IX .
Observations upon Lightning , and the Method of securing Buildings from its Effects : In a Letter to Sir Charles Frederick , Surveyor-General of His Majesty 's Ordnance , and F. R. S. By Benjamin Wilson , F. R. S. &amp; Ac .
R. Ups .
Soc. SIR , YOUR station , as Surveyor-General of His Majesty 's Ordnance , being such , as makes the subject of this paper particulary interesting to you , I presume an apology for this address will be wholly unnecessary .
Upon an application of the Board of Ordnance to the Royal Society , in July last , a committee was appointed , to consider of the properest method for securing the Magazine at Purfleet from mischief by lightning : which committee reported to the council of that learned body , what they thought necessary to be done upon that occasion .
The council , afterwards , transmitted to the board , a copy of that report , together with another paper written by myself , in consequence thereof .
For , during the consideration of that business , some doubts having arisen in my mind , with regard to the propriety of points , which were proposed to terminate the top of each conductor ; and those doubts being founded upon experiments and observations , I could not consistently subscribe to that report , nor suppress my opinion , on a subject of such importance .
Whatever may be the sentiments of others respecting those doubts , yet , they being the result of my mature consideration , I thought it my duty to propose them to the committee ; and further to express my dissent , in writing , to that particular part of their report : giving , at the same time , some of the principal reasons for such dissent ; and referring them , for further satisfaction on this subject , to a letter which is already published in the Transactions of the Royal Society .
As that dissent is the origin of this paper , a copy of it is here inserted .
See page 48 of this Volume .
AGREEABLE to the declaration at the end of the above dissent , I shall now proceed to offer my further reasons for objecting to pointed conductors .
Experience , which is our best guide in all physical enquiries , but particularly in electrical ones , every day convinces me , that we know but little of that subtle fluid , which operates so secretly , and at the same time so powerfully , upon the earth , and its atmosphere I confess that I am even now less acquainted with the principle of its action , than I thought I was twenty years ago : the smallest differences ferences in the circumstances of our experiments , frequently causing very material differences in their results .
And perhaps no one , who has not applied his mind closely to enquiries of this kind , could conceive how the pointing a piece of metal , or not , should make any material difference in the experiment .
The electrician has it always in his power to convince any one of the fact , who , through inexperience , may be inclined to entertain the least scruple about it : for even from those experiments to which it was thought proper to appeal at the committee , it appeared , that the difference in the effects upon this fluid , between pointed and blunted metal , is as 12 to 1 .
A thunder-cloud therefore , according to that reasoning , ( the circumstances of it being supposed to be nearly similar with what is called the prime-conductor in those experiments ) , if it acted at 1200 yards distance upon a point , would require a blunted end to be brought within the distance of 100 yards ; and beyond those limits , would pass over it , without affecting it at all .
On this occasion permit me to observe , that the longer the conductors are above any building , the more danger is to be apprehended from them ; as they will in that case approximate nearer in their effects to those that are pointed .
And that is one reason why I was not for advising the proposed conductors at Purfleet , to be so high as ten feet above the magazines , and more particularly upon that building called the Board-house , which stands considerably higher than the magazines themselves .
But , before we advance farther into this subject , it may be proper to show the reasons for introducing a pointed apparatus , when the experiment upon lightning was first proposed : what good consequences were derived from that experiment : and why , upon further experiments and observations , such points ought now to be laid aside , when our intention is not to make electrical experiments , but by the means of conductors , to preserve buildings from the dangerous effects of lightning .
Dr. Franklin , in his conjectures , that lightning and electricity were one and the same fluid , considered how he should invite , or bring down and collect the lightning , so as to make experiments upon it .
And he concluded , from observation , that the likeliest method would be , to make use of such an apparatus for the purpose , as was most susceptible of electric effects ; or , in other words , such an apparatus as would receive the electric fluid with the greatest ease .
Repeated experiments taught him , that metals had the property of receiving that fluid , with more ease than other substances .
He also learnt , from the like experience , that metals by being pointed , were rendered still more susceptible of receiving it .
And therefore , he proposed an experiment to be tried , ` ` Whether it was not in our power to invite , or bring down the lightning , by an apparatus , consisting of an electric stand , and an iron rod , twenty or thirty feet in length , rising upright from the middle of the stand , and at the top , terminating in a very sharp point .
' ' This apparatus was recommended to be put upon some high building , building , with the expectation , that if a thundercloud should happen to pass near this apparatus , some quantity of the lightning deposited therein would probably be collected in the rod , by means of the very sharp point , and the electrical stand at the foot of the rod That this contrivance answered the end he first proposed , we have had sufficient evidence .
And it is no wonder if , after this great discovery , we find him , and other electricians , pursuing new experiments of this kind , and raising those points higher into the air , to collect still greater quantities of that fluid which occasions lightning .
Nor need we be surprised , after knowing that lightning could be brought down from the heavens by so simple an apparatus , and after experiencing its subtle effects to be similar with the electric fluid , that the Americans , and others , upon Dr. Franklin 's recommendation , adopted the principle of securing their buildings from its dangerous effects , by raising above their houses rods of iron , very sharply pointed , and applying wires from the ends of those rods , down the outside of their houses , to the ground .
But though there appeared many arguments at that time in favour of such conductors , yet experiments and observations , at last , induced Dr. Franklin to alter his opinion in respect to those wires , and to substitute in their place rods of iron : still retaining the principle of having the rods at the top sharply pointed ; and many of the Americans , as well as Europeans , approved of the alteration , as appeared afterwards , from constructing their conductors accordingly .
About that time great attention was given , and many new experiments were made , in consequence of the frequent dangerous effects , which lightning was observed to produce in some valuable buildings , by rending and dashing to pieces very large stones and timbers , which were connected together by cramps and bars of iron : and at other times breaking and melting part of those rods , and sometimes exploding wires , even of a considerable thickness , like so much gunpowder .
From careful observations of these extraordinary appearances produced by violent shocks of lightning ; and upon making other experiments relating to a certain resisting power in , or upon , all bodies , which appears to act against the attacks of lightning , as well as against the electric fluid , philosophers were enabled to assign the reason , and , it is apprehended , upon a solid foundation , why Conductors should be made of metal , in preference to all other materials ; as the power of resisting such attacks is less in metals than in wood , stone , or marble .
And that this resistance might be the more simple and uniform , it appeared the most eligible to have the conductors made of one continued piece of metal only , and of an equal diameter throughtout .
But what that diameter ought to be , depended upon other circumstances , some of which are taken notice of in a former paper , referred to above , which I laid before the Royal Society .
By this historical sketch , we see the propriety of Dr. Franklin 's introducing points , and the advantage philosophy has derived from them : by ascertaining that lightning and electricity are one and the same fluid : which appears to be diffused every where , at least upon this earth and in the atmosphere .
But when curiosity , which I apprehend was one of the first motives for introducing points to invite the lightning , was satisfied ; and experience had taught us , that we had it in our power to collect that fluid which occasions it : and when the principle of its action was from experiments thus investigated and ascertained , this manner of invitation , viz. by using points , ought , in my opinion , to have ceased * ; because a greater quantity of lightning , than we have yet experienced , may chance to attack us .
For we are so far from knowing how great the magazine of lightning may be in the heavens , or in the earth , when it is ready to discharge itself , either by one or more explosions , that we are ignorant , even of the quantity actually discharged , whenever any stroke from lightning visits us .
Nor can the ablest philosopher fix the limits of the greatest discharge that may possibly happen .
Seeing then how vain it is to look for any thing like absolute security , in all cases , it surely behoves us to proceed with caution .
And it is for that reason I have always considered pointed conductors as being unsafe , by their great readiness to collect the lightning in too powerful a manner .
And lest the conductors .
without such points , should be too slender for very * Unless where the electrician , like Professor Richmann ( who was killed by it ) at his own hazard , chuses to make further observations on lightning .
violent attacks , in places of great consequence , I have always recommended the having them above four times larger in diameter , than what are commonly made use of , to the end our security may be the greater , by opening a larger passage for any extraordinary discharge , and so far lessening the danger to be apprehended from it .
I ought not , in this place , to omit taking notice of a paper , containing some further experiments and observations , which were produced at the committee , to show , among other things , that pointed metals were more disposed to receive the lightning , by virtue of a repelling principle in the lightning , as well as the electric fluid , which acted upon the natural quantity of the fluid contained within the metal , at a considerable distance from the point , causing , if I may be allowed the expression , a kind of vacuum therein ; but I suppose the author means to a certain distance only .
So far from disputing this philosophy , I readily admit the fact .
But , I am afraid , every attempt to prove that pointed conductors may be so disposed to receive this fluid more readily , will not mend the argument in the least ; because , the more we lessen the power of resisting , even supposing the whole Conductor to be in that state , the more we increase the power of invitation .
In regard to other experiments , with locks of cotton * , which are acted upon in a particular manner * Dr. Franklin 's Experiments .
by the apposition of points , and the conclusions drawn from thence , in favour of pointed conductors , as causing similar effects upon the fragments or small clouds , which , hanging below the thunder-clouds , have been supposed a kind of stepping-stones , for the lightning to pass upon , towards the earth : such pointed conductors being supposed to occasion those fragments to retire up into the cloud from whence they were suspended ; and on that account , to prevent a stroke from lightning , which might otherwise have happened , I shall , for the present , wave entering into this philosophy , as I could wish the conjecture to be reconsidered ; because I apprehend it is liable to many objections , which to enumerate would carry me beyond the proper bounds of such a paper as this .
However , if the same opinion should again be offered , and brought in argument , it may be worth while to enter more deeply into the enquiry .
If those gentlemen , who argued at the committee for the necessity of points , could have made it appear , that such points draw off , and conduct away , the lightning imperceptibly and by degrees , without causing any explosion , during a thunder storm ( which seems to have been once the opinion of Dr. Franklin ) I should readily have subscribed to their Report .
But experience shows us , that the fact is otherwise : there being many instances , where violent explosions of lightning have happened to conductors that were sharply pointed .
And three in particular , the accounts of which are inserted in a publication of Dr. Franklin 's * , where the points * Dr. Franklin 's Experiments , p. 394 .
416 , 417 , &amp;c. were dissipated , or destroyed ; and a small part of an iron rod melted next the points of one of them ; and also at the several crooked ends of the rods below , where they were hooked on to each other , and formed the conductor belonging to Mr. Maine in North America .
But as those letters are long , and contain several other curious facts , I shall reserve them , together with some further observations upon the nature and power of that resisting principle , which is found to act so sensibly against the attacks of the electric fluid , or lightning , to some future dissertation .
There is no building , that I know of , more exposed to this kind of danger , than the Eddystone Lighthouse , as it stands upon a rock in the sea , several miles from land .
The fixing of a conductor to that building , was thought highly proper ; and the fixing of a point upon it , as highly improper .
It was therefore resolved upon to put up a conductor without a point , that no more lightning might be unnecessarily solicited to the building , and that all the lightening , which accidentally fell on it , might be conveyed away without injuring it .
This conductor was fixed twelve years ago , and the building has since received no injury from lightning * .
There is another edifice of great consequence , I mean St. Paul 's Church , which stands much exposed , from its heighth , to accidents by lightning .
The dean and chapter of that cathedral , thought it an object deserving the serious attention * N. B. A former building erected for the same purpose , upon this rock , was set on fire by lightning .
of the Royal Society .
A committee was therefore appointed , in consequence of their application : and proper conductors were put up , in the several places where they were thought necessary , from the top of the lanthorn to the sewers underground .
And notwithstanding particular care was taken , to have the additional metal either of a considerable diameter , or an equal quantity of it formed into other shapes , for the convenience of the several places ; yet part of those conductors , consisting of iron , in the stone gallery , showed marks of their having been made considerably hot , if not absolutely red , by a stroke of lightning which happened in March last ( as appears by a letter which I communicated to the Royal Society from one of the vergers of that church , Mr. Richard Gould ) who had examined the conductors the morning following , along with Mr. Burton of the same cathedral * , and that the appearances were in general , * Mr. Gould acquaints us in his letter , that he examined the four conductors in the lanthorn and stone gallery of St. Paul 's Church , the morning after the lightning happened .
That no marks whatsoever appeared upon the conductor to the south , which was the first he attended to .
That he examined next the conductor to the West , and observed a thick rust lying upon the pavement in the stone gallery , as if it had been cleaned off , from the conductor , with a tool : that several parts of the iron appeared black , particularly the screws or nuts : something like the effects left by gun-powder upon iron or steel , or a smoaky fire .
That the conductor to the North , showed no marks , no more than that to the South .
But that upon examining the conductor to the East , he found stronger marks abundantly , than on the West conductor , ral , as the verger 's letter related them to me .
Mr. Delaval and myself attended , about a week afterwards , to observe them , and their particular it being much blacker ; particularly on the nuts and screws : the rust lying in greater quantities on the pavement .
And the extreme part of the conductor that goes into the water trunk , seemed like a piece of iron newly taken out of a farge by a smith , without working it on the anvil .
N. B. Mr. Gould has since added to the account in his letter , some circumstances which I apprehend ought not to be omitted .
He says , that where the end of the conductor , on the East~side , points towards the water trunk , a stone surrounds part of it , leaving an interval , half an inch wide or more , between them , and about four or five inches long , which is a little more than the breadth of the conductor .
That this interval was filled up with dirt , and had been so for some time , occasioned by frequent showers of rain washing the pavement in the stone-gallery .
That , after the lightning happened , he observed a hole was made through the dirt , one quarter of an inch in diameter , and about two inches in length .
That the hole was close to the iron ; and that , upon stooping down his head , he perceived a very disagreeable smell of sulphur from the stone , dirt , and conductor , particularly the last .
Upon hearing this account , Mr. Delaval and myself , a few days ago , went and examined the conductors again ; but more carefully than before .
For , upon causing the stone to be removed , which covered the top of the water trunk , we had an opportunity of examining near two feet more of the iron which points to the water trunk , than we could perceive before this stone was removed .
When we observed , that the conducting iron did not touch the lead .
We likewise observed , that there was a very thick coat of rust all over that part of the iron ; particularly at the end next the lead , where the water entered the trunk .
As the necessity of attending to these circumstances will be obvious to any one , who is but in the least degree acquainted with these researches , the danger of neglecting them will be seen~ in the strongest light , by the gentlemen of the committee who recommended the conductors for the security of that Cathedral .
situations ; with the circumstances attending them , when we were very well satisfied with his account , notwithstanding it had rained in the interim for three days together .
It is worthy of note , that those conductors did not terminate in a point , nor was any point put upon the cross at the top .
And yet Dr. Franklin was of that committee .
If points are so essential to our safety , why was not the reason enforced at the committee , for having them on that capital edifice ?
For my part , I think it was a happy circumstance , that there was no point fixed upon the top of the church , to solicit a greater quantity of lightning at that moment , than what fell upon the conductors , circumstanced as they were : as that quantity was great enough to heat so considerably a bar of iron , near four inches broad , and about half an inch thick .
This powerful effect , reminds me of another instance still more extraordinary , which happened in Martinico , and is related by Captain Dibden , where a bar of iron , one inch in diameter , was by a violent shock of lightning reduced in one part of it , to the thickness of a slender wire only .
See Ph. Tr. Vol. LIV .
p. 251 .
Since then we are at all times ignorant of the quantity of lightning in the earth and its atmosphere ; and the difference in the effects , between blunted and pointed , ends , in causing a discharge in our electrical experiments , appears to be as one to twelve ; it is easy to comprehend the very great danger this noble fabric has probably escaped , by having no pointed apparatus upon it .
From the above observations , I am naturally led to consider a part of the proceedings of the committee , respecting the magazines at Purfleet ; when a certain number of conductors , with tapering points at the top , were resolved upon , as necessary , to protect the several buildings where the powder is deposited .
For it was agreed upon at the same meeting , that the Board-house , which is a large building for the use of the board-officers , and which stands considerably higher than the magazines , as was observed above , did not require any point at the top : because it was apprehended to be perfectly secure , by reason of the copeings on the roof , the gutters and pipes to carry off the water , being all of lead : and further , because those pipes communicated with two wells , which always contained water .
I was not a little surprised at this last resolution , which appeared to be so inconsistent with the former .
Because , if points were necessary in one place , they ought to be so in another .
And on the other hand , if the Board-house is secure by the leaden accidental conductors , which have no points , why ought not the magazines to be equally secure , when put into the same circumstances ?
I therefore enforced the inconsistency of such a resolution in the strongest terms .
Notwithstanding which , the gentlemen , at that time , thought proper to confirm their resolution .
However , at the next meeting of the committee , I observed that they had been pleased , in the mean time , to make an amendment in favour of points for the boardhouse ; house ; which amendment was no sooner proposed , than approved of .
Why my observation was rejected at the preceding meeting , I must leave to the judgment of others .
But it certainly carries an appearance , as if manifest contradiction , upon further reflection , must have been the cause of that alteration .
And I am inclined to believe , from some gentlemen of the committee expressing their opinion , of its being a matter of mere indifference whether blunted or pointed conductors were made use of , ' ' that they have not considered this subject , with all the due attention which so important an object deserves .
For if our experiments show , that points , from the nature of their shape , and other circumstances attending them , resist the attacks of this fluid less than blunted ones ; and that blunted conductors , of proper dimensions , are sufficient to convey away the lightning safely , whenever it attacks them ; why should we have recourse to a method , which is at best uncertain ; and which some time or other may be productive of the most fatal effects ?
But perhaps no argument can be brought with more force against the principle of points , than Dr. Franklin 's own words , which are published in his experiments , p. 481 , where he declares positively .
Buildings , that have their roofs covered with lead , or other metal , and spouts of metal continued from the roof into the ground to carry off the water , are never hurt by lightning ; as whenever it falls on such a building , it passes in the metals , and not in the walls .
' ' This is the case with the British Museum , a building also of considerable consequence , where there are no other conductors , than what are formed by the copeings , gutters and pipes , which are all of lead , and communicate with the ground .
Now it is from the great quantity of metal contained in the several pipes , together with the other circumstances attending them , that I considered that building ( in a former paper laid before the royal society ) as being sufficiently secured , from those dangerous accidents .
But if any gentleman should be disposed to entertain a doubt about it , or indeed of any other part of my reasoning on this subject , a declaration of those doubts may be attended with good consequences , as they will necessarily open the door to a more minute investigation .
I have now , Sir , gone through the reasons which I proposed to lay before the royal society for the rejecting of points .
And I am very sorry , in the course of this letter , to have been under the necessity of mentioning any differences in opinion , which passed between the members of the committee , to whom this important matter was referred .
I think , however , I shall stand excused to the society , and the public , when it appears , as I hope it now sufficiently does , what my motive has been ; namely , to state clearly , and impartially , the objections which I conceived to lye against pointed conductors : and to disclose without any reserve , the principles on which such objections are grounded .
I am , SIR , with the greatest respect , Your most obedient , and most humble servant , 8th December , 1772 , Great Russel-street , Bloomsbury .
Benjamin Wilson .
P. S. Mr. Delaval , who was one of the committee , has given me leave to insert his opinion upon this subject ; which is this .
That he concurs with me in thinking that such conductors as are elevated higher than the buildings to which they are applied , or are pointed at the top , are improper and dangerous .
He was desirous of delivering his opinion at the committee : but , as the meetings of it were held in the summer only , his absence from London prevented his attendance .

