Received November 12 , 1767 .
XLIX .
An Account of some neutral Salts made with vegetable Acids , and with the Salt of Amber ; which shows that vegetable Acids differ from one another ; and that the Salt of Amber is an Acid of a particular kind , and not the same with that of Sea Salt , or of Vitriol , as alleged by many chemical authors .
By Donald Monro , M. D. Physician to His Majesty 's Army , and to Saint George 's Hospital .
F. R. S. Title read December 17 , 1767 .
THOUGH no substances have been more generally used , both for the preservation of health , and the cure of diseases , than vegetable acids , yet hitherto they have been examined with so little care , that it has been the common received opinion , that they were all nearly of the same nature , at least as to their chemical properties , and possessed nearly of the same virtues ; but the following account of neutral salts , made with these acids , and the fossil or mineral alkali , shows that they differ materially from one another .
1 But Read January 14 , 21 , Previous , however , to entering into the account of these salts , it will be proper to mention some few things relative to salts in general .
Simple salts are commonly divided into acid and alkaline .
The acid are reckoned four in number .
1 .
The vitriolic .
2 .
The nitrous .
3 .
The marine , or muriatic .
4 .
And the vegetable .
The alkaline three .
1 .
The vegetable , or that which is got from the ashes of most vegetable substances .
2 .
The fossil , or mineral , called likewise soda and natrum , which is got either by burning certain marine plants ; or from sea salt ; or in the bowels of the earth .
3 .
The volatile , which is got either by putrefaction , or by the force of fire , from most animal substances ; or by distillation from mustard seed , and some other particular vegetables .
The acid are distinguished from each other , by their taste , smell , and other properties , but principally by their forming different neutral salts with the same alkali .
And the alkaline are known likewise from one another , by their forming different neutral salts , when joined with the same acid .
Hence when we find acid , or alkaline salts , in different bodies , if we saturate each with the same alkali , or with the same acid , according as the original salt is of an acid , or of an alkaline nature , and find upon dissolving , evaporating , and crystallising the neutral salts , that they are all of the same kind , we conclude , that the original acid , or alkali , was the same in all ; but if we obtain different neutral salts from each , we conclude that the original acid , or alkali , was different in each .
If there are no more alkaline salts in nature , than the three already mentioned ; and if there were no more acids than four ; then the number of neutral salts would be confined to the twelve marked in Dr. Cullen 's Table ; but it will appear from the following experiments , that instead of one , there are many vegetable acids ; and that , therefore , the number of true neutral salts must be greatly multiplied * .
* Dr. Cullen 's Table of neutral Salts .
Acid Alkaline Neutral Salt Acid Alkaline Neutral Salt Vegetable Vitriolic Tartar Marine Vegetable Sal .
digest .
Sylvii Vitriolic Fossil Glauber Salt or Fossil Common Salt Volatile Vitriol .
Ammoniac Muriatic Volatile Common Ammoniac Vegetable Common Nitre Vegetable Regenerated Tartar Nitrous Fossil Cubic Nitre Vegetable Fossil Rochelle Salt Volatile Nitrous Ammoniac Volatile Spiritus Mindereri Dr. Vogel , Professor of chemistry in the university of Gottengen , in his Institutiones Chemiae , published in 1752 , gives a table of neutral salts , which comprehends the twelve mentioned by Dr. Cullen , with the addition of three or four more .
He seems to believe , that the acid of vitriol forms a different neutral salt with the pot-ash , and with the alkali procured from nitre .
He mentions three salts , made with the vegetable alkali Many chemists have affirmed , that the vitriolic is the only original acid in nature ; and that the nitrous and marine are only this acid changed into different forms by foreign mixtures ; and Dr. Boerhaave * , Vogel ~ , Macquer ~ , and most late chemists , seem to think , that as all trees , plants , and other vegetable substances , receive their nourishment from the bowels of the earth , therefore their acids are only some of the mineral changed into a different form by the vegetative process ; and that they all approached in their nature either to the vitriolic , the nitrous , or the marine : and as the neutral salts , produced from the mixture of the vegetable alkali , with vinegar , cream of tartar , and other common vegetable acids , have a good deal of the same external appearance , most chemists have concluded , that all vegetable acids were nearly of the same nature ; though some few have suspected , that they might be found to differ from one another , and to have different degrees of affinity , if they were examined with care ; and to confirm this , Dr. Vogel ~ tells us , that if some of the Rochelle salts be thrown into a decoction of tamarinds , the alkaline basis of the Rochelle salt will unite with the acid of the tamarinds , and the cream of tartar will be precipitated .
and vegetable acids ; to wit , with vinegar , crystals of tartar , and lemon ; and one with the native acid salt ( as he calls it ) of urine , and the volatile alkali , and one with the acid of tartar , and the volatile alkali .
* Boerhavii Element .
Chemiae , vol. I. 804 .
~ Vogel , Institut .
Chemiae , p. 215 .
sect. 468 .
Ed. II .
~ Macquer , Elemens de Chymie Theorique , chap .
xvi .
p. 240 .
~ Vogel , Institut .
Chemiae , p. 216 .
sect. 469 .
As I always suspected , from the taste and smell that vegetable acids differed materially from one another , and was the more confirmed in this opinion by the above experiment mentioned by Dr. Vogel , I began to consider whether some method might not be fallen upon to determine this question ; and , on recollecting , that the Rochelle salt * concreted into large solid crystals , which preserved their figure long , even in the open air , though the tartarus tartarisatus ~ always appeared in the form of a powdery foliated salt , and run very soon per deliquium , when exposed to the air , I imagined , that if we were to unite the fossil , or mineral alkali , with different vegetable acids , we should be able to obtain true neutral salts in form of regular crystals ; which would show how far these acids differed or approached to each other in their nature and properties ; and , upon trial , found that I had judged right ; for each particular acid almost yielded a neutral salt pecauliar to itself , of which I shall now give a particulr account , and shall range these salts under the following heads .
1 .
Of neutral salts formed with native vegetable acids .
2 .
Of neutral salts formed with fermented vegetable acids .
* The Rochelle salt is made with the crystals of tartar , and the fossil alkali .
~ The tartarus tartarisatus , with the crystals of tartar , and the salt of tartar ; so that the only difference between these two salts is , that the one is made with the fossil , and the other with the vegetable alkali .
3 .
Of neutral salts formed with distilled vegetable acids .
4 .
Of neutral salts formed with flowers of benzoin and salt of amber .
SEC T. I. Of neutral salts formed with native vegetable acids , and the fossil or mineral alkali .
EXPERIMENT I. With the acid of lemons .
The first experiment I made was with the acid of lemons ; six ounces of the juice saturated rather more than three drams of the fossil alkali ; and upon evaporating the liquor to a pellicle , and letting it stand for some days , I obtained a salt composed of a number of small crystals of irregular figures ; some appeared to be irregular squares , or rhomboidal ; others irregular pentagons ; others to have more sides ; but this general appearance was nearly what is represented at a. a. a. &amp;c. in TA B. XXIII .
fig. 1 .
They were mostly flat , and not above 1/ 8 or 1/ 1 0 of an inch thick ; though some few were somewhat of an oblong irregular cubical shape , if I may be allowed to use the expression .
Having observed that the figure of neutral salts , made with vegetable acids , varied sometimes , according as they were crystallised in larger or less quantity , I got a quart of lemon juice , and saturated it with about two ounces , and two drams of the fossil alkali .
Before adding the alkaline salt in this experiment , I tried the temperature of the lemon juice with one of Fahrenheit 's thermometers , and found that the quicksilver stood in the tube at 54 ; upon removing the thermometer , I immediately added the alkaline salt ; and as the solution was begun , I again put the thermometer into the liquor , and let it remain for above a minute , and the quicksilver sunk above one degree ; so that this acid generates cold in the time of its uniting with the fossil alkali , though the neutral salt , produced from their union , does not affect the thermometer in the time of its solution in water .
The appearance of the salt obtained in this crystallisation was very different from what it was in the former .
The whole was made up of an infinite number of chrystals , so small that one at first could scarce distinguish their figure ; but on examination part seemed to be of the same shape as the larger ones , got in the former process ; the others were very small oblong parallelograms , and they were every where interspersed with a number of small longish crystals , which in many places lay across each other , and formed a kind of lattice work .
The general appearance of this crystallisation is represented by b. b. &amp;c. in Tab. XXIII .
fig. 1 .
and that of some of the particular crystals by c. c. c. The taste of this salt is very mild , and rather pleasant , approaching a little to that of a very weak sea salt .
EXPERIMENT II .
With the acid of limes .
The lime is a fruit of the same genus as the lemon ; its acid is sharper , and has a more agreeable flavour .
From the near resemblance of these two fruits , one should have suspected that the neutral salt of both would have been almost the same ; but their appearance is somewhat different , though perhaps upon more accurate trials they may be found to have nearly the same virtues , and chemical properties .
The first experiment I made was with the juice of a dozen and a half of small limes ; and the neutral salt , produced from thence , was of the same shape , figure , and appearance , as the larger crystals obtained in the first experiment with the lemons ; only the crystals were much smaller , and such as represented by a. a. &amp;c. fig. 2 .
But having afterwards procured three dozen of larger and finer limes , I got from them near three times the quantity of juice I had in the former process ; and having saturated this with the alkali , evaporated and crystallised it , I obtained a salt very different in its appearance from the former ; though , in other respects , it seemed to be entirely of the same nature .
Its crystals were of the size , and somewhat of the appearance , of barley corns , or grains of wheat , as at c. c. c. ; some larger , some smaller ; and laid in an irregular manner , but so as to form a beautiful crystallisation , which is represented by b. b. b. fig. 2 .
They appeared , peared , at a little distance , to be roundish , but on examining narrowly , their sides were found to be made up of five or six flat surfaces ; and generally one end of each crystal was made up of two flattish sides , which rose like a wedge which did not come quite to a point , but left a small narrow surface between .
These chrystals , in the mouth , impress at first a very slight saltish , and somewhat sweetish cool taste ; which is by no means unpleasant , and resembles a good deal that of the salt of lemons .
They did not affect the thermometer in the time of their solution in water .
EXPERIMENTS III .
and IV .
With the acid of Sevill oranges , and of peaches .
It being late in the summer before I made any experiment with the juice of the Sevill oranges , I could get none of this fruit but what had been long kept and was shrivelled , in so much that a dozen and a half of the oranges did not yield more than half a pint of juice , which had lost a great deal of its acidity , and saturated but a very small quantity of the alkali ; and on crystallising I could obtain no other salt but a few very small cubical or square crystals , such as are represented by fig. 3 .
and similar to the salt got in an experiment I made with peaches , as may be seen in fig. 4 .
A saponaceous or mucous matter , with which these saturated juices abounded , seemed to prevent the crystallisation of the salts .
As both the juice of the orange , and of the peaches , was in small quantity , and not in the most proper state for yielding a neutral salt , these experiments ought to be repeated , before we can say what is the natural figure and appearance of the salts , that may be got by saturating the juices of these fruits with an alkali .
EXPERIMENT V. With the acid of currants .
A quart of the juice of white currants , ~~ ing saturated with about nine drams of the fossil alkali , and purified by repeated filtrations , was evaporated till a pellicle appeared ; being put into a cool place , and allowed to stand for two or three days , it yielded a number of small square flattish crystals , such as are represented by fig. 5 .
Many of them seemed to be exact squares , and in general they approached nearer to this figure , than the crystals of any of the other neutral salts I have hitherto met with .
This salt approached in its taste to that of the limes ; its crystals were hard and firm , and did not run per deliquium .
EXPERIMENT VI .
With the acid of gooseberries .
A quart of the juice of gooseberries , being treated in the same way , as that of the currants , yielded a neutral salt very different in its appearance , from any of those hitherto mentioned .
Its basis , or what adhered to the tea-cup , was made up of a number of very small roundish or squarish crystals ; which formed an incrustation thicker than a shilling ; from which grew up a number of very fine , thin , transparent plates , of irregular shapes ; they were narrower at the basis than above ; and in some measure might be compared to the scales of a small fish , or the wings of flies , set on their edges at a little distance from one another ; in some places the plates arose from the sides of others ; and in others they appeared somewhat like the fine leaves of very small plants .
In fig. 6 .
we have different views of this salt ; a. a. represents a piece of crystallised salt viewed from above ; b. b. a profile view of the thin plates standing on their basis ; c. c. the basis itself ; and the letters d. a view of the thin plates laid on their flat sides .
EXPERIMENT VII .
With the acid of apples .
Having got two dozen of codling apples , I cut them to pieces , put them into a large earthen vessel , and poured three quarts of water upon them ; and then dissolved above two ounces of the fossil alkaline salt in the water , and let them stand for six days ; on examining , I found the water to be nearly in a neutral state ; it did not ferment on the addition either of an acid or of an alkali .
I then filtered the liquor through paper , and evaporated it , till it was reduced to about five or six ounces , when it became thick , and a pellicle began to form on the surface .
I then set it in a cool place , to allow the salts to concrete .
After two days were elapsed , it was covered with a blueish variegated saline crust ; immediately below which was a clay coloured saline matter , which resembled wet earth or sand , that had been raised by small worms ; and this was interspersed every where with small flattish globules of the same sort of matter ; below this was a purplish jelly , interspersed with a whitish or ash coloured saline matter , formed into irregular longish flat plates , which looked more like a composition of salt and earth than a pure salt .
The appearance of this saline matter made me suspect , that it was mixed with some sort of oil , which the alkaline salt had extracted from the skins of the apples , which I had forgot to peel off before infusing them in water ; I therefore got a fresh parcel of codling apples , which I caused to be carefully peeled , and then treated them in the same manner as the former , and obtained the beautiful salt painted in fig. 7 .
which resembled a good deal the salt of the gooseberries ; being composed of a number of small roundish very delicate transparent plates , standing on one edge , on a fine saline crust , which adhered every where to the sides of the china bason ; and were intespersed with a grey coloured saline matter .
The crystals of this salt were in general rather smaller , rounder , and more of a size , than those of the gooseberry ; and I did not observe any rising from the sides of others as in it ; and they seemed to be disposed in a more regular uniform manner .
The letters a. a. &amp;c. represent pieces of this crystallisation viewed from above ; b. b. &amp;c. some of the fine plates laid on their side ; c. c. and e some of the ash coloured plates obtained in the first operation ; d. d. some of the brown clay coloured saline matter ; f. the flattish globules , which beset every where the inside of the pellicle , that was on the top .
After the crystallisation of the salt in this second process , the liquor which remained was poured into another small china bason ; and , on being evaporated , exhibited nearly the same appearances as had been observed in the first process .
EXPERIMENT VIII .
With the acid of wild sorrel .
In order to save the trouble of a tedious evaporation , by saturating this acid mixed with the other juices of the plant , I procured some of the essential salt of the wild sorrel , from Mr. Heineken , apothecary in Duke-street ; which I dissolved in boiling water , and saturated with the alkali ; and by evaporating obtained a beautiful pure white neutral salt , which is represented by fig. 8 ; a. a. shows a part of the crystallisation where the salt shot into longish crystals , resembling somewhat the small ones of nitre ; none of them exceeded the length of half an inch ; b. b. other pieces of the crystallisation , which had a different appearance ; c. c. a piece where it appeared like a small granulated salt ; d. d. some small roundish or square crystals , which adhered like a crust to the sides of the tea-cup ; e. e. e. detached crystals .
EXPERIMENT IX .
With the acid of tamarinds .
Having had a present of some tamarinds in pods , from Mr. Arch. Gloster , practitioner in physic in Antigua , I took out the pulp , and put about two pound of it into three quarts of water ; and then saturated its acid with the alkali , and , after filtrating the liquor , I evaporated it to the consistence of a syrup , and then put it into a cool place for 24 hours ; when I found that a crystallisation had actually taken place , I separated the salt from a thick sweetish liquor of the consistence of a syrup ; after it was dried , it had the appearance of a piece of common moss , made up of a number of small crystals disposed in an irregular manner , and mixed with viscid or saccharine juices .
The letters a. a. &amp;c. of fig. 9 .
show some pieces of this salt while it remained in this form .
As I suspected this salt to be still mixed with a viscid matter , I dissolved some of it in warm water , and crystallised it anew , when it had a very different appearance , for it had shot into an infinite number of very small crystals , which came every where from centres .
The length of these crystals did not exceed half an inch at most ; they were no thicker than horsehairs , or common white thread .
How many crystals shot from each centre I could not determine ; but , in many places , the crystallisation sation rose into small oblong , oval , or roundish tufts , made up of an infinite number of the small crystals that shot from the centre towards the circumference .
Some of the concentrated liquor having been accidentally left in a saucer , and on the sides of a tea cup at night , next morning the liquor in both vessels had shot every where into small fine crystals , that came like radii from a centre ; in some places they had completed the circle , in others only half , and in others only the two opposite quarters .
I treated three pound of East-India tamarinds , which I bought in a shop in Castle-Street , in the same manner ; only , after they were saturated with the alkali , and the liquor filtrated , it was set by for some weeks , and then filtered again before it was evaporated .
The people of whom I bought these tamarinds told me , that there was no sugar mixed with them ; and I believe what they said was true , for I obtained easily a very pure and fine salt from them .
Having at first carried the evaporation too far , as soon as the liquor was removed from the fire , it immediately began to concrete in form of a number of small circles on the surface of the liquor , which were successively succeeded by others , till the whole became one solid mass ; but on dissolving this mass in water , and evaporating only a little , and setting the liquor in a cool place to allow the salts to concrete , the crystallisation began on the surface of the liquor , in form of small circles or stars , and I obtained a salt in every respect similar to the former .
The general appearance of this salt is represented by b , b , in fig. 9 , and the different appearances in different parts of the crystallisation by c , c. EXPERIMENT X. With the acid of plums .
Having got a quantity of the larger sort of the green plums , I caused the stones to be picked out , and the plums to be bruised and put into a large china bowl ; I then poured about two quarts of water over them , and saturated their acid with the fossil alkali ; after they had stood 24 hours , I strained off the liquor , filtered , and evaporated it , till there remained only a few ounces , when it was set in a cool place for four days , at the end of which time I found that a crystallisation had taken place ; but , upon pouring off the superfluous liquor , I could not observe any general form of crystallisation ; the whole was made up of a number of very thin , flat , longish crystals , from about 1/ 12 to 3/ 4 of an inch long , and from 1/ 12 to 1/ 6 or 1/ 5 of an inch broad , of an irregular figure , laid without any particular form , and mixed every where with a mucous and black oily matter ; when dry , the whole appeared like a confused mass , where however the form of some of the crystals was to be observed , as is to be seen at a , a , in fig. 10 ; in some places the crystals seemed to be laid with their edges uppermost , and in others in a different manner , as at b , b , &amp;c. In order to know the regular and true form of the crystallisation of this salt , I separated a quantity of the purest from the large mass , dissolved it in boiling water , filtered it through paper , and crystallised it a second time in a tea cup .
It now appeared in a more regular form ; the crystallisation tion was divided into four roundish clumps , or clusters , which were separated or distinguished from each other by a furrow .
Each clump was made up of a number of very fine delicate plates laid edgeways , in somewhat of a regular manner ; and between them a number of others , where part of the flat sides were to be seen , and amongst them an infinite number of small rhomboidal or roundish crystals ; the clumps appeared , in miniature , in the sun , somewhat like to the lower part of the spread tail of a peacock .
The letters c , c , c , c , show the general form of the crystallisation , d , d , d , the form and shape of some of the separate crystals .
I treated another parcel of plums of the same kind in a different manner ; I saturated part of the liquor when fresh , and let it stand till a fermentation had taken place before I evaporated it ; and I let the other half stand till the fermentation was over before saturating it ; but the salt obtained from both , appeared nearly in the same form , though the number of clumps in this second crystallisation was only three : and in a third experiment the appearances were exactly similar , only the salt did not divide into clumps .
This salt tastes coolish on the tongue , but does not affect the thermometer , in the time of its solution in water .
In the present hard frost * some of the salt of plums , which had been dissolved in three or four times its own weight of water , and set by in a closet , crystallised anew .
The crystals were flat , thicker than a shilling , and most of them had six sides of unequal * N. B. The account of this last part of the experiment was given in to the Royal Society in the beginning of January 1768 .
lengths , as represented by h , h , in the figure marked large crystals of neutral salt of plums : where they were run together , their figures were most irregular as at i , i ; some few small ones were squares , as at k , k. Hence we see what a variety the different methods of crystallisation make in the figures of these salts .
EXPERIMENT XI .
With the acid of mulberries .
Three quarts of the pure juice of the mulberry being saturated with four ounces of the fossil alkali , filtered , clarified with the whites of eggs and evaporated , yielded a saline matter , mixed with a quantity of a mucus and oil ; which , on being purified as much as possible , by lying on a spongy brown paper , exhibited a very fine granulated salt almost like sea sand , in which no regular-formed crystals were to be observed .
Some of this salt being again dissolved in water , evaporated and crystallised a second time , appeared in the tea cup like a cake made up of the same sort of fine granulated salt as represented at a , a , fig. 11 ; and another parcel b , b , which was treated in the same manner , though it at first appeared rougher , and more of a crystalline form , yet on examination was found to be made up of the same sort of saline matter.-On taking out the cake , there were a few thin very small square crystals , such as those marked c , c , c , adhering to the bottom of the tea cup .
A small quantity of the saturated juice of the mulberries having been left by accident for ten or twelve days in different tea cups and china basons , there formed in each a number of figures , or sort of crystals , resembling somewhat the alphabet of the Chinese language , interspersed with a few small , oblong , parallelogram-shaped crystals , as at d , d , d. Three quarts more being saturated with the alkali , were allowed to stand for five or six weeks , and then filtered and evaporated to about seven or eight ounces ; the greater part of which was put into a stone bason , and about half an ounce into a small china bowl ; after ten days , the liquor in the bowl had shot into a number of small thin crystals , such as represented at e , e , e ; -and that in the stone bason into a fine pure salt made up of similar crystals , but thicker and larger , such as those at f , f , f. -These last are certainly the true last crystals of this salt .
EXPERIMENT XII .
With the acid of grapes .
A basket of grapes , which were brought to market for ripe , though many of them were still hard and sour , and not come to their full perfection , yielded three quarts of juice , which I filtered and saturated with two ounces and a dram of the fossil alkali:-after it had stood for a month to depurate , it was again filtered , and then clarified with the whites of eggs , and evaporated to about five ounces , when it became of the consistence of a syrup , and had somewhat of a sweetish taste .
It was then set in a cool place for two days to crystallise ; but , instead of forming any regular crystals , it concreted in form of a saline matter , resembling coarse loaf sugar , when it first concretes in a thick syrup ; some of which being dried on brown spongy paper , became very white , and seemed to be made up of long , very small crystals , no thicker than human hairs , and a saccharine matter .
From this appearance , I judged that the salt was still mixed with a quantity of viscid juices ; and therefore I diluted the whole with a quart of New River water , depurated it again with the whites of eggs , and evaporated it to four ounces , which I set in a cool place for eight days ; and then , on examining , I found that a crystallisation had taken place , and I obtained above a dram of a pure neutral salt , made up of small , square , and cubic , and small narrow oblong parallelogram crystals , resembling somewhat in appearance those got from the juice of the mulberry , only the crystals were less , as may be seen in fig. 12 .
After separating this salt , I set the remaining liquor again in a sand heat , and evaporated about half an ounce of it , and then put it for some days into a cool place ; and there formed a saline saccharine-like concretion , exactly similar to what was got in the first trial .
SECTION II .
Of neutral Salts formed with fermented vegetable Acids , and the fossil Alkali .
Having shown a variety of neutral salts made with native vegetable acids , we come next to take a view of those made with fermented acids , and shall begin with that produced from vinegar .
N.Salt of Lemons .
N.Salt of Limes .
N.Salt ~ Fig.1 .
Fig.2 .
b b ab bba b bcc baa cbb a a a cc c aa aa b ac N.Salt of apples .
N. Fig.7 .
N.Salt of Wild Sorrel .
Fig.8 .
aa e cc a ab ea bbb bc db ccc d dddd e f e Philos. Trans. Vol. LVII .
TAB. XXIII.p .
N. Sall of Peaches .
N. Salt of ~ Large Crystals of N. Salt of plums .
V. Salt of Sevil Orange .
Fig. 4 .
Fig. 10 .
2 .
Fig. 1 Fig. 3 .
i d d h i hia d hh hd kb kh h cc N. Salt of Currants .
Fig. 5 .
ac N. Salt of Plun c Fig. 10 .
a d dd cc N. Salt of ~ b N. Salt of Tamarinds .
bb Fig. 12 .
Fig. 9 .
bb b b a a b aecb aae N. Salt of acc Mullerries .
ab eb Fig. 11 .
af ffd dd ~ of ~ Fig. 6 .
b d aa cc bb c Plums .
~ .
~ of Grapes .
Fig. 12 .
of ~ EXPERIMENTS I. and II .
With common wine and distilled vinegar* .
The plain vinegar used , was said to be the best white wine vinegar that could be got ; and the distilled was said to be prepared from wine vinegar likewise .
I saturated a pint of each of these vinegars , with the pure alkali , evaporated them to a pellicle , and let them stand to crystallise .
From the distilled vinegar I obtained the salt represented by a , a , a , fig. 14 , Plate XXIV .
which in the evaporating glass appeared as you see it , resembling the figure of a sun in a fire-work .
Its crystals were a little twisted ; and upon taking them out , and examining them separately , they appeared like so many small crystals of glauber salt , as are represented by b , b , b.-On laying the evaporating glass on one side to allow the liquor to drain away , some thin flat square crystals , such as are represented by c , c , c , formed on the sides of the glass .
And what is very particular with regard to this salt is , that , on dissolving some of the crystals , resembling those of glauber salt , in pure water , and fully saturating the water with the salt , in some days there formed a number of crystals very different in figure and appearance from the former ; be* The neutral salt with vinegar I find mentioned , but not described , in a chemical dictionary published at Paris in the year 1766.-All that is said of it is , that it is a salt which crystallises easily , but is little known .
See the articles ALKALI MINERAL , SEL NEUTRE , and VINAIGRE .
ing some of them squares , others longish parallelograms , others irregular pentagons , and some with six sides ; some were flat , and from 1/ 12 to 1/ 5 , or 1/ 4 of an inch thick ; others appeared somewhat roundish , or oval , but the sides were made up of flat surfaces , as are represented by the letters d , d , d , &amp;c. I do not remember to have seen such a variety of shapes and figures in any other salt ; and I cannot account for the great difference of appearance in the first and second crystallisation in any other way , than from the liquor in the first crystallisation having been evaporated to a pellicle , and being very highly impregnated with the salt , the crystals began to shoot at once in every part of it , so that they had not room to extend in breadth , and to form themselves into various shapes , as in the second process , where the liquor was not so highly concentrated , and where each crystal was formed separate , and at a distance from another .
2 .
The plain wine vinegar , treated in the same way , but in a narrower vessel , yielded a salt which had a different appearance from the former ; for on pouring off the superfluous liquor which remained after the crystallisation was completed , it seemed to be composed of a number of small , thin , broad crystalline , square plates , standing up from about half an inch to an inch above the surface , as represented by a , a , a , in fig. 13 ; on separating them , each crystal appeared at the basis like a small crystal of glauber salt , which terminated at the top in the thin broad plate already mentioned , as represented by the letters b , b , b , &amp;c. On dissolving some of this salt in water , and letting it stand for 18 or 20 days , there formed a number of crystals of different shapes , as in the distilled vinegar ; some such as them , others resembling exactly the figure of the Rochelle salts , but smaller as those at c x ; some squares , others of different shapes and figures , as at c , c , c , &amp;c. and one large one marked d , d. Both the salts from the distilled and from the plain wine vinegar , have a pleasant cool taste , without any disagreeable bitter ; and generate cold in the time of their solution in water , for the quicksilver in the thermometer , which stood at 63 in New River water , sunk to 62 , as soon as some of this salt , which was put into it , began to dissolve .
From the figure and shape of some of the crystals of the salt of the wine vinegar coming so near to that of the Rochelle salt , I think we may reasonably conclude that the acid of vinegar approaches near to that of tartar , but is not entirely the same .
The salt of the distilled vinegar can be made with great ease and very pure ; but the common vinegar contains such a large proportion of oil as to require some care to purify it after it is made .
EXPERIMENT III .
With the crystals of tartar .
The Rochelle salt , made with the acid of tartar , and the fossil alkali , is so common a purging salt , that I shall not enter into any description of it , and I have only given a figure of some of its crystals at fig. 15 , that we might be able to compare it with the other neutral salts made with vegetable acids .
EXPERIMENT IV .
With the acid of verjuice of Apples .
I made two trials with the verjuice ; the first was with a quart of what was old and tart , and took rather above an ounce of the alkali to saturate it ; the other , which was newer , not so tart , and was saturated with about seven drams of the alkali .
The first was evaporated to a few ounces , when an oily or mucous pellicle appeared on the top ; after letting it stand for some days , no salt was likely to crystallise ; I therefore diluted it with water , filtered it , clarified it with the white of an egg , and evaporated it a second time ; and after it had stood for some days the salt concreted into the form represented by fig. 16 .
It was composed of a number of small long crystals , which branched out from centres somewhat like the sticks of a fan , or the fibres in the leaf of a tree , such as at a , a , a. The second or new verjuice , after being saturated , was allowed to stand for four or five weeks , then filtered , purified with the white of an egg , and evaporated ; and after standing some days in a cool place , a crystallisation was formed , which approached very near in its appearance to the salt of apples , though somewhat different ; it was composed of a number of very fine delicate small , flat square or rhomboidal plates set upon their edges , near to one another , without any certain regular order that I could observe , but so as on the whole to make a very beautiful appearance ; in this crystallisation the salt seemed to form in clumps , two of which are to be seen at b , b , &amp;c. and a profile view of a small piece at c , c , and a figure of some of the plates laid on their flat sides at d , d. Did the difference of the age of the verjuice employed in these two experiments , or the difference of the processes they underwent , make the difference in the appearance of the salts obtained in the different crystallisations ?
The salt of the old verjuice approached to that of vinegar ; of the new to that of apples .
EXPERIMENT V. With the acid of perry .
At the time I gave in this paper , in the beginning of November , I had made several attempts to obtain a neutral salt from perry ( or the fermented juice of pears ) but without success , owing to the large quantity of saccharine juice with which this liquor abounds .
But having accidentally left some of the concentrated liquor in a small china bason , on examining it some days after the present hard frost had begun , *I found that a crystallisation had taken place .
The crystals were flat , long , narrow , very thin transparent plates , such as represented in fig. 17 ; they were from a quarter of an inch to near an * The account of this experiment was given to the Royal Society about the middle of January 1768 .
inch long ; they were mostly fixed to the sides of the bason by one end , many stood almost upright , and others lay across each other .
One end was commonly made up of two short sides , which met at a point .
They remained some days exposed to the air in a cold room , and preserved their transparency and figure ; but after they had stood for about a quarter of an hour in a warm room , while the painter was drawing the figure , they lost their transparency , and became white and mealy .
They tasted cool , and somewhat bitter in the mouth .
SECTION III .
Of neutral Salts , formed with distilled vegetable Acids , and the fossil Alkali .
Acids distilled from wood , and other vegetable substances , have been mentioned as a distinct species , but no proof has been brought of their differing from the other vegetable acids ; on the contrary , in the tables of neutral salts given by chemists , no notice is taken of any neutral salts made with these acids ; and therefore it is to be presumed that they imagined them to be nearly of the same nature with the others .
In order to know if these acids differed from one another , and from the native and other acids , I had some guaiac wood , some fir wood , and some honey distilled , and procured some of the acid of each , which I saturated , filtered , evaporated , and crystallised .
EXPERIMENT I. With the acid of guaiac wood .
The crystals of the neutral salt of guaic wood were long and small , and shot like the rays of the sun from a centre , and appeared as represented in fig. 18 .
EXPERIMENT II .
With the acid of fir wood .
The neutral salt of fir had a very different appearance ; there were no such distinct crystals as in the other ; what were to be observed seemed to be long and small , to come in many places from points , and to go in somewhat of a circular manner , or to describe a curve , and appeared as represented by fig. 19 .
EXPERIMENT III .
With the acid of honey .
It has been a doubt among naturalists , whether honey should be ranked among the vegetable or the animal substances .
Most chemists seem to think it should be ranked among the vegetable , and look upon it as made up principally of the juices of plants collected by the bees ; but , however that matter may be , the following is an exact account of the neutral salt made with the acid obtained from this substance by distillation .
In order to procure this acid , I prevailed with Mr. Winter , brother-in-law to Mr. Heineken , apothecary , to distil four or five pounds of honey in a retort ; at first he imagined that I only wanted the watery phlegm , which has been called by the name of the spirit of honey , and stopped the distillation before the acid came over ; but having distilled a second quantity , he procured me about six ounces of a very acid liquor , which I mixed with the phlegm or spirit which he first brought me ; I then saturated the whole with the fossil alkali , filtered and evaporated the liquor to a pellicle .
After it had stood all night in a cool place , I found the pellicle to be composed of a yellow , bitter , saltish , mucous and oily matter ; below which was a dark purplish liquor , which I poured into a tea cup , and there remained at the bottom of the stone gallypot , in which the evaporation had been performed , a yellow concreted matter , somewhat of the appearance of yellow wax , mixed with a little honey ; on the surface of which was to be observed a number of globules of the same sort of matter , of the size of mustard seeds , and interspersed with a black very bitter stuff .
Next day , on examining the dark coloured purplish liquor which I had put into the tea cup , I found that a great part of it had concreted into a very beautiful salt , which is represented by fig. 20 .
a , a , a , shows the general form of the crystallisation ; b , b , b , b , the shape , figure , and size of some of the crystals .
The crystals were almost all flat , and seemed in general to assume the form of long , narrow parallelograms , or longish squares , if I may be allowed to use the expression ; c , c , some of the yellow saline matter .
This salt is pleasant to the taste , and evidently generates cold in the mouth in the time of its solution ; but I had not quantity enough to try with a thermometer what degree of cold it generated in the time of its solution in water .
SECTION IV .
Of neutral Salts formed with Flowers of Benzoin , and Salt of Amber .
EXPERIMENTS I. and II .
With the flowers of benzoin .
Most modern chemists have looked upon the gum benzoin as a resinous substance , which bears the same analogy to the vegetable resins , as the succinum or amber does to the fossil bitumens ; and they have esteemed the flowers of benzoin to be an acid salt , mixed with an oily and a small proportion of an earthy matter ; but have brought no proof of its being so .
1 .
In order to ascertain this fact , I put two drams and a half of the flowers of benzoin into some water , and then dropped into it by degrees a solution of the fossil alkali ; every drop raised an ebullition or effervescence , in the same manner as when any common alkaline salt is thrown into an acid liquor .
I continued adding the alkaline lye till all ebullition ceased , and the flowers were fully saturated and dissolved ; after which I filtered the liquor , and evaporated it till a pellicle began to appear , and then set it in a cool place all night , and next morning I had a fine pure transparent neutral salt , such as is represented by figure 21 .
It adhered to the china bason in form of a saline crust , which I removed ; and on looking thorough it in the light , it seemed to be composed of an infinite number of very small crystals ; above this lay , in many places , a number of crystals of the figure of small oblong parallelograms , as those at b , b. But from the greater part of the surface of the crust there arose a number of very fine thin delicate plates of irregular figures , standing on one edge ; some were squares , others parallelograms , and others had more sides , the general appearance of which was such as is to be seen at the letters a , a , a , &amp;c. This salt , when first made , appeared as transparent and clear as glauber salt , or nitre ; but on being exposed to the air , became very soon white and mealy .
In the time of the evaporation of this salt , a saline white mealy crust rose every where on the sides of the china bason in which the operation was performed , and even came over so far , as to cover its whole outside .
What rose in this manner had a sweetish taste , and was not so sharp in the mouth as what appeared in a transparent saline form .
The superfluous liquor , which remained after the crystallisation was completed , being put into a tea cup , concreted in a very uncommon manner .
In the middle of the tea cup it arose something like a plant , or a fountain , where the water is discharged from a number of pipes , and spread from the bottom of this , so as to cover both the inside and outside of the cup , with a sweetish , white , mealy , saline crust , which in many places seemed disposed like the fine fibres of plants , or of the leaves of trees .
2 .
As a further proof of the flowers of benzoin being an acid of a particular kind , I saturated some of them with the sal volatile ammoniacum , evaporated and crystallised ; and obtained an ammoniacal salt , which had a very singular appearance .
It was covered on the top with a very white saline pellicle , below which were a number of thin , flat , white transparent crystals , the greater number of which seemed to be exact squares , some few , oblong parallelograms , such as are represented in fig. 22 .
The flowers of benzoin generated a considerable degree of cold in the time of their saturation with the volatile alkali ; they sunk the quicksilver in the thermometer from 52 to 46 .
EXPERIMENTS III .
and IV .
With the salt of amber .
The salt of amber is now generally known to be of an acid nature ; but from what Mons. Bourdelin has said of it , in the Memoirs of the French Academy of sciences for the year 1742 , its acid has been looked upon by many chemists * , to be exactly of the same nature as the spirit of sea salt , only mixed with a little of the oleum succini ; though some have imagined it to be an acid of the vitriolic kind .
1st , When I first mixed this acid with the fossil alkali , I began to believe that what Mons. Bourdelin had alleged was true ; for the liquor tasted saltish , like to a weak solution of sea salt in common water , but I was soon convinced of my error ; for on evaporating and crystallising , I had a salt very different in its nature and properties from that of sea salt , or of glauber salt , one of which salts it must have been ~ , had the acid been the marine or the vitriolic .
This agrees with what Dr. Stockar de Neuforn ~ , has said of this being a particular acid .
* Macqner seems to be thoroughly convinced of the acid of succinum , or amber , being the same with that of sea salt ; for in mentioning the proofs which Mons. Bourdelin has brought of its being so , he says , ` ` C'est ce point qui est l'objet principal de memoir de Mons. Bourdelin ; &amp; cette decouverte est sans contredit un des plus belles , &amp; en meme temps des plus difficiles , qu'il y eut a fair sir ce Bitume .
' ' See his Elemens de Chymie pratique , tom .
ii .
p. 213 .
~ Sea salt is a neutral salt made of the fossil alkali , and marine acid , or spirit of sea salt ; and glauber salt , of the same alkali and the spirit of vitriol .
~ In the year 1760 , Dr. Jo. Geo. Stockar de Neuforn , in his inaugural Differtation de Succino , published at Leyden the 7th of July , 1760 , proves by a number of experiments , that the acid of succinum is neither that of vitriol nor of sea salt ; and he mentions two neutral salts made with this acid , the one with the common vegetable alkali , and the other with the volatile .
He says that the crystals of the one , made with the vegetable alkali , are clear and pellucid , and of the same figure as the The crystals , I obtained in the first experiment I made , were large and flat ; and such as are to be seen at the letters a , a , &amp;c. fig. 23 ; they were of no certain shape or figure ; some were roundish with a number of sides , others appeared somewhat traingular , and others of different figures ; and in some parts the crystallisation appeared like a piece of rock work .
I dissolved some of this salt in water , and crystallised it a second time , but the crystals were in general smaller than in the first operation ; and the crystallisation appeared as represented by b , b , b. In order to show the difference between this and sea salt , I made Mr. Paul draw the figure of some beautiful crystals of sea salt , near to those of this neutral salt of amber .
This salt is extremely different in its taste from that of sea salt , and certainly likewise in its virtues and properties .
2 .
In order to ascertain more fully that the sal succini is an acid sui generis , I saturated some of it with the volatile ammoniac salt , crystallised it , and obtained a neutral ammoniacal salt very different from that of the common sal ammoniacum ; it was composed of a number of small long narrow flattish crystals , whose sides were made up of four flat surfaces , such as those represented in fig. 24 , and laid crystals of the salt of amber itself ; that it has a particular taste , and dissolves easily in water , which the tartarus vitriolatus does not ; and when thrown on the fire , or put on a red hot iron , crackles and melts , but yet remains fixed and neuter .
Acids make no change on it , nor is aqua fortis converted into an aqua regia by its mixture ; it does not precipitate silver from spirit of nitre , though it precipitates lead from vinegar , in form of a white calx , which , however , cannot be changed into a saturnus corneus .
in an irregular order , some lying across others , and some standing on one end * .
The sal succini generates a great degree of cold in the time of its saturation with the volatile alkali , for it sunk the quicksilver in the thermometer from 52 to 40 ; in this it agrees with the common sal ammoniacum .
The Conclusion .
From the experiments above related , it is evident ~ ~ nearly of the same nature ; for from them it should seem that almost each of the acids , called vegetable , has something peculiar to itself , and upon future trials may be found to have different virtues and properties ~ .
The different appearance of the neutral salts above mentioned , from that of those produced by the union of the fossil alkali with any of the mineral acids , seems to make it doubtful whether the vegetable acids derive their origin from the mine* Dr. Stockar de Neuforn says , that this ammoniacal salt does not precipitate silver from aqua fortis , nor change aqua fortis into aqua regia ; and when put in a silver spoon , and set over the fire , it melts and flies off in form of a vapour .
~ However , it ought to be remarked , that when any of the concentrated saturated liquors stood for ten or twelve days before they crystallised , for the most part some crystals of a flat , square , or of a narrow oblong parallelogram figure , were found adhering to the sides of the cup or bason in which the liquor stood ; but whether this was owing to the alkaline basis of these salts , or to the acids approaching to each other in their nature , is what can only be determined by future experiments .
N. Salt of Verjuice .
N.o Fig. 16 .
Rochelle Salt .
a Fig. 15 .
a aa bb bbc decc c d d N. Salt of Guaiac Wood .
Fig. 18 .
d N. Salt of ~ .
Fig. 19 .
N. Salt of Benzoin .
Fig. 21 .
aa a a Ammoniacalsalt of amber .
bb Fig. 24 .
a N. Salt of Common Wine Vinegar .
N. Salt of Distilled Ninegar .
Fig. 13 .
Fig. 14 .
a a a d aa c d c d bbbb b cbb b ~ c d~ d d c d cc N. Salt of Honey .
Fig. 20 .
a N. Salt of amber .
a Fig. 23 .
b b bb bb b b b c a c aa a Ammoniacal Salt of Benzoin .
sea a a Fig. 22 .
Salt Philos. Trans. Vol. LVII .
TAB. XXIV .
p. 512 .
d d N. Salt of Perry .
Fig. 17 .
a ral ; or whether they are not new substances , generated either in the vessels of plants by means of the vegetative process , or by fermentation , or by the force of fire .
If they owe their origin to the mineral acids , they are certainly so much changed in their virtues , and properties by the combination of new particles , and by the processes they have undergone , that they may be looked upon as distinct bodies in many respects .
From what has been said , it is evident that the number of true neutral salts * is infinitely greater than what has been supposed , of late , by chemists ; and it is probable that many of the neutral salts , above described , may prove to be excellent remedies in the cure of diseases , as well as useful in many manufactories .
As there is such a variety of vegetable acids , and as each of them produces a distinct neutral salt with each of the three alkalies , I think it would be right to distinguish them from one another by particular names ; the salts made with the vegetable alkali may be called vegetable salts , as both the acid and the alkali are vegetable substances ; those made with the fossil alkali neutral salts ; and those made with the volatile alkali ammoniacal salts , as all the neutral salts hitherto made with this alkali have gone by this name .
Thus we may call the three neutral salts made with lemon juice : 1 .
Vegetable salt of lemons .
2 .
Neutral salt of lemons .
3 .
Ammoniacal salt of lemons .
* By true neutral salt is meant , a salt made with an acid and one of the three alkalies ; the word true is added to these salts , to distinguish them from neutral salts , made with earths or metals , and acids .
By means of these neutral salts we may be enabled to discover many of the properties of vegetable acids , and particularly the different degrees of affinity or attraction between them and alkaline salts ; thus , for example , if we dissolve in water some of the neutral salt of currants , and add some lime juice or some vinegar , and then evaporate and crystallize : if we obtain a neutral salt of currants , we conclude that the acid of currants has a greater affinity or attraction to the alkali than the acid of limes or of vinegar ; but , if we get a neutral salt of limes , or of vinegar , we conclude that these acids have a greater affinity with the alkali than the juice of currants .
As I am sensible that this account of vegetable neutral salts is very incomplete , and that I have done little more than given a very superficial description of their external appearance ; and as it will probably require a length of time , and the labours of many , to discover fully their virtues and properties , I shall recommend it to those who may prosecute this subject to endeavour to ascertain the following facts : 1 .
What degree of cold or of heat is generated on the mixture of each acid with the different alkaline salts ; and likewise to try the same experiment with each neutral salt at the time of its solution in water .
2 .
What quantity of pure alkaline salt it takes to saturate any determined quantity of each of the vegetable acids .
3 .
What figure each neutral salt assumes when it is first crystallised , and likewise after it has been purified , and again dissolved in water and crystallised .
4 .
What quantity of water it takes to dissolve any determined quantity of each salt .
5 .
What effects these salts or their solutions in water have on oils , sulphur , ardent spirits , metals , earths , and other substances ; what substances they mix easily with , and to what bodies they prove a menstruum , or assist in dissolving .
6 .
How far they agree in their virtues and properties with the neutral salts made with mineral acids , and with each other .
7 .
What effects they have on the human body ; whether they promote more particularly the perspiration or the secretion by the kidneys , or whether they act more readily on the bowels , and promote the discharge by stool ; and to ascertain the exact and proper doses of each .
8 .
And lastly , what effects fermentation and distillation have on native vegetable acids ; and to observe and compare the appearances of the neutral salts made with these acids in their different states : viz. 1 .
In their native state .
2 .
When made into wine .
And 3dly , when made into vinegar ; and likewise when made with acids brought over by the force of fire , or distilled from the same juices in each of the three different states mentioned .
And in order to facilitate their labours , I shall conclude this long paper with observing , 1st , That all vegetable juices used for making neutral salts ought to be strained through a cloth , and then filtered through paper , before they are saturated with the alkaline salt ; and that , after they are saturated , they ought to be allowed to stand for some days , and some of them for weeks , and then be filtered again , before they are evaporated .
2dly , That it is of use to clarify many of these juices , after being saturated , with the whites of eggs .
3dly , That it is sometimes easier to obtain a neutral salt , by evaporating with a boiling heat , than with a slow or gentle fire ; as the heat of boiling water coagulates , and throws up a quantity of viscid juices to the surface , which cannot be easily separated by any other means .
4thly , That the sweeter any fruit is , and the more it abounds with saccharine or viscid juices , the more difficult it is to obtain a neutral salt ; and for this reason I have not hitherto been able to get any neutral salt from the saturated juices of pears , or of cherries .
5thly , That , in cases where we are obliged to employ water mixed with the fruits cut small , instead of their juices , it is right to peel off the skins before we attempt to saturate the acid ; otherwise the alkaline salt is in danger of uniting with , and rendering soluble in water , the gross oils with which the skins generally abound , which afterwards prevent the crystallisation of the neutral salts .

