Received February 13 , 1772 .
XXII .
~ ~ .
O R , The Sieve of Eratosthenes .
Being an account of his method of finding all the Prime Numbers , by the Rev. Samuel Horsley , F. R. S. A Prime number is such a one , as hath no intregral divisor but unity .
A number , which hath any other integral divisor , is Composite .
Read May 7 , 1772 .
Two or more numbers , which have no common integral divisor , besides unity , are said to be Prime with respect to one another .
Two or more numbers , which have any common integral divisor besides unity , are said to be Composite with respect to one another .
The distinction of numbers into Prime and Composite , is so generally understood , that I suppose it is needless to enlarge upon it .
To determine , whether several numbers proposed be Prime or Composite with respect to one another , is an easy Problem .
The solution of it is given by Euclid , in the three first propositions of the 7th book of the Elements , and is to be found in many common treatises of Arithmetic and Algebra .
But to determine , concerning any number proposed , whether it be absolutely Prime or Composite , is a Problem of much greater difficulty .
It seems indeed incapable of a direct solution , by any general method ; because the successive formation of the prime numbers doth not seem reducible to any general law .
And for the same reason , no direct method hath hitherto been hit upon , for constructing a Table of all the prime numbers to any given limit .
Eratosthenes , whose skill in every branch of the philosophy and literature of his times , rendered his name so famous among the Sages of the Alexandrian School , was the inventor of an indirect method , by which such a table might be constructed , and carried to a great length , in a short time , and with little labour .
This extraordinary and useful invention is at present , I believe , little , if at all , known ; being described only by two writers , who are seldom read , and by them but obscurely ; by Nicomachus Gerasinus , a shallow writer os the 3d or 4th century , who seems to have been led into mathematical speculations , not so much by any genius for them , as by a fondness for the mysteries of the Pythagorean and Platonic philosophy ; and by Boethius , whose treatise upon numbers is but an abridgment of the wretched performance of Nichomachus * .
I flatter myself therefore , that a succinct account of it will not be unacceptable to this learned Society .
* There are more pieces than one of this Nichomachus extant .
That which I refer to is entitled ~ ~ .
But before I enter expressly upon the subject , I must take the liberty to animadvert upon a certain Table , which , among other pieces ascribed to Eratosthenes , is printed at the end of the beautiful edition of Aratus published at Oxford in the year 1672 , and is adorned with the title of ~ ~ .
It contains all the odd numbers from 3 to 113 inclusive , distributed in little cells , all the divisors of every Composite number being placed over it , in its proper cell , and the Prime numbers are distinguished , so far as the table goes , by having no divisors placed over them .
It hath probably been copied either from a Greek comment upon the Arithmetic of Nicomachus , preserved among the manuscripts of Mr. Selden in the Bodleian Library , in which , though the manuscript is now so much decayed as to be in most places illegible , I find plain vestiges of such a table * , which might be more perfect 100 years ago , when the Oxford Aratus was published ; or else , from another comment , translated from a Greek manuscript into Latin , and published in that language , by Camerarius , in which a table of the very same form occurs , extending from the number 3 to 109 inclusive .
It may sufficiently screen the editor of Aratus from censure , that he had these authorities to publish this table as the Sieve of Eratosthenes ; especially as they are in some measure supported by passages of Nicomachus himself .
But the Sieve of Eratosthenes was quite another thing .
* This manuscript seems to have contained the text of Nicomachus with Scholia in the margin .
But the table evidently belongs to the Scholia , not to the text .
The Oxford editor hath annexed to his table , to explain the use of it , some detached passages , which he hath selected from the text of Nicomachus , and from a comment upon Nicomachus ascribed to Joannes Grammaticus .
In these passages the difference between Prime and Composite numbers is explained , in many words indeed , but not with the greatest accuracy ; and it is proposed to frame a kind of Table of all the odd numbers , from 3 to any given limit , in which the Composite numbers should be distinguished by certain marks * .
The Primes would consequently be characterised , as far as the table should be carried , by being unmarked .
But , upon what principles , or by what rule , such a table is to be constructed , is not at all explained .
It is obvious that , in order to mark the Composite numbers , it is necessary to know which are such .
And , without some rule to distinguish which numbers are Prime , and which are Composite , independent of any table in which they shall be distinguished by marks , it is impossible to judge , whether the table be true , as far as it goes , or to extend it , if requisite , to a further limit .
Now it was the Rule by which the Prime numbers and the Composite might be distinguished , not a Table constructed we know not how , that was the invention of Eratosthenes , to which from its use , as well as from the nature of the operation , which * Nicomachus and Joannes Grammaticus propose that these marks should be such , as should not only distinguish the composite numbers , but likewise serve to express all the divisors of every such number .
It will be shown , in a proper place , that this was no part of the original contrivance of the Sieve .
proceeds ( as will be shown ) by a gradual extermination of the composite numbers from the arithmetical series 3 .
5 .
7 .
9 .
11 .
&amp;c. infinitely continued , its author gave the name of the Sieve .
I have thought it necessary to premise these remarks , to remove a prejudice , which I apprehend many may have conceived , as this beautiful and valuable edition of Aratus is in every ones hands , that this ill-contrived table , the useless work of some monk in a barbarous age , was the whole of the invention of the great Eratosthenes , and in justice to myself , that I might not be suspected of attempting to reap another 's harvest .
I now proceed , to give a true account of this excellent invention ; which , for its usefulness , as well as for its simplicity , I cannot but consider as one of the most precious remnants of Ancient Arithmetic .
I shall venture to represent it according to my own ideas , not obliging myself to conform , in every particular , to the account of Nicomachus , which I am persuaded is in many circumstances erroneous .
In stating the principles upon which the Operation of the Sieve was founded , he hath added observations upon certain relations of the odd numbers to one another , which are certainly his own , because they are of no importance in themselves , and are quite foreign to the purpose .
Every thing of this kind I omit : and having stated what I take to have been the genuine Theory of Eratosthenes 's method , cleared from the adulterations of Nicomachus , I deduce from it an operation of great simplicity , which solves the Problem in question with wonderful ease , and which , because it is the most simple that the theory seems to afford , I scruple not to adopt as the original Operation of the Sieve , though nothing like it is to be found in Nicomachus ; though , on the contrary , Nichomachus , and all his Commentators , would suggest an operation very different from it , and far more laborious .
For the satisfaction of the curious and the learned , I have annexed a copy of so much of Nicomachus 's treatise , as relates to this subject , with such corrections of the text , as it stands in the edition of Wichelius , printed at Paris ann .
1538 , as the sense hath suggested to me , or I have thought proper to adopt , upon the authority of a manuscript preserved among those of Archbishop Laud , in the Bodleian Library ; which , in this part , I have carefully collated .
By comparing this with the account which I subjoin , every one will be able to judge how far I have done justice to the invention I have undertaken to explain .
PROBLE M. To find all the Prime Numbers .
The number 2 is a Prime number ; but , except 2 , no even number is Prime , because every even number , except 2 , is divisible by 2 , and is therefore Composite .
Hence it follows , that all the Prime numbers , except the number 2 , are included in the series of the odd numbers , in their natural order , infinitely extended ; that is , in the series 3 .
5 .
7 .
9 .
11 .
13 .
15 .
17 .
19 .
21 .
23 .
25 .
27 .
29 .
31 .
33 .
35 .
37 .
39 .
41 .
43 .
45 .
47 .
49 .
51 .
&amp;c. Every number which is not Prime , is a multiple of some Prime number , as Euclid hath demonstrated ( Element .
7 .
prop. 33 .
) Therefore the foregoing series consists of the Prime numbers , and of multiples of the Primes .
And the multiples , of every number in the series , follow at regular distances ; by attending to which circumstance , all the multiples , that is , all the Composite numbers , may be easily distinguished and exterminated .
I say , the multiples of all numbers , in the foregoing series , follow at regular distances .
For between 3 and its first multiple in the series ( 9 ) two numbers intervene , which are not multiples of 3 .
Between 9 and the next multiple of 3 ( 15 ) two numbers likewise intervene , which are not multiples of 3 .
Again between 15 and the next multiple of 3 ( 21 ) two numbers intervene , which are not multiples of 3 ; and so on .
Again , between 5 and its first multiple ( 15 ) four numbers intervene , which are not multiples of 5 .
And between 15 and the next multiple of 5 ( 25 ) four numbers intervene which are not multiples of 5 ; and so on .
In like manner , between every pair of the multiples of 7 , as they stand in their natural order in the series , 6 numbers intervene which , are not multiples of 7 .
Universally , between every two multiples of any number n , as they stand in their natural order in the series , n-1 numbers intervene , which are not multiples of n. Hence may be derived an Operation for exterminating the Composite numbers , which I take to have been the Operation of the Sieve , and is as follows .
The Operation of the Sieve .
Count all the terms of the series following the number 3 , by threes , and expunge every third number .
Thus all the multiples of 3 are expunged .
The first uncancelled number that appears in the series , after 3 , is 5 .
Expunge the square of 5 .
Count all the terms of the series , which follow the square of 5 , by fives , and expunge every fifth number , if not expunged before .
Thus all the multiples of five are expunged , which were not at first expunged , among the multiples of 3 .
The next uncancelled number to 5 is 7 .
Expunge the square of 7 .
Count all the terms of the series following the square of 7 , by sevens , and expunge every seventh number , if not expunged before .
Thus all the multiples of 7 are expunged , which were not before expunged among the multiples of 3 or 5 .
The next uncancelled number which is now to be found in the series , after 7 , is 11 .
Expunge the square of 11 .
Count all the terms of the series , which follow the square 3 .
5 .
7 .
9 .
11 .
13 .
15 .
17 .
19 .
21 .
23 .
25 .
27 .
29 .
31 .
33 .
35 .
37 .
39 .
41 .
43 .
45 .
47 .
49 .
51 .
53 .
55 .
57 .
59 .
61 .
63 65 .
67 .
69 .
71 .
73 .
75 .
77 .
79 .
81 .
83 .
85 .
87 .
89 .
91 .
93 .
95 .
97 .
99 .
101 .
103 .
105 .
107 .
109 .
111 .
113 .
115 .
117 .
119 .
121 .
123 .
125 .
127 .
129 .
131 .
133 .
135 .
137 .
139 .
141 .
143 .
145 .
147 .
149 .
151 .
153 .
155 .
157 .
of 11 , by elevens , and expunge every eleventh number , if not expunged before .
Thus all the multiples of 11 are expunged , which were not before expunged among the multiples of 3 , 5 , and 7 .
Continue these expunctions , till the first uncancelled number that appears , next to that whose multiples have been last expunged , is such , that its square is greater than the last and greatest number to which the series is extended .
The numbers which then remain uncancelled are all the Prime numbers , except the number 2 , which occur in the natural progression of number from 1 to the limit of the series .
By the limit of the series I mean the last and greatest number to which it is thought proper to extend it .
Thus the prime numbers are found to any given limit .
Nicomachus proposes to make such marks over the Composite numbers , as should show all the divisors of each .
From this circumstance , and from the repeated intimations both of Nicomachus , and his commentator Joannes Grammaticus * , one would be led to imagine , that the Sieve of Eratosthenes was something more than its name imports , a method of sifting out the Prime numbers from the indiscriminate mass of all numbers Prime and Composite , and that , in some way or other , it exhibited all the divisors of every Composite number , and likewise showed whether two or * The Comment of Joannes Grammaticus is extant in manuscript in the Savilian Library at Oxford , to which I have frequent access , by the favour of the Reverend and Learned Mr. Hornsby , the Savilian Pofessor of Astronomy .
more Composite numbers were Prime or Composite with respect to each other .
I have many reasons to think , that this was not the case .
I shall as briefly as possible point out some of the chief , for the matter is not so important , as to justify my troubling the Society with a minute detail of them .
First then , in the natural series of odd numbers , 3 .
5 .
7 .
&amp;c. every number is a divisor of some succeeding number .
Therefore if we are to have marks for all the different divisors of every Composite number , we must have a different mark for every odd number .
Therefore we must have as many marks , or systems of marks , as numbers ; and I do not see , that it would be possible , to find any more compendious marks , than the common numeral characters .
This being the case , it would be impracticable to carry such a table as Nicomachus proposes , and his commentators have sketched , to a sufficient length to be of use , on account of the multiplicity of the divisors of many numbers , and the confusion which this circumstance would create * .
It is hardly to be supposed , that Eratosthenes could overlook this obvious difficulty , though Nicomachus hath not attended to it .
Eratosthenes therefore could not intend the construction of such a table .
In the next place , such a table not being had , Eratosthenes could not but perceive , that , the determining whether two or more numbers be Prime or Composite with respect to one another , is in all cases to be done more easily , by the direct method given by Euclid , than by * The number 3465 hath no less than 22 different divisors .
the method of the Sieve .
And he could not mean , to apply this method to a problem , to which another was better adapted .
Lastly , Eratosthenes could not mean , that the method of the Sieve should be applied to the finding of all the possible divisors of any Composite number proposed , because he could not be unacquainted with a more ready way of doing this , founded upon two obvious Theorems , which could not be unknown to him .
The Theorems I mean are these .
1st .
If two Prime numbers multiply each other , the number produced hath no divisors but the two prime factors .
2d .
If a Prime number multiply a Composite number , and likewise multiply all the divisors of that composite severally , the numbers produced by the multiplications of these divisors will be divisors of the number produced by the first multiplication : And the number produced by the first multiplication will have no divisors , but the two factors , the divisors of the Composite factor , and the numbers made by the multiplication of these divisors by the Prime factor severally .
The method of finding all the divisors of any Composite number , delivered by Sir Isaac Newton in the Arithmetica Universalis , and by Mr. Maclaurin in his Treatise of Algebra , may be deduced from these propositions , as every mathematician will easily perceive .
This method requires indeed that the least prime divisor should be previously found ; and , if the least prime divisor should happen to be a large number , as it is not assignable by any general method , the investigation of it by repeated tentations may be very tedious .
A table therefore of the odd numbers * , in which the Composite numbers should each have its least Prime divisor written over it , would be very useful .
But Nichomachus 's project of framing a table in which each Composite number should have all its divisors written over it , is ridiculous and absurd , on account of the insuperable difficulties which would attend the execution of it .
Feb. 7 , 1772 .
S. Horsley .
*A table of the odd numbers would be sufficient : for the number 2 is the least prime divisor of every even number ; and it is easy , even in the largest numbers , to try whether they are divisible by 2 .
In our method of notation , this may always be known , by observing the last figure in the expression of the number proposed .
EXCERPTAQU AE DAM EX Arithmetica Nicomachi Ad Cribrum Eratosthenis pertinentia .
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ( a ) Mallem ~ , etsi , no quid dissimulem , lectioni receptae adstipulatur Boethii interpretatio .
( b ) Voces uncis inclusas conjectura supplevi ; quin et sequentium ordinem paululum immutavi , pro ~~~ ~ , scribendo ~~ ~ .
~ .
~ .
( c ) Vocem ~ hic loci retinendam censeo .
Locum integrum sic interpretor .
` ` ~ horum indaginem Eratosthenes , Cribrum vocavit .
Propterea quod imparibus universis , nullo generum discrimine , in medio collocatis , ipsam procreationem continuam , quo tradidit ille modo , insequendo [ id est , procreationis continuae , Eratosthenis modo , explorata lege ] species diversas seorsim sistimus , cribro tanquam separatas .
' ' ( d ) Cod .
MS .
habet ~ .
Wechelius ~ .
( e ) Ex Cod .
MS .
pro ~ .
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ( f ) Locum in Editione Wechelii corruptum , in Cod .
MS .
mutilum &amp; turbatum , conjectura , prout potui , sanatum dedi .
Editio Wechelii habet ~~~~ ~ .
Codex MS .
~ .
( g ) Conjectura , pro ~ .
( h ) Litera numeralem ~ , conjectura posui pro voce ~ .
( i ) Restitui ex Cod .
MS pro ~ , quae est Wechelii lectio .
( k ) Particulam ~ omisi .
( l ) Wechelium sequor .
Cod .
MS .
habet ~ , sensu , ut videtur , ~ .
( m ) Ex Cod .
MS .
pro ~ .
* Conjectura pro ~ .
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ( n ) Conjectura pro ~ .
( o ) Voces ~~ ex Cod .
MS .
restitui .
( p ) Nempe series numerorum imparium 3 , 5 , 7 , 9 , &amp;c. infinite protensa , cum numeros impares universos contineat , imparis cujusvis multiplices omnes impares necessario complectitur .
Esto igitur n numerus quilibet impar .
In serie 3 , 5 , 7 , &amp;c. infinite protensa , habes numeros omnes nx 3 , nx 5 , nx 7 , nx 9 , &amp;c. Et cum seriei ea Lex sit &amp; Condition , ut naturali ordine numeri impares sequantur , &amp; minor omnis numerus majorem praecedat , fieri nequit , quin multiplices numeri n eum inter se ordinem servant , ut minor quisque majorem praecedat .
Primus igitur erit nx 3 , secundus nx 5 , tertius nx 7 , &amp; universim , nxm eum habiturus est , inter multiplices , locum , quem numerus m in serie .
( q ) Ex Cod .
MS .
vice ~ , quae Wechelii lectio est .
( r ) Conjectura pro ~ .
( s ) Particulam ~ ex Cod .
MS restitui .
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ( t ) Voces ~~~ conjectura supplevi .
( u ) Literam numeralem ~ pro voce ~ quae apud Wechelium legitur , ex Cod .
MS restitui .
( x ) Voces ~~~ ex Cod .
MS .
restitui .
Ex Arithmetica Boethii .
Lib. I. c. xvii .
GENERATIO autem ipsorum atque ortus hujusmodi investigatione colligitur , quam scilicet Eratosthenes Cribrum nominabat ; quod cunctis imparibus in medio collocatis , per eam , quam tradituri sumus , artem , qui primi , quive secundi , quique tertii generis videantur esse distinguitur .
Disponantur enim a ternario numero cuncti in ordinem impares , in quamlibet longissimam porrectionem 3 .
5 .
7 .
9 .
11 .
13 .
15 .
17 .
19 .
21 .
23 .
25 .
27 .
29 .
31 .
33 .
35 .
37 .
39 .
41 .
43 .
45 .
47 .
49 .
His igitur ita dispositis , considerandum , primus numerus quem eorum , qui sunt in ordine positi , primum metiri possit : sed , duobus praeteritis , illum , qui post eos est positus , mox metitur : et , si post eundem ipsum quem mensus est , alii duo transmissi sunt , illum , qui post duos est , rursus metitur : et , eodem modo si duos quis reliquerit , post eos qui est , a primo numero metiendus est ; eodemque modo , relictis semper duobus , a primo , in infinitum pergentes metientur .
Sed id non vulgo neque confuse .
Nam primus numerus illum , qui est post duos secundum se locatos , per suam quantitatem metitur : ternarius enim numerus ter a9 metitur .
Si autem post novenarium duos reliquero , qui mihi post illos incurre~ Conjectura pro tertio .
rit , a primo metiendus est , per secundi imparis quantitatem ; id est , per quinarium : nam si post 9 duos relinquam , id est 11 &amp; 13 , ternarius numerus 15 metietur , per secundi numeri quantitatem , id est , per quinarii ; quoniam numerus ternarius 15 quinquies metitur .
Rursus , si a quindenario inchoans duos intermisero , qui posterior positus est , ejus primus numerus mensura est , per tertii imparis pluralitatem : nam si post 15 intermisero 17 &amp; 19 , incurrit 21 , quem ternarius numerus secundum septenarium metitur ; 21 enim numeri ternarius septima pars est : atque hoc in infinitum faciens , reperio primum numerum , si binos intermisero , omnes sequentes post se metiri , secundum quantitatem positorum ordine imparium numerorum .
Si vero quinarius numerus , qui in secundo loco est constitutus , velit b quis , cujus prima ac deinceps sit mensura , invenire , transmissis quatuor imparibus , quintus ei quem metiri possit , occurrit .
Intermittantur enim quatuor impares , id est , 7 &amp; 9 , &amp; 11 &amp; 13 , post hos est quintus decimus quem quinarius metitur , secundum primi scilicet quantitatem , id est , ternarii ; quinque enim 15 ter e metiuntur : ac deinceps , si quatuor intermittat , eum qui post illos locatus est , secundus , id est , quinarius , sui quantitate metitur : nam post quindecim intermissis 17 &amp; 19 , &amp; 21 &amp; 23 , post eos 25 reperio , quos quinarius scilicet numerus sua pluralitate metitur ; quinquies enim quinario multiplicato , 25 succrescunt ; si vero post hunc quilibet quatuor intermittat , eadem ordinis servata b Conjectura pro vel .
c Conjectura pro tertio .
constantia , qui eos sequitur , secundum tertii , id est , septenarii numeri summam , a quinario metitur : atque haec est infinita processio .
Si vero tertius numerus quem metiri possit exquiritur , sex in medio relinquentur ; &amp; quem septimum ordo monstraverit , hic per primi numeri , id est , ternarii quantitatem metiendus est : et post illum , sex aliis interpositis , quem post eos numeri series dabit , per quinarium , id est , per secundum , tertii eum mensura percurret : si vero alios rursus sex in medio quis relinquat , ille , qui sequitur , per septenarium ab eodem septenario metiendus est ; id est , per tertii quantitatem ; atque hic usque in extremum ratus ordo progreditur .
Suscipient ergo metiendi vicissitudinem , quemadmodum sunt in ordine naturaliter impares constituti : metientur autem , si per pares numeros , a binario inchoantes , positos inter se impares , rata intermissione , transiliant ; ut primus duos , secundus quatuor , tertius sex , quartus octo , quintus decem d : vel si locos suos conduplicent , &amp; secundum duplicationem terminos intermittant ; ut ternarius , qui primus est numerus , &amp; Unus , omnis enim primus Unus est , bis locum suum multiplicet , faciatque bis unum ; qui cum duo sint , primus duos medios transeat .
Rursus secundus , id est , quinarius , si locum suum multiplicet , 4 explicabitur : hic quoque quatuor e intermittat .
Item si septenarius , qui tertius est , locum suum duplicet , sex creabit ; bis enim 3 senarium jungunt : hic ergo in ordidine f sex relinquat .
Quartus quoque , si locum d Conjectura restitui pro 12 .
e Conjectura pro 4 .
f Conjectura pro ordinem .
suum duplicet , 8 succrescent ; ille quoque octo transiliat : atque hoc quidem in caeteris perspiciendum .
Modum autem mensionis , secundum ordinem collocatorum , ipsa series dabit .
Nam primus primum quem numerat , secundum primum numerat g , id est , secundum se ; &amp; secundum primus quem numerat , per secundum numerat g , &amp; tertium per tertium , &amp; quartum item per quartum .
Cum autem secundus mensionem h susceperit , primum quem numerat secundum primum metitur ; secundum vero quem numerat per se , id est , per secundum ; &amp; tertium per tertium : &amp; in caeteris eadem similitudine mensura constabit .
Illos i ergo si respicias , vel qui alios mensi sunt , vel qui ipsi ab aliis metiuntur , invenies omnium simul communem mensuram esse non posse , neque ut omnes quemquam alium simul numerent ; quosdam autem ex his ab alio posse metiri , ita ut ab uno tantum numerentur k ; alios vero , ut etiam a pluribus ; quosdem autem , ut praeter Unitatem eorum nulla mensura sit .
Qui ergo nullam mensuram praeter Unitatem recipiunt , hos Primos &amp; Incomf Conjectura pro 8 .
g Pro numerat mallem in utroque loco , metitur , ut aliud sit numerare , aliud metiri , &amp; sensus sit , ` ` That which the first number [ of the Series ] counts the first [ of its multiples ] , it measures by the first [ of the Series ] , i. e. by itself .
That which it counts the second [ of its multiples ] , it measures by the second [ number in the Series ] .
' ' Sic enim infra legimus de Numero ordine secundo , ` ` primum quem numerat seundum primum metitur .
' ' h Conjectura , pro mansionem .
~ Conjectura , pro alios .
~ Ang .
` ` But so as to be counted in among the multiples of one number only .
' ' positos judicamus ; qui vero aliquam mensuram praeter Unitatem , vel alienigenae partis vocabulum fortiuntur , eos pronunciemus Secundos atque Compositos .
Tertium vero illud genus , per se Secundi &amp; Compositi , Primi vero &amp; Imcompositi ad alterutrum comparati , hac inquisitor ratione reperiet .
Si enim quoslibet primos numeros , secundum suam in semetipsos multiplices quantitatem , qui procreantur , ad alterutrum comparati , nulla mensura communione junguntur : 3m enim &amp; 5 , si multiplices , 3 ter n9 faciunt , &amp; quinquies 5 reddunt 25 .
His igitur nulla est cognatio communis mensurae .
Rursus 5 &amp; 7 quos procreant , si compares , hi quoque incommensurabiles erunt : quinquies enim 5 , ut dictum est , 25 , septies 7 faciunt 49 ; quorum mensura nulla communis est , nisi forte omnium horum procreatrix &amp; matter Unitas o. 1 Conjectura pro illos .
m Conjectura , pro tres .
n Conjectura pro tres tertio .
o Sed cave credas , Lector , numeros inter se primos nullos dari praeter Primorum Quadratos .

