XL .
Extract of a Letter from John Ellis , Esquire , F. R. S. to Dr. Linnaeus , of Upsal , F. R. S. on the Animal Nature of the Genus of Zoophytes , called Corallina .
IHAVE now finished a collection of that genus of Zoophytes , which you call Corallina ; and , with the assistance of our learned friend Dr. Solander , have made a description of each species : to do this with more exactness , I have taken care to dissect them minutely , and to pass them in review under his eye in the microscope , in order to establish a true general character of this genus .
Read July 9 , 1767 .
I have attended more particularly to examine the nature of these bodies , in order to confute the opinions of some late writers on Zoophytes , who , for want of good microscopes , and a proper care in chemically analysing them , have asserted that they were mere vegetables .
The first of these is Dr. Job Baster , of Zeeland , who , in the Philosophical Transactions , Vol. LII .
p. 111 , asserts that the Corallines of Linnaeus , which he says he has accurately examined , are most evidently true plants of the genus of Conferva ; because there are no polypes coming out of their tops , and that they have seed enclosed in their cells like other marine rine plants * .
But , as another part of this letter is intended for an inquiry into this new discovery of Dr. Baster 's , that Corallines are Confervas ; a thing never known even to the great Mr. Ray , Dr. Dillenius , or any other botanist , I shall now proceed to his ingenious friend Dr. Pallas of Berlin , who has lately resided in Holland , and who has taken great pains in collecting every thing that has been wrote on the subject of Zoophytes , from whence he has compiled a book called Elenchus Zoophytorum , where he has ranged the several genera and species of this class of beings in a systematical order .
When he comes to the genus of Corallina , he says ( vide Pallas Elenchus , p. 418 .
) ~ , ` ` They are to be left to the botanists , as they belong to the vegetable kingdom ; but makes this apology for inserting them , least his book should be thought imperfect , as Linnaeus and Ellis have ranked them as Zoophytes in their works .
' ' * Corallinas , non Zoophyta , quamvis Linnaeus iisdem adnumeret , sed veras e conservarum genere plantas esse , luculentissime perspexi .
Nunquam in earum apicibus polypi inveniuntur : semen contra cellulis inclusum eodem quo aliae plantae marinae modo produnt .
Phil. Trans. Vol. LII .
p. 3 .
~ Corallinas ad vegetabilia referendas esse .
Mihi vero totum hocce genus botanicis relinquendum videtur .
Nec enim structura , nec chymicis principiis ad Zoophytorum ullum genus accedunt , et pleraeque species etiam habitum prorsus peculiarem habent , aliquae ad fucos potius accedentes , plurimae confervis comparabiles , quamvis lapidescenti substantia ab iisdem et omnibus vegetabilibus distinctissimae .
Pallas Elenchus Zoophyt .
p. 418 .
He begins with observing , that they do n't come near to any one genus of Zoophytes , neither in their structure nor chemical principles ; that some species have a peculiar appearance , some approach to Fucus 's , many are like Confervas ; but that all of them are very distinct from them , and from all vegetables , on account of their lapidescent substance .
That they differ in their chemical principles from Zoophytes ; for when they are burnt , they smell like vegetables : and that , according to Count Marsigli 's Experiments ( Hist. Mar. p. 73 .
) they neither contain a volatile salt , or animal oil .
That the pores , in their calcareous substance , are too small for polypes to inhabit them ; and that the pores of Fucus 's prove them to be as much animals as the Coraliines , even when their pores are rendered more visible , by having the calcareous substance , that surrounds them , dissolved by an acid .
That the great Jussieu , in his diligent researches after marine productions could see no visible token of life in them .
That Mr. Meese , who has lately wrote a Flora Frisica , has found a Coralline growing upon a heath in Friesland ; which , Dr. Pallas says , is a strong proof of their vegetable origin .
Lastly , that their fructification is so nearly analogous to those of Fucuses and Confervas , that he likewise takes that to be a proof of their belonging to the vegetable kingdom .
To proceed then .
Dr. Pallas , after telling us that Corallines are vegetables , says , that some of them are like Fucuses .
In this I must agree with him ; because his first Coralline , which he calls Corallina Pavonia , is truly of that genus of plants : this most elegant Fucus I have particularly described and figured ( Essay on Coral .
p. 88 .
T. 33 .
fig. c , d , e , ) ; it is well known by the name of Turky-feather Fucus , and is called , in the Species Plant .
p. 1630 , Fucus Pavonius .
What could have led Dr. Pallas into this mistake ?
most probably those beautiful farinaceous semi-circular stripes on it , which he must have taken for a lapidescent or calcareous substance * , one of the most distinguishing characters of a Coralline , even according to his own description of this genus .
If he had tried this farinaceous substance with an acid , he might observe , that it would not ferment ; it is of the same nature with the farina that covers many plants , for instance the Primula Auricula , and almost all the Lichenes foliacei and fruticulosi , or Liverworts .
As to their similitude to the Conferva , the contrary will appear , as soon as I come to give the proper definitions to both these , and the Corallines .
In the same paragraph he says , that the Corallines do not come near to any genus of Zoophytes .
How far he is mistaken in this assertion , I will endeavour to prove from the following experiments .
Break a thin piece from the Corallium Anglicum , Essay on Coral .
T. 27 .
N. 1 .
c. ( Millepora Calcarea , Pallas Elench .
p. 265 .
) or of the Corallium Lichenoides , Essay on Coral .
T. 27 .
N. 2 .
d. ; both * Quamvis lapidiscenti substantia ab omnibus vegetabilibus distinctssimae .
Pallas , Elench .
418 .
which , Dr. Pallas , in his Elench .
p. 265 .
has confounded together under the name of Millepora Calcarea ( but which he confesses to be animal ) ; and when you examine them in the microscope , you will find in them both regular series of cells , as figured in Essay on Cor. Tab. 27 .
Fig. D. Split at the same time one of the joints of the Corallina Officinalis of Linnaeus lengthways , and you will find the series of cells * correspond in shape exactly with both the former ; which I think proves the organization of these bodies to be the same , and consequently animal .
Besides these , compare the structure of the Miriozoon of Donati , Phil. Trans. Vol. XLVII .
p. 107 .
Tab. 5 .
( Millepora truncata , Pallas Elench .
p. 249 .
) with those of the Corallina Rosarium , and Corallina incrassata , both which I have carefully dissected and figured in Tab. XVII .
Fig. 15 , 20 , &amp;c. and there appears so great an affinity between their cells ( and even in the opercula of the Corallina incrassata ) , that it affords us reason to conclude with great probability , that their mouths , or suckers , are the same .
It cannot be amiss to mention the similitude there is between the stony-jointed Corallines , and the Isis Hippuris , or jointed black and white East Indian Coral , and the Cellularia Salicornia , Pallas Zooph .
p. 61 .
or Bugle Coralline , Essay on Coral .
T. 23 .
which two last are universally allowed to be animals : in all these are found the same kind of fibres that connect their joints , and exactly in the same manner .
In order to prove that these Corallines have a smell very different from vegetables , I must appeal to * See Tab. XVII .
fig. 12 and 13 .
an experiment made publicly before the Society of Arts , Commerce , &amp;c. and which gave them a satisfactory demonstration of the great difference in nature between Corallines and vegetable substances .
It happened upon the following occasion .
A gentleman of Wales had sent the society a parcel of Lichen tartareus , of Linn. Ed. 2 .
Sp. Pl .
1608 .
as a proper material for dying a red colour , to answer the same purpose of that expensive article among the dyers , called Orchell , or Canary weed , which is the Lichen .
Roccella of Linn. Sp. Pl .
1622 .
As the object was of consequence , the society was very desirous of being fully informed of the nature and appearance of this useful dye ; and therefore , several curious gentlemen of the society were desired , against the next meeting , to bring some specimens of true Orchell .
Accordingly some specimens were obtained from the Orchell dyers in Southwark , and laid before the society .
At the same time Dr. Maningham , a member of that society , produced before the society a specimen , in a paper with Orchell wrote upon it , from Mr. Miller of Chelsea , likewise as the true Orchell : but , upon examining it , it proved to be the Corallina nervo tenuori fragiliorique internodia nectente of Sir Hans Sloane 's History of Jamaica , Vol. I. Tab. 20 .
Fig. 4 .
Some disputes arising on the different appearance of the specimens , I took the liberty to inform the gentlemen present , that , having lately made some experiments on Corallines , I believed that Mr. Miller 's specimen was a Coralline , or animal substance , and the Lichen Roccella , or Dyers Orchell , was a vegetable ; and in order to convince the society of the difference , I called for a lighted candle , and having first set fire to the Lichen Roccella , it yielded the same smell that burnt vegetables usually do ; but when the Coralline ( which was Mr. Miller 's specimen ) was burnt , it filled the room with such an offensive smell like that of burnt bones , or hair , that the door was obliged to be opened , to dissipate the disagreeable scent , and let in fresh air .
Another argument that Dr. Pallas offers the world of the vegetable nature of Corallines , or rather a proof of their not being of an animal nature , are Count Marsigli 's Chemical experiments on the Corallina Officinalis ( Hist. Mar. p. 73 .
) where he says it neither contains animal oil nor volatile salts .
But , to prevent such plausible arguments from misleading mankind , I determined to have fair and accurate experiments made on this substance .
Accordingly I applied to Mr. Peter Wolf , F. R. S. a gentleman distinguished for his great knowledge in chemistry ; and in order to have the specimens fresh from the sea , I applied to a worthy member of this Society , the Right Honourable the Earl of Hillsborough , for Mr. Potts , the Secretary to the PostOffice , to procure me a sufficient quantity of the Corallina Officinalis from the sea-coast near Harwich : this parcel , about two months ago , I sent to Mr. Wolf ; and in answer have received the following letter , with an account of his experiments made on it .
Clerkenwell , May 5 , 1767 .
SIR , ITOOK twelve ounces troy of the Corallina Officinalis ( which you sent me ) picked clean from every extraneous substance , and put it into a clean stone-coated retort ; the retort was set in a reverberatory furnace , and an adopter and quilled receiver luted to it : the fire was very gentle for the first eight hours ; in which time , half an ounce and eighteen grains of a transparent and almost colourless liquor came over , which was set aside for examination .
The fire was then increased , and in six hours time there were distilled two drams and three grains of a turbid liquor , which had some appearance of oiliness on its surface ; this was likewise set apart to be examined .
The fire was then increased for six hours longer , and during the last two hours the retort was quite red hot all over , which ended the distillation .
In this third and last process the portion of liquor that came over was more turbid than the second , and some of it from the redundancy of its volatile alkaly was crystallized ; it also contained rather more than a dram of light empyreumatic oil , very much resembling the smell of hartshorn ; in the recipient there was also some crystals of a volatile alkali .
The whole of this last product weighed three drams and an half .
The caput mortuum was quite black , and weighed ten ounces , one dram , and one scruple ; so that there was a loss of four drams and forty-nine grains out of the twelve ounces of Coralline .
The first liquor that distilled slightly effervesced with spirit of salt , and changed syrup of violets green , certain proofs of a volatile alkali .
The second and third portion effervesced strongly with spirit of salt , as did also the volatile salt that came over into the receiver , evident marks of its being a concentrated alkali .
Here I must observe , that had this distillation been conducted in a hurry , there would have been no concrete volatile alkali ; for then this would have been confounded and dissolved in the first liquor that came over .
Had there been a sufficient quantity of this Coralline , I should first have proposed to have taken off the calcareous substance , by an acid menstruum , and afterwards washed the membranaceous part so clean from the acid , as not to change the syrup of violets red .
Then the distillation of this part alone would have afforded a much larger proportion of empyreumatic oil , and volatile alkali , and but a very small quantity of caput mortuum .
If you think these experiments of any use , you have my free leave to lay them before the Royal Society .
I am , Sir , yours , &amp;c. To John Ellis , Esq ; Peter Woulse .
in Grays Inn .
Doctor Pallas proceeds to prove that Corallines cannot be animals , as the * pores of their calcareous * Pori autem calcareae substantiae ita sunt minuti , ut polypi in iis hospitari nequeant .
Pall .
Elench .
p. 419 .
substances are too minute for any polypes to harbour in .
These words of the Doctor 's seem to imply , as if the Coralline substances were only habitations for detached polypes , and not part of the animals themselves .
How this affair stands , I hope to have clearly demonstrated long before this , for I have plainly seen , and endeavoured to show mankind , that the softer and harder parts of zoophytes are so closely connected with one another , that they cannot separately exist ; and therefore have not hesitated to call them constituent parts of the same body , and that the polype-like suckers are so many mouths belonging thereto .
Now , for the smallness of the pores , which the Doctor has mentioned here ( among the Corallines ) to be a contradiction to animal life ; he certainly has forgot one circumstance , when he introduces the Corallium pumilum album ( Essay Cor. T. 27 .
f. c. ) or his Millepora calcarea ( Pall .
Elench .
p. 265 .
) as an animal , which is , that he there says , it has absolutely no pores at all ~ .
As there can be no doubt , but every part of what is called Coralline is necessary to make out such an animal , or being , it will be very difficult , if not almost impossible , to determine the proportion there ought to be between softer and harder parts ; and therefore it cannot be thought unreasonable to say , that in some of this tribe the stony parts are by much the greater part of the whole , especially as Doctor Pallas 's objection can be only against the crust , or lapidescent part , as the inside of many of them is far from being hard , being ~ Pori omnino nulli .
Pall .
Elench .
p. 266 .
exactly like a Sertularia , so that I do not know if it would not be a good definition to one well acquainted with that tribe to say , a Coralline is a Sertularia covered with a stony or calcareous crust ; if the mouths should happen to be very small , their number may make up that deficiency .
We see in the greatest number of Corallines their surface full of holes ; we saw the same in Escharas and Milleporas thirty years ago ; since that time magnifying glasses have been improved , so as to show us , that they are all orifices , for polype-like suckers ; why should not we now admit that glasses may be still more improved , so as even to make us able to see what may be the intention and use of these minute orifices , which according to all rules of reasoning , we must suppose to approach in nature to them they are most alike .
From this extreme minuteness then of the pores of these Millepora , confessed to be zoophytes , as well as those of Corallina officinalis as before mentioned , it is no great matter of surprise , that Doctor Jussieu could not perceive any animal life in the Corallines , nor Doctor Schlosser in the Millepora calcarea .
As these experiments ought to be attended with many convenient coinciding circumstances that do not often happen to persons who only go to the sea-side , perhaps for a few days , or hours , so that it is unreasonable to conclude , because they have been unsuccessful , that more accurate observers may not be more fortunate at another time .
I believe I shall be justified in this , by many essays that have been made , by persons of judgment , to observe the polype-like suckers in many , even of the Sertulariae , which they have several times attempted in in vain ; I must own it has often happened to me in many species , and yet I have not the least doubt of their being true Sertulariae from the similarity there is in their habit and form to others of the same genus ; and of this fact I am sure Doctor Pallas is fully convinced .
Another argument made use of by Doctor Pallas , to overthrow the animal existence of Corallines , is taken from Mr. Meese 's assertion , that he had sound on Bergummer Heath in Friesland , a substance of the same nature with the Corallines .
Meese , in his Flora Frisica , p. 75 .
calls it a Lichen ; but Doctor Pallas has ventured in his Elench .
p. 427 .
to rank it among the Corallines , under the name of Corallina terrestris * .
In this Doctor Pallas is in the right , as I have had an opportunity of examining a small specimen , that my worthy and learned friend Doctor Schlosser of Amsterdam was so kind to procure me : but how such a nice and accurate philosopher as Doctor Pallas could let it escape him to consider the nature and quality of this subject , and how much it differs from any thing else growing on the land , is a thing that surprises me .
It only being mentioned by Mr. Meese , as found on Bergummer Heath , ought not to have satisfied him so far , as to declare a body with a calcareous crust to be a land production , when no such thing in the whole vegetable kingdom has ever been found ; it has always been thought quite the contrary , that a stony or hard substance of that nature , could not be produced , but from an animal , and chiefly those that live under water ~ .
* See the figure of it in Tab. XVII .
fig. 28 .
~ It is worthy of our notice how easily this ingenious Natural Historian reconciles it to himself , that this inhabitant of the This should certainly have made him minutely inquire in what manner it was found , if buried under moss , loose on the ground , or perhaps near some of the canals , which communicate with the sea .
Many accidents might have brought it thither , which is more probable than to imagine nature to go out of her usual track .
It is not improbable that that part of Holland has been overflowed by the sea , and this production left there when the water subsided , or blown there by a storm , which I beg leave to believe till I am better informed .
I do not in the least doubt of Mr. Meese 's veracity ; but as that gentleman was more intent on discovering vegetables than animals , and thinking this very like a dry Lichen fruticulosus , he did not scruple to believe it to be one of that tribe ; and therefore , perhaps , neglected to observe all those circumstances , that we now wish to be informed of .
The irregular pedunculated figures or fructifications ( as Doctor Pallas pleases to call what is represented in Tab. XVII .
fig. 29 .
) seem to be rather a defect in the growth of the ramifications , especially as they differ from one another in shape , and some of them appear beginning to form other branches .
In fig. a the whole consists of two opposite curled processes , with a small cavity between them at the top ; this cavity is filled up at fig. b. so that the top becomes rounded ; in fig. c. c. there seems to be a beginning of a continuation lengthways ; and in fig. d. it is still more plain the beginning of a branch .
sea can grow on dry land .
See Pallas Zoophyt .
p. 427 .
Nec magis miror Corallinam in sicco crescentem , quam Lichenum cum Fucis summam analogiam .
If If the inside of these processes had been hollow , and the outside of a regular figure , I should not have hesitated to consider them to be the ovaries of the Coralline ; but as they are solid , and of the same structure with the rest of Corallines , I shall rather call them defective branches .
Doctor Pallas 's last argument to prove that Corallines are vegetables is , that the nodules , or tubercles , which he has observed in Corallines , contain little seeds subanalogous , or somewhat resembling those we find in the fructification of the Fucus 's and Confervas .
If this method of reasoning should hold good , what will become of the Cellularias , Sertularias , and Millepora calcarea &amp; agariciformis , with many other zoophytes , that have such roundish ovaries ; they must be recalled to the vegetable kingdom , notwithstanding all doubt about their being living animals has long been laid aside .
I come now to his ingenious friend Doctor Baster , who carries this matter still farther , and says positively , in Phil. Trans. Vol. LII .
p. 111 .
that the Corallines are true Confervas ; and in his Opuscula Subseciva , Vol. I. Tab. I. fig. 3 .
A. and B. he refers us to the figure of the Corallina rubens in seed ; which , he says , is a true Conferva ; but the figure is so bad , that I am persuaded nobody can find out what he means to represent by it .
I shall therefore conclude this letter , with recommending to these ingenious gentlemen , to analyse these bodies chemically , and with care ; and likewise to view them with the same attention , that I have done , in the microscope ; if so , I am persuaded they will be of our opinion .
I must defer the sequel of what I intended to another day , which was to give you an account of the discoveries I have made in the fructification of the Confervas ; these , I flatter myself , will fully convince Doctor Baster of the great difference between these two bodies , and that they belong to two different kingdoms of Nature .
I am , SIR , Your most obedient Servant , Gray's-Inn , June 2 , 1767 .
John Ellis .
The Description of Plate XVII .
Fig. 1 .
The Miriozoon of Donati , or Millepora truncata of Pallas .
2 .
The end of a branch magnified , to show the situation of the pores .
3 .
The same cut perpendicularly through , to show the Trumpet-like suckers in their cells connected with the middle tubes .
4 .
The horizontal section of the same , with the suckers extended .
5 .
The magnified drawing of one of the suckers , with its cell and operculum .
26 27 a 24 25 23 20 15 14 19 18 17 28 C c a 16 c 21 b C D 29 B 22 Phil : Trans. Vol. LVII .
Tab. XVII .
p 418 .
3 21 4 56 87 9 10 11 13 Fig. 6 .
The oblique view of the opening of the cell with the sucker and operculum .
7 .
The cell with the operculum open .
8 .
The cell covered with its operculum .
9 .
The Corallium Lichenoides of Ellis 's Corallines , with ovaries upon it .
10 .
The natural and magnified size of a piece and 11 .
of this Coral , to show the arrangement of the inside of the cells , which are just the same as in the following .
12 .
The order of the cells , in a joint of the Corallina Officinalis , to show the great affinity between them .
13 .
The natural size of a small piece of the Corallina Officinalis .
14 .
The milk-white Millepora calcarea , from the Mediterranean , where , though the pores are not visible on the outside , the arrangement of the cells in the inside are the same with the Corallium Lichenoides , and Corallina Officinalis .
15 .
The Corallina Rosarium , or White-bead band-string of Sloan 's Hist. of Jamaica , Tab. XX .
fig. 3 .
16 .
Two joints magnified , one to show the situation and figure of the pores , and the other to show how the suckers pass from the middle cartilaginous tube through the calcareous covering to the surface .
Fig. 17 .
Shows four of the suckers , and the ovary between them , magnified highly .
18 .
The Ovary .
19 .
One of the eggs taken out of the ovary .
20 .
The Corallina incrassata , from the WestIndies .
21 .
One of the joints of its natural size .
22 .
The same magnified a little , to show its pores in its calcareous surface .
23 .
Part of the inside tubes of the joint , of their natural size .
24 .
The same magnified , to show the openings of the cells on the surface , connected together .
25 .
A perpendicular section of half of one of these joints .
26 .
The same magnified , to show the figure of the vessels leading to the suckers in the calcareous surface .
27 .
A piece of the calcareous surface highly magnified , to show some of the pores open , and others covered with their convex opercula ; letter a shows the figure of one of the trumpet-shaped suckers highly magnified .
28 .
A small branch of Meese 's Coralline supposed to grow on a health , called by Dr. Pallas Corallina terrestris .
29 .
The same magnified , to show the disposition and figures of its supposed fructification at a. b. c c. and d. which are higher magnified at A. B. C C. and D. to show how unlike they are to fructifications .
SEQUE L. Title read December 17 , 1767 .
ICOME now to answer Doctor Baster , who asserts positively , in his memoir published in the Transactions of the Royal Society , Vol. LII .
p. 111 , that all the Corallines , which you and I have described , are plants of the genus of Conferva .
Read Jan. 14 , 1768 .
In order to explain myself , it will be necessary to let him know what I mean by a Conferva , and what I would be understood by a Coralline , according to your system .
By a Conferva I mean a plant with jointed filaments , either single or branched , bearing fruit , which are disposed in different ways : in Latin , thus , Conferva est planta , cui sunt filamenta articulata , vel simplicia vel ramosa , fructificationes vario modo dispositae habentia .
By a Coralline I mean an animal growing in the form of a plant , whose stem is fixed to other bodies .
The stem is composed of capillary tubes , whose extremities , tremities pass through a calcareous crust , and open into pores on the surface .
The branches are often jointed , and always sub-divided into smaller branches , which are either loose and unconnected , or joined , as if they were glued together : in Latin , thus , Corallina est animal crescens habitu plantae .
Stirps fixa , e tubis capillaribus per crustam calcaream porosam sese exerentibus composita .
Rami saepe articulati , semper ramulosi , vel divaricati liberi , vel conglutinati et connexi .
This difference then will evidently appear by putting each kind into an acid liquor .
The Coralline will immediately discover the nature of its * calcareous surface , by a strong fermentation ; when the Conferva will not appear in the least affected .
This acid liquor will likewise soon dissolve the calcareous substance in the Coralline , by which means the minute vessels that lead to the pores on the surface will become visible ; whereas the Conferva will unalterably remain the same , and be rather preserved than corroded by the acid .
When Doctor Pallas , who supports the opinion of Doctor Baster , comes to the chemical analysis of the Corallines , he tells us ~ that he had not time nor opportunity to try them ; but depends on the report of other authors .
* Lin .
Syst. Not .
Ed. 12 .
p. 1304 .
` ` Corallinas ad regnum animale pertinere ex substantia earum calcarea constat , cum omnem calcem animalium esse productum verissimum sit .
' ' ~ Pallas Zooph .
p. 418 .
` ` Temporis angustia et opportunitas impediverit no in Corallinarum naturam accuratius igne inquirerem .
' ' This dependence on the authority of others , to overturn what I think we have established with very strong evidence , will , I am in hopes , convince him of the propriety of that well-chosen motto of the Royal Society .
` ` Nullius in verba ; ' ' which I find he has adopted as the common seal of his epistles to his literary correspondents : and he will now have a further opportunity of * complimenting Doctor Baster on making a second apology for what he has advanced against me in the Phil. Trans. Vol. LII .
p. 111 .
by showing him , that they have both been mistaken in blending two very different genera of the animal and vegetable kingdoms of nature together .
To make this difference appear still more evident , I come now to lay before you a new scene of nature ; which an accurate examination into the fructification , as well as the articulations , of some of the Confervas , afforded me .
Indeed the minuteness of these objects would scarce seem worth while to examine into so critically , if my reputation had not engaged me to show the wide difference between them and Corallines .
This , joined to some remarkable discoveries , which I made in the year 1754 on the coast of Sussex ( in company with Mr. G. D. Ehret , F. R. S. ) in the fructification of this class of plants , which * Pallas Zooph .
p. 20 .
` ` Candidissimus Basterus , qui hucusque contra Ellisium reliquosque prioris sententiae patronos steterat , alterius evidentiae victas dedit manus , et gloriosissimo exemplo , repudiata priori sua opinione , veram theoriam acriter desendere caepit .
' ' before that time were esteemed by * botanical writers to have no fructification at all , has induced me to lay a few specimens of them with their magnisied drawings before the Royal Society .
In examining these plants I was amazed to find two species of them evidently of your class of Diaecia ; that is , male parts of fructification on one , and female on the other .
The first of these is the Conferva polymorpha , where in Tab. XVIII .
at fig. a. is represented a very small branch of the female in its natural size , and at fig. A. the same is magnified : in the transparent capsules of this specimen , we can easily discover the seed as it lies expanded in a watch-glass in water .
Letter b. represents the natural size of a small branch of the male .
Letter B. the same branch magnified , showing its amentaceous flowers , or catkins , with its minute male seed in spikes .
B 1 .
shows one of them highly magnified .
The other Conferva is the Plumosa , and is one of our most elegant sub-marine plants .
Fig. c. represents the natural size of a minute sprig of the female .
At fig. C. the same is magnified , where the seeds appear in their capsules .
The fig. d. shows the natural size of a sprig of the male Conferva plumosa ; and fig. D. the same sprig magnified , showing the spikes of male seed .
* Ray , Synop .
Ed. 3 .
p. 57 .
` ` Conferva est Musci genus sterile et capitulis floridis destitutum , immo nec peltis &amp; tuberculis , quae horum loco aliqui gerunt , donatum , ex meris foliis teretibus et uniformibus seu mavis cauliculis , in tenuia capillamenta divisis , constans .
' ' The next is the Conferva flosculosa , and is represented at fig. e. in a branch of the natural size .
Fig. E. is the same magnified .
This is one of those remarkable Confervas that has footstalks to its flowers or fructification .
It appears to have fruit like a strawberry , or raspberry , surrounded by a leafy calyx .
This was found on the sea-coast , near Yarmouth in Norfolk , by my worthy friend George Whatley , Esquire , in the year 1764 .
When it was fresh , it was of a most vivid carmine colour .
The other with flowers , at fig. f. is the Conferva geniculata .
Fig. F. shows the same branch more distinctly , being magnified with flowers surrounding the joints ; this , with one which I have called in my catalogue of Confervas , Conferva florifera , I discovered in the year 1754 near Brighthelmstone in Sussex , when Mr. Ehret was so kind as to make drawings of them while recent .
The colour of this , when fresh , is a fine scarlet .
The Conferva plumula , at fig. g. is one of the smallest of the tribe , but most elegantly feathered ; it is of a pale red colour .
The same is magnified at fig. G. which shows the order that the fruit and branches are disposed in .
G1 shows the fruit or seeds , which are of a red colour , surrounded by a clear gelatinous pulp .
The Conferva at fig. h. I have called Ciliata , from the circle of small fibres at the top of each joint .
The magnified drawing at fig. H. shows these fibres like a crown on each joint .
This was inserted here to show , with the rest , some of the infinite variety of beautiful forms , which the great Author of nature has impressed even upon one of the lowest classes of he vegetable tribe .
Before I conclude , I must obeserve ; That as Doctor Pallas has likewise introduced among his arguments , that the fruit of the Fucus 's are subanalogous to those of the Corallines , I could introduce an infinite variety to show the great difference there is between them ; but this part of natural history , too long neglected , requires a volume by itself , to show the amazing variety of vegetables , that lie hid from us in the great deep ; I may make some observations on them the subject of a future letter , especially as many of them are of the class of Diaecia , as well as those which I have already shown in the Confervas ; which I believe will be new to the botanists .
I am , Dear Sir , Your most obedient servant , John Ellis .
The Description of Plate XVIII .
Fig. a. The female Conferva polymorpha .
A. The same magnified , to show the seeds in the Capsules .
b. The male Conferva polymorpha .
B. The same magnified , with its male flowers .
B 1 .
One of the catkins , or male flowers , highly magnified .
c. The female Conferva plumosa .
Phil : Trans : Vol~ LVII~ Tab : XVIII~ p. 426 .
A B ab G B1 G1 Ec D C H h g F d Fig. C. The same magnified , to show its sructification .
d. The male Conferva plumosa .
D. The same magnified , showing its catkins , or male flowers .
e. Conferva flosculosa .
E. The same magnified , showing its pedunculated flowers , or fruit , with their polypetalous cups .
f. Conferva geniculata .
F. The same magnified , to show its flowers surrounding the joints .
g. Conferva plumula .
G. Part of it magnified , to show the disposition of its branches .
G ~ .
Some of the fruit highly magnified , to show its seeds , surrounded by a clear viscid pulp .
h. Conferva ciliata .
H. The same magnified , to show the little coronets on the joints .

