Received November 15 , 1770 .
XXXIX .
Some Experiments on Putrefaction ; by F. L. F. Crell , M. D. and Professor of Chemistry at Brunswick .
THE celebrated lord Bacon [ a ] has , without doubt , shown a very great sagacity , in pointing out to posterity , putrefaction , as a subject , worthy of making further inquiries into ; and certainly , as there happen daily so many changes , not only in the inanimate , but also in the animate world , carried on by its means ; the knowledge of every thing relating to it must clear up a great many points in natural philosophy , not thoroughly understood before .
But these inquiries ought to be still of more consequence to mankind , as health depends greatly upon keeping in due bounds putrefaction , which the body naturally tends to .
For these reasons , Sir John Pringle deserves , besides his other eminent merits , very great praises , on his having made many experiments on this subject ; and medicine is indebted to him for considerable improvements resulting from them .
He has besides opened [ a ] Not .
Hist. Cent. IV .
the Read Nov. 7 , the way to many other gentlemen , among whom excel Dr. Gaber , and Dr. M`Bride , whose numerous experiments show the ingenuity , and sagacity , they are possessed of : but the subject is not yet exhausted , nor will it be very easily .
I have made some experiments relating to it ; and should be very glad , if they threw a new light on some points of the greatest importance to medicine .
Dr. Gaber has proved , by his experiments , the presence of a volatile alcali produced by putrefaction ; but as he did not discover by the same proceedings [ b ] any in its beginning or end , though there was a very putrid smell , he denies its existence in these states , and concludes , that this volatile alcali is not a necessary product of putrefaction [ c ] .
This doctrine seemed to me not quite conformable to the phenomenon : for , as all smell , as much as we know at least till now , depends on a saline matter , joined with a [ b ] Acta Taurinens .
Vol. I. p. 78 .
Cum attegerint summum effervescentiae gradum , continuato ejusdem loci calore effervescentiae vim amiserunt .
P. 79 .
Citius plerumque prodiit foetor , quam alkali , idemque tardius desiit .
P. 82 .
Massam inde relinqui foetentissimam , sed emisso alkali ad effervescentiam ineptam .
[ c ] Id. p. 83 , 15 .
Quum foeteret gravissime residuum destillationis , quamquam omni alkali orbatum , manisestum videtur , ab alkali foetorem exaltari quidem posse , &amp; magis penetrantem effici , non autem ab eodem produci , quandoquidem superest eo sublato-16 .
Videtur is odor a volatilibus admodum particulis proficisci , sed quae ab alkali dissimiles sunt , ~ citius gignantur , tardiusque dissipentur alcalescentia adesse potest medico foetori conjuncta vicissim maximus foetor absque alcaliEx quibus differentia inter foetidas alcalinasque parts confirmari videtur.-P.84 , 17 .
Videtur alcali non esse productum necessarium putrefactionis neque gradum alcalescentiae gradui putrefactionis respondere .
phlogiston , and the saline matter producing the putrid stench , was not very likely an acid ; I supposed it to be a volatile alkali , which , involved in phlogistic matter , might fly off , before the alkali was developed .
I wanted to know by experiment , if I was right ; for this purpose , I put , the 19th of June ( the thermometer being 58~ of Fahrenheit , and continuing between 58~ and 62~ all the time I observed ) , in a pretty large receiver , some beef cut in very small pieces ; I covered the bottom with it thinly , and poured upon it water , about two inches high .
The 22d , the putrid smell was very sensible : but I let it stand till the 24th , when I poured off the fluid [ d ] , adding again about the same quantity of water to the flesh .
I filtrated then the fluid through a piece of fine linen , and mixed with some of it the syrup of violets , which it did not alter ; neither did it effervese with the spirit of vitriol , diluted to a sharpness near that of the vegetable acid .
I thought of keeping it in digestion for some days ; but , for fear that some little solid particles might have passed through the linen , and by that means , in growing putrid , might give some alcali , and render the trial inaccurate , I distilled the fluid by a heat of about 160~ , after which , I repeated the trial with the syrup of violets and the spirit of vitriol ; but it produced no [ d ] It requires some attention to find out the proper time when to pour off the liquor ; if it is done too soon , it will give too little volatile alcali to be much sensible by experiments ; for , though it smells strongly , it is known how little matter is required to produce a strong smell .
If it is delayed too-long , it shows already signs of an alcali .
For that reason , I made many experiments in vain .
change .
I then put it , the 25th , into a retort , fitted to it a receiver , applied to the jointure a ring of paste made of flower and water , covered it with a piece of wet bladder , and exposed it in a balneum arenae to a heat of 108~ to 116~ , till the 29th of June , when the whole fluid was distilled over .
I perceived during this operation , that the liquor , from being quite transparent , grew turbid ; the first distilled transparent fluid grew also turbid in the receiver , and at the bottom of the retort there was a small settlement of a whitish earth .
The liquor had a particular smell , but quite different from a putrid one , inclining to the volatile alcali ; and showed a slight but sensible degree of effervescence with the spirit of vitriol ; and the syrup of violets was turned evidently green by it .
In the mean time , the flesh with the water continued to emit a putrid stench ; and the 28th of June I found the fluid colouring the syrup of violets greenish , and showing a kind of effervescence with the acid .
Both these qualities were increasing every day , till the 8th of July , when , on account of a journey , I could not observe it any longer .
I had left the mouth of the receiver open ; and on my return the 1 st of August , I found an exceeding putrid smell ; I covered the vessel ; and the 2d , examined the fluid , but it did not effervesce any more .
I then filtrated the liquor ; but the flesh was so rotten , that a great many particles passed through the linen , and rendered it turbid .
I put it into a retort , adapted a receiver , and luted it , as before-mentioned ; the heat was also the same , between 108~ and 116~ .
In this warmth it continued for about four days , when the fluid was distilled over .
On opening the vessels , the smell was again entirely changed , not near so disagreeable as before .
In the receiver I obtained a fluid , which turned the syrup of violets green , effervesced very smartly with the very same spirit of vitriol I had used before ; gave the smell of a volatile alcali , on adding to this the fixed alcali ; praecipitated the calces of metals dissolved in acids , and showed itself by all proofs a true volatile alcali .
In the retort remained a yellowish matter , almost without any smell .
I put to it some water ; and after 24 hours , it gave the herbaceous smell , but showed no signs of any alcali .
I let it stand four days longer : the herbaceous smell continued ; but there was no alcali to be discovered .
I distilled it with a gentle fire : but neither then did there appear an alcali [ e ] ; and by applying a stronger fire , I got nothing but a kind of empyreumatic oil .
I had poured , the 3d of August , some fresh water on the putrid matter ; its putrid smell continued ; the 7th I decanted the fluid , filtrated it , and made it undergo the same operation , with exactly the same effect as before ; which I did again the 11th , with the very same effect .
I did not repeat it oftener , as I had occasion for this putrid flesh to some other purpose .
These experiments show , I think , that the volatile alcali is present as long , at least , as the putrid smell [ e ] What this herbaceous smell did depend on , I did not enquire any farther , as not relating to medicine , since a living body never was found in such a state : but very likely it depends on some volatile alcali , which is perhaps in so very small a quantity as not to be perceptible by experiments .
continues ; and that this volatile alcali is the basis of it , because , as this was distilled over , the residuum , being still in intestine motion , got only the herbaceous smell .
The reason , why the volatile alcali has been distinctly observed at a certain period of putrefaction , and not in the others , is , I believe , this ; the volatile alcali has , it seems , a tendency , to disentangle itself , by intestine motion , of all such matter as it is involved with ; but if it is not combined with such fixed matter as retains it till it has gone through all its evolutions , it is , being itself volatile , carried off by the still more volatile phlogistic matter with which it is commonly joined .
For this reason , I suppose , the putrefying matter shows in its beginning no sign of a volatile alcali ; because its smell depends only on those particles , which have been on the surface , without any strong cohesion with the substance .
In the farther progress of putrefaction , the matter involving the alcali , or forming it , is intermixed , and in cohesion with the solid particles of the substance , and is by these means retained till the alcali is come to its purer state .
Towards the end of putrefaction , the cohesion of the particles being almost entirely taken off , the volatile alcali is carried off before it can go through all its states .
If it is therefore true , that the volatile alcali is essential to , or at least always present in putrefaction , it seems to follow , that the alcalies never can be used in living bodies , as antiseptics [ f ] , for laying [ f ] It is very difficult , methinks , to account for the antiseptic power of the volatile alcali , and other salts , on dead animal subV O L. LXI .
Xx aside aside their stimulating quality , which must prevent their use in most of the putrid diseases , they would increase the morbific matter , by being intimately mixed by circulation with phlogistic matter , which they find in abundance in such bodies .
It has been objected to this , that the exhalation of stale urine , though showing a great quantity of volatile alcali , is inoffensive to health [ g ] : and that some persons have taken the volatile alcali in very great quantity , without its bringing on a putrid disease [ h ] : but there stances : I once thought , that as the ammoniac salt , nitre , &amp;c. bring down the thermometer several degrees , perhaps all these salts acted by instantly absorbing the heat produced by the beginning intestine motion ; and that , as a certain degree of warmth is necessary to putrefaction , in preventing this degree from coming on , it might hinder the whole operation .
To see by experiment how far this might be true , I put into phials a certain quantity of water , with that proportionate quantity of alcalies , fixed and volatile , sal ammoniac , &amp;c. which Sir John Pringle had found ( Append .
p. xvi .
xvii .
) to be antiseptic ; and in one as much pure water as a standard .
I stopped every one of them with a cork , in which I had made a hole for a thermometer of Fahrenheit .
I exposed all these phials to the same heat ; Sir John had used about 112~ ; but I found , that both those with the salts and that without it marked the same degree of heat ; and that therefore the absorption of heat can by no means be the reason of the putrefaction being stopped .
May this phenomenon not depend upon the salts penetrating the body , and giving to the particles more puncta contactus ( according to their greater or less affinity ) ?
and may not these salts , in augmenting cohesion , hinder the fluids from separating themselves from one another , and , in consequence , prevent intestine motion ?
Is this not somewhat confirmed by the action of adstringents ?
and by the most powerful actions of metallic salts , as being of the greatest specific gravity ?
[ g ] Sir J. Pringle , Append .
p. vi .
[ h ] Id. ibid. p. xcii .
are however some examples [ i ] , where it has been hurtful .
It is urged further , that a person , being only for a short time exposed to really putrid exhalations , may be infected with putrid diseases ; and therefore that this effect of putrid exhalations does not depend on the volatile alcali , as it may be taken pure in very large doses , without producing such effects .
To this I reply , by an analogous instance ; a small quantity of ferment will bring on fermentation in a large mass of fermentable matter , and yet as much acid as could be obtained from the ferment , far from exciting an intestine motion in the fermentable matter , would rather check it ; but can it , for all that , be denied , that the involved acid in the ferment is the chief cause of setting the whole mass in fermentation ?
In the same way , the alcali combined with phlogistic matter may produce such intestine motion as the pure alcali cannot ; and very likely the first would not produce it , if the volatile alcali in it could be changed .
To bring this about , the most powerful means seem to be the use of acids ; and the most celebrated physicians agree in the good effect they have observed from acids in putrid diseases , and recommend them strongly .
Dr. M`Bride thinks otherwise , and his reasons are these : first that if the acids came unchanged to the absorbent vessels , they would not admit of them [ k ] ; secondly , [ i ] Huxham on the sore throat , p. 67 , 68 .
Ejusd .
Essay on fevers , p. 118 , edit .
5 .
[ k ] Experiment Essays , edit .
sec. p. 20 .
The austere acid ( generated in the first passages of weakly persons ) is exactly in the same state with a foreign acid , for the lacteals will admit none of it .
if they did , they would be dangerous [ l ] ; and thirdly that they are quite changed , before they leave the primae viae [ m ] .
As for the first , I do not know what reasons Dr. M`Bride founds his assertions upon , as acids never are given in so concentrick a state , as by their astringency to make these vessels shut up their orifice ; and as metallic salts themselves are absorbed in their very compound state ( which seems clear with regard to the corrosive sublimate , and other such saline preparations ) , I do not see , why the simple acids could not be absorbed .
The second reason seems to be founded upon some of Dr. M`Bride 's experiments ( p. 132 , 133 ) , viz. that putrid flesh , sweetened by distilled vinegar and spirit of vitriol , was firm ; but on being boiled went quite to pieces , whereas that sweetened by volatile alcali did not .
But , I conceive , these experiments are not applicable to a living body : for the acid being there mixed with the fluids , cannot act in this way on the solids , till the fluids are ( if I may use that [ l ] Ibid. p. 134 .
the acids dissolve the elementary earth , and thus destroy the texture of that substance , whose soundness they are supposed to restore.-P .
148 .
we are not to expect , that they are to pervade the minute branches of the vascular system ; when indeed it is evident , that they ought not to be allowed to pass into the blood in their acid form ; since it is plain , that , from their dissolvent nature , the body must be destroyed , and its most solid parts melted down to a jelly , if naked acids were to be received into the general mass of fluids .
[ m ] Ibid. p. 148 .
acids are neutralized during the alimentary fermentation ; and therefore they cannot act as acids , by saturating any thing of the alcaline kind that they meet with in their course of circulation .
expression ) supra-saturated with the acid [ n ] , which in putrid diseases cannot be the case .
And farther , a heat of 212~ of Fahrenheit never can increase the action of the acids in living bodies , as it did in the experiments ; for , though Dr. M`Bride denies this consequence , and will prove the contrary , as the flesh with the alcali did not dissolve ; yet this circumstance proves nothing more , than that the volatile alcali has not such power of dissolving the gluten of animal fibres , as acids have ; for , if the effect depended only on the action of the acids by themselves , the flesh would rather have been dissolved when immersed in them , than when boiled in water.-The Doctor besides seems not quite consistent on this head ; for , p. 151 , he says , ` ` Adstringents can only ` ` be of importance in those cases , where , from extreme relaxation and resolution of the solids , the dissolved fluids are suffered to transude , and either form spots of different hues , or run off by actual haemorrhage ; here , indeed , the acid of vitriol , as an astringent , not as an acid , is found of great use in gaining time .
' ' As the acid could not exert its astringent power on the vessels , without coming to the secundae viae ( p. 153 .
) he seems not afraid , in this case , of its melting down the most solid parts to a jelly .
In proof of his third reason , he alleges some experiments ; viz the third , p. 40 , where a mixture of flesh , bread , lemon juice , and saliva , did not effervesce , after fermentation with an alcali ; and the 5th , [ n ] This has , it seems , happened in some rare cases quoted by Dr. M`Bride , and Dr. Haller , p. 148 .
p. 42 , where a mixture of bread , water , saliva , and spirit of vitriol effervesced smartly , before the intestine motion ; but not at all after it .
I could object against these experiments , and especially the 5th , that perhaps the proportion of the saliva to the acid was too great , and that a person in a putrid disease ought to take more acids than could be neutralized by the inquiline liquors .
However , I will not insist on this ; and suppose these experiments to be quite applicable to the case : but if these mixtures do not effervesce any more , does it follow , ` ` that they are neutralized , and therefore act as acids , by saturating any thing of the alcalinous kind , that they meet with , in their course of circulation ?
' ' There are some saline bodies , which do not effervesce when mixed together ; which will , however , change one another 's nature .
Thus f. e. brimstone , mixed with a strong fixed alcali , does not effervesce [ o ] , but changes , on being dissolved , the nature of the alcali .
A solution of soap does not effervese on the addition of an acid , but joins with the acid , and neutralizes it .
These instances made me suspect the conclusion drawn by Dr. M`Bride from his experiments ; and to clear up these doubts , in this particular case , I referred to experiments .
For this purpose , I mixed , the 4th of August , the thermometer being at 64~ , three ounces of saliva , a dram of the liquor of [ o ] This applies also to the solution of brimstone in limewater , out of which the lime particles have been precipitated , by the intoduction of fixed air .
putrid flesh , and a very small quantity of bread : and added as much of the diluted spirit of vitriol , as to make it sour , and effervesce definitely with the alcali .
There was not any sign of intestine motion till the 7th of August , when from time to time some air bubbles , and also some solid particles , rose to the top ; and this continued till the 8th .
Not perceiving any farther motion , I poured off the clear liquor , which did not effervesce any more with the alcali .
I mixed , the 9th , six drams of the putrid liquamen , with about the double of this liquor , and put in besides four solid pieces of flesh , which had lain three days in the liquamen : these pieces were of a prodigious stench , and so rotten , that with the least force they were torn to pieces .
There appeared no signs of intestine motion : the 10th , the putrid smell was very much abated : the 11th , it was changed , and there remained only a smell much like that of sound flesh : the pieces were without any smell , and had acquired again some degree of firmness .
In this condition they remained for a week , and I did not observe them any longer .
This experiment proves , I believe , that acids , though changed in the alimentary canal so far , as not to effervesce with alcalies , may notwithstanding check putrefaction ; and that , therefore , their use is of great consequence , and ought not to be omitted in putrid diseases .
Though Dr. M`Bride believes that these diseases may be cured with sermentable substances only ; I must own that I do not agree with him , and am not quite convinced of his opiV O L. LXI .
Xx4 nion , nion , that putrefaction depends only on the loss of fixed air .
I rather believe this an effect than the cause of putrefaction ; but I shall refer this subject to another occasion .
ENDOFPART I.

