XLII .
A Letter from David Macbride , M. D. to John Walsh , Esq ; F. R. S. accompanying two Letters from Mr. Simon to Dr. Macbride , concerning the Reviviscence of some Snails preserved many Years in Mr. Simon 's Cabinet .
To JOHN WALSH , Esq ; DEARSI R , Dublin , 22 Jan. 1774 .
I Enclose to you two letters , which I received from Mr. STUCKEY SIMON , concerning that extraordinary fact in Natural History , which you seemed to regret had not been sufficiently authenticated to be communicated to the public , in the Philosophical Transactions of last year.-The Royal Society are undoubtedly in the right to be extremely cautious of allowing any thing , so very much out of the hitherto-observed course of nature , as this is , to appear in their publications , without the fullest evidence .
In Red , May 5 , B 8 C BDEC DGG 9 10 In Mr. SIMON 's letter of the 26th of November , you will please to observe , that he mentions a particular shell , whose snail had come out repeatedly four different times , in the presence of different people ; each of whom have assured me that they saw it .
That gentleman having done me the favour to dine with me , a day or two after the date of that letter , he brought the identical shell ( as he declared ) , in order that we might try if the snail would again make its appearance .
The company were not disappointed ; for , after the shell had lain about ten minutes in a glass of water that had the cold barely taken off , the snail began to appear ; and in five minutes more we perceived half the body fairly pushed out from the cavity of the shell .
We then removed it into a basin , that the snail might have more scope than it had in the glass : and here , in a very short time , we saw it get above the surface of the water , and crawl up towards the edge of the basin .
While it was thus moving about , with its horns erect , a fly chanced to be hovering near , and , perceiving the snail , darted down upon it .
The little animal instantly withdrew itself within the shell , but as quickly came forth again , when it found the enemy had gone off .
We allowed it to wander about the basin for upwards of an hour ; when we returned it into a wide-mouthed phial , wherein Mr. SIMON had lately been used to keep it .
He was so obliging , as to present me with this remarkable shell ; and I observed , at twelve o'clock , as I was going to bed , that the snail was still in motion : but , next morning , I found it in a torpid state , sticking to the side of the glass .
In a few weeks after the time above-mentioned , I took an opportunity of sending this shell to Sir JOHN PRINGLE , who showed it at a meeting of the Society ; but , as he has been pleased to inform me , some of the members could not bring themselves to believe , but that Mr. SIMON must have suffered himself to be imposed on by his son , who , as they imagined , substituted fresh shells , for those which he had got out of the cabinet .
When Sir JOHN PRINGLE acquainted me with this difficulty , I wrote to Mr. SIMON , and that produced his letter of the 4th of February .
I afterwards also examined the boy myself ; and could find no reason to believe , that he either did , or could impose on his father .
Mr. SIMON is a merchant of this place , of a very reputable character , and undoubted veracity .
He lives in the heart of the city , a circumstance which rendered it almost impossible for the son ( if he had been so disposed ) to collect fresh shells .
The father of Mr. STUCKEY SIMON was Mr. JAMES SIMON , a Fellow of the Royal Society ; who , being a lover of Natural History , as well as an Antiquarian , made a little collection of fossils , which is still in the son 's possession , and contains some articles that are rather uncommon .
Should Mr. SIMON'S letters be inserted in the Transactions , they will no doubt be the means of exciting Naturalists to enquire into the extent of vitality in the lower orders of animals .
I am , dear Sir , your most obedient , and very humble servant , DAVID MACBRID E. Mr. STUCKEY SIMON to Dr. MACBRIDE .
SIR , Dublin , 26 Nov. 1772 .
AN accident having brought to light what some Naturalists have not had an opportunity to examine into , and which has been a subject of some conversation amongst gentlemen to whom I have mentioned it , has made me commit to writing the simple facts , in order to put others on making further experiments on the subject.-About three months since , I was settling some shells in a drawer ; amongst which were some snail-shells .
I took them out , and gave them to my son ( a child about ten years old ) , who was then in the room with me .
The Saturday following , the child diverted himself with the shells , put them into a flower-pot , which he filled with water , and next morning put them into a basin .
Having occasion to use it , I observed the snails had come out of the shells .
I examined the child .
He assured me they were the same I gave him some days before ; and said he had a few more , which he brought me .
I put one of them in water ; and , in half an hour after , I observed him put out his horns and body , which he moved with a slow motion , I suppose from weakness .
I then informed Major Vallancy and Dr. Span of this surprising discovery .
They did me the favour to come to my house the Saturday following , to examine the snails ; and , on putting them in water , found that only one had life , which was that I put in water , for he came out of his shell , and carried it on his back about the basin .
The rest , I suppose , died by being kept too long in water ; for , on the first discovery , I let them remain in the water until the Monday following , when I poured off the water , the snails being still out of their shells , and seemingly dead .
They lay in that state until Tuesday night , when I found they had all withdrawn into their shells ; and , though I several times since put them into water , they showed no signs of life .
Dr. Quin and Dr. Rutty did me the favour , at different times , to examine the snail that is living ; and were greatly pleased to see him come out of his solitary habitation in which he has been confined upwards of fifteen years , for so long I can with truth declare he has been in my possession ; as my father died in January 1758 , in whose collection of fossils those snails were , and for what I know they might have been many years in his possession before they came into my hands .
The shells are small , and of one kind ; white , striped with brown .
Since this discovery , I have kept this snail in a small phial , with a cover with holes , to let in air ; and he seems at present very strong , and in health .
I shall be extremely glad , if this plain account I have given you would induce gentlemen to make some further experiments on this subject .
I am , Sir , Your most obedient , humble servant , STUCKEY SIMON .
3 Mr. Mr. STUCKEY SIMON to Dr. MACBRIDE .
DEARSI R , Strand-street , 4 Feb. 1773 .
IRECEIVED your letter ; and see that Sir JOHN PRINGLE received the snail safe .
You say , that some gentlemen are inclined to think , my son has imposed on me fresh shells , in the stead of those I gave him .
He had no opportunity to get any other shells , being , at the time and for several days after , confined to the house with a cold .
I am positive they are the same I gave him , having more of the same sort of shells in my cabinet , and nearly the same size .
The nine shells , which produced the snails , are of the same kind as the one you sent to Sir JOHN PRINGLE ; and I now send you one of them , with the snail in it , which I take to be dead .
Having put it in water several times , it became soft ; and a part of it pushed out of the shell , but showed no other sign of life .
I would have sent you a few more of the shells , but that the Bishop of Derry , and some other friends , have begged of me to give them a share .
I am , dear Sir , Your most obedient , humble servant , STUCKEY SIMON .

