Received April 3 , 1767 .
XXIII .
A Letter to Dr. William Watson , F. R. S. from the Hon. Daines Barrington , F. R. S. on some particular Fish found in Wales .
Dear Sir , KNOWING your attention to every thing which relates to any branch of natural history , I shall not make apologies for sending you an account of the following particulars with regard to perch in a pool of Merionethshire ; and trout , which are found in a river of Cardiganshire .
Read April 9 , 1767 .
The pool is situated in the parish of Trawsvynnyd , and is called Llyn Raithlyn ; as it does not lie near any road , a common traveller cannot hear any thing about it , but by very extraordinary acccident .
Having been informed by Mr. Garnons of Riwgoch , who lives near this pool , that perch were frequently caught there , which were crooked near the tail , I have ; through him , procured fish of this sort at three different times ; as I intended to preserve them in spirits , I have always desired that they should be of a small size .
These fish were all of them most apparently crooked in that part ; which appears still stronger ( as I am informed ) in those of a larger size , and some of them have been taken of nearly two pounds .
I have never examined the back bone of these perch , but I have now by me that of one of the trout ( which I mean likewise to give you an account of ) : this bone , any one may immediately see , differs most apparently from that of a common trout , or any other fish , by its being crooked near the tail .
I have therefore no doubt but that the back bone of these perch will turn out to be equally crooked .
These fish are not only crooked near the tail , and for about one third of the whole length of their body ; there is likewise a very remarkable protuberance on each side , which I have opened with a knife , but did not observe it to differ materially from other parts of the flesh .
I have likewise eat these perch , and should not , by the taste , have distinguished them from the common ones of the same kind .
I happened likewise ( after these inquiries with regard to the perch of Llyn Raithlyn ) to hear of trout , which were crooked in the same part , said to be peculiar to the river Eynion in Cardiganshire , which is a small brook , that empties itself into the Dovey , near Egglwys Vach , and is on the road from Machentleth in Montgomeryshire , to Talypont in Cardiganshire * .
* In Dalekarlia , a province of Sweden , near Fahlun , are two small lakes , famous for the singular shape of the perch , wherewith they abound .
These perch grow to the common size , and are of a good taste , but they have all a hump on their back .
This peculiarity is taken notice of in Linnaei Fauna Suecica , ~ p. 118 .
The country people in the neighbourhood imagine that it may be occasioned by the quality of the water in those lakes , which ~ In stagnis Fahlunae hujuspiscis ( Percae ) varietas est , quae spina recurva , &amp; corpore omnino gibbo , frequens reperitur .
I have procured at two several times specimens of these trout likewise , and have one now by me in spirits .
They are crooked in the same manner near the tail ; but , as the make of a trout is more taper than that of a perch , the curve does not appear so strongly : no one , however , who looks at them with any degree of attention , can have the least doubt of their differing most materially , from other fish of the same kind .
These trout are caught , only in a small bason of perhaps eight or nine feet deep , which the river Eynion forms after a fall from the rocks .
I have been informed , that , in a calm day , you may often see them in this bason ; it hath so happened that a good deal of wind hath ruffled the surface , when I have examined it .
I have only to add to these particulars , that , by very accurate accounts from those , who have caught both the perch and trout , it is not above half of these fish which are thus crooked ; and that the others do not in any respect differ from the common ones of these two sorts .
As I have often observed that the existence of such fish was doubted by the Welsh themselves , till I had procured these specimens , it hath occasioned my might probably be impregnated with some mineral salt , especially as they are situated near the largest copper mine in Europe .
Dan .
Solander .
There is no copper mine near Llyn Raithlyn , or the river Eynion .
Daines Barrington .
inquiring with regard to monocular fish , which are said by Giraldus Cambrensis , to be found in the lakes of Snowden , and from whom I shall transcribe the whole passage : In summis autem montium istorum verticibus , duo lacus reperiuntur , sua non indigni admiratione : alter enim insulam habet erraticam , ad oppositas plerumque parts errabundam ; alter vero miro &amp; inaudito miraculo pollet , quia cum trium generum piscibus abundet , anguillis , truttis , &amp; perchiis , omnes in eo pisces monoculi reperiuntur , oculum dextrum habentes , &amp; sinistro carentes : si rei tam novae , tamque stupendae rationem scrupulosus lector efflagitet , assignare non praesumo .
' ' Giraldus Cambrensis , lib. ii .
cap. 10 .
This writer was Archdeacon of Brecknock , and attended Baldwin Archbishop of Canterbury , in a progress which he made in the year 1188 through South and North Wales , to recommend a collection for a crusade which was then in agitation .
We have no account of any part of England nearly so ancient , Leland 's Itinerary having been undertaken only in the reign of Henry the VIIIth : it is not however merely the antiquity of the work , which should recommend Giraldus 's observations to the perusal of every English reader ; they are at the same time very entertaining , nor is the latinity contemptible .
Giraldus hath in common with other ancient travellers been considered as taking the liberties , with which they have been so frequently charged .
For my own part the last undoubted discovery of the Patagonian giants , mentioned , but not credited in any previous account , will teach me not to disbelieve entirely what is not a contradiction , on the very state of it .
I therefore do not absolutely disbelieve Mr. Grose 's late description of pigmies which are found in a forest of the Carnatic , though I admit such facts require the strongest testimony before one should give a complete assent .
In short , I am neither for implicit belief or disbelief of such extraordinary facts ; and it is remarkable that Aristole , in his account of a nation of pigmies , says , ` ` this is not a fable , but a truth .
' ' ~ ~ ~ Arist .
de Not .
anim .
i. viii .
cap. 12 .
But to return to the extract from Giraldus which hath been looked upon as one of the most glaring falsities , in this traveller .
It will appear to any one who reads the whole of his Iter , and is at all acquainted with the geography of the country , that Giraldus ( who was a native of Pembrokeshire ) never was himself in these mountains of Snowden ; he had therefore only picked up this account , from some of the inhabitants of the towns , through which the Archbishop passed , who themselves probably received it from mountaineers .
There are few inhabitants of the principality , who have ever been in this tract of mountains ; and I , who have been in most parts of them , have always been informed , at my setting out , that the roads were nearly unpassable .
Upon these occasions , I have frequently inquired whether there was any such notion or tradition amongst the mountaineers , with regard to monocular fish , and have found , that it is supposed there are such in a pool called Llyn y Cwn , which indeed I have never seen ; but , by the best accounts I can procure , it is high up the Glyder mountain , which forms the opposite side of the vale of Lanberris to Wyddva , or the highest part of Snowden .
I have , by means of an interpreter , examined some of these mountaineers very particularly with regard to this point .
One of them told me that , though he had often heard of these monocular fish , yet he had seen two or three taken by an angler in Llyn y Cwn , which did not seem to differ from common trout ; and indeed the fish of that lake are seldom caught , as they are of very difficult access , and have no extraordinary character either for goodness or size .
Mr. Hughes ( of Penrhyn in Carnarvonshire ) having known that I had a curiosity with regard to these extraordinary fish , sent me over last summer a mountaineer , whose account of them I took down by means of an interpreter , and send you herewith .
Thomas William , of the parish of Lanleched , taylor , aged 51 , remembers one Daniel Pritchard of Comb Cloran , yeoman , who was near 100 years of age , and died in 1764 .
This Daniel Pritchard told him ( about nineteen years since ) , that he caught a trout at Llyn y Cwn with one eye only in the forehead , and that the head was thicker than the heads of trout commonly are .
He added also , that William Robert , a fuller , had heard the same story from Pritchard : Thomas William himself , however informed me , that he had been fishing in this pool , but never caught a trout of this extraordinary kind .
He had likewise fished in Llyn Marchleyn , and Llyn Bochlwyd , and though he caught some fish with crooked backs , never took any that had but one eye .
He concluded his account by saying , that there is a brother-in-law of Pritchard now alive , who will confirm Pritchard 's testimony ; and that it is generally believed in Lanleched parish , there are fish which have but one eye , in some of the pools of the neighbouring mountains .
' ' If by this I have not established the existence of such monocular fish in the Carnarvonshire lakes , I hope you will at least think that Giraldus 's account is not to be so immediately rejected as impossible , especially when I send you an extract from the History of the French Academy of Sciences , which contains the following proof of nearly as extraordinary fish in a lake of France .
Monsieur le Marquis de Montalembert a fait a l'Academie l'observation suivante .
Dans la fontaine du Gabard en Angoumois , on peche souvent des brochets aveugles , &amp; jamais aucun qui no soit borgne .
Ceux qui no sont que borgnes , le sont tous de l'oeil droit , &amp; dans ceux qui sont aveugles on voit aisement que l'oeil droit a ete attaque le premier , &amp; est beaucoup plus endommage que l'autre .
Cette fontaine est un espece de gouffre , dont on no peut trouver le fond ; plusieurs petites isles de roseaux , qui flottent a sa surface , empechent qu'on no puisse se servir de filets , pour y pecher , ce qui rend cette peche tres longue , &amp; tres difficile .
M. de Montalembert fut assez heureux pour attraper , traper un jeune brochet , qui effectivemeut se trouva borgne du cote droit .
Ce qu'il ya de singulier c'est que cette fontaine se decharge par un assez gros ruisseau dans la Lissonne , &amp; que malgre cette communication , qui est tres facile , les gens du pais assurent qu'on no prend jamais dans cette riviere de brochets borgnes , ou aveugles , &amp; qu'on n'en prend aucuns dans la fontaine qui no le soient .
' ' I refer you for this extract to page 27 and 28 , of the History of the Academy of Sciences for the year 1748 , being the quarto edition , which you was so good as to lend me on this occasion * .
The latter part of this extract , which asserts that these blind pike are only to be found in the pool of Gabard , and not in the small river by which it communicates with the Lissonne , suggests to me that it is generally supposed ( and even by Lhwyd in his additions to Cambden 's Britannia ) salmon are never caught in the lake of Bala in Merionethshire , though they are frequently taken in the river Dee , just below where it issues from that lake ; whilst the contrary is observed with regard to the fish called a Gwyniad , which is at the same time conceived to be peculiar to this lake .
I happened myself once to see a salmon of about fifteen pound , caught in the lake , at least 200 yards *I am likewise referred by an ingenious friend to a passage in Fr. Ern .
Bruckmanni Epistola Itineraria xxxvi .
Wolfenb .
1734 , p. 10 , which mentions a river in Germany , having all the trout blind : ` ` Truttae omens ( teste P. Stephan .
Amiodt , de Germania in naturae operibus admiranda , p. 66 .
) in flumine Fischau prope Mandorf visu destitutae dicuntur .
Vide plura apud Kirkelbeck , p. 809 , E. Brown in Itin .
p. 196 .
and Math. Puel in Iten .
Thalassico , p. 33 .
' ' above the bridge through which the river Dee issues ; and though I never saw the Gwyniad taken in the Dee , yet I was most authentically informed by a gentleman who was present , that several of them were caught within these three years as low down as Landrillo , which is near six measured miles from the lake of Bala .
With regard to the Gwyniad 's being peculiar to this lake , which is so generally believed , I can myself most flatly contradict this notion , as the first parcel of fish , which I happened to see in the market at Perith , in Cumberland , were of this sort , and were brought from the Ulles Water , which is a large lake not above four or five miles distant from that town .
I have been likewise informed , by some people , who lived on the banks of Loch Lomond in Scotland , that fish answering to my description of a Gwyniad were often caught in that lake .
I did not happen however , myself , to see any of this sort .
There is indeed one very striking mark in this fish , which cannot but be attended to by those even who are not naturalists : they have ventral fins of a very deep blue ; and the belly , at most seasons , is marked with small blue specks , which I do not recollect to have observed in any other fish of this island .
I have thus endeavoured to contribute my poor mite with regard to the natural history of Wales , which I have been enabled to state with some precision , from having had occasion to go twice a year into the principality , and to stay six or seven days in a particular place .
When I have mentioned to some friends , who are versed in botany , and the study of natural history , the necessity of a more accurate and complete history of this kind ; I have been frequently answered , that they despaired of making any material additions to the discoveries of Ray and other naturalists , who have been in many parts of this country .
It is very true that Ray and some of his contemporaries were in many of the Welsh counties ; it appears , however , by his Journal lately published , that he stayed but a very short time at any place , and only went to the top of some of the high mountains .
Now , Sir , I need not say , to a person of your consummate knowledge in botany , that to discover all the plants of a country , one should at least , once a fortnight , search every part , from the time vegetation commences , to that period of the autumn when it ceases .
He who searches for pilewort in july , without knowing that it is a plant , which appears early in the spring , and that both leaves and flowers immediately afterwards decay , will search in vain : the botanist must look for it in april , or not at all .
Dillenius is the latest botanist of reputation , who hath visited these mountains ; as I remember to have seen him a year or two before his death , I can venture to say that those who may afterwards make the same search , need not absolutely despair of new and material discoveries , notwithstanding his known diligence and accuracy .
He was of a very improper make for clambering up a rock , or mountain ; and indeed it is a misfortune to the naturalist , that when from experience his knowledge becomes considerable , his strength and activity begin to fail .
When a stranger , from botanical or other curiosity ' goes to the top of a Welsh mountain , he is obliged to trust implicitly to his guide , who contrives to carry him where he can ride on horseback .
The stranger therefore proceeds in the very track , where a sheep or cow can graze , which consequently crop the flowering stem and leaves of the plants .
It is in the fissures of rocks , and the central parts of bogs , that the search for uncommon plants must be made ; he who looks elsewhere for them , may travel a great deal of ground , but will never make any material discoveries .
I will not detain you longer with observations of this kind , as they must have been to you long obvious and familiar .
I have , however , been insensibly betrayed into this length , by thinking , that every attempt to render the natural History of Great Britain more complete , and accurate , may not be entirely without its use .
I am , Dear Sir , Your most faithful Humble servant , Daines Barrington .

