon disappears , without which M. de Buffon imagines that the bird cannot exist ; though his ninth plate represents the Ptarmigan , in his winter dress , sir [ e ] The Partridge , when full-grown , weighs thirteen ounces , and the Ptarmigan , sixteen .
[ f ] T. ii .
p. 272 .
rounded with trees and plants in most luxuriant foliage and vegetation .
I cannot agree , moreover , with M. de Buffon , when he says , that the flesh of the Lagopus is bitter ; as I have eat them myself in the Highlands of Scotland ; nor should I have been able to distinguish the taste from that of the common Grous , which is well known to be a bird of most excellent flavour .
What I have hitherto remarked is chiefly in answer to that ingenious naturalist , M. de Buffon , who is the last ornithologist that hath both described and engraved this bird .
I have only one new observation to make myself ; which is , that the claws are scooped off at the end exactly like a writingpen ( wanting indeed the slit ) ; which circumstance may likewise be seen in the claws of our common Grous , or Heath-game , though the resemblance is not quite so strong as in the Ptarmigan .
I shall now conclude with copying , from the catalogue transmitted with the specimens from Hudson 's Bay , what further relates to the Lagopus ; which , as I observed before , is there called a Willow-partridge [ g ] .
The Willow-partridges gather together in large flocks in the beginning of October , harbouring amongst the willows , the tops of which are their principal food ; they then change to their winter [ g ] It is not at all extraordinary , that it should there be considered as a Partridge ; because the White Partridge is the name given to this bird by the old ornithologists , who have very naturally considered edible birds nearly of the same size , as Partridges when they have short tails , and as Pheasants , when they have long ones .
dress .
They change again in March , and have their complete summer dress by the latter end of June .
They make their nest in the ground in dry ridges ; and are so plentiful , that ten thousand have been killed in the three forts in one winter .
' ' I am , dear SIR , Your most faithful , humble Servant , Daines Barrington .

