XIV .
An Inquiry into the Quantity and Direction of the proper Motion of Arcturus ; with some Remarks on the Diminution of the Obliquity of the Ecliptic : By Thomas Hornsby , M. A. Savilian Professor of Astronomy in the University of Oxford , and F. R. S. AS an accurate knowledge of the position of the fixed stars is of the greatest importance , being the basis and foundation of astronomy , it is no wonder that the astronomers of different nations have given great attention to this matter .
By comparing ancient with the best modern observations , it appears that some of the fixed stars have a proper motion , independent of any motion hitherto known in our own system ; or that , in other words , the angular distances of the fixed stars have not always continued the same , and in some of them the alteration is so very considerable as to be easily perceived in the course of a few years , with instruments accurately made , and nicely adjusted .
Of all the stars visible in our hemisphere , the variation in the place of Arcturus is the most remarkable , and such as cannot possibly be attributed to the uncertainty of observation .
It has accordingly been taken no6 tice Read Dec. 24 , tice of by many astronomers : in particular , Dr. Halley mentions it in No 355 of the Philosophical Transactions : Mr. Cassini , in the Memoirs of the Academy of Sciences for 1738 , p. 231 , has shown , that there is a variation of five minutes in the latitude of that star between his own time and that of Tycho , in an interval of a century and a half : and M. le Monnier , in the Memoirs of the Academy of Sciences for 1767 , p. 417 , proves , that the latitude of Arcturus varies at the rate of two seconds every year ; and that the longitude decreases at the rate of 60~ in a hundred years * .
But as an inquiry as well into the true quantity as into the direction of this motion has not hitherto been made public , I propose to give some account of my own observations made expressly with this view in the years 1767 and 1768 , with a transit instrument of 44 inches , and a moveable mural quadrant of 33 inches , both constructed by Mr. Bird , and of the conclusions resulting from a comparison between them and some observations made by Mr. Flamsteed in 1690 .
It may perhaps be objected , that the differences of right ascension , as determined by Mr. Flamsteed 's mural instrument , are not to be depended upon from the very nature of his instrument .
Mr. Flamsteed was himself too good an observer not to be aware of this ; and accordingly in the Prolegomena to the third volume of the Historia Caelestis , p. 132 , he informs us in what manner he determined the error of * See also the Memoirs of the Academy of Sciences for 1769 , p. 21 .
See also Astronomiae Fundamenta , by the Abbe de la Caille ; who , in reducing his observations of Arcturus , supposes the annual motion of declination in that star =19~,0 .
p. 169 , and 187 .
the plane at different distances from the zenith .
By distributing these errors in the best manner I could , I am of opinion , that the error of the plane of his instrument may be supposed to decrease uniformly at the rate of half a second in time for every degree of zenith distance from 28~ to 60~ , the error being 39~ at the former , and 23~ at the latter , by which quantity stars passed the horary wire , in his instrument , before they came to the true meridian .
It should seem also that the error continued nearly the same from 60 to 75 degrees , being at the latter only 22~ : but that it decreased irregularly from 75~ to 85~ , viz. 1~ in time for each degree from 75~ to 80~ , and 0~ , 4 for each degree from 80~ to 85 degrees .
The mural arc was fixed upon a stone pier , the southern part of which was found to settle yearly , from whence the error of the line of collimation to the south necessarily became every successive year greater and greater .
As Mr. Flamsteed seems not to have had any method of adjusting his instrument by a plumb-line , these errors must have been irregular at different seasons of the same year , and were perhaps never truly determined .
But as the observations here referred to were made on the same day , and within the compass of an hour , they are probably not affected with this latter error .
We are at present concerned with the difference of two zenith distances , and not with the absolute quantity of those zenith distances .
The conclusions may indeed be affected with an error in the divisions ; and from the examination which I have been able to make , I am of opinion that the arc of Mr. Flamsteed 's instrument was not of the proper quantity ; and that , though the observations generally erred in defect , they in some parts erred in excess .
On the 14th of February , 1690 , Mr. Flamsteed observed , that a small star , of the seventh or eighth magnitude , whose place is not determined in the British catalogue , and which star was named by him Infra Arcturum , preceded Arcturus three seconds in time , or 3~ , 3 , when an allowance is made for the error of the plane of the instrument= 0~ 42~ , 6 , and was 26~ 30~ to the south of Arcturus * .
By a mean of eight observations made at Oxford , on and near June the 10th , 1767 , with the transit instrument , and with a refracting telescope of eight feet , furnished with a micrometer ; the difference of right ascension was 1~ , 8~ , 75 of a degree , the star following Arcturus ; and by a mean of three observations , the extremes differing only 3~ , the small star was 23~ 55~ , 0 to the south of Arcturus .
The right ascension of Arcturus and the small star being nearly the same , the change in declination ought to be so likewise .
But , from the observed difference in declination , the right ascension of the two stars must vary unequally , though with a very small difference .
Accordingly it appears from computation ( in which the annual precession is supposed = 50~ , 35 , the obliquity of the ecliptic at the middle of the interval of the time = 23~ 28~ 30~ , and the right ascensions and declinations of the two stars taken at a mean between the times of observation ) that the variation of Arcturus in right ascension was 3270~ , 6 , and of the small star 3277~ , 6 in * This is the only observation of that star made by Mr. Flamsteed .
77,287 years .
Therefore the right ascension of Arcturus alters less than that of the star ; and consequently Arcturus should in 1767 have followed the star by 42~,6 .
But the star was observed to follow Arcturus by 1~ 8~ , 75 .
The right ascension therefore of Arcturus has increased less than that of the star , or Arcturus has moved westward 1~ 51~ , 35 in 77,287 years ; and has gone southward 2~ 35~ in the same time , supposing the small star not to have moved , which is highly probable .
On the same day the difference of right ascension in time between the star n Bootis and Arcturus was 21~ 32~ of mean solar time , = 5~ 24~ 02~ , 2 , when a proper allowance is made for the going of the clock , and for the error of the plane of the instrument ; and the difference of declination was 50~ 45~ , 6 , when an allowance is made for refraction .
On the 24th , 26th , and 29th of May , and the 9th of June , of the year 1768 , I determined the difference in right ascension to be 21~ 27~ of sidereal time by the two former observations , and 21~ 263/ 4~ by the two latter , the difference in declination being 49~ 48~ , 7 , by a mean of the observations in May , the extremes differing only four seconds .
It appears from computation , that between the times of observation the variation of n Bootis in right ascension was 3371~ , 7 , and 1417~ , 3 , in declination ; of Arcturus 3311~ , 7 in right ascension , and 1347~ , 9 in declination : The difference of variation in right ascension is 1~ 0~ , and of declination 1~ 9~ , 4 ; by the former the difference in right ascension was diminished , and in declination increased by the latter , agreeably to the places of the two stars .
The difference in right ascension therefore in 1768 , if neither of the stars had moved , should have been = 5~ 23~ 02~ , 2 , and 51~ 55~ in declination ; but they were observed to be 5~ 21~ 43~ , 4 , and 49~ 48~ , 7 .
Arcturus therefore by this observation has in 78,257 years gone 1~ 18~ , 8 to the west , and 2~ 06~ , 3 to the south , supposing n Bootis not to have any proper motion .
On the 5th of April , 1691 , the difference in right ascension between n Bootis and Arcturus was 21~ 33~ of mean solar time , = 5~ 24~ 14~ , 0 ; and the difference of declination 50~ 45~ , 6 , as in the preceding example .
The difference of variation in right ascension is 59~ , 1 , and in declination 1~ 8~ , 4~ The difference of right ascension therefore at the latter end of May , 1768 , should have been 5~ 23~ 14~ , 9 , and 51~ 54~ , 0 in declination ; but , according to observation , they were 5~ 21~ 43~ , 4 , and 49~ 48~ , 7 .
Arcturus therefore , according to this observation , has moved 1~ 31~ , 5 to the west , and 2~ 05~ , 3 to the south in 77 , 120 years .
On the 4th of May , 1691 , the difference of right ascension between n Bootis and Arcturus was 21~ 33~ of mean solar time , = 5~ 24~ 14~ , 3 when allowance is made for the going of the clock and the error of the plane of the instrument , and the difference of declination on the 3d of May = 50~ 50~ , 6 .
According to computation , those differences should have been 5~ 23~ 15~ , 2 and 51~ 59~ , 0 respectively ; but they were observed to be 5~ 21~ 43~ , 4 , and 49~ 48~ , 7 .
Arcturus therefore in 77,071 years has moved 1~ 31~ , 8 westward , and 2~ 10~ , 3 southward .
N. B. The zenith-distance of Arcturus , as as determined by Mr. Flamsteed , on the 4th of May , is manifestly erroneous .
On the 27th of May , 1692 , n Bootis preceded Arcturus in right ascension by 21~ 32~ , 5 of mean solar time , = 5~ 24~ 10~ , 1 , the difference of declination being 50~ 50~ , 6 .
In 75,978 years the difference of right ascension should have been 5~ 23~ 11~ , 8 and 51~ 58~ , 0 in declination ; but those differences were observed to be 5~ 21~ 43~ , 4 and 49~ 48~ , 7 .
Arcturus therefore has moved 1~ 28~ , 4 westward , and 2~ 09~ , 3 southward .
On the 27th of May , 1692 , Arcturus preceded ~ Bootis in right ascension by 24~ 35~ , 5 of mean solar time , = 6~ 9~ 32~ , 2 , when an allowance is made for the going of the clock and the error of the plane of the instrument , the difference of declination being 3~ 2~ 28~ , 9 .
On the 24th and 26th of May , and 5th of June , 1768 , the difference of right ascension between the same stars observed at Oxford was 24~ 44~ , 58 of sidereal time , = 6~ 11~ 9~ , 1 , the difference of declination being 2~ 58~ 24~ , 2 .
In 1768 , the difference of right ascension should have been 2~ , 7 greater , = 6~ 9~ 34~ , 9 ; and the difference of declination 1~ 31~ , 7 less , = 3~ 0~ 57~ , 2 .
But they were observed to be 6~ 11~ 9~ , 1 , and 2~ 58~ 24~ , 2 .
Arcturus therefore in 75,978 years has , by a comparison with this star , moved 1~ 34~ , 2 westward , and 2~ 33~ , 0 southward .
Again , the difference of declination between Arcturus and ~ Bootis was observed to be 3~ 2~ 33~ , 9 on the 14th of February , 1690 , when the difference of right ascension between these two stars was not observed by Mr. Flamsteed .
It appears by compuO 2 tation , tation , that the difference of variation in declination between the times of observation was 1~ 34~ , 5 , by which quantity the difference of declination was diminished , and should therefore in 1768 have been 3~ 0~ 59~ , 4 .
But it was 2~ 58~ 24~ , 2 by actual observation .
Arcturus therefore by this observation has moved southward 2~ 35~ , 2 in 78,255 years .
By the foregoing comparisons Arcturus appears to have moved as in the following table .
Westwd .
Southwd .
years .
' ' ' ' ' ' By the small star Feb. 14 , 1690 , in 77,237 1 51,35 2 35,0 n Bootis Feb. 14 , 1690 , in 78,257 1 18,8 2 6,3 n Bootis Apr. 5 , 1691 , in 77,120 1 31,5 2 5,3 n Bootis May 4 , 1691 , in 77,071 1 31,8 2 10,3 n Bootis May 27 , 1692 , in 75,978 1 28,4 2 9,3 By ~ Bootis May 27 , 1692 , in 75,978 1 34,2 2 33,0 ~ Bootis Feb. 14 , 1690 , in 78,257 not obs .
2 35,2 As the quantity of the motion of Arcturus southward in declination , as deduced from a comparison with n Bootis , differs considerably from the quantities given by the small star and ~ Bootis , which agree very nearly together , I have compared n Bootis with some of the neighbouring stars , as that star , though of the third magnitude only , may have a small motion of its own .
On the 14th of February , 1690 , the difference of declination between n and ~ Bootis was observed by Mr. Flamsteed to be = 2~ , 1~ 47~ , 8 .
By computation , that difference in 1768 should have been 2~ 43~ , 9 less , = 2~ 9~ 3~ , 9 : but it was actually observed to be 2~ 8~ 34~ , 3 only .
The star n Bootis therefore appears by this comparison to have moved southward 29~ , 6 in 78,257 years .
On the 27th of May , 1692 , n Bootis was observed by Mr. Flamsteed to be 2~ 11~ 37~ , 8 to the north of ~ Bootis , which quantity should by computation be 2~ 39~ , 1 less in 1768 , or 2~ 8~ 58~ , 7 .
But it was found to be 2~ 8~ 34~ , 3 .
The star n therefore appears to have moved southward 0~ 24~ , 4 in 75,978 years .
On the 25th of April , 1693 , n Bootis was observed to be 40~ 20~ , 8 to the south of f Bootis , a star of the 6th magnitude ; and by myself that difference was observed to be 42~ 37~ , 5 , by taking the mean of two observations on the 24th and 26th of May , 1768 , differing only 4~ , 7 .
According to computation , the variation of n Bootis in declination during the interval of the two observations was 1359~ , 3 , and of f Bootis 1256~ , 0 ; and therefore the difference of variation in declination was 1~ 43~ , 3 , by which the distance of the stars was increased .
The difference in declination therefore in 1768 , if neither of the stars moved , should have been 0~ 42~ 04~ , 1 ; but it was observed to be 33~ , 4 greater , by which quantity therefore n Bootis must have moved southward in 75,052 years .
By reducing all the foregoing deductions to 78 years , Arcturus appears to have moved , Westw .
Southw .
' ' ' By the small Star , Feb. 14 , 1690 1 52,380 2 36,43 n Bootis Feb. 14 , 1690 1 18,541 2 5,88 n Bootis Apr. 5 , 1691 1 32,557 2 6,75 n Bootis May 4 , 1691 1 32,906 2 11,87 n Bootis May 27 , 1692 1 30,752 2 12,74 By ~ Bootis May 27 , 1692 1 36,707 2 37,07 ~ Bootis Feb. 14 , 1690 not observe .
2 34,69 But the Star n Bootis appears also to have moved Southward .
' ' ' By ~ Bootis Feb. 14 , 1690 0 29,503 ~ Bootis May 27 , 1692 0 25,049 By f Bootis Apr. 5 , 1693 0 34,712 By a mean 0 29,755 As Arcturus appears to have moved southward of n Bootis 2~ 9~ , 31 , by taking a mean of the four quantities resulting from the comparisons with that star ; and as n Bootis has also moved southward of some of the neighbouring small stars by 29~ , 755 in the same time , Arcturus upon the whole has moved 2~ 39~ 06 to the south , by the comparisons with n Bootis only ; and therefore , by taking a mean of all the results , Arcturus has altered its right ascension less than the neighbouring stars by 1~ 33~ , 97 in 78 years , in which time it has also moved 2~ 36~ , 81 to the south of the same stars .
In order to see how far the motion of right ascension is to be depended upon , which is deduced from the above comparisons , I have selected and computed the following observations , made at Shirburn castle with a transit instrument of 51/ 4 feet , placed exactly in the plane of the meridian , and consequently more to be relied upon than those made with a mural instrument .
By a mean of five observations , made on the 7th , 12th , 23d , 24th , and 31st of May , 1741 , O. S. the difference in right ascension between n Bootis and Arcturus was 5~ 22~ 38~ , 9 , the extremes differing only 4~ , 4 of a degree .
The difference in the variation of right ascension to the end of May , 1768 , is 20~ , 5 , by which the ascensional difference is diminished .
It should therefore have been 5~ 22~ 18~ , 4 ; but it was observed to be 5~ 21~ 43~ , 4 .
Therefore in 27 years Arcturus has moved westward 35~ , 0 .
On the 16th and 20th of May , 1744 , the difference in right ascension between n Bootis and Arcturus was 5~ 22~ 30~ , 0 by each of the observations , which difference should have been , supposing neither of the stars to have any proper motion , 5~ 22~ 11~ , 7 in May , 1768 .
But it was found to be 28~ , 3 less ; by so much therefore had Arcturus moved westward in 24 years .
On the 24th of May , and 8th of June , 1746 , the difference in right ascension between the same stars was 5~ 22~ 26~ , 2 , by taking a mean of the two observations ; that difference should have been 5~ 22~ 09~ , 5 in 1768 .
But it was observed = 5~ 21~ 43~ , 4 .
Arcturus therefore in 22 years has moved 26~ , 1 to the west .
Lastly ; on the 16th of April , and 27th and 28th of May , 1747 , the difference in right ascension between n Bootis and Arcturus , by taking a mean of the three observations , was 5~ 22~ 25~ , 0 .
By computation putation the variation in the difference of right ascension was 16~ , 0 , by which the ascensional difference should have been diminished , and = 5~ 22~ 09~ , 0 .
But by observation it was found = 5~ 21~ 43~ , 4 : Arcturus therefore by this last observation appears to have gone 25,6 , ' ' westward .
By the observations therefore at Shirburn Castle Arcturus appears to have gone westward as in the following table ; in the last column of which are contained the quantities resulting from the observations of each year , reduced to 78 years .
' ' ' ' ' ' 1741 0 35,0 1 41,11 1744 0 28,3 1 31,97 1746 0 26,1 1 32,59 1747 0 25,6 1 34,90 Mean 1 35,14 The mean of all the observations , when reduced to an interval of 78 years , is 1~ 35~ , 14 , which differs only 1~ , 17 from the mean of the other comparisons .
As then the proper motions of Arcturus westward in right ascension = 1~ 33~ , 974 , and 2~ 36~ , 81 in declination southward , seem well established , the real motion of Arcturus is inclined in an angle of 30~ 56~ to the west of the meridian or horary circle , and to be in that direction 3~ 2~ , 81 in 78 years , or at the rate of 2~ , 343 in a year .
As this direction of its motion is nearly perpendicular to the plane of the ecliptic , the latitude of Arcturus must diminish yearly almost in the same proportion ; and its longitude will alter less than that of other stars , though not so considerably as its right ascension .
The proper motion of Arcturus then , in right ascension Westward , being 1~ , 205 , and in declination 2~ , 005 , its annual precession in right ascension is 41~ , 108 , and in declination 19~ , 133 ; and the true right ascension of Arcturus , on Jan. 1 , 1773 , is 211~ 19~ 47~ , 4 , and declination North 20~ 22~ 23~ , 3 .
As none of the other principal stars have been found to have a motion so considerable as this , though many of the stars of the first magnitude , as for instance , Sirius , Procyon , ~ Aquilae , ~ Orionis , as also ~ Aquilae of inferior magnitude , do really vary their positions ( and perhaps all of the first order will hereafter be found to have a proper motion ) , we may , I think , fairly conclude that Arcturus is the nearest star to our system , visible in this hemisphere .
If therefore the annual parallax of the fixed stars can ever be discovered , that is , if the diameter of the annual orbit bear a sensible proportion to the distance of the nearest fixed star , it is most likely to be discovered from the observations of Arcturus .
The system of the world , considered in an enlarged sense , and agreeable to the idea we may entertain of an allpowerful benevolent Creator , may be taken to occupy the whole-abyss of space , and to consist of an assemblage of bodies , having different magnitudes , and emitting various degrees and modifications of light .
The apparent change of situation visible from the planet which we inhabit , and which revolves round one of the great bodies constituting a part of the general system , as a center , may be owing either to the motion of our own system in absolute space , or , if our system should be at rest , to a real motion in the stars themselves : from whence the angular distances of the stars must vary in proportion to the velocity of those motions , or to the direction of those motions with respect to ourselves .
I have reason , at present , to believe that a small motion may be discovered in the star o Ceti , and perhaps in other stars that vary in degrees of brightness , which the diligence of future astronomers will discover , and perhaps in less time than at first sight might seem necessary , when we consider the several improvements which have of late been made in the methods of observing the heavenly bodies .
As the motion of Arcturus in declination ( the quantity of which we have thus endeavoured to ascertain ) has been often acknowledged , it is matter of wonder that some astronomers , by comparing either the altitude or zenith distance of the Sun 's limb with Arcturus , without previously settling the quantity of that star 's motion in declination , or at least doing it indirectly , should endeavour to determine whether the obliquity of the ecliptic hath remained constant , or still continues to diminish , as it should seem , to have done for many centuries past , from the observations of successive astronomers .
Mr. Cassini , and Mr. le Monnier , have both practised this method , and are of opinion , that the obliquity of the ecliptic hath not altered ; or , if it hath altered , that the quantity of its alteration is not near so considerable as hath been imagined by some celebrated astronomers .
By observing for several days before and after the solstice the altitude or zenith distance of the Sun 's limb , and that of a star situated near the same parallel , the differences to be remarked in process of time in the distances of the Sun from that star ( the motion of the star in declination being allowed for during that interval of time ) , will be the quantity by which the Sun will have approached to or have receded from the star .
If the star were absolutely a fixed point , and the observations sufficiently numerous , that , by taking a mean , the necessary and unavoidable errors in observation might either be considerably diminished or almost annihilated , the method might be practised to great advantage .
But as the star ( Arcturus ) had a proper motion , and its apparent place was continually varying from the effect of the nutation of the earth 's axis ; as the limb of the Sun was sometimes approaching to , and sometimes receding from , the star , by a kind of libratory motion from the effect of the nutation ; also and as the obliquity of the ecliptic itself was , in all probability , continually diminishing ; from a combination and as it were involution of these motions no certain conclusion could be drawn , since , in the space of a few years , the apparent obliquity may be the same , and yet the mean obliquity may have diminished , or perhaps , in the space of a few years , the obliquity may appear to have increased , when it may really have become less .
Whereas , by reducing the observations to their mean position , and by assigning to each known cause its proper and allowed effect , a regularity and uniformity must necessarily take place , as far at least as is consistent with the unavoidable errors in observing .
Mr. Cassini , in the Memoirs of the Academy of Sciences for 1767 , acquaints us , that , in 1748 , the apparent distance of Arcturus from the upper limb of the Sun , at the time of the solstice , was the same as in 1766 .
In 1748 .
Distance of Arcturus from o ' ' ' ' ' ' the solstitial limb of the Sun 3 13 36 40 Altitude of Arcturus ... .
61 41 17 0 Therefore the apparent solstitial altitude ... ... .
64 55 13 40 In 1766 .
Distance of Arcturus from the solstitial limb of the Sun 3 19 32 0 Altitude of Arcturus ... .
61 35 42 0 Therefore the apparent solstitial altitude ... ... .
64 55 14 0 The same astronomer has , in the Memoirs for 1759 , p. 325 , communicated the following conclusions .
Dist .
of the star Reduction .
Solstitial distance .
from ~ 's limb .
1763 .
o ' ' ' ' ' ' o ' ' ' June 14 .
37 29 + 11 13 18 30 15 .
3 10 16 +8 13 3 18 29 25 .
3 15 40 +2 48 3 18 28 July 1 .
2 59 1+ 19 22 3 18 23 2 .
2 54 55 + 23 33 3 18 28 3 .
2 50 18 + 28 83 18 26 Mean 3 18 27 Mr. le Monnier , in the Memoires for 1762 , p. 269 .
has published the following distances of Arcturus from the limb of the Sun , reduced to the solstitial point , with a view to obtain differences in the apparent obliquity of the ecliptic : and , from the observations vations made with the gnomon of St. Sulpice , and communicated by Mr. le Monnier , in the same volume , it should seem that that astronomer is of opinion , that the obliquity of the ecliptic hath no other variation than what the nutation of the earth 's axis will occasion ; and that therefore we must either abandon the absolute diminution of the ecliptic , or at least suppose it extremely small , since , in the space of eighteen years , it hath not produced a sensible alteration .
o ' ' ' 1738 .
3 10 15 1740 .
3 11 5 1742 .
3 11 48 1763 .
3 18 40 with the mural quadrant of 5 feet .
3 18 35 with the large mural instrument .
As the result of the observations only , and not the observations themselves , are communicated , I have only to observe , that there is a very considerable difference between the conclusions of the two astronomers for the same year 1763 , and , at the same time , to declare my suspicion , that if the apparent ( for such I apprehend them to be ) were reduced to the mean distances , they would probably afford a confirmation of the diminution of the ecliptic .
For the following observations of the Sun 's zenith distance , made at Shirburn Castle , near the summer solstices of the years 1743 , 1746 , 1748 , and 1766 , and of Arcturus in the years 1743 , 1746 , and 1766 , when reduced to their mean state at the solstice , do not confirm the assertion of Mr. Cassini , but are an evident and absolute proof that the obliquity of the ecliptic has sensibly diminished during an interval of 23 , and even of 18 years .
The observations of 1743 were made with a mural quadrant of five French feet , constructed by the late Mr. Sisson : but as the linear divisions were found to be somewhat less accurate than was expected , and as the body of the quadrant was not framed with proper strength and solidity , Mr. Bird was employed in the summer of the year 1745 , by the Earl of Macclesfield , ( the body of the instrument having been strengthened by screwing a large and broad plate of brass upon the cross-bars ) , to put a set of points upon the limb between the 90 and 96 arches of linear divisions .
By these operations the line of collimation was found to have varied , and to be = 6~,3 , by which the zenith distances were given too small , by the positive divisions , from the end of 1746 to the end of June 1751 , when Mr. Bird bisected the spaces between the points which he had formerly added in 1745 .
But after the year 1751 , the error of the line of collimation was = 2~,6 , as appears from observations of ~ Persei , ~ and ~ Draconis , by which the zenith distances are also given too small ; and in that state the instrument continued to the year 1767 , when a new set of wires was put into the telescope , and the line of collimation thereby altered .
The error of the line of collimation from 1743 to 1745 cannot directly be ascertained , for want of zenith observations ; but , from some indirect methods , it should seem that the error was as nearly as possible = 2~ , to be added to the observed zenith distances .
Observed zenith BaroThermoRefracSun 's semiDist .
from Observations redistance .
meter .
meter .
tion .
diameter .
solstice .
duced to solstice .
1743 .
o ' ' ' ' ' + ' ' ' o ' ' ' o ' ' ' June 7 .
Up .
L. 28 37 39 29,54 62 30,2 + 15 48,1 0 43 5,7 28 10 51,6 8 .
Lo .
L. 29 3 37 29,36 60 30,8 15 48 37 22,3 28 10 57,5 9 .
Up .
L. 28 26 44,2 29,46 591/ 2 30 + 15 47,9 32 3,3 28 10 58,8 12 .
Up .
L. 28 13 14,5 29,72 611/ 2 29,9 + 15 47,6 18 31,6 28 11 0,4 18 .
Up .
L. 27 57 9 29,81 67 29,4 + 15 47,3 2 30 28 10 55,7 19 .
Lo .
L. 28 27 28,5 29,54 671/ 2 29,8 15 47,2 1 16,1 28 10 55 21 .
Up .
L. 27 54 41,8 29,66 66 29,1 + 15 47,1 0 2,8 28 10 55,2 22 .
Lo .
L. 28 26 22,2 29,50 63 29,8 15 47 0 3,4 28 11 1,6 23 .
Up .
L. 27 55 10,2 29,59 61 29,5 + 15 47 0 28,6 28 10 58,1 24 .
Lo .
L. 28 27 35,5 29,59 58 30,4 15 46,9 1 18,8 28 11 0,2 25 .
Up .
L. 27 57 15,5 29,39 58 29,5 + 15 46,9 2 33,7 28 10 58,2 27 .
Lo .
L. 28 32 34 29,57 58 30,5 15 46,9 6 17,9 28 10 59,7 Mean ... ... ... 28 10 58,2 Sun 's parallax ... ... .
4,1 28 10 54,1 Nutation ... ... . .
+ 6,7 28 11 0,8 Line of collimation ... . .
+2 Mean solstitial zenith distance , 1743 , 28 11 2,8 1746 .
o ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' o ' ' ' o ' ' ' May 31 .
Lo .
L. 29 57 50,5 29,48 78 30,5 15 48,8 1 31 41,9 28 10 50,3 June 5 .
Up .
L. 28 48 24,8 29,621/ 2 64 30,4 + 15 48,3 53 50 28 10 53,5 6 .
Lo .
L. 29 13 36,3 29,62 65 30,8 15 48,2 47 26,3 28 10 52,6 7 .
Up .
L. 28 35 58,9 29,53 71 + 29,4 + 15 48,1 41 24,3 28 10 52,1 10 .
Lo .
L. 28 52 1,8 29,28 67 29,8 15 47,8 25 49,8 28 10 54 16 .
Up .
L. 28 0 14,4 28,69 591/ 2 28,7 + 15 47,3 5 34,6 28 10 55,8 19 .
Lo .
L. 28 27 5,1 29,60 581/ 2 30,3 15 47,2 0 59,8 28 10 48,4 22 .
Up .
L. 27 54 45 29,75 631/ 2 29,4 + 15 47 08 28 10 53,4 23 .
Lo .
L. 28 26 47,4 29,85 64 30,2 15 47 0 40,4 28 10 50,2 26 .
Up .
L. 27 59 23,4 29,63 69 29 + 15 46,9 4 45,9 28 10 53,4 27 .
Lo .
L. 28 33 6,6 29,63 741/ 2 29,2 15 46,9 6 57,1 28 10 51,8 28 .
Up .
L. 28 4 11,8 29,50 651/ 2 29,3 + 15 46,9 9 32,9 28 10 55,1 30 .
Lo .
L. 28 42 5,9 29,22 631/ 2 30,2 15 46,9 15 58,2 28 10 51 July 4 .
Up .
L. 28 28 16,6 29,67 69 29,6 + 15 46,9 33 40,1 28 10 53 Mean ... ... ... 28 10 52,5 Sun 's parallax ... ... .
4,1 28 10 48,4 Nutation ... ... . .
+ 9,4 28 10 57,8 Error of the line of collimation. .
+ 6,3 Mean solstitial zenith distance , 1746 , 28 11 4,1 Observed zenith BaroThermoRefrac~ Sun 's semiDist .
from Observations redistance meter .
meter .
tion .
diameter .
solstice .
duced to soltice .
1748 .
o ' ' ' ' ' + ' ' ' o ' ' ' o ' ' ' June 15 .
Up .
L. 28 1 21,1 29,511/ 2 64 29,3 + 15 47,4 06 38,6 28 10 59,2 16 .
Lo .
L. 28 30 41,3 29,55 60 30,3 15 47,4 4 31,9 28 10 52,3 20 .
Up .
L. 27 54 45,7 29,861/ 2 631/ 2 29,5 + 15 47,2 0 5,7 28 10 56,7 21 .
Lo .
L. 28 26 11,3 29,651/ 2 75 + 29,2 15 47,1 0 1,3 28 10 52,1 22 .
Up .
L. 27 55 3,5 29,67 811/ 2 28,2 + 15 47 0 21,4 28 10 57,3 23 .
Lo .
L. 28 27 18,7 29,601/ 2 72 29,3 15 47 1 6,7 28 10 54,3 24 .
Up .
L. 27 56 59,7 29,55 + 65 29 + 15 46,9 2 16,7 28 10 58,9 29 .
Lo .
L. 28 40 29,3 29,90 64 30,5 13 46,9 14 18,7 28 10 55,2 Mean ... ... ... 28 10 55,8 Sun 's parallax ... ... .
4,1 28 10 51,7 Nutation ... ... . .
+ 6,1 28 10 57,8 Error of the line of collimation. .
+ 6,3 Mean solstitial zenith distance , 1748 , 28 11 4,1 ~ .
o ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' o ' ' ' o ' ' ' June 11 .
Lo .
L. 28 47 12 29,51 62 30,4 15 47,7 0 20 42,3 28 11 12,4 12 .
Up .
L. 28 11 38,3 29,38 61 29,6 + 15 47,6 16 47,1 28 11 8,4 17 .
Lo .
L. 28 29 47,9 29,151/ 2 66 29,4 15 47,3 3 20,2 28 11 9,8 21 .
Up .
L. 27 54 57,4 29,72 683/ 4 29 + 15 47,1 0 29 28 11 13,5 22 .
Lo .
L. 28 26 39,6 29,871/ 2 703/ 4 29,7 15 47 0 11,9 28 11 10,4 23 .
Lo .
L. 28 27 19,2 29,951/ 2 751/ 2 29,5 15 47 0 48,6 28 11 13,1 24 .
Up .
L. 27 56 45,7 29,80 781/ 4 28,4 + 15 46,9 1 50,1 28 11 10,9 25 .
Lo .
L. 28 29 41,2 29,49 74 29,2 15 46,9 3 16,2 28 11 7,3 27 .
Up .
L. 28 2 18,5 29,40 67 28,9 + 15 46,9 7 22,6 28 11 11,7 29 .
Lo .
L. 28 29 30,6 29,28 66 29,7 15 46,9 13 7 28 11 6,4 Mean ... ... ... 28 11 10,5 Sun 's parallax ... ... .
4,1 28 11 6,4 Nutation ... ... . .
+ 7,6 28 11 14 Error of the line of collimation. .
+ 2,6 Mean ~ zenith distance , 1766 , 28 11 16,6 Observed zenith Refrac~ AberNuta~Observations ~ .
of ~ .
tion .
ration .
tion .
sion .
reduced .
~ .
o ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' o ' ' ' May 12 .
31 6 57,8 34 1,9 + 1,4 + 2,1 31 7 33,4 17 .
31 6 57,8 34 0,8 + 1,4 + 1,8 31 7 34,2 18 .
31 6 57,8 34 0,6 + 1,4 + 1,8 31 7 34,4 June 5 .
31 6 52,3 34 + 2,9 + 1,2 + 0,9 31 7 31,3 9 .
31 6 50,3 34 + 3,8 + 1,2 + 0,7 31 7 30 10 .
31 6 52 34 +4+ 1,2 + 0,6 31 7 31,8 16 .
31 6 57 34 + 5,3 ~ 1,2 + 0,3 31 7 37,8 18 .
31 6 54,8 34 + 5,5 + 1,2 + 0,1 31 7 35,6 25 .
31 6 52 34 + 6,7 + 1,2 0,2 31 7 33,7 July 1 .
31 6 52 34 + 7,8 + 1,2 0,5 31 7 34,5 Mean ... ... ... ... ... .
31 7 33,6 Error of the line of collimation ... ... . .
+2 Mean zenith distance of Arcturus , June 21 , 1743,. .
31 7 35,6 Mean zenith distance of the Sun 's center , June 21 , 1743 , 28 11 2,8 Mean distance of Arcturus from the Sun 's center , 1743 , 2 56 32,8 1746 .
o ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' o ' ' ' June 4 .
31 7 51,1 34 + 2,5 5,8 + 1,1 31 8 22,9 21 .
31 7 53,1 34 + 6,1 5,9 0 31 8 27,3 22 .
31 7 50,2 34 + 6,3 5,9 0 31 8 24,6 23 .
31 7 52,3 34 + 6,4 5,9 0,1 31 8 27,7 Oct. 9 .
31 7 58,6 34 + 8,9 6,4 5,7 31 8 29,4 Mean ... ... ... ... ... .
31 8 26,4 Error of the line of collimation ... ... . .
+ 6,3 Mean zenith distance of Arcturus , June 21 , 1746,. .
31 8 32,7 Mean zenith distance of the Sun 's center , June 21 , 1746 , 28 11 4,1 Mean distance of Arcturus from the Sun 's center , 1746 , 2 57 28,6 Observed zenith BaroThermoRefracAberNutaPrecesObservations dist. of Arcturus .
meter .
meter .
tion .
ration .
tion .
sion .
reduced .
1766 .
o ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' o ' ' ' May 13 .
31 14 20,7 29,46 43 34,9 1,9 7,6 +2 31 14 48,1 21 .
31 14 23,1 29,81 46 35,1 0,2 7,6 + 1,7 31 14 52,1 22 .
31 14 19,9 29,67 49 34,7 0 7,6 + 1,6 31 14 48,6 June 23 .
31 14 20,8 29,90 70 33,1 + 6,4 7,7 0,1 31 14 52,5 Mean ... ... ... ... ... .
31 14 50,3 Error of the line of collimation ... ... . .
+ 2,6 Mean zenith distance of Arcturus , June 21 , 1766,. .
31 14 52,9 Mean zenith distance of the Sun 's center , June 21 , 1766 , 28 11 16,6 Mean distance of Arcturus from the Sun 's center , 1766 , 33 36,3 From the foregoing observations , it appears that the mean solstitial zenith distance in summer was as follows .
Variation in 100 years .
o ' ' ' ' ' 1743 .
28 11 2,8 60 1746 .
28 11 4,1 62,5 1748 .
28 11 4,1 69,4 1766 .
28 11 16,6 And , by comparing the three former with the latter , the variation of the obliquity of the ecliptic in 100 years is as is expressed in the last column of the table .
By comparing the distance of Arcturus from the center of the Sun in 1743 , with the same distance as observed in 1766 ( an allowance being made for the proper motion of the star during the interval , as also for its variation in declination arising from the precession cession of the equinoxes ) , it appears that its distance is 17~,3 less than it would have been , if the distance of the Sun 's center from the equator had remained unvaried .
By that quantity , therefore , the obliquity of the ecliptic has altered in 23 years ; which is at the rate of 75~,2 in 100 years .
By comparing , in like manner , the distance in 1746 , the obliquity of the ecliptic has diminished 15~,6 in 20 years , or 78~ in 100 years .
o ' ' ' o ' ' ' Distance in 1743..,. .
2 56 32,8 In 1746 .
2 57 28,6 Motion of the star in decl .
Southward 7 20,8 6 23,3 Computed distance in 1766. .
33 53,6 33 51,9 Observed distance in 1766 ... 33 36,3 33 36,3 Variation of obliquity ... .
17,3 15,6 The foregoing deductions prove , I think , beyond all doubt , that the obliquity has become less ; but as the interval of time between the two terms of comparison is so short , that the errors committed in observing may bear a sensible proportion to the small quantities just now found , and which , perhaps , are somewhat too large ; let us have recourse to Mr. Flamsteed 's observations , and compare them with observations made by myself , in the course of the last and present years .
For this purpose , I have reduced all the observations of the Sun , made in 1690 , from May 26 to June 24 , O. S. and also all the observations of Arcturus , made in the same year , to their mean position at the summer solstice of that year .
The observations , together with my own made at Oxford , are as follows .
Observed zen .
dist. RefracSun 's semiDist .
from Observations of the Sun 's limbs .
tion .
diameter .
solstice .
reduced .
1690 .
o ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' o ' ' ' o ' ' ' May 26 .
Lo .
L. 29 6 20 31,8 15 46,4 0 50 26,1 28 0 39,3 Up .
L. 28 34 50 31,1 15 46,4 41,4 June 2 .
Lo .
L. 28 31 35 31,1 15 45,7 0 15 28,3 52,1 Up .
L. 28 05 30,4 15 45,7 52,8 3 .
Lo .
L. 28 28 20 31 15 45,6 0 12 8,6 56,8 Up .
L. 27 56 45 30,3 15 45,6 51,1 4 .
Lo .
L. 28 25 15 30,9 15 45,5 09 10,9 49,5 Up .
L. 27 53 55 30,3 28 0 59,9 6 .
Lo .
L. 28 20 40 30,8 15 45,5 04 30,1 28 0 55,2 Up .
L. 27 49 15 30,2 28 1 0,6 7 .
Up .
L. 27 47 10 30,1 15 45,4 02 46,8 28 0 38,7 Lo .
L. 28 18 40 30,8 28 0 38,6 10 .
Lo .
L. 28 16 10 30,7 15 45,3 00 5,5 28 0 49,9 Up .
L. 27 44 40 30,1 28 0 49,9 12 .
Up .
L. 27 44 50 30,1 15 45,3 00 22 28 0 43,4 Lo .
L. 28 16 45 30,8 28 1 8,5 13 .
Lo .
L. 28 17 17,5 30,8 15 45,1 01 7,4 28 0 55,8 Up .
L. 27 45 50 30,1 28 0 58,8 14 .
Up .
L. 28 13 30 30,8 15 45,1 02 17,6 28 0 58,1 Lo .
L. 27 46 50 30,1 28 0 47,6 16 .
Up .
L. 27 50 40 30,2 15 45,1 03 51,8 28 1 3,5 Lo .
L. 28 22 15 30,9 28 19 17 .
Up .
L. 27 53 5 30,2 15 45 08 16,4 28 1 3,8 Lo .
L. 28 24 30 30,9 28 0 59,5 20 .
Lo .
L. 28 34 15 31,1 15 45 0 17 56,4 28 1 4,7 Up .
L. 28 2 45 30,4 28 14 24 .
Up .
L 28 21 5 30,8 15 45,1 0 36 30,6 28 0 50,3 Mean ... ... ... ... ... ... 28 0 54,2 Error of the line of collimation ... ... ... .
1 30 27 59 24,2 Sun 's parallax ... ... ... ... ... 4,1 27 59 20,1 Nutation ... ... ... ... ... . .
+ 9,5 Mean solstitial zen~ dist. of the Sun 's center , June 11 , 1690 , O. S. 27 59 29,6 Observed zenith RefracAberNutaPrecesObservations dist. of Arcturus .
tion .
ration .
tion .
sion .
reduced .
1690 .
o ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' o ' ' ' Feb. 14 .
30 39 20 33,8 -12,2 5,1 2,3 30 39 34,2 Apr. 13 .
30 39 20 33,8 5,5 5,3 5,4 30 39 37,6 25 .
30 39 10 3,3 5,4 6 29,1 26 .
30 39 15 2,9 5,4 6,1 34,4 May 13~ 10 + 0,4 5,5 6,9 31,8 14 .
10 + 0,6 5,5 7 31,9 15 .
30 39 10 33,8 + 0,8 5,5 7 32,1 20 .
10 + 1,9 5,5 7,3 32,9 22 .
10 + 2,3 5,5 7,4 33,2 24 .
30 39 5+ 2,7 5,6 7,5 28,4 June 12 .
10 33,8 + 6,4 5,6 8,5 36,1 13 .
10 + 6,6 5,6 8,6 36,2 16 .
30 39 10 + 7,1 5,6 8,7 36,6 17 .
10 + 7,2 5,6 8,8 30 39 33,4 July 1 .
30 39 10 33,8 + 9,4 5,7 9,5 30 39 30,6 Dec. 13 .
30 39 35 33,8 6,6 6,5 18,1 30 39 37,6 14 .
30 39 40 33,8 6,8 6,5 18,2 30 39 42,3 Mean , January 1 , 1690 , O. S ... ... ... 30 39 34 Precession to June 11 , 1690 ... ... ... + 8,4 Mean zenith distance of Arcturus , June 11 , 1690. .
30 39 42,4 Mean solstitial zenith distance of the Sun 's center , June 11 , 1690 ... ... ... . .
27 59 29,6 Mean distance of Arcturus in declination from the Sun 's center , 1690 ... ... ... ... 2 40 12,8 Observed zeBaroTherRefracSun 's semiDist .
from Observations ~ distance of meter .
mometion .
diameter .
solstice .
reduced .
the Sun 's upper ter .
limb .
1771 .
o ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' o ' ' ' o ' ' ' June 8 .
28 36 47,6 30,081/ 2 641/ 3 30,9 15 48 0 36 0,4 28 17 6,1 14 .
28 11 38,1 29,94 63 30 15 47,4 10 46,6 8,9 18 .
28 3 4,4 29,75 61 + 29,7 15 47,2 2 8,3 13 21 .
28 0 55,4 30,082/ 3 651/ 3 29,7 15 47 0 0,8 11,3 22 .
28 1 1,4 30,07 66 + 29,6 15 47 0 7,6 28 17 10,4 24 .
28 2 26,1 30,07 62 30 15 46,9 1 35,8 7,2 25 .
28 3 46,9 30,05 69 29,5 15 46,9 2 56,8 6,5 26 .
28 5 38,1 29,971/ 2 68 29,5 15 46,9 4 42,7 11,8 29 .
28 13 21,3 29,84 61 30,2 15 ~,9 12 27,7 28 17 10,7 Mean ... ... ... ... ... .
28 17 8,7 Sun 's parallax ... ... ... ... .
4,1 28 17 4,6 Nutation ... ... ... ... ... 6,8 28 16 57,8 Error of the line of collimation ... ... . .
+ 4,8 Mean solstitial zenith distance of the Sun 's center , 1771 , 28 17 2,6 Observed zenith BaroTherRefracSun 's semiDist .
from Observations distance of the Sun 's meter .
mometion .
diameter .
solstice .
reduced .
limbs .
ter .
1772 .
o ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' o ' ' ' o ' ' ' June 8 .
Lo .
L. 29 4 31,3 30,18 71 30,7 15 48 0 31 59,9 28 17 14,1 9 .
Up .
L. 28 28 1 30,051/ 4 671/ 2 30,1 + 15 47,9 27 5,4 21 17 13,6 11 .
Lo .
L. 28 51 5,5 30,101/ 2 713/ 4 30,3 15 47,7 18 29,2 18,9 12 .
Lo .
L. 28 47 15,7 30,222/ 3 602/ 3 31,2 15 47,6 14 48,4 10,9 14 .
Up .
L. 28 9 34,4 30,151/ 2 63 30,1 + 15 47,4 8 38,4 13,5 Lo .
L. 28 41 11,1 30,8 16,1 15 .
Up .
L. 28 7 5,4 29,941/ 2 72 29,2 + 15 47,3 6 10,7 11,2 Lo .
L. 28 38 40,8 29,8 28 17 12,6 16 .
Up .
L. 28 5 0,3 29,821/ 2 703/ 4 29,1 + 15 47,3 4 7,6 9,1 Lo .
L. 28 36 38,6 29,8 13,5 18 .
Up .
L. 28 2 16,4 30,023/ 4 711/ 2 29,2 + 15 47,2 1 15,6 17,2 Lo .
L. 28 33 48,1 29,7 15 19 .
Up .
L. 28 1 26,3 29,97 751/ 3 28,8 + 15 47,1 0 26,8 15,4 Lo .
L. 28 32 55,8 29,5 11,4 20 .
Lo .
L. 28 32 30,3 29,93 79 29,1 15 47,1 0 2,8 28 17 9,5 21 .
Lo L. 28 32 32,8 29,79 72 29,6 15 47 0 3,5 11,9 22 .
Up .
L. 28 1 24,8 30,001/ 4 73 29 + 15 47 0 29,9 28 17 10,9 23 .
Up .
L. 28 2 14,4 30,01 761/ 4 28,8 + 15 47 1 19,4 28 17 10,8 Lo .
L. 28 33 54,1 29,5 17,2 26 .
Up .
L. 28 7 20,3 29,96 85 28,2 + 15 46,9 6 18,9 16,5 Lo .
L. 28 38 50,4 28,8 28 17 13,4 Mean ... ... ... ... ... 28 17 13,4 Sun 's parallax ... ... ... ... .
4,1 28 17 9,3 Nutation ... ... ... ... . .
8,7 28 17 0,6 Error of the line of collimation ... ... .
+ 4,8 Mean solstitial zenith distance of the Sun 's center , 1772 , 28 17 5,4 Observed ~BaroTher RefracAberNutaPreces~ ~ distance of ~ .
~tion .
~ .
tion .
sion .
reduced .
~ .
ter .
~~ ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ~ ' ' ' ~ 11 .
31 21 53,6 29,87 73 32,9 + 9,4 + 1,9 10,1 31 22 27,7 Aug. 11 .
31 21 56,6 29,91 ~ 33,8 + 12,2 + 2,1 11,7 33 17 .
50,6 29,93 75 + 3~,8 + 12,2 + 2,1 12 25,7 19 .
54,6 29,76 77 ~+ 12,3 + 2,2 12,1 29,5 Oct. 10 .
31 21 58,1 29,99 ~ 61 34,2 + 7,7 + 2,6 15,1 27,2 Nov. 2 .
31 22 3,3 29,32 1/ 4 49 34~5 + 4~4 + 2,7 16 28,9 7 .
~ 3,5 29 , ~ 49 34,3 + 3,8 + 2,7 16,3 28 12 .
8,3 29~~ 38 35~9 + 2,1 + 2,7 16,5 32,5 ~ .
31 22 12,3 29,85 46 + 34,1 + 0,4 + 2,7 16,9 31 22 32,6 ~ .
10,3 ~+ 40 35~4 + 0,2 + 2,7 17 31,6 ~ .
11,3 29,37 40 35,2 0,2 + 2,7 17,2 31,8 Dec. 10 .
15,3 29~62 39 ~ ~,7 3~9 + 2,9 18 32 ~ .
31 22 12,3 29,69 45 1/ 4 35,1 5+ 2,9 18,3 31 22 27 Mean zenith distance of Arcturus , January 1 , 1772 ... ... .
31 22 29,8 Precession to June 21 , 1772 ... ... ... ... . .
+9 Mean zenith distance of Arcturus , June 21 , 1772 ... ... .
31 22 38,8 Error of the line of collimation ... ... ... ... .
+ 4,2 True mean zenith distance of Arcturus , June 21 , 1772 ... . .
31 22 43 Mean zenith distance of the Sun 's center , June 21 , 1772 ... . .
28 17 5,4 Mean distance of Arcturus in declination from the Sun 's center , June 21 , 1772 ... ... ... ... ... . .
35 37,6 o ' ' ' Mean distance in June 1690. .
2 40 12,8 Precession , &amp;c. to June 1772. .
26 16,4 Computed distance in June 1772 .
36 29,2 Observed distance in June 1772 .
35 37,6 Diminution of obliquity in 82~years 51,6 From the foregoing observations it appears that , at the summer solstice of the year 1690 , Arcturus was 2~ 40~ 12~,8 to the South of the Sun 's center in declination : the motion of the star , in declination , from that time to the summer solstice of the year 1772 , including its proper motion , is 26~ 16~,4 .
Arcturus , therefore , in 1772 , should have been 3~ 6~ 29~,2 to the South of the Sun 's center , if the angle of the ecliptic and equator had not varied : but that distance was found by actual observation to be 51~,6 less .
By so much therefore must the obliquity of the ecliptic have become less in an interval of 82 years ; and , consequently , the variation in 100 years will be 62~,92 .
If the observations of Arcturus be reduced to the solstice of 1771 , and the zenith distance of the Sun 's center , as observed in that year , be made use of in the same manner , the variation of the obliquity in 81 years will be found = 48~,8 , and in 100 years = 60~ .
If the quantity of the arc of Mr. Flamsteed 's instrument were accurately known , the observations which he made at the winter solstice in 1690 might be compared with later observations , in order to determine both the quantity of the obliquity in 1690 , and also the variation since his time .
Accordingly , I have endeavoured to determine the error of the arc of the instrument between 28~ and 75~ of zenith distance , and proceeded in the following manner .
I computed several observations of the stars ~ Tauri , ~ Pleiadum , ~ and ~ Geminorum , and ~ , ~ , and ~ Sagittarii , as observed by Mr. Flamsteed , in the years 1690 , 1691 , and 1692 , and reducing them to the years 1760 and 1766 , I compared the differences of declination between those stars , resulting from Mr. Flamsteed 's observations , with the differences given by the places of the same stars , as settled by Dr. Bradley in 1760 , and also by actual observations of the same stars made at ShirburnCastle in 1766 ; and , by combining these differences together , I found that the whole arc of 90 degrees was too short by 43~ .
Supposing the error to be uniform , the proportional part of this quantity , thus found for the solstitial zenith distance of the Sun in June = 13~,4 , is nearly confirmed upon the authority of Mr. Flamsteed himself , who , in the prolegomena to the third volume of the Historia Caelestis , where he is deducing the latitude of the Royal Observatory at Greenwich , and the quantity of the obliquity in 1690 , from his own observations , allows the zenith distances at 28~ , 36~ , and 40~ , on his instrument , to be too small by 15~ and by 20~ , at 75~ .
I have therefore computed the observations of the Sun , made from November 30 to December 20 of 1690 , which , reduced to the solstice , are as in the following table ; to which are subjoined the observations made by myself at Oxford , at the winter solstice of 1771 .
Observed zenith RefracSun 's semiDist .
from Observations distance of the Sun 's tion .
diameter .
solstice .
reduced .
limbs .
++ 1690 .
o ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' o ' ' ' o ' ' ' Nov. 30 Lo .
L. 74 45 17,5 3 27,9 16 16,6 0 25 43,1 74 58 11,9 Up .
L. 74 12 40 3 19,6 + 16 16,6 74 57 59,3 Dec. 2 .
Lo .
L. 74 54 53 28,7 16 16,6 17 16,1 74 58 33,2 2 .
Up .
L. 74 21 25 3 21,7 19,4 10 .
Lo .
L. 75 11 03 32,7 16 17,2 0 4,6 20,1 Up .
L. 74 38 35 3 25,4 22,2 13 .
Lo .
L. 75 9 50 3 32,4 16 17,2 1 24,4 74 58 29,6 Up .
L. 74 37 15 3 25,3 21,9 15 .
Lo .
L. 75 6 45 3 31,6 16 17,3 4 39,4 74 58 38,7 Up .
L. 74 34 53 24,5 26,2 17 .
Lo .
L. 75 1 30 3 30,2 16 17,3 9 46,9 29,8 20 .
Up .
L. 74 13 15 3 19,8 + 16 17,3 25 38,8 74 58 30,9 Lo .
L. 74 46 53 27 16 17,3 74 58 53,5 Mean ... ... ... ... ... ... 74 58 25,9 Error of the line of collimation ... ... ... .
1 10 74 57 15,9 Sun 's parallax ... ... ... ... ... 8,5 74 57 7,4 Nutation ... ... ... ... ... . .
9,6 Mean solstitial zenith distance of the Sun 's center , Dec. 1690 , 74 56 57,8 Observed zeBaroTherRefracSun 's semiDist .
from Observations ~ distance of meter .
mometion .
diameter .
solstice .
reduced .
~ 's up .
limb .
ter .
++ o ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' o ' ' ' o ' ' ' 1771 .
Dec. 8 .
74 11 1,7 29,43 441/ 4 3 21 16 18 0 42 26,3 75 13 12,2 12 .
74 32 25,4 29,561/ 3 47 +3 25,2 16 18,5 21 3,4 17,7 16 .
74 46 32,3 28,68 452/ 3 3 22,7 16 18,7 7 2,5 21,8 19 .
74 51 57,3 29,23 42 3 29,6 16 19 1 26,1 17,2 24 .
74 51 48,5 29,07 40 3 29,6 16 19,1 1 31 13,4 25 .
74 50 24,2 29,43 411/ 4 3 31,2 16 19,2 2 56,9 16,7 27 .
74 46 13,3 29,421/ 2 481/ 2 3 26,6 16 19,2 7 13,4 17,7 30 .
74 36 13,9 30,13 391/ 4 3 34,1 16 19,3 17 9,3 75 13 21,8 Mean ... ... ... ... ... ... .
75 13 17,3 Sun 's parallax ... ... ... ... ... . .
8,5 75 13 8,8 Nutation ... ... ... ... ... ... + 7,9 75 13 16,7 Error of the line of collimation ... ... ... ... + 4,8 Mean solstitial zenith distance of the Sun 's center , December 1771 , 75 13 21,5 The mean obliquity of the ecliptic resulting from the zenith distances , as observed at the two solstices in 1690 , by applying the known latitude of the place , will be found to be widely different , if no correction be applied for the error of the instrument .
o ' ' ' o ' ' ' June , zenith distance 27 59 29,6 Dec. zen .
dist. 74 56 57,8 Latitude of Greenwich 51 28 38 51 28 38 23 29 8,4 23 28 19,8 But if the observations be corrected by the error of the instrument , the two results will be found to agree together as nearly as can be expected .
~ ' ' ' ' ' ' 27 59 29,6 74 56 57,8 + 13,4 + 35,8 27 59 43 74 57 33,6 51 28 38 51 28 38 Obliquity 23 28 55 23 28 55,6 Or , if the obliquity be required independent of a knowledge of the latitude of the place , it will be found to be = 23~ 28~ 55~,3 .
o ' ' ' December ... ... 74 57 33,6 June ... ... 27 59 43 Difference ... ... 46 57 50,6 Mean obliquity 1690 , 1/ 2 Diff. 23 28 55,3 By commparing the observations at the summer solstices of 1771 and 1772 with those at the winter solstice of 1771 , it appears that the mean obliquity was about the beginning of the year 1772 = 23~ 28~ 9~,4 and 23~ 28~ 8~ .
I suppose therefore the mean obliquity to be 23~ 28~ 8~ at the beginning of the present year ; and consequently , the obliquity has diminished , by my observations , 47~ in 81 years , since Mr. Flamsteed 's time , or at the rate of 58~ in 100 years , a quantity which will be found nearly at a mean of the computations framed by Mr. Euler and Mr. de la Land , upon the principles of attraction .
Oxford , Dec. 23 , 1772 .

