Received April 24 , 1767 .
XXVII .
An Inquiry into the probable Parallax , and Magnitude of the fixed Stars , from the Quantity of Light which they afford us , and the particular Circumstances of their Situation , by the Rev. John Michell , B. D. F. R. S. THOUGH no man can at present doubt , that the want of a sensible parallax in the fixed stars , is owing to their immense distance , yet it may not perhaps be disagreeable to see , that this distance is farther confirmed by other circumstances ; for let us suppose them to be , at a medium , equal in magnitude and natural brightness to the sun , to which they seem in all respects to be analogous .
And , having laid this down as a foundation to build upon , let us inquire what would be the parallax of the sun , if he were to be removed so far from us , as to make the quantity of the light , which we should then receive from him , no more than equal to that of the fixed stars .
In order to do this with accuracy , it would be proper to compare the quantity of light ; which we at present receive from him , with that of the fixed stars , by some such methods , as are made use of by Monsieur Bouguer Read May 7 , and Bouguer in his Traite d'Optique a ; but as my present purpose does not require any such exactness , I shall deduce it in a more gross way from facts already well known .
I shall assume Saturn then in opposition , exclusively of his ring ( and when the earth and he are at their mean distances from the Sun ) as equal or nearly equal in light to the most luminous fixed star .
Now the mean distance of Saturn from the Sun , being equal to about 2082 of the Sun 's semidiameters , the density of the Sun 's light , at Saturn , will consequently be less than at his own surface , in the proportion of the square of 2082 ( or 4334724 ) to 1 .
If Saturn therefore was to reflect all the light , that falls upon him , he would be less luminous in the same proportion ; but , besides this difference in his brightness , his apparent diameter , in opposition , is at most but 105th part of that of the Sun , and consequently the quantity of light , which we receive from him , must again be diminished in the proportion of the square of 105 ( or 11025 ) to 1 .
If we multiply these two numbers together , we shall have the whole of the light of the Sun to that of Saturn ( upon the supposition of his reflecting all the light , that falls upon him ) as the square of nearly 220000 ( or 48,400,000,000 ) to 1 ; and removing the Sun to 220000 times his present distance , he would still appear at least as bright as Saturn , and his whole parallax upon the diameter of the earth 's orbit would be less than two seconds .
This must consequently be assumed for the parallax of the brightest of the fixed stars , upon the supposition that their light does not exceed that of Saturn .
a This work was published at Paris in 1760 .
By a like computation we shall find , that the distance , at which the Sun would afford us as much light , as we receive from Jupiter , is not less than 46000 times his present distance , and his whole parallax , in that case , upon the diameter of the earth 's orbit , would not be more than nine seconds , the light of Jupiter and Saturn , as seen from the Earth , being in the ratio of about 22 to 1 , when they are both in opposition , and supposing them to reflect equally in proportion to the whole of the light that falls upon them .
But if Jupiter and Saturn , instead of reflecting the whole of the light , that falls upon them , should in fact reflect only a part of it , as for example , only a fourth or sixth ( and this may very possibly be the case ) , we must then increase the distances computed above , in the proportion of 2 or 21/ 2 to 1 , to make the Sun 's light no more than equal to theirs ; and his parallax would be less , in the same proportion , than those already mentioned a. Upon the supposition then , that the fixed stars are of the same magnitude and brightness with the Sun , it is no wonder , that their parallax should have hitherto escaped observation , since , if this is the case , it could hardly amount to two seconds , and probably a The light , which we receive from the full Moon ( according to Monsieur Bouguer 's experiments in the work above-mentioned ) , is only a 300000th part of that which we receive from the Sun , whereas it ought to amount to no less than a 45000th part of it , according to the principles , which we have made use of in computing the quantity of light derived from Jupiter and Saturn ; so that the Moon , as appears from these experiments , reflects no more than between a sixth and a seventh part of the light that falls upon her .
not more than one in Sirius himself ; though he had been placed in the pole b of the ecliptic , and in those , that appear much less luminous , such for example as ~ draconis , which is only of the third magnitude , it could hardly be expected to be sensible with such instruments as have hitherto been used in search of it .
We have assumed the magnitude of the fixed stars , as well as their brightness , to be equal to those of the sun ; it is however probable , that there may be a very great difference amongst them in both these respects ; and how much soever we may therefore be wide of the truth , in attempting to fix the distance of particular stars from this reasoning , yet there is a very great probability , that their mean distances , settled by this method , will not be much out , some exceeding and some falling short of it .
And perhaps the consideration , that a star must be a thousand times as great , caeteris paribus , to appear equally bright , if it is placed at ten times the distance , may serve to make it probable , that the limits of the errors , which we are likely to commit , in judging by such a rule , are not so great as we might otherwise imagine them to be .
With regard to the difference there may be in the native brightness of different stars , though it is probably very considerable , yet I think we can hardly suppose , that it is equal to their difference in magnitude , at least if we except those , which are subject to certain changes , and which for that reason we may suppose to be luminous in some parts of their surfaces b The latitude of Sirius being only 39~ 33~ , his parallax will be a little less than two thirds of the whole parallax .
only .
In other instances we may perhaps judge in some degree of the native brightness of different stars with respect to one another by their colour ; those , which afford the whitest light , being probably the most luminous a. a We have at present no means of judging of the comparative brightness of the Sun and of the fixed stars , in proportion to their respective sizes , excepting from the comparison of the Sun 's brightness with that of our common fires ; but the Sun 's light exceeds the light of our brightest fires in so very great a proportion , ( viz. of some thousands to one ) that we want some middle terms to be able to form any analogy , which might serve to carry us farther .
We find however in general , that those fires , which produce the whitest light , are much the brightest , and that the Sun , which produces a whiter light than any fires we commonly make , vastly exceeds them all in brightness ; it is not therefore improbable , from this general analogy , that those stars , which exceed the Sun in the whiteness of their light , may also exceed him in their native brightness ; now this is the case with regard to many of them ; and , on the contrary , there are some that are of a redder colour .
If however it should hereafter be found , that any of the stars have others revolving about them ( for no satellites shining by a borrowed light could possibly be visible ) , we should then have the means of discovering the proportion between the light of the Sun , and the light of those stars , relatively to their respective quantities of matter ; for in this case , the times of the revolutions , and the greatest apparent elongations of those stars , that revolved about the others as satellites , being known , the relation between the apparent diameters and the densities of the central stars would be given , whatever was their distance from us : and the actual quantity of matter which they contained would be known , whenever their distance was known , being greater or less in the proportion of the cube of that distance .
Hence , supposing them to be of the same density with the Sun , the proportion of the brightness of their surfaces , compared with that of the Sun , would be known from the comparison of the whole of the light which we receive from them , with that which we receive from the Sun ; but , if they should happen to be either of greater or less density than the Sun , the whole of their light not being As far then as we can guess at the parallax of the fixed stars from the principles above laid down , we may reasonably expect , that it should be exceedingly small even in those of the first magnitude ; yet , besides the probability , that some of them may be either less , or less luminous than the Sun , it is not so small as to leave us altogether without hopes , that we may some time or other be able to discover it in some of them ; for I think it is not impracticable to construct instruments , capable of distinguishing even to the 20th part of a second , provided the air will admit of that degree of exactness ; but such instruments must be upon a plan a good deal different from those hitherto made use of , as they would otherwise be not only vastly too expensive , but also much too great and unwieldy to be of any use .
But whatever room there may be to hope , that we may some time or other be able to discover the parallax of a few amongst the fixed stars , yet at the same time it seems probable , that we shall never be able to discover any sensible magnitude in their apparent diameters , which in Sirius himself , if he is not of less native brightness than the Sun , must be considerably less , whatever be his parallax , than the affected by these suppositions , their surfaces would indeed be more or less luminous , accordingly as they were , upon this account , less or greater ; but the quantity of light , corresponding to the same quantity of matter , would still remain the same .
The apparent distances , at which satellites would revolve about any stars , would be equal to the semiannual parallaxes of those stars , seen .
from planets revolving about the Sun , in the same periodical times with themselves , supposing the parallaxes to be such , as they would be , if the stars were of the same size and density with the Sun .
hundreth , probably than the two hundreth part of a second ; so that it would scarcely be distinguishable with a telescope , upon the former supposition , that should magnify six , or , upon the latter with one , that should magnify twelve thousand times .
Nor can we well expect to find their apparent diameters from any occultation by the moon , since a diameter of the hundredth part of a second would be covered by the moon , if it entered directly , in less than the fiftieth part of a second of time , and therefore a star can hardly enter so obliquely , as to appear to vanish by degrees ; no star probably , which the moon can pass over , subtending an angle half so great .
A star might however appear to vanish by degrees in an occultation by the planet Venus , especially if the occultation was to happen only a little before or after either station ; but this is an event , which can occur so very seldom , that little is to be expected from it ; and if Venus should be surrounded with an atmosphere , which is probably the case , it might very possibly then be of no service at all .
For the same reasons also it is probable , that nothing can be determined from occultations by any of the rest of the planets , which upon other accounts are still less proper for the purpose than Venus .
There seems to be little chance therefore of discovering with certainty the real size of any of the fixed stars , and we must consequently be contented to deduce it from their parallax ( if that should ever be found ) and the quantity of light which they afford us , compared with that of the Sun .
And in the mean time , till this parallax can be found , or something else may arise to furnish us with a more general analogy , we can only suppose them , at a medium , to be equal in size to the Sun , this being the best means , which we have at present of forming some probable conjecture concerning the extent of the visible universe .
That we may be the better enabled to do this , it seems to be an object worth the attention of Astronomers , to enquire into the exact quantity of light , which each star affords us separately , when compared with the Sun ; that , instead of distributing them , as has hitherto been done , into a few ill defined classes , they may be ranked with precision both according to their respective brightness , and the exact degree of it .
A catalogue of the stars formed upon this plan , would answer several good purposes ; for , besides giving us a more just and certain notion of their general distances , it would perhaps help us , especially if the parallax of a few amongst them should be discovered likewise , to trace some analogies in their situation , which might enable us to determine both their distances , and other circumstances relating to them , with still more probability ; and it would be a standing register , by which future Astronomers might inform themselves of many variations , of which we are now ignorant for want of an ancient register of that kind .
From what has been said above , I think it is very probable , that we shall not be a great way from the truth in estimating the whole parallax of Sirius at one second , supposing him to be of the same size and native brightness with the Sun ; this therefore I shall assume as a standard , till some better experiments shall inform us more exactly of the quantity of his light .
Now , according to the best judgment I have been able to make from some gross experiments , the quantity of light which we receive from Sirius does not exceed the light which we receive from the least fixed stars of the sixth magnitude in a greater proportion than that of 1000 to 1 , nor in a less proportion than that of 400 to 1 ; and the smaller stars of the second magnitude seem to be about a mean proportional between the two .
Hence the whole parallax of the least fixed stars of the sixth magnitude , supposing them of the same size and native brightness with the Sun , should be from about 2~ to 3~ , and their distance from about eight to twelve million times that of the Sun : and the parallax of the smaller stars of the second magnitude , upon the same supposition , should be about 12~ , and their distance about two million times that of the Sun .
I have hitherto argued about the distances of the fixed stars , upon the supposition of their being of the same size and brightness with the Sun ; and , if this was really so , those which appear the brightest must be the nearest to us .
That this is in general the case , I suppose , will be very readily allowed ; for , though it is true , that a much greater degree of real magnitude may compensate for the greatness of distance , and there is no reason for assigning any one limit to them rather than another ; yet , when it is as likely that the largest stars should be in any one part of space as in any other , the probability in favour of this hypothesis is very great : the real motions also , which have been observed amongst several of the brightest of the fixed stars , is another argument to the same purpose ; and we shall find it still farther confirmed by very strong arguments of analogy drawn from the circumstances of the particular situation of the stars in the heavens .
It has always been usual with Astronomers to dispose the fixed stars into constellations : this has been done for the sake of remembering and distinguishing them , and therefore it has in general been done merely arbitrarily , and with this view only ; nature herself however seems to have distinguished them into groups .
What I mean is , that , from the apparent situation of the stars in the heavens , there is the highest probability , that , either by the original act of the Creator , or in consequence of some general law ( such perhaps as gravity ) they are collected together in great numbers in some parts of space , whilest in others there are either few or none .
The argument , I intend to make use of , in order to prove this , is of that kind , which infers either design , or some general law , from a general analogy , and the greatness of the odds against things having been in the present situation , if it was not owing to some such cause .
Let us then examine what it is probable would have been the least apparent distance of any two or more stars , any where in the whole heavens , upon the supposition that they had been scattered by mere chance , as it might happen .
Now it is manifest , upon this supposition , that every star being as likely to be in any one situation as another , the probability , that any one particular star should happen to be within a certain distance ( as for example one degree ) of any other given star , would be represented ( according to the common way of computing chances ) by a fraction , whose numerator would be to it 's denominator , as a circle of one degree radius , to a circle , whose radius is the diameter of a great circle ( this last quantity being equal to the whole surface of the sphere ) that is , by the fraction 60~2/ 6875.5~2 , of , reducing it to a decimal form,.000076154 ( that is , about 1 in 13131 ) and the complement of this to unity , viz..999923846 , or the fraction 13130/ 13131 , will represent the probability that it would not be so .
But , because there is the same chance for any one star to be within the distance of one degree from any given star , as for every other , multiplying this fraction into itself as many times as shall be equivalent to the whole number of stars , of not less brightness than those in question , and putting n for this number,.999923846n , or the fraction 13130~n/ 13131 will represent the probability , that no one of the whole number of stars n would be within one degree from the proposed given star ; and the complement of this quantity to unity will represent the probability , that there would be some one star or more , out of the whole number n , within the distance of one degree from the given star .
And farther , because the same event is equally likely to happen to any one star as to any other , and therefore any one of the whole number of stars n might as well have been taken for the given star as any other , we must again repeat the last found chance n times , and consequently consequently the number.999923846n~n , or the fraction 13130n~n/ 1313~n~ will represent the probability , that no where , in the whole heavens ; any two stars , amongst those in question , would be within the distance of one degree from each other ; and the complement of this quantity to unity will represent the probability of the contrary .
By a like reasoning , if we would compute the probability , upon the same supposition , that no two stars should be , one within the given distance x , and the other within the given distance z of some one particular star , we must , first , find the probability , that no star , of the whole number of stars n , would be within the distance x from the given star , which will be represented , as before , by the fraction 6875.5~2-xx/ 6875.5~2~n and , secondly , we must find the probability , that no star , of the whole number of stars n , would be within the distance z from the given star , which , for the same reason , will be represented by the fraction 6875 5~2-zz/ 6875 5~2~n ; and the complements of these to unity will represent the respective probabilities of the contrary : but the probability that two events shall both happen , is the product of the respective probabilities of those two events multiplied together ; if therefore we multiply the two last mentioned complements together , we shall have the probability , that some two stars would be , one within the distance x , and the other within the distance z from the given star ; and the complement of this to unity , will be the probability , that it would not be so : let us now suppose c/ d to represent this last quantity , and , because the same event may as well happen in respect to any one star , as any other , multiplying this quantity into itself n times , according to the number of the stars , we shall have c/ d~n representing the probability , that no where , in the whole heavens , would be found any two stars , one within the distance x , and the other within the distance z from the same star .
If now we compute , according to the principles above laid down , what the probability is , that no two stars , in the whole heavens , should have been within so small a distance from each other , as the two stars ~ Capricorni , to which I shall suppose about 230 stars only to be equal in brightness , we shall find it to be about 80 to 1 .
For an example , where more than two stars are concerned , we may take the six brightest of the Pleiades , and , supposing the whole number of those stars , which are equal in splendor to the faintest of these , to be about 1500 , we shall find the odds to be near 500000 to 1 , that no six stars , out of that number , scattered at random , in the whole heavens , would be within so small a distance from each other , as the Pleiades are a. a The computations of these probabilities are as follow .
The distance between the two stars ~ Capricorni is something less than 3~ 1/ 3 ; according to the rule above laid down , therefore , if we suppose 230 stars equal to these in brightness , the probaIf , If , besides these examples that are obvious to the naked eye , we extend the same argument to the smaller bility , that no two stars of that brightness will be found , any where in the whole heavens , within the distance of 3~ 1/ 3 from each other , will be represented by the fraction 6875.52-3.33 &amp;c. 2/ 6875.52~230X230 .
From twice the Log. of 6875.5 [ 7.6746086 ] then , subtract twice the Log. of 3.33 &amp;c. [ 1.0457496 ] and the remainder 6.6288590 will be the Log. of the number of times , that 3.33 &amp; ~.2 is contained in 6875.52 viz. 4254603 times , and consequently 4254602/ 4254603~230X230 will be equivalent to the former fraction .
From the Log. of 4254602 , subtract the Log. of 4254603 , and the remainder will be-.000000102 , the proportional part for an unit in the number 4254603 : this multiplied into 230 times 230 , or 52900 , gives -.0053958 , the Log. of the whole quantity , which corresponds to the proportional part for an unit between 80 and 81 ; this quantity therefore is equivalent to the fraction 80/ 81 nearly , the complement of which to unity is 1/ 81 .
In the Pleiades , the five stars Taygeta , Electra , Merope , Alcyone , and Atlas are respectively at the distances of 11 , 191/ 2 , 241/ 2 , 27 , and 49 minutes from the star Maia nearly .
From 7.6746086 , twice the Log. of 6875.5 , then , as before , subtract 2.0827854 , twice the Log. of 11 ( the number of minutes between Taygeta and Maia ) and the remainder 5.5918232 will be the Log. of the number of times , that 112 is contained in 6875.52 viz. 390682 times ; and consequently a fraction , whose denominator is this number , and whose numerator is this number less by an unit , multiplied into itself 1500 times , will represent the probability , that no star out of 1500 , scattered by chance in the whole heavens , would be within the distance of 11 minutes from the star Maia .
From the Log. of 390681 therefore subtract the Log. of 390682 , as in the former example , and the remainder will be-.00000111 , the proportional part for an unit in the number 390682 , which multiplied by 1500 will give us-.0016650 for the Log. of the probability sought .
In like manner from stars , as well those that are collected together in clusters , such for example , as the Praesepe Cancri , 7.6746086 subtract 2 5800692 , twice the Log. of 191/ 2 ( the number of minutes between Electra and Maia ) and the remainder will be 5 0945394 , the proportional part for an unit corresponding to the natural number of which will be-.00000349 ; and 1500 times this quantity , or-.0052350 will be the Log. of the quantity , representing the probability , that no star out of 1500 scattered by chance would be within the distance of 191/ 2 minutes from Maia .
If we follow the same rule for the three remaining stars Merope , Alcyone , and Atlas , we shall find the similar Logs .
corresponding to these to be-.0076650 , -.0100395 , and.0330300 respectively .
The natural numbers corresponding to these five Logs .
taken in the same order , are.996173,.988018 , .982506,.977148 , and.926766 , which severally express the respective probabilities , that no stars out of 1500 scattered by chance , would be within the same distances , at which the five stars above mentioned are found to be , from Maia .
The complements of these quantities to unity.003827,.011982,.017494 , .022852 , and.073234 , which severally express the respective probabilities , on the contrary , that such stars would be found within the distances above specified from the star Maia , must all be multiplied together , to determine the probability , that these events should all take place at the same time .
The sum of the Logs .
of these numbers is 9 +.1279139 or-8.8720861 , which is therefore the Log. of all these numbers multiplied together ; and subtracting this number from 0 , or , what amounts to the same thing , changing the sign , we shall have the Log. of the number of times that this quantity is contained in unity , that is , about 744880000 times ; a fraction , therefore , whose denominator is this number , and its numerator unity , will represent the probability in favour of all these events taking place together ; and a fraction , whose denominator is the same number , and its numerator the same number less by an unit , will represent the probability of the contrary .
But , as this event might as well have happened to any other star as to Maia , we must multiply this last fraction into itself 1500 times , according to the supposed number of stars , to find the probability , that it should not have happened any where in the whole heavens .
Now the proportional part for an unit upon this number is-.0000000005825 , which multiplied the nebula in the hilt of Perseus 's sword , &amp;c. as to those stars , which appear double , treble , &amp;c. when seen through telescopes , we shall find it still infinitely more conclusive , both in the particular instances , and in the general analogy , arising from the frequency of them .
We may from hence , therefore , with the highest probability conclude ( the odds against the contrary opinion being many million millions to one ) that the stars are really collected together in clusters in some places , where they form a kind of systems , whilst in others there are either few or none of them , to whatever cause this may be owing , whether to their mutual gravitation , or to some other law or appointment of the Creator .
And the natural conclusion from hence is , that it is highly probable in particular , and next to a certainty in general , that such double stars , &amp;c. as appear to consist of two or more stars placed very near together , do really consist of stars placed near together , and under the influence of some general law , whenever the proby 1500 gives us-.00000087377 , the proportional part for an unit in somewhat more than 496000 .
But it must be observed , that this number is smaller than it ought to be upon two accounts ; for , in the first place , this method of computation gives only the probability , that no five stars would be within the distance above specified from a sixth , if they occupied the largest space , they possibly could do , under that limitation ; and secondly , we have made no allowance upon account of the different magnitudes , which , if it had been attended to , would have given a somewhat greater result .
These considerations , however would have made the reasoning a good deal more intricate ; and we have no need to descend to minutiae , a difference in the proportion of 10 to 1 not at all affecting the general conclusion .
bability is very great , that there would not have been any such stars so near together , if all those , that are not less bright than themselves , had been scattered at random through the whole heavens .
After what has been said , it will be natural to inquire , whether , if the stars are in general collected into systems , the Sun does not likewise make one of some system ; and which are those , amongst the fixed stars , that belong to the same system with himself .
Now , supposing the stars of one system to be , in general and at a medium , of the same size and brightness with those of another , the number of stars of any one apparent magnitude would bear the same proportion to the number of stars of any other apparent magnitude , as they would do , in case all the stars were scattered uniformly , and not in systems , provided the eye was not placed in or near to one of those systems .
And , in this case , the brightness decreasing , as the square of the distance inversely , and the sphere , in which they are included , increasing , as the cube of the distance directly , the number of stars of any one degree of brightness and upwards , should be , as the cube of the square root of that brightness .
Supposing then the faintest of the 2000 brightest stars to be less bright than the faintest of the first 70 , in the proportion of about 30 to 1 ( and I think the difference is not less than this ) this number is smaller , than we might have expected , if the Sun was not one of a system , in the proportion of 2000 to about 12000 or 1 to 6 ; but I shall lay the less stress upon this argument , for want of a more certain determination of the proportion of light , which we receive from the stars of different magnitudes .
If , however , upon a more accurate examination , it should be found , that the quantity of light above assigned is not far from the truth , or if the difference of light should be greater than I have supposed it to be ( in which case the argument will be still stronger ) ; this will add a considerable degree of weight to the other arguments drawn from analogy , in favour of the Sun 's making one of a system of stars .
If we would now inquire , which are probably those stars , which compose part of the same system with the Sun ; though it will not be possible to point them out with certainty , yet there are some marks , by which we may , with great probability include some and exclude others , whilst the rest remain more doubtful .
Those stars which are found in clusters and surrounded with many others at a small distance from them , belong probably to other systems and not to ours .
And those stars , which are surrounded with nebulae , are probably only very great stars , which , upon account of their superior magnitude , are singly visible , whilst the others , which compose the remaining parts of the same system , are so small as to escape our sight .
And those nebulae , in which we can discover either none , or only a few stars , even with the assistance of the best telescopes , are probably systems , that are still more distant than the rest .
The Pleiades , as they appear to the naked eye , have been shown above to be probably a system by themselves ; and if we examine them still farther by means of telescopes , we shall find , that they are surrounded with so large a number of smaller stars , as to increase the odds against the contrary opinion many millions to one .
Now supposing the Pleiades to be in reality a system of stars , the probability is at least , I suppose , an hundred to one , that no one amongst them , of those visible to the naked eye , belongs to the same system with the Sun ; but that these are only such stars , as are greater than the rest .
The exact quantity of this probability depends upon the number of stars , visible to the naked eye , belonging to this system ; the proportion , that the space occupied by the Pleiades bears to the whole heavens ; and lastly , how far the situation of any one of the Pleiades falls in with the general analogy of the stars composing this system , if any such general analogy should appear .
As the nebulae , and smaller constellations , composed of a great number of stars , within a small distance from one another , belong probably to other systems ; so those , which being placed at greater distances from each other compose the larger constellations , and such as have few or no smaller stars near them , when examined with telescopes , belong probably to our own system .
Most of the stars of the first and second magnitude have this criterion to distinguish them as belonging to the same system with the Sun , besides several other circumstances , such as their greater brightness ; the proper motions ~ , that have a The apparent change of situation , that has been observed amongst a few of the stars , is a strong circumstance in favour of those stars being some of the nearest to us .
This apparent change of situation may be owing either to the real motion of the stars themselves , or to that of the Sun , or partly to the one , and partly to the other .
As far as it is owing to the latter ( which it is by no means improbable may in some measure be the case ) it may be considered as a kind of secular parallax , which , if the annual parallax of a few of the stars should some time or other be discovered , and the quantity and direction of the Sun 's motion been observed amongst some of them ; their being more numerous , than we might naturally expect in proportion to the smaller stars , if they did not compose a part of the same system with ourselves , &amp;c. Besides the brighter stars , it is probable there are many of those of the smaller magnitudes also , that belong to the same system with the Sun .
Now , if this should be the case , many of them being only fainter upon account of their less real magnitude , we may stand the same chance of finding a parallax amongst some of these , as amongst the brighest ones , provided we pitch upon such as happen to belong to our own system : to direct us with some probability to these , we have the circumstances above-mentioned of their composing larger constellations , and their having few stars lying very near to them ; and perhaps there may be still a little more reason to suspect , that those stars form a part of the same system with ourselves , where , besides these circumstances , there have been observed changes of brightness , &amp;c. amongst several of them in the same neighbourhood , such for instance as the changes , which have been observed amongst several of the stars in the constellations of the Swan , Cassiopeia , &amp;c. We may , I think , also venture to add to these most of those stars , that are of a redder hue than the rest , as it is probable that they are a good deal bigger , in proportion to their brightness , than the whiter stars [ see the last note should be discovered likewise , might serve to inform us of the distances of many of them , which it would be utterly impossible to find out by any other means .
but two ] .
Many of them also have been observed to have a proper motion of their own , which with several other concurrent circumstances tends to make it highly probable , that they are some of the nearest to us .
Having thus endeavoured to establish the probability , that the Sun is one of a system of stars , placed by themselves in this part of the universe , I shall next inquire into some of the consequences of this hypothesis .
Now if this is the case , and we suppose the whole number of stars , which belong to this system only ( excluding those which belong to others ) , to amount to about 1000 , we shall find it to be an even chance , that the parallax of the nearest amongst them does not exceed the parallax of one half that number in a greater proportion than that of 9 to 1 , supposing the Earth to be placed in or near the centre of the whole system ; nor in a greater proportion than that of about 12 to 1 , supposing it to be placed very near the edge of the system ; for supposing 1000 points to be placed within a sphere of any given magnitude , and that they are equally indifferent to every part of that sphere , if we assume any one of these points as a centre , we shall find , according to the known doctrine of chances , that there is an equal degree of probability whether any one of the rest shall or shall not fall within a sphere , described about the point assumed , of about seven ten thousandths of the size of the whole sphere ; but the radius of such a sphere is about 8/ 90 or a little less than 1/ 11 of the radius of the whole sphere , that is about 1/ 9 of the radius of a sphere of half the size of the greater one ; and therefore a sphere , of about nine times this radius , will include half the greater sphere , if its centre be assumed near the centre of the greater sphere , and a sphere of twelve times this radius will include half the greater sphere , if the point be assumed almost in the surface of it .
If we assume the stars belonging to our own system to be about 1000 ; since they are in all respects similar to the Sun ( excepting perhaps such amongst them as are liable to frequent changes ) , and we have nothing to determine us to one magnitude rather than another , we may most reasonably suppose the magnitude of the Sun to be a medium amongst the whole number .
Upon this supposition , he will probably rank only with the stars of the fourth magnitude ; and his light therefore , if he was removed to the medium distance of the other stars ( viz. a distance equal to the radius of the sphere , that would include half the stars of our own system ) would hardly , I think , exceed a 200th part of the light of Sirius ; and consequently , if the parallax of Sirius would be about one second , if he was of the same size and native brightness with the Sun , it will be an equal chance , that the parallax of one half of the stars , belonging to this system , is not less than one second divided by the square root of 200 , that is a little more than 4~ ; and it will likewise be an equal chance , that the parallax of no one amongst them exceeds between 9 and 12 times that quantity , or a little more than two thirds of a second .
If , instead of 1000 stars , we suppose the whole number , belonging to this system , to be only about 350 , the Sun will then , if he is of a medium size amongst them , rank probably with the stars of the third magnitude , and his light , at a medium distance , upon this hypothesis , would be , I apprehend , about a 50th part of that of Sirius .
And therefore , according to the reasoning above , we should then find it an equal chance , that the parallax of one half of these 350 stars would not be less than about 8~ 1/ 2 ; and there would be the same chance , that the parallax of no one amongst them would be more than between 50~ and about 1~ .
In the former supposition of 1000 stars ; the apparent magnitude of the Sun , when removed to the medium distance ; &amp;c. it seems not improbable , that the biggest star in the system may perhaps exceed the Sun , in the proportion of about 1000 to 1 ; and in the latter supposition of 350 stars , &amp;c. that it may perhaps exceed the Sun , in the proportion of about 120 to 1 .
In whatever proportion the diameter of the Sun is greater or less than the medium we have taken for it in the suppositions above , in the same proportion will the parallaxes be increased or diminished ; and in the inverse triplicate of that proportion must their magnitudes be diminished or increased .
Let us now examine the circumstances of the Pleiades ; and , assuming the respective distances of the stars , composing that system , from each other to be , at a medium , equal to those of our own , let us see what will be the consequences of this supposition .
Now , if the Pleiades do not extend farther in the direction of a line drawn between the Earth and them , than in a direction at right angles to that line ( which , from their composing a system , we have a right to suppose they do not ) we can hardly allow the mean distance of those , that are next to each other , amongst the six stars visible to the naked eye , to be greater than what would subtend an angle , if seen directly from the earth , of about forty or fifty minutes .
And consequently the distance between them and the earth would be about 70 times that distance , and their apparent brightness , seen from those that are next to each other , must be about 4900 times as great , as it appears to us ; But ~ of the Pleiades , if I judge rightly , is not fainter than Sirius in a greater proportion than that of about 100 to 1 ; this star therefore must appear brighter to the nearest of those six , which are visible to the naked eye , than Sirius does to us , in the proportion of about 49 to 1 .
Let us now suppose all the stars belonging to the Pleiades , as well those discoverable with telescopes , as those which are visible to the naked eye , to be contained within a sphere , whose apparent diameter at the earth is two degrees ; and consequently the mean distance of them from a spectator placed somewhere amongst them , as it might happen , would subtend an angle , when seen directly from the earth , of about a degree .
Since therefore we have supposed the distances of the stars of our own system to be , at a medium , equal to those of the Pleiades , and consequently their mean distances from the earth to subtend at the Pleiades an angle of one degree , we shall have the distance of the Pleiades about 57 times as great as the mean distance of the stars of our own system , from the earth .
Hence , if the biggest of the stars of our own system should be at this mean distance from us , and Sirius should be the biggest , ~ of the Pleiades must exceed it in the proportion of about 200 to 1 ; for removing Sirius to 57 times his present distance , his light would then be fainter than it is , in the proportion of 3249 to 1 , that is , fainter than ~ of the Pleiades in the proportion of 32.49 to 1 , supposing ~ of the Pleiades , as above , to afford us a hundredth part of the light of Sirius ; but the magnitude of stars , supposing them equally luminous and their distance to be given , is as the cube of the square root of their brightness ; and therefore ~ of the Pleiades , upon this supposition , must be bigger than Sirius in the proportion of the cube of the square root of 32.49 ( that is 185 ) to 1 .
But I must observe , that according to general ( and , I believe , I may say universal ) analogy in all those nebulae , in which we discover stars bigger than the rest , these stars are placed towards the middle of their respective systems , and , if therefore the same thing obtains with regard to our own system , this will make ~ of the Pleiades still something greater .
If the distance of the Pleiades is greater than the mean distance of the stars of our own system , in the proportion of 57 to 1 , it would be necessary , in order to make stars , of the same real magnitude amongst the Pleiades , equally visible to us with those of our own system , to take in a pencil of rays of a greater diameter , than the pupil of the eye , in the same proportion : this , after proper deductions for the loss of light , could not well be effected by an object lens of less than two feet aperture .
Now Dr. Hooke tells us , in his Micrographia , that , with a telescope of twelve feet length , he discovered in the Pleiades 78 stars , and , with longer telescopes , many more ; but if a telescope of twelve feet length , the aperture of whose object lens was probably less than two inches , increased the number of visible stars in the Pleiades to 78 , we may well suppose , that with an object lens of two feet diameter , they would amount to more than 1000 .
What this number would be must depend however upon the gradation of real magnitude amongst the stars of that system , to which there must necessarily be some limit , and it is not therefore improbable , that observations of the increase of the number of stars amongst the Pleiades , &amp;c. with telescopes of larger apertures , especially if this was carried on to very large sizes , might serve to inform us of many circumstances , both with regard to this gradation , and perhaps some other things , that would enable us to judge with more probability concerning the distances , magnitudes , &amp;c. of the stars of our own system .
If we now imagine a spectator amongst the Pleiades to take a view of this system from thence , supposing the distance , as before , 57 times the mean distance of our own stars , we should appear to him as a nebula , in which there would be no star bright enough to be distinguishable by the naked eye ; and with a telescope , the aperture of whose object lens was two inches , he would hardly , I suppose , be able to distinguish more than half a score stars at the utmost .
Having hitherto supposed the distances of the stars of our own system to be the same with those of the Pleiades , and examined the appearances according to that hypothesis , let us now , instead of their distances , suppose their magnitudes to be the same .
This would make this system , as seen from the Pleiades , to subtend an angle of about twelve degrees instead of two , and about half a score of the biggest stars would be there visible to the naked eye ; but a telescope , whose object lens was of two inches aperture , would in that case , I apprehend , take in almost all the stars belonging to this system of the fourth magnitude and upwards .
These appearances fall in less , I think , with the general analogy of what we see in the heavens , than the former supposition ; but for want of more observations I cannot say this with any certainty : in the mean time however till we have something farther to go upon , it may not perhaps be amiss to take a kind of medium between the two , and suppose the Pleiades to be at about twenty times the mean distance of the stars belonging to our own system , in which case ~ will exceed the biggest of these , in the proportion of about eight or ten to one ; or it will exceed the Sun , according to our former suppositions of his being of a medium size amongst 1000 or 350 stars , in one case in the proportion of about eight or ten thousand , and in the other , about a thousand or twelve hundred to one ; its parallax in the former case being about 36~ and in the latter about 1 1/ 4~ .
I shall conclude this inquiry with one observation more , concerning the appearance of the stars of our own system , as seen from great distances .
Whatever then the real distance and magnitude of these stars may be , provided we have not been greatly out in assigning the proportion of their light in respect to that of the Sun and one another , if they were to be seen from a distance , at which the whole system would not subtend an angle of more than six or eight minutes , it would appear only as a nebula , no single star being visible with perhaps any telescope , that has ever yet been made ; for at this distance , the distance between the earth and the biggest star of this system not subtending an angle of more than about three minutes ( that is , about a twelve hundredth part of the radius ) the stars of this system must appear less luminous than they do to ourselves , in the proportion of the square of 1200 ( or 1440000 ) to 1 .
And supposing the light of Sirius to exceed that of the least visible star in the proportion of about 1200 to 1 , the brightest star therefore would still require to have its light increased in the proportion of 1200 to 1 , before it would begin to be distinguishable .
To do this would require a telescope , that should take in a pencil of rays of a larger diameter than the pupil of the eye , in the proportion of 35 to 1 , that is , a pencil of about a foot diameter , exclusive of deductions ; for the pupil of the eye is not less than a third of an inch in diameter , in a clear star-light night , when there is no Moon ; but to obtain such a pencil , we must not make use of a refracting telescope ( with two lenses only ) of less than 15 inches , nor a reflector of less than nearly two feet aperture .
This may serve to show us , that those nebulae , in which we cannot distinguish any stars , may yet reasonably be supposed to consist of stars , though too far distant to be singly visible ; since this would be the case with our own system , seen from as great a distance as we may well suppose those nebulae to be from us , if we judge of it from the magnitude of the visible area , which they occupy in the heavens .
Of the twinkling of the fixed stars .
Having never yet seen any solution of the twinkling of the fixed stars , with which I could rest satisfied , fied a , I shall offer the following , which may not perhaps be found an inadequate cause of that appearance ; at least it has undoubtedly some share in producing it , especially in the smaller stars .
It is not , I think , unreasonable to suppose , that a single particle of light is sufficient to make a sensible impression upon the organs of sight .
Upon this supposition , a very few particles of light , arriving at the eye in a second of time , will be sufficient to make an object visible , perhaps not more than three or four ; for though the impression may be considered as momentary , yet the perception , occasioned by it , is of a much longer duration : this sufficiently appears from the well-known experiment of a lighted body whirled round in a circle , which needs not make many revolutions in a second , to appear as one continued ring of fire .
Hence then it is not improbable , that the number of the particles of light , which enter the eye in a second of time even from Sirius himself , may not exceed three or four thousand ; and from stars of the second magnitude , they may therefore probably not much exceed an hundred .
Now the apparent increase and diminution of the light , which we observe in the twinkling of the stars , seems to be repeated at not very unequal intervals , perhaps about four or five times in a second : why may we not then suppose , that the ina Some astronomers have lately adopted , as a solution of this appearance , the extreme minuteness of the apparent diameters of the fixed stars , which , they suppose , must , in consequence of this , be intercepted by every little mote , that floats in the air ; but , that an object should be able to intercept a star from us , it must be large enough to exceed the apparent diameter of the star by the diameter of the pupil of the eye ; so that , if the star was a mathematical point , it must still be equal in size to the pupil of the eye .
equalities , which will naturally arise from the chance of the rays coming sometimes a little denser and sometimes a little rarer , in so small a number of them as must fall upon the eye in the fourth or fifth part of a second , may be sufficient to account for this appearance ?
An addition of two or three particles of light , or perhaps of a single one upon twenty , especially if there should be an equal deficiency out of the next twenty , would I suppose be very sensible : this seems at least probable from the very great difference in the appearance of stars , whose light is much less different than , I imagine , people are in general aware of ; the light of the middle-most star in the tail of the great Bear does not , I think , exceed the light of the very small star next to it , in a greater proportion than that of about sixteen or twenty to one ; and Monsieur Bouger tells us , in his Traite d'Optique before-mentioned , that he finds a difference in the light of objects of one part in sixty-six sufficiently distinguishable .
It will perhaps be objected , that the rays coming from Sirius are too numerous to admit of a sufficient inequality , arising from the common effect of chance , so frequently as would be necessary to produce this effect , whatever might happen in respect to the smaller stars ; but till we know what inequality is necessary to produce this effect , we can only guess at it either one way or the other ; there is however another circumstance , that seems to concur in the twinkling of the stars , besides their brightness , and this is a change of colour .
Now the red and blue rays being very much fewer , I apprehend , than those of the intermediate colours , and therefore much more liable to inequality from the common effect of chance , may help very much to account for this phenomenon , a small excess or defect in either of these making a very sensible difference in the colour .
It will now naturally be asked , why the frequency of the changes of brightness should not be often much greater , as well as sometimes less , than that abovementioned , and why the interval of the fourth or fifth , or some such part , should be pitched upon , rather than the fortieth or fiftieth part of a second , or than a whole second , &amp;c. for , according to the length or shortness of the time assumed , the changes , that will naturally occur , from the effect of chance , will be smaller or greater in proportion to each other .
The answer to this question will , I think , tend to render the above solution more probable , as well as to throw a good deal of light upon the whole subject .
The lengths of the times then between the changes of brightness , if I am not mistaken , depend upon the duration of the perception before mentioned , occasioned by the impression of the light upon the eye , than which they seem to be neither much longer nor shorter .
Whatever inequalities fall within a much shorter time than the continuance of this perception , will necessarily be blended together , and have no effect , but as they compose a part of the whole mass ; but those inequalities , which fall in such a manner as that they may be assigned to intervals nearly equal to , or something greater than the continuance of this perception , will be so divided by the imagination , which will naturally follow , and pick them out as they arise .
ENDOFPART I.

