Received March 8 , 1770 .
XIX .
Experiments and Observations on Charcoal : By Joseph Priestley , LL. D. F. R. S. AMONG the original experiments , published in the History of Electricity , was an account of the conducting power of charcoal .
This substance had been considered by electricians , in no other light than that of mere perfectly baked wood , which is known to be no conductor of electricity .
I have even heard of attempts being made to excite it ; and though those attempts were ineffectual , the failure of success was attributed to other causes than that of charcoal being no electric substance ; so fixed was the persuasion , that water and metals were the only conducting substances in nature .
The consideration of the chemical properties of charcoal , which are , in many respects , remarkably different from those of the wood from which it is made , might have led them to suspect , that since , after its being reduced to a coal , it was become quite another thing from what it was before , it might possibly differ from wood in Ee2 this Read April 5 , this property ; but this consideration had not been sufficiently attended to .
In the account of my former experiments on charcoal , I observed , that there were very great differences in the conducting power of charcoal , and particularly of wood charcoal , though I could not determine on what circumstances in the preparation , &amp;c. those differences depended .
I thererefore expressed a wish , that some person , who had conveniences for making chemical experiments , would prosecute the inquiry , as one that promised , not only to ascertain the cause of the conducting power of charcoal , but perhaps of conducting power universally .
Not hearing that any chemist or electrician has attended to this business , I have , at length , resumed the subject , though not with every advantage that I could have wished .
I have , in a great measure , however , succeeded in the principal object of my inquiry ; and I shall now lay before this Society , the result of my experiments and observations .
I shall begin with correcting a mistake I lay under at the time that I made the former experiments .
Having been informed by persons , who attend the making of pit charcoal , that it was considerably increased in bulk after the process ; I imagined that all other substances received an increase of bulk , when they were reduced to a coal ; but the first experiments that I made , convinced me of my mistake .
All vegetable substances are considerably contracted in all their dimensions , by the process of coaling , and the more perfect this process is , that is , as will be explained hereafter , the greater heat is applied in the course of it , the greater is the diminution .
I have even reduced pieces of wood to little more than one fourth of their original length and breadth , in a common fire , by the use of a pair of hand bellows only .
And this was the case equally with wood of the firmest texture , as ebony ; that of a middle texture , as oak ; and that of the loosest , as fir , &amp;c. As moisture , and , I believe , small degrees of heat or cold , affects wood much more sensibly across the fibres than along them , it might have been supposed , that when wood was reduced to a coal , by the application of a greater degree of heat , the same rule would have been observed ; but I found very little difference in this respect .
To ascertain this circumstance , I took , from the same board , two pieces , each 2 1/ 2 inches in length .
In one of them , the fibres were divided , in the other they were not ; and after coaling them thoroughly together , in the same crucible , I found that the former measured 2.05 inches , and the latter 2.15 .
Their conducting power could not be distinguished .
A more particular account of the degree , in which wood is shortened in coaling , will be seen afterwards , when the variations in this respect are compared with the variations in the power of conducting electricity .
To my great surprise , I found animal substances not reduced in their dimensions by the process of coaling .
This , at least , was the case with some pieces of ivory , several inches in length , and a piece of bone .
They bore a very intense heat for many hours , and came out of the crucible considerably diminished in weight , but hardly so much as distorted storted in their shape , as is remarkably the case with wood , and , I believe , all vegetable substances .
In examining mineral substances , I found that my information , mentioned above , was just .
Coals are very much enlarged in their dimensions by charring ; but the experiment must be made with great care , to judge of this circumstance ; for , unless the operation be very slow , the coal will retain nothing of its former shape , having been made in some measure fluid by the heat .
The inside of all pieces of pit charcoal is full of cavitities , and there is generally a very large one in the center of every piece ; so that , the dilatation is nothing like the extension of fibres ; but is produced by the elasticity of the new formed vapour , in forcing its way out , while the substance is soft .
With respect to the main object of my inquiry , I presently satisfied myself , that the conducting power of charcoal depends upon no other circumstance than the degree of heat , that is applied in the process of making it .
I had not suspected this ; but numberless experiments clearly proved it .
Taking an iron pot filled with sand , and putting into it pieces of wood , cut out of the same plank , marking them , and carefully noting their places in the pot , I always found that those pieces came out the best conductors , that had been exposed to the greatest heat .
The result was the same when I made coals of bits of wood , placed one above another , in a gun barrel , one end of which was made red hot , and the rest gradually cooler and cooler .
Taking pieces of charcoal that conducted very imperfectly , or not at all , I never failed to give them the strongest conducting power , by repeating the process of coaling , either in a crucible , or a gun barrel , covered with sand , and kept in an intense heat .
I could not find that the mere continuance of the same degree of heat had any effect with respect to the conducting power of charcoal .
Macquer and other chemists define charcoal to be wood burned , without being suffered to flame ; but , with respect to its conducting power , and , I make no doubt , with respect to all other essential properties also , it makes no difference whether it flame or not .
I have coaled pieces of wood , both in gun barrels , and in crucibles , slightly covered with sand , and have let the inflammable vapour that exhaled from them take fire , at various distances from the substances ; and I have also put pieces of wood in an open fire , and urged the heat applied to them , with a pair of bellows ; and in all these cases have found the charcoal equally good .
In the last method , indeed , very little of the substance is preserved ; but the little that doth remain , after it has ceased to flame , whether it be quenched immediately , or not , conducts as well as any charcoal whatever .
But one can hardly be sure that the same degree of heat is given to every part of a piece of wood , except it be exposed to it for some time ; and in an open fire , urged with a pair of bellows , the wood wastes as fast as it is red hot , before the center of it is much affected with the heat .
When once any degree of conducting power is given to a piece of charcoal , ~ never found that it was afterwards lessened .
A partial consuming of it in an open fire doth not affect the remainder , as I observed in the account of my former experiments .
I had imagined , that the solidity of substances converted into charcoal would have had a very considerable effect on their conducting power afterwards ; but the conjecture was not confirmed by experiment .
Coals made of the lightest woods conducted , as far as I could perceive , as well as those that were made from the most solid , if they had been exposed to the same degree of heat in the process .
Fine shavings of fir , the thin coats of an onion , the lightest sort , and every other vegetable substance that ~ tried , conducted equally with coals made of oak or ebony .
I had imagined , also , that the moment a piece of wood was become black with heat , it was , to all intents and purposes , a real charcoal , and , along with other properties of charcoal , would conduct electricity , more or less : but I found , by coaling several pieces very slowly , that they would not conduct in the least degree , not only when they were made superficially black , but likewise when they were black quite through , and had remained a long time in the heat that made them so ; so that no eye could distinguish them from the most perfect charcoal .
I have sometimes found charcoal in such a state , that it would assist the passage of an explosion along its surface , when it would not conduct a shock any other way .
In order to satisfy myself in what proportions the diminution of weight , the decrease of bulk , and the conducting power of wood and charcoal , corresponded to one another .
I took several pieces from the same plank , and having carefully weighed and measured them , converted them into coals very slowly , and by a gradual increase of heat , on an iron plate , held on the fire , turning them constantly , to prevent their catching fire .
The following were the results .
A piece of very old dry oak , weighing 12 grains , and which conducted in the imperfect manner that wood generally does , from the moisture it contains , was , after the loss of about one grain , no conductor at all ; and it continued the same as baked wood , till it was reduced to 4 grains , when it was black quite through ; and even then , no part of it conducted , except one corner , where it had catched fire .
Another piece I carefully weighed and measured several times , in the course of the process .
At first it weighed 12 grains , when its dimensions were 2 inches and.45 .
At 8 grains they were 2 and.4 ; at 5.5 gr. 1.91 and.4 ; at 3.5 gr. 1.8 and.35 .
It was now become an imperfect conductor .
I then urged it with a strong heat , in a crucible , and taking it out , it weighed 1.75 gr. and measured 1.6 , and .3 .
It was now a perfect conductor ; and though I afterwards kept it in a very intense heat several hours , by which it was reduced to 1 gr. and measured 1.6 , and.3 , its conducting power was not sensibly increased ; but it was become very brittle or friable .
It appears from these experiments , that these pieces of wood were reduced to about 1/ 4 of their weight before they would conduct at all ; though , at the same time , they were diminished in length ( i. e. along the fibres ) only 1/ 10 .
The breadth and thickness could not be measured with sufficient accuracy in these small pieces .
To make them perfect conductors , they were reduced to about 1/ 10 in weight , and 1/ 2 in length .
A variety of circumstances led me to conclude that the cause of blackness , and of the conducting power in charcoal , is the oil of the plant , made empyreumatic , and burnt to a certain degree .
I therefore conclude that these properties are some way connected with that part of the inflammable principle , otherwise called phlogiston , that is fixed and united to the earth of the plant , when the union is strengthened by an intense heat .
The sand , with which I covered the substances that I converted into coals , and also the pipe clay which I sometimes put over them , contracted a blackness like charcoal , and would often conduct pretty well .
Sometimes they would conduct a shock .
This must have been owing to the oil they received from the substances out of which it was expelled by the heat .
In the experiment of the gun barrel fitted with pieces of wood , mentioned above , the uppermost pieces were not in the least burnt .
They could hardly have been hot ; yet , having contracted a superficial blackness , from the vapour of the oil expelled from the piece below them , they would even conduct a shock , though not in the most perfect manner .
Sometimes those substances that had no phlogiston themselves , but received it in consequence of being placed in the neighbourhood of other bodies out of which it was expelled , would not conduct immediately ; but would be made to do so by being exposed to a greater heat , which more thoroughly burnt the oil with which their pores were filled .
I put a piece of common pipe into a crucible , in which I was burning some turpentine ( which will be mentioned below ) ; and it came out black quite through , like a pipe in which tobacco has been frequently smoaked .
In this state it would not conduct at all ; but , putting it into a crucible , covered with sand , I treated it in the same manner as I would have done a piece of wood , in order to coal it , and it came out a very good conductor .
Had it been burned in the open fire , the phlogiston would have escaped , and the pipe would have been left white as at first .
Being convinced that the conducting power of charcoal depended upon the oil , or rather the phlogiston contained in the oil , and on the degree of heat with which it was burned , I took several methods to give vegetable substances more of this principle ; or at least endeavoured to make them retain more of it than they usually do , in the process of coaling .
But I had no apparent success in those experiments .
I began with plunging a piece of old dry oak in oil ; and then , pumping the air out of it , let it stand in vacuo a day and night , in which time it seemed to discharge a great quantity of air ; after which , I let into the receiver the air , and thereby forced the oil into its pores .
But the coal from this wood was not sensibly better than others .
The application of heat may perhaps expel the phlogiston in such a manner , that the residuum , being fully saturated , can retain no more than a certain proportion .
I made coals of other pieces of wood , when they were covered with cement ; and I also coaled several pieces together , that they might receive phlogiston from one another ; but , in both cases , without any sensible improvement in the quality of the coal .
In order to prevent the escape of the phlogiston belonging to the substance to be reduced to a coal , I put some pieces of wood into a gun barrel , and corked it as close as I could , at the same time covering the cork with cement .
In this case the rarefaction of the exhaling vapour never failed to drive the cork out ; but it must have been after a considerable resistance to its escape .
However , I could not perceive any peculiar excellence in the charcoal made in this manner .
I do not , indeed , know any method in which differences in substances that conduct so well as these can be accurately tried , at least none that can be applied in this case .
The charcoal I can make in a common fire , by the use of a pair of hand bellows , I cannot distinguish , with respect to its conducting power , from the most perfect metals , gold and silver ; either by the length of the electric spark , the colour of it , or the sound of the explosion .
I make no doubt but that wood , in the process of coaling , may easily have a degree of conducting power communicated to it , exceeding that of lead , iron , or the other more imperfect metals .
We may , perhaps , be guided in our conjectures on this subject , by considering the degree of heat that is necessary , either to unite the phlogiston to its base , or to separate them , both in the case of wood , and the different metals .
Lead is very easily calcined , and it is also known to conduct electricity very imperfectly .
Iron soon turns to rust ; and its conducting power I found to be very small , in comparison with that of copper , or the more perfect metals .
If , therefore , in making charcoal , a degree of heat be applied greater than is necessary to calcine or revivify a metal , we may perhaps conclude , that the conducting power of the charcoal will be superior to that of the metal .
As it may be possible to give charcoal , when cut off from any communication with the external air , a greater degree of heat than silver or gold would bear , without being dissipated in vapour ; it may even be possible to make charcoal that shall conduct electricity better than those most perfect metals .
Had there been any phlogiston in water , I should have concluded , that there had been no conducting power in nature , but in consequence of some union of this principle with some base .
In this , metals and charcoal exactly agree .
While they have the phlogiston , they conduct ; when deprived of it , they will not conduct .
I believe , however , that all vegetable , or animal substances , that contain phlogiston may be reduced to a coal ; and if the heat applied in the process be sufficient , that coal will conduct electricity .
Flesh , glue , bones , and other parts of an animal body , make good conducting charcoal .
The only approach , or seeming approach , I ever made towards retaining more phlogiston than usual , in wood reduced to a coal , was by the slowness of the process .
For I always found that , if the heat was applied very gradually , less volatile phlogiston , i. e. less inflammable air , was expelled ; and therefore I suppose that more of it was fixed .
I could never afterwards , by equal degrees of heat , make this coal to weigh as little as another that was first coaled by a sudden heat .
I took two pieces of dry oak , the contiguous parts of the same stick , each weighing exactly 14 grains .
One of these I heated suddenly .
It yielded 8 ounce measures of inflammable air , and then weighed 2 grains .
The other I heated slowly , but as vehemently , at the last , as the other .
It yielded only 11/ 2 ounce measures , and weighed 3 grains .
I repeated the same experiment several times , and always with nearly the same result .
Examining the conducting power of the pieces of charcoal , made with these different circumstances in the process , I could not distinguish which were better .
Perhaps a more accurate method of trying them might show , that those which were coaled slowly were the better conductors ; unless , which is not improbable , the goodness of the conducting power consist in the completeness of the union that is produced between the inflammable principle and its base , which will depend upon the degree of heat only , and not on the quantity of phlogiston thus united to the earth .
N. B. To catch the inflammable air , set loose in making charcoal , I put the substances into a gun barrel , to which I luted a long glass tube , and to the tube I fastened a bladder , out of which the air was carefully pressed .
As metals and charcoal agree in consisting of phlogiston united to an earthly base , and also in conduct~ ing ing electricity , I suspected that these two different substances might also agree in their readiness to expand by heat .
Mr. Smeaton was so obliging as to assist me in my attempts to ascertain this circumstance , by the application of his excellent pyrometer .
Though we could not make the experiment with all the exactness that we could have wished , yet the result of near thirty trials was uniformly in favour of the greater degree of expansion , by heat in the charcoal , than in wood of the same kind , as we imagined , out of which it was made .
In general , the expansion of the charcoal was about double to that of the wood .
It is evident that a certain degree of heat makes wood and charcoal expand , and also that a greater degree of heat makes them contract .
I wish we had an instrument to ascertain the precise degree of heat , at which the expansion ceases , and the contraction begins ; and whether the two effects be produced by the same gradation .
In the course of these experiments on charcoal , I met with a substance , the conducting power of which is singular , and exhibits a beautiful appearance .
In order to see what would remain after burning a quantity of turpentine in a glass tube , I covered it with sand , in a crucible , in the same manner in which I used to make charcoal ; and , after letting it continue a sufficient time , in a very hot fire , and the flame had long ceased , I examined the tube , and found that it had been melted ; but , instead of any thing like charcoal , or the least blackness , I observed that the tube was uniformly lined with a whitish glossy matter , that I could not scrape off .
Upon trying whether it would conduct electricity , I found it transmitted the smallest shocks , to a considerable distance ; and , what appeared very remarkable , the path of the explosion was luminous all the way , and seemed to consist of a prodigious number of small separate sparks , scattered to a great distance , exhibiting such an appearance as would be made by firing gunpowder scattered carelessly in a line .
The explosion very much resembled the firing of a squib .
To compare it to another electric appearance , it was like the explosion passing through a thin surface of gilding .
I imagine that , though I could not perceive any interruption in this white coating , not even by the help of a microscope , it must , in fact , have been full of interstices , and the electric sparks could only be visible in passing from and conducting one particle to another .
In this experiment , I often got pieces of glass very imperfectly covered , with intervals in the white coating very large and visible ; but , though I exposed the same pieces of glass to catch more of this matter , I never could get a coating of it so thick , but that , in transmitting the electrical explosion through it , it exhibited the same luminous appearance , as if there were interstices in the circuit .
I got the same matter from oil of turpentine , and oil of olives ; but not from bees-wax , or spermaceti oil ; perhaps not from any animal substance .
In order to observe the progress of this incrustation , I poured oil of turpentine on some flat pieces of glass , and burnt them on an iron plate , in the open fire , the heat being moderate ; but the effect was a black covering , like soot , which would not conduct in the least .
But these same pieces of glass , thus covered with the black coating , being put into a crucible full of sand , and urged with a strong heat , came out white , and conducted exactly as before .
With a less degree of heat the black covering wa changed to white , but it did not adhere so firmly to the glass , as when the heat had been greater ; though it adhered more closely than the black covering , which might be wiped off with a feather .
But this white coating , produced by a moderate heat , would not conduct at all .
In some cases I have found this whitish matter to be dispersed by several explosions , as Mr. Franklin found gilding with leaf gold to be .
In whatever manner the pieces of glass were covered , the coating vanished when it was made red hot in an open fire ; and the glass that remained would not conduct , any more than it did before .
This circumstance exactly resembled the escape of phlogiston from charcoal and metal , burnt in the open air .
In a microscope , this whitish matter looked exactly like metal , or rather some of the semi-metals , having a bright polish , tho ' it soon became , as it were , tarnished .
To try whether it was metal , I dipped the pieces of glass that were covered with it in the acids , but found that they had little or no effect upon it , though it is by no means fixed in the pores of the glass , but covers it quite superficially .
It was not in the least affected by the magnet .
Upon the whole , the matter that forms this coating of the glass seems to be a kind of charcoal , only white instead of black .
Considering that metals resemble charcoal , in that they consist of an earth united to phlogiston , and that charcoal will not consume without burning in the open air ( there being , probably , something in the atmosphere with which it can unite , on the principle of chemical affinities , the moment it is separated from the metallic base ) I imagined that metals might not calcine or vitrify except in the same circumstances , and the event verified my conjecture .
I took a certain quantity of lead , and having put it into an open crucible , observed that it was all vitrified in 10 minutes ; but the same quantity of lead , covered with pipe clay , and sand , was kept several hours in a much hotter fire , and was hardly wasted at all , the bottom of the crucible only being slightly glazed ; it having been impossible wholly to exclude all access of air , and some being necessarily in contact with it when the process began .
Treating charcoal in the same manner , I could never prevent some loss of weight , when the crucible was kept in a very hot fire , for several hours .
As , by this process , lead will bear a much greater degree of heat than would calcine or vitrify it in the open air , I should think it probable , that lead thus prepared must have the phlogiston more closely united to its earthy base , and be thereby a better conductor than common lead ; since this is the case with charcoal thus treated .
Perhaps lead , and other base metals , may have their quality altered , and be improved in other respects also by this proof ; though they should not be changed into gold by it .
The specific gravity is not changed by this process ; so that , alas !
it is still lead .

