XXIV .
Directions for making a Machine for finding the Roots of Equations universally , with the Manner of using it : By the Rev. Mr. Rowning , to John Bevis , M. D. F. R. S. SIR , PERUSING a discourse in the memoirs of the Royal Academy at Petersburgh , Tome vii .
page 211 , by the learned John Andrew de Segner , containing an universal method of discovering the roots of equations , which you was so kind as to recommend to my consideration ; I found , that the author 's method , as you observed to me , consisted in finding several ordinates of a parabolic curve , such , that its abscissas being taken equal to any assumed values of the unknown quantity in the equation , the ordinates corresponding to those abscissas , should be equal to the values of all the terms in the equation ( when brought to one side ) that is , in other words , in finding several ordinates of a parabolic curve defined by the equation proposed : in which case , as is well known , if a curve be drawn through the extremities of the said ordinates , the points upon the axis , where the curve shall cut it , will necessarily give the several values of the real roots Read May 3 , S MNS Fig.1 .
R DxP ~-x ~PD kql~ C lrdqk CsB r~ B A As ZOQTZZQO SMR HMS X Fig.4 F z 10 Tez a~x2 r7 h 60 tB U 19 4 17 AgS G 21 g n s g E S Fig.2 .
R D ~ C kb B la Fig.3 .
A OTZ K SR Z M f 12 ~ 7l 22 i 60 Q 15 Y 20 ~ 5 348 18 C I R ~ 23 O 16 dm Die w ~.~ .
Vol. LX.Tab .
VIII .
p.241 .
k roots of the equation ; and the several points , where the curve shall approach the base , but shall return without reaching it , will show the impossible ones .
This is a method I myself fell into ten or twelve years ago , and have constantly used for finding the roots of such equations as I have had occasion to consider .
But his method is preferable to mine in one respect , viz. that whereas I always compute the value of the ordinates in numbers , he finds them by drawing certain right lines ; however , when there are both possible and impossible roots in an equation , as generally there are , these methods are both of them extremely embarrassing : the learned author therefore wishes , that some method might be thought of , whereby such curves , as we are now speaking of , might in all cases be described by local motion ; but this , he tells us , he looked upon as so very difficult a task , that he never attempted it .
Quod ad descriptionem attinet , says he , motum excogitare , quo tales accurate designari possunt omnes [ hujusmodi curvae ] admodum difficile judico , quare id neque tentavi .
This hint , however , convinced me , that the thing was possible ; I therefore determined to endeavour it .
I soon found , that if rulers were properly centered , and so combined together , that they should always continue representatives of the several right lines , by which he discovers the abovementioned ordinates , upon moving the first , a point or pencil , so fixed as to be carried along perpetually by the intersection of the first and last rulers , would describe the required curve , let the number of dimensions in the equation be what it will ; only the greater that number , the greater must be the number of the rulers made use of .
And this appeared to me so obvious , that I wondered , neither the learned author , who seems to have the thing much at heart , nor any body else since the publication thereof , saw it .
Let the equation to be resolved , be a+bx+cxx +dxxx , &amp;c. =~ .
Upon the line ZZ , as a base , in either the first or second figure , draw the lines SS and RR perpendicular thereto , at any distance taken at pleasure from each other .
Then upon the line SS in either figure , TAB. VIII .
set off the lines OA , AB , BC , CD , &amp;c. proportionable to the coefficients a , b , c , d , &amp;c. in the equation , remembering to take each line upwards from the extremity of the last , when the coefficient , it is to represent , is affirmative ; but downwards from the said extremity , when the coefficient is negative .
Then through the extremity of the last of the lines OA , AB , BC , &amp;c. which in our case is D , draw the line Dc , parallel to the base ZZ , and through c , where Dc intersects RR , draw cC ; and parallel to SS , and at any distance from it taken at pleasure , draw MM : then parallel to Dc , and where Cc intersects MM , draw the line kb ; through b , where this last line intersects RR , draw bB ; parallel also to Dc , and where bB intersects MM , draw la ; and through a , where la intersects RR , draw aA .
This done , let SS , RR and Cc , be supposed to represent three rulers with grooves or notches cut quite through them , of such form as is represented Fig. 3 .
and let those rulers be screwed down in their respective places SS , RR , and Cc , to a plane or frame of sufficient size .
Then let other rulers of like form , as Bb , Aa , &amp;c. be moveable upon the centers B , A , &amp;c. and let those centers themselves be moveable upwards and downwards in the groove or notch in the ruler SS , and in such manner , that the centers B and A may be placed upon one another , or upon C , if occasion requires , and let those centers be screwed down in their proper places , viz. the center A at A , the center B at B , &amp;c. Then let kb and la represent other moveable rulers , such as the former , and so confined that they shall always continue parallel to themselves and to the line Dc ; and let MM represent another ruler of like form .
And let the rulers kb and MM be connected with the fixed ruler Cc by a sliding pin passing through the intersection of their notches at q~ and let the rulers kb , Bb , la and Aa be connected with one another and with MM and RR , by like pins passing through their notches at b , r , a , and s ; and let the last of these pins s , have the point of a pencil fixed therein ; then , I say , that if the ruler MM be moved backwards or forwards , from or towards SS , and always held parallel thereto ( or be so confined as to be capable of moving in no other manner ) the pencil s shall describe the required curve .
And the distances from the point O , at which that pencil shall cross the base ZZ , on the right hand side of SS , shall denote the affirmative roots of the equation ; and the distances from the same point O , where it shall cross the said base on the left hand side of SS , shall express the negative ones ; and the places , where it shall approach the said base , but shall return without reaching it , shall indicate the impossible ones ; the said distances being always to be estimated on a scale on which the assumed line Dc is unity .
Demonst .
Since the lines OA , AB , BC , &amp;c. are to be taken proportional to the coefficients a , b , c , &amp;c. let us suppose the first of them , viz. OA , to be taken equal to the first coefficient a , or to any part of it taken at pleasure ; suppose for instance , to the nth part , that is , to a/ n ; then , to preserve the above-mentioned proportionality , the next viz. AB will be equal to b/ n , BC will be equal to c/ n , and CD to d/ n , &amp;c. Call OQ or its equal DP , x ; then Dc , as abovementioned , being taken equal to unity , Pc will be equal to 1-x , and DC being equal to d/ n , and the triangles DCc and Pqc being similar , we have this proportion , viz. 1 : 1-x : : d/ n:d-dx/ n=Pq or Dk ; but kB is equal BC+CD-Dk , that is , to c/ n + d/ n d-dx/ n , that is , to c+dx/ n ; and by similar triangles , as kb : qb : : kB : qr , that is , in symbols , as 1 : 1-x : : c+dx/ n ; c+dx-cx-dxx/ n=qr or kl : but Al is equal to AD-Dk-kl , that is , in symbols , to b/ n+c/ n+d/ n d-dx/ n c+dx-cx-dxx/ n , that is , to b+cx+dxx/ n ; and by similar triangles , la : ra : : Al : rs ; in symbols 1 : 1-x : : b+cx+dxx/ n : b+cx+dxx-bx-cxx-dxxx/ n =rs ; Qs therefore , which by the figure is equal to QP-Pq-qr-rs , is equal to a+b+c+d-d-dx/ n c+dx-cx-dxx/ n b+cx+dxx-bx-cxx-dxxx/ n , that is , to a+bx+cxx+dxxx/ n ; consequently , when Qs is nothing , that is , when the curve described by s , cuts the base , a+bx+cxx+dx3/ n will be equal to nothing , and therefore equal also to a+bx+cxx+dxxx ; this last being also , from the equation proposed , equal to nothing ; Qs therefore in those circumstances will be equal to a+bx+cxx+dxxx ; and consequently whatever value of x or OQ renders a+bx +cxx=dxxx equal to nothing , will render Qs equal to nothing : but every value of x that renders a+bx +cxx+dxxx equal to nothing , is a root of the proposed equation a+bx+cxx+dxxx=0 ; consequently the curve will cross the base ZZ at every real root of that equation , whether negative or affirmative , and therefore , as every one acquainted with curve lines knows , will attempt to do so , but not quite reach it , at every impossible one .
Q , E. D. This demonstration is adapted only to an equation of three dimensions ; but it is easy to see , it may be extended to any other .
Note .
To obtain the negative roots , the rulers must be extended to the left of the line SS , as represented fig. 2 .
where they are denoted by the same letters as in the other figure ; viz. the ruler Cc must be extended from c to q ; the ruler Bb from b to r , and aA from a to s , and onwards towards the left , the two last turning upon the centers A , B , in the fixed line SS .
It is not necessary , that the curve should be described with accuracy , or even that it should fall upon the plane or frame , except where it crosses or attempts to cross the base ; and therefore there will arise no inconveniency in this respect from taking the lines OA , AB , &amp;c. large .
But the immovable rulers OD and Tc must be fixed so near together , that , their distance Dc or OT , being reckoned unity , the base OT extended to the extremity of the plane to the right , may take in all the affirmative roots : and when extended to the left , may take in all the negative ones .
There is one thing more , very well worth observing , viz. that if you have an equation of this sort xxx-5xx+1200x+9000=0 ( where you may observe , that the coefficients unity , 5,1200 and 9000 are so very different from each other , that it would be difficult to set them off in due proportion upon the line OD ) you may reduce them into a more manageable form , by the following contrivance : instead of each x in the equation put 10x , 20x or 100x , suppose 20x ; then instead of xxx you will have 8000xxx , instead of -5xx you will have -2000xx , &amp;c. and the whole equation will stand thus , 8000xxx-2000xxx+24000x+9000=0 ; then divide each term by 100 , and you bring it to 8xxx-2xx+24x+9=0 , a much more tractable equation than the other : but then it must be remembered , that as you made x 20 times less than it was , the roots when discovered will be so many times less than the true ones , and therefore each must be multiplied by that number 20 .
The following observations relative to the application of the abovementioned rulers may be useful : 1 .
The roots of equation are of three sorts , affirmative , negative , and impossible ; which last are sometimes called imaginary .
2 .
Every equation contains as many roots as it has dimensions .
3 .
The impossible roots go by pairs .
Thus , if an equation has an impossible root of this form a+b ~-1 , it has another impossible one of this , viz. a-b~-1 , which may be called its fellow : from hence it follows , that every equation , if it has any impossible roots , has either two , four , or six , &amp;c. that is , an even number of them : and every time the curve described by the rulers abovementioned approaches the base , and leaves it again without crossing it , it implies one impossible root and its fellow ; so that if it approaches the base in this manner three times , it implies , that the equation has six impossible roots .
And this is all the rulers can do with regard to this sort of roots ; they cannot show what those are , but only how many there are .
I shall direct to a method of finding what they are in the 8th article below .
Inasmuch then , as the impossible roots go by pairs , and the number of roots in any equation is equal to the number of its dimensions , it follows , 4 .
That every equation of an odd number of dimensions , must contain at least one real root .
5 .
Every equation whose first and last terms ( when brought to one side ) have contrary signs , will have at least also one real root : and therefore , when this is the case , and the number of its dimensions is also even , it must have two real roots at least : because the number of dimensions being even , and the number of impossible roots always even , the number of real ones must be even also .
6 .
If any equation be divided by the unknown quantity minus one of its roots , it will be reduced one dimension lower .
And as every equation contains as many roots as it has dimensions , it follows , 7 .
That if you deduct the number of impossible roots from the whole number of its roots , that is , from the number of its dimensions , the remainder will give the number of its real roots .
8 .
When you have found by the rulers , what those real roots are , put the unknown quantity ( x ) equal to each of them , transpose the terms in each equation to one side , multiply all the equations together , and divide the equation proposed by their product ; then make the quotient equal to nothing , and you have an equation containing all your impossible roots , without any real ones intermixed .
Then those impossible roots may be found by the method for that purpose laid down by Mons. de Bougainville in his Traite du Calcul integral , in the fifth and sixth chapters of his introduction ; and which is the best method I know of .
His method consists in parting the equation into two others , of the same number of dimensions indeed , but such as shall involve no other than real roots ; which real roots you may then find by these rulers , or otherwise ; and from thence you will obtain all the impossible roots of your equation .
But because few English mathematicians , I suspect , are acquainted with this method , it may be useful to give the substance of it here in our own language .
The author previously demonstrates the two following proportions .
PROP .
I. That when a quantity is equal to nothing , and is composed of many terms , some of which are real , and the other are terms multiplied by ~-1 , the sum of the real ones is equal to nothing ; and the sum of those that are multiplied by ~-1 is also equal to nothing .
This is the 69th article of his introduction .
PROP .
II .
That when an equation involves imaginary roots only , the unknown quantity may always be supposed equal to m+n~-1 ; m and n being real quantities .
This is the 80th article of his introduction .
Then to find the roots of such an equation as we are speaking of , for every unknown quantity ( x suppose ) in the equation , substitute m+n~-1 , and you will obtain a new equation involving real terms , and terms multiplied by ~-1 ; the former of which by Prop. I. are always equal to nothing , and so are the latter : make them so therefore , and you have two equations , from which the two assumed quantities m and n may be discovered ; and consequently , since the value of x is by the second proposition equal to m+n~-1 , it is discovered also .
What I mean in the former part of this article may be explained by the following instance ; suppose the real roots discovered by the rulers abovementioned to be a , b , -c , &amp;c. then put x=a , x=b , x=-c , &amp;c. transpose the terms to one side , and you have x-a =0 , x-b=0 , x+c=0 , &amp;c. multiply all these last equations together , divide the equation proposed by their product , and proceed as abovementioned .
9 .
The greatest negative coefficient of any equation ( considered as affirmative ) and increased by unity always exceeds the greatest affirmative root of the equation .
And therefore , 10 .
If for the unknown quantity ( x ) in the equation , you put that coefficient taken affirmatively and increased by unity minus x , all the roots of the equation will be rendered affirmative .
If you do this , you need only use such rulers , as are described in the first figure , whose centers are at their extremities , and so one sort of rulers will be sufficient for all cases .
For you may observe , those in the second figure are different from the other , as to their centers .
11 .
If , when you have made all the roots of your equation affirmative , you would avoid removing the ruler MM to the right hand side of RR , which might be attended with inconveniency ; that is , if you would have all the roots of your equation fall between O and T , that is , between nothing and unity , instead of the unknown quantity x in your last equation , put x multiplied by the greatest negative coefficient therein considered as affirmative and increased by unity ; for instance , if the greatest negative coefficient in the equation be minus 9 , put 10x ~nstead of every x in the equation , and you will have a new equation , all whose roots shall fall upon the line OT unproduced ; for then they will be less than unity , that is , than DC or OT : but when the roots are thus found , each of them must be multiplied by that coefficient increased by unity , that is , in the above instance , by 10 ; because putting 10x for x , is making every root ten times smaller than it is .
These propositions are all taken from the writings of the algebraists , or however are such as easily follow from them , and therefore need not be demonstrated here .
The following is a description of a machine for regulating the motion of the abovementioned rulers , which I caused to be made by an excellent workman in this town , and which I desire the society to accept of , to be kept as a specimen , for the inspection of any gentleman , who may chuse to have such made .
It extends only to equations of two dimensions ; but it is easy to see from it , how it may be carried to others of any number .
A draft of it is exhibited in fig. 4 .
of the abovementioned table : where ABCD represents a frame of iron or steel , consisting of four strait bars joined together at their extremities , and forming a rectangular parallelogram about 12 inches long and 8 broad ; into which at its four corners are screwed four perpendicular columns OF , GH , IK and LM , whose lower ends serve it as feet to stand on .
And on one of the aforesaid bars , viz. on A , is a moveable nut or slider , which may be screwed to it at any point thereof ; it appears in the figure at N ; and on this nut , as a center , one end of the bar NO turns , whose other end is screwed down to the cross bar PQ at R , which cross bar is screwed down to the frame at P and Q , and may be set nearer or further from the end A at pleasure : this bar represents the line RR in fig. 1 .
Then on the perpendicular pillars OF , GH , IK and LM , are fixed three bars ST , UX and YZ ; on the first of these ST , is a sliding nut c , which carries one extremity of the bar ab turning upon it as a center ; on the second and third , viz. UX and YZ , are also two nuts e and f , which may be screwed on any part of them , and on which the silken cord of is fastned .
The two first of those bars , viz. ST and UX together with the bar A , or rather lines such as the pricked line upon the upper one drawn upon them from pillar to pillar , represent the line SS in fig. 1 .
and the silken cord extended from the nut e to f and fixed to them , represents the base line ZZ in that figure .
Then besides these there is another rectangular figure ghik , about twice the length of the former , whose sides , gk and hi slide in grooves or supporters screwed to the frame ABCD , at proper places ( three of which may be seen at l , m , and n ) , and have triangular teeth on their under sides from g to d , and from h to o , which run in similar teeth in two wheels s and t , of equal diameters , fixed on an axis pqr , and their axis pr is supported by proper cocks , one of which appears at u , the other not seen in this view of the figure .
These wheels being both fixed to the same axis , and the triangular teeth in the bars fitting those in the wheels exactly , occasion the bars gk and hi to move with equal paces , when the machine is put in motion ; by which means the bars wx and yz , which slide in two pieces 1 and 2 screwed to the said bars gk and hi , necessarily move parallel to themselves : these bars represent MM in fig. 1 .
In the lower of these bars wx is fixed a perpendicular pin , at 3 , whose upper end passes through the groove of the bar 4 , 5 , and its lower end through that of the bar N O , and in the upper of these bars y z , is fixed a perpendicular pin 6 , 7 , the upper end of which may be taken out , and a pencil put in its place ; this pin represents the point s , and the former pin 3 , the point r , in fig. 1 .
There is also a perpendicular pin screwed to the bar 4 , 5 , at 8 , which must be fixed upon that bar directly over the groove in the bar PQ This pin denotes the point a in fig. 1 .
There are also two bars 9 , 10 , and 11 , 12 , with triangular teeth , which bars slide in supporters screwed to the frame at proper places ( which appear at 13 , 14 , 15 , and 16 ) , and ride upon the wheels 17 and 18 , with similar teeth , and both fixed on the axis 19 , 20 .
These wheels prevent the said bars from moving with unequal paces , and therefore cause the bar 4 , 5 , which is screwed down to them at each end of it , to move parallel to itself ; this bar represents la in fig. 1 .
Then the aforesaid nuts or sliders e , f , c , N , and R , being screwed down at proper places according to the coefficients of the equation ( as shall be directed more particularly in the next article ) , and the bar gh being pushed forwards or backwards by the hand , will put the whole in motion ; and the pin 6 , 7 , will describe a curve , which shall be the locus of the equation , and the distances where it shall pass under the silken cord e f , reckoning from the pricked line upon the bar U X , shall denote its real roots ; and as many times as that pin shall approach the said cord , and then recede from it without passing under it , twice so many will be the number of impossible roots in that equation .
N. B. There are some small pieces screwed on to the perpendicular pillars E F , G H , IK and L M , three of which appear at 21 , 22 , and 23 ; these serve only to prevent the bars which slide under them from rising up .
To rectify the machine for a proposed equation .
Screw the nuts e and f , which carry the silken cord at any equal distances from the pillars OF and L M. Then slide the nut c , which carries the extremity of the bar a b , till it is farther from the pillar OF than the place you have fixed the nut e at , by a number of divisions upon any scale of equal parts , equal to the known term of the equation , if that term be affirmative ; but so much nearer to it , if that term~be negative ; and fix it there .
Then slide the nut N that carries the bar N O , till it is farther from or nearer to the pillar E F , than the last nut c is , by a number of divisions taken from the same seal , equal to the second coefficient of the equation ( I mean that , where the unknown quantity is of one dimension ) ; farther from it , if that coefficient is affirmative ; but nearer , if it is negative : and fix it there .
Then , lastly , slide the nut R , which fixes the other end of the bar N O , till it is farther from a line drawn from the pillar OF to L M , that is , farther from the side D of the frame than the last nut N is from the same , as many divisions , as the coefficient of that term of the equation , where the unknown quantity is of two dimensions , indicates ; farther , there , if that coefficient is affirmative , otherwise nearer to it : for which purpose the end A of the frame .
and the bars S T , U X , YZ and the cross bar PQ should all be graduated , beginning at the front of the frame D. They are graduated on the machine itself in a manner somewhat different , but it is found not so convenient for use .
Then the several distances upon the cord e f , where the pencil or pin 6 , 7 , shall cross it , being reckoned from the pricked line upon the upper bar U X , and measured upon a scale , on which the distance of the cross bar PQ from a line drawn along the middle of the end A , from OF to G H , is unity ( the reason of which appears from the foregoing demonstration , where Dc or OT in fig. 1 .
and which answers to the distance of this line PQ from the bar A , was put equal to unity ) shall give the required roots .
And if the cord of is removed , and a piece of pasteboard put over the machine , on the two upper bars UX and Y Z , having a strait line drawn on its under side , representing the cord e f , and a pencil with its point upwards be put in the place of the pin 7 , that pencil will describe on the under side of the pasteboard a curve , which with the said right line shall construct the equation proposed : and the larger the coefficients of the equation are ( which coefficients may be made as large as you please without altering the roots , by multiplying them by any number at pleasure ) the larger will be the angles at which the curve and the strait line shall cut each other ; which in the construction of equations is a very desireable circumstance .
And as it appears from the foregoing demonstration , that this machine by the application of more bars , may be extended to equations of all dimensions , it may not , I think , be improperly called an Universal constructor of Equations .
I am SIR , With great respect , your most humble and most obedient servant , London , Essex-street , March 24 , 1768 .
J. Rowning .

