XX .
A Letter from the Hon. Daines Barrington , F. R. S. to Matthew Maty , M. D. Sec. R. S. occasioned by the three preceding Letters .
DEARSI R , February 15 , 1771 .
IHAVE lately had an opportunity of perusing three letters from Dr. Ducarel , Mr. Thorpe , and Mr. Hasted , which contend that the sweet chesnut is an indigenous tree of this country , and which are intended to be communicated to the Royal Society .
Read March 8 , 1771 .
As I do not see any reason for altering the opinions which I have happened to form on this subject , from what is contained in these three letters , I should not trouble the Society with any answer to the contents of them , did not Mr. Thorpe contradict , on the testimony of another person , what I have asserted I was an ocular witness of .
I must therefore a second time repeat , that the chesnut woods near Newington , in Kent , are planted in rows at four or five yards distance ( other trees often intervening ) ; and for a proof of this fact , I refer Mr. Thorpe to the woods on the North East of the church * ; as also the wood to the eastward of the great road to Canterbury , immediately after you leave the town of Newington .
I spent very near a whole day in the examination of these woods ; but I would more particularly refer to the two chesnut plantations above specified , as they were just then shooting from the stools , when I took this very minute view of them .
I have already said , that I am willing to leave the point in controversy , upon what hath been advanced on the one side , and on the other .
I will only beg leave to state a single observation , together with what seems to be an inference that is fairly deducible from it , and which is applicable to any disputes , with regard to trees being of native growth , or otherwise .
I believe~ I may say , that I have been almost in every corner of the twelve Welsh counties ; and never saw a beech tree in any of them , which had the least pretence to be indigenous .
I will suppose , however , that a wood of any given number of acres , with beech in it , was found in the central part of the principality ; and that these trees were not planted in rows ( as at Newington and Sittingborne ) ; but dispersed , as happens in other indigenous woods .
Could it possibly be contended , that such beech trees had not been introduced by some planter ; notwithstanding it might be proved to be a wood of great antiquity ?
*I think , I can depend upon my memory so far , as to say that the chesnuts I have alluded to , are at the North East of the church ; but at all events , they are very near to it .
If this was insisted upon , it must at the same time be conceived , that when the beech mast was wasted by the wind to such a most selected spot , some preternatural cause must have prevented its being sown in any intermediate place .
I am , DEARSI R , Your most faithful humble servant , Daines Barrington .

