P HILOSOPHICAL TRANSACTIONS .
PART II .
XL .
Observations upon Five ancient Persian Coins , struck in Palestine , or Phaenicia , before the Dissolution of the Persian Empire .
In a Letter to Matthew Maty , M. D. Sec. R. S. from the Rev. John Swinton , B. D. F. R. S. Custos Archivorum of the University of Oxford , Member of the Academy degli Apatisti at Florence , and of the Etruscan Academy of Cortona in Tuscany .
SIR , THE coins before me , as well as several others similar to them , were undoubtedly struck , in some of the cities of Syria , Palestine , or Phaenicia , before the reduction of those provinces , and the conquest of the Persian empire , by Alexander the Great .
This , if I am not mistaken , was first remarked by ( 1 ) M. Baudelot ; who has been lately followed herein by ( 2 ) M. l'Abbe Barthelemy , and ( 3 ) M. Pellerin .
I entirely agree whith all those learned men in what they have advanced relative to those coins , and shall now beg leave to submit a few cursory observations upon five of them ( as the subject is extremely curious ) to the conderation of the Royal Society ; which may possibly ( 1 ) Baudel .
l'Utilit .
des voyag .
&amp;c. p. 638 .
A Paris , 1693 .
( 2 ) Journ. des Scav .
&amp;c. T. LIII .
Aout , 1760 .
p. 279 , 280 .
( 3 ) Peller .
Recueil de Medail .
de Rois , &amp;c. Explicat .
de la Vignette , p. iii .
iv .
A Paris , 1762 .
VO L. LXI .
Yy serve Read June 20 , serve to evince the truth of what has been offered by those celebrated antiquaries , on this head , and set this matter in the clearest light .
I. The first of the medals to be considered here ( see TA B. XIII .
n. 1 .
) was given me some years since , by my worthy friend , the Reverend and learned Mr. Thomas Crofts , late chaplain to the British factory at Aleppo , and formerly of Wadham College , Oxford ; who brought it with him to England , out of the East .
On one side we discover Atergatis , Adergatis , or Derceto , taken by several learned ( 4 ) men , for the Dagon of Scripture , nearly as we find that pagan divinity described ( 5 ) by Diodorus Siculus , and Lucian , with a pigeon before her , and a fish in her right hand .
On the other , we perceive a galley , or small vessel , on the sea , with rowers in it ; under which there appears a sea-horse , or rather a sea-monster , of a very particular form .
Near the face of Adergatis , the two Phaenician letters ~ ~ , M A , present themselves to our view .
The piece is in good conservation , having suffered very little from the injuries of time .
That this silver medal must have been anterior to the dissolution of the Persian empire , we may fairly collect from the reverse ; which agrees in every particular , but the sea-horse , with the reverse of a Daric , that undoubtedly preceded the abovementioned event , and exhibits the very same Phaenician letters , with which it is adorned .
But this will be rendered incontestable by a bare inspection of the draught of that ( 4 ) Seld .
de Diis Syris , Syntagm .
II , cap. iii .
Andr .
Beyer .
ad Joh. Seld .
ubi sup. p. 300 .
( 5 ) Diod .
Sic .
Bibl .
Hist. lib. II .
Lucian de Dea Sir .
~ Johan .
Selden .
ubi sup. Vid. Athen .
Dcipnosoph .
lib. VIII .
Philos. Trans. Vol. LXI .
Tab. XIII.p.346 .
TAB. XIII.n.1 .
TAB. XIII.n.2 .
A~ ~ AER TAB. XIII.n.3 .
TAB. XIII.n.4 .
~~ TAB. XIII.n.5 .
TAB. XIII.n.6 AER AER TAB. XIII.n.7 Daric , and others of similar coins , in the ( 6 ) plate referred to here .
That this piece was struck at Ascalon , a very ancient and celebrated city of Palestine , there is , I think , little reason to doubt .
Dagon , or Atergatis , was a deity of the Philistines , to whom Ascalon appertained , as we learn from ( 7 ) Scripture ; and therefore may very naturally be supposed to have been worshipped there , as well as in the other principal cities belonging to that people .
We are assured by ( 8 ) Diodorus Siculus , and Lucian , that Ascalon was famous for the worship of Atergatis , or Derceto , and the superb temple of that deity there .
The coins of Ascalon ( 9 ) not infrequently exhibit Atergatis , with a pigeon , as here ; pigeons ( 10 ) , as well as fishes , having been considered as sacred animals , bearing a near relation to Atergatis , if not as objects of religious worship , in that city .
The reason of this is given us in few words , by a ( 11 ) very learned author , who sets the point here insisted on beyond dispute .
I own , indeed , the divinity in question is said to have had a temple at Hierapolis , and to have been worshipped there ; but this , according to the great ( 12 ) Mr. Selden , seems to be a mistake .
Besides , the goddess of Hierapolis was worshipped under ( 13 ) a human form , and not with the tail of a ( 6 ) Numism .
Antiqu .
&amp;c. a Thom .
Pemb .
et Mont .
Gom .
Com. collect .
p. 2 .
T. 75 .
( 7 ) 1 Sam .
v. 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , &amp;c. ( 8 ) Diod .
Sic .
&amp; Lucian .
ubi sup. ( 9 ) Joan .
Vaill .
Nnmism .
Imperator .
&amp;c. a Pop .
Rom .
Dit .
Greece loquent .
&amp;c. p. 81 .
Henr .
Noris , An. et Epoch .
Syro-Maced .
p. 510 .
Lipsiae , 1696 .
( 10 ) Joh. Selden .
ubi sup. p. 192 -202 .
Amstelodami , 1680 .
( 11 ) Id. ibid. ( 12 ) Seld .
ubi sup. p. 192 .
( 13 ) Id. ibid. fish , as Derceto is represented on the medal I am considering .
Nor do I remember ever to have seen Atergatis , or Derceto , in that form , or attended by a fish and a pigeon , as on my medal , on any of the Hierapolitan coins .
Lastly , I have a brass medal of Ascalon ( see TA B. XIII .
n. 2 .
) , in my small collection , with a gallery , or little vessel , on the water , and rowers in it , as we find exhibited by the piece before me , over which the two Greek letters A~ plainly appear ; which seems most clearly to evince , at least the high probability of , the point in view .
It must therefore be allowed extremely probable , if not absolutely certain , that the coin considered here was struck at Ascalon , though current throughout Syria , Palestine , and Phaenicia , before the reduction of those provinces by the arms of Alexander the Great .
As no chronological characters on the piece in question present themselves to our view , it will be extremely difficult , if not impracticable , to ascertain , with any precision , the time when it first appeared .
However , I cannot help thinking it probable , that the coin was struck about 351 years before the birth of CHRIS T , when the ( 14 ) provinces of Palestine and Phaenicia were subdued by Artaxerxes Ochus , soon after they had revolted from him .
The people of those provinces might then have used money similar , at least in some respects , to that which was current in Persia , either out of compliment to , or by the positive order of , that prince .
This , I say , might not improbably have been the case ; but that it really was so , I must not presume absolutely to affirm .
Be this , however , as it will , a circumstance ( 14 ) Diod .
Sic .
Bibl .
Hist. Lib. XVI .
will occur , in the explication of the fourth medal to be considered here , that will bring no small accession of strength to the notion I would now recommend to the attention of the learned world .
With regard to the two Phaenician letters exhibited by this coin , they seem either to form the word ~~ , MA , which in Phaenician not improbably denoted WATER , or the SEA , ( 15 ) as in Arabic , or to be the two first elements of the word MAIVMA , in Syriac ( 16 ) signifying likewise WATER , the name of the port and place of the magazine of naval stores , such a port and place having formerly appertained both to Ascalon ( 17 ) and Gaza .
For those two Phaenician letters , preserved on many medals , ( 18 ) can scarce always be looked upon either as the whole or part of the proper name of the place where the coins were struck , as they seem first to have appeared in different towns ; though it must be owned , that MAIVMA , as applied to the ports of Ascalon and Gaza , was ( 19 ) considered as the proper name of a town , erected at a small distance from each of those two cities .
However , I should rather take the word MA to have denoted WATER , or THE SEA , as a small vessel on the sea is visible on these coins , and the word MAIVMA , as applicable to the ports of Ascalon and Gaza , seems not to have ( 20 ) been used long before the time of Constantine the Great : ( 15 ) Gol .
Lex .
Arab .
p. 210 .
Val .
Schind .
Lex .
Pent .
p 994 .
Hanoviae , 1612 .
( 16 ) Gothofred .
apud Henric .
Noris , ubi sup. p. 511 .
( 17 ) Sozom .
Lib. ii .
c. 4 .
Henr .
Noris , ubi sup. p. 511 , 512 .
( 18 ) Numism .
Antiqu .
&amp;c. a Thom .
Pemb .
et Mont .
Gom .
Com. collect .
p. 2 .
T. 75 .
n. 7 , 8 .
( 19 ) Henr .
Noris , ubi sup. p. 511 .
( 20 ) Id. ibid. unless we would suppose it to denote AN HVNDRED , and to refer to some remarkable occurrence , from whence the Persians dated their computation of time , in the days of Ochus , to us at present utterly unknown .
II .
The second medal ( see TA B. XIII .
n. 3 .
) I received , as a present , from the Reverend and learned Mr. Crosts , who brought it with him from Syria , at the same time that he gave me the first .
Atergatis , or Derceto , on this silver piece , holds a concha-marina , or seashell , in her left hand ; but , in all other respects , it is so similar to the former as sufficiently appears from the draughts of them both , that it may almost , if not absolutely , pass for a duplicate of the same coin .
The piece , however , has been but indifferently preserved ; so that without the assistance of the medal already described , it would have been of no great service to the learned world .
As the two Phaenician characters , that occur on the first medal , have been entirely defaced on this , by the injuries of time , I can offer nothing relative to them here .
It may not , however , be improper to observe , that neither this nor the former medal has yet , as far as I can find , been ever communicated to the learned world .
III .
The third medal ( see TA B. XIII .
n. 4 .
) is a very small silver piece , and was presented to me by my worthy and learned friend , the Reverend Mr. Thomas Crosts , who brought it with the other two , above described , out of the East .
The reverse , which exhibits the two Phaenician elements ~ ~ , MA , and a galley , or small vessel , full of rowers , on the water , almost entirely agrees with that of two Persian Darics ( 21 ) , as will appear from an inspection of the draughts of them , in the plate here referred to .
This indicates the piece to have been struck in Palestine , or Phaenicia , before the dissolution of the Persian empire , probably at the same time that the two former first appeared .
On the other side we observe a laureated ancient head , which I take to represent Jupiter Marnas , a deity worshipped ( 22 ) at Gaza , a celebrated ancient city , at no great distance , 3 parasangs only , from Ascalon ; who might therefore probably have had divine honours paid him there , as well as at Gaza ; and consequently we may attribute the coin to either of those cities , though , on account of the head of Jupiter Marnas , I should rather prefer Gaza .
This , I say , appears to me extremely probable ; but that either the laureated head really represents Jupiter Marnas , or the piece was certainly struck at Gaza , I must by no means take upon me absolutely to decide .
If the head on this medal should not be imagined to point out Jupiter Marnas , the local deity worshipped at Gaza , it may perhaps be supposed to represent some hero , or the founder of Ascalon , or Gaza .
Be that , however , as it will , as either this very coin , or one exceedingly similar to it , has a place assigned it in ( 23 ) Lord Pembroke 's noble collection , it can scarce be allowed to pass for an inedited coin .
( 21 ) Numism .
Antiqu .
&amp;c. a Tho. Pemb .
&amp; Mont .
Gom .
Com. collect .
p. 2 .
T. 75 .
n. 7 , 8 .
( 22 ) Henr .
Nor .
ubi sup. p. 494 .
Golii not .
ad Alfragan .
p. 142 .
( 23 ) Numism .
Antiqu .
&amp;c. ubi sup. p. 2 .
T. 75 .
n. 8 .
IV .
The fourth ( see TA B. XIII .
n. 5 .
) is a small brass medal , that may pass for an inedited coin , though one not unlike it has been published by M. Baudelot .
On one side a human figure , that probably represents a king of Persia , with a Persian tiara on its head , in a triumphal car , drawn by two horses , and driven by a similar figure , with a Persian tiara likewise on its head , presents itself to our view .
On the other , a vessel navigated by rowers , resembling that exhibited by the three foregoing coins , may be clearly discerned .
The piece has been well preserved , and was undoubtedly anterior to the reduction of Syria and Phaenicia by Alexander the Great .
For that the person in the car is a Persian , we may infer from the tiara on his head , which occurs on the heads of several Persian figures ( 24 ) in the ruins of Persepolis ; and that he was a royal personage , appears from hence , that the kings of Persia only had their effigies impressed on the Persian coins .
It is true , some of the figures in the ruins of Persepolis are the produce of the Parthian times , and several of them even coeval with some of the princes of the house of Sassan , and consequently of still a later date .
But , notwithstanding this , the figures now in view were undoubtedly Persian , and fully evince the point they are brought to prove ; but had they been Parthian , that would have made no alteration in the present case , as the Persians and the Parthians ought to be considered as one and the same nation , and their attire as one and the same .
( 24 ) Engelbert .
Kaempfer .
Amaenitat .
Exoticar .
Fascic .
p. 345 , 312 , 340 , &amp;c. Lemgoviae , 1712 .
That the piece then was struck in Palestine , or Phaenicia , whilst under the domination of the Persians , there is , I think , little reason to doubt ; though it may , perhaps , be not altogether so easy to ascertain , with any precision , the time when it first appeared .
There is , however , one period , and one only , as I apprehend , in the Persian history , to which this may , with the strictest propriety , be referred ; and that is , immediately after the reduction of Sidon , by Artaxerxes Ochus , when the Phaenicians , who had before entered into an alliance with Nectanebus , king of Egypt , and asserted their independency , made their ( 25 ) submission to him .
This happened in the year of the Julian period 4363 , about 351 years before the ( 26 ) birth of Christ .
That prince having then entirely subdued the Phaenicians , who had revolted from him , and reinforced his army with a body of 10000 Greeks , resumed his design of invading Egypt ; and , ( 27 ) after the surrender of Jericho , probably advanced at the head of his forces to Ascalon and Gaza , through which he might have passed , on his route to that country , though he seems to have undertaken the Egyptian expedition , or rather to have entered Egypt , the following year .
Upon his arrival at Ascalon , he may naturally be supposed to have struck some of the pieces , at least , considered here ; and particularly that which is the present object of my attention , with the representation of a Persian king , in a triumphal car , upon it .
For this must seem naturally to have announced the entire reduction of Syria and Phaenicia , that had just before submitted to him .
( 25 ) Diod .
Sic .
ubi sup. ( 26 ) Jac. Usser .
Annal .
ad An. Jul. Period .
4363 .
p. 146 , 147 .
Genevae , 1722 .
( 27 ) Solin .
cap. 35 .
As therefore the coins in question are found in ( 28 ) , and come from , those parts of the East ; I would willingly flatter myself , that what is here advanced will meet with the approbation of the learned .
There is one farther circumstance relative to this coin , which must not be omitted here .
Over the Persian monarch 's head , at a small distance from it , we may easily discover a kind of letter ( 29 ) , not appertaining , as it should seem , to the Phaenician alphabet ; which , as I apprehend , may be taken for an ancient Persic character .
It not a little resembles that endued with the power of the short A , deduced from the Zend and Pazend , by ( 30 ) Dr. Hyde ; as also ( 28 ) Peller .
ubi sup. ( 29 ) This coin seems to have been struck either at Ascalon , Gaza , or Acco ; as most of the similar coins hitherto published probably first appeared in one of those cities .
But the names of all those places begin with an Ain , not an Aleph , and therefore the character in question cannot be supposed to have appertained to any of those names .
Whereas Ardshir , Ardschir , or Artaxerxes , the name of the king , in whose reign the coin seems to have been struck , has for its first letter , an Aleph , not an Ain ; and therefore the character on this piece may be presumed , after what has been said , to point at that name .
And this will be rendered still more probable by the position of the Persian character I am here considering .
It is placed over the head of the great personage in the triumphal car , or rather almost contiguous to the tiara with which it is covered .
This appears to me almost decisive in favour of what is here advanced .
If any learned man , however , should dissent from me in this particular , I shall not quarrel with him for adhering to his own opinion .
Baudel .
Peller .
pass .
Barthel .
Schikard .
Prosop .
Pers .
Proem .
et alib .
Tubingae , 1628 .
( 30 ) Vid. Lit. in Libr .
Zend &amp; Pazend , juxta apographum D. Hyde , usitat .
&amp;c. apud D. Hyd .
in Hist. Relig .
Vet .
Pers .
Ed. Oxon .
1760 .
Memoir de Litterat .
Tom. XXXI .
p. 358 .
A Paris , 1768 .
That the Persians used the Assyrian letters in the days of Herodotus , we learn from that celebrated historian .
But , notwithstanding this , they might likewise have used other ancient alphabetic characters , at least in some part of the intertwo two others belonging to two of the ancient Persian alphabets published by M. Anquetil du ( 31 ) Perron , to which he assigns the power of A. All which if we admit , it may probably be considered as the val between the commencement and the dissolution of the Persian empire , if not throughout that interval .
And that they had actually then such characters , the coin under consideration here gives us good reason to believe .
But we must not positively assert this , since nothing certain or decisive , without the farther assistance of ancient coins , or other genuine monuments of antiquity , can be offered in support of such an opinion .
The very learned M. Ja Croze , takes the ancient letters of the Persians , so many specimens of which have been given us by Dr. Hyde , to have been originally deduced from the Syriac alphabet .
But this is by no means certain .
That they are , however , more ancient than has been hitherto generally imagined , will be readily acknowledged , by all who admit the character in question to be one of the letters of the ancient Persic alphabet , as I am inclined to believe it is .
But neither must this be laid down as a fact , till it is confirmed by other ancient coins , or by other authentic monuments of antiquity , that may be entirely depended upon .
Herodot .
lib. IV .
c. 87 .
Matur .
Veys .
la Croze , apud Joan .
Chamberlain .
Dissertat .
&amp;c. p. 129 , 130 .
Amstelaedami , 1715 .
( 31 ) M. Anquetil du Perron has lately published , at Paris , his translation of the Zend-Avesta of Zeratusht .
In the preliminary discourse , or introduction to which , he has been pleased to abuse and ridicule two of the most respectable members of our University , as well as me .
This conduct is the more extraordinary , as , by his own account , the polite and friendly reception he met with from us , during the two days he resided in Oxford , towards the close of January , 1762 , ought to have inspired him with sentiments very different from those of hatred and aversion to the whole English nation ; which he , though greatly obliged to them both in the East Indies and in England , discovers in many parts of his first volume .
But I mean not at this time to recriminate .
Nor indeed is there any need of a recrimination .
His own account of the treatment he met with at Oxford , from the gentlemen he has so grossly abused , is a much severer refiection upon him than any thing I have said , or could have said , of him , here .
In my present circumstances it would be improper for me to characterize his translation of the Zend-Avesta , as I might seem to be acted by too vindictive a spirit , if I delivered here my true sentiments of it .
But I would beg leave to recommend to the initial letter of Ardshir , Ardschir , or Artaxerxes , the name of the prince in whose reign , and by whose command , the piece was struck .
This , if allowed , will be an additional proof of the truth of what has been here advanced , relative to the time in which the medal first appeared , as well as to the occasion of that appearance , hinted at above .
It is certain , such initial letters sometimes represented the names of kings and great men amongst ( 32 ) the Greeks , who were neighbours to the Persians , and were imitated by them in several particulars , even as early as the year wherein I believe this coin to have been struck .
This observation will throw no inconsiderable light upon what I would now propose to the consideration of those that are the best versed in this branch of literature , and render my elucidation of the medal before me , as well as of the others considered here , not altogether unworthy the attention of the learned .
V. The fifth medal ( see TA B. XIII .
n. 6 .
) is extremely similar to the fourth , but very ill preserved ( 33 ) .
The learned world the perusal of a little piece lately published * , highly meriting their attention ; the ingenious author of which , a most valuable member of our University , though a very young man , is at least a match for M. Anquetil , in the knowledge of the Arabic , Persic , Turkish , &amp;c. languages , as well as other branches of oriental literature , and seems to have done him tolerable justice , by giving us a clear and adequate idea of this performance .
However , I may possibly hold him up to the public , in his proper colours , on some future occasion .
( 32 ) Erasm .
Frael .
Not .
Element .
Numism .
Ant. p. 138 , 142 .
Viennae , Pragae , et Tergesti , 1758 .
( 33 ) I shall beg leave in this place to remark , that we find a noble Persian silver medallion ( see TA B. XIII .
n. 7 .
) , published by M. Pellerin , with a Persian monarch , in a triumphal car , drawn ~~~~A du P - , a Londres , 1772 .
former , however , differs from the latter in this , that it exhibits a lacquey , or slave , as it should seem , following the triumphal car .
This renders it still more probable , that the figure in that car was intended to represent a person of the first distinction , or rather a Persian monarch .
Both of these coins have been hitherto unpublished ( 34 ) , though of medals similar to them , in conjunction with several others of the same kind , one ( 35 ) of the most valuable parts of Lord Pembroke 's inestimable collection has been formed .
If there were originally any characters on the piece last described , they have all been effaced by the injuries of time .
From the fourth medal I have attempted to elucidate in this paper , it seems to appear , that certain ancient Persian letters , as well as Phaenician , are sometimes handed down to us , by this species of coins .
A draught of one of them , in the ( 36 ) plate here referred to , may possibly be thought , by some , to bring a fresh accession of strength to such an opinion .
Thus have I endeavoured to illustrate five very valuable ancient coins , struck in Palestine , or Phaeby two horses , and followed by a lacquey , or slave , on one side , as here , attended by the Phaenician legend ~ O ; which is manifestly equivalent to the three letters ~ , ARC , the second character being a Phaenician monogram , formed of Resch and Caph .
On the other side , we discover a galley , navigated by rowers , and adorned with one of the Dii Pataeci , at the stern .
Over the galley , there appears a date ; which may , perhaps , denote 203 , or 213 , if we suppose the character representing Ten , now defaced , to have originally occupied the chasm in the middle of the numerical characters , though the aera to which this refers I cannot take upon me to ascertain .
The letters ~ , ARC , evince the piece to have been struck at ARCA , or ARCE , a city of Phaenicia , between Byblus and Heliopolis , called by the Greeks ' ' Apxn , or ' ' ~ , as we learn from Stephanus Byzantinus .
Steph .
Byzant .
in voc .
' ' Apxn .
Vid. etiam Lucae Holstenii not .
in loc. ( 34 ) Numism .
Antiqu .
&amp;c. p. 2 .
T. 75 .
( 35 ) Numism .
Antiqu .
&amp;c. p. 2 .
T. 75 .
&amp; 87 .
n. 2 .
nicia , before the time of Alexander the Great , almost entirely unnoticed by any other writer ; and this purely in order to excite others of more learning , greater abilities , and better versed in these matters , to consider with proper attention , and treat more copiously , a very curious subject , hitherto but barely touched upon by the learned .
And as the paper now sent you may not improbably produce such an effect , it may possibly contribute to the farther extension of the knowledge of ancient medals , at least by introducing to future discussion several important points , relative to that species of literature , at present utterly unknown .
You will therefore excuse the trouble given on this occasion , by , SIR , Your much obliged , and most obedient , humble servant , Christ-Church , Oxon .
March 16 , 1771 .
John Swinton .
( 36 ) Numism .
Antiqu .
&amp;c. ubi sup. p. 2 .
T.87 .
n. 2 .

