Received March 8 , 1770 .
XXIV .
Observations on the proper Method of calculating the Values of Reversions depending on Survivorships : By Richard Price , D. D. F. R. S. ALL questions relating to the values of lives and reversions , are at present of particular importance in this kingdom .
Much business is continually transacted in this way ; and any considerable errors in the method of solving such questions must in time produce very bad consequences .
The design of the following observations is , to point out a particular error , into which there is danger of falling , in finding the values of such reversions as depend on survivorships .
In doing this , I shall , in order to be as plain as possible , take the following case .
Read May 10 , 1770 .
A , aged 40 , expects to come to the possession of an estate , should he survive B , aged likewise 40 .
In these circumstances , he offers , in order to raise a present sum , to give security for 40 l. per ann .
out of the estate at his death , provided he should get into possession ; that is , provided he should survive B. What is the sum that ought now to be advanced to him in consideration of such security , reckoning compound interest at four per cent. ?
' ' M. de Moivre 's directions , in his treatise on annuities , prob .
XVII .
and XX .
lead us to seek the required sum in this case , by the following process .
Find first , the present sum A should receive for the reversion of 40 l. per ann .
for ever after his death , supposing it not dependent on his surviving B.-The present value of such a reversion , is the value of the life substracted from the perpetuity * .
The value of the life , taken from Mr. de Moivre 's tables , is 13.2 years purchase .
This subtracted from 25 , the perpetuity , leaves 11.8 , the value of the supposed estate after the life of A ; which value therefore , is in money 472 l. But ( as M. de Moivre observes ) , the lender having a chance to lose his money , a compensation ought to be made to him for the risk he runs , which is founded on the possibility that a man of the age of 40 may not survive another person of the same age .
This chance is an equal chance ; and therefore half the preceding sum , or 236 l. is the sum which should be advanced now on the expectation mentioned .
This solution carries a plausible appearance ; and most persons will , probably , be ready to pronounce it right ; nor will this be any wonder , as so great a master of these subjects as M. de Moivre , appears to have been misled by it .
Nothing more is necessary to prove it to be fallacious , than proceeding in the same way to solve the following similar question .
A , aged 40 , offers to give security for 40 l. per ann .
to be entered upon at his death , provided it * By Prob. XXVI .
p. 293 , of Mr. Simpson 's Select Exercises .
should happen before the death of B , aged likewise 40 .
What sum should now be advanced to him for such a reversion , interest being reckoned at 4 per cent. ?
' ' In solving this problem , agreeably to the method just described ; we are to find the value of 40 l. per ann .
to be entered upon certainly at the death of A , and then to multiply this value by the chance that A shall not survive B , or by 1/ 2 ; and in this way the answer comes out the same as that already given .
Now , it may be easily seen that this must be wrong .
The value of a reversion to be received when a person of a given age dies , cannot be the same whether the condition of obtaining it is , that he shall die before , or that he shall die after another person ; that is , whether it is provided that a purchaser , if he succeeds , shall get into possession sooner or later .
The reversion in the latter case must , without doubt , be of less value than in the former .
The first question here proposed resolves itself into the following general question .
` ` What is the present value of a given reversionary sum or estate , to be received after the failure of two lives , provided one in particular of them should be the longest life ?
' ' Now , the present value of an estate to be enjoyed for ever after the failure of the longest of two lives , is the value of the longest of the two lives substracted from the perpetuity .
The value of the longest of two lives is , it is well known , the value of the two joint lives substracted from the sum of the values of the two single lives .
In the present case , therefore , it is 9.82 ( the value of two joint joint lives of 40 l. * ) subtracted from twice 13.2 , ( the value of a single life of 40 ) that is , 16.58 years purchase .
And this subtracted from 25 ( the perpetuity ) gives 8.42 , which multiplied by 40 gives 336.8 l. the value of the given estate , were it certainly to be enjoyed after the extinction of the longest of two lives both 40 ; that is , whether one or other of them failed last .
But that A 's life in particular should fail last rather than B 's , is an even chance .
The true value of the reversion , therefore , is 1/ 2 the last value , or 168.4l .
In like manner .
The second question is the same with the question .
` ` What is the present value of 40 l. per ann .
for ever , to be entered upon after the extinction of two joint lives both 40 ; that is , whenever either of them shall fail , provided the first that fails should happen to be A 's life in particular ?
' ' And the answer is found by subtracting the present value of the two joint lives from the perpetuity , and multiplying the remainder by 1/ 2 , or the chance that A in particular shall die first ; and this will give the required value , 303 l. In short , it appears in both these cases , that , according to the first method of solution , we are to subtract from the perpetuity the value of one of the single lives , when , in the former case , the value of * The value of the two joint lives is here given on M. de Moivre 's hypothesis of an equal decrement of life ; and it has been calculated by a rule in Mr. Simpson 's treatise on the Doctrine of Annuities and Reversions , p. 16 .
M. de Moivre 's rules , in the second and third problems of his treatise on annuities , give the values of joint lives so much less than the truth , that they ought never to be used .
the longest of the two lives , and , in the latter case , the value of their joint continuance , ought in reality to be subtracted .
I need not say what prodigious errors may often arise from hence , and how unfit such a method of solution is for practice .
The Society in Nicholas-Lane , Lombard-street , for equitable assurances on lives and survivorships , have in constant practice such questions as those now stated ; and , had they happened to have adopted this method of solution , they could not have continued long an advantage to the public .
Mr. Simpson , in p. 322 .
of his Select Exercises , speaks on this subject in the following manner .
` ` I have been very particular on these kinds of problems ; and the more so , as there has been no method before published , that I know of , by which they can be rightly determined .
It is true , the manner of proceeding by first finding the probability of survivorship ( which method is used in my former work , and which a celebrated author has largely insisted on in three successive editions ) may be applied to good advantage when the given ages are nearly equal ; but then it is certain , that this is not a genuine way of going to work , and that the conclusions hence derived are at best but near approximations .
' ' This accurate and excellent mathomatician has here expressed himself much too favourably , of the method of solution on which I have remarked .
In both the cases I have specified , the ages are equal ; and yet in one of them the error is a good deal above a third of the true value , and in the other a fifth : And it is obvious , that in cases where three equal lives are taken , the errors will be much greater .
Mr. Simpson 's observations in this passage , are true only , when applied to a different method used by himself in the 28th and following problems of his Treatise on the Doctrine of Annuities and Reversions .
This method is exact when the lives are equal ; but it gives results that are too far from the truth , when there is any considerable inequality between the lives .
It is with reluctance I have made some of these remarks .
M. de Moivre has made very important improvements in this branch of science , and the highest respect is due to his name and authority .
This , however , only renders these remarks more necessary * .
* The strict demonstration of the solution I have given of the questions here stated , is as follows .
It is plain that the purchaser of A 's right , as stated in the first question , cannot get into possession till the year when A and B shall be both dead , nor then , unless A happens to die last .
Now , supposing the common complement of life n , the probability that A and B shall be both dead at the end of the first year , and A die last , is 1 n-1/ n ~1n 1/ n ~ 1/ 2 = 1/ 2 n 1/ 2n n 1/ 2n +n1 ~2/ 2n2 .
In like manner , the probability that they shall be both dead at the end of the second and third , &amp;c. years , and A survive , is 1/ 2 n-2/ 2n n-2/ 2n + n-2~2/ 2n2 , 1/ 2n-3/ 2n n-3/ 2n + n-3~2/ 2n2 , &amp;c. The present value , therefore , of the 1st , 2d , and 3d , &amp;c. rents of the reversionary estate , is 1/ 2r n-1/ 2nr n1/ 2nr + n1~w/ 2nr2r , 1/ 2r2 n-2/ 2nr2 n-2/ 2nr2 + n-2~2/ 2n2r2 , 1/ 2r3 n-3/ 2nr3 n-3/ 2nr3 + n-3~2/ 2n2r3 , &amp;c. r signifying 1 l. increased by its interest for a year ; and the estate being 1 l. per annum .
And the sum of these terms is the In the practice of assurances on the survivorship of one life beyond another , there is frequent occasion for making such assurances , for a term of years only .
The method of determining the value in such cases I have not seen any where described .
Perhaps , therefore , a brief account of it here may be of some use .
By reasoning in the same manner with Mr. Simpson , p. 322 , Select Exercises , it will appear , that the value of any given sum S assured , for n years on a given life A , provided in that time another given life B should survive A , is S/ a ~ b-1/ r + b-2/ r2 + b-3/ r3 , &amp;c. ( continued to n terms ) + S/ a ~ 1/ 2br + 1/ 2br2 + 1/ 2br3 , &amp;c. ( continued likewise to n terms ) r denoting 1 l. increased by its interest for one year ; and a and b , the numbers in the table of observations alive at the ages of A and B , divided by the quotient arising from dividing the sum of the differences in the table from these value required .
But 1/ 2r + 1/ 2r2 + 1/ 2r3 , &amp;c. is half the perpetuity ; and n-1/ 2nr + n-1/ 2nr n-1~2/ 2n2r + n-2/ 2nr2 + n-2/ 2nr2 n-2~2/ 2n2r2 + n-3/ 2nr3 + n-3/ 2nr3 n-3~/ 2n2r3 , &amp;c. is half the value of the joint lives subtracted from half the sum of the values of the two single lives ; that is , half the value of the longest of the two lives by problem IV .
of M. de Moivre 's Treatise on Life Annuities .
A similar demonstration may be easily applied to the solution of the other question .
The best rules for finding , in all cases , the values of reversions depending on survivorships , are Mr. Simpson 's , in his Select Exercises , p. 297 , &amp;c. ages respectively for n years , by n. Now b-1/ b r+ b-2/ br2 , &amp;c. ( continued to n terms ) is the value of an annuity on the given life B for n years .
And 1/ 2br + 1/ 2br2 , &amp;c. ( continued to n terms ) is the value of an annuity certain for n years , divided by 2b .
The general rule , therefore , is this .
Find ( by problem 23 .
in M. de Moivre 's Treatise on Annuities , fourth edition ) the value of an annuity on the life of B for n years .
To this value add the quotient arising from dividing by 2b , the value of an annuity certain for n years , taken out of M. de Moivre 's tables in the treatise just mentioned , or out of table III .
in Mr. Simpson 's Select Exercises : and the sum multiplied by S/ a will be the required value .
' ' EXAMPLE .
Let the rate of interest be 3 per cent. or r= 1.03 .
The table of observations , Mr. Simpson 's in his Select Exercises , p. 254 .
Let the age of A be seven years .
B , 30 .
n= 14 and S= 100 l. The sum of the decrements in the table for fourteen years from seven years of age , is 73 ; which divided by 14 is 5.2 .
The number alive at seven is 430 ; and this , divided by 5.2 , gives 82.6 for the value of a. In like manner the value of b may be found to be 41.7 .
The value of an annuity for 14 years on a life of 30 , is 9.5 .
The value of an annuity certain for 14 years is 11.296 , which divided by 2b or 83.4 , gives 0.13 ; and this added to 9.5 , and the sum multiplied by 100/ 82.6 gives 11.66 , or 11 l. 13 s. for the value in present payment of 100 l. assured to a person 30 years of age , and payable to him at the death of a child seven years of age , provided that should happen before his own death in 14 years .
It deserves to be particularly remarked , that in this method likewise may be determined , what sums ought to be paid on any survivorship , within a given term of years , of one life beyond another , in consideration of any given sums now advanced .
The following example of this is a case which has offered itself in practice , and which I have had occasion particularly to consider .
A person aged 30 , having in expectation an estate which is to come to him , provided he survives a minor aged seven before he comes of age , wants in these circumstances to raise 1000 l. What reversion , depending on such a survivorship , is a proper equivalent for this sum now advanced , interest being reckoned at 3 per cent. and the probabilities of life being supposed the same with those in the London table of observations ?
' ' Answer .
It appears from what has been just determined , that , for 11l .
13s .
now advanced , the proper equivalent in these circumstances is 100 l. to be paid , in case the supposed survivorship should take place .
By the rule of proportion , therefore , it will appear , that for 1000l .
the proper equivalent is 8576l .

