Received September 24 , 1766 .
V. An Attempt to account for the formation of Spars and Crystals .
By Edward King , Esquire , of Lincoln 's Inn , F. R. S. IN all our enquiries concerning the works of the Supreme Being , and in our endeavours to investigate the secondary causes by which the various phenomenon of nature are effected , we certainly cannot be too cautious and circumspect .
Our comprehension of things is at best very imperfect ; and we may easily be led , by too hasty a view , to draw false conclusions .
It therefore becomes us to be very modest , and to endeavour to go upon sure grounds , before we indulge any hypothesis whatever .
But if we observe this rule , we cannot carry our searches or conjectures too far , since the result of them will often be the discovery of what may be useful to mankind , and will almost always increase our knowledge in some degree , and be a means of raising in our minds more noble and exalted ideas of the Almighty Creator of all things .
Read Jan. 29 , 1767 .
This consideration encourages me to fling together the following conjectures , with regard to the production of those beautiful and transparent substances , which go by the name of spars , crystals , and jewels ; but I would not venture to consider them as amounting to any thing more than queries .
I was first led to entertain these thoughts , by observing the nature of Bristol stones , and the various states in which they appear ; and was encouraged to think they might have some little weight , by observing also the nature of spars , and of those stony concretions found in large caverns .
I shall , therefore , first mention the observations I made , and then draw my conclusions .
1 .
And in the first place , it is known , that the Bristol stones grow within the hollow cavity of some other rough stone ; and that the substance of the external stone is porous , and frequently so strongly impregnated with crystalline corpuscles , that they glitter amongst the earthy particles , when held up to the light .
2 .
In the next place , it is to be observed , that , wherever there is a hollow cavity in these kind of stones , the inside is almost always lined with such shining substances , either in a perfect or imperfect state .
3 .
We find the Bristol stones appear in several different states ; for in some places of the cavity , where the crystallization is not completed , they are of a dusky red , without any transparency ; in others they appear of a dirty yellow ; and in others white ; and at last transparent .
4 .
As to the spars and crystals formed even in flints , and other hard bodies ; I think they are generally observed in such as have evidently been at one time or other in a soft state , and lay in or near moist places strongly impregnated with saline particles of some kind or other ; or else they are found in bodies wherein some saline and moist substances have forI 2 merly merly been enclosed , and prevented from evaporating ; of which kind are the spars found in fossil shells , wherein the bodies of the shell fish have perhaps lain and perished .
5 .
We observe , not only in the small cavities of stones , but also in large caverns , such as those in the Peak in Derbyshire , Okeyhole in Somersetshire , and the famous grotto in the Greek island of Antiparos , and in short wherever moisture descends through the earth to a void space , and stops upon the inward surface , that it there forms crystals , or spars , or stony concretions of some sort or other ; of which some are so very imperfect , as to have only the appearance of rude heaps of petrified matter , without any regular form , which chiefly happens where there is much moisture , and where it descends , or soaks through pores so large as to carry many earthy particles with it .
6 .
To all which I must add , that Sir Isaac Newton has made it appear , that the transparency of bodies is occasioned by the minuteness of their pores , and the opacity of them by the largeness of the pores , in which the rays of light being reflected from side to side are lost , and prevented from passing through ; whence it is , that paper becomes transparent by being oiled , and the oculus mundi stone by being soaked in water .
These are the principal observations on which I found my conjectures ; and from hence I am induced to conclude , that all these above-mentioned substances , are formed by means of those crystalline ( perhaps saline ) corpuscles with which the surrounding earth or porous stones abound , and which probably are diffused throughout the whole globe , and mixed in some degree with most stratas .
These small particles , I apprehend , are carried along gradually , by the moisture , or vapors , which soak through the pores , till they come to some cavity , and there , being stopped by the discontinuance of the earthy or stony substance from proceeding any further , they collect together in drops , and as they dry and harden , do of course , by their mutual attraction , form themselves into crystalline figures ; and as the pores are more and more filled up , by the accession of more corpuscles , or by their mutual attraction which draws them closer together , they become more and more transparent .
Some , however , of the bodies thus formed never have any transparency at all , being mixed with too many earthy or stony particles , or other heterogeneous matter , and have sometimes so much of that as not to be able to put on any regular form , but only to petrify in a confused heap ; the earthy or stony particles preventing the crystalline or saline particles from forming themselves , by their mutual attraction , into regular figures ; and there being perhaps but few of the true crystalline corpuscles mixed with them .
This seems to be the case with many of the stony concretions in large caverns : and perhaps , from a small mixture of these same heterogeneous particles it is , that spars are inferior to crystals , and also differ from one another .
Mr. Platt , in the Philosophical Transactions , Vol. LIV .
p. 41 .
has observed , that spar seems to be nothing but crystal debased by a calcareous earth .
I cannot help suspecting , that what I have called crystalline corpuscles are in reality a kind of salts ; I will beg leave , therefore , to call them hereafter by that name ; and will just endeavour to illustrate what I have said more particularly by the instance of Bristol stones .
In their first state , these are of a dirty red , or some other dusky color ; but afterwards , as more salts , or crystalline corpuscles , are added , by the descent of moisture , or the passage of more vapor , they begin to be more compact ; and then , the pores becoming smaller , they approach nearer to transparency , and put on a yellow or whitish color ; and at last , receiving a further addition of salts , and having the component particles drawn still closer together by their mutual attraction , they become still harder and more transparent , till they acquire , by a length of years , their greatest degree of perfection .
As to the Bristol stones being found of such different sizes ; I am induced to think they grow larger or continue small , only by the accident of the moisture bringing salts to them faster or slower ; for had they any other regular method of growing , I think they ought never to be found in their most perfect state , till they had first acquired their full bulk ; whereas , on the contrary , they are found in their greatest degree of perfection of all sizes .
I therefore imagine , that , till the outside surface is hardened , whatever addition of salts is made will increase the bulk of the stone ; but that , after the outward surface is once hardened , the addition of salts then only helps to bring it to its most perfect transparent state ; and therefore , that when the flow of moisture or vapor , and consequently the addition of salts , is very quick , there ( the outward surfaces not having time to harden till a considerable quantity of salts are accumulated together ) the stone , will grow large ; large ; but where the flow of moisture is slow , there ( the outside surfaces , and indeed the whole mass , becoming hard before a fresh supply of salts is added ) the stones will be small .
And again , where the moisture and salts pass through large pores , there the crystal , or spar , or other concretion , will be very imperfect , being mixed with much heterogeneous matter ; but where the moisture , and crystallizing particles , or salts , descend though very minute pores , there the salts will be most unmixed and pure , and the crystal or stone will be of the most transparent kind .
In short , I cannot but look upon the largest caverns in the earth , and the smallest cavities in stone , as producing similar effects , and therefore consider them in the same light .
In these conclusions I may perhaps be mistaken , but they are at least consistent with the observations we make : for wherever there are cavities in the earth , or in stones , into which moisture can any way descend , we almost always find these kind of crystallizations and concretions ; and the more plentiful the moisture is , and the more porous the strata of earth or stones are through which it passes , the larger the concretions are , and the more remote from a transparent state ; as appears in those great caverns in the Peak , and in Somersetshire , &amp;c. Whereas , on the contrary , the harder and less porous the substance is through which the moisture passes , the more transparent are the stones formed by it , as in the case of Bristol stones , and of some of those beautiful spars adjoining to veins of ore .
Whether all kind of stones may not be formed in somewhat the same manner , by the water carrying the stony particles to the same place , and their collecting there together , by their mutual attraction , I leave to others to determine ; but I am much persuaded , that this may probably be the manner of the production of spars and crystals : and perhaps jewels , or precious stones , May grow just in the same way ; and owe their perfection solely to their being composed of still more minute salts , and more slowly ; whence we may conjecture , why it is so rare to find large diamonds .
I have observed some of the Bristol stones to have a fine purple appearance , like an amethyst ; and it is well known , that several sorts of spars are of various beautiful colors , by means of a mixture of mineral particles , in which they have a distant resemblance of jewels ; and indeed they seem to be very analogous to them in many respects .
After all , however , I am sensible that what I have advanced deserves not to be considered as any thing more than mere guess .
I know that a confirmation of the truth of these conjectures must depend upon experiments , which I have it not in my power to make : and I can only conclude with wishing , that some gentlemen , conversant in chemistry , may some time or other attempt to analyze these bodies , and to see whether they really are composed of what may properly be called salts , and of what kind .
It is much to be lamented , that , in enquiries into the nature of fossils , there have not been more chemical experiments made .

