PHILOSOPHICAL TRANSACTIONS .
Received in 1765 .
I. A monstrous human Faetus , having neither Head , Heart , Lungs , Stomach , Spleen , Pancreas , Liver , nor Kidnies .
By Claude , Nicholas Le Cat , M. D. Professor and Demonstrator Royal in Anatomy and Surgery ; perpetual Secretary to the Academy of Sciences at Rouen , F. R. S. &amp;c. Translated from the French , by Michael Underwood , Surgeon to the British Lyingin Hospital , in London .
M. F~ , a chair-woman , in the parish of Carville de Dernetal , aged thirty-four years , was brought to-bed , at nine months end , on tuesday the third of january , 1764 , of two children , having already had six .
VOL. LVII .
B This Read December 1766 , This last labour , in which she was attended by the widow Mauger , a midwife of the same town , began with so considerable a discharge of water , that it was judged , not without reason , that her pregnancy was attended with a dropsy of the uterus .
The first child was a girl , well formed , who died in the birth , solely from the obstacles which were occasioned , during the course of the labour , by the second child , or monster , which I am going to describe .
All the lower part of this child , from a finger 's breadth above the navel , was likewise a female , tolerably well formed , except that on her left foot she had but four toes , joined together by a membrane , like the web of a duck 's foot .
But all the parts of this faetus , above the navel , composed a perfect mola , a shapeless mass , represented in the two following figures , of which it will be necessary to read the explanation , in order to have a just idea of the external appearance of this monster .
The drawings are reduced to almost half the natural size , both as to length and breadth ; from whence it may be observed , that each of the children , who had lived to their full time , had acquired , in this dropsical womb , a bulk pretty near equal to that of other children , born at full time , when twins , and not very thriving .
The full size of our monster was twelve inches six lines , and the navel was in the middle of this space .
d AA b A B Fig. 1 .
~ B C C f ~ ~ by Mrs. David daughter to the Author .
Philos. Trans. Vol. LVII .
TAB 1p .
3 .
b a ~ e d B f C C Fig. 2 .
TA B. I. FIGURE 1 .
Represents the monstrous faetus in a front view .
A. The upper and only monstrous part , which seems to contain its head , its superior extremities , and the breast .
B. The belly .
C. The lower extremities .
a. Solid and bony eminences , which appeared to be portions of a jaw .
without any opening for a mouth .
b. The extremity of the thumb of the right hand .
d. The hair , the same as on other children .
All the surface of this bag was like the skin of any other faetus .
e. The genital-parts of a female .
f. The umbilical cord .
FIGURE 2 .
Represents a back view of the faetus .
A. The same bag as at letter A. fig. 1 .
B. The loins .
C. The lower extremities .
a. The hair as seen in the former Fig. under which might be felt the bones of the cranium .
b. A transparent vesicle , like an hydatide , which I took for an imperfect eye .
c. Part of the bag , where we observed the extremity of a thumb seen at b , fig. 1 .
d. Part of the same bag , which resembled that marked c. e. Under this region might be felt the spina dorsi and colli .
Description of the internal parts of this monster .
I began the dissection on the hind part ; the muscles of the back were well formed .
I found on the right side eight ribs , reckoning from below upwards , and seven on the left .
Immediately above these was an hydatide , in which lay the cervical nerves , destined for the upper extremities .
In this place also might be seen very imperfect rudiments of the scapula and clavicle .
On the right side , and near to those rudiments , was a sort of thumb , easily known to be the thumb of the right hand , whose extremity projected beyond the integuments three-fourths of its natural length .
Above , and on the right side of this hydatide , I discovered another more considerable , surrounded by a large bag , very smooth on the inside , and supported by something , which had the appearance of a beginning of maxillae .
At the extremity of the fore part of this bag were two orifices , almost contiguous , across a septum , which led to another bag of a much smaller size .
These two hydatide bags were behind that represented in Fig. 2 .
( letter b. ) which I took for an imperfect eye , because it was transparent , and surrounded by teguments not unlike eyelids .
On tracing the spine , and divesting it of all the soft parts , we discovered that it terminated above in a bony mass , that resembled the larynx , above which was a large soft substance of the consistence of , and covered with , that kind of skin common to a cow 's udder ; on which we saw hair like that of other children .
This occupied the usual place for the head .
Under this kind of parenchymatous substance , which was white and glandular , was a muscular mass , more considerable and conspicuous than one could well have expected in such a subject .
It doubtless consisted of the occipital and perhaps frontal muscles , drawn towards each other .
Having raised this fleshy part , I opened the upper bag of the spine , resembling a larynx .
Its surface was altogether bony , as usual in the faetus , viz. somewhat cartilaginous .
This I opened in the direction of a membranous triangular line , somewhat like the lambdoidal suture of the occiput .
We found this kind of larynx fitted with cerebrum , or rather cerebellum ; it might be about a cubical inch in proportion ; and this was all the brain of the faetus .
At the extremity of this cavity , backwards , lay the proper medulla spinalis .
This cavity was not separated by an elongation of the cerebellum , it had but a very small falx forwards ; and on the right side was another appearance of an elongation of the cerebellum , so that this small portion of brain did most likely belong to the cerebellum .
At the basis of this kind of unformed cranium , forwards , was an opening leading to a small brown hydatide , situated on the right side , under a bone which had the appearance of a portion of the maxilla , which led towards a sort of mouth , scarce formed , and closed ; it is represented at the letter ( a ) of the first figure .
There was nothing on the other side , no appearance of a mouth , nor any thing that seemed the least like it .
I took this hydatide for an unformed jugular bag , or true caecum ; in the adjoining bone I found a kind of right ear .
The fore part of this same superior surface of the cranium was flat , but a little hollowed , like the upper surface of the larynx ; in the middle was a considerable ridge , and on its anterior part appeared a prominence : thus this bone , which should have been similar to the two parietals , did not resemble them at all .
Underneath this prominence , the bone took a perpendicular turn , making a sharp angle with the upper surface , and forming a cavity in its descent , which terminated in a projection forwards ; it was on the right side of this projection where the supposed right branch of the maxilla was attached ; within that branch appeared the trace of the jugular above-mentioned , and very distinctly the nerve of the eighth pair .
In the breast , or rather under the ribs , were neither heart nor lungs , but the same white , parenchymatous and aedematous-like substance , which we saw in the place of the head .
Below this was no diaphragm , at least no distinct one .
In the belly , which extended itself just under the ribs , was a bundle of intestines , and a little red mass , which I called the liver , for want of a better name , because it seemed , that , when I pulled the umbilical cord , this substance moved , which induced me to believe that the umbilical vein entered there .
No stomach , spleen , pancreas , or kidneys were seen .
The intestinal mass was divided into two portions .
The first was of a reddish colour , which terminated upwards in a blind pouch , and below joined the other portion , as the ileum does where it unites with the colon and caecum .
This second portion was white , and seemed to include the large intestines .
The caecum was very long , or rather the caecum and its appendix vermi-formis were of the same size .
Thus , there was neither jejunum , or duodenum , or stomach , or any liver properly speaking : for that , which I found in the place of it , was a red viscus , and of the conglomerate kind , like the kidney in a faetus .
Having cleared it from all its adhesions , I discovered neither vessels analogous to those of the sinus of the vena portae , or any thing that resembled the figure of the liver , or of any of its appurtenances .
I opened it , and was more and more convinced that it was rather a kidney , or knot of renal glands , than a liver , although it was one mass , and placed in the midst of the intestines ; it had still less the resemblance of a heart , having no cavity , no vessels , or any muscular fibres .
The extremity of the colon , or the rectum , passed betwixt the bladder and the uterus as usual .
I dissected all these parts , and traced the bladder up to the umbilical cord , where it lengthened into a pipe , and formed an open urachus .
It had not the pyriform shape of the common bladder .
It was in making these dissections of the kidneyliver , and those of the pelvis , that I divided the principal vessels , which I shall mention in the second examination .
All these intestines , and especially the rectum , contained excrements of a light ash colour , but no meconium .
The bladder , although lengthened and continued by an urachus , as high as the navel , opened in the usual place betwixt the nymphae .
The anus was imperforate , and the rectum , immediately under the uterus , terminated in a blind pouch , attached to some membranes that went to the anus .
This pouch was quite full of that sort of excrement just now described .
Second examination , made the next morning .
I had confined myself , in the first examination , to the singularity of a want of head , lungs , and heart , and of the existence of nerves , notwithstanding these defects .
In this second review , the organs of the circulation in such a production , which had lived nine months , raised my curiosity ; but it was rather too late for my entire satisfaction , for I had not taken care enough to preserve the internal parts , imagining before-hand that they resembled those Philos. Trans. Vol. LVII .
TAB. II.p.9 .
AG F Fig. 3 .
L bD a B g d e h f CH d E Fig. 4 .
h DB aA e f g f of two headless twins , in my possession , whose inside was entirely similar to that of other faetuses .
I discovered , notwithstanding , the following things , and I have represented the most essential in a rough sketch seen in figure 3 .
FIGURE 3 .
A. Is the region of the breast , whose internal surface was lined with a membrane , which I took to be a diaphragm thrust back and stuck to the pleura , because it arose from lumbar muscular portions resembling the pillars of the diaphragm .
Under this species of midriff was a very regular distribution of arteries and nerves , which I neglected to delineate , as thinking it useless ; I contented myself with dissecting the aorta F. of which the upper ramifications were as usual .
B. is the lumbar region .
C. Those of the ossa ilia , and of the pelvis .
D. The umbilical cord passing through an opening across the teguments of the lower belly , to be brought into view .
E. The intestines .
F. The aorta superior before-mentioned .
G. H. The integuments of all the right side , opened on the back , to preserve it whole , and also those of the belly ; they are thrust to the right side to give a view within .
a. A kind of single kidney , which occupied the place of the liver .
The principal part is covered by the intestines .
It received several small vessels from the aorta , but none of them was near so large as the emulgent .
b. A small lobe , that might pass either for a small lobe of the liver , or for a capsula renalis .
d. An orifice of a vein , which was also ramified , through the kidney-liver , by branches as fine as those it received from the aorta .
But this vein did not terminate there .
1 .
It sent , upwards , branches to the muscles , to the vertebrae , and thence to the ribs ; for , by blowing into the trunk , the air came out at the origin of the uppermost rib I had dissected .
2 .
Below , it formed two large iliac veins , g. which took the usual course .
e. The trunk cut , belonging to the aorta inferior , of the length of a line .
f. The distribution of the rest of this aorta , or right iliac , through that side of the pelvis .
g. The iliac veins going off to right and left , as usual .
h. The orifice of the umbilical vein , being so exactly of the same diameter , of the same white colour and strength , and of the same consistence with the divided trunk , e. that at first sight , I took this for the same vessel .
The trunk , d. was much thinner , and of a more bluish tint .
Under the umbilical vein , h. was the umbilical artery on each side , which went as usual into the pelvis , and there sent off the ordinary ramifications .
On the right side , its anastmosis with the iliac artery was very discernible ; but on the left we could not discover the iliac , a vessel which is pretty considerable , even in the faetus , and was so on the other side , as seen at letter I. On the left side ; the umbilical artery , at its origin , or its inflection , had a kind of web of arteries subdivided , some of which , doubtless , communicated with the aorta , or right iliac ; but neither of these branches appeared to be near the size of the right iliac , nor could we find any thing any-wise like to the trunk , e. which I long suspected to be the trunk of the right iliac .
What vessels then are these trunks , d. e. ?
Which of the two is the continuation of the umbilical , h. ?
This is a very important point , but not easily determined .
It would not have proved so , if I had injected the umbilical vein , as I generally do in all my monsters ; or if I had taken more care of the parts about the kidney-liver , which I certainly should have done , had I but suspected so many singularities .
I said , that at first sight , I took the trunk , e. to belong to the umbilical vein , and it is still an opinion , to which I am inclined , for the following reasons .
1 .
At this part , e. the aorta had its greatest circumference ; and , in tracing it from this trunk , above as well as below , it grew less and less .
This was , therefore , its trunk , or origin , and could not be a branch of it .
2 .
I have already said , that the mouths , h. of the umbilical vein , and , e. of the aorta inferior , were exactly of the same diameter , of the same white color , and of the same strength ; and that the other vessel , d. was much weaker , of a laxer texture , and of a somewhat livid color , like the coats of the veins .
3 .
The umbilical vein is , with respect to the mother , or to the placenta , which transmits the blood to the faetus , a real artery , going from the center to the circumference , or from the principal body , which is the mother , to an adjoining organ , which is the child ; and the umbilical arteries are properly veins , which return the blood from that adjoining body to the common center of the grand circulation .
The blood from the umbilical vein then is truly an arterial blood to the faetus .
In the usual structure of the embryo , nature has shortened all the ways , to bring the arterial blood of the mother more speedily into the heart , into the very aorta inferior of her faetus .
Therefore , in a subject , where there is no heart , or even liver , that vein ought to communicate immediately with the aorta inferior .
In this manner one conceives how this subject could do without a heart , the umbilical blood being a continuation of that from the arteries of the placenta , the uterus , and in short of the mother ; the impulsion of the maternal blood was propagated by that aorta through all its ramifications both above and below .
In one word , the heart of the mother supplied that of the faetus , and the circulation in this was a continuation of that of the mother .
These are the reasons inclining me towards that first opinion ; and here are those that suspended my judgment for some time in favour of the supposition of a communication of the umbilical vein with the trunk , d. of the vena cava of the faetus .
1 .
In every faetus the umbilical vein empties itself into the vena-cava in the liver ; therefore nature hath here followed her usual course .
2 .
With regard to the arterial trunk , e. it is close by the division , g. of the Iliac vein , whence it is very likely that it was the left iliac vein which was divided .
This last , and above all striking reason , made me employ almost a whole morning , in looking over and over this left iliac region , to discover the divided vessel , which would have put the whole matter out of dispute ; but I could find no trace or appearance of it .
All the vessels communicating with the left umbilical vein appeared very entire , though deprived of part of their ramifications by which the air escaped , but all grew in their course less and less in diameter .
Which then was the origin of this left umbilical artery ?
doutless the branches of the trunk , f. of the aorta , which were numberless in the pelvis , but had partly been spoiled the preceeding night , in dissecting the rectum , uterus , and bladder of this monster .
I add , that this trunk , e. was joined to some membranes , which we were obliged to pull about , in order to make it turn to the left , and this direction appeared not to be its natural position .
Be it granted , for a moment , that , e. is the left iliac , and that the umbilical vein joins it at , d. ; how could the blood circulate in this faetus ?
How could it have lived the nine months ?
d. is evidently a trunk of the cava , which generally enters the right auricle of the heart , dividing , like this , into the cava superior , d. b. which rises by the vertebrae up to F. and into the cava inferior , d. g. 1 .
It would be absurd to place the only moving power of circulation in the vena cava , or indeed in any vein .
2 .
When you have placed it there , what will this supposition tend to ? ?
3 .
This vein subdivides , and ramifies itself through the kidney-liver , the muscles and the spine ; but none of its branches communicates with the aorta .
The aorta on its part sends several branches into the kidney liver , very slender , and resembling , by their transversal direction , the common emulgents , but very different in size .
If then the circulating force were placed at d. it could only produce an inverse circulation , by the communication the cava might have by its capillary branches , with the like ramifications of the aorta , which supposition seems too much against nature to counterbalance the other opinion , which makes the trunk e. of the aorta , a portion of the umbilical vein , and the substitute of the heart .
Another anatomical fact proves this last opinion ; which is , that the aorta , and especially the superior , F. ran up as high as the cranium , and was of a pretty considerable size , while the venal trunk , d. had nothing but capillary branches in the upper parts ; so that it almost appeared evident that the vessel , e. F. was connected with the chief mover of the fluids .
Wherefore , supposing the trunk , d. to be the vena porta , or an imperfect cava going to some of the viscera , being the rudiments of an imperfect heart , or a vena-cava ending in a pouch , as the intestines did which should have entered the stomach , if there had been one ; the difficulty almost disappears .
I say almost , because , even on this supposition , if there was a circulation tion in this monster ; we must admit some anastomoses , between the arterial and venal system , which supplied those found in other faetuses ; since the venal blood must in some place or other re-enter the arterial torrent .
Such might be the anastomosis , K. fig. 4 .
For , by this hypothesis , the vascular system of this subject would be represented by fig. 4 .
in the following manner .
A. The umbilical cord .
B. The intestinal tube .
D. The kidney-liver .
E. A sort of glandula renalis .
a. The umbilical vein ; the great mover of the fluids .
b. The aorta , a continuation of that vein .
c. d. aorta superior , accompanied by the venacava .
e. Aorta inferior .
f. The distribution of the iliac .
g. The umbilical arteries , making a part of the distribution .
h. The trunk of the venae-cavae coming either from the portae , or from the viscus D , or forming a blind pouch in that part .
Some traces of the vena-cava superior appear towards C. I. The cava inferior going to form the iliacs .
K. A necessary anastomosis between the two kinds of vessels , arteries , and veins .
I place it in this conspicuous situation , though it might have been any where else .
I repeat it again , if I had but suspected so many singularities , what I now can give only by way of conjecture , might have become demonstrable in fact .
It is scarce probable that I shall ever have such another opportunity ; but it is more so , that it may offer to some one among the great number of the literati in Europe , who read the Philosophical Transactions .
This was the principal motive that determined me to present this observation , though imperfect , to the Royal Society .
Why should we hesitate to make a public acknowledgement of our faults , when our brethren may profit by , and amend , them ?
Another motive , which engaged me to offer this observation , such as it is , was , that even the imperfection of it does not affect the useful consequences deducible from it : for , whatsoever may have been the disposition of the blood-vessels of this monster , it is a fact absolutely certain , that it had no heart , nor any other viscus in the place of it ; and that the circulation of the fluids , which appears to have taken place from the existence of the principal arteries and veins , could not have had any other moving power than the circulation of the mother itself .
Hence this child , monstrous as it is , demonstrates the circulation of the blood from the mother to the faetus , and from the faetus to the mother again ; which some moderns deny , and others endeavour , at least , to render doubtful .
I presented to the Academy at Rouen some years ago , several observations which favoured the ancient system ; the present comes to their support , to give this excellent hypothesis of Harvey all the credit it deserves .
The child I speak of had no mouth , oesophagus , nor stomach , thus it could not , by that usual passage , be nourished from the waters that surrounded it ; it could not absorb from the surrounding fluid wherewith to fill its vessels , and supply its growth .
It , therefore , follows that it received both its arterial and alimentary fluids from the mother by the umbilical cord , and that it owed every thing to that circulation , which some would attempt to annihilate .
In the intestines of new-born children we find a black excrement , called meconium ; this black pulp can receive its color only from a bile thickened by retention , and poured directly from the ductus choledochus into the duodenum .
Now this faetus , having no liver , nor gall-bladder , &amp;c. could have no meconium ; therefore the pulp found in the intestines was of an ash-colour .
This monster had so little brain , that that viscus must have been of small import towards the functions of this animal .
And yet all these brainless faetuses are very lively .
Mr. Denis , who , in his twelfth conference , has given an account of one of them , and M. Vaissiere , who sent me one from Toulouze , the last year , both remark , ` ` that these children are remarkably lively in the mother 's belly ; that they were in violent motion , at the time of labor ; that the moment they were in the world they seemed suffocated , and became all at once motionless .
' ' This is a matter worthy of much reflection .
How can we conceive there can be sensation and motion , without almost any brain in one of these monsters ; and absolutely without any in the other ?
Sensibility , sensations , and passions , may exist without the brain , and have their seat in its meninges , and in the coats of the nerves formed by those meninges .
If I had not endeavoured to prove that point in my physiology , and lately in my dissertation on the sensibility of the dura and pia matter , the observations of children and animals born without brain , which are pretty considerable in number , would demonstrate it by facts .
That these children are more lively , that is , more sensible , I attribute to their having little of the nervous juice , though not less of the active fluid .
This nervous juice I termed fluide conservateur , the preserving fluid , in my physiology .
It is long since I have observed that an abundance of this nervous juice produces the contrary of vivacity ; and , as a consequence , of our principles , long sleep , or rigid continency for a length of time , renders us heavy and benummed , because in each of these circumstances , this nervous juice abounds and regurgitates , if I may so speak .
But these violent motions , whence have they their origin ?
there must be a nervous juice , to act in the muscles , and here we have very little .
Neither of these animals was deprived of the medulla spinalis , and one of them had a small portion of brain , or cerebellum .
This is one source of the nervous juice , and of the active fluid , necessary to muscular motion .
This source , I grant , is weak and poor , but I have made it appear in my treatise on this subject , which obtained the prize from the Academy of Berlin , that there is in the blood a richer store , which the nervous fluid unites to , and makes use of , in muscular motion .
We explain by this , how it happens that an ass , who has so much less brains than a man , is , notwithstanding , so much stronger , because it has much more blood .
Here then is a second spring that affords these monsters a considerable supply ; but though sufficient for their motions , it is not equal to that of an ordinary faetus , and the violent agitations of their body arise from their great sensibility , which we have just now accounted for .
Now , the blood in the faetus , and especially in these , belongs to the mother ; they are furnished by her , as well with air , as with the nervous juice , and the animal fluid , which are essential to her .
Wherefore , as soon a these children are separated from the mother , and deprived of that vital source , all motion must cease in them , as if they were suffocated , that is , as in any other suffocated faetus .
Let us conclude this account by a word or two on the cause of these monsters .
The great quantity of waters voided by the mothers of these children , proves that the principle of their monstrocity is a disease , a sort of dropsy , and even a kind of hydrocephalus , which had run off a considerable time before the labor .
The two hydatides I found at the origin of the brachial nerves , and which had evidently been the cause of the mutilation of the upper extremities , are examples that help us to comprehend that of the other organs .
On supposing a like disorder on the origin of other nerves , which have their rise from the brain , it will be obvious that the organs , to which these nerves run , that is , where they convey the nervous fluid , which contain the rudiments of every part , will be wanting .
It may indeed be said , there are hydrocephali that have all the organs very well formed : but there the disease has commenced after the perfect formation of these parts , whereas if you suppose it to have happened in the very time of that formation , you will see that the nervous juice , vitiated , diluted , and turned out of its natural course , can no longer be employed in the generation of those organs .
Those who have attended my courses , and have read my physiology , will be pleased to see that all these mysteries , which one would have thought impenetrable , are easily accounted for upon the principles I have laid down .

