Received February 8 , 1770 .
XXX .
Extract of a Letter from John Winthrop , Esq ; F. R. S. Hollisian Professor of Mathematics and Natural Philosophy , at Cambridge , N. England ; to B. Franklin , LL. D. F. R. S. Dated Sept. 6 .
1769 .
IFIND that Mr. Bliss and Mr. Hornsby , in their calculations in the Philosophical Transactions , suppose the phases of the transit of Venus , to be accelerated by the equation for the aberration of light , which amounts to 55~ of time .
According to my idea of aberration , I should think the transit would be retarded by it .
I can very easily suppose that I am in an error ; and that I may more readily be led out of it , I beg leave to lay before you the several steps by which I have been led into it .
And I think it will be best to take some similar instance , rather than to consider the thing in a general abstract manner .
1 .
Let Read April 5 , J. Let the paS T rallelogram E represent a vessel sailing in the line L R , from left hand to right ; and S , a fixed station , e. g. a castle , discharging balls in the right line S M , perpendicular to the route of the vessel .
If the vessel had been at rest , a ball arriving at the middle of it , M , would have gone right across it , to N. But as it is supposed to be sailing , the ball will not go right M over from M to LER N , but will cross ON the deck obliquely , in another right line , as M O , and so will be left behind towards the stern as much as the vessel had gone forward , while the ball was crossing it ; and MN will be to NO as the velocity of the ball to the velocity of the vessel .
Thus , to the people on board , the ball would seem to move obliquely across the deck , as if it came from some point T in the line O M , produced , instead of coming from S. And a tube capable of receiving the ball , would allow the ball to pass through it without striking its sides , if it were inclined forward in the direction O M ; which it would not do in any other situation .
The angle OMN or SMT answers to the aberration ; and supposing S to be the sun , and E , the earth , this angle is 20~ ' ; and the general effect is , to make the sun , or any fixed star , to appear farther that way towards which the earth is moving .
2 .
Let us suppose another vessel V , between S and E , sailing the same way as E , in a parallel direction .
If both the vessels sailed with the same velocity , a ball from V coming to M , would go right across to N , just as if both of them had been at rest ; because the ball , while crossing the vessel E , would be carried just as far to the right hand as the points M and N are .
And a tube to receive it must be held in the direction M N. So here would be no aberration of the vessel V. 3 .
Suppose V to move the same way , but flower .
A ball from V would now be really carried forward , that is , to the right hand , though not so far as in the second supposition ; and therefore would be left behind in respect of the vessel E ; and so , would come to the side of the vessel somewhere between O and N ; but the greater its velocity towards the right , the nearer to N. So that if the velocity of V were to be continually increasing from nothing till it became equal to that of E , a tube to receive the ball must be held first in the direction O M , looking forward , and afterwards , more and more in1 clined clined till it came into the perpendicular direction M N. From hence it is natural to conclude , 4 .
That if V move the same way , but swifter , a tube to receive the ball must be reclined backward .
For the ball would now be carried to the right hand farther than in the second supposition ; and therefore would come to the other side of the vessel at some point P on QST the right hand of N , as if it proceeded from some point Q on the left hand of S. This last seems to be the case of the transit , by supposing S to be the sun , E the earth , and V the planet Venus passingbetweenthem from left to right , V and with a greater velocity than the earth ( greater , nearly as 24 : 20 ) .
And it should seem that the aberration must make Venus apM pear farther to LER the left hand , or to the East from ONP the sun , and consequently retard the transit , and make it happen later than it would otherwise do .
Thus , Sir , I have explained very particularly my apprehension of the matter ; and I make no doubt you will immediately discover where the error lies , and shall take it as a great favour if you will please to point it out to me .

