XLVI .
Of Torpedos found on the Coast of England .
In a Letter from John Walsh , Esq ; F. R. S. to Thomas Pennant , Esq ; F. R. S. Chesterfield-street , June 23 , 1774 .
DEAR SIR , TO the Author of the British Zoology it will , I am persuaded , be no unwelcome information , that the Torpedo , or Electric Ray , frequents the shores of this island , contrary to a received opinion among Naturalists , who have in general considered it as an inhabitant only of warmer climates .
Red , June 23 , 1774 .
In consequence of inquiries I had set on foot in some of our southern fishing ports , two Torpedos , taken in Torbay , one in the beginning of August , and the other in the beginning of November , last year , have been actually sent up to this metropolis .
The first , procured for me by the good offices of Mr. Amyatt , Apothecary in Berkeley Square , arrived during my absence ; but it was examined , and the electrical organs were successfully injected , by Mr. John Hunter .
The second , forwarded to me by Mr. Grant , a principal Fishmonger in the Landcarriage branch , then at Brixham , came up very fresh and perfect , in one of his fish-machines .
This I weighed and measured before it was touched by the dissecting knife , and found it to weigh fistythree pounds avoirdupois , and to measure four feet in length , two feet and a half in its extreme breadth , and four inches and a half in its extreme thickness .
The largest Torpedo I met with in the neighbourhood of la Rochelle , where upwards of seventy passed through my hands , weighed little more than ten pounds , and measured not quite two feet in length , nor quite sixteen inches in breadth : and the largest I have read of is that mentioned by Rhedi to Lorenzini ( a ) , weighing twenty-four pounds , without doubt of Leghorn , which make about eighteen avoirdupois .
Though this Mediterranean Torpedo has been ever considered as of an extraordinary size , it is exceeded in weight nearly three to one by our enormous British Torpedo .
The back of it was of a dark ash-colour , with somewhat of a purple cast , but not at all motled like those of the Atlantic Coast of France , nor regularly marked with eyes , as they have been called , like some found in the Mediterranean .
Its under part was white , skirted however with the same ashcolour , which towards its tail became almost universal .
The side fins being a little contracted and curled up , prevented the precise measurement of its breadth , but it appeared to hold the general proportion observed in those of la Rochelle ; that is , the breadth was two-thirds of the length ( b ) .
Its electric ( a ) Lorenz .
Oss .
intor .
alle T orp .
p. 4 .
( b ) The breadth of the Ray-Torpedo of Brazil is , according to Marcgrave , just one-third of the length , falling in with the proportion of the Squatino-Raia .
See Marcg .
Lib. iv .
Cap. 6 .
organs likewise were proportionate with theirs , each organ measuring fifteen inches in extreme length , and eight in extreme breadth .
In short , the Torpedo of Torbay no way differed from those I saw in the Bay of Biscay but in size and colour ; and perhaps this difference may be thought rather casual than denoting a specific distinction .
It was a female , without any signs of pregnancy .
The intestines contained , with some black slime , two vertebres of a fish , seemingly of the cod kind .
The electrical organs of this Torpedo were likewise injected by Mr. Hunter , though not with his first success , from the bursting of the artery in the operation ; he determined , however , the number of columns in one organ to amount to 1182 , and fully confirmed the observation he formerly made , that their numerous horizontal partitions were very vascular .
Shall I take notice that the rest of this fish was dressed and brought to table , and that some of my friends suffered a little for their curiosity in tasting it ?
Rondelet speaks unfavourably of the Torpedo as food ; and tells us , that at Venice the Prefect of Health forbids it to be sold in the market .
But to deem it wholesome diet , we have the sanction of Hippocrates as well as Galen ; and if forbid at Venice when Rondelet was there , in the markets of France I know it to be sold .
The truth is , that the electrical organs , which make one half of the animal , are , though wholesome to be eaten , an insipid mucilage ; but its muscular part is , at least , as palatable as the flesh of the other Rays : among these the old and overgrown are ever in little request .
Our Torpedo was was doubtless such ; and we must beside confess that , as a rarity , it had been kept too long .
The first Torpedo was not weighed ; but Mr. Hunter , who examined both , assured me , that they appeared to him equal in size , and alike in every other respect ; indeed their electrical organs , preserved to this hour , show them to have been of the same magnitude .
The first was a female likewise , and not pregnant .
The following accounts were received from Brixham , concerning Torpedos found in that quarter .
From Mr. Philip Lyde , Surgeon at Brixham , who forwarded the first , on the 4th of August , 1773 .
I send a Torpedo , or Numb-fish , which had , when living , the greatest effect , as I am informed by the men who caught it .
There have been three taken this week .
The one sent seems to be of the largest size .
' ' In an earlier account , dated the 23d June , it is mentioned that one or two are caught there every week .
From Mr. Grant , fishmonger , who sent the second Torpedo , on the 3d November , 1773 .
The Torpedo , or Numb-fish , is by no means plenty in these parts , as it rarely happens that more than one is taken at a time ; nor can the proper season for catching them be ascertained , as they have been seen at all times of the year .
The usual depth of water in which they are caught is from thirty-six to forty fathom ; and being of the Ray kind , they are commonly taken with them .
As to the time when their young are to be seen , no satisfactory information can be obtained ; but it is Ooo2 ` ` imagined imagined that the season for them and the Rays is the same .
Their numbing quality is pretty strong through the net , though much weaker than when they are taken out .
The general name by which they are known here , is the Numb or Cramp-fish .
Few or no small Torpedos are to be met with in these parts , those hitherto caught being from ten to sixty , seventy , and eighty pounds weight ; which may probably proceed from the young being thrown away promiscuously with other offal fish .
' ' At la Rochelle , during the entire month of July , most of the larger female Torpedos , being those from fifteen inches to two feet in length , were found with an uncertain number of eggs in their matrices , the largest females appearing to have the greatest number .
The eggs of the same female differed little from each other as to forwardness ; nor did the eggs of one female differ much from those of another : the embryo in all was but little advanced .
A letter from M. Saunier of la Rochelle , written about six weeks after I had left that place , informed me , that on the 10th September , he opened a very large Torpedo of about two feet and a quarter by one and a half , and discovered flating in the left matrice nine fetuses quite formed , near two inches long , and distinct from them nine eggs in no state of forwardness ; and that in the right matrice he met with four such fetuses and nine such eggs .
The observation , therefore , of Aristotle , that the Torpedo brings forth at the autumnal equinox , is well founded , notwithstanding Lorenzini has questioned the fact .
From the remarkable superfetation in this instance , we may besides inser , that the Torpedo , agreeably to Aristotle 's information .
concerning the cartilaginous fish in general , goes with young near six months ; as the eggs here found seem , from their being so little advanced in so late a time of the year , to be destined for the spring-brood .
Lorenzini 's dissections of female Torpedos big with eggs in February and March , and of others without any in April , show that they produce about the vernal as well as autumnal equinox .
This was confirmed by the many young Torpedos we met with in the month of July , from four and a half to six inches long , which were evidently the offspring of that year .
Among these , however , was one , taken on the 4th July , weighing one ounce , and measuring four inches and a half by three , which had still its native yolk unconsumed in its abdomen .
By this circumstance it appears , that there may be a production likewise at Midsummer ; but our general observations led us to conclude , that it principally takes place at the two equinoxes .
I have dwelt the longer on the season in which foreign Torpedos bring forth , as we are yet entirely ignorant on that point with regard to those of our colder climate , and as this knowledge may , in some degree , assist us in knowing when and where to look for the animal .
Most fish , we are told , approach the shore in the summer season ; and the Torpedo will doubtless then , in quest of food , and of a warmer element , both for itself and for its young , haunt the shoal water .
In the cold and tempestuous part of the year , we shall probably find it in a deeper sea , which then affords it the more mild and still retreat .
My learned friend Dr. George Baker has procured for me a drawing and some account of a Torpedo , taken about five years since in Mount 's Bay in Cornwall .
The particulars , as they were lately collected by Mr. Scobell of Penzance , from the fisherman who took it , are these : ` ` that he judged it on memory to have weighed about forty pounds , and to have been about three feet long and two and a half broad ; that its skin was smooth like an eel , darkbrown on the back , and white underneath ; and that it had been caught with a large hook , in the month of March , on sandy ground .
' ' For the sake of Oppian 's fine description of the capture of the Torpedo , which Claudian has elegantly paraphrased , and which you , struck with the passage , have rendered in English metre , I am glad the Torpedo is found to take the hook .
That description , though thought to have been fabulous , proves to be no less just in each circumstance , than , as it was always confessed to be , poetically beautiful in the whole .
But to catch with the greatest success the Torpedo , as well as other flat fish , which keep near the ground , the trawl , or drag-net , must be used .
This kind of fishing is much practised in Torbay ; but in Mount 's Bay , as I am informed , not yet adopted ; which may be the chief reason why the Torpedo has but seldom been taken at the one , and so very frequently at the other place .
I had an opportunity last autumn of making a short visit to Dungarvan in Ireland , where Smith in his History of Waterford , as you have remarked , mentions a Torpedo of six or eight pounds to have been found about thirty years since .
The fishery there , which is very considerable , is wholly carried on with hook and line , and the fishermen were entire strangers to the Torpedo .
But at Ring , a fishing village in the neighbourhood , furnishing about fourteen or fifteen small vessels , with which they practise pole-trawling , the fishermen were acquainted with it .
They told me , that they sometimes caught one or two in a year , and sometimes none for two or three years ; that they had taken two that year , and one the year preceding ; that these were about eighteen inches long , and fourteen broad , and were caught a league off shore ; that the fish benumbs those who touch it , and that they had been benumbed by it ; and that its name in Irish is Aunghellaw .
From this name it might seem that they confounded it with the Angel-fish : but by their description , both of the animal and its effects , it was plain they knew and meant the Torpedo .
To prove the electrical effect of the animal , the curious should be informed , not only where to find , but how best to preserve it alive .
The Electric Ray is so far amphibious as to exist in air twenty-four hours : in fresh water it survives but little longer .
Well-boats kept in salt water , and not put into much motion , may best suit it : In reservoirs on shore , which on sea-coasts are not unfrequent , it will be subject to be annoyed , notwithstanding its electrical armour , by the Sea-leach and the common Sea-crab .
A commodious well-boat we experienced might soon be made from a small flat-bottomed boat , termed by the French Pousse-pied ; which , partitioned with laths into three or four chambers , and secured in the same manner at the top , kept floating , from its leaky state , just even with the water .
In this pen we were able to preserve them several days , and always without food ; for though in the stomach of these animals , when taken , a Plaice or Surmullet may , as we have seen , be found , yet in confinement they neglect all kinds of prey : it will be easy however , as they are of a quiet nature , to force them to swallow food , if necessary .
But the frequent , and perhaps favourite situation of the Torpedo is to lie in concealment under sand .
If he be placed by design , as he is sometimes left by accident , in any hollow of a sandy beach , from whence the tide has just retired , he swims to that brink where the water is still draining away , and on finding himself unable after repeated attempts to push himself over the shallow , and follow the course of the tide , he begins with admirable address to bury himself in the sand , and by a gentle but quick flapping of his extremities all round soon sinks himself a bed , and in the action throws the sand in a light shower over his back .
Neither the animal nor the spot he is in can now be distinguished ; save only that , on a nice search , his two small inspiratory foramina , and their membranes at play , may be perceived .
It is in this situation that the Torpedo gives his most forcible shock , which throws down the astonished passenger who inadvertently steps on him .
I have thus shown that Great Britain too claims the Torpedo , or Electric Ray ; that ours is the broad marine sort , which Socrates , as Meno thought , resembled ; and that it is the black Torpedo , whose influence subdues obstinate Head-achs , and the Gout itself ( c ) .
In announcing to our Naturalists and ( c ) Scribonius Largus , Cap. 1 .
&amp; 41 .
See also several of the early physicians , Roman and Arabian , for different cures attributed by them to the effect of the Torpedo .
Electricians the presence of this wonderful guest , I should certainly felicitate our Invalids on their acquisition , but that the Leyden phial contains all his magic power .
I remain , with true esteem .
DEAR SIR , Your affectionate and obedient servant , JOHNWALS H.

