XLVII .
A Letter from Richard Price , D. D. F. R. S. to Benjamin Franklin , L L. D. F. R. S. on the Effect of the Aberration of Light on the Time of a Transit of Venus over the Sun .
DEARSI R , I Cannot doubt but that the observation made by your ingenious friend in the paper * you sent me is right .
The aberration of Venus must , I think , affect the phases of a transit , by retarding them , and not by accelerating them .
This retardation is 551/ 2~ ; for that is the time nearly which Venus , during a transit , takes to move over 3~.7 .
This , however , is by no means the whole retardation of a transit occasioned by aberration .
There is a retardation arising from the aberration of the Sun , as well as from that of Venus .
The aberration of the Sun , it is well known , lessens its longitude about 20~ .
and the aberraton of Venus , agreeably to your friend 's demonstration , increases its longitude at the time of a transit 3~.7 .
Venus , therefore , and the Sun , at the instant of the true beginning of a transit , must be separated from one another by aberration 23~.7 ; and , since Venus then moves nearly at the rate of 4~ in an * The paper which occasioned this letter , and which is here referred to , may be found in p. 358 of this volume .
hour , 7 Read Dec. 20 .
hour , it will move over 23~.7 in 5~ : 55~ .
And consequently , from the instant of the real beginning of a transit , 5~ : 55~ must elapse before it can begin apparently .
It may , I know , be objected here , that the aberration of the Sun ought not to be taken into consideration , because the calculations from the solar tables give the apparent places of the Sun , or its longitude with the effect of aberration included , and therefore always about 20~ too little .
But from this observation a conclusion will follow very different from that which the objection supposes .
The retardation I have mentioned is properly the time that the calculated phases of a transit of Venus will precede the apparent phases , supposing the tables from which the calculation is made to give the true places of the Sun .
If they give the apparent places of the Sun , this retardation , instead of being lessened , will be considerably increased .
In order to prove this , I must desire it may be remembered , that in deducing by trigonometrical operations the geocentric places of a planet from the heliocentric , the Earth is supposed to be in that point of the ecliptic which is exactly opposite to , or 180~ from the place of the sun , and that this supposition is just only when the sun 's true place is taken .
In reality , the Earth is always about 20~ more forward in its orbit than the point opposite to the Sun 's apparent place ; and in consequence of this it will happen , that in calculating a transit of Venus from tables which give the Sun 's apparent places , a greater difference will arise between the calculated and the observed times than if the tables had given the Sun 's true places .
For , let S be the Sun , T the Earth , V Venus .
Were there no aberration of light , the Sun would be always seen in its true place , or in the direction TS .
But , in reality , in consequence of aberration , it will be seen 20~ less advanced in the ecliptic , or in the direction Ts , supposing STs to be an angle of 20~ .
Now a calculation from tables giving the true places of the Sun , would fix the moment of a conjunction , to the time that Venus gets to TS ; but this , though the time of the true conjunction , would not be the time of the observed conjunction ; for the Sun being then really seen in the direction Ts , Venus , after getting to TS , must move 20~ , or from a to c , before the apparent conjunction can take place .
But if the calculations Ss L are made from the apparent places of the Sun , the conjunction will be fixed to the time Venus gets to t S , or a line drawn through S parallel to s T , for in this case t will be the point of the ecliptic opposite to the apparent place of the Sun , and the longitude of the sun seen from t will be 20~ less than its true longitude , and therefore the same with ac EV its apparent longitude .
But the Earth being then really at T , Venus will , at the calculated time of a conjunction , be observed at a distance from the Sun equal to the angle LT s. This angle , supposing VT 277 , and VS 723 , may be easily found to be 72~.2 .
Add to this 3~.7 , the proper aberration of Venus at the time of a transit , removing it more towards E , and the whole visible distance of Venus from the Sun 's center at the calculated moment of a conjunction , will be 75~.9 , over which it will move in 19 minutes of time .
And this , consequently , will be the retardation of the phases of a transit of Venus occasioned by aberration , on the supposition , that in calculating , the Sun 's apparent , and not his true place is taken .
I believe these observations have not been attended to by astronomers ; and therefore I am the more desirous of communicating them to you .
I am , Dear Sir , with much respect , your obliged humble servant , Richard Price .
P. S. In a former letter which I sent you , I gave , by mistake , the error occasioned by aberration less than I have now given it .
The discovery of this mistake I owe to the kind assistance and correction with which Mr. Maskelyne , the astronomer royal , has been pleased to favour me .
I have , for the sake of more distinctness and clearness , supposed Venus to move in the plane of the ecliptic .
Some differences will arise from the inclination of the path of Venus to the ecliptic , and also from taking the aberration of the Sun , and the proportion of Venus 's distance from the Earth to her distance from the Sun , exactly as they really are at the time of a transit .
Thus , at the time of the last transit of Venus , supposing light to come from the Sun to the Earth in 8~,2 , the aberration of the Sun was 19~.8 .
The distance of Venus from the Earth was to its distance from the Sun as 290 to 726 , and therefore the retardation 18~ : 16~ .
Mr. Canton has observed , that in the Con .
des Temp , Mr. De la Land makes the effect of aberration at the inferior conjunction of Venus and Mercury to be an augmentation of their longitudes .
Indeed , Mr. Bliss himself observes this ; and yet , through an oversight , makes the effect as to time to be an acceleration .
Vid. Phil. Trans. vol. LII .
p. 249 .

