II .
Investigation of the specific Characters which distinguish the Rabbit from the Hare : In a Letter to Samuel Wegg , Esq ; T. and Vice-President of the R. S. from the Honourable Daines Barrington , V. P. R. S. November 24 , 1771 DEAR SIR , 16 .
I CALLED lately at your house , to measure some parts of the quadruped which you have received by the last ship from Hudson 's Bay , and am now convinced that it should be rather considered as a Hare than as a Rabbit , which latter name it hath obtained in that part of the world .
Read Jan. 1772 .
You will find indeed , from what I am going to state , that it is not very easy to settle a specific , and at the same time scientific difference , between these two animals , even when the greatest authorities in Natural History are consulted .
Ray [ a ] makes the distinction between the Hare and the Rabbit to consist in the smaller size of the latter , its property of burrowing , and the greater whiteness of the flesh when dressed : he chiefly relies , however , on the one being larger than the other ; [ a ] Syn .
Quadr .
Art .
LEPUS .
as this is the most material circumstance in which they are supposed by him to vary , whether exterior or interior .
Though bulk is undoubtedly a very proper circumstance to be attended to in the description of an animal ; yet recourse should never be had to it in establishing a specific difference , except it is the only criterion which can be fixed upon , and the disproportion in point of size is very great .
An Hare , however , does not exceed a Rabbit so much in bulk as a Patagonian does a Laplander , or a mastiff does a lap-dog , which yet are not to be considered as differing in species .
Besides this , age , climate , and food , as well as other circumstances , often occasion great distinction between animals of the same species , in point of bulk .
The Hare ( for example ) which is found in most parts of North America , is a third less than the European Hare , and consequently is scarcely larger than our Rabbit [ b ] .
The next criterion which Ray fixes upon to distinguish the Rabbit from the Hare , is that the latter burrows in the ground ; this , however , only holds with regard to the warren Rabbit , for those which are called hedge Rabbits seldom burrow , and many of them sit in forms as Hares do .
[ b ] Mons. de Buffon is misinformed , when he asserts , on the contrary , that the American Hare is larger than that of Europe , ( Hist. N. t. VI .
p. 246 ) if I can depend upon the accounts I have received from those who have long resided in America , as well as some stuffed specimens which I have examined .
See also Mr. Pennant 's Syn .
of Quadr .
p. 249 .
The third and last is , that the flesh of the Rabbit is more white when dressed ; which distinction is always to be found between the European Hare and Rabbit , but it does not often happen that one can dress the flesh of an animal which comes from another part of the globe ; it is therefore a criterion we can seldom have recourse to .
Linnaeus , thus describes the Rabbit in his Fauna Suecica .
( Art .
LEPUS ) .
Lepus Caniculus , cauda abbreviata , Auriculis Nudatis .
Lepus cauda brevissima , pupillis rubris .
With regard to the first circumstance of the Cauda abbreviata , he equally applies it to the Hare in his Systema Naturae , published in 1766 , and drops the Cauda brevissima of the Fauna Suecica ; where in propriety the Rabbit should not have found a place , as it is not indigenous in Sweden , the climate being too cold for it .
Linnaeus therefore could only have described from a tame Rabbit , which I suppose had balder Ears by some accident than common , as his next criterion is Auriculis Nudatis .
I have examined lately a great number of Rabbits , and do not find that their ears are balder than those of a Hare : this second circumstance therefore establishes no specific difference .
From the third and last particular which this great Naturalist relies upon , I am also convinced that the specimen before him was not only a tame Rabbit , but that its fur was either white or carroty , because Rabbits of these colours only have red pupils [ c ] .
[ c ] I have examined a great number of Rabbits thus coloured , which commonly have red pupils , though I have seen some I find accordingly , that Linnaeus hath omitted the pupillis rubris , as applied to the Rabbit , in the twelfth edition of his Systema Naturae ; but adds another distinction , which will be found equally to fail .
He there says , that the ears of a Rabbit are shorter than the head ; whereas those of a Hare are longer : which is a just observation , when the warren Rabbit is examined ; but the tame Rabbit ( and particularly those which are white or carroty ) have ears that are considerably longer than their head .
This circumstance , therefore , establishes no more a specific difference between the Rabbit and the Hare , than the greater length of the ears of a dog would , which in some varieties of that animal are known to be excessively long .
Mons. de Buffon , in his description of the Hare and Rabbit , agrees with Ray that there is nothing either exterior or interior which seems to constitute a specific difference , though he endeavours to establish an incontestable proof that they are really distinct .
He informs us , that he had tried to procure a breed between Rabbits and Hares , but never could succeed in the experiment .
This most ingenious and able writer does not state , however , at what ages the Hares or Rabbits were thus confined , which is known to be a most material with black : the grey Rabbit however never hath eyes of a red colour .
When the white Rabbits are very young , their eyes are often like a ferret 's ; but when they are grown to their full size , the pupile are generally quite red .
circumstance , by those who have raised male Canary birds [ d ] .
Mons. de Buffon 's expression is , ` ` J'ai fait elever des hases avec des lapins , ' ' which at first seems to imply that he had reared them from their earliest infancy .
Upon consulting however the dictionary of Trevoux , the compilers inform us the word Elever [ e ] often signifies the feeding and keeping an animal , without respect to its age ; and they cite its being applied to elephants in Europe , which it is believed never bred in that quarter of the globe .
But the best expositor of the sense in which an author uses a word is in other parts of the same work .
In the fifth Vol. of his Natural History , p. 210 .
Mons. de Buffon gives an account of his making the same sort of experiment between the Wolf and a Dog , in the following words : J'ai fait elever un louve prise dans les bois , de deux ou trois mois .
' ' In this passage , the word is applied to a wolf , of three months old , and to show that Mons. de Buffon did not think the age at which the animal is confined to be material in such an experiment , he immediately afterwards states , that he caught some [ d ] Birds which differ specifically scarcely ever breed except both are taken early from the nest , and particulerly the hen ; I have procured a breed from two robins in a cage the present year by attending to this circumstance , and I believe I could equally succeed with almost any other kind of birds , as when they are thus reared , they have not the least awe of man .
[ e ] ` ` Elever signify , Nourrir aussi , soit plant , soit animal , &amp; en avoir soin .
' ' On a de la peine a elever des elephans en Europe .
' ' foxes in snares ( which were probably therefore full grown ) , and kept them a considerable time with dogs of different sexes .
After this , he says [ e ] , it is evident from these experiments , that wolves , foxes , and dogs are specifically different , without distinguishing between the foxes being full grown when caught , and the wolf which was only three months old .
But the decisive argument against Mons. de Buffon 's experiment not being satisfactory , is to be found in Mr. Pennant 's Synopsis of quadrupeds , p. 144 : where he informs us , that a breed was actually procured between a dog and a wolf at Mr. Brooks 's ( animal merchant ) in Holborn .
Mons. de Buffon also supposes that the Rabbit is much more sagacious than the Hare , because , both having equal powers of burrowing , the one thus secures himself from most enemies , whilst the other , by not taking the same precaution , continues liable to their attacks .
There are , however , several causes for the Rabbit 's burrowing , and the Hare 's neglecting to do so .
In the first place , the fore-legs of a Rabbit are shorter in proportion to its hind legs , and at the same time much stronger ; the claws are also longer and sharper , resembling much those of a mole .
I have before observed that the Rabbits , which the sportsmen call Hedge Rabbits , seldom burrow ; and they neglect taking this trouble , for the same reason that induces the Hare to trust to her form , be[e ] Hist. Not .
T. v. p. 213 .
cause they have an opportunity of selecting a proper place for their concealment .
The ground , however , in a warren , is eaten so very bare by Rabbits , that it is impossible for them to hide themselves if they make a form in any part of it , and they therefore very judiciously choose to burrow under ground .
Another reason , perhaps , for the Rabbit 's burrowing arises from the animal 's being not only born , but continuing the first six weeks of its life , under ground ; they therefore only practise what they have seen and learned in their earliest infancy , as birds from the same circumstance always build their nest in the same form , and with the same materials .
I therefore cannot allow entirely of the distinction arising from the superior sagacity of the Rabbit , because it burrows ; and Mons. de Buffon himself informs us , that tame Rabbits turned into a warren do not burrow for many generations [ f ] .
Having thus endeavoured to show that no proper criteria have hitherto been fixed upon to distinguish the Rabbit from the Hare , I shall now venture to suggest the two following , which , I flatter myself , will be found less liable to the same exceptions .
If the hind legs of an European Hare are measured from the uppermost joint to the toe , the number of inches will turn out to be just half of the length of the back , from the rump to the mouth ( the tail not being included ) The hind legs of the Rabbit being measured in the same manner , and compared with the back are not much more than one third ; from which [ f ] Hist. Not .
T. 5 .
p. 306 .
it seems not unfair to consider any animal of the Hare genus , ( whose legs thus measured are less than the half of the distance from the rump to the mouth ) as a Rabbit , and on the contrary when they are either one half , or more , as a Hare .
If the fore and hind legs of a Rabbit and Hare are also respectively compared , it will be found that the fore legs of the former are proportionally more short , than those of a Hare .
By both these criteria the quadruped from Hudson 's Bay must rather be considered as a Hare , than a Rabbit ( as it is called in that part of the world ) , according to the admeasurements subjoined , which include the respective proportions also of the Alpine Hare [ h ] .
Fore Leg .
Hind Leg .
Back and Head .
Inches .
Inches .
Inches .
Rabbit 41/ 2 63/ 4 161/ 2 Hare 73/ 4 11 22 Hudson 's Bay 63/ 8 106/ 8 18 Quadruped 64/ 8 106/ 8 22 Alpine Hare From the From the uppermost uppermost joint to the joint to the toe .
toe .
From the proportion of these parts , in the Hudson 's Bay quadruped , according to this table , I flatter myself , that it may with greater propriety be classed as belonging to the Hare species , than by any other marks of a specific difference which have been hitherto relied upon .
[ h ] This species of Hare is found in the Highlands of Scotland , whence I received a specimen , which I had the honour of presenting to the Museum of the Royal Society .
I do not mean , however , to assert from this , that a Hare and Rabbit are certainly of a distinct species ; as this can only be settled by failing to procure a mixed breed between the animals after repeated experiments , and under proper circumstances .
I shall now add , that the Hudson 's Bay animal also approaches nearer to the Hare than the Rabbit , by the fore legs being much more slender in proportion to the hind legs than those of a Rabbit are ; and that the claws are also shorter .
As the animal likewise happened to die on the 22d of this month , I boiled the flesh , by your permission , which was as brown as that of the European Hare ; and consequently it is to be classed as of that species , according to Ray 's third criterion .
But the most curious particular in this quadruped is the white winter coat , which covered , at its death , the greatest part of the animal .
This refutes at once the notion , that animals in the more Northern countries become white by the intense cold of the climate , because this quadruped arrived in England about the time that the change should have begun if it had continued in Hudson 's Bay .
As the animal was born , however , in a country where snow covers the ground during the whole winter , it is providential that the formation of its parts and juices should be such as should periodically occasion such a change in the fur ; and perhaps , it is the only quadruped which ever was brought from a climate of such rigour , to a more temperate one , before the alteration of the colour in its hair took place .
By four different specimens in that valuable collection of animals , which the directors of the Hudson 's Bay Company have lately procured from a country unvisited but by their own servants , it appears that the change begins in October ( or perhaps the latter end of September ) and that it is completed in January .
We owe this knowledge of the regular gradations of colour in this animal at different intervals as the winter advances , to the very sensible attention in the company 's servants , who have tied memorandums to the specimen of each animal , which inform us of the day and month in which it was caught .
If the fur of your quadruped is accurately examined , it will be found to consist of two distinct coats of hair , one of which is much more thinly scattered over the body , but is more than twice the length of the inmost covering , at the same time that it is vastly stronger .
This upper and thinner coat is composed also of hairs which are white from the top to the root , and form the winter surtout for the animal : its brown fur , therefore , never becomes white , but is concealed by the upper coat .
This additional covering seems to be absolutely necessary for the animal 's preservation , as it is thereby enabled to endure the rigour of a Hudson 's Bay winter , whilst at the same time the colour of the new fur being white , prevents its being distinguished by its very numerous enemies [ g ] .
If this surtout , however , was not to fall off during the summer , it would prove the destruction of the animal : because the extraordinary heat from such a warm cloathing would not only become highly inconvenient , but the colour also ( being white ) would point the animal out to its pursuers ; as Mr. Graham takes notice in his very accurate catalogue , that this quadruped does not burrow .
This very sensible officer of the Hudson 's Bay Company likewise adds , that this animal continues always near the same spot ; that its coat is brown in summer ; that they breed from 5 to 7 young ones , and sometimes twice a year : he also states , that the weight at a medium is nearly 4 ~ .
I am , DEAR SIR , Your most faithful , humble servant , Daines Barrington .
[ g ] It must be admitted , however , that the white coat during the winter is not a sufficient protection to the animal against the sagacity of the arch-enemy man .
Mr. Reinhold Forster ( who is a native of Polish Prussia ) informs me that Hares are found in the northern parts of Europe , when the snow is on the ground , by an exhalation of vapours from their bodies , whilst they are sitting in their form , especially if the sun happens to shine .
I can very easily conceive that such a vapour may be distinguished , as I have frequently in a frosty morning seen the air condensed , which hath issued from the mouth of so small a bird as a Robin , when in full song .

