XVIII .
Copy of Mr. Thorpe 's Letter to Dr. Ducarel , concerning Chesnut Trees .
Dear Sir , HAVING perused the Hon. Mr. Barrington 's letter to Dr. Watson , published in the Philosophical Transactions , I find he lays down three or four general rules to determine whether a tree is indigenous or not in any country , as follows : Read March 8 , 1771 .
I. They must grow in large masses , and cover considerable tracts of ground ; nor must such woods end abruptly by a sudden change to other trees , except the situation and strata become totally different .
II .
If the trees grow kindly in copses , and shoots from the stool , it must for ever continue in such a wood , unless grubbed up , nor is it then easily extirpated .
III .
The seed must ripen kindly : nature never plants but where a succession may be easily continued , and in the greatest profusion .
Lastly , many places in every country must receive their appellation from indigenous trees , which grow there , &amp;c. When the instances of this are singular , singular , it will prove directly the contrary , as he hopes to show with regard to the chesnut , &amp;c. ' ' In answer to his objections , and agreeable to these his forgeoing rules ; I shall endeavour to prove the chesnut to be an indigenous tree , in this island ; and 1st , Mr. Barrington says , that he examined the woods near Sittingbourn himself ; ` ` and on a very minute inspection of them , found those parts which consist of chesnuts , to be planted in beds or rows , about five yards distant from each other ; nor are there any scattering trees to introduce them , &amp;c. ' ' In what wood or woods , he observed these plantations , I must confess , I am quite at a loss to find , having never observed this regularity in any of the woods I have been in ; and I very lately asked a person who has lived many years in that neighbourhood , deals largely in timber and underwood , and is over all these woods every year , who told me he knew of no such regular plantations in any of them ; that the chesnut grew intermixed with other trees , as in all ancient woods .
Indeed , the amazing distance of the plants from each other , which Mr. Barrington mentions , is somewhat extraordinary ; as the usual custom now , in planting sets of chesnut or ash , for hop poles , is about seven or eight feet distance , as has been lately done by John Cocking Sole , Esq ; in his plantation of chesnuts , at Newington .
The woods , called the Chesnut woods , the property of the Earl of Aylesford , which lie in the parishes of Newington , Borden , and Bobbing , abound with these trees , which grow promiscuously with others , both from stubs and stools of a large size ; twenty acres of which are annually felled for poles , &amp;c. Cranbroke Wood , belonging to Mrs. Mercer , in Newington , has the chesnut in plenty with other trees , which produce poles in abundance , from old stubs and stools .
The Squirrel Wood , the property of the Hon. Mr. Roper , in the parish of Stockbury ; those called Long Tun and Binbury , contain plenty of chesnut , intermixed with other trees , in which are very large chesnut pollards ; to appearance some hundred years standing ; which grow on a poor soil , and are quite hollow shells , having no nourishment but from the rind or bark ; yet throw out plenty of shoots from the roots .
I have a farm in the parish of Stockbury , called Nettlested , forty acres of which are tithe free , which portion of tithes belonged to the great monastery of St. Austin , situated without the walls of Canterbury .
They were given in very ancient times to the use of the almonary or almonry of that abbey ; as far back as the time of Archbishop Walter , in the year 1193 , how long before is uncertain , and are mentioned by William Thorn , a monk of that house , and published by Sir Roger Twisden , in the Decem Scriptores ; part of these tithes are woodland , and to this day called Almery or Ambry-Tanton .
In this wood are very old stools of chesnut , some of which are ten feet circumference , and stand promiscuously with oak , ash , and other trees .
These stools yet produce very good poles , which were felled once in my father 's time , and have twice since they have been in my possession .
In short , all that vast range of woods , called Stockbury vallies , which extend from Key-street to Binbury Pound , produce the chesnut in common with other trees ; the woods formerly belonging to the abbey of Lesnes , founded by Richard de Lucie , chancellor and chief-justice to Henry II .
in the parish of Earith , still called the Abbey woods , having great plenty of chesnut , both timber and stub wood , and from the stumps and stools of large timber trees formerly felled , which stools are now quite hollow and decayed , except the outward bark or shell , round the crowns of which arise many stools , and are cut for poles at the proper growth .
Church wood , in the same parish , has the like ; and many others in this neighbourhood .
In Wrotham parish above Kemsing , is a wood belonging to a farm , called Cottons , which has chesnut intermixed with other trees .
I could enumerate many more in different parts of this county , was it necessary ; and I make no doubt , on due inspection , the like may be found in other counties of this kingdom : it is most certain , the chesnut does not grow in every wood , but in such only , where the soil is adapted to it .
Different strata will produce different trees ; as for example , the great wood called Jordens , in the parishes of Bexley and North Cray , the woods beyond Ruxley towards Farningham , have some acres nothing but birch , some only hazel , &amp;c. Godden-wood , in the parish of Seal , is entirely birch .
The woods on the Cold hills , of Chelsfield and Nockholt , run most upon beech ; and those in the Weald of Kent , upon a clayey soil , are chiefly oak .
In answer to the third and last general rule ; that the nuts of the chesnut tree ripen kindly , and in great quantity , is manifest from the numbers of poor people at Earith , and the adjoining hamlet ; going into the woods at the proper season , and gathering some a quarter , others three sacks each , to fat their hogs , especially when pulse and grain are dear .
It is true , the nuts are not so large as on trees which stand single and open to the sun , in parks , courts , &amp;c. Even the oak will not produce acorns in a wood , till it becomes an old tree ; and then not so large and in such plenty as on old trees and pollards which stand open in fields and hedge rows .
But where the chesnut , as before observed , stands single and planted for ornament , as in the Wilderness park , the seat of Mr. Prat , in Seal ; and in Bradbourn park , the seat of Sir Roger Twisden , Bart , at East Malling , and divers other places , the nuts are large , well tasted , and in great plenty , yielding excellent food for the deer .
It is well known that trees close planted in orchards will not produce fruit so large and fair , as in kitchen gardens , where they stand single , are often digged about , and manured .
Mr. Barrington himself says , Dr. Watson informed him , ` ` that in Spain the chesnut trees destined to produce the best fruit , are engrafted upon the wild chesnut ; and that the French call the common sort Chataignier , and the improved one Maronier .
' ' If so , the latter may be the sort which are annually brought to England , and sold at all the fruit shops , &amp;c. and are called Spanish chesnut .
Mr. Barrington says , ` ` the very name of Spanish , seems most strongly to indicate the country from which this tree was introduced here .
' ' But why Spanish ?
I do not know that it is any where here so called , and none of the wood-men know it by that name .
The old Botanical writers , John Bauhine , Gerhard , and Parkinson , call it Castanea Vulgaris .
~ Bauhine , in his Pinax , Castanea Sylvestris , the common or wild chesnut tree .
Ray indeed , in his Synopsis , the 3d Edit .
published by Dillenius , p. 449 , has the following , ` ` in sylvis quibusdam prope Sittingburn Cantii oppidum , &amp; Woburn Bedfordiae , observavimus an spontaneam , an olim ibi satam , nescimus .
' ' It is somewhat strange that so celebrated a Botanist should treat of it in so slight a manner , and with seemingly so little attention , as to mention it only in those two places .
Lastly , Mr. Barrington says , ` ` that many places , in every country , must receive their appellation from indigenous trees which grow there , &amp;c. ' ' There are many trees which give few , if any , appellation to places .
It does not therefore follow that they are not indigenous .
In ancient time , England abounded more in woods and forests than at present ; and the oak and ash being then two of the most common trees , occasioned the names of the contiguous places and parishes to receive their derivation .
Notwithstanding his trial of the specimens of oak and chesnut , I am well assured many old buildings were , and are , of the latter ; especially in places where these trees flourished .
When I repaired the old house at Nettlested , in Stockbury , in sawing off the end of the main girder , it was decayed at heart ; and pronounced by the surveyor and carpenter then present to be chesnut , as are the other timbers .
Cowsted , a very ancient seat in the same parish , is entirely of that wood ; and Dr. Stukely , in his letter to the late Lord Hardwick , read at the Society of Antiquaries , and since published in the Archaeologia , p. 44 .
says , ` ` the curious roof of the large hall of the mansion house at Lesnes is of chesnut , which no doubt was felled in the abbey woods there .
' ' In latter times , the seat called Mount Mascal , in the parish of North Cray , rebuilt by Sir Comport Fitch , Bart. about fourscore years since , the girders and large timber of which are , as I am well informed , of chesnut felled in the woods adjoining .
And why should it not have been used in buildings , seeing it is very durable , and grows to a great size ?
witness the fine trees felled last summer , together with some oak and beech , in the park of Penshurst in this county ; possibly in length of time , the characteristic of the chesnut trees decaying inwardly , might be the reason of the oaks being mostly used , as the more durable timber ; and the former found to turn to better account for underwood and poles ; especially when hops came into use in Henry the Eighth 's time , and are the best for that purpose .
Even oak , by reason of its scarcity and dearness , is now little used in public buildings ; firtimber altogether supplying its place .
The chesnut tree yet alive in the court at Tortworth , in Gloucestershire , supposed by Evelyn and Bradley to have been planted in the time of King John , may possibly be the oldest tree of the kind extant in this kingdom ; but is no proof of there not not being chesnut trees before that time : Any more than the famous tree called Bears oak , in the park at Penshurst abovementioned ; or the well-known tree called Fisher 's oak , in the parish of Farnborough , in this county ; or that in Welbeck park , the seat of the Duke of Portland , were some of the first trees of that kind here planted ; the situation and ornament of these trees protected them from the axe .
The common elm , Evelyn thinks not to be an indigenous tree , and it may not as it is seldom , if ever , found growing in woods ; but in road ways , hedge rows , &amp;c. ; and not in the North of England , though , as Mr. Ray observes , some trees are only found in the North , some in the South , and others in the West ; neither does the elm , when an old tree , shoot kindly from the stool .
I agree with Mr. Barrington , that the box tree is an exotic ; but the yew is certainly indigenous , as I think may be easily proved , and which he assents to , but doubts whether the euonymus or spindle tree , and ligustrum or privet , are so ; most certainly they are , as no shrubs are more common on dry banks , and in hedges , &amp;c. : but , as he assigns no reason for their not being indigenous , I shall dwell no longer on that subject , and conclude , Dear Sir , Your most humble servant , J. Thorpe .
Bexley , Nov. 26 , 1770 .

