XXX .
Remarks on the very different Accounts that have been given of the Fecundity of Fishes , with fresh Observations on that Subject : By Mr. Thomas Harmer ; communicated by Samuel Clark , Esq ; F. R. S. THE ascertaining the secundity of the several species of fish , as far at least as we are able to do it , is one point necessary to the making our natural histories perfect ; and at the same time opens a view wonderfully affecting to the imagination .
Read May 28 , 1767 .
The carp , in which Petit is said to have found 342,144 eggs ; and the cod , in one of which of middling size Lewenhoek , it seems , affirmed there were 9,384,000 , have been mentioned as very surprising instances of this fesundity ; and by their being selected by writers , who appear to have been well versed in this part of learning , they should seem to be the most memorable we have of this kind .
The accounts , however , that have been given of the fruitfulness of these two species of fish differ from each other very considerably .
For Bradley , the Botanic Professor at Cambridge some years ago , tells us in his philosophical account of the works of nature , a book professedly written on a very celebrated , though unexecuted plan * , that the increase in some fish is surprising , and to those that are not used to disquisitions of this kind must appear incredible ; he however sinks the number of eggs in these two species extremely , when he tells us the roe of a cod-fish must contain about a million of eggs , and that a carp does not spawn less than 20,000 , to which he adds , and perhaps a tench half as many .
This is making the cod almost ten times less prolific than the other account , and the carp above seventeen times less .
Some other writers , who appear also to have been desirous to impress the mind with the wonders of natural history , have made their estimate still lower .
One of them , I remember in particular , in one of our monthly publications , from whence numbers must take their ideas , who have no opportunity of reading more authentic accounts elsewhere , tells us , that carp and perch have nine or ten thousand eggs , and that cod-fish , and herring , are not less prolific ; and this he calls wonderful .
The increase of cod-fish is indeed , even according to this , very great , but almost a thousand times less than Lewenhoek is said to have found it .
Their accounts being so very different , I thought I should not improperly employ some leisure hours , if I inquired into this matter afresh , and saw what the fecundity of these species of fish really was , as well as of such other sorts as might fall in my way ; and especially as I had found that a small pickerel , whose spawn I had taken a pretty exact account of , from mere curiosity , some time before , contained no fewer than 25,800 eggs : a fish which * Proposed by Mr. Addison in one of the Spectators .
none of these authors had mentioned , and of which notwithstanding a small one had produced a larger number of eggs than Bradley himself had assigned to the carp , which has been always looked upon as remarkable for its prolific quality , not to mention the unknown writer , who makes its fecundity much less .
The make of my eyes , which are much less proper for distinguishing objects at a distance , than the seeing small things that are near ; and my living in a maritime country , and though not near the sea , yet in a situation which I thought very proper for the procuring such fish as I wanted , were additional motives to the search : though as to the last particular , I have since found myself greatly disappointed .
It will not be imagined , that , in order to ascertain the real number of eggs in each fish which I examined , I told them all over one by one ; this would have been , if not absolutely impracticable , at least inconsistent with other engagements , and much more fatiguing than was necessary .
My way was to weigh the whole spawn very exactly ; then to take a piece weighing twenty , thirty , or forty , or more grains , as was most convenient , and after weighing that parcel with care , and giving the turn of the scales to the weights , not to the eggs , to tell them over very carefully ; and then by dividing the number of eggs by the grains , to find how many eggs there were in each grain , or nearly so .
I say nearly , for there must , according to this method , have been rather more ; but I chose to estimate them after this manner , that there might be no danger of representing the fecundity of these animals greater than the truth .
I frequently boiled the portions of spawn that I told , and after macerating them some hours in water , gently pressed them with a penknife , whose point I afterwards made use of to number them distinctly , by separating them from each other to greater distances , after they were rendered by that gentle squeezing fitter for telling over .
In several fish I found their eggs of very different sizes .
In such cases my rule was , to tell all I could distinguish by my naked eye , and those only ; though I have often found , by the help of an eye-glass , that , by thus limiting myself , I passed over great multitudes of eggs that might justly have been counted * .
I generally told them on a fine earthen * For , though they were very different in size , they were all , I presume , to be deposited in the proper places for hatching that season , though it may be not on the same day , since after fish are shotten , as it is called , we find no eggs at all in them .
I think I do not by any means take upon me to affirm , that all fish deposit their eggs after this manner , i. e. by degrees , and at times a little distant from each other ; but some species of them , I should think it is plain , do .
This is the case of stickleback in particular , in which , when they have been extremely distended with spawn , I have found several eggs very large , but several hundreds very small , and many of them too small to be counted distinctly by an unassisted eye , which smaller ones could never , I apprehend , grow to the size the larger ones had grown to before thelarger ones were excluded .
I have seen some of these eggs so large , that 24 or 25 would weigh a grain ; about which size , I believe , they are excluded , since some of that bulk came away from one of those creatures after it was taken out of the water , and were found in the paper in which it was wrapped up : but generally upon opening these fish they are not quite so large , though very large in comparison of many of the rest .
I told in one of these smallest of fishes , which weighed very little more than 14 gr. spawn and all , about 936 eggs , some of which almost eluded my eye , besides vessel , which was extremely black , by which means I could much better discern them , than I otherwise should have been able to do .
The weights I have reckoned by are Avoirdupois weights ; but there being no weights of that sort small enough to answer all purposes , I was obliged to make use of grains along with them , of which I reckon 4371/ 2 make an ounce Avoirdupois .
After this manner I made the observations of which I am going to give an account , with all the nicety and care I was capable of .
I begin with the herring , which makes a distinguished figure in these two counties of Norfolk and Suffolk , and a considerable part of our commerce , when salted and smoked .
One of the above-mentioned authors supposed , they may have 9 or 10,000 eggs : of several I examined , I found none which had so few as 20,000 ; and in one I found 36,960 .
The intermediate numbers which appeared to me on numbers of others that I could not tell at all .
Those that I told were of all sizes ; and though there were but 56 very large eggs , yet the creature was extremely distended .
Now it does not appear possible that all the 936 eggs should grow to the bulk of the largest of their companions without destroying the fish , since the growing of 56 to such a size as to weigh about 11/ 2 grain distended it in such a manner as I have hardly seen in any other species of fish .
In some very large sticklebacks , which weighed 45 or 50 grains , I have found between 2 and 300 of these large eggs , along with great numbers of smaller ones , so that the number of large eggs seems to bear some proportion to the size of the fish , by which means a greater number of eggs , answerable to their size , may be deposited in the same time in which the smaller fish of this species discharge their less numerous spawn .
I will only farther observe here , that if this be the case as to the other fish , the number of their eggs may , on this account , appear very different to different observers .
examination , may be met with in a table that I shall place at the end of this paper , which will give the particulars relating to this sort of fish , and several others , in the shortest manner , but with sufficient distinctness .
The next that came under my inspection was the smelt .
These , it is well known , are a very small sort of fish , and are frequently used for garnish to those that are larger .
In one of these , which did not weigh quite two ounces , I found 38,272 eggs ; and in none so few as 20,000 ; excepting one , which was extremely small , not weighing above 2891/ 2 grains , in which very small fish I found 14,411 .
This was amazing .
I was much more surprised , when , after this , I learnt what was the fecundity of mackarel .
This no author that I met with gave an account of , though it is a fish so extremely common .
In one large fish of this kind , weighing somewhat better than 11/ 4lb , I found 454,961 eggs ; in a second , of much the same weight , 430,846 ; and in a third , which weighed but about 1 lb 20z .
I found 546,681 .
I was astonished upon this , that Bradley should call the supposed fecundity of carp , which he makes to be but about 20,000 , so surprising ; or that even Petit 's observation , which made it appear , that in some fish of that species the eggs amount to 342,144 , should cause the carp to be selected as the most extraordinary fish for increase , after the cod , when it appears to be so much greater in mackarel ( which is at the same time so common a fish ) , as to be not much short of the proportion of 5 to 3 , in the last I examined .
I shall leave it to the table at the close , to give an account of the prolific quality of some other fish , whose eggs I have counted , and shall pass on to what I have found in the carp , which species Petit examined .
As to this fish , though I cannot say I have found the eggs , in those that have come under my notice , so numerous as he did ; yet , as I have found the number much larger than Bradley mentions , so I make no doubt but that Petit really found them amount to 342,144 ; and I would add , that I dare say they may be found to be much more numerous still in large fish of this kind , since in one that I examined , weighing but 163/ 4 oz. I found 101,200 ; and in another , which weighed no more than 251/ 2 oz. I found 203,109 , and carp grow to a much larger size than the biggest of these , but I could not procure any of those large carp that were full of spawn .
If I failed in verifying Petit 's number of eggs in a carp , I found those of a tench to exceed it , more than once , which Bradley reckons not to produce more than half the number a carp does , or 10,000 .
For I found in one tench , which weighed 21/ 2 lb , 383,252 eggs at least ; and in another that weighed not quite 13/ 4 lb , 350,482 .
As to perch , which one of those authors I mentioned puts upon a par with carp , I could get none of any size .
The largest , which weighed but 8 oz. 9 dr .
contained 28,323 eggs ; and a second of 5 oz. 10 dr .
had in it 20,582 .
They seem , however , to be much less prolific , in proportion to their bulk , than tench , since the largest of these had but about 28,323 eggs , and I found a tench of nearly that size , weighing but 8 oz. 143/ 4 dr .
produced 83,104 .
Bradley seems to have been as careful not to be guilty of exaggeration with respect to the cod-fish , as in the other cases .
He estimates them at a million , while Lewenhoek affirmed that he found above nine millions of eggs , in one of middling size .
The spawn of one of that size which I examined , that is to say , one of 18 or 20lb weight , I found to contain between three and four millions , if my friend 's weights were accurate , for I made the examination at a distance from home ; and by a subsequent observation at home , I have reason to think there was this number in it , though I was prevented pursuing my second examination so far as I would have done , by some particular occurrences .
According to this , there is nothing incredible in Lewenhoeck 's account ; his fish , I suppose , being remarkably distended with spawn , and for that reason perhaps thought , by that inquisitive and curious person , a subject that ought not to pass unexamined .
I have hitherto mentioned no flat fish , nor do I remember that any author has given us an account of their fecundity .
I imagined , from their make , it could not be extraordinary ; I was therefore extremely surprised to find in the first flounder I examined and which did not weigh quite three ounces , 133,407 eggs ; in a second , which weighed little more than 31/ 2 ounces , 225,568 ; and much more still when I discovered in a large one , that weighed about 241/ 4 oz. and which was of that sort that is spotted like a plaise , as Ray has told us some flounders are , 1,357,400 : this was truly astonishing .
The number of eggs that a soal produces , I have observed to be great , but nothing like that which I found in flounders , finding in one , which did not fall much short of a pound , rather more than 100,000 ; and in another , that weighed about five ounces , 38,772 .
To make this disquisition still more extensive , I examined two or three kinds of shell-fish .
I found in a lobster of 141/ 2 oz. when in the shell , and of 103/ 4 , when divested of it , 7,227 ; and in another that weighed 21/ 4 ~ , and out of the shell somewhat better than 13/ 4 ~ , I told 21,699 eggs .
I took also the pains to tell all the eggs of some shrimps , one by one , and found in one which weighed 171/ 2 grains only , 3057 ; in another of 31 gr. 4090 ; and in a third of 39 gr. 6807 .
This , considering the smallness of the creature , is more remarkable than the fruitfulness of the lobster ; but neither is the one or the other to be compared , in this respect , to the crab , for in a large one , weighing near 11/ 4 ~ , but not quite , I found that the spawn weighed 687 gr. but the eggs were so minute , and at the same time adhered so close together , that I could not number them distinctly ; however , the weight of the whole , and the minuteness of the eggs , show that they must have been very numerous ; and I believe from a rough estimate I made , that they exceeded a million .
The table , at the close , gives all these accounts , with the addition of several more particulars , in a very short compass .
The first column contains the names of the fish which I examined ; the second theirweight ; the third the weight of their spawn ; the fourth their fecundity ; and , as I supposed some persons might be desirous to know how large a portion of spawn I weighed in each case , I have set down the number of grains in each such portion , in a fifth ; the number of eggs found in a grain , by this method is seen in a sixth , by which we may give some guess at the different sizes the eggs of each species are of , when they are excluded ; and I have made the time of examining each fish respectively a seventh ; which possibly may be of some use to those who may have an inclination to repeat any of these observations , as from thence may be learnt something concerning the most advantageous time of examining these creatures , which certainly ought to be as nearly as we can , when the eggs are come to their full size , and before any of them are deposited .
However , after all , if my notion is just , that some species deposit a part of their eggs come to their full growth , before others laid the same year are big enough to be told with distinctness , the accounts of the fecundity of such fish must be extremely defective ; and this I apprehend , amongst those I have examined , is the case of mackarel , carp , tench , and some others ; in herring , &amp;c. there does not appear such a difference in the size of different eggs .
From this table it appears , that the size of the eggs is nearly the same in great and small fishes of the same species , at the same time of the year ; that the quantity of spawn is , usually , nearly proportionate to the size of the animal , from whence we may give a tolerable guess at the greatest fecundity of each species , if we know to what weight they have been found to grow while in a breeding state ; we may likewise settle their produce at a medium , upon learning what is the mean size of each species when in the forementioned state , but we see , however , that this is not universal , nor consequently perfectly exact , some fish being much more prolific than others of the same size , and species .
To conclude , the great fecundity of fish is not the only thing that affects the imagination , when we are examining matters of this sort : the extreme disproportion between their size when they first appear in the water after hatching , and that of their full-grown state , as well as the little proportion that is to be observed between the bulk of fish of different species and that of their eggs , are things that are very amazing to persons of a curious turn .
The egg of a smelt , which at its full growth weighs but two or three ounces , appeared , in those I examined , to be larger than those of a cod-fish , which weighed eighteen or twenty pounds , and might have grown to double that bulk ; and that of a stickleback , which is the smallest of all known fish , was found to be above six times bigger than the largest I ever observed in a smelt .
What becomes of such amazing numbers of young fish , and why some are made so extremely prolific , the flounder and crab in particular among the smaller sorts , would doubtless be highly entertaining subjects , if duly illustrated ; but these are enquiries I have no opportunity of making .
The TABL E. 1 .
2 .
3 .
4 .
5 .
6 .
7 .
Names of the fish .
Their weight Weight ~ Fecundity The portion No.of eggs Time of exam .
the ~ of sp.~ to a~ oz. dr .
grains .
grains .
Carp No. 1 16 12 1265 101.200 46 80 May 25 No. 2 25 8 2571 203.109 55 79 April 4 Cod-fish 12.540 3.686.760 29 294 Dec. 23 Flounder No. 12 14 1821/ 2 133.407 23 731 Feb. 21 No. 23 81/ 2 152 225.568 19 1484 Dec. 18 No. 36 12 598 351.026 263/ 4 587 March 14 No. 4 24 4 2.200 1.357.400 241/ 2 617 do .
Herring No. 143 367 32.663 48 89 Oct. 8 , 1763 No. 25 2361/ 2 21.285 481/ 2 90 29 No. 33 13 259 23.569 521/ 2 91 Oct. 2 , 1764 No. 45 10 480 36.960 53 77 25 No. 54 61/ 2 366 29.646 57 81 do .
No. 648 4201/ 2 27.753 51 66 Nov. 3 No. 751 4901/ 2 32.863 411/ 2 67 Oct. 18 Lobster No. 1 14 8 7227 14 April 4 No. 2 36 0 1671 21.699 129 Aug. 11 Mackarel No. 1 20 1027 454.961 33 443 June 20,1764 No. 2 20 949 430.846 241/ 2 454 29 No. 3 18 12231/ 2 546.681 321/ 2 447 18,1765 Perch No. 189 7651/ 2 28.323 85 37 April 5 No. 25 10 502 20.582 85 41 ~ Pickerel No. 1 56 4 51001/ 2 49 304 70 92/ 3 April 25 No. 2 3248 80.388 761/ 2 243/ 4 Nov. 25 No. 3 48 101/ 2 3184 33.432 43 101/ 2 March 19 Prawn No. 1 ( 127 gr. ) 3.806 243 May 12 No. 2 ( 941/ 2 gr. ) 3.479 287 d~ .
No. 3 ( 1001/ 2 gr. ) 3.579 247 do .
1 .
2 .
3 .
4 .
5 .
6 .
7 .
Names of the fish .
Their weight Weight of Fecundity The portion No.ofeggs Time of exam .
the spawn of sp.weighed to a grain oz. dr .
grains .
grains .
Roach ( or what No. 12 114 9.604 April 4 I took to be of No. 268 671 43.615 68 65 May 4 1764 that species ) No. 338 3461/ 2 29.799 421/ 2 86 do .
No. 422 153 9.486 421/ 2 62 5 No. 5 10 61/ 2 361 81.586 39 226 2 1765 No. 69 103/ 4 417 113.841 42 273 6 No. 738 2131/ 2 45.475 20 213 24 Shrimp ( with No. 1 ( 171/ 2 gr. ) 3 3.057 1000 May 3 light coloured No. 2 ( 39 gr. ) 7 6.807 972 do .
spawn .
) No. 3 4.601 do .
Ditto ( with No. 1 ( 31 gr. ) 5 4.090 818 do .
dark colour ) No. 2 ( 22 gr. ) 4 2.849 712 do .
Smelt No. 12 1491/ 2 38.278 30 256 Feb. 21 No. 2 ( 2891/ 2 gr. ) 50 14.411 288 Mar.21,1764 No. 31 14 1571/ 2 29.925 401/ 2 190 27,1765 No. 41 12 1451/ 2 30.991 20 213 28 No. 517 149 24.287 20 163 do .
No. 615 136 23.800 20 175 do .
Soal No. 1 14 8 5421/ 2 100.362 20 185 June 13 No. 25 1791/ 2 38.772 20 216 28 Tench No. 1 40 383.252* May 28,1764 No. 2 28 8 5331/ 2 280.087 25 525 3,1765 No. 38 143/ 4 224 83.104 20 371 10 No. 498 2841/ 2 108.963 20 383 do .
No. 5 12 8 366 138.348 221/ 4 378 do .
No. 6 27 91/ 2 1969 350.482 23 178 June 11 No. 7 14 15 866 138.560 20 160 do .
* No. 1 .
of the tench certainly had a much larger number of eggs ; but being extremely distended with spawn , and unluckily let fall before it was brought to me , the enveloping skin in which the eggs were contained was broke , which made it difficult to determine some circumstances relating to this fish ; it however had the number of eggs I have set down , at the lowest way of reckoning , and I believe many thousands more .
I have taken no notice of several fractions in the number of eggs contained in a grain in many cases , choosing to fall rather below than to exceed the truth , in all the fish I have given an account of in this table .
I have been scrupulously exact in all particulars , excepting what are contained in the second column , which gives the weight of the fish I examined , in which the utmost nicety was not necessary : some few might weigh a little more or a little less ; but all were nearly of the weight set down , and much the greatest part exactly so .

