PHILOSOPHICAL TRANSACTIONS .
1 .
Observations on the SOLAR SPOTS .
By Alexander Wilson , M. D. Professor of Practical Astronomy in the University of Glasgow .
Communicated by the Rev. Nevil Maskelyne , Astronomer Royal .
WHEN the great COPERNICUS had revived the true system of the world , it was objected against it , that the planet Venus ought to be seen with different phases like the moon ; to which he answered , that some time or another that very thing would perhaps come to VO L. LXIV .
B pass .
Red , Apr.29 , pass .
Who then would have thought , that this prophecy was so near being fulfilled , and that , by means of combining a convex and a concave glass , the common uses of which had been known for near 300 years before , the fight of man was to be extended almost to the remotest parts of the universe ?
This instrument , which nothing but its being so common hinders us from regarding with the greatest wonder , was invented , about 170 years ago , by one of those happy accidents , to which we owe many of the finest discoveries .
At that time flourished the famous GALILEO , who was the first that constructed a telescope from some knowledge of the refraction of the rays of light .
Having finished one in 1610 , he directed it to the heavens , and thus entered upon the most pleasing and most striking field of observation , which any philosopher ever enjoyed .
The name of GALILEO will always be familiar to us , so long as there remains any remembrance of those celebrated discoveries , which he then made by the help of his glasses .
One of the most remarkable of them was that of the SOLAR SPOTS .
So strange a discovery , relating to the sun , commanded a great-deal of attention .
At that time the authority of Aristotle , by controlling the reason of men , governed their opinions in all parts of philosophy ; and one of the absurd doctrines , then taught in the schools , was , that the matter of the heavens was ungenerated , incorruptible , and subject to no alteration .
But the arguments , which GALILEO now produced against that notion , were founded upon the evidence of sense , and it was impossible to oppose them .
The spots upon the sun , and the many strange variations , to which they were subject , convinced all , who were able to lay aside the prejudices of a vain philosophy , that there was not so great a difference , betwixt celestial and sublunary bodies , as had been imagined .
To such as were so reconciled to it , the discovery appeared grand and striking ; and great hopes were entertained , that , by duly attending to the phenomenon of the spots , something curious and important might be determined concerning the nature and constitution of the sun itself .
We accordingly find , that many astronomers , of the first note , were very early engaged in this inquiry .
Of all those who applied themselves this way , SCHEINER and HEVELIUS deservedly hold the first place , and nothing but the charms of so noble an investigation could have induced them to prosecute their observations with so much assiduity .
SCHEINER began his in the year 1624 , 14 years after GALILEO had first made the discovery .
In the year 1630 , he at last published his Rosa Ursina , in which we have a detail of his labours during that long interval of time .
HEVELIUS came after SCHEINER , and diligently watched the appearances of the spots for two years , the result of which application he has given us in his Selenographia and Cometographia .
But notwithstanding these attempts , so worthy of men actuated by a true desire of knowledge , it must be confessed , that nothing of moment hath been derived from them .
If we except a few conclusions concerning the rotation of the sun round its axis , and the inclination of its axis to the plane of the ecliptic , every thing else , which hath been inferred from the phenomenon of the spots , seems altogether to be matter of conjecture .
HEVELIUS , from his great fondness of the subject , and from a desire to avail himself of that long course of observation , to which he had so patiently submitted , has been led into many speculations concerning the spots and the nature of the sun 's body .
The following quotations furnish us with a remarkable instance of this , and will serve to give us a view of the ideas , which he came to entertain upon these subjects .
In his Cometographia , p 360 , speaking of the solar spots he expresses himself thus : Haec materia nunc ea ipsa est evaporatio et exhalatio ( quia aliunde minim oriri potest ) quae ex ipso corpore solis , ut supra ostensum est , expiratur et exhalatur : quae penitus ex diversis partibus heterogeneis , certos gradus opacitatis et densitatis habentibus , constat , modo ex tenuioribus , modo opacioribus , modo siccioribus , modo magis viscosis , glutinosis ( ut nostro loquar more usitato ) sive bituminosis .
Unde etiam diversa procreantur phenomenon ; ex tenuioribus , purioribus , et siccioribus , umbrae videlicet faculae et luculae ; ex impurioribus vero crassioribusque illis viscosis , maculae eorundemque nuclei progignuntur .
Cum ergo solis exhalationes ejusmodi parts sint heterogeneae , quidni etiam illud ipsum corpus , quod eas ejaculatur , prout in praecedentibus fuse assertum est , ex diversis partibus heterogeneis constabit ?
Ad haec , quia tales admirabiles et manifestissimae generationes , mutationes , alterationes , condensationes , rarefactiones , coitiones , diductiones , imo motus locales corporum , ac rerum materiarumque ex ipso sole ejectarum evaporatarumque , pene continenter , ad instar nubium ac meteororum sublunarium ex terra promanantium , peragi videmus ; nonne clare ex eo evincitur , solem habere suam atmosphaeram , in eaque dari , pro virtutis suae indole , generationes et corruptiones rebus sublunaribus haud dissimiles rarioresque ?
imo , nonnunquam longe frequentiores , et insigniores accidere ( si praesertim observationes macularum a Scheinero nobisque habitas exact examinaveris ) quam prope hanc terram unquam possint ?
' ' And again , when speaking of the sun 's body : ` ` Atque ita hic liquor igneus ( ut sic loqui liceat ) est quasi vastissimum luminum pelagus et mare igneum , quod suos habet abyssus , occultos meatus , voragines atque vortices ; quod , ad instar maris nostri , perpetuis fluctuum quibusdam voluminibus agitatur , et suo modo evaporationes et exhalationes jugiter evomit atque exhalat : eoque magis aut minus , quo magis vel minus materia ista in visceribus ejus , atque intimis recessibus , igneum llud pelagus , illiusque fluctus commoventur ac concitantur .
' ' But all that we here find , however plausible and ingenious , can be regarded only as conjecture .
It does not appear , that any who have followed HEVELIUS have met with more success .
Their observations seem not to differ from his in any remarkable circumstance ; nor do we find , that their inferences from them , although sometimes different , have any better pretensions to the truth .
The many strange and variable circumstances of the spots , which were disco discoverable from a minute observation , still remained unaccountable ; and we often find them at a loss , in framing any hypothesis , which could fully satisfy the mind concerning them .
In process of time , astronomers began to withdraw their attention from a subject , which remained so dark and perplexing , and , for many years , all researches of this sort have been , in a great measure , laid aside .
Chance , or a happy concurrence of circumstances , hath sometimes effected more , than could have been expected from the most promising measures : a remark which , it is hoped , will , in some degree , be found justified in the sequel of this paper .
The observations upon the solar spots , which I now proceed to relate , appear to be totally different from any hitherto to be found , and such as seem to open a new and curious field of speculation into the whole of this subject .
Astronomers will remember , that a spot of an extraordinary size appeared upon the sun , in the month of November 1769 .
The first notice , I had of it , was by a letter from a friend at London , but the weather continued dark and cloudy for some days after ; at length , on the 22d day , I had a view of the sun through an excellent Gregorian telescope , of 26 inch focus , which magnified 112 times .
I then beheld the spot , which at that time was not far from the sun 's western limb , and below his equatorial diameter .
The atmosphere being now very clear , and free from all tremor and undulation , it was pleasant to see the nucleus of the spot , and the shady zone or umbra which surrounded it , so very distinct .
It being afternoon when I first got sight of it , I had not an opportunity of observing it long that day .
Next day being the 23d , I had a curiosity to see it again , and so repaired to my telescope , in order to examine , if any alterations , in the size and figure , had taken place since last observation .
The air was still favourable , and I again saw the spot , it having its nucleus and umbra very sharply defined .
I now found however a remarkable change ; for the umbra , which before was equally broad all round the nucleus , appeared much contracted on that part which lay towards the center of the disc , whilst the other parts of it remained nearly of their former dimensions .
This change of the umbra seemed somewhat extraordinary , as it was the very reverse of what I expected from the motion of the spot towards the limb .
But next day , at 10 o'clock , I had another observation , and discovered changes , which were still more unexpected .
The distance of the spot from the limb was now about 24~ .
By this time , the contracted side of the umbra above mentioned had entirely vanished ; and the figure of the nucleus was now remarkably changed , from what it had been the preceding day .
This alteration of the figure appeared evidently to have taken place upon that side which had now lost the umbra , the breadth of the nucleus being thereby more suddenly impaired than it ought to have been , by the motion of the spot across the disc .
Fig. 1 , 2 , [ T A B. I. ] represent the appearance which the spot had on the 23d and 24th days .
Regarding these circumstances as new , I began to consider , what might be the cause of them .
One of two things seemed necessarily to be the case ; either , that they were owing to some physical alteration or wasting of the spot , and of that part of it where the deficiency of the umbra was observed ; or else , that they were owing to the nearer approach of the spot to the limb , by the sun 's rotation on his axis .
The last of these two ideas had no sooner struck me , than I began to suspect , that the central part , or nucleus of this spot , was beneath the level of the sun 's spherical surface ; and that the shady zone or umbra , which surrounded it , might be nothing else but the shelving sides of the luminous matter of the sun , reaching from his surface , in every direction , down to the nucleus : for , upon this supposition , I perceived , that a just account could be given of the changes , of the umbra and of the figure of the nucleus , above ~ .
The opinion therefore , which I ventured to form from what I had seen this day , was , that this spot might , probably , be a vast EXCAVATION in the luminous matter of the sun ; the nucleus , commonly so called , being the bottom , and the umbra the shelving sides of the excavation : and , moreover , that the umbra , next the center of the disc , although out of my view , did still however exist , and was rendered invisible by its present position only ; and further , that the sudden alterations , now discernible in the figure of the nucleus , were occasioned by some part of it also being hid , by the interposition Suns Eastern .
Limb .
5 34 ~ ~ Philos. Trans. Vol. LXIV .
Tab.1.p.8 .
12 ~ No. 1 .
Great Spot Nov. 23 .
1769 .
2 ... 24 .
3 ... Dec~ 11 .
for the second time .
4 ... 12 ~ position of the edge of the excavation , between the nucleus and the eye .
These views , which now presented themselves , I remember to have communicated , that afternoon , to my son ; when I then told him , that , if they were well founded , there would be room to verify them , if the spot should again return upon the opposite side of the disc .
I was however uncertain , if it would last so long upon the sun 's body , as to be again visible after the time of half a revolution ; a circumstance which I wished to take place , as I was aware , that my present observations might justly be deemed insufficient , for establishing so singular an opinion concerning the nature of this spot ; and that , notwithstanding all which I had seen , we might still imagine , that these changes were produced by certain physical alterations of the spot itself .
These considerations made me attentively wait its return .
At last , on December 11th , I again discovered it , on the opposite side of the disc , it having by that time advanced a little way from the eastern limb , being distant from it 1~ 30~ .
And now I could only perceive three sides of the umbra , namely , the upper and under sides , and that towards the limb , which was the side that formerly had vanished .
The side towards the center of the disc was not as yet visible ; but I concluded , upon the same grounds as formerly , that it was hid from my sight , by its averted position only , and that , after the spot had advanced a little further , it would make its appearance .
Accordingly , the next day , being December 12th , at ten o ' clock , it came into view , and I saw it distinctly , though narrower than the other sides .
After this , my observations were interrupted , by unfavourable weather , till the 17th , when the spot had passed the center of the disc , the umbra now appearing to surround the nucleus equally .
Fig. 3 , 4 , and 5 , represent the spot , as it appeared on December 11th , 12th , and 17th , when it came upon the disc for the second time .
All the foregoing appearances , when taken together , and when duly considered , seem to prove in the most convincing manner , that the nucleus of this spot was considerably beneath the level of the sun 's spherical surface .
The next thing , which I took into consideration , was to think of some means , whereby I could form an estimate of its depth .
At the time of the observation I had on December 12th , I had remarked , that the breadth of the side of the umbra , next the limb , was about 14~ ; but , for determining the point in question , it was also requisite , to know the inclination of the shelving side of the umbra to the sun 's spherical surface .
And here it occurred , that , in the case of a large spot , this would in some measure , be deduced from observation .
For , at the time when the side of the umbra is just hid , or begins first to come in view , it is evident , that a line joining the eye and its observed edge , or uppermost limit , coincides with the plane of its declivity .
By measuring therefore the distance of the edge from the limb , when this change takes place , and by representing it by a projection , the inclination or declivity in some measure may be ascertained .
For in fig. 5 .
[ T A B. II .
] let ILDK be a portion of the sun 's limb , and ABCDa section of the spot , SL the sun 's semidiameter , LG the observed distance from the limb , when the side of the umbra changes , then will the plane of the umbra , C D , coincide with the line , ED G , drawn perpendicular to S L , at the point G. Let FH be a tangent to the limb , at the point D , and join S D. Since G L , the versed sine of the angle LS D , is given by observation , that angle is given ; which , by the figure , is equal to FD E , or GD H ; which angle is therefore given , and is the angle of inclination of the plane of the umbra to the sun 's spherical surface .
In the small triangle therefore CM D , which may be considered as rectangular , the angle MDC is given , and the side D C , equal to A B , is given nearly , by observation ; therefore the side MC is given , which may be regarded as the depth of the nucleus , without any material error .
I had not an opportunity , in the course of the foregoing observations , to measure the distance G L , not having seen the spot , at the time when either of the sides of the umbra changed .
It is however certain , that , when the spot came upon the disc for the second time , this change happened sometime in the night between the 11th and 12th of December ; and I judge that the distance of the plane of the umbra , when in a line with the eye , must have been about 1~ 35~from the sun 's eastern limb ; from which we may safely conclude , that the nucleus of the spot was , at that time , not less than a semidiameter of the earth , below the level of the sun 's spherical surface , and made the bottom of an amaC 2 zing zing cavity , from the surface downwards , whose other dimensions were of much greater extent .
Being thus persuaded of the depression of this great spot below the surface , I immediately set about examining smaller ones , in order to discover if they were of the same kind .
With this view , I began a course of observations , that from them I might either make the inference universal , or limit it , as the phenomenon should point out .
I was not long engaged in this pursuit , before I perceived in them the same changes of their umbrae , which have been described above at so much length .
This was manifest in spots of any considerable size , when the air was favourable , and the telescope well adjusted for distinct vision .
The first , which I saw undergo this change upon its near approach to the limb ; was on January 17th , 1770 , as represented in Fig. 1 .
[ T A B. II .
] The figures 2 , 3 , 4 , in this plate , and 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , [ T A B. III .
] are so many other instances taken from the register of the observations at that time .
But , as this appearance , of the umbra changing , is evident from a bare inspection of the figures , we have omitted any unnecessary description of them .
These eight cases are taken out from above 40 others of the same kind ; and in them all , the nuclei were in the middle of the umbrae , before their approach to the limb .
It may be remarked , that in fig. 2 .
[ T A B. II .
] the same spot c traversed the disc and had its umbra changed , both in the coming on and going off .
In general , we have found that the umbra thus changes , when a spot is about a minute distant from the limb , at a medium .
Philos. Trans. Vol. LXIV .
Tab. II .
p.12 .
Fig. 1 .
1770 .
Fig. 2 .
1770 .
cc Ecliptic .
~~ c th th 8 .
9 .
~ ~ May ~ ~ 21 .
~ ~ 7th Jan. ~ 11th .
Fig.3 .
Fig.4 .
~ .
~ .
g e~ June.5th .
~ d Augst .
6th .
~f 5th .
~ June 6th .
Augst .
I LGS H A B MC D Fig.5 EFK From all these observations , may we not safely conclude , that every spot consisting of a nucleus and surrounding umbra , as defined by SCHEINER and HEVELIU S , is of the same kind with those above described ?
But as , in researches of this sort , we can never be too cautious in making a general conclusion , so I would humbly recommend these observations to every lover of the subject , to those especially who are provided with large and good telescopes ; for , without this advantage , I have found by repeated trials , that I could not discern the minute changes of the small spots .
In the course of the foregoing observations , I had occasion to remark , five different times , another extraordinary circumstance of the spots , which I have not seen mentioned , by any one who has written upon the subject .
It consists of changes , which seem to arise from a disturbing force , when one spot breaks out in the neighbourhood of another .
The first case of this sort which I met with , was on Nov. 9th , 1770 , when the umbra of the spot m , fig. 1 .
[ T A B. IV .
] although a great way from the limb , was deficient towards the right hand , at which side , and very near it , there lay another spot much smaller .
In like manner , the two spots n and o , fig. 2 .
[ T A B. IV .
] which lay very near one another , had each of them that side of its umbra , which faced the other , taken away .
But it was remarkable , that , three days after , the spot o had nearly vanished , when the side of the umbra of the spot n , which faced it , began now to dilate .
In fig. 3 , the spot p , had its umbra flattened upon opposite sides , by three small spots on one hand , and one upon the other .
Again , in fig. 4 , the two spots q , r , had their umbrae deficient , by the intervention of some small spots , that lay between them .
Now it must here be particularly remarked , that though a spot , when undisturbed , will , when near the sun 's limb , exhibit the change of the umbra formerly mentioned , yet it is plain , that a case may now and then occur , when this change will be counteracted , by means of the phenomenon which we have just now described .
For if we should suppose , for example , the spot m , fig. 1 .
TA B. IV .
to have been on November 9th , near the western limb , it is evident , that we should have formed a different judgment concerning the change of the umbra .
And accordingly , in the course of the observations formerly mentioned , I in reality met with three cases , when this change did not take place .
I am sensible , that it may be thought strange , that none of the observers , who had looked at the solar spots with so much attention , should ever have taken notice of the gradual changes above described .
This partly may be accounted for from the following considerations .
We have already seen , that conjectures , concerning the nature of the fun , were early indulged in the course of this inquiry .
His body was thought to be an immense globe of fire , which was for ever raging with the most servant heat .
Hence the first observers , reflecting upon the perpetual generation , changes , and decay of the spots , and that through so wide an extent of his surface , very naturally imagined , that they could consist of nothing but smoke and grosser oxhalations , or such transient and perishable materials .
This hypothesis had at least the air of being supported by a very plausible analogy .
The minds of men being carried away by such prepossessions , it would less readily occur , that successful observations were only to be made , by an accurate and critical attention to those minute changes , which the spots sometimes undergo .
But what would still more conduce to this oversight , was the method , which most of them followed , in making their observations .
This was by the camera obscura , which both SCHEINER and HEVELIUS often used , and which we find greatly extolled by them , and described at great length in their writings .
But spots , when seen in this way , have nothing of that distinctness , which is so remarkable , and so pleasing , when they are viewed directly through a good telescope armed with an helioscope , or glass properly smoaked .
PART II .
IT appears then that the solar spots are immente excavations in the body of the sun ; and that what hitherto hath been called the nucleus is the bottom , and what hath been called the umbra the sloping sides of the excavation .
It also appears , that the solar matter , at the depth of the nucleus , does not emit light , or emits so little , as to appear dark compared to that resplendent substance at the surface ; that this beauteous substance is at the surface , most fulgid ; and when any of it is , seen below the general level , forming the sides of an excavation , that then its lustre is somehow impaired , so as to give the appearance of a surrounding umbra .
Here our induction ends .
To proceed further would be to carry it beyond its true limits , and to intermix with conclusions , which are certain and manifest , the suggestion of hypotheses , which at best are precarious and liable to error .
But from what we have now seen , many curious speculations do naturally present themselves .
By what mysterious process is it , that those astonishing excavations are at first produced ?
What is the nature of that shining substance , which is thereby perpetually disturbed ?
To what are we to ascribe the darkness of the nucleus , and the diminished lustre of the umbra ?
And what conceptions are we to form of the many strange changes , and at length of the final decay of all these appearances , whereby those regions of the sun , that were so hurt and disfigured , again undergo a renovation ?
Philos. Trans. Vol. LXIV Tab. III .
p.16 .
Fig. 1 .
Fig. 2 .
1770 .
1770 .
ii h 9th Nov.r 7.th ~ .
Fig. 3 .
Fig. 4 .
1770 .
1771 .
~ Jany .
27th h 7th Dec.r We often find SCHEINER and HEVELIUS mentioning many things concerning the spots , which appeared to them very inexplicable .
HEVELIUS , when speaking of the vast number of spots which break out upon the sun , and of the prodigious size of some of them , admires how from his single body so much matter , exhalations , &amp;c. could be generated , as in any degree to be adequate to so many and so vast phenomenon .
` ` Nuclei autem , ( says he , Cometograph .
p. 401 ) macularum scilicet parts densiores , saepius unam partem centesimam , imo quinquagesimam , de solari diametro occupant ; sic , ut paucis dicam , immania ct admiranda sunt corpora .
Adhaec , intellectum humanum fere superat , quomodo unquam , ex unico isto corpore solis , tantum materiae , totque exhalationes vaporesque erumpere ac produci queant , quo talia vastissima phenomenon procreari possint .
' ' Again , SCHEINER , when speaking of that property of the spots , where a large nucleus is often divided into two or more nuclei , seems greatly puzzled to account for it .
Sch .
Rosa Ursina , p. 498 , says : ` ` Ex uno saepe magno nucleo fiunt duo , tres , pluresve , non locali partium ipsius distractione , sed intervallorum nescio qua exinanitione .
Manent enim illorum centra inter se aequaliter dissita .
' ' Many instances of this sort could be brought ; and indeed , considering the contrariety , betwixt any hypothesis they had formed , and what would now seem to be the real condition of the phenomenon , it is no wonder that such difficulties should occur .
Every theory , how ingenious soever , which is founded upon a misapprehension of things , is apt to be pressed with many difficulties ; and whenever palpable contradictions appear , they may be regarded certainly as proofs of our having fallen into error .
Upon this principle , I think , we might freely have rejected any theories , hitherto entertained , concerning the solar spots , tho ' their falsity had not become manifest from more enlarged experience and observation .
It must indeed be acknowledged , that it is very disadvantageous to science , to indulge much in hypotheses , the truth being rarely hit upon in this way , and very often missed .
Sometimes , however , it may not be improper , to throw out hints and conjectures , when we can attain to nothing better , provided we are at due pains to distinguish betwixt such and that real knowledge , which we derive , by strict induction , from incontestable principles .
The best way therefore , of preserving so proper and necessary a distinction , will be to propose what further remains to be said , upon this subject , in the form of queries ; because , however plausible they may appear , they are at best but matter of conjecture .
Hints , when propounded in this way , are freed from the danger of making us rest in any error , whilst , sooner or later , they may become helps in leading us to a right understanding of the subject .
The queries which we shall proceed to make , are chiefly founded upon the following phenomenon of the spots , as described by Scheiner and Hevelius .
1 .
Every spot which hath a nucleus , hath also an umbra surrounding it .
Vid. Scheiner , p. 496 .
Have .
p. 409 .
349 .
2 .
The boundary betwixt the nucleus and umbra is always distinct and well defined .
Vid. Scheiner , p. 497 .
3 .
The increase of a spot is gradual , the breadth of the nucleus and umbra dilating at the same time .
Vid. Scheiner , p. 491 , &amp;c. 4 .
In like manner the decrease of a spot is gradual , the breadth of the nucleus and umbra contracting at the same time .
Sch .
p. 491 .
498 .
5 .
The exterior boundary of the umbra never consists of sharp angles , but is always curvilinear , how irregular soever the out-line of the nucleus may be .
Sch .
511 .
6 .
The nucleus of a spot , whilst on the decrease , in many cases changes its figure , by the umbra encroaching irregularly upon it ; insomuch that , in a small space of time , new encroachments are discernible , whereby the boundary , betwixt the nucleus and umbra , is perpetually varying .
Sch .
514 .
Have .
412 .
7 .
It often happens , by these encroachments , that the nucleus of a spot is divided into two or more nuclei .
Sch .
498 .
8 .
The nuclei of spots vanish sooner than the umbrae .
Many instances of this sort are to be seen in Hevelius ' plates , and the same is affirmed by Mr. Derham in The Philosophical Transactions .
9 .
Small umbrae are frequently seen without nuclei .
Sch .
p. 497 .
10 .
An umbra of any considerable size is seldom seen without a nucleus in the middle of it .
Ibid. 11 .
When a spot , which consisted of a nucleus and umbra , is about to disappear , if it is not sucD 2 ceeded ceeded by a facula , or more fulgid appearance , the place , which it occupied , is soon after not distinguishable from any other part of the sun 's surface .
This is certain from the accounts of all observers .
QUERIES and CONJECTURE S , tending to explain the above properties of the spots .
When we consider , that the solar spots , some of whose properties have just now been enumerated , are so many vast excavations in the luminous substance of the sun , and that , wherever such excavations are found , we always discern dark and obscure parts situated below ; is it not reasonable to think , that the great and stupendous body of the sun is made up of two kinds of matter , very different in their qualities ; that by far the greater part is solid and dark ; and that this immense and dark globe is encompassed with a thin covering of that resplendent substance , from which the sun would seem to derive the whole of his vivifying heat and energy ?
And will not this hypothesis help to account for many phenomenon of the spots in a satisfactory manner ?
For if a portion of this luminous covering were by any means displaced , so as to expose to our view a part of the internal dark globe , would not this give the appearance of a spot ?
In this case , would not that part of the dark globe , which is now laid bare , correspond to the nucleus , and the sloping sides of the luminous matter to the umbra ?
And is not this consonant to that property of a spot mentioned in the first article ; for would it not hence follow , that every spot , having a nucleus , should also have an umbra surrounding that nucleus , a natural account being at the same time suggested , for the boundary betwixt the nucleus and umbra being always distinctly defined , as mentioned in the second article .
Although we may never have a competent notion of the nature and qualities of this shining and resplendent substance , or of the means by which the excavations in it are formed ; we however discover , in their production , the agency of some mighty , though unknown , cause , which is there often exerting itself .
Although we manifestly behold its effects , yet the mode of its operations may perhaps remain unsearchable .
But if we were here to venture a conjecture , might we not suppose , that the luminous matter is so disturbed , and the excavations in it occasioned , by the working of some sort of elastic vapour , which is generated within the dark globe ?
And might not this elastic principle , by its expansion , swell into such a volume , as to reach up to the surface of the luminous matter , which would thereby be separated and laid aside in all directions ?
And for as much as there is no regularity in the time of a spot 's enlarging , compared to the time of its decreasing , some enlarging quickly , and decreasing slowly , and vice versa , may we not imagine , that this is owing to the duration and quantity of the elastic principle now mentioned ?
and in general , may we not from hence form some idea of the production and subsequent enlargement of a spot , as mentioned in the 3d article ?
But to proceed .
As we know , from experience , that the spots are of a transient nature , not lasting upon the sun for a long space of time , does it not seem reasonable to think , that their gradual decrease , as mentioned in article 4th , is occasioned by the luminous matter encroaching again upon that part of the dark globe , which had been uncovered ?
And from this may we not infer , that the luminous matter gravitates , and is in some degree fluid ; for thereby would it not have a tendency to flow down , in all directions , and encroach , so as at last to cover the nucleus ?
And do not these things appear further probable , when we reflect upon that uniform inclination , which the sides of the umbra , or excavation , have to the external surface of the sun 's body ?
For does not this indicate a fluid sort of matter gradually yielding to the force of gravity ?
And again , is not this notion further supported , when we consider the property mentioned in the 5th article , namely , that the exterior boundary of the umbra never consists of sharp angles or turnings , but is always curvilinear , and , most frequently , of a round form : for we know , that this boundary is nothing else but the lip of the excavation , which , on supposition that the luminous matter possesses some degree of fluidity , will not be disposed , either in enlarging or contracting , to become irregular by sudden or sharp turnings ?
Upon supposition that the surface of the dark globe of the sun is smooth and level , it may be urged , that the nucleus of a spot , whilst upon the decrease , should , according to the present view of things , always acquire a figure , at least nearly , circular , cular , and that the luminous matter , continuing to flow down on all sides by an equal gravity , should so encroach upon the nucleus , as to make it retain that figure , till at last it be entirely overflowed .
But this not being the case , and because it most frequently happens , that the encroachments of the umbra upon the nucleus are extremely variable , as mentioned in the 6th article , may we not from this infer , that the surface of the internal dark globe of the sun , is by no means smooth and level , but on the contrary very irregular , for , upon this supposition , if for example the area of the nucleus of a great spot were so diversified by mountains and vallies , would not the encroachments of the lnminous matter be consequently irregular ; and , aucording as it was more or less retarded or accelerated , at different places , by being contiguous to prominencies or hollows , would not all the alterations in the figure of the decreasing nucleus , how variable soever , be thus plainly accounted for ?
and because it often happens , that the nucleus of a spot , whilst on the decrease , is gradually cut in pieces by a luminous zone or zones , which wander across it , as mentioned in the 7th article , does not this look like the gradual flowing in of the luminous matter , as it were , into deep channels , which would thus appear to abound in the surface of the sun 's dark body ?
If we reflect upon the irregularities , which are upon the surface of this earth , and upon the enormous mountains and cavities , which are in the moon , may we not , from such analogy , imagine , that there may be the like , or much greater , irregularities in the surface of the sun ?
I may here take notice of a curious instance of a nucleus being divided into two parts , which fell under my own observation .
On October 8th , 1770 , the spot s , TA B. IV .
had a small jutting in of the luminous matter , upon the opposite sides of the nucleus , which , by the 10th day , had advanced contrary ways , so as to meet , by which means the nucleus was now divided into two parts , as represented by fig. t. It was here very remarkable , that the parts of the umbra opposite to this cut in the nucleus , were dilated as in fig. t. May not this dilatation have been occasioned by the rapid flowing in of the luminous matter into the deep channel below ?
Is not the property mentioned in the 8th article , namely , that the nucleus of a spot vanishes sooner than the umbra , also agreeable to the present views ?
from this state of the phenomenon , we suppose that that part of the sun 's dark body , which had been uncovered and exposed to our view , when the spot first broke out , is now again just overflowed by the gradual inundation of the luminous matter .
But , after the nucleus thus disappears , may there not however , in many cases , be still left a cavity in the luminous matter , large enough to be perceived ?
and will not this cavity , so long as it continues , give the appearance of a small undivided umbra ?
and will not this umbra still be perceivable , till the luminous matter , by continuing to flow in , has filled up the cavity ?
after which , will not the place of the umbra acquire the same lustre with the rest of the sun 's surface , and thus will not all traces of the spot Philos. Trans. ~ .
LXIV .
Tab. IV .
p.24 .
Fig.1 .
1770 .
Fig.2 .
1770 .
~ .
m non ~ .
7th Fig.3 .
1771 .
Fig.4 .
1771 .
qr ~ April.22d .
~ .
t s vanish from his body ?
And do not the particulars mentioned in the 9th 10th and 11th articles seem agreeable to what is now said ?
Both SCHEINER and HEVELIUS seem to think , that spots sometimes alter their place upon the disc , not only by the sun 's rotation round his axis , but also by a motion , which they impute to the spots themselves .
This I could never observe .
It is very true , that when a number of small spots lye near one another , there may be from time to time a change of their relative situation , but it is plain , that this may proceed entirely from some of them increasing and others diminishing irregularly .
But what would further contribute towards forming a judgment of this kind is , the apparent alteration of the relative place , which must arise from the motion across the disc on a spherical surface ; a circumstance which I am uncertain if it has been sufficiently attended to .
What has been advanced , in the course of the foregoing queries , may perhaps be rendered still more probable , by considering the observations related in the first part of this paper , concerning the changes which are made upon the figure of a spot , when another breaks out in its neighbourhood ; and which seem to arise from a disturbing force .
For , from the cases there laid down , would it not appear , that when a spot is breaking out , the luminous matter is then forced , in all directions , from the nucleus , and is affected much in the same manner , as it would be , were it a fluid matter encompassing the sun 's dark body ?
As to the particular nature and qualities of this luminous matter , we have been sometimes apt to imagine , that it cannot well be any very ponderous fluid , but that it rather must resemble as to its consistence a very dense and thick fog , which broods on the surface of the sun 's dark body .
How far will this idea tend to facilitate our conceptions of the various phenomenon of the spots above described ?
It has been gathered from many observations , that the time which the spots take to traverse the whole disc , is nearly equal to the time that they are hid by being on the opposite surface .
It is plain , that the time of their appearing upon the disc must be some small matter shorter than that of their being hid behind it , on account of our not seeing a complete hemisphere of the sun .
But further , it must now be considered , that when a spot just enters the disc , the part , which is first visible , is the farthest umbra , by which time the spot has really advanced a whole diameter of itself upon the disc .
And again , when the same spot goes off the disc , it is evident , that the part , which is last visible , is then the farthest umbra , on which account the continuance of the spot upon the disc will be shortened by an interval of time , which corresponds nearly to the whole breadth of it .
This , as well as the other appearances , described in the first part of this paper , concerning the change of the umbra and figure of the nucleus , when spots approach the limb , are all well illustrated , by making in a sphere , an excavation similar to what we have described , the bottom of which may be painted black to represent the nucleus , and the sloping sides shaded , if the sphere be of a light colour .
According to the view of things given in the foregoing queries , there would seem to be something very extraordinary in the dark and unignited state of the great internal globe of the sun .
Does not this seem to indicate , that the luminous matter , which encompasses it , derives not its splendor from any intensity of heat ?
For , if this were the case , would not the parts underneath , which would be perpetually in contact with that glowing matter , be heated to such a degree , as to become luminous and bright ?
At the same time it must be confessed , that although the internal globe was in reality much ignited , yet when any part of it , forming the nucleus of a spot , is exposed to our view , and is seen in competition with a substance of such amazing splendor , it is no wonder , that an inferior degree of light should , in these circumstances , be unperceivable .
In order to obtain some knowledge of this point , I think an experiment might be tried , if we had an opportunity of a very large spot , by making a contrivance in the eye-piece of a telescope , whereby an observer could look at the nucleus alone with the naked eye , without being in danger of light coming from any other part of the sun .
In this case , if the observer found no greater splendor , than what might be expected from a planet very near the sun , and illumined by as much of his surface as corresponds to the spots umbra , we might reasonably conclude , that the solar matter , at the depth of the nucleus , is in reality not ignited .
But , from the nature of the thing , doth there seem any necessity for thinking , that there prevails there any such raging and fervent heat , as many have imagined ?
It is proper here , to attend to the distinction betwixt this shining matter of the sun , and the rays of light which proceed from it .
It may perhaps be thought , that the re-action of the rays upon the matter , at their emission , may be productive of a violent degree of heat .
But whoever would urge this argument , in favour of the sun being intensely heated , as arising from the nature of the thing , ought to consider , that all polished bodies are less and less disposed to be heated , by the action of the rays of light , in proportion as their surfaces are more polished , and as their powers of reflection are brought to a greater degree of perfection .
And is there not a strong analogy betwixt the re-action of light upon matter , in cases where it is reflected , and in cases where it is emitted ?
It may perhaps be expected , that , in this paper , mention should be made of the other appearances , that are discernible upon the surface of the sun , besides the spots properly so called ; I mean the faculae , luculi , &amp;c. as described by Scheiner and Hevelius .
But all these phenomenon seem to be so different from any thing we have considered , and so unconnected with the present discovery , that little assistance can be brought from that quarter towards a right conception of them .
As to the faculae , or brighter parts of the sun , we are at a loss for their origin .
It may in general be remarked , that although we have obtained an experimental rimental proof , that the luminous matter acquires some degree of shade , when forming the sides of an excavation , yet it is uncertain , if this be merely the effect of position , and much more so , if any different modification of position could ever dispose it to put on a brighter or more fulgid appearance .
Yet , after all , may not these faculae , &amp;c. depend upon some irregularities in the bright surface of the sun ?
For may not the luminous matter , by being agitated by the same eause to which the spots owe their origin , though in a less degree , have its surface perpetually disturbed , and made irregular , and thus give occasion to a variety of light and shade , sufficient perhaps to produce the phenomenon under consideration ?
And does not this conjecture receive further confirmation , when we consider , that these faculae , &amp;c. are found only in that zodiac , within which the spots appear , and that they always abound most in the neighbourhood of the spots themselves , or where spots recently have been ?
For in those undisturbed regions of the sun which lye towards his poles , and where no spots ever appear , and which SCHEINER calls the plagae aequabiles , we never discover any diversity of appearance .
Thus we have endeavoured to give a general idea of the production , changes , and decay of the solar spots , considered as excavations in the body of the sun ; a thing which seems to be established from the observations described in the first part of this paper .
But concerning the nature of that mighty agency , which occasions those amazing commotions in the luminous matter , or concerning ing the density , viscidity , and other qualities of this matter , or the manner in which it is disturbed in the middle zone only , and not at the polar regions , and many such other questions , I freely confess , that they far surpass my knowledge .
To conclude ; as what hath now been said may open a new field of inquiry into this subject , so a discussion of these curious points may , some time or other , fall to the share of abler me n , whose lone of philosophy may induce them to pursue so hoble an investigation .

