Received September 24 , 1766 .
IV .
An Attempt to account for the universal Deluge , by Edward King , Esq ; of Lincoln's-Inn , F. R. S. AFTER so many conjectures as have been already formed concerning the cause of the universal deluge , it may perhaps appear both impertinent to attempt a new solution , and also useless , as theories formed on mere hypothesis are always uncertain , and little to be depended upon .
But if we give them no more weight than they deserve , and , considering them only as small steps towards the investigation of truth , do not desire any further assent to our conclusions than the probability on which they are founded demands , even such kind of enquiries may be of service , and open a door to new discoveries .
Read Jan. 22 .
1767 .
Where we cannot arrive at demonstration we must be content with probability .
Our despair of attaining the one ought not to make us neglect the other .
And with regard to this remarkable event , the universal deluge , every degree of probability , even the smallest , that appears in an attempt to account for it philosophically , has its use ; as it tends to remove those objections that are made to the truth of the fact , by persons who may not think the mere relation of it in the Mosaic writings a sufficient proof of the reality of it ; or who may be led , from the difficulty there appears in accounting for such an event , to doubt of the authority of those sacred books .
Many ingenious hypotheses have been already formed on this subject ; but they all seem liable to most insuperable objections : and therefore I make no scruple to venture another into the world , which appears to me free from such difficulties as they are involved in , and more simple .
I am willing , however , it should fall to the ground , as soon as there appear any reasonable and weighty objections to it .
I only wish that the hints contained in this paper may be a means of leading some person of greater abilities to a more perfect discovery ; and that it may always be remembered , that the fossil shells found in all parts of the earth , are a sufficient proof of the truth of its having been at some time or other entirely covered with water , however fallible any attempt to account for the deluge may be .
Dr. Burnet , in his theory , has given such an account of the deluge , as Dr. Keill has shown to be very improbable , and unphilosophical .
He has first described the primaeval earth so as to divest it of all beauty and elegance , and then has ascribed the deluge to such causes , as are not only somewhat inconsistent with that part of his theory , where he supposes the earth to be well watered and moistened with dew ; but are also insufficient to account for the waters flowing over the tops of the mountains : since on the breaking of his imaginary shell , it is impossible to suppose that the waters of the abyss , even on such a concussion , should flow up high enough upon those parts that were left elevated , so as to cover the mountains that now subsist .
Mr. Whiston has called in the assistance of another planetary body ; and has supposed the tail of a comet to be so greatly condensed as to afford a quantity of water sufficient for this purpose .
But , besides the inconsistency of this theory with that of gravitation , it is no less difficult , according to his hypothesis , to get rid of the water with which the earth was covered , than it is , according to others , to find a sufficient quantity .
Mr. Ray has accounted for this amazing event , by supposing a change to have happened in the center of gravity of the earth .
But how to find a cause for such a change in the center of gravity , and for a restoration of it to the same place again , is more difficult , and the supposition of it more inconsistent with our philosophical ideas , than any other hypothesis whatever .
Such have been some of the principal theories hitherto advanced , and far be it from me to presume that mine may not in the end be found equally fallible ; but it appears to me at present to be more plain and consistent , and at the same time is free from that great difficulty which has perplexed all the rest , and is indeed the most important difficulty in the enquiry , that is , the accounting for a sufficient quantity of water .
We find in the Mosaic history of the creation , that God at the first created sea as well as land ; and therefore have grounds to believe both from thence , and from the reason of things , that there was as great a quantity of sea on the antediluvian earth , as there is now upon the earth in its present state .
We find also the whole surface of the earth to be undermined by subterraneous fires , which make their appearance in various places , in very formidable volcanoes .
This had been the case in Italy , and amongst the Azores , in Tartary , in Kamtschatca , in South America , in Ireland , in the islands of the East Indies , and in other parts : and we have reason to believe that these subterraneous fires have made eruptions , not unfrequently , even in the bottom of the sea ; as Mr. Mitchell has made appear in his excellent paper concerning the causes of earthquakes * .
We have also , in the Philosophical Transactions , an account of entire islands being raised in the Archipelago , and likewise amongst the Azores , by such subterraneous fires ~ ; and Mr. Ray , in his travels , mentions a mountain one hundred feet high , raised by the earthquake in 1538 , which also threw up so much earth , stones , and ashes , as quite filled up the Lacus Lucrinus ~ .
To which may be added , that fossil shells and other marine bodies are so universally found in all parts of the present continents and islands , as to amount almost to a demonstration , that all the now dry land was once covered with sea , and that for a considerable space of time , probably much longer than the continuance of the deluge is related to have been .
For though such a violent flux of waters might have thrown up some shells and marine bodies upon the hills and mountains , yet it could not have flung up such vast quantities , nor so universally .
The prodigious beds of shells which we now find in all parts * Philos. Trans. Vol. LI .
part II .
p. 566 .
~ Philos. Trans. No 372 , or Eames 's Abr .
vol. VI .
part II .
p. 203 , and Jones 's Abr .
vol. V. part II .
p. 196 , ~ Ray 's Travels , old edition , p. 273 .
cannot well be accounted for , but by supposing the waters , in which those shell-fish lived , to have covered the countries where they are now found , for a long time , and even for ages .
The supposition therefore , which I am about to advance , founded on these facts , is this ; that originally Almighty God created this earth with sea and land nearly in the same proportion as they now remain , and that it continued in that state for many ages , during which the bottom of the sea became covered with shells , and various heterogeneous bodies that from the first of its creation there were also many subterraneous fires found within the bowels of the earth ; and that , at the appointed time , these fires bursting forth at once with great violence , under the sea * , raised up the bottom of the ocean , so as to pour out the waters over the face of what was before dry land , which by that means became sea , and has perhaps continued so ever since , as that which was before the flood the bottom of the sea , probably from that time has continued to be continent and dry land ~ .
* Mr. Mitchell has shown , in his paper on the causes of earthquakes , that such subterraneous fires are at all times very liable to make eruptions under the sea , and that when they do so , the earthquakes consequent upon such eruptions are more extensive than any whatever .
~I do not mean by this to insinuate that all that part of the globe which is now sea was dry land before the flood : or that the antediluvian ocean was merely of the extent of our present continent .
I apprehend , on the contrary , that there was always a greater proportion of water on the face of the earth than of continent ; and I would only be understood to mean , that all that which was dry land before the flood is now buried under the sea , whilst that which was a part of the bottom of the antediluvian This This hypothesis may perhaps be liable to great objections ; but it is at least consistent with what Moses relates of the fountains of the great deep being broken up ; and , without any perplexity or difficulty , accounts at once for a sufficient quantity of water to cover the tops of the highest antediluvian mountains , even supposing they were left standing : though it is not improbable but that they might be thrown down by means of the same earthquake .
If they were lest standing , some of them might ( on the retreat of the waters from their tops after the first concussion ) form some of the islands that now subsist .
I must also add , that this hypothesis is perfectly consistent with , and perhaps in some measure accounts for , that singular position of the strata of coals , ores , and various kinds of earths ( mentioned in Mr. Mitchell 's paper ) , which are found always sloping from mountainous countries , and higher grounds , towards the bottom of the sea ; so that what is nearest the surface of the earth in mountains and high countries lies deepest in low lands and under the sea .
It is , besides , somewhat confirmed by that singular observation of Dr. Hasselquist 's , in his travels , ( p. 33 ) where , speaking of Natolia and the eastern countries in general , he says , ` ` In no place was it more evident that the continent , we call earth , was in the beginning the bottom of the sea .
' ' Ulloa also informs us , that the same thing is evident in the whole country of Valles in South America * : and Norden ocean forms our present land : and that consequently some part of the ocean was sea both in the antediluvian earth and in the present state of it , and common to both .
* Ulloa 's voyage to South America , vol. II .
p. 99 .
tells us , that the rocks in Egypt bear evident marks of having been washed by the sea * .
These are the reasons which induce me to venture upon this supposition ; and now I will just consider one or two objections , that appear to me amongst the most material which may be made to what I have advanced .
It may perhaps be said , that we read ~ ` ` of the waters returning from off the earth , and of their being abated at the end of the hundred and fifty days : and also , of the waters decreasing continually till the tenth month ; and of the tops of the mountains being then seen .
' ' And it may be objected , that we ought from thence to conclude , that the waters of the deluge , having covered what was before dry ground , afterwards retreated , and left the very same hills and land dry again .
But this conclusion is by no means necessary ; for all that can be inferred from what we find in Genesis concerning the decrease of the waters , is , that they gradually subsided from off the face of what is now continent and dry land , as of course they would do on the elevation of it , agreeable to the foregoing hypothesis .
And indeed , if the deluge was effected in the way here supposed , we can then give a rational and easy account how all the water came to drain off the ground , and to leave it dry so soon as is recorded ; which otherwise is a circumstance in this piece of history very perplexing .
It is evident , that such a violent earthquake , or bursting forth of the subterraneous fire , as is here supposed to have raised the * Norden 's Travels , vol. II .
p. 21 .
~ Genesis , ch .
viii .
3-5 .
bottom of the then sea ( the present continents ) , at once as high or higher than what was before dry land , must in a very short time have drowned and overwhelmed the antediluvian earth , by pouring out the waters upon it ; and it is also evident , that for some time the bottom of the sea , so raised , would continue covered with the waters , which , till the vast agitation into which they were flung subsided , would continue flowing backwards and forwards .
But , by degrees , and very easily within the time mentioned in Scripture , the water would drain off from all the higher parts , and leave the new land quite dry , and in the state we now find it , with strata of shells , and sand , and stones , and other bodies , lying just as the sea had by accident many ages before placed them .
Whereas , were the deluge occasioned only by an addition of water sufficient to raise the surface of the sea higher than the land and mountains , in that case , it is impossible to imagine any means , at all consistent with the course and laws of nature , by which such an immense body of water could be evaporated or conveyed away in so short a space of time .
And besides , in that case , the shells , &amp;c. flung upon the land by the concussion of the waters , and subsiding there within so short a space of time , would rather be found lying according to their specific gravities : a fact which Dr. Woodward supposed certain , but which is by no means true .
Nor indeed , according to the conjectures here advanced , is it at all necessary that it should be so .
For , as I imagine the shells and other marine bodies , which are now found on various parts of the dry land , to have been placed there gradually during a succession of ages , whilst it was the bottom of the sea ; it will follow , that they must be found just as the sea , by its washings and motion , laid them ; which would of course firsh wash many of them together , and then wash gravel , or sand , or clay , or other substances over them ; after which , more shells or other bodies would be deposited , and then more stones or gravel , &amp;c. according to the nature of the soil .
In short , whatever was specifically heavier than water , would ( after its removal by any agitation ) soon subside , and remain fixed , whether the substances underneath it were specifically heavier than itself or no : it is sufficient that they were but all specifically heavier than the water .
We find to this day great changes are continually making , within the memory of man , both on the face of the earth , in the shores , and in the bottom of the sea , even in those small parts of it that we are acquainted with ; and such changes must also have happened before the flood , and might very probably produce that situation of shells , &amp;c. so different from what might be expected from their specific weights .
Another objection may perhaps be made by saying , if all the antediluvian earth was at once overwhelmed , and of course all its plants with it , whence came it to pass , that the now dry land was so soon covered with vegetables and herbage of all kinds ?
To this I answer , in the first place , that the difficulty is just the same , whether we suppose the bottom of the antediluvian sea to be the present continents , or whether we suppose the face of the earth to have remained the very same ; since , by the waters of the deluge , all plants , trees , and vegetables , must in both cases equally have been destroyed ; and nothing could well remain , except some of their shoots and seeds ; which might just as well take root on the new continent , on the subsiding of the waters , as on the old .
And in the next place , I answer , that there are not a few instances ( as is shown in Stillingfleet 's tracts * ) of barren rocks and plains becoming by degrees well covered with verdure , though very remote from any places that might apparently furnish seeds .
They have first borne a kind of moss , and afterwards other plants of an higher order ( the seeds being brought there by accident , and by the various and admirable means of conveyance , which the Creator has given them ) , till at last they have been covered with rich verdure .
To which may be added a very extraordinary fact , now well known , namely , that if a piece of ground which has not been cultivated be turned up , and the clods loosened , it will very soon produce a variety of plants , some of which were never known to grow there before .
We find that one acorn is sufficient to produce a forest , and it is by no means to be supposed ( let the deluge have happened how it would ) that , immediately after it , the earth was as well cloathed with verdure , as it has become since .
Probably it was for a time in general very barren , except such parts as Noah and his sons cultivated , with seeds which they had preserved in the ark .
As to the leaf which the dove brought in ~ , that might be found on some plant which had taken fresh root immediately on the subsiding of the waters , or it * Stillingfleet 's Tracts , p. 78 , and also p. 45 , where an instance is produced , much to the purpose , of marshes becoming by degrees fine meadows .
~ Genesis , ch .
viii .
v. 11 .
is not impossible but the top of some antediluvian mountain , having been but slightly covered , might on the ceasing of the first concussion ( as I before observed ) remain in the state of an island , elevated above the surface of the sea .
I apprehend , no objection of any weight can arise from the description of paradise in Scripture , nor from its being said that the ark rested on the mountains of Ararat : since , whether the continent was changed or no , there is no place now remaining that answers the description of the former ; nor is there any thing said about the latter , that should lead us to conclude there ever was such a mountain as Ararat before the flood .
But , leaving these objections from the words of Scripture , and the history of the deluge ; another may perhaps arise , from this circumstance , that shells are found in various parts of the earth , which are evidently not the shells peculiar to the seas adjoining , but such as belong to a different climate .
This fact at first certainly seems to contradict what I have advanced : and yet , when well considered , it will perhaps rather be found to confirm my hypothesis .
For let any one but look on a terrestrial globe , and he will instantly see , that the present continents are evidently not in the same climates as the present seas ; and therefore , though the shells found in many places of the earth are not found in the neighbouring parts of the ocean ; yet , when those parts of the earth were ocean , they might have had a very proper climate and situation there .
Thus , for instance , we may observe that the Mediterranean is in a more southern climate than the neighbouring continent of Europe , and in a more northern climate than that of Africa .
And the whole continent of Asia is in a climate much more northern , than the neighbouring Indian ocean .
But , if this solution of the difficulty is not thought sufficient , it may be added , that so great a concussion , and such a change in the figure of the earth , as must have happened from the subterraneous fires elevating so many parts higher than they were before , might possibly affect the gravitation of the parts of the globe of the earth , and cause it to revolve round a different axis after the flood ; whence there would undoubtedly arise a change of climate in all parts , sufficient to account for the present situation of shells , in places so foreign to the climates where shell fish of the same species are now found .
And as I have before observed with regard to seeds , so it may also be observed with regard to shell fish , that the conveyance of a very few of each sort ( by the flux of water ) to the beds proper for them , would be sufficient to preserve all the various kinds , and to cause them now to be found in such numbers , in those parts of the ocean that are best adapted to each peculiar class .
Another thing proper to be taken notice of , is the horns and bones of terrestrial animals being found in the earth , together with fossil shells ; which seems to contradict the supposition of the present continents having been originally the bottom of the sea .
But with regard to this , I must beg leave to observe , that probably some of those bones have been deposited there since the flood , and have been covered by an addition of earth , as has happened also to some of the trees and woods that were cut down in this island by the Romans .
And , as to the rest , it cannot be supposed , but that on the first great eruption , which poured the waters of the ocean upon the dry land , there must have been a violent agitation for some time , by their flowing backward and forward ; during which interval , the bodies of many terrestrial animals ( floating on the water ) would be washed to different parts of the new-raised continent , and be left there as the water subsided .
Some little objection perhaps may arise , from its being observed , that the sea at present covers a much greater part of the globe than the dry land does .
But I apprehend this was also the case before the flood ; and it may easily be conceived , that some part of the bottom of the antediluvian ocean might be flung in the manner supposed in this paper , and not the whole ; and that the bottom of the present ocean consists not only of what was before the flood dry land , but also of some part of what was , even from the beginning , the bottom of the sea .
I will therefore only just add , that probably the same subterraneous fires ( which originally raised the continents and islands that now appear , and have ever since been making great changes in the bowels of the earth , and producing those tremendous earthquakes , which have happened from time to time ) may in the end break forth with redoubled violence , and destroy it , in the manner foretold in Scripture .
It may not be amiss to add , in confirmation of the foregoing hypothesis , that the beds of shells , discovered in chalk pits , gravel pits , and other places , consist generally of one or two , or at most of a very few different sorts in each particular place , as they would of course do upon a supposition that those respective beds were formerly at the bottom of the sea , in the several places where those different kind of shell fish lived and bred ; and that they were from thence , together with the bottom of the antediluvian ocean , raised up by the force of subterranean fires : for we may observe in the present seas , that one species of shell fish take up their habitation in one place , whilst those of a different species are found in some other ; and that numbers of the same kind , as for instance cookles , or oysters , are generally found on the same banks .
The present appearance of fossil shells , therefore , does at least in this respect seem consistent with the conjectures here advanced : whereas , upon a supposition that these fossil shells were carried to their respective places , at the time of the flood , merely by the torrent of water that then flowed to and fro , they ought rather to be found mixed promiscuously together ; and not those of one species in one place ; and those of a different species in another .
And I beg leave here to mention , that , since the writing of the foregoing paper , I find an hypothesis somewhat similar to what is here advanced was adopted by Lazzaro Moro , a Venetian author , who asserts that the continents were originally raised by subterranean fires ; but he considers this merely as the cause of their first and original formation , and not as having occasioned the deluge , nor as having happened at that time .

