Received December 11 , 1766 .
XI .
Experiments on Rathbone-Place Water : By the Hon. Henry Cavendish , F. R. S. D R. Lucas has given a short examination of this water in the first part of his treatise of waters .
It is the produce of a large spring at the end of Rathbone-place , and used a few years ago to be raised by an engine for supplying part of the town .
The engine is now destroyed ; but there is a pump , nearly in the same situation , which yields the same kind of water .
It is the water of this pump , which was used in these experiments .
Read Feb. 19 , 1767 .
Most waters , though ever so transparent , contain some calcareous earth , which is separated from them by boiling , and which seems to be dissolved in them without being neutralized by any acid , and may therefore not improperly be called their unneutralized earth .
The following experiments were made chiefly with a view of enquiring into the cause of the suspension of this earth , for which purpose this water seemed well adapted ; as it contains more unneutralized earth than most others .
These experiments were made towards the latter end of September 1765 , after a very dry summer ; whereby the water was most likely more impregnated with saline and other matters than it usually is .
The water , at the time I used it , looked rather foul to the eye .
On exposing some of it for a few days to the open air , a scurf was formed on its surface , which was nothing else but some of the unneutralized earth separated from the water .
On dropping into it a solution of corrosive sublimate , it grew cloudy in a few seconds ; it quickly became opake , and let fall a sediment .
This is a property , which I believe does not take place , in any considerable degree , in most of the London waters .
EXPERIMENT I. 494 ounces of this water were distilled in a copper still , till about 150 oz. were drawn off .
A good deal of earth was precipitated during the distillation , which being collected and dried , weighed 271 grains .
It proved to be entirely a calcareous earth , except a small part , which was magnesia .
This I found in the following manner .
A little of this earth , being mixed with spirit of salt , dissolved entirely ; which shows it to consist solely of an absorbent earth , but does not show whether it is a calcareous earth or magnesia .
The remainder was saturated with oil of vitriol : a great deal of matter remained undissolved , which , as the earth was shown to be entirely of the absorbent kind , must have been selenite , or a calcarious earth saturated with the oil of vitriol .
The clear liquor strained from off the selenite yielded on evaporation only eighteen grains of solid matter , which proved to be Epsom salt ; so that all the earth , except that contained in the eighteen grains of Epsom salt , must have been of the calcareous kind .
That contained in the Epsom salt is well known to be magnesia .
The The water remaining after distillation , and from which the earth was separated , was evaporated , first in a silver pan , and afterwards in a glass cup , till it was reduced to about three ounces .
Not the least earth was precipitated during the evaporation , till it was reduced to a small quantity ; there then fell 39 grains , which were entirely selenite : so that all the unneutralized earth in the water was separated during the distillation .
The liquor thus evaporated was of a reddish colour , like an infusion of soot .
Many waters contain a good deal of neutral salt composed of the nitrous acid united to a calcareous earth ; the most convenient way of ascertaining the quantity of which , is to drop a solution of fixed alcali into the evaporated water , till all the earth is precipitated ; whereby this salt is changed into true nitre , and is capable of being crystallized .
For this reason , some fixed alcali was dropped into the evaporated water till it made no farther precipitation .
The earth precipitated thereby weighed thirty-six grains , and was entirely magnesia .
The liquor was then farther evaporated , but no nitre could be made to shoot : being then evaporated to dryness , it weighed 256 grains .
It gave not the least signs of containing any nitrous salt , either by putting some of it upon lighted charcoal , or by making a match with a solution of it , but appeared to be a mixture of sea salt and vitriolated tartar , or some other salt composed of the vitriolic acid .
As I have heard of no other London water , that has been examined with this view , but what has been found to contain a considerable proportion of nitrous salt , it seems very remarkable that this should be entirely destitute of it .
I now proceed to the experiments made on the distilled water .
The distilled water , especially that part of it which came over first , became opake , and let fall a precipitate , on dropping into it a solution of sugar of lead .
It also became opake by the addition of corrosive sublimate , much in the same manner that the plain water did before distillation .
It was found , by dropping into it a little acid of vitriol and committing it to evaporation , to contain a small quantity of volatile alcali ; as it left four grains of a brownish salt , which being re-dissolved in water , yielded a smell of volatile alcali on the addition of lime .
It is doubtless this volatile alcali , which is the cause of the precipitate , which the distilled water makes with sugar of lead and corrosive sublimate .
What first suggested to me that the distilled water contained a volatile alcali , was the distilling some of it over again in a retort ; whereby the first runnings were so much impregnated with volatile alcali , as to turn paper died with the juice of blue flowers , to a green colour , and in some measure to yield a smell of volatile alcali .
In the foregoing experiment , the salt procured from the distilled water was perfectly neutral ; so that the quantity of acid employed was certainly not more than sufficient to saturate the alcali , but it may very likely have been less ; as in that case the superfluous volatile alcali would have flown off in the evaporation .
The following experiment shows pretty nearly the quantity of volatile alcali in the distilled water .
EXPERIMENT II .
1128 ounces of Rathbone-place water were distilled in the same manner as the former .
The distilled water was divided into two parcels , that parcel which came over first weighing 121 ounces , the other 146 .
A preparatory experiment was first made , in order to form a judgement of the comparative strength of each parcel ; and also of the quantity of acid which it would require to saturate them .
This was done by dropping sugar of lead into each parcel till it ceased to make a precipitate .
It was judged from hence that the first parcel contained about 21/ 2 times as much volatile alcali as an equal quantity of the second .
Into 30 ounces of the first parcel , mixed with as much of the second , was then put 43 grains of oil of vitriol , which was supposed to be about 1/ 2 more than sufficient to saturate the alcali therein .
The mixture was then evaporated .
When reduced to a small quantity , it was found to be rather acid : sixteen grains of volatile sal ammoniac were therefore added , which seemed nearly sufficient to neutralize it .
Being then evaporated to dryness , it left sixty-six grains of a brownish salt , which dissolved readily in water , leaving only a trifling quantity of brown sediment .
A little of this salt was found to make no precipitate on the addition of fixed alcali , and the remainder , being boiled with lime , was converted into selenite ; a sure sign that the salt was merely vitriolic ammoniacal salt .
The volatile alcaline salt contained in sixty-six grains of vitriolic ammoniacal salt is 581/ 2 grains ; from whence deducting sixteen grains , the weight of the volatile sal ammoniac added , it appears that the distilled water used in this experiment contains 421/ 2 grains of volatile salt ; and therefore the whole quantity of volatile salt driven over by distillation seems to be about sixty-eight grains , which , as the second parcel was so much weaker than the first , is probably nearly the whole volatile alkali contained in the water .
EXPERIMENT III .
Dr. Brownrig , in a paper printed in the Philosophical Transactions , for the year 1765 , shows that a great deal of fixed air is contained in Spa water .
This induced me to try whether I could not find any in that of Rathbone-place ; which I did by means of the contrivance represented in the drawing .
AE M BG L HK CD ACDE represents a tin pan , filled with Rathboneplace water as high as BG .
HKL is another tin pan , within the first , in the manner of an inverted funnel , and made in such a manner as to leave as little room as possible between that and the sides of the outward vessel .
M represents a bottle , full of the same water , inverted over the mouth of the funnel .
By this means , as fast as the air is disengaged by heat from the water within the funnel , it must necessarily rise up into the bottle .
The Rathbone-place water , put into the vessel , weighed 411 ounces , the funnel held 353 ounces .
A bottle full of water being inverted over the mouth of the funnel , as in the figure , the water was heated , and kept boiling about 1/ 4 of an hour .
As soon as one bottle was filled with air , it was removed by putting a small ladle under its mouth , while under water , and set with its mouth immersed in the same manner in another vessel of water , taking care not to suffer any communication between the included air and the outward air during the removal .
At the same time , another bottle full of water was inverted over the mouth of the funnel , in the same manner as the former .
It was not easy telling how much air was discharged from the water ; as the air in the bottles , when first removed , was hot and expanded ; and , before I could be sure it was cold , there was some of it absorbed by the water : but there seemed to be above 75 ounce measures discharged , scarce twenty of which arose before the water began to boil .
The water continued discharging air after the experiment was discontinued .
In about a day 's time , much the greatest part of the air was absorbed , scarce sixteen ~ measures remaining .
That which was absorbed appeared to be fixed air , as the water which had absorbed it made a precipitate with lime-water .
But , in order to absorb all the fixed air more perfectly , the air which remained not absorbed was transferred into another bottle of water , in the manner described in my first paper on factitious air , page 142 of the preceding volume .
This bottle was then set with its mouth immersed in a bottle of sope-leys ; after which , by shaking the bottle , the sope-leys was mixed with the included water ; whereby the air in the bottle was brought in contact with the sope-leys , which is well known to absorb fixed air very readily .
By this means the air was reduced to 83/ 4 ounce measures .
A small vial being filled with equal quantities of this and inflammable air , and a piece of lighted paper applied to its mouth , it went off with as loud a bounce , as when the same vial was filled with equal quantities of common air and inflammable air .
The specific gravity of the remainder was tried by a bladder , in the manner described in the above-mentioned paper ; as well as could be judged from so small a quantity , it was just the same as that of common air .
From these two circumstances , I think we may fairly conclude that this unabsorbed part was entirely common air ; consequently the air discharged from the Rathbone-place water consisted of 83/ 4 ounces of common air and about 66 of fixed air .
The air which was discharged before the water began to boil contained much more common air , than that which was discharged afterwards ; that which was discharged towards the latter end seeming to contain scarce any but fixed air .
As so much fixed air is discharged from this water by boiling , it seemed reasonable to suppose , that the distilled water should contain fixed air .
I accordingly found it to make a precipitate with lime-water .
EXPERIMENT IV .
The following experiment shows that the fixed air was not generated during the boiling , but was contained in the water before .
Into 30 ounces of Rathbone-place water was poured some lime-water , which immediately made a precipitate .
More limewater was added , till it ceased to make any farther precipitate .
It required 201/ 4 ounces .
The precipitated earth being dried weighed 39 grains .
The unneutralized earth contained in 30 ounces of Rathbone-place water is 16 1/ 2 grains , and the earth contained in 201/ 4 ounces of lime-water ( as was found by precipitating the earth by volatile sal ammoniac ) is 21 grains .
Therefore the earth precipitated from the mixture of Rathbone-place water , and lime-water , is about equal to the sum of the weights , of the earth contained in the lime-water , and of the unneutralized earth in the Rathbone-place water ; and consequently all the unneutralized earth seems to be precipitated from Rathbone-place water by the addition of a proper quantity of lime-water .
But a more convincing proof that this is the case , is that the clear liquor , after the precipitate had subsided , did not deposit any earth on boiling , or become in the least cloudy on the addition of fixed alkali ; whereas Rathbone-place water in its natural state becomes opake thereby .
It might perhaps be expected , that the clear liquor should still make a precipitate on the addition of fixed alkali , though the unneutralized earth is precipitated ; as in all probability there is still a good deal of earth remaining in it in a neutralized state .
The reason why it does not , seems to be , that the remaining earth is most likely entirely magnesia ; and Epsom salt , when dissolved in a great quantity of water , does not make any precipitate on the addition of fixed alkali .
There is great reason to suppose that the earth precipitated on mixing the Rathbone-place water and limewater , was very nearly saturated with fixed air , i. e. that it contained very near as much fixed air , as is naturally contained in the same quantity of calcarious earth .
If so , 30 ounces of Rathbone-place water contain as much fixed air as 39 grains of calcarious earth ; whereas the unneutralized earth , in that quantity of water , is only 16 1/ 2 grains ; so that Rathbone place water contains near 2 1/ 3 times as much fixed air as is sufficient to saturate the unneutralized earth in it .
It seems likely from hence , that the suspension of the earth in the Rathbone-place water , is owing merely to its being united to more than its natural proportion of fixed air ; as we have shown that this earth is actually united to more than double its natural proportion of fixed air , and also that it is immediately precipitated , either by driving off the superfluous fixed air by heat , or absorbing it by the addition of a proper quantity of lime water .
Calcareous earths , in their natural state , i. e. saturated with fixed air , are totally insoluble in water ; but the same earths , entirely deprived of their fix d air , i. e. converted into lime , are in some measure soluble in it ; for lime-water is nothing more than a solution of a small quantity of lime in water .
It is very remarkable , therefore , that calcareous earths should also be rendered soluble in water , by furnishing them with more than their natural proportion of fixed air , i. e. that they should be rendered soluble , both by depriving them of their fixed air , and by furnishing them with more than their natural quantity of it .
Yet , strange as this may appear , the following experiments , I think , show plainly that it is the real case .
EXPERIMENT V. In order to see whether I could suspend a calcareous earth in water , by furnishing it with more than its natural proportion of fixed air , I took 30 ounces of rain water , and divided it into two parts : into one part I put as much spirit of salt , as would dissolve 30 3/ 10 grains of calcareous earth , and as much of a saturated solution of chalk , in spirit of salt , as contained 20 grains of calcaroeus earth : into the other part I put as much fixed alkali , as was equivalent to 46 8/ 10 grains of calcareous earth , i. e. which would saturate as much acid .
This alkali was known to contain as much fixed air as 39 grains of calcareous earth .
The whole was then mixed together and the bottle immediately stopped .
The alkali was before said to be equivalent to 46 8/ 10 grains of calcareous earth , and was , therefore , sufficient to saturate all the spirit of salt , and also to decompound as much of the solution of chalk as contains 16 1/ 2 grains of earth .
This mixture , therefore , supposing I made no mistake in my calculation , contained 161/ 2 grains of unneutralized earth , with as much fixed air as is contained in 39 grains of calcareous earth ; which is the quantity which was found to be in the same quantity of Rathbone place water .
The mixture became turbid on first mixing , but the earth was quickly re-dissolved on shaking , so that the liquor became almost transparent .
After standing some time , a slight sediment fell to the bottom , leaving the liquor perfectly transparent .
The mixture was kept three or four days stopped up , during which time it remained perfectly clear , without depositing any more sediment .
The clear liquor was then poured off from the sediment , and boiled for a few minutes , in a Florence flask ; it grew turbid before it began to boil , and discharged a good deal of air ; some earth was precipitated during boiling , which being dried weighed 13 grains .
This shows that there was really , at least 13 grains of earth suspended in this mixture , without being neutralized by any acid ; the suspension of which could be owing only to its being united to more than its natural proportion of fixed air .
But , as a further proof of this , I made the following experiment .
EXPERIMENT VI .
I took the same quantities of rain water , solution of chalk , spirit of salt , and fixed alkali , as in the last experiment , but mixed them in a different order .
The fixed alkali was first dropped into the spirit of salt , and when the effervescence was over , was diluted with 1/ 2 the rain water .
The solution of chalk was then diluted with the remainder of the rain water , the whole mixed together , and the bottle immediately stopped , and shook vehemently .
A precipitate was immediately formed on mixing , which could not be re-dissolved on shaking .
It must be observed , that , in the first of the two foregoing experiments , all the fixed air contained in the alkali was retained in the mixture , none being lost by effervescence ; whereas , in the last experiment , the greatest part of the fixed air was dissipated in the effervescence ; no more being retained than what was contained in that portion of the fixed alkali , which was not neutralized by the acid ; and consequently the unneutralized earth , in the mixture , contained not much more fixed air than what was sufficient to saturate it .
As the latter of these mixtures differed no otherwise from the former , than that it contained less fixed air ; the suspension of the earth in the former must necessarily be owing to the fixed air .
In the two foregoing experiments the water contained , besides the unneutralized earth , and fixed air , some sal fylvii , and a little solution of chalk in the marine acid ; which , it may be supposed , contributed to the suspension of the earth : but the following experiment shows that a calcarious earth may be suspended in water , without the addition of any other substance than fixed air .
EXPERIMENT VII .
A bottle full of rain water was inverted into a vessel of rain water , and some fixed air forced up into the bottle , at different times , till the water had absorbed as much fixed air as it would readily do ; 11 ounces of this water were mixed with 6 1/ 2 of lime water .
The mixture became turbid on first mixing , but quickly recovered its transparency , on shaking , and has remained so for upwards for a year .
This mixture contains 7 grains of calcareous earth ; and , from a subsequent experiment , I guess it to contain as much fixed air , as there is in 14 grains of calcareous earth .
EXPERIMENT VIII .
Least it should be supposed , that the reason why the earth was not precipitated in the foregoing experi2 meant , meant , was , that it was not furnished with a sufficient quantity of fixed air , the following mixture was made , which contains the same proportion of earth as the former , but a less proportion of fixed air : 4 3/ 4 ounces of the above-mentioned water , containing fixed air , were diluted with 61/ 4 of rain water , and then mixed with 6 1/ 2 ounces of limewater .
A precipitate was immediately made on mixing , which could not be re-dissolved on shaking .
EXPERIMENT IX .
I made some experiments to find whether the unneutralized earth could be precipitated from other London waters , by the addition of lime water , as well as from Rathbone-place water .
It is necessary for this purpose , that the quantity of lime water should be adjusted very exactly ; for , if it is too little , it does not precipitate all the unneutralized earth ; if it is too great , some of the earth in the lime water remains suspended .
For this reason , as I found it almost impossible to adjust the quantity with sufficient exactness , I added such a quantity of lime water , as I was well assured , was more than sufficient to precipitate the whole of the unneutralized earth ; and when the precipitate was subsided , decanted off the clear liquor , and exposed it to the open air , till all the lime remaining in the water was precipitated , by attracting fixed air from the atmosphere .
The clear liquor was then decanted and evaporated , which is much the most exact way I know of seeing whether any unneutralized earth remains suspended in the water .
The result of the experiments was as follows : 200 ounces of water , from a pump in Marlborough-street , were mixed with 38 ounces of lime water .
The earth precipitated thereby weighed 38 grains .
The clear liquor , exposed to the air , and evaporated in a silver pan till it was reduced to 6 or 7 ounces , deposited no more than 2 or 3 grains of unneutralized earth .
A like quantity of the same pump water , evaporated by itself without the addition of lime water , deposited about 19 grains of unneutralized earth .
200 ounces of water , from a pump in Hanoversquare , being mixed with 67 ounces of lime water , the precipitate weighed 93 grains .
The clear liquor , treated in the same way as the former , deposited about 2 grains of earth .
200 ounces of the same water , evaporated by itself , deposited 28 grains of earth .
The same quantity of water from a pump in St. Martin 's church-yard , being mixed with 82 ounces of lime water , the precipitate weighed 108 grains .
The clear liquor deposited scarce any unneutralized earth on evaporation .
The same quantity of water , evaporated by itself , yielded 45 grains of unneutralized earth .
The way , by which I found the quantity of unneutralized earth deposited on evaporation , was , after having decanted the clear liquor , and washed the residuum with rain water , to pour a little spirit of salt into the silver pan , which dissolves all the calcareous earth , but does not corrode the silver .
Then , having separated the solution from the insoluble matter , the earth was precipitated by fixed alcali .
In this way of finding the quantity of unneutralized earth , care must be taken to add very little more acid than is necessary to dissolve the unneutralized earth , and to use as little water in washing out the solution as possible ; for otherwise a good deal of the selenite , which is deposited in the evaporation of most water , will be dissolved ; the earth of which will be precipitated by the fixed alcali , and by that means make the quantity of unneutralized earth appear greater than it really is .
It appears from these experiments , that the unneutralized earth is entirely precipitated from these three waters , by the addition of a proper quantity of lime water ; as the trifling quantity found to be deposited , on the evaporation of two of them , most likely proceeded only from not exposing the water to the air , long enough for all the lime to be precipitated .
So that I think it seems reasonable to conclude , that the unneutralized earth , in all waters , is suspended merely by being united to more than its natural proportion of fixed air .
To return to Rathbone-place water ; it appears from the foregoing experiments , that one pint of it , or 7315 grains , contains , first , as much volatile alcali as is equivalent to about 9/ 10 grains of volatile sal ammoniac : secondly , 8 4/ 10 grains of unneutralized earth , a very small part of which is magnesia , the rest a calcareous earth : thirdly , as much fixed air , including that in the unneutralized earth , as is contained in 19 8/ 10 grains of calcareous earth : fourthly , 1 2/ 10 of selenite : fifthly , 7 9/ 10 of a mixture of sea salt , and Epsom salt ; and the whole solid contents of 1 pint of the water is 17 1/ 2 grains .
One pint of water , from the pump in Marlborough-street , contains 1 4/ 10 grains of unneutralized earth , and as much fixed air as is contained in 2 9/ 10 grains of calcareous earth .
The same quantity of water , from the pump in Hanover-square , contains 2 1/ 10 grains of unneutralized earth , with as much fixed air as is contained in 7 2/ 10 of earth .
The same quantity of water , from St. Martin 's Church-yard , contains 3 4/ 10 grains of unneutralized earth , with as much fixed air as is contained in 8 2/ 10 of earth .
Received November 18 , 1766 .

