VIII .
On the noxious Quality of the Effluvia of putrid Marshes .
A Letter from the Rev. Dr. Priestley to Sir John Pringle .
To Sir JOHNPRINGL E , Baronet .
DEARSI R , HAVING pursued my experiments on different kinds of air considerably farther , in several respects , than I had done , when I presented the last account of them to the Royal Society ; and being encouraged by the favourable notice which the Society has been pleased to take of them , I shall continue my communications on this subject ; but ; without waiting for the result of a variety of processes , which I have now going on , or of other experiments , which I propose to make ; I shall , from time to time , communicate such detached articles , as I shall have given the most attention to , and with respect to which , I shall have been the most successful in my inquiries .
Red , Deo .
16 , 1773 .
Since the publication of my papers , I have read two treatises , written by Dr. ALEXANDER , of Edinburgh , and am exceedingly pleased with the spirit of philosophical inquiry , which they discover .
They appear to me to contain many new , curious , and valuable observations ; but one of the conclusions , which he draws from his experiments , I am satisfied , from my own observations , is ill founded , and from the nature of it , must be dangerous .
I mean his maintaining , that there is nothing to be apprehended from the neighbourhood of putrid marshes .
I was particularly surprised , to meet with such an opinion as this , in a book inscribed to yourself , who have so clearly explained the great mischief of such a situation , in your excellent treatise on the diseases of the army .
On this account , I have thought it not improper , to address to you the following observations and experiments , which I think clearly demonstrate the fallacy of Dr. ALEXANDER'S reasoning , indisputably establish your doctrine , and indeed justify the apprehensions of all mankind in this case .
I think it probable enough , that putrid matter , as Dr. ALEXANDER has endeavoured to prove , will preserve other substances from putrefaction ; because , being already saturated with the putrid effluvium , they cannot readily take any more ; but Dr. ALEXANDER was not aware , that air thus loaded with putrid effluvium is exceedingly noxious when taken into the lungs .
I have lately , however , had an opportunity of fully ascertaining how very noxious such air is .
Happening to use at Calne , a much larger trough of water , for the purpose of my experiments , than I had done at Leeds , and not having fresh water so near at hand as I had there , I neglected to change it , till it turned black , and became offensive , but by no means to such a degree , as to deter me from making use of it .
In this state of the water , I observed bubbles of air to rise from it , and especially in one place , to which some shelves , that I had in it , directed them ; and having set an inverted glass vessel to catch them , in a few days I collected a considerable quantity of this air , which issued spontaneously from the putrid water ; and , putting nitrous air to it , I found that no change of colour or diminution ensued , so that it must have been , in the highest degree , noxious .
I repeated the same experiment several times afterwards , and always with the same result .
After this , I had the curiosity to try how wholesome air would be affected by agitation in this water ; when , to my real surprise , I found , that after one minute only , a candle would not burn in it ; and , after three or four minutes , it was in the same state with the air , which had issued spontaneously from the same water .
I also found , that common air , confined in a glass vessel , in contact only with this water , and without any agitation , would not admit a candle to burn in it after two days .
These facts certainly demonstrate , that air which either arises from stagnant and putrid water , or which has been for some time in contact with it , must be very unfit for respiration ; and yet Dr. ALEXANDER'S opinion is rendered so plausible by his experiments , that it is very possible that many persons may be rendered secure , and thoughtless of danger , in a situation in which they must necessarily breathe it .
On this account , I have thought it right to make this communication as early as I conveniently could ; and as Dr. ALEXANDER appears to be an ingenuous and benevolent man , I doubt not but he will thank me for it .
That air issuing from water , or rather from the soft earth , or mud , at the bottom of pits containing water , is not always unwholesome , I have also had an opportunity of ascertaining .
Taking a walk , about two years ago , in the neighbourhood of Wakefield , in Yorkshire , I observed bubbles of air to arise , in remarkably great plenty , from a small pool of water , which , upon inquiry , I was informed had been the place , where some persons had been boring the ground , in order to find coal .
These bubbles of air having excited my curiosity , I presently returned , with a bason , and other vessels proper for my purpose , and having stirred the mud with a long stick , I soon got about a pint of this air ; and , examining it , found it to be good common air ; at least a candle burned in it very well .
I had not then discovered the method of ascertaining the goodness of common air , by a mixture of nitrous air .
Previous to the trial , I had suspected that this air would have been found to be inflammable .
I shall conclude this letter with observing , that I have found a remarkable difference in different kinds of water , with respect to their effect on common air agitated in them , and which I am not yet able to account for .
If I agitate common air in the water of a deep well , near my house in Calne , which is hard , but clear and sweet , a candle will not burn in it after three minutes .
The same is the case with the rain water , which I get from the roof of my house .
But in distilled water , or the water of a spring-well near the house , I must agitate the air about 20 minutes , before it will be so much injured .
It may be worth while , to make farther experiments , with respect to this property of water .
In consequence of using the rain water , and the well water above-mentioned , I was very near concluding , contrary to what I have asserted in my printed papers , that common air suffers a decomposition by great rarefaction .
For when I had collected a considerable quantity of air , which had been rarefied about four hundred times , by an excellent pump made for me by Mr. SMEATO N , I always found , that when I filled my receivers with the water above-mentioned , though I did it so gradually as to occasion as little agitation as possible , a candle would not burn in the air that remained in them .
But when I used distilled water , or fresh spring water , I undeceived myself .
I think myself honoured by the attention , which , from the first , you have given to my experiments , and am , with the greatest respect , Dear Sir , Your most obliged humble Servant , London , 7 Dec. 1773 .
J. PRIESTLE Y. POSTSCRIP T. I cannot help expressing my surprise , that so clear and intelligible an account , of Mr. SMEATO N'S air-pump , should have been before the public so long , as ever since the publication of the fortyseventh volume of the Philosophical Transactions , and yet that none of our philosophical instrument makers should attempt the construction .
The superiority of this pump , to any that are made upon the common plan , is , indeed , prodigious .
Few of them will rarefy more than 100 times , and , in a general way , not more than 60 or 70 times ; whereas this instrument must be in a poor state indeed , if it do not rarefy 200 or 300 times ; and when it is in good order , it will go as far as 1000 times , and sometimes even much farther than that ; besides , this instrument is worked with much more ease , than a common air-pump , and either exhausts or condenses at pleasure .
In short , to a person engaged in philosophical pursuits , this instrument is an invaluable acquisition .
I shall have occasion to recite some experiments , which I could not have made , and which , indeed , I should hardly have dared to attempt , if I had not been possessed of such an air-pump as this .
It is much to be wished , that some person of spirit in the trade would attempt the construction of an instrument , which would do great credit to himself , as well as be of eminent service to philosophy .

