XXXV .
A Memoir concerning the most advantageous Construction of WaterWheels , etc. by Mr. Mallet of Geneva .
Communicated by M. Maty , M. D. Sec. R. S. Translated from the French , by J. Bevis , M. D. R. S. S. Read March 26 , 1767 .
~I THE stream of rivers is of such importance in moving machines of all kinds , that any attempt towards perfecting this part of mechanics may be considered as of very great utility .
The first wheel on which the stream acts is one of the most essential members of the machine , and it is easy to discern that the greater or less effect thereof must depend , in a great measure , on the manner of constructing this wheel , and on the dimensions given to it .
I shall not at present inquire whether wheels of different constructions from those which have been long in use might be advantageously substituted in their stead ; but confine myself , in this essay , to an examination of the most common ones , and to discover the means by which they may be made to produce the greatest possible effects .
Their construction is very simple ; they consist of several planes inserted into the same axle placed horizontally above the surface of the water , and in a position perpendicular to the stream .
These planes , called Philos. Trans. Vol. LVII .
TAB. XV .
p.373 .
Fig. 2 .
Fig. 4 .
AA CC PP ~pp BB ~ C Fig. 4 .
e Fig. 3 .
d AF G C HE O ID B A P B C C E Fig. 6 .
Fig. 5 .
AD A N B po m P M B O K I g~ Fig. 7 H f~ G h~ m F p n E e D d C c B b A ~-boards , by yielding to the action of the stream , cause the axle on which they are fixed to turn round , by means of several wheels , which take into each other , and give motion to the part destined to produce some purposed effect , as the mill-stone in a corn-mill .
The size of the float-boards , the velocity with which the wheel is to turn , and the number of the float-boards to produce the greatest possible effect , are three main things I propose to examine in the following inquiry .
In the first place I will suppose the total resistance which this wheel has to encounter , on the part of the machine , and which hinders it from moving so swift as the stream , to be expressed by a weight ~ , suspended to the extremity of a cord fixed to the circumference of a wheel whose radius is d , and which has the same axle as the float-board wheel , so that the effect of the stream is to raise the said weight ~ , as expressed in TAB. XV .
fig. 1 .
I will likewise suppose , that the stream , by its velocity , moves through v feet in one second of time , and that this velocity is the same , though at different depths .
~ II .
After these suppositions , the first thing that presents , is to determine what should be the size of the float-boards for the stream to be capable of raising the weight ~ with a certain determinate velocity .
Let AAB B , fig. 2 .
be one of the float-bords let into the axle A A , and placed vertically in the water , so as to receive the perpendicular impulse of the stream .
Its horizontal length B B=~ feet , its vertical height A B=~ feet , the velocity of the wheel at the point B , such that it shall run through z feet in a second ; n pounds the weight of a cubic foot of water ; and I will suppose the impulse of the stream on a plane perpendicular to it is ( as Dr. Daniel Bernoulli has stated in his Hydrodynamica ) equal to the weight of a prism of water , whose base is the plane , and its altitude the generating height of the velocity with which the plane is impelled .
This being supposed ; let AP=x , Pp , its differential , =dx , which will give the velocity of the float-board at the point p=x/ ~z , and the relative velocity of the stream with which the plane is impelled at the same point =v x/ ~z whose generating height is ( v-x/ ~z)~/ 60 feet , whence we have the weight of the parallelopiped of that height , and of the base PP pp equal to n~dx/ 60 ( -vx/ ~z)2 pounds , which weight multiplied by the length AP ( x ) of the lever which tends to turn the plane , will give n~xdx/ 60 ( v-x/ ~z)2 for the total effect of the stream on the little rectangle PP pp , whose integral is n~/ 60s .
( wxdx 2vz/ ~ xxdx + zz/ ~~ x3dx ) = n~/ 60 ( 1/ 2 wxx 2/ 3 vz.x3/ ~ + 1/ 4 zz.x4/ ~~ 1/ 2 wff + 2/ 3 vz .
f3/ ~ 1/ 4 zz f4/ ~~ ) ( putting AC=f for the distance between the axle and the surface of the water when the float-board has only its part CB plunged in the water ) which ( putting x= ~ ) will become n~60 ( 1/ 2 w 2/ 3 vz + 1/ 4 zz .
~~ 1/ 2 wff + 2/ 3 vzf~/ ~~ 1/ 4 zzf4/ ~~ ) and will express the effect on the whole plane CCB B , equal ~ d , the product of the weight ~ by the length d of the lever on which it acts in opposing the motion of the wheel .
~ III .
If the wheel be plunged as deep as its axle , that is , f= o , the equation is changed into this n~~ ~/ 60 ( 1/ 2 w 2/ 3 vz + 1/ 4 zz ) =d ~ , where it appears 1~ .
That the quantities d , ~ , v and ~ remaining the same , we have ~ inversely proportional to the square of ~ , whence it follows , that if the length ~ is to be diminished without altering the affect of the floatboard , the height ~ must be increased proportionally to the square root of ~ ; for example , if ~ is to be made four times less , it will be sufficient to double the height ~ .
2~ That likewise the velocity of the float-board remaining the same , the weight ~ will be in the compound ratio of the length ~ , and of the square of the height ~~ .
3~ Without meddling with the dimensions of the float-board , the more the quantity z is increased , the more must the weight ~ be diminished .
If z be made = o , we have ~=n~~ ~/ 60d .
1/ 2 w , and if z=v we have ~=n~~ ~/ 60d .
~v v , that is six times greater than in the first case ; which is very conformable to the nature of things , for when the wheel is in motion , the stream then not acting upon it but with the excess of its velocity above that of the wheel , it follows , that the greater such velocity is , the more will the effect of the stream be diminished .
It follows from our last remark , that the greatest weight with which the stream can constitute an equilibrium , will be =n~~~v v/ 120d , but then the wheel will not have any motion , nor consequently the weight ~ : If the float-board be increased , or the weight diminished , from that instant the wheel will begin to turn , and the swifter as the float-board is greater , or the weight less ; but in most machines , it is required that the weight may be the greatest possible , as also the velocity with which it is raised .
A question therefore here offers itself , whose solution is of much importance .
What must be the velocity of the floatboard whose dimensions are given , that the product of the weight by its velocity shall be the greatest possible ?
~ IV .
The velocity of the weight ~ is d/ ~ z feet in a second , which being multiplied by the value of ~=n~~ ~/ 60d ( 1/ 2 w 2/ 3 vz + 1/ 4 zz ) will give the product n~ ~/ 60 ( 1/ 2 v2z 2/ 3 vzz + 1/ 4 z3 ) which must be a maximum ; for which purpose make 1/ 2 wdz 4/ 3 vzdz + 3/ 4 z2dz = o ; whence we have z=8~ 10/ 9 = 0,53752v : this value of z being substituted , make the equation 1/ 2 w 2/ 3 vz + 1/ 4 zz = 11 +2~ 10/ 81 v v , so that we have the equation ~~~= 11 +2~ 10/ 4860 +d ~/ n w= 280,529 +d ~/ n v v , which expresses the dimensions of the float-board where the effect will be the greatest possible .
If the float-board be plunged no deeper than to CC , as we have at first supposed , the most advantageous value of z may be determined in the same manner , which will be found z=8 ~4 8~ f3 ~~ 10 ~6 + 54 ~4 f2 128 ~3 f3 + 54 ~2 f4 + 10 f6/ 9 ( ~ 4 f4 ) v If f= 0 , this value of z= 0~537v f= 0,25 ~= 1/ 4 ~ .
= 0,498v f= 0,3 ~= 0,486v f= 0,5 ~= 1/ 2 ~ .
= 0,436v f= 0,7 ~= 0,390v f= 0,9 ~= 0,353v f=~= 0,333v By the inspection of these different values it appears that this value of z diminishes as the plunged part is greater , and that this velocity can never exceed the quantity 0,537v , nor be less than 1/ 3 v * .
This value of z and of its square zz being substituted in the general formula ( ~ II .
) we shall obtain from it the following equation : ~d ~/ v ~w= 11 ~ 6-27 ~4 f2+32 ~ f3-27 ~2 f4+11 f6+2 ( ~ 3-~ f f ) ~ 10 ~ 6+54 ~4 f2-128 ~3 f3+54 ~2 f4+10 f~/ 81 ( ~4-f4 ) which for a given relation between f and ~ will show the breadth ~ for producing the greatest effect .
* If in the value of z we make f= ~ , we have z=~ which obliges us to take , according to the common method , the differentials of the numerator and of the denominator , considering f as variable , and the relation of these differentials will give the value of z : but on account of the radical quantity , the calculus being somewhat tedious , and , again bringing out z=~ and that after several similar operations , it is better to have recourse to the equation from which the value of z was deduced ; this equation is 3/ 4 ~v z. ~3 f3/ ~ 4 f4 1/ 2 ~~v v. ~2 f2/ ~ 4++ f4 , which by the above operation will be 3/ 4 ~z=vz 1/ 4 v v , and z= 1/ 3 v. As the extremity of the float-board must have a certain velocity depending on the relation of the height ~ to the plunged part , and as the velocity of the weight ~= d/ ~ z , it follows that if we would increase the velocity of ~ , we must diminish the height ~ and increase the breadth ~ , so that the product ~~~ and the relation of f to ~ may be the same as before ; for example , if the wheel be plunged as deep as the axle , to double the velocity of the weight , the height of the float-board must be reduced one half , and its breadth be quadrupled .
~ V. It may so happen that the channel on which the wheel is placed shall be so shallow and narrow , as not to allow the float-boards the necessary dimensions , for raising the weight with a convenient velocity .
In this case we are obliged to raise the axle of the wheel above the surface of the water , so much that the lever on which the stream acts may be long enough to recompense the smallness of the float-boards .
Herein it is necessary to solve the following problem : The breadth b , and the height a , of the float-board AB being given ; to find the radius CA ( r ) of the wheel which shall cause the weight ~ to ascend with the velocity d/ r +~ z. The exact solution of this problem might be deduced from the formula ( ~ II .
) which would render the operation tedious , the equation being of the fourth degree ; but it may be rendered far more simple by a supposition which is but little wide of the truth when AB is but small in comparison of C A , and this is to consider all the points of the float-board AB as affected with the same velocity z. Let CP fig. 3 .
= x , we shall have n b/ 60 ( v-z)z s. xdx for the effect of the portion A P , and n b/ 60 ( v z)z ~2ar+a a/ 2 for the effect of the whole float-board A B. This quantity must be made equal to d ~ , and then , just as in the foregoing cases , such a value of z be sought , that the weight ~ and its velocity may be the greatest possible ; that is , the differential of z ( v z)z must be made = 0 , which gives z= 1/ 3 v. Therefore d~=nabv v/ 270 ( 2 r+ a ) , and r= 270 d ~-n aabv v/ 2 nabv v , and the velocity of the weight ~ will be = 2ndabv v/ 810 d~+3nbaav~ v. ~ VI .
We have seen that the calculus was much simplified by supposing one of the velocities constant for all points of the float-board .
For this velocity being c , the effect of the whole float-board will be simply n ~/ 60 ( vc)~ ~~f f/ 2 .
It will therefore not be unuseful to inquire what this velocity c must be , that the effect of the float-board may be the same , as supposing , as we have hitherto done , a variable velocity , and proportional to the distances from the axle , we have only to make n ~/ 60 ( v c~2 ( ~ ~f f/ 2 ) =n ~/ 60 ( 1/ 2 w ( ~ ~f f ) 2/ 3 vz~3 f3/ ~ + 1/ 4 zz~4 f4/ ~ ~ ) ( ~ IV .
) but the equation whence we got the value of z ( ~ IV .
) 1/ 2 w4v z/ 3 ~ .
~3 f3/ ~2 f2 + 3/ 4 zz .
~~+f f/ ~ ~= 0 , we shall have c=v~ 1/ 2 w 1/ 4 z z. ~~+f f/ ~ ~ .
If f= 0 , we have zz= 0,288 w and c= 0,345 v f= 1/ 2 ~zz= 0,190 we= 0,336 v f=~zz= 1/ 9 we= 1/ 3 v. so that whatever be the relation of f to ~ , the velocity c is ever nearly = 1/ 3 v , and the more exactly so , as f is greater .
Wherefore we may always assume ~/ 2 70 n~v v. ( ~ ~f f ) =d~ for the effect of the stream upon a float-board whose plunged part is ~ f ; this effect will be increased in the ratio , of 4 to 9 , when the wheel has no motion , for making c= 0 , we find it = 1/ 1 2 0 .
n~v v. ( ~ ~f f ) .
~ VII .
Hitherto we have all along supposed , that the float-board did through its whole plunged part receive the perpendicular impulse of the stream ; but it is easily understood , that the wheel coming to turn , presents to the stream the plane of the float-board under an angle which is continually varying , which diminishes its effect every instant , as it removes from the vertical : This inconvenience may be remedied by multiplying the number of the float-boards , so that when the first is removed from the vertical as far as a certain point , the next may occupy that advantageous place , to be in its turn replaced some time after by a third , and so on .
Now our third inquiry is , to assign the angle contained between two float-boards , or , which comes to the same , the number of floatboards the wheel should consist of , that its effect may be the greatest possible , being of no less importance than the preceding ones .
To begin then with the most simple case ; we will suppose the wheel immovable , or that c= 0 , and proceed to investigate , whether , supposing the number of float-boards to be greater , the sum of the effects will come out greater or less than what results from one single float-board placed vertically .
In order to a general solution of this question , we will suppose two float-boards CD and CE fig. 4 .
making any angles with the vertical , and let us compare the effect of the single float-board GD with the effect resulting from the float-boards FE and GD taken together , which will be reduced to FE and O D , because the part OG becomes useless , as the stream is intercepted by F E. Let CB=CD =CE= ~ , CA= f , cousin .
BCD= m , cousin .
BCE= ~ , which gives CG= f/ m CF= f/ ~ and CO=~m ~ .
Then we shall find , by ~ VI , the effect of GD=n~v v/ 120 ( m m~~f f ) that of OD =n~v v/ 120 ( m m~~~~~ ~ ) .
and that of FE =n~v v/ 120 ( ~ ~~~f f ) ; whence it appears , that the sum of the two last is exactly equal to the first , which will ever hold good whatever be the value of f. Whence arises the following theorem : Whether the wheel be plunged quite up to the axle , or only in part so , provided it be immovable , and that one of its float-boards be placed vertically , its effect will be constantly the same , whatever be the number of float-boards opposed to the stream , even though it were infinite .
The latter part of this theorem , though flowing from the general demonstration , may be also demonstrated , immediately , in the following manner ; Let BP fig. 5 .
be = x , we have MO=~d x/ ~ x , and CO =~~dx~ x/ ~ ~ ; 2~C O= ~4 2~3x + ~2x2 2~3dx + 2~~xdx/ ~~ 2~x + xx neglecting the dx2 ) and ~~ 2~C O= 2~~xdx/ ~ v ; Therefore the effect of the stream upon O M , which is = n~w/ 120 .
( ~~ 2~C O ) 2~C P/ 2~C P will become = n~w/ 120 ( 2~x 2xdx ) whose integral is = ~~w/ 120 ( 2ax-xx ) wherein putting x=~ f , we have n~w/ 120 ( ~~ ff ) for the total effect of the stream upon the wheel , which is the same as that of a single float-board AB in a vertical position .
~ VIII .
This theorem will also hold true for the case of ~ V. wherein we have supposed the height of the float-boards very small , in comparison of the radius of the wheel ; we have seen that the effect of a single float-board placed vertically was =nab w ( 2r + ~ ) ; the demonstration of the preceding ~ will be applicable here after the same manner , and will show that whatever be the number of float-boards , the effect will be ever the same .
It does not however follow that the number of float-boards should be indifferent ; for the wheel coming to turn the float-board , its lower part , which received the perpendicular impulse , will no longer receive it otherwise than obliquely , and the effect will diminish till the angle formed by two neighbouring float-boards be bisected exactly by the vertical , which will render the first entirely useless ; after which the effect will increase anew , and will become again greatest , when the second float-board is got to the vertical ; so that in order to fix upon the most advantageous number of float-boards , regard must be had to the sum of the different effects for all the situations of the float-boards during one whole turn of the wheel .
Whence it follows that in this case , wherein they are supposed very small , the greater their number is , the greater will be the sum total of the effects , since , if that number were infinite , there would be a floatboard in a vertical position every instant .
~ IX .
This will no longer hold good , if the height of the float-boards be more considerable , and it be found necessary to take the different velocity of their different points into consideration ; by comparing ( fig. 4 .
) the pressure on FE with that on the portion G O , they will be found no longer equal , as in the foregoing case ; it is true that the same quantity of fluid acts on these two planes , and the disadvantage which FE has by receiving the impulse more obliquely , is exactly compensated , as before , by the length of the lever , but the difference arises from the different velocity of the corresponding points of FE and G O ; those velocities are in the ratio of CF to C G , or as cos. ACG to cos. AC F , which shows that the effect of FE is always less than that of G O , and consequently the effect must be diminished , by adding a greater number of float-boards ; the said effect will be greatest when there is only one float-board placed vertically , and least when their number is infinite : let us enquire what it will be in this latter case .
We will suppose the same fig. 5 , and the same denominations as in ~ VII .
We had CO=~~~x~d x/ ~ x , we shall have ( neglecting d x2 , d x3 , and d x4 ) ~~C O2 =2~~d x/ ~-x , ~3 C O3/ ~ , and ~4 C O4/ ~ ~=4~~d x/ ~ x. Now the pressure on OM is , by ~ II , =n ~/ 120 ~ x2/ ~ ~ ( v v ( ~ ~ C O2 ) 4~3 v z. ~3 C O3/ ~ + 1/ 2 z z. ~4 C O4/ ~ ~ ) which ( by putting for CO its value ) will become =n ~/ 120 ( 2 ~dx2xd x ) ( v z2 ) whose integral n ~/ 120 ( 2 ~xx x ) ( v z2 ) =n~ ( v z2)/ 120 ( ~ ~f f ) ( making x=~ f ) will express the effect resulting from an infinite number of float-boards : this least effect will be to the greatest , that is when there is but one float-board , as ( v z2 ) : w 4/ 3 v z/ ~ ~3 f3/ ~ ~ff+ 1/ 2 z z/ ~ ~ .
( ~ ~+f f ) or as ( v x2 ) : 1/ 2 w 1/ 4 z z. ( ~ ~+f f/ ~ ~ ) ~ .
VI .
This ratio will be that of 1 : 2 if f=0 1 : 1,485 f= 1/ 2~ 1 : 1f=~ ~ X. If we take nothing but the most advantageous position into consideration , and preserve the greatest effect entire , it follows that the angle BCD ( fig. 6 .
) between two float-boards must be such that E should enter the water at the instant when AB quits the vertical , so that the cosine of that angle be = f/ ~ ; in consequence of which the following table may be constructed , showing what the number of float-boards should be for a given ratio between f and ~ .
For 4 float-boards , we have f= 0 , 5 0,3090~ 6 0,5000~ 7 0,6236~ 8 0,7071~ 9 0,7660~ 10 0,8090~ 12 0,8669~ 14 0,9009~ 16 0,9239~ 18 0,9397~ 20 0,9510~ &amp;c. &amp;c. ~ XI .
Certain authors treating of hydraulics , have in this part thereof given the same table , as containing the true number of float-boards the wheel should consist of : but we have seen upon what principle it was formed , and that it was only to preserve entirely the effect of the vertical float-board ; from whence it follows not that the number of floatboards which it assigns should be the most advantaV O L. LVII .
Ddd geous .
geous .
To which purpose the effect produced from every position of the wheel , and for the different number of the float-boards , should be computed ; the number which gives the arithmetical mean between all these effects , the greatest of all , will be that to be chosen , and preferred before what the above table indicates .
It may be sufficiently satisfactory to compute only the effect from 1 to 10 degrees .
Thus , for example , for the wheel entirely plunged , we are to find the effect ( fig. 7 .
) 1~ on OA , 2~ on OI and gb , 3~ on OH , and fc , 4~ on OG and hd , 5~ on OF , and pe , 6~ on O , 7~ on OD , 8~ onOC , and 9~ on OB .
After which the wheel returns into the same position it had at first ; and we are to divide the sum of all these effects by 9 , to get the arithmetical mean .
We will next suppose the number of six floatboards for the same case of f= 0 , and compute the following effects .
1~ on OG +a A , 3~ on O + nc , 5~ on OI + ~C 2~ OF + mb , 4~ OD 6~ OH+~B .
The sum of all these effects divided by 6 will give the effect of the wheel of 6 float-boards .
The same thing , supposing the angle 40 degrees , or 9 float-boards , and as after a revolution of these 40 degrees , the wheel returns into a similar position , the same must be divided by 4 .
Then for an angle of 30 degrees we are to divide by 3 , and so on .
I have made this computation to great exactness , for the case of f= 0 , f= 1/ 2 ~ , and f= 0 , 866 ~=~ cos. 30~ ; the result , 1~ If f= 0 .
for 4 float-boards , the arith .
mean = 0.335 ( 1/ 20 n~~ ~v v ) .
It may be observed in this first case , that there is some advantage in taking 6 float-boards instead of 4 shown by the table ; the effect will be increased in the ratio of 100 to 118 , and yet will be more than about 92/ 100 of the greatest effect above calculated for a single vertical float-board ; so that the found dimensions must be a small matter altered , and the quantity ~ ~~ increased by 1/ 10 .
for 6= 0,396 ( &amp;c. 9= 0,336 ( &amp;c. 12 = 0,323 ( &amp;c. 18 = 0,295 ( &amp;c. an infinite number = 0,214 ( &amp;c. 2~ If f= 1/ 2 ~ .
for 6 flo .
0,277 ( &amp;c. 7 0,281 ( &amp;c. 9 0,285 ( &amp;c. 12 0,284 ( &amp;c. 18 0,276 ( &amp;c. an infinite number 0,238 ( &amp;c. In this second case 9 float-boards are to be taken instead of 6 shown by the table , though the difference will be but very small ; and we shall have an effect which will be 86/ 100 of that of a vertical float-board , and in that ratio that the quantity ~~ ~ found by the above formulae , must be increased .
3~ If f= 0,866 ~ for 12 fl. = 0,099 ( &amp;c. 18 = 0,099 ( &amp;c. 36 = 0,104 ( &amp;c. an infinite number = 0,103 ( &amp;c. In this third case the difference is still very small , and the effect resulting from 36 float-boards will be ~ of the effect of a single vertical floatboard .

