Philos. Trans. Vol. LXI .
TabXVII .
p 547 .
T~~~ QRSTV HKLMN ~~~~~ ~~ abcde ~ ~~ VWX OP ~~ f FG L. A Supplement to a former Paper , concerning Difficulties in the Newtonian Theory of Light : by the Rev. S. Horsley , L L. B. F. R. S. PROBLEM I. APARCEL of equal Circles being disposed upon a plane surface , of any figure whatsoever , in the closest arrangement possible , to determine the ultimate proportion of the space covered by all the Circles , to the space occupied by all their Interstices , when each circle is infinitely small , and the space , over which they are disposed , is of a finite magnitude .
Read Dec. 19 , 1771 .
The closest manner , in which a parcel of equal circles can be disposed upon a plane , is when the centers of every three contiguous circles are situated at the angles of an equilateral triangle , which hath each of its sides equal to a diameter of any one of the circles .
A number of circles , thus disposed , may be divided , as TA B. XVII .
shows , into several rows of circles , having their centers ranged upon parallel right lines , A G , H P , Q X , ~ ~ , &amp;c. Every circle , which is not in an outermost row , or at the extremity of any other row , touches six others , namely two in its own row , and two in the row on either side of its own : and each adjacent pair of these six do also touch each other .
In the outer rows , every circle , which is not at one extremity of its row , touches four others , two in its own row , and two in the row next beside it ; which last two do likewise touch each other .
A circle at either extremity of an outer row , touches only a single circle in its own row , but either one or two in the row next beside it .
The bare inspection of the figure ( T A B. XVII .
) will make these assertions manifest .
Now , imagine the equal circles , exhibited in the figure , to be each infinitely small , the number of them being infinitely great , and the whole space over which they are disposed being of a finite magnitude .
The ultimate proportion of the space covered by all the Circles , to the space occupied by all their Interstices , is that of 1/ 2 the area of one of the circles to the whole of one interstitial area , i. e. the proportion of 39 to 4 very nearly .
DEMONSTRATIO N. The circles ranged along the parallel right lines A B , H P , form two rows of interstices ; the row marked a , b , c , d , &amp;c. and the row marked ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ , &amp;c. and , in like manner , two rows of interstices are formed by every two contiguous rows of circles .
Now , the numbers of the circles ranged along the several parallel right lines , A G , H P , Q X , &amp;c. are either equal or unequal , according to the figure of the space over which they are disposed .
Case I. First suppose , that an equal number of circles is ranged along each of the parallel lines ; in which case , the figure , in which they are included , must be a parallelogram .
The number of circles , ranged along the parallel right lines A G , H P , being equal , the number of interstices in each of the rows , a , b , c , d , &amp;c. ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ , &amp;c. is less by unity than the number of circles upon either line , A G , or H P , be that number what it will .
Thus the two circles A , B , upon the line A G , with the two circles H , K , upon the line H P , have the single interstice a , in the row a , b , c , d , &amp;c. and the single interstice ~ , in the row ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ , &amp;c. Again , the three circles A , B , C , upon the line A G , with the three , H , K , L , upon the line H P , have the two interstices a , b , in the row a , b , c , d , &amp;c. and the two ~ , ~ , in the row ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ , &amp;c. And universally , if the number of circles in each row be m , the number of interstices , in each of the two rows of interstices , will be m 1 .
Consequently , the whole number of interstices formed by these two rows of circles is 2m 2 .
In like manner , the two rows of circles H P , Q X , form two more rows of interstices .
And the number of circles upon each line , H P , Q X , being m , the number of interstices in each row is m 1 , and the whole number in both rows 2m 2 , Therefore , the whole number of interstices formed by the three rows of circles , A G , H P , Q X , is 2m 2 twice taken , or 2 m-2 X 2 .
By the same reasoning if a fourth row of m circles , ~~ be added , the number of interstices formed by the four rows is 2 m-2 X 3 .
And universally , if there be n rows of equal circles , and m circles in each row , the number of interstices formed by all the rows is 2m2Xn 1 .
Now , when the circles are infinitely small , their diameters are infinitely small .
Therefore , the space which they cover being of finite magnitude , it is necessary , that both the number of circles in each row , and the number of rows , that is , that each of the numbers , m and n , should be infinitely great .
But when m and n are each infinitely great , 2m2Xn 1 , that is , the number of interstices , becomes ultimately 2m n ; and the interstices being all equal one to another , if the area of one be called P , the sum of their areas will be 2mnX P. But the number of circles in n rows , each row consisting of m circles , is m n ; and the circles being equal , if the area of one be called A , the sum of their areas will be mnX A. Hence the space covered by all the circles is to the space covered by all their interstices , when the magnitude of each circle is infinitely diminished , and the number of them so infinitely augmented , as that they shall cover a space of finite magnitude , ultimately , as mnXA to 2mnX P , that is , as A to 2 P , or as 1/ 2 A to P , that is , as 1/ 2 the area of one circle to the whole area of one interstice .
Case 2 .
Now , suppose , that unequal numbers of circles are ranged along the several lines A G , H P , Q X , &amp;c. which must always be the case , if the figure of the space , in which they are contained , be any other than a parallelogram ; and let the number upon AG be the greatest of all , and call that number , as before , m. If from the row H P , the extreme treme circle P be taken away , all the rest being left , the interstice ~ will be taken away , and all the other interstices , formed by m circles upon H P , with m circles upon A G , will remain .
If again the circle O be taken away , besides the interstice ~ already taken away , the two ~ , f will disappear ; and every circle more that is taken away , of those remaining upon H P , from the extremity of the line , two more interstices will disappear .
If from the row of circles H P , the extreme circle H be taken away , the two interstices a , ~ , will disappear .
And if the circles K , L , M , be taken away successively , every new circle that is taken away , two more interstices will disappear , of those formed by the two rows A G , H P. Again , if the two circles P and H be taken away , the three interstices ~ , a , ~ , will disappear ; and every circle more that is taken away , from either extremity , two more interstices will disappear .
Hence whatever number of circles be taken away out of m circles upon H P , provided they be taken successively , from either or both ends of the row ( and when the number of circles upon HP is supposed less than that upon A G , the deficiency must be at the end , not in the middle of the row , otherwise the circles remaining would not be in the closest arrangement ) , it is evident that the number of interstices which disappear , of those which would be formed by m circles upon H P , with m circles upon A G , must be either double the number of circles taken away , or less than the double of that number by 1 .
That is , if ma be the number of circles left upon H P , the number of interstices formed by them , with m circles upon A G , is less than the number which would be formed by m circles upon H P , with m circles upon A G , either by 2 a , or by 2a 1 .
The number of interstices formed by m circles upon each row would be , as hath been shown in the preceding case , 2m 2 .
Therefore , the number formed by m circles upon A G , with ma circles upon H P , is either 2m22 a , or 2m2a 1 .
That is , ultimately ( when the number ma is infinitely increased ) 2m2 a. Now , suppose the number of circles upon QX to be ma b. The number of circles upon the two rows A G , H P , is 2m a. Upon the three rows A G , H P , Q X , the number is 3m2a b. And if the number of circles upon ~~ be mab c , the number of circles upon the four rows A G , H P , Q X , ~ ~ , will be 4m3a2b c. And , universally , the number of rows being n , and the number of circles upon the several rows , m , m a , ma b , mab -c , mabc d , &amp;c. successively , the whole number upon all the n rows will be maXn1bXn2cXn 3 , &amp;c. But , as it hath been shown that m circles upon A G , with ma circles upon H P , form 2m2a interstices , if the number ma be infinite , in the same manner it may be shown , that ma circles upon H P , with mab circles upon Q X , form 2m2a2b interstices , when the number mab is infinite .
Therefore , the whole number of interstices formed by the three rows upon A G , H P , Q X , is 2m2aX22 b. And , in like manner , the number of interstices , formed by the circles of four rows , will be 2m2aX32bX22 c. And , universally , n being the number of rows , the number of the interstices will be 2 m-2 ax n-1-2 bx n-2-2 cx n-3 , &amp;c. That is , 2mx n-1-2 ax n-1-2 bx n-2-2 cx n-3 , &amp;c. By comparing this expression with the former expression of the number of the circles , it will appear , that when n , the number of the rows of circles , is infinitely augmented , the number of interstices is to the number of circles , ultimately , as 2 to 1 .
For the two expressions always consist of an equal numbers of terms .
The same numerical terms in both are affected with the same signs .
The first term of the latter ( 2 mxn 1 ) is ultimately double the first term of the former ( m n ) , when n is infinitely increased , and each succeeding term of the latter is double the corresponding term of the former .
Therefore , the whole of the latter expression is ultimately to the whole of the former , as 2 to 1 .
That is , the number of interstices is ultimately double the number of circles : whence it follows , as in the former case , that the whole space covered by the circles is to the whole space occupied by the interstices , as 1/ 2 the area of one circle to the whole area of one interstice .
In this Demonstration I have supposed the number of circles upon the several lines A G , H P , Q X , &amp;c. to decrease continually .
Had I supposed them to decrease by fits , and in any manner imaginable , still the conclusion would have been the same ( a ) .
There(a ) Suppose the number of circles upon the 1st row to be m , upon the 2d , m-a , upon the 3d , m-a+b , upon the 4th , m-a+b-c , upon the 5th , m-a+b-c+d , and so on , and fore , let the figure of the finite space , including the circles thus closely arranged , with their interstices , be what it will , the proportion of the space covered by all the circles , to the space taken up in interstice , is ultimately that of 1/ 2 the area of one circle to the whole area of one interstice .
Now , that this is the proportion of 39 to 4 , very nearly , will appear by computing one of the interstitial areas .
The method of computing the interstitial area is obvious .
Let A , B , H be the centers of the three circles , which close the interstice ~~ ~ .
Join A B , A H , B H. The right lines A B , A H , B H , pass through the points of contact ~ , ~ , ~ , respectively .
and each of these numbers to be infinitely increased .
Then , n being the number of rows , the whole number of circles will be maxn1+bxn2cxn3+dxn 4 , &amp;c. Number the interstices formed by every two contiguous rows , and add them all together , and the whole number of interstices will be found to be 2mx n-1-2 ax n-1 +2bxn 3-2 cxn3+2dxn 5 , &amp;c. Now , by comparing these two expressions , it appears , that both consist of the same number of terms : That the same numerical terms in order from the first , have the same signs : That the first term of the latter ( 2 mxn 1 ) is ultimately the double of the first term of the former , when n is infinitely increased : That of the terms following the first , the negative terms of the latter are each double the corresponding negative terms of the former : and each positive term of the latter differs from the double of the corresponding positive term of the former .
by a number which vanishes with respect to either of those corresponding terms , when n becomes infinite .
Therefore , when n becomes infinite , the whole of the latter expression becomes the double of the whole of the former .
Hence the conclusion is as before .
The area of the triangle , AH B , is equal to the areas of the three sectors A~ ~ , B~ ~ , H~ ~ , added to the interstitial area ~~ ~ .
But the triangle AHB is equilateral .
Therefore each of the sectors A~ ~ , B~ ~ , H~~ is 1/ 6 of the circle to which it belongs : and , the circles being equal , the three sectors are equal to the half of any one of the circles .
Therefore , the area of the triangle AHB is equal to 1/ 2 the area of one circle ( as of A ) added to the interstitial area ~~ ~ .
Therefore , from the area of the triangle AHB take 1/ 2 the area of the circle A , and there will remain the interstitial area ~~ ~ .
Now , if the radius A~ be put = 1 , each side of the triangle AHB will be 2 .
Therefore , the area of the triangle AHB = 1,73205 will be ... ... ... But the radius being 1 , 1/ 2 the area of the = 1,5708 circle A is ... ... . .
The difference is 0,1612 And this is the interstitial area ~~ ~ , the half area of the circle A being 1,5708 .
Therefore , the semicircle is to the interstice as 1,5708 to 0,1612 , or as 9,74 to 1 , or as 39 to 4 , very nearly .
COROLLAR Y. If a parcel of equal circles be so disposed upon a plane surface of any figure whatsoever , that the centers of every three adjacent circles are situated at the angles of equal equilateral triangles , having sides greater than the diameters of the circles , but greater in a finite proportion , the ultimate proportion of the space covered by all the circles to the space occupied by all the interstices , when each circle is infinitely diminished , and the number of them so infinitely increased , that the space over which they spread is of a finite magnitude , is that of 1/ 2 the area of one circle to the whole area of one interstice .
And the area of any one interstice is equal to the difference of the area of the equilateral triangle , formed by the right lines joining three adjacent centers , and 1/ 2 the area of one of the circles .
PROBLEM II .
To determine the greatest possible density of an infinitely thin crust composed of equal spberules , having their centers all in the same plane .
From the number 39 subtract its third part .
To the number 4 add the third part of 39 .
The remainder is to the sum , that is , 26 is to 17 , very nearly , as the space occupied by all the matter to the space occupied by all the pore , in an infinitely thin crust , of the greatest possible density , composed of equal spherules , having all their centers in the same plane .
DEMONSTRATIO N. Upon a base of innumerable infinitely small circles , arranged in the closest manner possible , ( according to Prob. I. ) imagine right cylinders to be erected , each cylinder having one of the little circles for its base , and its altitude equal to the diameter of its base .
These These cylinders are in the closest arrangement possible for equal cylinders ; and the spheres , which they circumscribe , are in the closest arrangement possible for equal spheres , which have their centers in the same plane .
The solid space occupied by the cylinders , is to the solid space occupied by their interstices , as the surface covered by their circular bases , to the surface covered by the interstices of their bases : That is , as 39 to 4 , very nearly , by the first Problem .
But the spheres contained within these cylinders are each but 2/ 3 of the contained cylinder .
The solid content therefore of all the spheres is but 2/ 3 of the solid content of all the cylinders ; and the remaining third part of the solid content of the cylinders , together with the interstices between the cylinders , makes up the whole of the interstices between the spheres .
Therefore , the space occupied by the spheres is to the space occupied by their interstices , as 39 39/ 3 to 4+ 39/ 3 , or as 26 to 17 , very nearly .
The spheres being in the closest arrangement possible , if each be a solid atom , or without pore within its own dimensions , then , the infinitely thin crust , which these atoms compose , is plainly the most dense that can be composed of equal spherules , having their centers in one plane .
And the space occupied by its matter is to the space occupied by its pore , as 26 to 17 , very nearly .
SCHOLIU M. If the component spherules , instead of being solid , be supposed to be each of the density of gold , in which one half of the bulk may reasonably be supposed to be pore , then only 1/ 2 of the space , which they occupy , is filled with matter , and the other half is to be added to the pore .
Hence spherules of the density of gold , arranged in the closest manner possible , having their centers in one plane , compose a crust , in which , 1 3/ 4 3ds , or somewhat more than 1 2/ 4 0ths , of its bulk is matter .
Therefore , the density of such a crust is somewhat greater than 12 times that of water , since 1/ 4 0th only of the bulk of water is supposed to be matter , and 3 9/ 4 0ths is pore .
S. Horsley .
The first these two Problems , enabled me to determine the greatest possible number of spherical particles of a given magnitude , that could find room to lie at one time upon the surface of the Sun ; and , by the second , I found the density of the crush , which such particles , in the closest arrangement possible , with a given density of each particle separately , would compose .

