Received February 8 , 1770 .
XXXIV .
Difficulties in the Newtonian Theory of Light , considered and removed , by the Rev. S. Horsley , LL. B. F. R. S. DR. Franklin , in a letter to a correspondent at New-York , the 23d of that valuable collection with which the public was obliged in the latter end of the year 1768 , proposes some objections to the Newtonian theory of light .
His words are these .
` ` I am much in the dark about light .
I am not satisfied with the doctrine that supposes particles of matter called light , continually driven off from the sun 's surface with a swiftness so prodigious .
Must not the smallest particle conceivable have , with such a motion , a force exceeding that of a twenty-four pounder discharged from a cannon ?
Must not the sun diminish exceedingly by such a waste of matter , and the planets recede to greater distances by the lessened attraction ?
Yet these particles with this amazing motion will not drive before them , or remove , the least and lightest dust they meet with : and the sun , for aught we know , continues of his ancient dimensions , and his attendants move in their ancient orbits .
' ' Dr~ VOL. LX .
Hhh Franklin 's Read Dec. 20 , Franklin 's questions are of some importance , and deserve a strict discussion .
Upon the supposition that light is a copious emanation of innumerable small particles of matter from the sun , I had once occasion to enquire , what the force of motion produced in every such emission could possibly amount to at the utmost .
For this purpose , I made an estimate of the greatest probable magnitude of the particles of light ; and of the greatest density of each .
I likewise computed the greatest number of such particles , that could possibly fly off at once from the surface of the sun ; supposing the sun 's horizontal parallax to be no more than 8~ .
These computations , with an account of the principles on which they were founded , having been already given to the publica ; I shall make use of the results ( which I shall here briefly state ) as data for the discussion of Dr. Franklin 's questions .
I suppose the particles of light to be equal spherules .
This , perhaps , is not the case .
Each color has probably its own size ; but , there will be a mean size , which is sufficient for my purpose .
This mean size I suppose to be so small , that the diameter of each spherule does not exceed one millionth of one millionth of an inch .
I shall show hereafter , that there is much reason to suppose that the particles of light are in fact much less than spherules of this diameter .
a In a little treatise , entitled , The Power of God , deduced from the computable instantaneous Productions of it in the Solar System .
I suppose the density of each particle three times that of ironb .
The number of such spherules that contain as much matter as an iron ball of one yard diameter , I have found to be 15552 XXXVIc d ; conquently 576 XXXVI such spherules contain as much matter as an iron ball of 1 foot diameter .
Let such a ball be supposed to move uniformly with a velocity that should carry it 1000 yards in 1~ .
The light of the sun traverses the semidiameter of the orbis magnus in 7~ nearly .
In the ensuing calculations , I shall reckon the sun 's horizontal parallax 9~ .
According to this hypothesis , the semidiameter of the orbis magnus will contain 22919 semidiameters of the earth .
In 1~ of time , light , according to the velocity assigned to it , traverses 1/ 4 2 0th of this space , or 54,57 semidiameters of the earth , or 381092323 London yards .
Hence the velocity of each particle of light , will be to that of the iron ball moving 1000 yards in 1~ as 381092 to 1 , very nearly .
And the ball being 1 foot diameter , it has been shown that the matter in each particle is to the matter in the ball , as 1 to 576 XXXVI .
Hence the force of the motion in each particle of light , is to the force of motion in the ball as 381092 to 576 XXXVI ; that is , as 1 to 1511444 XXVII , or~ b Instantaneous Product .
&amp;c. p. 30 .
c Ibid. d The Roman numerals placed after the Arabic characters , denote the number of zeros that must be added to the Arabic figures , to complete the expression of the number intended .
it is equal to the force of motion in an iron ball of 1 foot diameter moving 1/ 1511444 XXVIIth of 1000 yards in 1~ , or to that of an iron ball of 1 inch diameter moving 1/ 874679 XXIth of 1 yard in 1~ , or to that of an iron ball of 1/ 4 of an inch diameter moving 1/ 13666 XXIth of 1 yard in ~~ ; that is , moving less than 1/ 4555 XXI of 1 foot in 1~ ; that is , moving less than a foot in 4555 XX.1 seconds , or in more than one hundred forty four thousand millions of millions of Egyptian years : or the force of motion in each particle of light coming from the sun , is less than that in an iron ball of 1/ 4 of an inch diameter , moving at the rate of less than an inch in 12 thousand millions of millions of Egyptian years .
Dr. Franklin 's first question is answered .
A particle of matter , which is probably larger than any particle of light , moving with the velocity of light , has a force of motion , which , instead of exceeding the force of a twenty-four pounder discharged from a cannon , is infinitely less than that of the smallest shot discharged from a pocket pistol , or less than any that art can create .
I proceed to the other questions-And , I think that I shall make it appear , that it is very possible that light may be produced by a continual emission of matter from the sun , without any such waste of his substance as should sensibly contract his dimensions , or sensibly alter the motions of the planets , within any moderate length of time .
Indeed , I do not think it necessary to the production of any of the phenomenon of light , that the emanation from the sun should be continual in a strict mathematical sense , or without any interval .
It seems sufficient to all purposes , that the intervals should be exceeding short .
But this I only mention .
I think it possible that a continual emanation might subsist , without any such dangerous consequences to the solar system , as Dr. Franklin apprehends .
Dr. Franklin 's character is not more distinguished by his superior talents , than by a candor truly philosophical .
And upon this circumstance , I build the strongest confidence , that he will not be offended , that I differ from him : that , as a friend to enquiry , he will be pleased that I take the liberty to communicate my own notions , however opposite they may be to his .
It will be easily understood , that a continual emanation from the sun does not necessarily imply a continual waste , or loss , equal to the emanation.-If light is continually issuing from the sun in all directions , part of this is continually returning to him , by reflection from the planets , and other light is continually coming to him , from the suns of other systems .
It is true , that the light which he receives , is but a very small part of the light which he gives .
For if the light always coming to the sun were equal to the light always going from him , our atmosphere would be as strongly enlightened in the night as in the day.-But this is not the case ; and the proportion of the light that comes , to the light that goes , cannot be greater than that of night-light at a medium , to day-light at a medium-still it is something-and the continual loss of substance that the sun sustains cannot be more than the difference between the light that he gives , and the light that he receives .
And therefore , if there were no other recruit of the sun 's substance ( which is by no means a probable supposition ) yet the continual waste will , on this account alone , be less than the continual emission ; and the sun cannot lose so much of his substance as a single emission of light contains , but in some determinate time .
I shall suppose that the sun gives so much more than he receives , that he loses the amount of one emission in every second of an hour .
Let us see what will be the consequence .
Every particle of light that issues from the sun , must leave a spherical vacuity of one millionth of one millionth of an inch diameter .
The greatest number of particles of this size that can issue from the surface of the sun at once , if the horizontal parallax be 9~ , is 104666 XLI ~ , because this is the greatest number of such particles that would have room to lie at once upon his surface .
And the same will be the greatest number of spherical vacuities made by one emission .
Many of these vacuities are no sooner made , than they are filled up by the light that is coming to the sun from other systems , or returning to him from the bodies of his own , or , perhaps with other matter which he may receive in various emanations from the planets ; for I strongly suspect that a perpetual circulation of finer matter may subsist between all the large bodies of the universe .
The emission of light , however , is supposed so far to exceed the whole ~ The greatest number of particles that can issue from the sun at once , was reckoned in the Instant .
Product .
132467 XLI ; but then the ~ 's parallax was reckoned only 8~ .
supply , that in every second , over and above the vacuities that have been filled up with adventitious matter , the foregoing number , 104666 XLI , have been formed that have received no such supply .
The fluid matter of the sun~ rushes from all sides into these , and fills them up to its own level .
The sun by this means shrinks a little , and loses , once in every second , so much of its solid content , as the solid contents of these vacuities amount to .
I have found that the solid contents of 46656 XXXVI such vacuities are equal to the sphere of one yard g. Therefore the solid contents of 104666 XLI such vacuities , are equal to 2243351/ 2 times the sphere of one yard .
And so much is the sun 's solid content diminished every second .
The sphere of the earth is to the sphere of one yard , as 27247031 XIV to I h. Therefore the sphere of the earth is to 2243351/ 2 times the sphere of one yard as 121456 XI to I. Therefore the sun loses an earth of its solid content in 121456 XI seconds , or 385130000 Egyptian years nearly .
If the sun 's parallax be 9~ , the solid content of the earth 1/ 1 217420 of the solid content of the sun .
Therefore , in 385130000 Egyptian years , the sun should lose 1/ 1 217420 th of his solid content , and consequently in the same time the diameter of the sun fI suppose the sun to be a fluid mass : by this hypothesis , I give the utmost force to Dr. Franklin 's objection ; for , the more perfectly the sun is fluid , the more suddenly will the vacuities be filled up .
g Vide Instant .
Product .
p. 30 .
h Ibid. p. 16 .
should lose 1/ 3 652260 th of its whole dimensions .
And in the same time the apparent diameter should lose the like part of its quantity , if the distance between the earth and sun remained unaltered .
The sun 's mean apparent diameter contains 1922 seconds .
Therefore 1/ 3 6522~0 th of the ~ 's apparent diameter , is 1/ 1 90 0th of one second very nearly .
So inconsiderable would be the whole diminution of the sun 's apparent diameter , that could arise from the waste of his substance , in 385130000 Egyptian years .
But the waste of the sun 's substance must lessen the attraction between the earth and sun .
As the attraction lessens , the earth will recede to greater distances .
And hence there will arise a further diminution of the sun 's apparent diameter , and a prolongation of the anomalistic year .
The density of each particle of light has been supposed three times that of iron , or 23 times the mean density of the earth i. Therefore , as often as the sun 's loss by light amounts to an earth in size , it will amount to 23 earths in matter .
The matter of 23 earths is 1/ 1 3232d of the sun 's matter , if the sun 's parallax be 9~ .
Therefore in 385130000 Egyptian years the sun loses 1/ 1 3232d of his matter ; and the gravitation towards the sun , at any given distance , diminishes in ~I reckon the mean density of the earth no greater than that of common water .
It is certain that it cannot be less .
Sir Isaac Newton reckons it 5 or 6 times greater ; but I consess that I am not satisfied with his reasons for making it so great .
If I have under-rated it , I have , in so doing , given the advantage to Dr. Franklin 's objection .
the same proportion .
But this alteration is much too small to discover itself in the motions of the earth or any of the planets .
I will not at present consider , by what law the distance of the planets from the sun would increase , because the enquiry could not be reduced to a small compass ; but it is obvious , that , whatever that law may be , it must arise solely from the diminution of gravitation : and the like is to be said of the increase of the anomalistic periods .
And therefore , while the diminution of gravitation is insensible , the changes in these circumstances must be insensible too .
Of all the changes to which our system may be obnoxious , those which should arise from the waste of the sun 's substance in light , upon the supposition that light is an actual emanation of matter from the sun , reckoning that waste at the utmost , are perhaps the least considerable .
In the foregoing computations , the instantaneous emission of light has been greatly over-rated .
For if the particles of light were of the magnitude and density which has been assigned to each , and were to issue from the sun in the close arrangement that has been supposed , they would form a sort of crust upon the sun 's surface , at least 12 times more dense than water , i. e. 9600 times more dense than our atmosphere in the parts next the earth 's surface , if the density of common water compared to that of air be reckoned only as 800 to I k. But if the density of light upon the sun 's surface be 9600 that of our air , its density when it arrives at the earth , or its k It is well known that the density of water to that of air , is as 850 to I at least .
density upon the surface of the orbis magnus ~ , should be more than 1/ 5th part of the density of our air .
When substances of different specific gravities , as a piece of gold and a piece of cork , descend , in the exhausted receiver , with equal velocities , and fall equal heights in the same time , it is obvious , that the density of the medium , through which they fall , bears no sensible proportion to the density even of the lighter substance .
The medium through which such substances fall , in a transparent glass receiver , is composed of some small portion of rarefied air , and , to all appearance , of the same quantity of light , as the receiver contains before exhaustion .
For the quantity of light , in a transparent receiver , can by no means suffer any diminution , by the action of the air-pump .
The density of the light therefore , in our air , is certainly too small to bear any sensible proportion to that of gold or even of cork .
And the density of cork bears , though a great , yet a finite and a sensible proportion to that of the atmosphere ; because in air gold and cork do not descend with equal velocities .
Hence , I think , I may conclude with the greatest certainty , that the density of the sun 's light at the earth , or upon the surface of the orbis magnus , is too small to bear any sensible proportion to the density of common air ; and I shall hardly underrate the density of the light , if I reckon it only 1/ 1 000 0th part of the density of the air , or 1/ ~ 00000 0th part of the density of common water .
Suppose this ~ By the surface of the orbis magnus , I mean to denote a particular place in absolute space , namely the surface of that sphere which is concentric with the ~ , and hath the earth 's mean distance from the ~ for its semidiameter .
to be the density of light upon the surface of the orbis magnus , and it will be found by computation , that its density upon the sun 's surface , must be less than 1/ 1 7 3d of the density of common water .
From these considerations , I think it may be concluded with the greatest certainty , that the quantity of matter that issues from the sun in light , has been greatly over-rated in the foregoing computations .
I apprehend , however , that the density of each separate particle cannot be less than has been supposed : but that the magnitude of each is less , and the arrangement less compact m. Let the density of each , and the number that issues at any one time from the sun , remain as before ; and let us consider , in what proportion the magnitude of each particle , must be diminished , so that they may altogether form a fluid , on the sun 's surface , 173 times less dense than water .
Let ABCD represent a section of the sun 's sphere , through the centre S n. In the spherical surface ABC D , take any point B. Join S B , and take Be , Bf , each equal to the semidiameter of a particle of light .
Upon the centre S , at the distances Se , S f , imagine two other spheres , eg h , fk l , one enclosing , the other enclosed within the sphere ABC D. The solid space efklg h , is the space that contains all the particles of light ( with their interstices ) that issue together from the spherical surface ABC D ; and because of bears an exceeding small proportion to S B , therefore the spherical surfaces eg h , fk l , are very nearly equal each to the other , and to the sphe~ Vide Instant .
Product .
p. 37 .
~ See the fig. p. 429 .
rical surface ABCD ; and the solid space contained between them is very nearly equal to a cylinder , upon a base equal to the spherical surface ABCD , and of altitude equal to e f. Therefore diminish the diameter of each particle of light , that is , diminish e f , in any proportion whatsoever , and the solid space ABCD xef diminishes in the same proportion .
And if the matter in that space were given , the density of it would always be as 1/ e f. But the matter of each particle of light , and consequently the matter of the given number in the space ABCDxe f , is always as e f3 .
Therefore the density of the substance formed by light in the space ABCDxe f , is always as e f3/ e f , or as e f2 .
That is , the number of spherical particles of light , in the solid space ABCD xe f , being given , and the density of each particle , and the spherical surface ABCD being given , the square of the diameter of each particle will be as the density of the substance they compose , upon the surface of the sun .
But it has been found , that if the diameter of each spherule were one millionth of one millionth of an inch , the greatest number of such spherules , that the sun 's surface can contain at once , would , with the density which has been assigned to each separate particle , form a substance upon it 12 times more dense than water .
Therefore , that the same number of such particles should form a substance about 173 times less dense than water , the diameter of each must not exceed 1 0/ 4 5 6th of one millionth of one millionth of an inch .
But I have shown that the A e B f S ~ l h D g k c greatest probable density of light upon the sun 's surface does not amount to 173d part of the density of common water .
Therefore the diameter of each spherule does not exceed 1 0/ 4 5 6th , or more accurately , 100 0/ 4 564 8th , of one millionth of one millionth of an inch ; and is probably still less n. More than 95100 spherules of this size go to make up one of the size first assumed .
Therefore , though the sun should lose as much a Instant .
Product .
p. 38-41 .
matter , as can be supposed to be contained in any single emission of light , 95100 times in every second , no sensible alterations in the system could take place in millions of years .
And perhaps light does not issue from the sun so frequently as 95100 times in a second .
June 13 , 1770 .
S. Horsley .
P. S. The late Dr. Pemberton , of Gresham College , to whom the foregoing paper was communicated , about twelve months before his death , in a letter with which he favoured the author , upon the subject , remarked , that he had no material objection to any part of the reasoning , except it was , that the particles of light are too peremptorily spoken of as spherules .
Their real figure is quite unknown ; but the probability is , that they are not spherical , since Sir Isaac Newton found that their different sides have different properties .
As the like objection may occur to others , it may not be improper to add a few words to obviate it .
I would by no means be understood to assert , that the particles of light are of a spherical figure .
But , whatever their figure may be , I conceive that their size must be so small , that the diagonal of each little solid cannot exceed one millionth of one millionth of an inch , or , at least , that each is capable of being circumscribed within a sphere of that diameter .
To the reasons which are given for making them so small , in the treatise so often referred to , I shall here add another , which may perhaps be more generally convincing : namely , that these bodies must be so minute as to find room to enter in , in swarms , at the pupils of the eyes of the smallest microscopic animals , and not to injure , by their stroke , the very delicate fibres of their optic nerves , nor to lacerate the edges of the uvea ; which those that enter near the sides of the perforation , if their figure be not round , must often brush with their angles , as they pass by .
Now , if it be granted , that the greatest diagonal of each solid corpuscle of light does not exceed one millionth of one millionth of an inch , or that each is capable of being circumscribed with a sphere of that diameter ; then , the solid content of a sphere of that diameter is the maximum of the solid content of each corpuscle , and the matter in such a sphere , of due density , is the maximum of the matter in each corpuscle .
The maximum therefore of the force of motion in each particle , is the force of a spherule of the size assumed , moving with the known velocity of light ; and therefore , be the figure what it will , my conclusion ( p.420 .
) which rests entirely on the maximum of size and matter , will still hold good , unless it can be shown that I have under-rated the density of each particle ; and even if it could be proved that I have assumed the density too small , in the proportion of 1 to 12 thousand times the square of one million , still the general conclusion will not be shaken : for this vast increase of the density will raise the force of motion , in each corpuscle puscle , to no more than that of an iron ball 1/ 4 of an inch diameter , moving one inch in a whole year .
Again , in the diagram , p. 429 , SB being the diameter of the sun , and f B , Be being each the half of one millionth of one millionth of an inch , the space contained between the spherical surfaces fk l , eg h , is the maximum of the space that the particles of light with their due proportion of interslice can fill , as they start forth from the surface of the sun .
For , whatever their figure be , it must be such a one as can be laid between these two spherical surfaces .
Now the quantity of matter in this space , must not be greater , than it would be upon the hypothesis that each figure was spherical , and the number of spherical particles the greatest possible .
Since , upon that hypothesis , the density of matter , crowded into this space , is vastly too great , to be consistent with the appearances of nature ( vide p. 425 , 426 .
) ; and consequently a greater density would be more inconsistent .
Therefore the maximum of the matter , and consequently , if the density of each separate particle has been rightly assumed , the maximum of the solid content , in each emission of light , is what I have made it ; at least it does not exceed what I have made it , be the figure of the particles what it will ; and my conclusions ( p. 424 and 425 .
) which rest entirely upon the maximum of the solid content , and that of the matter , and are the stronger the less these maxima be , will still hold good .
But if these conclusions stand , the objections moved by Dr. Franklin vanish .
The only part of my reasoning which will be affected , by supposing the figure of the particles of light not to be spherical , will be that , ( p. 427 , &amp;c. ) in which I attempt to show , in what proportion the magnitude of each particle , and the matter , contained in each emission , must be less than the maximum , in order to make the density of light no greater , than may be consistent with the appearances of nature .
Here indeed the figure of the corpuscles is of great importance .
The diminution necessary will be very different in different figures , and the figure , I confess , may be such , as to make it much less , than what I have shown to be requisite upon the spherical hypothesis .
However , if 1/ 1 000 0th part of density of our air be admitted to be as great a density , as can reasonably be allowed to light , at the surface of the orbis magnus , the matter of each emission must not , upon any hypothesis of the figure of the corpuscles , exceed 1/ 2 08 4th of the maximum .
For , in order to bring the density down , from the maximum to any other given limit , either the matter must remain unaltered , and the space , which it is supposed to occupy , be increased , in the proportion in which the density is to be diminished ; or the space must remain unaltered , and the matter be diminished in proportion to the density ; or , if both space and matter be altered , the matter must be changed in the proportion compounded of the two , in which both space and density are varied .
Now the space which we suppose the light to occupy , as it is emerging from the surface of the sun , must not exceed the space contained between the spherical surfaces eg h , fkl ( fig. p. 429 .
) .
For that space , as has been observed , is the maximum .
This space may be diminished ; but if it be diminished , the matter being diminished as the space and as the density jointly , must be more diminished than in the simple proportion of the density .
Therefore the diminution of the matter will be the least possible , if , the space being supposed to continue at its maximum , the matter be diminished in the simple proportion of the maximum of the density to the density required .
Various formations of the particles of light might be thought of which would answer this purpose .
It might be answered , indeed , upon the spherical hypothesis , by diminishing the number of spherules , retaining the maximum of their size ; or retaining the maximum both of size and number , if it can be thought reasonable to diminish the density of each particle .
But upon any hypothesis , the diminution of matter cannot be less than has been said .
That is , the matter of each emission cannot possibly exceed 1/ 2 08 4th of the maximum .
For the proportion of the maximum of the density to the density required , will be found by computation , to be that of 2084 to 1 , very nearly .
Therefore the utmost probable amount of one emission is 1/ 2 08 4th of the maximum , be the figure of the corpuscles what it will .
And the sun may lose the quantity of a whole emission 2084 times in a second without any sensible consequences .
I cannot apprehend from , any quarter , so unphilosophical an objection , as that the extreme minuteness of the particles of light , which I have shown to be necessary , if light be really matter , is an argument against their existence .
Size is a mere accident , and no part of the essence of any being .
Great and small , applied to finite things , are purely terms of comparison .
One Being only is absolutely Great : he whose substance pervades and fills the whole and every part of Absolute Space ; because in respect of Him , all things that are , are little .
Notwithstanding the maximum of moving force , in each particle of light is so inconsiderable as I have shown it to be , yet the number of particles , out of each emission , which are directed towards the earth , and fall upon its enlightened hemisphere , being exceeding great , it may perhaps be imagined , that the , force impressed by them all upon the earth , if they all actually strike its surface , may amount to something worth attending to .
I have taken the pains to satisfy myself upon this question , and shall briefly mention the result of my computations .
Reckoning every emission at its maximum , I find that the number of the particles , out of each , which should fall upon the earth 's enlightened hemisphere , is 492023 XXXI , or that of which the logarithm is 36.6919854 .
The moving forces of this whole number amount to as much , as the force of an iron ball , of one yard diameter , flying 68 mile and 887 yards in one second .
But the progressive force , which they might communicate to the earth , does not exceed that of an iron ball of the same size , flying 34 mile and 443 yards in one second o. And , if this whole force be transferred ~ Only one particle out of each emission from any very small given part of the sun 's surface , can strike the earth 's surface perK kk2 from from the iron ball to the globe of the earth , the progressive velocity of the earth 's center will be found to be no more , than that with which a body would traverse about 1/ 2 of one millionth of one millionth of pendicularly .
The force of every particle , which impinges obliquely , is resolvable into two , one perpendicular to the surface , and the other parallel to it .
That part of the force , which is perpendicular to the earth 's surface , produces a progressive motion of the whole globe .
The other , which is parallel to the surface , contributes nothing to the progressive motion , but tends to produce a rotation of the globe upon an axis .
Hence the progressive force of motion , communicated to the globe , is less than it would be , if all the particles struck the surface perpendicularly .
It is further lessened upon another account , namely , that the whole of the operpendicular force is not effective in moving the earths ~ .
I find by computation that the diminution upon the whole is 1/ 2 .
For the ease of the mathematical reader , I shall briefly state the principles upon which this computation of the force with which the earth may be struck by light , has been framed .
The number of particles , which are directed to the earth out of each emission , is to half the number of the whole emission , in the duplicate proportion of the chord of the sun 's horizontal parallax , to the chord of 90~ : by the known doctrine of Archimedes .
Hence , the number of the whole emission being determined , the number of those which tend towards the earth , is given .
And the force of each single particle being given , the sum of the forces of that given number is given ; and this is the progressive force which would be impressed upon the earth , if all the force of each particle were effective .
In what proportion the progressive force is diminished , on account of the various obliquities of impulse , is thus investigated .
Imagine T to be the earth 's center and ACB to be half a great circle 1 C pq no lm hk o t K ATgfedB an inch in 100~ .
This is the utmost effect of the force impressed upon the earth by each emission .
If the emissions were incessant , this might be considered as a central force , counteracting the sun 's attraction : of the earth , perpendicular to that which separates the enlightened and the dark hemisphere , and which shall be called the terminator .
Upon the plane of this semicircle , suppose the terminator , and its parallels in the enlightened hemisphere , to be projected , into right lines AB , k h , l m , no , &amp;c. which are diameters of the circles respectively , of which they are the projections .
The sun 's distance may be considered as infinite ; and therefore the rays of light , i. e. the directions of the particles , when they reach the earth 's surface , are to be considered as parallel to each other , and all of them perpendicular to the plane of the terminator .
Now imagine the whole enlightened hemisphere to be divided into innumerable little zones AB k h , hkm l , mln o , &amp;c. by small circles parallel to the terminator .
Let the breadths of these little zones , measured upon a great circle passing through the poles of the terminator , that is , let the insinitesimal arcs B k , k m , n o , &amp;c. be so proportioned to each other , that perpendiculars k d , m e , o f , &amp;c. being drawn from the extremities of these arcs , to the right line AB , which is the common intersection of the great circle ACB , and the plane of the terminator , the infinitesimal segments of that line Bd , d e , e f , &amp;c. may be equal .
Now imagine the particles of light which fall upon any one of these little zones , for instance , noq p , to meet with no resistance from the earth 's surface , but to penetrate the globe , and to pass on without refraction or inflection , in the direction perpendicular to the terminator , till they arrive at the plane of the terminator , and there suppose them to stop , and each to lye still , in the place on which it falls .
It is evident that the particles of light that fall upon , and have been supposed to pass through , the spherical zone pqo n , will , with their proper interstices , cover that annular space upon the plane of the terminator , which is the orthographical projection of the zone pqo n , upon that plane , and is comprised between the circumferences of circles , of which the right lines Tg and Tf are the radii .
Hence the number of the particles of light , which fall upon the evanescent zone pqo n , are as that evanescent annular space for its tendency is to push the earth directly from the sun .
I need not say , that it is infinitely too small , in comparison of the sun 's attraction , to produce any sensible effect .
which they cover , that is , as gfx the circumference of the circle of which Tf is the radius , that is , as gfx in the right line T f. But that part of the force of each particle , impinging on the zone pqo n , which is perpendicular to the surface of the zone , is as o f , if TB ( the semidiameter of the earth ) be put for the whole force .
For join T o , and draw fK perpendicular to T o. The particle impinging at o moves in the direction o f. Let the right line of then express its whole force , and this force of is composed of the two o K , K f , of which oK is perpendicular to the surface of the sphere at o , and Kf is parallel to it .
But o K : of=o f : oT or TB .
Again , through K , draw Kt perpendicular to o f. The force oK is resolved into two o t , t k , of which ot is perpendicular to the plane of the terminator , and is the only part of the force oK , which tends to produce a progressive motion of the globe , in the direction of the impinging particles , that is , directly from the sun .
The other part tK urges the center of the globe along the plane of the terminator ; but the forces tK being equal and contrary on opposite sides of , and at equal distances from , the perpendicular ray , destory each others effects .
Now it has been shown , that the whole force of the particle impinging at o is to that part of its force which is perpendicular to the earth 's surface at o , as TB to o f. And it is manifest that oK is to o t , that is , the perpendicular force , of the particle impinging at o , is to that part of it , which is effective in moving the earth 's center , as TB to o f. Therefore the whole force of the particle impinging at o is to its effective part , as TB2 to o f2 .
That is , the effective part is as o f2 .
The number of particles impinging on the zone , has been shown to be as gfxT f. The progressive force of motion excited in the earth 's center , by all the particles impinging on the infinitessimal zone pqo n , must be , as the number of the particles and the effective part of each , jointly ; that is , as g~xTfx of2 , or writing a for TB , and x for B f , as xx a-x x 2ax-x2 .
And this is the fluxion of the progressive force of motion excited in the globe , by the particles impinging upon that segment of the The rotatory forces mentioned in the last note if they were infinitely greater than they really are , would not , in the least degree , disturb the diurnal rotation ; because every one of them is destroyed , by an equal one , in a contrary direction , on the other side of , and at an equal distance from , the perpendicular ray .
I have enquired , what may be the utmost stroke , which the retina of a common eye sustains , when the eye , in a bright day , is turned up directly to the sun .
This force will evidently be at its maximum , if the emission be reckoned at its maximum .
The number of particles which enter an eye , looking up directly at the sun , are to the number out of each emission , which are directed towards the earth , in the duplicate proportion of the diameter of the pupil to the diameter of the earth .
And the force with which the eye is struck , is to the sum of the forces of all the particles which strike the earth , in the same proportion .
If , therefore , the diameter of the pupil , when the eye is exposed to the direct impulse of the sun 's rays , be reckoned 1/ 10th of an inch , which I apprehend must rather exceed sphere , of which p AB q is the projection .
The number of particles impinging on the zone pqo n , being as gfxT f , or as xx a-x , if each impinged perpendicularly , and its whole force were effective , the sum of the effective forces impressed upon the whole , would be as gfxTfx TB2 , or xx a3-a2x .
And this would be the fluxion of the progressive force of motion of the globe excited by the particles impinging upon the segment of which p AB q is the projection , if all impinged in directions perpendicular to the surface , and the whole of their forces were effective .
The fluent of xx a-x x 2ax-x2 is 1/ 4 x 2ax-x2 2 .
And the fluent of xx a~ a2 x is a3 x 1/ 2 a2 x2 .
than fall short of its real magnitude , in those circumstances , it will be found that every stroke which it receives from them , exceeds not that , which an iron shot , 1/ 4 of an inch diameter , would give , moving only at the rate of 16 , 16 inches in a year .
This would be the stroke if the emission were at its maximum .
Is it not owing to the extreme minuteness of the fibres of the nerves , that a stroke , which is certainly less than the 1/ 2084th part of this , is not sustained by our organs , without pain ?
When x=a , the first of these two fluents is the sum of the progressive forces actually impressed upon the whole hemisphere ACB , and the latter is the sum of the forces which would be so impressed , if all the impinging particles impinged perpendicularly , and the whole force of each were effective .
But when x=a the first fluent becomes 1/ 4 a4 .
And the latter becomes 1/ 2 a4 .
Whence it is manifest that the progressive motion communicated to the globe of the earth , by the particles of light , is to the force which they would communicate , if the whole force of each were effective , in the proportion before assigned , of one to two .

