Received December 20 , 1766 .
XV .
History of a Faetus born with a very imperfect Brain ; to which is subjoined a Supplement of the Essay on the Use of Ganglions , published in Philos. Trans. for 1764 : By James Johnston , M. D. IN october 27 , 1765 , a monstrous birth was brought me by a midwife of this place .
It was a female child come to its full time , in which the whole scull excepting its basis was wanting : this was covered with something which had the appearance of red flesh .
I found it to consist of different membranes ; and in a small depression , in a back part of the basis of the skull , lay the brain , such as it was , not exceeding the size of the kernel of a filberd nut , flaccid and membranous .
I could not have positively pronounced it brain , had I not traced its continuation into spinal marrow , down the channel of the vertebrae .
The eyes were perfect and sound .
The optic nerve of one eye I examined , though not large enough , yet in thickness was almost equal to one third of the spinal marrow , which was too small likewise .
Read March 5 , 1767 .
Upon opening the breast and abdomen , all the organs contained therein seemed in structure perfect , properly situated and full grown .
The heart in particular was plump and strong .
This infant had not breathed ; its lungs , which were perfect , sunk in water : yet the mother and midwife felt it active and strong just before delivery .
This child had tongue , nostrils , eyes , and ears , and every other part , excepting the brain , perfect and plump , as in the healthiest infants come to their full time .
Many births similar to this , in most circumstances , are recorded in the Transactions of the Royal Society , No. 99 .
226 .
228 .
242 .
1 .
Such of them as were born alive , died soon after birth , though lively and strong in the womb , and perfect in all parts , the brain and scull excepted .
2 .
In that of which an account is given by Dr. Preston ( Philos. Trans. No. 226 .
) , the celebrated anatomist Mons. du Verney traced the eighth and ninth pairs , the medulla spinalis , and the intercostals .
The child was well proportioned , the cranium , brain , and cerebellum were wanting ; in lieu thereof , remained only a substance , like congealed blood , covered with a membrane .
3 .
In a case related , and largely commented upon , by the celebrated Wepfer * , which differs in many respects from other children said to be without brains ; the child was well proportioned , its head of the usual size , but its brain had degenerated into vesicles , or hydatides , each of which had its blood vessel ( might one from thence infer the natural state of the cortical substance of the brain to be cellular ?
) and the optic and auditory nerves took their rise from three portions of medullary substance lying upon the sphaenoid bone near the sella equina .
* Manget Biblioth .
Auct .
Vol. II .
p. 339 .
4 .
These singular existences afford useful inferences , and show that the irritability of the heart , is capable of being sustained , by very low degrees of the nervous power , while that irritability is kept up by the fostering heat of the mother .
This feeble life is soon extinguished , when the influences of the mother 's warmth and circulation cease ( No. 1 ) .
Such infants die as soon as born , or soon after .
5 .
Such examples more consequentially than experiments demonstrate that the spinal marrow is the principal origin of the intercostal nerves ( No. 2 .
) ; and better than ligatures illustrate their vast importance .
for , 6 .
From the plump state of the body , and vigorous appearance of the heart , it is evident the circulation , and the development of the several organs , had been carried on properly in the faetus ; and that the irritability of the heart derived a sufficiency of nervous influence from the intercostal nerves , and its ganglions , and these again from the spinal marrow , for growth , and that state of existence .
In the essay which was published in the Philos. Trans. for 1764 , I endeavoured to prove , that as ganglions are seated constantly on the intercostal nerves , and on others sent to muscles whose motions are involuntary , and are very rarely seen on nerves sent to voluntary muscles , and not at all on the sensory nerves ; it seems that , by means of ganglions , the motions of the heart and intestines and uvea are rendered uniformly involuntary .
I was then , and am still sensible that various strong objections may be made to this doctrine , in common with every other system whatever ; but especially every system which pretends to explain any thing relating to so obscure a part of the animal oeconomy , as the nerves , and their faculties .
But as this doctrine , weighed against what has been said against it , seems to me to have a considerable preponderance of evidence and probability in its favour , I shall now state the strongest objections which have been opposed to it , and endeavour to answer them .
1 .
The chief objection which has been made to this doctrine arises from observing , that the spinal nerves , have each one ganglion : and that one or two have been observed sometimes upon the subdivisions of the fifth pair of nerves .
With respect to the first , it is in the highest degree probable that the ganglion observed upon each of the spinal nerves respects solely the intercostals ( see Winslow 's description of that nerve , Exp. Anat .
p. 462 .
) and is there seated to set apart for the uses of the great sympathetic nerves the surculi , which are from each of these ganglions detached to that great pair of nerves .
1 .
Because the spinal nerves have no other ganglion in any part of their course .
2 .
When nervous twigs are sent off from the spinal nerves , to join others besides the intercostals , they have no ganglions ; as the nervi accessorii sent from the upper spinal nerves to join the eighth pair : and the first of the spinal nerves , and the last of the nervi sacri are represented by Vieussens * as being without ganglions , and sending no contribution to the intercostals .
Were the ganglions only little knots indiscriminately suitable for nerves , which carry the commands of * Neurograph .
the will , and those which do not , one might expect them equally frequent on the nerves of the limbs , as at the rise and on the course of the intercostals , where they are numerous , large and constant : on the nerves sent to the sensory organs , and on the phrenetic as well as the lenticular ganglion from which the Iris is provided with nerves .
In a word the solicitude , so to express myself , and the constancy with which all parts whose motions are involuntary are provided with nerves furnished and beset with ganglions ; and the great scarcity and rarity of them on nerves detached to muscles subject to our volitions , and the total want of them on the sensory nerves , sufficiently bespeaks their general distinction and use , notwithstanding a few seeming exceptions .
I say seeming , because some that are alleged as exceptions are not permanently and constantly found .
To ascertain the use and importance of any part of animal structure , we ought to be certain that it is constantly found in that situation ; if , on the contrary , it be only accidentally seen , and not perpetually , we can neither assign any important use to it , or draw any important doctrine from it , and have great reason to suspect it to be rather some morbid phenomenon than otherwise .
Now this is the case with respect to the ganglia described by Mekelius as seated on twigs of the second and third branches of the fifth pair of nerves ; betwixt which and other ganglions Baron Haller makes a very essential distinction , particularly the ganglion ophthalmicum , which he says is constant and perpetual , whereas these beforementioned ed are not so , for he * mentions his having examined bodies in which they were wanting .
But , supposing the utmost in favour of these ganglia of the fifth pair : the nervous twigs on which they have been observed are chiefly distributed to the salivary and mucous glands , about the tongue , jaw , palate , throat , and nostrils , and therefore may be supposed to have some use in glandular secretion ; for we see the glandular parts in the abdomen are supplied by the intercostals as well as the muscular fibres of the heart and intestines .
2 .
It has likewise been objected that the intercostals send some branches to parts under the control of the will as the pharynx and diaphragm ; as well as to the heart and intestines , not subject to that control .
It is well known that the pharynx has its most considerable supply of nerves , from the eighth pair : and the diaphragm is rendered paralytic by tying or cutting the phrenic nerves distributed to it , which shows that its motions have very little if any dependence on the minute filaments , which it receives from the intercostals .
The motions however of both these parts are properly speaking of the mixed kind , sometimes being voluntary , at other times involuntary : thus the diaphragm moves when we are asleep , as well as when we wake , and continues for some time , even during a profound apoplectic fit : and though we can raise the pharynx by an effort of the will , yet in the action of deglutition its motions are chiefly involuntary from the stimulus of the food , passing down the gullet , as has been shown in the most ingenious * Haller , El .
Phys. T. IV .
work of a great and worthy man lately deceased , an essay on the vital and involuntary motions of animals , by Dr. Whytt * .
And it deserves to be remarked , that parts , whose motions are of this mixed kind , will be found to have generally a double distribution of nerves , namely such as are without ganglions , to subject them to the will ; and such as have ganglions occasionally to support those motions of the same parts which go on without the will ; but , these supplies from the intercostals being very minute , their action is generally called forth and assisted by some degree of uneasy sensation or stimulus .
If these anatomical objections have not force enough to overthrow our doctrine , the following of a physiological nature , it is presumed , will not be more formidable .
3 .
It has been objected , that if the ganglia intercept the communication between the sensorium commune and those parts whose nerves are derived from them , they ought not only to intercept the commands of the will , and render the motion of these parts not voluntary , but they ought also to prevent the impressions made on the nerves of these parts from being conveyed to the sensorium commune , i. e. these parts ought to be insensible .
The contrary of which is true ; for example , the intestines , whose nerves come from ganglia , are among the most sensible parts of the body .
And if the uneasy sensation in the lungs , in asthmatic cases , was not conveyed to the sensorium commune , how could the will redouble the action of the diaphragm and the intercostal muscles ?
* P. To this I answer , that the interruption of the parallel direction of the nervous filaments , which probably takes place in ganglions , may intercept the efforts of the will , and also render the sensations of parts wholly supplied with nerves from ganglions , more indeterminate and confused than in other parts ; which in fact is the kind of sensation proper to these parts , yet without rendering such parts totally insensible , which is well illustrated by morbid cases .
Paralytic diseases show that the nerves may be so affected as to become incapable of conveying the commands of the will , and yet remain sufficiently capable of re-conveying sensible perceptions .
In the palsies which are most frequent , the parts rendered immovable by the disease have as quick a feeling as those that remain moveable by the will , and , what by the way deserves attention , are often moved involuntarily , especially upon the application of any painful stimulus : and it is observable that the paralytic limbs , which are not to be moved by our volitions , are often called into action , when the paralytic person is suddenly thrown into some vehement passion : just as we observe the same cause to produce extraordinary commotions in the heart and intestines , &amp;c. notwithstanding the will , coolly exerted , has no power over these parts .
Various observations show that the feelings of parts whose nerves come from ganglia are by no means acute , but blunt and confused .
We have it on the authority of the great Harvey , confirmed by the experiments of Baron Haller , that the heart , though highly irritable , is yet when touched hardly sensible of it .
Dr. Haller asserts that the lungs , liver , spleen and kidneys , all supplied with nerves from the intercostals , have been cut in pieces without the animal 's seeming to feel pain .
And what is less liable to exception , operations and diseases in the kidneys , and ulcers in the lungs , show their feelings not to be exquisite * .
The stomach , which has a very large portion of the eight pair of nerves bestowed upon it , by ligatures of this nerve , loses its sensibility and contractive power so perfectly , that the food neither passes down the oesophagus , nor is concocted in the stomach , but , by spontaneous corruption there , puts on the appearance of the faeces themselves in the great intestines ~ .
This proves what was asserted concerning the eighth pair , as being a sensory nerve ; and it is in consequence of the sensibility which the stomach derives by means of this nerve , as well as its own structure , that the stomach becomes the principal seat of hunger : And ( to use the words of Dr. Whytt ~ ) , as it is affected with a more disagreeable sensation , when we have wanted food for any considerable time , than the guts , so likewise it is more sensible of an agreeable feeling from grateful food , and in these respects it may be said to be more sensible than the intestines .
' ' Baron Haller has observed that parts which have nerves from ganglions are not so distinctly painful as others , ` ` ut anima non adeo accurate locum dolentem distinguat , sed obiter utcunque , et cum aliqua latitudine ~ .
' ' And this confused indeter* Haller .
Irritab .
et Whytt .
Path .
Essays .
~ See Vieussens , Bruni , Morgagni , Haller .
~ Path .
Ess .
p. 155 .
~ Elem .
Phys. T. IV .
p. 407 .
minate sensation is the sensation proper to the intestines , though in many instances they are the seat of exquisite pain ; yet , in consequence of the concourse and commixture of the nervous filaments in ganglia , any painful disease seated in the intestines , or in others of the viscera contained in the abdomen , is less determinable to its particular seat , or rather is more apt to affect the parts contained in the abdomen , not primarily affected , than diseases of a painful nature , which are seated in the stomach itself , or other parts whose nerves are unsupplied with ganglions .
And this leads to a natural solution of the cause of that sympathy , that communion of sensation , or imputation of sensation , which so frequently takes place , in the diseases of the contained parts of the abdomen , from which some writers ( Linn. * ) have very conclusively argued for the necessity of such a communication of the nervous filaments in ganglia as we contend for , from the best anatomical authority , and which appears to have such important uses in the animal oeconomy , and to be the occasion of that sympathy or confusion of sensation among the abdominal viscera in particular ~ .
* In Haller .
El .
Phys. T. IV .
p. ~ The solution of the problems concerning the sympathetic affections , or consent of parts , has employed the hands and pens of many ingenious writers ; and if all the questions relating to it were discussed , volumes might be filled , and the subject neither exhausted nor understood .
The ingenious Dr. Whytt has with great acuteness shown that sympathy in general is only to be accounted for from a sentient principle , seated in the sensorium commune , where all nerves begin , and communicate ; his objections to particular sympathies arising from a connexion of nerves in ganglions seem inconclusive ; for he remarks that such a communication as is supposed in ganglia to occasion sympathy , 4 .
It is objected also that every voluntary muscle in the body becomes involuntary when it is strongly stimulated , for example the acceleratores urinae are quite voluntary in their action of expelling the urine , but act involuntarily in expelling the semen .
When we consider the state of the soul and body under any great commotion of mind , we find the usual operations of the mind itself are not only interrupted , but those parts of the body too which the will cannot control are now agitated by the storm ; for every one has experienced that the heart and viscera in general are vehemently affected by strong passions .
The mind is in its turn re-acted upon , by very strong bodily sensations ; it being well known that muscular parts , which are ordinarily subject to our volitions , cease to be so if any part is stimulated by exquisitely pleasing , or excessively painful sensations ; under such a stimulus , they are necessarily contracted or convulsed .
But it is not therefore to be concluded that the gentle stimulus of the blood on the surface of the heart , and of the air , food , and intestinal juices on the intestines , of which the mind has no conscious perception at all , much less a disagreeable one , can lay it under any similar necessity , as some have argued ; and therefore the independence would cause a confusion in our sensations as well as in the motions of our muscles .
with respect to sensation I have remarked that confusion or indeterminate sensation , is that , which is proper to parts whose nerves arise from ganglions and that the muscular motions of these parts are by means of ganglions not regulated by the will , but subsist by the application of an irritating cause : and , instead of proving that sympathy in the abdominal viscera does not arise from ganglions , they prove that it does .
See Whytt on diseases of the nerves .
of these motions on our minds , cannot be explained from this analogy , which does not subsist in fact .
This objection therefore can have no force against our doctrine , however it may recoil upon another ; as all voluntary muscles whatever may be excited to contractions by irritations excessively painful or pleasing , the contraction in such cases being involuntary , necessary , and uncontrollable .
But the stimuli that affect the heart and other parts , whose motions are naturally involuntary , are not of this class and strength , and indeed are so little perceived by the mind , as to lay it under no such necessity , as that stimulus which renders the action of the acceleratores urinae involuntary in expelling the semen .
5 .
Lastly it has been objected , that , though the motions of the uvea are involuntary from light affecting the eye ; they are truly voluntary when it contracts in order to the distinct vision of an object placed near the eye , whose minute parts we want to observe accurately .
It seems on the contrary certain , that the contractions of the uvea , in order to distinct vision , equally arise from different impressions of light on the retina , and are equally involuntary , and solely dependant upon the impressions of different degrees of light in all cases : the distinction indeed is chiefly verbal ; as it is granted , that the motions of the uvea are involuntary from light affecting the eye , that is , different degrees of light striking upon the retina necessarily occasion more or less of contraction in the pupil .
But as vision , considered as distinct or indistinct , is occasioned by various impressions of light upon the retina , the contraction of the pupil necessarily folVOL .
LVII .
S lows , lows , according to the degree of that impression : in the case of distant objects , the faint impressions of light on the retina make the pupil contract little , and it remains wide ; for dilatation is the natural state of the pupil .
In observing very near objects , the light is caeteris paribus stronger , and stimulates the retina , and contracts the pupil more .
In a word , the contractions of the uvea arise from the sensations of the retina involuntarily and uniformly , according to an invariable law and connexion ; otherwise why does the pupil constantly become immovable , when by a gutta serena the retina becomes insensible ?
Let any one observe the motions of the pupil , by the help of a mirror , they will always find it impracticable to subject them to the will .
Indeed it is clear from experiments , as well as diseases , that the iris , like all other parts provided with nerves from ganglia , has but a dull degree of feeling , and is moved entirely independent of the will * .
` ` What persuades me , says M. de Haller , that the iris is much less sensible than the retina , is , that if , after having pierced the cornea , you irritate or cut the iris , it is not therefore contracted , whereas the least increase of light makes it contract ; which evidently proves that this contraction does not depend upon the proper sensibility of the iris , but on that of the retina .
The gutta serena serves to prove the same thing , the iris being no ways changed in that disease , any further than it is deprived of motion , from the sensation of the retina , being destroyed by a palsy of the optic nerve .
' ' Essay on Irritability , p. 31 .
* See Whytt , Ess .
on the Invol .
motions .
Le Cat , on the Senses .
Haller , Elem .
Phys. &amp;c. To conclude , the ganglia , respecting their structure , may justly be considered as little brains , or germs of those nerves detached from them , consisting , according to Winslow , of a mixture of cortical and nervous medullary substance , nourished with several small blood vessels * , in which various nervous filaments are collected , and in them lose their parallel rectilineal direction , according to Baron Haller ~ , who likewise observes that ganglia send off more and larger nerves then came to them ~ ; so that a new nervous organization , analogous to the brain , probably takes place in them .
Respecting their uses , ganglions are the origins of the nerves , sent to organs , moved involuntarily , and probably the cause , or check , which hinders our volitions from extending to them .
As different sources of nervous power , ganglions are analogous to the brain in their office , though they derive their nervous filaments ( to be new arranged in them ) , and consequently their power , ultimately from it .
In a word , ganglions appear to limit the arbitrary power of the soul in the animal oeconomy .
They put it out of our power , by a single volition , to stop the motions of our heart , and in one capricious instant irrevocably to end our lives : and however in the dark we may be , what subordinate agents are substituted , so uniformly to guide and direct , independent of us , our vital and involuntary motions ; we must at least clearly discern , in the contrivance , the goodness , boundless , and unerring wisdom , no less than the power , of our adorable Creator !
` ` ad impellendum satis , ad docendum parum .
' ' * Winslow , Traite de la Teste , 629 .
~ Halleri Elem .
Phys. T. iv .
p. 203 .
~ Haller , ibid.

