Received November 29 , 1771 .
XX .
An Essay on the periodical Appearing and Disappearing of certain Birds , at different Times of the Year .
In a Letter from the Honourable Daines Barrington , Vice-Pres .
R. S. to William Watson , M. D. F. R. S. DEARSI R , ASI know , from some conversation we have had on this head , that you consider the migration of birds as a very interesting point in natural history , I send you the following reflections on this subject as they have occurred to me upon looking into most of the ornithologists who have written on this question .
Read April 2 , 9 , 30 , and May 14 , 1772 .
It will be first necessary in the present , as in all other disputes , to define the terms on which the controversy arises .
I therefore premise that I mean by the word Migration , a periodical passage by a whole species of birds across a considerable extent of sea .
I do not mean therefore to deny that a bird , or birds , may possibly fly now and then from Dover to Calais , from Gibraltar to Tangier , or any other such narrow strait , as the opposite coasts are clearly within the bird 's ken , and the passage is no more adventurous than across a large fresh water lake .
I as little mean to deny that there may be a periodical flitting of certain birds from one part of a continent to another : the Royston Crow , and Rock Ouzel , furnish instances of such a regular migration .
What I mean chiefly to contend therefore is , that it seems to be highly improbable , birds should , at certain seasons , traverse large tracts of sea , or rather ocean , without leaving any of the same species behind , but the sick or wounded .
As this litigated point can only receive a satisfactory decision from very accurate observations , all preceding naturalists , from Aristotle to Ray , have spoken with much doubt concerning it .
Soon after the appearance of Mons. Adanson 's voyage to Senegal , however , Mr. Collinson first , in the Philosophical Transactions * , and after him the most eminent ornithologists of Europe , seem to have considered this traveller 's having caught four European Swallows on the 6th of October , not far from the African coast , as a decisive proof , that the common swallows , when they disappear in Europe , make for Africa during the winter , and return again to us in the spring .
It is therefore highly incumbent upon me , who profess that I am by no means satisfied with the account , given by Mons. Adanson of these European * Part II .
1760 , p. 459 , &amp; seq. swallows , to enter into a very minute discussion of what may , or may not , be inferred from his observation according to his own narrative .
I shall first however consider the general arguments , from which it is supposed that birds of passage periodically traverse oceans , which indeed may be almost reduced to this single one , viz. we see certain birds in particular seasons , and afterwards we see them not ; from which data it is at once inferred , that the cause of their disappearance is , that they have crossed large tracts of sea .
The obvious answer to this is , that no well-attested instances can be produced of such a migration , as I shall endeavour to show hereafter ; but besides this convincing negative proof , there are not others wanting .
Those who send birds periodically across the sea , being pressed with the very obvious answer I have before suggested , have recourse to two suppositions , by which they would account for their not being observed by seamen during their passage .
The first is , that they rise so high in the air that they become invisible * ; but unfortunately the rising to this extraordinary height , or the falling from it , is equally destitute of any ocular proof , as the birds being seen during their passage .
I have indeed conversed with some people , who conceive they have lost sight of birds by their perpendicular flight ; I must own , however , that I have * It is well known that some ornithologists have even supposed that they leave our atmosphere for that of the Moon .
See Harl .
Misc .
Vol. II .
p. 561 .
always supposed them to be short-sighted , as I never lost the sight of a bird myself , but from its horizontal distance , and I doubt much whether any bird was ever seen to rise to a greater height than perhaps twice that of St. Paul 's cross * .
There seems to be but one method indeed , by which the height of a bird in the air may be estimated ; which is , by comparing its apparent size with its known one , when very near us ; and it need not be said that method of calculating must depend entirely upon the sight of the observer , who , if he happens not to see objects well at a distance , will very soon suppose the bird to be lost in the clouds .
There is also another objection to the hypothesis of birds passing seas at such an extraordinary height , arising from the known rarefaction of the air , which may possibly be inconvenient for respiration , as well as flight ; and if this was not really the case , one should suppose that birds would frequently rise to such uncommon elevations , when they had no occasion to traverse oceans .
* Wild geese fly at the greatest height of any bird I ever happened to attend to ; and from comparing them with rooks , which I have frequently looked at , when perched on the cross of St. Paul 's , I cannot think that a wild-goose was ever diminished , to my sight at least , more than he would be at twice the height of St. Paul 's , or perhaps 300 yards .
Mr. Hunter , F. R. S. informs me , that the bird which hath appeared to him as the highest flier , is a small eagle on the confines of Spain and Portugal , which frequents high rocks .
Mr. Hunter hath first seen this species of eagle from the bottom of a mountain , and followed it to the top , when the bird hath risen so high as to appear less than he did from the bottom .
Mr. Hunter however adds , that he could still hear the cry , and distinguish the bird .
The Scotch Ptarmigan frequents the highest ground of any British bird , and he takes but very short flights .
But it is also urged by some , that the reason why seamen do not regularly see the migration of birds , is because they choose the night , and not the day , for the passage * .
Now though it may be allowed , that possibly birds may cross from the coast of Holland to the Eastern coast of England ( for example ) during a long night , yet it must be dark nearly as long as it is within the Arctic circle to afford time for a bird to pass from the Line to many parts of Europe , which Mons. de Buffon calculates , may be done in about eight or nine days ~ .
If the passage happened in half the nights of the year , which have the benefit of moonlight , the birds would be discovered by the sailors almost as well as in the day time ; to which I must add that several supposed birds of passage ( the Fieldfare in particular ) always call when on their flight , so that the seamen must be deaf as well as blind , if such flocks of birds escape their notice .
Other objections however remain to this hypothesis of a passage during the night .
* Mr. Catesby supposes that they may thus pass in the night time , to avoid birds of prey .
Phil. Trans. Abr .
Vol. II .
p. 887 .
But are not owls then stirring ?
On the other hand , if they migrate in the day time , kites , hawks , and other birds of prey , must be very bad sportsmen not to attend ( like Arabs ) these large and periodical caravans .
~ In the preface to the first volume of his lately published Ornithology , p. 32 .
Most birds not only sleep during the night , but are as much incapacitated from distinguishing objects well as we are , in the absence of the sun : it is therefore inconceivable that they should choose owl-light for such a distant journey .
Besides this , the Eastern coast of England , to which birds of passage must necessarily first come from the continent , hath many light-houses upon it ; they would therefore , in a dark night , immediately make for such an object , and destroy themselves by flying with violence against it , as is well known to every bat-fowler .
Having endeavoured to answer these two suppositions , by which it is contended that birds of passage may escape observation in their flight ; I shall now consider all the instances I have been able to meet with of any birds being actually seen whilst they were crossing any extent of sea , though I might give a very short refutation to them , by insisting , that if this was ever experienced , it must happen as constantly in a sea , which is much navigated , as the return of the seasons .
I cannot do better than to follow these according to chronological order .
The first in point of time is that which is cited by Willoughby * , from Bellon , whose words are thus translated , ` ` When we sailed from Rhodes to Alexandria , many quails flying from the North towards the South , were taken in our ship , whence I am persuaded that they shift places ; for formerly , when I sailed out of the Isle of Zant to Morea , or Negropont , in the spring , I had ob* B. II .
c. 11 .
~ .
8 .
served quails flying the contrary way to N. and S. that they might abide there all summer , at which time also a great many were taken in the ship .
' ' Let us now consider what is to be inferred from this citation .
In the first place , Bellon does not particularize the longitude and latitude of that part of the Mediterranean , which he was then crossing ; and in his course from Rhodes to Alexandria , both the islands of Scarpanto and Crete could be at no great distance : these quails therefore were probably flitting from one island of the Mediterranean * to another .
The same observation may be made with regard to the quails which he saw between Zant and Negropont , as the whole passage is crouded with islands , they therefore might be passing from island to island , or headland to headland , which might very probably lye East and West , so as to occasion the birds flying in a different direction , from which they passed the ship before .
I have therefore no objection to this proof of migration , if it is only insisted upon the show that a quail shifts its station at certain seasons of the year ; but cannot admit that it is fair from hence to argue that these birds periodically cross large tracts of sea .
Bellon himself states , that when the birds settled upon the ship , they were taken by the first person who chose to catch them , and therefore they must have been unequal to the short flight which they were attempting .
* One of the Mediterranean islands is supposed to have obtained its ancient name of Ortygia from the numbers of quails .
It is very true that qualis have been often pitched upon as instances of birds that migrate across seas , because they are scarcely ever seen in winter : it is well known , however , to every sportsman , that this bird never flies 300 yards at a time , and the tail being so short , it is highly improbable they should be equal to a passage of any length .
We find therefore , that quails , which are commonly supposed to leave our island in the winter , in reality retire to the sea coasts , and pick up their food amongst the sea weeds * .
I have happened lately to see a specimen of a particular species of quail , which is described by Dr. Shaw ~ , and is distinguished from the other kinds by wanting the hind-claw .
Dr. Shaw also states that it is a bird of passage .
Now if quails really migrate from the coast of Barbary to Italy , as is commonly supposed , whence can it have arisen that this remarkable species hath escaped the notice of Aldrovandus , Olina , and the other Italian ornithologists ?
When I had just finished what I have here said with regard to the migration of quails , I have had an opportunity of seeing the second volume of Mons. de Buffon 's ornithology ~ ; where , under this article , he contends that this bird leaves Europe in the winter .
It is incumbent upon me , therefore , either to own I am convinced by what this most ingenious and able naturalist hath urged , or to give my reasons why I * See Br .
Zool. Vol. II .
p. 210 .
2d Ed. octavo .
~ Phys. Obs. on the kingdom of Algiers , ch .
2 .
~ See p. 459 , &amp; seq. still continue to dissent from the opinion he maintains .
Though M. de Buffon hath discussed this point very much at large , yet I find only the following facts or arguments to be new .
He first cites the Memoirs of the Academy of Sciences * , for an account given by M. Godeheu of quails coming to the island of Malta in the month of May , and leaving it in September .
The first answer to this observation is , that the island of Malta is not only near to the coast of Africa , but to several of the Mediterranean islands ; it therefore amounts to no more than the flitting I have before taken notice of ~ .
Mons. de Buffon supposes that a quail only quits one latitude for another , in order to meet with a perpetual crop on the ground .
Now can it be supposed that there is that difference between the harvest on the coast of Africa , and that of the small quantity of grain which grows on the rocky island of Malta , that it becomes inconvenient to the bird to stay in Africa as soon as May sets in ; and necessary , on the other hand , to continue in Malta from May till September .
Mons. de Buffon then supposes that quails make their passage in the night , as well as conceives them to be of remarkably warm temperature ~ , and says * Tom. III .
p. 91 and 92 .
~ Both Mons. de Godeheu and M. de Buffon seem to conceive that the quail should fly in the same direction as the wind blows ; but birds on the wing from point to point , which are at a considerable distance , fly against the wind , as their plumage is otherwise ruffled .
~ As this is given for a reason why the African quails migrate Northward : Q. what is to become of the Icelandis quails during the summer ?
that ` ` chaud comme un caille , ' ' is in every one 's mouth * .
Now in the first place their migration during the night , is contrary to Belon 's account , which M. de Buffon so much relies upon , who expressly says , that the birds were caught in the day time ~ .
In the next place , I apprehend that ` ` chaud comme un caille , ' ' alludes to the very remarkable salaciousness of this bird , and not to the constant heat of its body .
Mons. de Buffon then observes , that if quails are kept in a cage , they are remarkably impatient of confinement in the autumn and spring , whence he infers that they then want to migrate ~ ; he also adds , in the same period , that this uneasiness begins an hour before the sun rises , and that it continues all the night .
This great naturalist does not state this observation as having been made by himself , and it seems upon the face of it to be a very extraordinary one .
* All birds indeed are warmer by four degrees than other animals .
See some ingenious thermometrical experiments by Mr. Martin of Aberdeen , Edinb .
1771 , 12mo .
~ Upon looking a second time into Belon , he does not indeed state whether it was in the day or the night ; but if it had happened in the latter , this traveller and ornithologist could not well have omitted such a circumstance .
Besides this , he mentions in what direction the quails were flying , which he could not have discerned in the night .
~ It may also arise from this bird 's being of so quarrelsome a disposition , and consequently most likely to fight with its fellow prisoners when they are all in greatest vigour after moulting , and on the return of the spring .
M. de Buffon allows that they will fight for a grain of millet , and adds , ` ` car parmi les animaux il faut un sujet reel pour se battre .
' ' M. de Buffon hath never been in a cockpit .
No one ( at least with us ) ever keeps quails in a cage except the poulterers , who always sell them as fast as they are fat , and consequently can give no account of what happens to them during so long an imprisonment as this observation necessarily implies .
No such remarkable uneasiness hath ever been attended to in any other supposed bird of passage during its confinement ; but , allowing the fact to be as M. de Buffon states , he himself supplies us with the real cause of this impatience .
He asserts , that quails constantly moult twice *a year , viz. at the close both of summer and winter ; whence it follows , that the bird , in autumn and the spring , must be in full vigour upon its recovery from this periodical illness : it can therefore as little brook confinement , as the physician 's patient upon the return of health after illness .
Thus much I have thought it necessary to say , in answer to M. de Buffon , who ` ` dum errat , docet , ' ' who scarcely ever argues ill but when he is misinformed as to facts , and who often , from strength of understanding , disbelieves such intelligence as might impose upon a naturalist of less acuteness and penetration .
*I have often heard that certain birds moult twice a year , some of which I have kept myself without their changing their feathers more than once .
I should suppose that this notion arises from some birds not moulting regularly in the autumn every year ; and when the change takes place in the following spring , they very commonly die : I can scarcely think that many of them are equal to two illnesses of so long a continuance , which are constantly to return within twelvemo nths .
I should therefore rather account for the extraordinary briskness of a quail in autumn and the spring , from its recovery after moulting in the former , and from the known effects of the spring as to most animals in the latter .
The next instance of a bird being caught at any distance from land , is in Sir Hans Sloane 's voyage to Jamaica , who says , that a lark was taken in the ship 40 leagues from the shore : this therefore was certainly an unfortunate bird , forced out to sea by a strong wind in flying from headland to headland , as no one supposes the skylark to be a bird of passage .
The same answer may be given to a yellow-hammer 's settling upon Hasselquist 's ship in the entrance of the Mediterranean , with this difference , that either the European or African coast must have been much nearer than 40 leagues * .
The next fact to be considered is what is mentioned in a letter of Mr. Peter Collinson 's , printed in the Philosophical Transactions ~ .
He there says , ` ` That Sir Charles Wager had frequently informed him , that in one of his voyages home in the spring as he came into soundings in our channel , that a great flock of swallows almost covered his rigging , that they were nearly spent and famished , and were only feathers and bones ; but being recruited by a night 's rest , they took their flight in the morning .
' ' The first answer to this is , that if these were birds which had crossed large tracts of sea in their periodical migrations , the same accident must happen eternally , both in the spring and autumn , which is not however pretended by any one .
In the next place , the swallows are stated to be spent both by famine and fatigue ; and how were they to procure any flies or other sustenance on the * See Hasselquist 's Travels , in princ .
~ 1760 .
Part II .
p. 461 .
rigging of the admiral 's ship , though they migth indeed rest themselves ?
Sir Charles , however , expressly informs us , that he was in the channel , and within soundings : these birds , therefore ( like Bellon 's quails ) were only passing probably from headland to headland ; and being forced out by a strong wind , were obliged to settle upon the first ship they saw , or otherwise must have dropped into the sea , which I make no doubt happens to many unfortunate birds under the same circumstances .
As the birds which thus settled upon Sir Charles Wager 's rigging were swallows , it very naturally brings me now to consider the celebrated observation of Mons. Adanson , under all its circumstances , as it hath been so much relied upon , and by naturalists of so great eminence .
Mons. Adanson is a very ingenious writer , and the public is much indebted to him for many of the remarks which he made whilst he resided in Senegal .
I may , however , I think , presume to say , that he had not before his voyage made ornithology his particular study ; proofs of which are not wanting in other parts of his work , which do not relate to swallows .
For example , he supposes , that the Canary birds which are bred in Europe are white , and that they become so by our climate 's being more cold than that of Africa .
J'ai remarque que le serin qui devient tout blanc en France , est a Teneriffe d'un gris presque aussi fonce que celui de la linotte ; ce changement de couleur provient vraisemblablement de la froidure de notre climate * .
' ' * Voyage au Senegal , p. 13 .
Mr. Adanson in this passage seems to have deduced two false inferences from having seen a few white Canary birds in France , which he afterwards compares with those of Teneriff , and supposes the change of colour to arise merely from alteration of climate : it is known , however , almost to every one , that there is an infinite variety in the plumage of the European Canary birds , which , as in poultry , arises from their being pampered with so much food , as well as confinement * .
Mons. Adanson , in another part of his voyage ~ , describes a Roller , which he supposes to migrate sometimes to the Southern parts of Europe .
This circumstance shows that he could not have looked much into books of natural history , because the principal synonym of this bird is garrulus Argentoratensis ~ ; and Linnaeus informs us that it is found even in Sweden ~ .
* In the same passage , he compares the colour of the African Canary bird to that of the European linnet , and says it is d'un gris presque aussi fonce , whereas the European linnet is well known to be brown , and not grey .
The linnet affords a very decisive proof that the change of plumage does not arise from the difference of climate , but the two causes I have assigned .
The cock bird , whilst at liberty , hath a red breast : yet if it is either bred up in a cage from the nest , or is caught with its red plumage , and afterwards moults in the house , it never recovers the red feathers .
That most able naturalist , Mons. de Buffon , from having seen some cock linnets which had thus moulted off , or perhaps some hen linnets ( which have not a red breast ) considers them as a distinct species , and compares their breeding together in an aviary , to that of the Canary bird and goldfinch .
Ornith .
p. XXII .
~ P. 16 .
~ Or of Strasburgh .
~ Faun .
Suec. 94 .
The strong characteristic mark of this bird , is the outermost feathers of the tail , which able naturalists describe as three fourths of an inch longer than the rest * .
Mons. Adanson , however , compares their length , not with the other feathers of the tail , but with the length of the bird 's body , which is by no means the natural or proper standard of comparison .
The reason of my taking notice of these more minute inaccuracies in Mons. Adanson 's account of birds , arises from Mr. Collinson 's relying upon his observations with regard to swallows being so absolutely decisive , because he is represented to be so able a naturalist .
I shall now state ( very minutely ) under what circumstances these swallows were caught , and what seems to be the true inference from his own account .
He informs us , that four swallows settled upon the ship , not 50 leagues from the coast of Senegal , on the 6th of October ; that these birds were taken , and that he knew them to be the true swallow of Europe~ , which he supposes were then returning to the coast of Africa .
I shall now endeavour to show that these birds could not be European swallows ; nor , if they were , could they have been on their return from Europe to Africa .
* Willoughby , p. 131 .
Br .
Zool. Vol. II .
in append .
~I have before endeavoured to show that Mons. Adanson does not always recollect with accuracy the plumage of the most common European birds , by what he says with regard to the linnet .
The word hirondelle , in French , is used as a general term for the four * species of these birds , as the term swallow is with us .
Now the four swallows thus caught and examined by Mons. Adanson were either all of the same species , or intermixed in some other proportion .
Would not then any naturalist in stating so material a fact ( as he himself supposes it to be ) have particularised of what species of swallow these very interesting birds were ?
Should not Mons. Adanson also have taken care to distinguish these supposed European swallows from two species of the same tribe , which bear a general resemblance to those of Europe , and are not only described , but engraved by Brisson , under the name of Hirondelle de Senegal &amp; Hirondelle de rivage du Senegal ~ ?
Though Mons. Adanson was above a year on this part of the African coast , paid so much attention to swallows , and was so immediately acquainted with the different species on the first inspection , yet he seems never to have discovered that there were such African swallows as are thus described and engraved by Brisson , though he must have seen them daily .
Mons. Adanson however concludes his account of the supposed European swallow , whilst it continues on the coast of Senegal , by a circumstance which * Viz .
the swallow ~ ~ , the martin , the sand martin , and the swift : I omit the goatsucker , because this bird , though properly classed as a species of swallow by ornithologists , is not so considered by others .
~ See Brisson , Tom. II .
pl. xiv .
seems to prove to demonstration of what species the four swallows caught in the ship really were .
He says that they roost on the sand either by themselves , or at most only in pairs , and that they frequent the coast much more than the inland parts * .
These swallows therefore , if they came from Europe , must have immediately changed at once their known habits : and is it not consequently most clear that they were of that species which Brisson describes under the name of Hirondelle de rivage du Senegal ?
But though it should be admitted , notwithstanding what I have insisted upon , from Mons. Adanson 's own account , that these were really swallows of the same kind with those of Europe ; yet I must still contend that they could not possibly have been on their return from Europe to Africa , because the high road for a bird from the most Western point of Europe to Senegal , is along the N. West coast of Africa , which projects greatly to the Westward of any part of Europe .
What then could be the inducement to these four swallows to fly 50 leagues to the Westward of the coast of Senegal , so much out of the proper direction ?
It seems to me therefore , very clear , that these swallows ( whether of the European kind or not ) were flitting from the cape de Verde islands to the * Voyage au Senegal , p. 67 .
I wish Mons. Adanson had also informed us whether these swallows had the same notes with those of Europe , which is a very material circumstance in the natural history of birds , though little attended to by most ornithologists .
coast of Africa , to which short flight , however , they were unequal , and were obliged from fatigue to fall into the sailors hands .
Mons. A danson likewise mentions * that the ship 's company caught a Roller on the 26th of April , which he supposes was on its passage to Europe , though he was then within sight of the coast of Senegal : this bird , however , must be admitted not to have had sufficient strenght to reach the first stage of this round-about journey , and was therefore probably forced out to sea by a strong wind , in passing from head-land to head-land .
But I must not dismiss what hath been observed with regard to the swallows seen by Mons. Adanson at Senegal , without endeavouring also to answer what M. de Buffon hath not only inferred from it , but hath endeavoured to confirm by an actual experiment ~ .
M. de Buffon , from the many instances of swallows being found torpid even under water , very readily admits , that all the birds of this genus do not migrate , but only that species which was seen by Mons. Adanson in Africa , and which he generally refers to as the chimney swallow ~ ; but from the outset , seems * Voyage au Senegal , p. 15 .
~ See the two prefatory discourses to his sixteenth volume of natural history .
~ So little do naturalists know of this very common bird , that I believe it hath never yet been observed by any writer , that the male swallow hath only the long slender feathers in the tail , which are considered as its most distinguishing marks .
I venture to make this remark upon having seen the difference in two swallows which are in Mr. Tunstall 's collection , F. R. S. as also in two others , which have lately been presented to the Museum to show that he hath himself confounded this species with the martin .
Prenons un seul oiseau , par exemple , l'hirondelle , celle que tout le monde connoit , qui paroit au printems , disparoit en automne , &amp; fait son nid avec de la terre contre les fenetres , ou dans les cheminees .
' ' p. 23 .
It is very clear that the design in this period is to specify a particular bird in such a manner that no doubt could remain with any one about the species referred to ; and from other passages which follow , it is as clear that Mons. de Buffon means to allude to the swallow ~ ~ .
Though this was certainly the intention of this most ingenious naturalist , it is to me very evident that the martin , and not the swallow , was in his contemplation , because he first speaks of the bird 's building against windows , before he mentions chimneys , and therefore supposes that either place is indifferent ; which is not the case , because the swallow seldom builds on the sides of windows , or the martin in chimneys .
There are perhaps three or four martins to one swallow in all parts ; and from their being the more common bird of the two , as well as from the circumstance of their building at the corner of windows ( and consequently being eternally in our sight ) , nineof the Royal Society , by the directors of the Hudson 's Bay company .
These long feathers would be very inconvenient to the hen during incubation ; and they are likewise confined to the cock widow-bird , as , from their more extraordinary length , they would be still more so .
teen out of twenty , when they speak of a swallow , really mean a martin * .
I only take notice of this supposed inacuracy in Mons. de Buffon , because , if that able naturalist does not speak of the different sorts of swallows with that precision which is necessary upon such an occasion , why should he rely so entirely upon the impossibility of Mons. Adanson 's being mistaken ?
I shall now state the experiment of Mons. de Buffon , to prove that the swallow is not torpid in the winter , and must therefore migrate to the coast of Senegal ~ .
He shut up some swallows ( hirondelles ) in an ice house , which were there confined ` ` plus ou moins de temps ; ' ' and the consequence was , that those which remained there the longest died , nor could they be revived by exposing them to the sun ; and , that those ` ` qui n'avoient souffert le froid de la glaciere que pendant peu de tems ' ' were very lively when permitted to make their escape .
* In the same manner the generical name in other languages , for this tribe of birds , always means the martin , and not the swallow .
Thus Anacreon complains of the ~ for waking him by its twittering .
Now if it be considered that there was only the kitchen chimney in a Grecian house , it must have been the martin which built under the eaves of the window , that was troublesome to Anacreon , and not the swallow .
Ovid also speaking of the nest of the hirundo , says , -luteum sub trabe figit opus .
by which he necessarily alludes to the martin , and not the swallow .
~ Plan de l'ouvrage , p. 15 .
Mons. de Buffon does not , in this account of his experiment , state the time during which the birds were confined ; but as the trial must have been made in France , the swallows which he procured could not be expected to be torpid either in an ice-house * or any other place , because the season for their being in that state was not yet arrived .
I cannot also agree with M. de Buffon that those birds which were shut up the longest time died through cold , as he supposes , but for want of food , as he neither supplied them with any flies , nor , if he had , could the swallows have caught them in the dark : a very short fast kills these tender animals , which are feeding every instant when on the wing .
It therefore seems not to follow from this , or any other experiment , that swallows must necessarily migrate ( as Mons. de Buffon supposes ) to the coast of Senegal .
* The very name of an ice-house almost strikes one with a chill ; I placed , however , a thermometer in one near Hyde Park Corner , on the 23d of November , where it continued 48 hours , and the mercury then stood at 431/ 2 by Fahrenheit 's scale .
This is therefore a degree of cold which swallows sometimes experience whilst they continue in some parts of Europe , without any apparent inconvenience ; and it should seem that the cold vapours which may arise from the included ice , sink the thermometer only 7 or 8 degrees , as the temperature in approved cellars is commonly from 50 or 51 throughout the year .
Sir William Hamilton informs me , that he hath frequently seen swallows in the winter between Naples and Puzzuoli , when the weather was warm ; as does Mr. Hunter , F. R. S. that he hath observed them during the same season , on the confines of Spain and Portugal .
It should seem from this , that very mild and warm weather for any continuance always wakes these birds from their state of torpidity .
Swallows are seen during the summer , in every part of Europe from Lapland to the Southern coast of Spain ; nor is Europe vastly inferior in point of size to Africa .
If swallows therefore retreat to Africa in the winter , should not they be dispersed over the whole Continent of Africa , just as they are over every part of Europe ?
But this most certainly is not so : Dr. Shaw , who was a very good naturalist and attended much to the birds in the neighbourhood of Algiers ( as appears by his account of that country ) , makes no mention of any such circumstance , nor have we heard of it from any other traveller * .
It must be admitted indeed , that Herodotus speaking of a part of upper Egypt ( which he had never seen ) says , that kites and swallows never leave it ~ ; this , however , totally differs from Mons. Adanson 's account , who informs us that they disappear in Senegal on the approach of summer .
It seems to follow therefore , from this silence in others , that swallows cannot be accommodated for their winter residence in any part of that vast continent , but in the neighbourhood of Senegal .
But this is not the whole objection to such an hypothesis .
* It may also be observed here , that credit is in some measure given to M. Adanson 's eyesight , against that of all the English , French , Dutch , Portuguese , and Danes , who have been settled not far from Senegal for above a century , many of which have spent the greatest part of their lives there , and whose notice , swallows seen during the winter , must have probably attracted .
~~~~~~~~~ ~ .
Euterpe , p. 98 .
ed. Gale .
If the swallows of Europe , when they disappear in those parts , retreat to the coast of Senegal , what necessarily follows with regard to a Lapland swallow ?
I will suppose such a bird to have arrived safely at his winter quarters upon the approach of that season in Lapland ; but he must then , according both to Mons. Adanson 's and de Buffon 's account , return to Lapland in the spring , or at least some other swallow from Senegal fill his place * .
Such a bird immediately upon its arrival on the Southern coast of Spain would find the climate and food which it desired to attain , and all proper conveniences for its nest : what then is to be its inducement for quitting all these accommodations which it meets with in such profusion , and pushing on immediately over so many degrees of European continent to Lapland , where both martin and swallow can procure so few eaves of houses to build upon ?
What also is to be the ininducement to these birds , when they have arrived at that part of the Norwegian coast which is opposite to the Ferroe islands , to cross degrees of sea , in order * Mr. Stephens , A. S. S. informs me , that there was a nest of martins for twenty years together in the hall of his house in Somersetshire ( near Bath ) ; nor could the old birds procure food either for themselves , or their young , till the door was opened in the morning .
Can it it be supposed that the same birds or their descendants could have so long fixed upon so very inconvenient a spot , to which they constantly returned from the coast of Africa , neglecting so many others , which they must have always passed by ?
Does it not also afford a most strong presumption , that they were torpid during winter in the neighbourhood of this old hall ?
to build in such small spots of land , where there are still fewer houses ?
The next fact I have happened to meet with of a bird 's being seen at a considerable distance from the shore , is in Mr. Forster 's lately published translation of Kalm 's account of N. America * .
We are there informed that a bird ( which Kalm calls a swallow ) was seen near the ship on the 2d of September , and , as he supposes , 20 degrees from the continent of America ~ .
It appears however , by what he before states in his journal , that the ship was not above 5 degrees from the island of Sable .
Besides , if it is contended that this was an European swallow on its passage across the Atlantic on the 2d of September , it is too early even for a swift , to have been on its migration , which disappears with us sooner than the three other species of European swallows ~ .
Only two more instances have occurred of birds being seen in open sea that have been described * Vol. I. p. 24 .
~ It may not be improper here to observe , that in all instances of birds being seen at sea any great distance from the coast , it is not improbable that they may have before settled on some other vessel , or perhaps on a piece of floating wreck .
By accidents of this sort , even butterflies have sometimes been caught by the sailors at 40 leagues distance from any land .
See Mons. l'Abbe Court de la Blanchadiere 's Voyage to Brazil , Paris , 1759 , 21mo .
p. 169 .
~ The bird mentioned by Kalm was probably an American swallow , forced out to sea by some accidental storm : there are several species of them and they seem to bear a general affinity to those of Europe .
with any sort of precision , which I shall just state , as I would not decline giving the best answer I am able to every argument and fact which may be relied upon , by those who contend that birds periodically migrate across oceans .
On the 30th of March , 1751 , Osbeck , in his voyage from Sweden to China * , met with a single house swallow near the Canary Islands , which was so tired that it was caught by the sailors : Osbeck also states , that though it had been fine weather for several preceding days , the bird was as wet as if it had just emerged from the bottom of the sea .
If this instance proves any thing , it is the submersion and not the migration of swallows so generally believed in all the northern parts of Europe .
It would swell this Letter to a most unreasonable size , to touch only upon this litigated point ; and I shall , for the present , suppress what hath happened to occur to me on this controverted question ~ .
* See the lately published translation of this voyage .
~I will , however , mention one most decisive fact on this head .
Mr. Stephens , A. S. S. informs me , that , when he was fourteen years of age , a pond of his father 's ( who was vicar of Shrivenham in Berkshire ) was cleaned , during the month of February ; that he picked up himself a cluster of three or four swallows ( or martins ) , which were caked together in the mud , and that he carried them into the kitchen , on which they soon afterwards flew about the room , in the presence of his father , mother , and others .
Mr. Stephens also told me , that his father ( who was a naturalist ) observed at the time , he had read of similar instances in the northern writers .
This fact is also confirmed to me by the Reverend Dr. Pie , who was then at school in Shrivenham , as also by a very sensible land-surveyor , who now lives in the village .
Osbeck afterwards , in the course of his voyage , mentions , that a swallow ( indefinitely ) followed the ship , near Java , on the 24th of July , and another on the 14th of August , in the Chinese sea , as he terms it .
After what I have observed before with regard to other instances of the same sort , I need scarcely say that this naturalist does not state of what species these swallows were ; and that , from the latitudes in which they were seen , they must have been some of the Asiatic kinds .
I cannot , however , dismiss this article of the swallow , without adding some general reasons , which seem to prove the great improbability os this or any other bird 's periodically migrating over wide tracts of sea ; and I the rather do it in this place , because There are several reasons why swallows should not be frequently thus found ; ponds are seldom cleaned in the winter , as it is such cold work for the labourers ; and the same instinct which prompts the bird thus to conceal itself , instructs it to choose such a place of security , that common accidents will not discover it .
But the strongest reason for such accounts not being more numerous , is , that facts of this sort are so little attended to ; for though I was born within half a mile of this pond , and have always had much curiosity with regard to such facts , yet I never heard a syllable about this very material and interesting account , till very lately .
To this fact I must also add , that swallows may be constantly taken in the month of October , during the dark nights , whilst they sit on the willows in the Thames , and that one may almost instantaneously fill a large sack with them , because at this time they will not stir from the twigs , when you lay your hands upon them .
This looks very much like their beginning to be torpid before they hide themselves under the water .
A man near Brentford says , that he hath caught them in this state in the eyt opposite to that town , even so late as November .
the swallow is commonly pitched upon as the most notorious instance of such a regular passage .
This seems to arise first from its being seen in such numbers during the summer , from its appearing almost always on the wing , and from its feeding in that position ; from which two latter circumstances it is supposed to be the best adapted for such distant migrations .
And first , let us consider , from the few facts or reasons we have to argue from , what length of flight either a swallow or any other bird is probably equal to .
A swallow , it is true , seems to be always on the wing ; but I have frequently attended , as much as I could , on a particular one ; and it hath appeared to me , that the bird commonly returned to its nest in eight or ten minutes : as for extent of flight , I believe I may venture to say , that these birds are seldom a quarter of mile from their mate or young ones ; they feed whilst on the wing , and are perpetually turning short round to catch the insects , who endeavour to elude them as a hare does a greyhound .
It therefore seems to me , that swallows are by no means equal to long flights , from their practice during their summer residence with us .
I have long attended to the flight of birds ; and it hath always appeared to me , that they are never on the wing for amusement ( as we walk or ride ) , but merely in search of food .
The only bird which I have ever observed to fly without any particular point of direction , is the rook : these birds will , when the wind is high , Ride in the whirlwind , and enjoy the storm .
' ' They never fly , however , at this time , from point to point , but only tumble in the air , merely for their diversion .
It seems , therefore , that birds are by no means calculated for flights across oceans , for which they have no previous practice : and they are , in fact , always so fatigued , that , when they meet a ship at sea , they forget all apprehensions , and deliver themselves up to the sailors .
Let us now consider another objection to the migration of the swallow , which Mons. de Buffon supposes may cross the Atlantic to the Line in eight days * ; and this not only from the want of rest , but of food , during the passage .
A swallow , indeed , feeds on the wing : but where is it to find any insects , whilst it is flying over a wide expanse of sea ?
This bird , therefore , if it ever attempted so adventurous a passage , would soon feel a want of food , and return again to land , where it had met with a constant supply from minute to minute .
I am aware it may be here objected , that the swallow leaves us on the approach of winter , when soon no flying insects can be procured : but I shall hereafter endeavour to show , that these birds are then torpid , and , consequently , can want no such food .
Another objection remains to the hypothesis of migration , which is , that birds , when flying from * Discourse sir la nature des oiseaux , p. 32 .
point to point , endeavour always to have the wind against them * , as is periodically experienced by the London bird-catchers , in March and October , when they lay their nets for singing birds ~ .
The reason , probably , for birds thus flying against the wind is , that their plumage may not be ruffled , which indeed I have before had occasion to mention .
Let us suppose , then , a swallow to be equal to a passage across the Atlantic in other respects ; how is the bird to be insured of the wind 's continuing for days in the same quarter ; or how is he to depend upon its continuing to blow against his flight with moderation ?
for who can suppose that a swallow can make his way to the point of direction , when buffeted by a storm blowing in the teeth of his intended passage ~ ?
Lastly , can it be conceived that these , or any other birds , can be impelled by a providential instinct , regularly to attempt what seems to be attended with such insuperable difficulties , and what most frequently leads to certain destruction ?
But it will still be objected , that as swallows regularly appear and disappear at certain seasons , it is incumbent upon those who deny their migration , to * Kalm , in his voyage to America , makes the same observation , with regard to flying fish , and Valentine says , that if the wind does not continue to blow against the bird of paradise , it immediately drops to the ground .
~ These birds , as it should seem , are then in motion ; because , at those seasons , the ground is plowed either for the winter or lent corn .
~I have myself attended to swallows during a high wind , and have observed that they sly only in sheltered places , whilst they almost touch the surface of the ground .
show what becomes of them in Europe during our winter .
Though it might be answered , that it is not necessary , those who endeavour to show the impossibility of another system or hypothesis , should from thence be obliged to set up one of their own ; yet I shall , without any difficulty , say , that I at least am convinced swallows ( and perhaps some other birds ) are torpid during the winter .
I have not , I must own , myself ever seen them in this state ; but , having heard instances of their being thus found , from others of undoubted veracity , I have not scarcely the least doubt with regard to this point .
It is , indeed , rather difficult to conceive why some ornithologists continue to withhold their assents to such a cloud of witnesses , except that it perhaps contradicts a favourite hypothesis which they have already maintained .
Why is it more extraordinary that swallows should be torpid during the winter , than that bats are found in this state , and so many insects , which are the food of swallows ?
But it may be said , that as the swallows have crowded the air during the summer , in every part of Europe since the creation , and as regularly disappear in winter , why have not the instances of their being found in a torpid state been more frequent ?
To this it may be answered , that though our globe may have been formed so many centuries , yet the inhabitants of it have scarcely paid any attention to the study of natural history , but within these late years .
As for the ancient Greeks and Romans , their dress prevented their being so much in the fields as we are ; or , if they heard of a rather extraordinary bird in their neighbourhood , they had not a gun to shoot it : the only method of attaining real knowledge in natural history , depends almost entirely upon the having frequent opportunities of thus killing animals , and examining them when dead .
If they did not stir much in their own country , much less did they think of travelling into distant regions ; want of bills of exchange , and of that curiosity which arises from our being thoroughly acquainted with what is near us at home , probably occasioned this ; to which may also be added , the want of a variety of languages : scarcely any Greek seems to have known more than his own tongue , nor Roman more than two * .
Aristotle , indeed , began something like a system of natural history , and Pliny put down , in his common place-book , many an idle story ; but , before the invention of printing , copies of their works could not be so generally dispersed , as to occasion much attention to what might be interesting facts for the natural historian .
In the sixteenth century , Gesner , Belon , and Aldrovandus , published some materials , which might be of use to future naturalists ; but , in the seventeenth , Ray and Willoughy first treated this extensive branch of study , with that clearness of method , * It need be scarcely here mentioned also , that their navigation was confined to the Mediterranean , from the compass not having been then discovered .
perspicuity of description , and accuracy of observation , as hath not , perhaps , been since exceeded .
The works of these great naturalists were soon dispersed over Europe , and the merit of them acknowledged ; but it so happened , that Sir Isaac Newton 's amazing discoveries in natural philosophy making their appearance about the same time , engaged entirely the attention of the learned .
In process of time , all controversy was silenced by the demonstration of the Newtonian system ; and then the philosophical part of Europe naturally turned their thoughts to other branches of science .
Since this period , therefore , and not before , natural history hath been studied in most countries of Europe ; and consequently , the finding swallows in a state of torpidity , or on the coast of Senegal , during the winter , begins to be an interesting fact , which is communicated to the world by the person who observes it .
To this I may add , that the common labourers , who have the best chance of finding torpid birds , have scarcely any of them a doubt with regard to this point ; and consequently , when they happen to see them in this state , make no mention of it to others ; because they consider the discovery as neither uncommon or interesting to any one .
Molyneux , therefore , in the Philosophical Tansactions * , informs us , that this is the general belief of the common people of Ireland , with regard to land-rails ; and I have myself received the same answer from a person who , in December , found swallows torpid in the stump of an old tree .
~ Phil. Trans. abr .
Vol. II .
p. 853 .
Another reason why the instances of torpid swallows may not be expected so frequently , is , that the instinct of secreting themselves at the proper season of the year , likewise suggests to them , it 's being necessary to hide themselves in such holes and caverns , as may not only elude the search of man , but of every other animal which might prey upon them ; it is not therefore by any common accident that they are ever discovered in a state of torpidity .
Since the study of natural history , however , hath become more general , proofs of this fact are frequently communicated , as may appear in the British Zoology * .
That it may not be said , however , I do not refer to any instance which deserves credit , if properly sifted , I beg leave to cite the letter from Mr. Achard to Mr. Collinson , printed in the Philosophical Transactions ~ , from whence it seems to be a most irrefragable fact , that swallows ~ are annually discovered in a torpid state on the banks of the Rhine .
I shall also refer to Dr. Birch 's History of the Royal Society ~ , where it is stated , that the celebrated Harvey dissected * See Vol. II .
p. 250 .
Brit. Zool. ill .
p. 13 , 14 .
As also Mr. Pennant 's Tour in Scotland , p. 199 .
~ 1763 , p. 101 .
~ ` ` Swallows or martins , ' ' are Mr. Achard 's words , which I the rather mention , because Mr. Collinson complains that the species is not specified .
Mr. Collinson himself had endeavoured to prove , that sand martins are not torpid , Phil. Trans. 1760 , p. 109 .
and concludes his letter , by supposing that all the swallow tribe migrates , therefore the swift is the only species remaining ; for his friend Mr. Achard shows to demonstration , that swallows or martins are torpid ; he does not , indeed , precisely state which of them .
~ Vol. IV .
p. 537 .
some , which were found in the winter , under water , and in which he could not observe any circulation of the blood * .
Assuming it , therefore , from these facts , that swallows have been found in such a state , I would ask the partisans of migration , whether any instance can be produced where the same animal is calculated for a state of torpidity and , at the same time of the year , for a flight across oceans ?
But it may be urged , possibly , that if swallows are torpid when they disappear , the same thing should happen with regard to other birds , which are not seen in particular parts of the year .
To this I answer , that this is by no means a necessary inference : if , for example , it should be insisted that other birds besides the cuckoo are equally careless with regard to their eggs , it would be immediately allowed that the argument arising from * As the swallows were found in the winter , they must have been in a state of torpidity , as otherwise the animals must have been putrid .
I shall likewise here refer to Phil. Trans. abr .
Vol. V. p. 33 .
where Mr. Derham says , that he heard a swift squeak in an hole of his house on the 17th of April ; but that , the weather being cold , it did not stir abroad for several days .
This seems to be a strong instance of a bird 's first waking from a state of torpidity , but resuming its sleep on the weather being severe .
I shall close the proofs on this head ( which I could much enlarge ) by the oignified testimony of Sigismond , King of Poland , who affirmed on his oath , to the cardinal Commendon , that he had frequently seen swallows , which were found at the bottom of lakes .
See the life of cardinal Commendon , p. 211 .
Paris , 1671 .
410 .
such supposed analogy could by no means be relied upon * .
It is possible , however , that some other birds , which are conceived to migrate , may be really torpid as well as swallows ; and if it be asked why they are not sometimes also seen in such a state during the winter , the answer seems to be , that perhaps there may be a thousand swallows to any other sort of bird , and that they commonly are found torpid in clusters .
*I here suppose the common notion about the cuckoo to be true ; because both learned and ignorant seem equally to agree in the fact .
During the present summer , however , a girl brought a full feathered young cuckoo to a gentleman 's house , where I happened to be , who said , that it had been for several days before fed by another bird of equal size with itself ; which therefore could not be a hedge-sparrow , or other small bird , but the parent cuckoo .
I have also lately been favoured , by Mr. Pennant , with the following extract from a manuscript of Derham 's on instinct .
The Rev. Mr. Stafford was walking in Glossop-dale in the Peak of Derbyshire , and saw a cuckoo rise from its nest , which was on the stump of a tree , that had been some time felled , so as much to resemble the colour of the bird .
In this nest were two young cuckows , one of which he fastened to the ground , by means of a peg and line , and very frequently , for many days , beheld the old cuckoo feed these her young ones .
' ' It is not impossible , therefore , that this most general opinion will turn out like the supposed effects of the venom of the tarantula ; and , indeed , it is difficult to conceive how so small a bird as a hedge-sparrow can feed a cuckoo : it is also remarkable , that the witnesses often vary about the species of small bird thus employed .
It is possible , however , that the cuckoo ( though it may not hatch its young ) may feed them , when grown too large for the foster parent .
If a single bird of any other kind happens to be seen in the winter , without motion or apparent warmth , it is immediately conceived that it died by some common accident .
I shall , however , without any reserve , say , that I rather conceive the notion which prevails with regard to the migration of many birds , may most commonly arise from the want of observation , and ready knowledge of them , when they are seen on the wing , even by professed ornithologists .
It is an old saying , that ` ` a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush ; ' ' and this holds equally with regard to their being distinguished , when those even who study natural history , have but a transient sight of the animal * .
If , therefore , a bird , which is supposed to migrate in the winter , passes almost under the nose of a Linnaean , he pays but little attention to it , because he cannot examine the beak , by which he is to class the bird .
Thus I conceive , that the supposing a nightingale to be a bird of passage arises from not readily distinguishing it , when seen in a hedge , or on the wing ~ .
This bird is known to the ear of every one , by its most striking and capital notes , but to the eye of very * An ingenious friend of mine makes always a very proper distinction between what he calls in-door and out-door naturalists .
Thomas Willisel , who assisted Ray and Willughby much with regard to the natural history of the animals of this island , never stirred any where without his gun and fishing-tackle .
~ No two birds fly in the same manner , if their motions are accurately attended to .
few indeed ; because the plumage is dull , nor is there any thing peculiar in its make .
The nightingale sings perhaps for two months * , and then is never heard again till the return of the spring , when it is supposed to migrate to us from the continent , with redstarts , and several other birds .
That it cannot really do so , seems highly probable , from the following reasons .
This bird is scarcely ever seen to fly above twenty yards , but creeps at the bottom of the hedges , in search of maggots , and other insects , which are found in the ground .
If the swallow is not supplied with any food during its passage across oceans , much less can the nightingale be so accommodated ; and I have great reason to believe , from the death of birds in a cage , which have had nothing to eat for twenty-four hours , that these delicate and tender animals cannot support a longer fast , though using no exercise at all .
To this I may also add , that those birds which feed on insects are vastly more feeble than those whose bills can crack seed , and consequently , less capable of bearing any extraordinary hardships or fatigue .
But other proofs are not wanting , that this bird cannot migrate from England .
* Whilst it sings even , the bird can seldom be distinguished , because it is then almost perpetually in hedges , when the foliage is thickest , upon the first burst of the spring , and when no insects can as yet have destroyed considerable parts of the leaves .
Nightingales are very common in Denmark , Sweden , and Russia * , as also in every other part of Europe , as well as Asia , if the Arabic name is properly translated .
Now , if it is supposed that many of these birds which are observed in the southern parts of England , cross the German sea , from the opposite coast of the continent ; why does not the same instinct drive those os Denmark to Scotland , where no such bird was ever seen or heard ~ ?
But these are not all the difficulties which attend the hypothesis of migration ; nightingales are agreed to be scarcely ever observed to the westward of Dorsetshire , or in the principality of Wales ~ , much less in Ireland .
I have also been informed , that these birds are not uncommon in Worcestershire , whereas they are excessively rare ( if found at all ) in the neighbouring county of Hereford .
Whence , therefore , can it arise , that this bird should at one time be equal to the crossing of seas , and at other times not travel a mile or two into an adjacent county ?
Does it not afford , on the other hand , a strong proof , that the bird really continues * See Dr. Birch 's History of the Royal Society , Vol. III .
p. 189 .
Linnaei Fauna Suecica .
and Biographia Britannica , art .
FLETCHER ; where it is said , that they have in Russia a greater variety of notes than elsewhere .
~ Sir Robert Sibbald , indeed , conceives the nightingale to be a bird of North Britain ; but , if I can depend upon many concurrent testimonies , no such bird is ever seen or heard so far northward at present , nor could I ever trace them in that direction further than Durham .
~I have , however , frequently seen the nightingale 's congener ( and supposed sellow-traveller ) the redstart in Wales .
on the same spot during the whole year , but happens not to be attended to , from the reasons I have before suggested ?
I am therefore convinced , that if I was ever to live in the country during the winter , I should see nightingales , because I should be looking after them , and I am accordingly informed , by a person who is well acquainted with this bird , that he hath frequently observed them during this season * .
If it be asked , why the nightingales are all this time mute ?
the answer is , that the same silence is experienced in many other birds , and this very muteness is , in part the cause why the bird is not attended to in winter .
I must now ask those who contend for the migration of a nightingale , what is to be its inducement for crossing from the continent to us ?
a swallow , indeed , may want flies in winter , if it stays in England ; but a nightingale is just as well supplied with insects on the continent , as it can be with us after its passage ~ .
I must also ask , in what other part of *I find they have also been seen in France during the winter .
See a treatise , entitled , Aedologue , Paris 1751 .
p. 23 .
~I have omitted the mention of a more minute proof , that this bird cannot migrate from the continent , from the having kept them for some years in a cage , and having been very attentive to their song .
Kircher ( in his Musurgia ) hath given us the nightingale 's notes in musical characters , from which it appears that the song of a German nightingale differs very materially from that of an English one : now , if there was a communication by migration between the continent and England , the song of these birds would not so materially differ , as I may , perhaps , show , by some experiments I have made , in relation to the notes of birds .
I have before mentioned , that Mr. Fletcher , who was ambassador from England to Russia in the time of Queen Elizabeth , the world this bird is seen during the winter ?
must it migrate to Senegal with the swallow ?
I am persuaded likewise , that the cuckoo never migrates from this island any more than the nightingale : this bird is either probably torpid in the winter , or otherwise is mistaken for one of the smaller kind of hawks * ; which it would be likewise in the spring , was it not for its very particular note at that time , and which only lasts during courtship , as it does with the quail .
If there is fine weather in February , this bird sometimes makes this sort of call to its mate , whilst it is supposed to continue still on the continent .
An instance is mentioned by Mr. Bradley ~ , of not only a single cuckoo , but several , which were heard in Lincolnshire , during the month of February ; and that able naturalist Mr. Pennant informs me , another was heard near Hatcham in Shropshire , on the 4th of February in the present year ~ .
observed that the song of the Russian nightingale differed from that of the English .
* Mr. Hunter , F. R. S. informs me , that he hath seen cuckows in the island of Belleisle during the winter , which is not situated so much to the southward , as to make it improbable that they may equally continue with us .
~ Works of Nature , p. 77 .
~ Mr. Pennant received this account from Mr. Plimly , of Longnor in Shropshire .
Thus likewise Mr. Edwards informs us , that the sea fowls near the Needles , which are commonly supposed to migrate in winter , appear upon the weather 's being very mild .
Essays , p. 197 .
It is amazing how much the being interested to discover particular objects contributes to our readily distinguishing them .
I remember the being much surprised that a greyheaded game-keeper always saw the partridge on the ground before they rose , when I could not do the same .
He told me , however , that the reason was , I lived in a time when the shooter had no occasion to give himself that trouble .
He then further explained himself , by saying , that when he was young , no one ever thought of aiming at a bird when on the wing , and consequently they were obliged to see the game before it was sprung .
He added , that from this necessity he could not only distinguish partridges , but snipes and woodcocks , on the ground .
Another instance of the same kind , is the great readiness with which a person , who is fond of coursing , finds a hare sitting in her form : those , however , who are not interested about such sport , can scarcely see the hare , when it is under their nose , and pointed out to them .
But more apparent objects escape our notice , when we are not interested about them .
Ask any one , who hath not a botanical turn , what he hath seen in passing through a rich meadow , at the time it is most enamelled with plants in flower ; and he will tell you , that he hath observed nothing but grass and daisies .
If most gardeners even are in like manner asked whether the flowers of a bean grow on every side of the stalk , they will suppose that they do .
whereas they , in reality , are only to be found on one side .
The mouths of flounders are often turned different ways , which one would think could not well escape the observation of the London fishmongers ; yet , upon asking several of them whether they had attended to this particular , I found they had not , till I showed them the proof in their own shops .
A fishmonger , however , knows immediately whether a fish is in good eating order or not , on the first inspection ; because this is a circumstance which interests him .
I shall , however , by no means suppress two arguments in favour of migration , which seem to require the fullest answer that can be given to them .
The first is , that there are certain birds , which appear during the winter , but disappear during the summer ; and it may be asked , where such birds can be supposed to breed , if they do not migrate from this island .
These birds are in number four , viz. the snipe , woodcock , redwing , and fieldfare .
As for the snipe , I have a very short answer to give to the objection , as far as it relates to this bird ; because it constantly breeds in the fens of Lincolnshire , Wolmar forest , and Bodmyn downs ; it is therefore highly probable , that it does the same in almost every county of England .
I must own , however , that , till within these few years , I conceived the nest of a snipe was as rarely seen in England , as that of a woodcock or fieldfare ; and that able ornithologist Mr. Edwards supposes this to be the fact , in the late publication of his ingenious Essays on Natural History * .
Woodcocks likewise are known to build in some parts of England every year ; but , as the instances are commonly those of a single nest , I would by no means pretend to draw the same proof against the summer migration of this bird , as in the former case of the snipe .
I will most readily admit , that these accidental facts are rather to be accounted for , perhaps , from the whimsy or silliness of a few birds , which occasions their laying their eggs in a place where they are easily discovered , and contrary to what is usual with the bulk of the species .
I remember to have seen a duck 's nest once on the top of a pollard willow , near the decoy in St. James 's Park ; it would not be , however , fair to infer from such an instance , that all ducks would pitch upon the same very improper situation for a nest , upon which it is difficult to conceive how a webfooted bird could settle .
Some silly birds likewise now and then choose a place for building , which cannot escape the observation of either man or beast , as he passes by .
I therefore suppose that the few proofs of woodcocks nests having been found in England , arise either from one or other of these two causes , and all which they seem to prove is , that our climate in summer is not absolutely improper for them .
It is to be observed , however , that Mr. Catesby considers such instances as of equal force against the * P. 72 .
migration of the woodcock , as of the snipe * .
Willughby also says , that Mr. Jessop saw young woodcocks sold at Sheffield ( which rather implies a certain number being brought to market ) , and that others had observed the same elsewhere ~ .
We are , indeed , informed by Scopoli ~ , that they breed constantly in Carniola , which is considerably to the southward of any part of England : out country is therefore certainly not too hot for them .
Woodcocks appear and disappear almost exactly about the same time in every part of Europe , and perhaps Africa ~ : heat and cold , therefore , seem not to have any operation whatsover with regard to the supposed migration of this bird .
But it may be said , what signifies proving the probability of woodcocks breeding in England , if it is not a known fact that they do so ?
To this it should seem there are several answers , as it is equally incumbent upon those who contend for migration , to show that these birds were ever seen on such passage .
Another answer is , ask ninety-nine people out of a hundred , whether snipes ever make a nest in Enggland ; and they will immediately say , that they do not ; so little are facts or observations of this sort attended to .
But I shall now endeavour to give some other reasons why woodcocks may not only continue with us * Phil. Trans. abr .
Vol. II .
p. 889 .
~ B. iii .
c. 1 .
~ Ornith .
Leipsig , 1769 .
~ Shaw 's Trav .
Phys. Obs. ch .
ii .
during the summer , but also breed in large tracts of wood or bog , without being observed .
In the other parts of Europe , all birds almost are considered as game , or , at least , are eaten as wholesome food , Ray therefore mentions , that hawks and owls are sold by the poulterers at Rome ; every sort of small bird also is equally the foreign sowler 's object * .
An Englishman does not consider , on the other hand , perhaps twelve kinds of birds worthy his attention , or expense of powder , none of which are ever shot in our woods during the summer , nor are birds then disturbed by felling either coppice or timber .
But it will be said , why are not woodcocks sometimes seen , however , as they may be supposed to leave their cover in search of food ?
To this I answer , that woodcocks sleep always in the daytime , whilst with us in the winter , and feed only during the night ~ .
Whenever a woodcock , therefore , is flushed , he is roused from his sleep by the spaniel or sportsman , and then takes wing , because there are no leaves on the trees to conceal the bird .
Whoever hath looked attentively at a woodcock 's eye , must see that , from the appearance of it , the * In one of Boccace 's Novels , a lover , who lives at Florence , dresses a falcon for the dinner or his mistress .
Giorna a V. Novel .
IX .
~ Almost all the wild sowl of the duck kind also sleep in the daytime , and feed at night .
sight must be more calculated to distinguish objects by night than by day * .
The fact therefore is notorious to those who cut glades in their woods , and fix nets for catching these birds , that they never stir but as it begins to be dark , after which they return again by day-break , when their sight even then is so indifferent , that they strike against the net , and thus become entangled .
No one with us ever thinks of fixing or attending such nets in summer for woodcocks , because it is not then supposed that there is any such bird in the island ; if they tried this experiment , however , I must own that I believe they would have sport ~ .
Mr. Reinhold Forster , F. R. S. who is an able naturalist , informs me , that the fowlers in the neighbourhood of Dantzick kill many woodcocks about St. John 's day ( or Midsummer ) , in the following man* I conceive also , it is from the eyes looking so dull ; that this bird is generally considered as being so foolish : hence the Africans call the woodcock hammar el hadgel , or the partridge 's ass .
Shaw 's Phys. Obs. ch .
ii .
~I would ask those who will probably laugh at the very idea of such sport ( which I do not , however , absolutely insure ) , whether , if I was to send them to any part of the British coast to catch the true anchovy , or tunny fish , they would not suppose equally that it was a fool 's errand .
Notwithstanding , however , this incredulity , I can produce the authority of both Ray ( Syn .
Pisc .
p. 107 .
) and Mr. Pennant ( Brit. Zool. ill .
p. 34 .
36 .
) , that the true anchovy is caught in the sea not far from Chester , and the tunny fish on the coast of Argyleshire , together with the herrings , where they are called mackrel sture .
Is it not amazing , however , that a fish of such a size as the tunny should never have been heard of , even by the Scotch naturalist Sir Robert Sibbald ?
ner , and that they continue to do so till the month of August .
They wait on the side of some of the extensive wood in that neighbourhood , before day-break , for the return of the woodcock from his feeding in the night-time , and always depend upon having a very good chance of thus shooting many of them .
The Dantzickers , however , might be employed the whole summer near these woods in the daytime , without ever seeing such a bird ; and it seems therefore not improbable , that it arises from our not waiting for them at twilight or day-break , that they are never observed by Englishmen in the summer .
If this bird should , however , be seen in the night , it is immediately supposed to be an owl , which a woodcock does not differ much from in its flight .
To these reasons for woodcocks not being observed , it may be added , that the bird is believed to be absolutely mute , and consequently , never discovers itself by its call .
If it be still contended , that the nest or young must sometimes be stumbled upon , though in the centre of extensive woods , or large bogs , the siskin ( or aberdavine * ) is a much more extraordinary instance of concealing its nest and young .
The plumage of this bird is rather bright than otherwise ; and the song , though not very pleasing , yet is very audible , both which circumstances should discover it at all times ; yet Kramer ~ informs us , that , though immense numbers breed annually on * Brit. Zool. p. 309 .
~ Elenchus Animalium per Austriam , p. 261 .
Viennae , 1736 .
the banks of the Danube , no one ever observed the nest .
This bird is rather uncommon in England ; so that if I ask when the nest was ever found within the verge of the island , it may be considered as rather an unfair challenge .
There is another bird , however , called a redpoll * , which is taken in numbers during the Michaelmas and March flights by the London bird-catchers , whose nest , I believe , was never discovered in England , though I have seen them in pairs during the summer , both in the mountainous parts of Wales and highlands of Scotland ~ .
But I shall now mention another proof that woodcocks breed in England .
The Reverend Mr. White , of Selborn , who is not only a well-read naturalist , but an active sportsman , informs me , that he hath frequently killed woodcocks in March , which , upon being opened , had the rudiments of eggs in them , and that it is usual at that time to flush them in pairs .
Willughby also observes the same ~ .
This bird , therefore , certainly pairs before its supposed migration ; and can it be corceived that this strict union ( which birds in a wild state so faithfully adhere to ) ~ , should take place before they * Brit. Zool. p. 312 .
~ This elegant little bird is very common in Hudson 's Bay , where it feeds chiefly on the birch trees ; which being more common in the northern than southern parts of Great Britain , may account for the bird 's being more often seen northward .
~ B. III .
c. i. ~ It is believed that no mule-bird was ever seen in a wild state , notwithstanding M. de Buffon suspects many an intrigue traverse oceans , and when they cannot as yet have pitched upon a proper place for concealing their nest and nestlings ?
Let us examine if this intercourse before migration takes place in other birds , which are supposed to cross wide extents of sea : and a quail affords such proof .
I have been present when these birds have been caught in the spring , which always turn out to be males , and are enticed to the nets by the call of the hen ; quails therefore pair after they appear in England .
But I shall now consider the other two instances of birds which are seen with us in the winter , and are not observed in the summer ; I mean , the fieldfare and redwing .
And first , let us examine , where these birds are actually known to breed : the northern naturalists say , in Sweden ; Klein , in the neighbourhood of Dantzick , which is only in lat. 54~ 30~ * ; and Willughby , in Bohemia .
in the recesses of the woods ( Hist. Not .
des Oiseaux , tom .
I. ) such irregular intercourse is only observed in cages and aviaries , where birds are not only confined , but pampered with food .
* See Klein , de Avibus Erraticis , p. 178 .
Klein , however , cites Zornius , who lived in the same part of Germany , and who asserts that the turdus Iliacus ( or redwing ) leaves those parts in the spring .
The circumstance therefore of the redwing 's breeding in numbers ( per multitudines ) had escaped the notice of Zornius , though he hath written a dissertation on this question .
Is it at all surprising , after this , that such discoveries , if made at all , should not be commonly heard of ?
As they therefore build their nests in more Southern parts of Europe , there is certainly no natural impossibility of their doing so with us , though , I must own , I never yet heard but of one instance , which was a fieldfare 's nest found near Paddington * .
I cannot , however , but think it is only from want of observation , that more of such nests have not been discovered , which are only looked after by very young children ; and the chief object is the eggs , or nestlings , not the bird which lays them ~ .
The plumage therefore and flight of the fieldfare or redwing being neither of them very remarkable , it is not at all improbable they may remain in summer , without being attended to ; and particularly the redwing , which scarcely differs at all in appearance from other thrushes .
Thus the cough is by no means peculiar to Cornwall , as is commonly supposed , but is mistaken for the jackdaw , or rook .
But it may be said , that these birds fly in flocks during the winter , and if they remain here during the summer , we should see them equally congregate .
I have not before referred to Klein , who hath written a very able treatise , in which he argues against the possibility of migration in birds ; because , though I should be very happy to support my poor opinion by his authority , yet I thought it right neither to repeat his facts , or arguments .
* See also Harl .
Misc .
Vol. II .
p. 561 .
~ Many birds also build in places of such difficult access , that boys cannot climb to ; birds nesting is confined almost entirely to hedges , and low shrubs .
This circumstance , however , is by no means peculiar to the fieldfare and redwing ; most of the hardbilled singing birds do the same in winter , but separate in summer , as it is indeed necessary all birds should during the time of breeding .
I shall now consider another argument in favour of migration , which I do not know hath been ever insisted upon by those writers who have contended for it , and which at first appearance seems to carry great weight with it .
There are certain birds , which are supposed to visit this island only at distant intervals of years ; the Bohemian chatterer and cross-bill * ( for example ) once perhaps in twenty .
The fact is not disputed , that such birds are not commonly observed in particular spots from year to year ; but this may arise from two causes , either a partial migration within the verge of our island , or perhaps more frequently from want of a ready knowledge of birds on the wing , when they happen to be seen indeed , but cannot be examined .
I never have disputed such a partial migration ; and indeed I have received a most irrefragable proof of such a flitting , from the Rev. Mr. White of Selborn in Hampshire , whose accurate observations I have before had occasion to argue from .
* This bird changes the colour of its plumage at different seasons of the year , which is sometimes red .
The first account we have of their being seen , is in the Ph. Tr. abr .
Vol. V. p. 33 .
where Mr. Edward Lhwyd suspects them to be Virginia nightingales , from their feathers being red , and had no difficulty of at once snpposing that they had crossed the Atlantic .
The rock ( or ring-ouzel ) hath always hitherto been considered as frequenting only the more mountainous parts of this island : Mr. White , however , informs me that there is a regular migration of these birds , which flock in numbers , and regularly visit the neighbourhood of Selborn , in Hampshire * .
I therefore have little doubt but that they equally appear in others of our Southern counties ; though it escapes common observation , as they bear a sort of general resemblance to the black-bird , at least to the hen of that species .
I own also , that I always conceived the Bohemian chatterer was not observed in Great Britain but at very distant intervals of years , and then perhaps only a single bird , whereas Dr. Ramsey ( professor of natural history at Edinburgh ) informs Mr. Pennant , that flocks of these birds appear constantly every year in the neighbourhood of that city ~ .
As for cross-bills , they are seen more and more in different parts of England , since there have been so many plantations of firs : this bird is remarkably sond of the seeds of these trees , and therefore changes its place to those parts where it can procure the greatest plenty of such food ~ .
* See also Br .
Zool. Ill. p. 56 .
~ These birds are said to be particularly fond of the berries of the mountain-ash , which is an uncommon tree in the Southern parts of Great Britain , but by no means so in the North .
~ This bird should also , for the same reason , be found from year to year in the cider counties , if it was true ( as is commonly supposed ) that he is particularly fond of the kernels of This flitting therefore by no means amounts to a total and periodical migration over seas , but is no more than what is experienced with regard to several birds .
For example , the British Zoology informs us * , that , at an average , 4000 dozen of larks are sent up from the neighbourhood of Dunstable , to supply the London markets ; nor do I hear , upon inquiry , that there is any complaint of the numbers decreasing from year to year , notwithstanding this great consumption .
I should not suppose that 50 dozen of skylarks are caught in any other county of England ; and it should therefore seem that the larks from the more adjacent parts croud in to supply the vacuum occasioned by the London Epicures , which may be the cause possibly of a partial migration throughout the whole island .
I begin now to approach to something like a conclusion of this ( I fear ) tedious dissertation : I think , however , that I should not omit what appears to me at least as a demonstration , that one bird , which is commonly supposed to migrate across seas , cannot possibly do so .
apples , which it is conceived he can instantly extract with his very singular bill .
Mr. Tunstall , F. R. S. however , at my desire , once placed an apple in the cage of a cross-bill , which he had kept for some time in his very valuable and capital collection of live birds : upon examining the apple a fortnight afterwards , it remained untouched .
* P. 235 .
A landrail * , when put up by the shooter , never flies 100 yards ; its motion is excessively slow , whilst the legs hang down like those of the water fowls which have not web feet , and which are known never to take longer flights .
This bird is not very common with us in England , but is excessively so in Ireland , where they are called corn-creaks .
Now those who contend that the landrail , because it happens to disappear in winter , must migrate across oceans , are reduced to the following dilemma .
They must first either suppose that it reaches Ireland periodically from America ; which is impossible , not only because the passage of the Atlantic includes so many degrees of longitude , but because there is no such bird in that part of the globe .
If the landrail therefore migrates from the continent of Europe to Ireland , which it must otherwise do , the necessary consequence is , that many must pass over England in their way Westward to Ireland ; and why do not more of these birds continue with us , but , on the contrary , immediately proceed across the St. George 's channel ?
Whence should it arise also , if they pass over this island periodically in the spring and autumn , that they are never observed in such passage , as I have already stated their rate in flying to be excessively slow ; to which I may add , that I never saw them rise to the height of twenty yards from the ground , nor indeed exceed the pitch of a quail .
* Br .
Zool. p. 387 .
I have now submitted the best answers that have occurred , not only to the general arguments for the migration of birds across oceans , but also to the particular facts , which are relied upon as actual proofs of such a regular and periodical passage .
Though I may be possibly mistaken in many of the conjectures I have made , yet I think I cannot be confuted but by new facts , and to such fresh evidence , properly authenticated , I shall most readily give up every point , which I have from present conviction been contending for .
I may then perhaps also flatter myself , that the having expressed my doubts with regard to the proofs hitherto relied upon , in support of migration , may have contributed to such new , and more accurate observations .
It is to be wished , however , that these more convincing and decisive facts may be received from islanders ( the more distant from any land the better* ) and not from the inhabitants of a continent ; as it does not seem to be a fair inference , because certain birds leave certain spots at particular times , that they therefore migrate across a wide extent of sea .
For example , storks disappear in Holland during the winter , and they have not a very wide tract of sea between them and England ; yet this bird never frequents our coasts .
*I would particularly propose the islands of Madera and St. Helena ; to these , I would also add the island of Ascension ( had it any inhabitants ) , as likewise Juan Fernandez , for the Pacific ocean .
The stork , however , may be truly considered as a bird of passage , by the inhabitants of those parts of Europe ( wherever situated ) to which it may be supposed to resort during the winter , and where it is not seen during the summer .
I am , dear Sir , Your most faithful , humble servant , Daines Barrington .
SINCE I sent to you my very long letter on the migration of birds , I have had an opportunity of examining the ` ` Planches Enluminees , ' ' which are said to be published under M. de Buffon 's inspection , and which seem to afford a demonstration of M. Adanson 's inaccuracy in supposing either the roller , or swallows , which he caught in his ship , near the coast of Senegal , to be the same with those of Europe .
In the 8th of these plates , there is a coloured figure of a bird , called le rollier d'Angola , which agrees exactly with M. Adanson 's description * ; but he trusted too much to his memory , when he pronounced it to be the same with the Garrulus Argentoratensis of Willughby , and therefore supposed it to be on its passage to Europe .
This bird hath , indeed , in many respects , a very strong resemblance to the common roller of Europe , which is represented also in the Planches Enluminees , plate 486 ; but it differs most materially in the length of the two exterior feathers of the tail , as well as in the colour of the neck , which in the African roller is of a most bright green , and in the European of rather a dull blue .
In the 310th plate , there is likewise a coloured representation of the ` ` Hirondelle a ventre roux du Senegal , ' ' which specimen was possibly surnished by Mons. Adanson himself .
* Voyage au Senegal , p. 15 .
There is also another African bird , represented in the ` ` Planches Enluminees , ' ' which might very easily , on a hasty inspection , be mistaken for the Garrulus Argentoratensis , viz. the Guepier a longue queue du Senegal .
Pl .
Enl .
p. 314 .
The roller of Angola is also engraved by Brisson , T. ii .
pl. 7 .
It very much resembles the European swallow , but the tail differs , as the forks ( in the Senegal specimen ) taper from the top of the two exterior feathers to the bottom , at three regular divisions , whereas in the European they are nearly of the same width throughout .
The convincing proof , however , that the ` ` Hirondelle a ventre roux du Senegal ' ' differs from our chimney swallow is , that the rump is entirely covered with a bright orange or chesnut , which in the European swallow ` ` is of a very lovely but dark purplish blue colour * .
' ' Having lately looked into Aristotle 's Natural History , with regard to the cuckoo , I take this opportunity also of enlarging on the doubts I have thrown out , in relation to the prevailing notion of this bird 's nestlings being hatched and fed by foster parents .
I find that this most general opinion takes its rise from what is said by this father of natural history , in his ninth book , and twenty-ninth chapter .
Aristotle there asserts , that the cuckoo does not build a nest itself , but makes use most commonly of those of the wood-pigeon , hedge-sparrow , lark , ( which he adds are on the ground ) as well as that of the ~ ~ , which is in trees .
Now , if we take the whole of this account together , it is certainly not to be depended upon ; for the wood-pigeon ~ and hedge-sparrow do not build upon the ground , and no one ever pretended to have * See Willughby , p. 312 .
~ The ~ is rendered luteola ; but , as there is no description , it is difficult to say what bird Aristotle here alludes to ; Zinanni supposes it to be the greenfinch .
~ The wood-pigeon , from its size , seems to be the only bird which is capable of hatching , or feeding , the young cucfound found a cuckow 's egg in the nest of a lark , which , indeed , is so placed .
I have before observed , that the witnesses often vary with regard to the bird in which the cuckow 's egg is deposited * ; and Aristotle himself , in the seventh chapter of his sixth book , confines the fosterparents to the wood-pigeon and hedge-sparrow , but chiefly the former .
If the age ~ of Aristotle is considered , when he began to collect the materials for his Natural History , by the encouragement of Alexander after his conquests in India ~ , it is highly improbable he should have written from his own observations .
He therefore seems to have hastily put down the accounts of the persons who brought him the different specimens from most parts of the then known world .
Inaccurate , however , and contradictory as these reports often turn out , it was the best compilation which the ancients could have recourse to ; and Pliny kow ; yet , if it is recollected that this bird lives on seeds , it is probable that the cuckoo , whose nourishment is insects , would either be soon starved , or incapable of digesting what was brought by the foster-parent .
This objection is equally applicable to the ~ , if it is our greenfinch .
* Thus Linnaeus supposes it ( in the Fauna Suecica ) to be the white wagtail , which bird builds in the banks of rivers , or roofs of houses , ( See Zinanni , p. 51 .
) where it is believed no young cuckoo was ever found .
~ He did not leave the school of Plato till the age of thirtyeight ( or , as some say , forty ) ; after which , some years passed before he became Alexander 's preceptor , who was then but fourteen : nor could he have written his Natural History , probably , till twelve years after this , as Pliny states that specimens were sent to him by Alexander , from his conquests in India .
Aristotle therefore must have been nearly sixty , when he began this great work , and consequently must have described from the observations of others .
~ Pliny , L. viii .
c. 16 .
therefore professes only to abridge him , in which he often does not do justice to the original .
Whatever was asserted by Aristotle , is well known to have been most implicitly believed , till the last century ; and I am convinced that many of the learned in Europe would , before that time , not have credited their own eyesight against what he had delivered .
There cannot be a stronger proof that the general notion about the cuckoo arises from what is laid down by Aristotle , than the chapter which immediately follows , as it relates to the goatsucker , and states that this bird sucks the teats of that animal .
From this circumstance , the goatsucker hath obtained a similar name in most languages , though it is believed no one ( who thinks at all about matters of this sort ) continues to believe that this bird sucks the goat * , any more than the hedgehog does the cow .
I beg leave , however , to explain myself , that I give these additional reasons only for my doubting with regard to this most prevailing opinion ; because I am truly sensible that many things happen in nature , which contradict all arguments from analogy , and I am persuaded , therefore , that the first person who gave an account of the flying fish , was not credited by any one , though the existence of this animal is not now to be disputed .
All that I mean to contend for is , that the instances of such extraordinary peculiarities in animals , should be proportionably well attested , in all the necessary circumstances .
I must own , for example , that nothing short of the following particulars will thoroughly satisfy me on this head .
* See Zinanni p. 95 .
who took great pains to detect this vulgar error .
The hedge-sparrow 's nest must be found with the proper eggs in it , which should be destroyed by the cuckoo , at the time she introduces her single egg * .
The nest should then be examined at a proper distance from day to day , during the hedge-sparrow 's incubation , as also the motions of the foster parent attended to , particularly in feeding the young cuckoo , till it is able to shift for itself .
As I have little doubt that the last mentioned circumstance will appear decisive to many , without the others which I have required , it may be proper to give my reasons , why I cannot consider it alone , as sufficient .
There is something in the cry of a nestling for food , which affects all kinds of birds , almost as much as that of an infant , for the same purpose , excites the compassion of every human hearer ~ .
I have taken four young ones from a hen skylark , and placed in their room five nestling nightingales , as well as five wrens , the greater part of which were reared by the foster parent .
It can hardly in this experiment be contended , that the skylark mistook them for her own nestlings , be* I could also wish that the following experiment was tried .
When a hedge-sparrow hath laid all her eggs , a single one of any other bird , as large as a cuckoo , might be introduced , after which if either the nest was deserted , or the egg too large to be hatched , it would afford a strong presumption against this prevailing opinion .
I must here also take notice , that Mr. Hunter , F. R. S. who hath dissected hen cuckows , informs me that they are not incapacitated from hatching their eggs , as hath been supposed by some ornithologists .
~I am persuaded that a cuckoo is oftener an orphan , than any other nestling , because , from the curiosity which prevails with regard to this bird , the parents are eternally shot .
cause they differed greatly , not only in number and size , but in their habits , for nightingales and wrens perch , which a skylark is almost incapable of , though , by great assiduity , she at last taught herself the proper equilibre of the body .
I have likewise been witness of the following experiment : two robins hatched five young ones in a breeding cage , to which five others were added , and the old birds brought up the whole number , making no distinction between them .
The Aedologie also mentions ( which is a very sensible treatise on the nightingale * ) that nestlings of all sorts may be reared in the same manner , by introducing them to a caged bird , which is supplied with the proper food .
Not only old birds , however , attend to this cry of distress from nestlings , but young ones also which are able to shift for themselves .
I have seen a chicken , not above two months old , take as much care of younger chickens , as the parent would have shown to them which they had lost , not only by scratching to procure them food , but by covering them with her wings ; and I have little doubt but that she would have done the same by young ducks .
I have likewise been witness of nestling thrushes of a later brood , being fed by a young bird which was hatched earlier , and which indeed rather overcrammed the orphans entrusted to her care ; if the bird however erred in judgement , she was certainly not deficient in tenderness , which I am persuaded she would have equally extended to a nestling cuckoo .
* Paris , 1751 , or 1771 .

