Received June 19 , 1769 .
XXXI .
Account of several Phenomenon observed during the Ingress of Venus into the Solar Disc .
By the Reverend W. Hirst , F. R. S. in a Letter to the Astronomer Royal .
Inner Temple , June 12 , 1769 .
DEARSI R , AGREEABLY to your desire , I now send you a particular account of all the phenomenon I observed during the ingress of Venus into the solar disc ; but , before I do this , I look upon myself as obliged in gratitude to return you many thanks for the kind manner in which you accommodated me with the apparatus necessary for the observation .
The telescope I used , as you well know , belonged to Mr. Dunn , and was a reflector two feet in length , and magnified 55 times .
Expecting the planet to enter the solar disc at or near the zenith , I kept my eye constantly fixed at that part of the Sun a considerable time before the beginning of the transit .
The first intimation which I had of the near approach of the planet , was by the sudden appearance of a violent corruscation , ebullition , Read Nov. 16 , Fig. 1 .
Philos. Trans. Vol. LIX .
TAB. X &amp; XI.p.229 .
5 ab 2 6 3 7 4 8 6 tion , or agitation of the upper edge of the Sun , as in TAB. X. and XI .
fig. 1 .
when I called out to my good friend , governor Vansittart , who was so kind to give himself the trouble of taking the time for me , and desired him to take care .
I had not taken this precaution above five or six seconds , when I plainly saw a black notch breaking in upon the Sun 's limb , and which seemed a portion of a much less sphere than that of Venus , as in fig. 2 .
Instantly I desired Mr. Vansittart , by the word Now , to mark the time , which was 11h 57~ 35~ sidereal time , by Dr. Halley 's little clock , belonging to the royal observatory .
The last-mentioned time , allowing for the necessary corrections , and reduced to apparent time , is 7h 11~ 11~ As I imagined , from the instructions of Dr. Halley , that the precise and accurate time of observing the internal contact is , when the thread of light should break in between the concave edge of the Sun and the convex edge of Venus , as in fig. 6 .
I waited till that particular period , which was when Dr. Halley 's clock marked 12h 15~ 45~ , sidereal time , or 7h 29~ 18~ , apparent time , the difference being 18~ 7~ of apparent time .
The same phenomenon of a protuberance , which I observed at Madras , in 1761 , * at both internal contacts , I observed again at this last transit : at both times , the protuberance of the upper edge of Venus diminished nearly to a point before the thread of light between the concave edge of the Sun , and the convex edge was perfected , when the protuberance instantaneously * Philos. Trans. vol. LII .
part i. 1761 , p. 396 .
broke off from the upper edge of the Sun , but Venus did not assume its circular form till it had descended into the solar disc , at least to the distance , by estimation , from the upper edge of the Sun , as described in fig. 7 .
Although at the time of the contacts the atmosphere was remarkably clear , yet , as the Sun descended towards the horizon , the atmosphere grew more and more hazy , so that the edge of the Sun , as well as the edge of the Planet , began to grow more and more tremulous , and caused the Planet to assume , in appearance , different configurations , resembling sometimes a prolate and sometimes an oblate spheroid , till we lost sight of the Sun by its being intercepted by a dark cloud , or rather fog-bank , some time before the calculated time of Sun-set .
Although these last phenomenon are entirely optical deceptions , owing to the state of the air at that particular time , or to horizontal vapours , yet I beg it may be here very carefully remarked , that , at the times of the contacts , the air , as you can bear me witness , was perfectly clear and favourable , so that our observations were then certain , and not subjected to any fallacy in vision .
The following circumstance is a proof of this assertion .
The first warning which I had of the near approach of Venus to the Sun 's external edge was , as I have before said , by the sudden appearance of a violent corruscation , ebullition , or agitation of the upper edge of the Sun , five or six seconds before the edge of Venus broke in upon the Sun ; where alone I observed the violent agitation , the edge on each side remaining perfectly quiescent , as a , b , fig. 1 .
If this appearance had been owing to the state of our atmosphere only , then would the edge of the Sun be universally fluctuating or trembling ; but as this was not the case , the undulation must be imputed to some other cause not improbably to an atmosphere about Venus .
I am the more minute on this circumstance , because you yourself , Sir , in a late * publication , have taken notice , that when I took the observation of the transit of Venus at Madras , in the year 1761 , I saw a kind of penumbra or dusky shade , which preceded the first external contact two or three seconds of time , and was so remarkable , that I was thereby assured the contact was approaching , which happened accordingly .
Upon your foregoing paragraph I must beg leave to make the following remark , that in the transit of this present year I did not take notice of the same phenomenon as I did of the transit of Venus in India , in the year 1761 ; but I must here again insist upon it , that such penumbra or dusky shade I then actually saw , but I do not recollect I then saw the least undulation , ebullition , or corruscation , as happened in the transit of this present year .
Yet both phenomenon were conducive to the same purpose , and served to give me notice of the near approach of the planet Venus to the solar disc , the event , in both instances , justifying the presage ; and both appearances might be the consequences of the same cause ; which cause , as I have before observed , might be nothing less than the atmosphere of Venus .
I say might be , for I would not be understood to assert here any * Instructions relative to the observation of the ensuing transit of the planet Venus over the Sun 's disc , on the 3d of June 1769 .
By the Rev. Nevil Maskelyne , Astronomer Royal , p. 32 .
thing dogmatical , preserving at this time the same diffidence in expression as I made use of when I observed the transit of Venus in India , where I was apprehensive , that to * be able to discern an atmosphere about a planet at so great a distance as Venus may be regarded as chimerical : yet I may venture to say , that my observation of the transit of the present year seems to corroborate my assertion , in the account of the transit observed in India , in 1761 ; however , I shall not here peremptorily assign the cause , leaving such remarks to be made by others .
On my return from India , I was glad to find I was not particular in remarking the strange phenomenon of the oblongation of the orb of Venus at the time of both the internal contacts .
It was with sensible pleasure I have seen , in the ~ Philosophical Transactions , that four astronomers at Upsal , in Sweden , as well as ~ Mr. Dunn , in England , took notice of the same or similar circumstances .
The appearance of this protuberance or ligament must now be universally confirmed , especially by all observers of the transit of the present year , at least by all such who have viewed it through telescopes of sufficient magnifying powers , and who have sense enough to believe their own eyes , or candour enough to embrace and acknowledge conviction , malgre all prejudice and preconceived opinion .
Fig. 1 .
represents the first presage I had of the approach of Venus to the Sun 's external disc .
Fig. 2 .
is the appearance of the black notch , when I noted * Philos. Trans. vol. LII .
part i. 1761 , p. 396 .
~ Ibid. p. 227 .
and vol. LVI , 1766 , p. 72 .
~ Ibid. p. 184 .
the time of the first external contact .
Fig. 3 .
is the body of the planet within the solar disc , adhering to the Sun 's upper edge , the thread of light not yet formed .
Fig. 4 the protuberance forming , and the undulation at , c , d , very violent , better seen in fig. 8 .
Fig. 5 .
the undulation decreasing , and the protuberance forming itself into a point , the luminous filaments darting between the edges of the Sun and the planet .
Fig. 6 .
the luminous filaments cease to move , and the upper edge of the planet is well defined .
Its whole orb more opaque , but not yet divested of its oval appearance , the thread of light at c , d , is formed ; and at this period I marked down the time of the internal contact .
Fig. 7 .
the planet is restored to its circular figure .
I shall conclude this account with a few remarks I think it necessary to make on the manner in which my observation of the transit in India , in 1761 , was inserted in the Philosophical Transactions .
I am very much grieved , that the observations of the equal altitudes and meridional transits for regulating my time-keeper were altogether omitted .
Had this not been the case , every one might have judged of the care and pains I took in that distant part of the world , as well in making several of my instruments myself , as in using them when made .
What degree of confidence was to be given to my observations might be easily seen .
Monsieur Pingre * would have had no occasion to lament that I did not acquaint the world in what manner I observed the equal altitudes to determine the passage either of a fixed star , or of the Sun over the * Philos. Trans. vol. LIV .
1764 , p. 156 .
meridian , &amp;c. If these particulars had been inserted , there would have been no occasion likewise to alter my numbers respecting the periods of the transit , since every astronomer , from the previous observations , might draw his own conclusions .
Observations ought not to be rejected or stifled because they do not entirely suit any adopted system , or favourite parallactic angle .
If I declared I saw an oblongation of the planet Venus , it ought not to be discredited because another did not see it .
If I gave reasons for suggesting that Venus had an atmosphere , but had not a satellite , the report should have been impartially stated , though another should be of a contrary opinion .
I shall beg leave to extract the following paragraph from my original letter from India to Lord Macclesfield , on the subject of the transit of Venus , in the year 1761 , which , for what good reason I know not , was suppressed , and had not the honour of a place in the Philosophical Transactions ; but which I am the more desirous should now be inserted , as it tends to elucidate a matter of fact , and to render indisputable an astronomical truth , only to be established by those who had the opportunity of seeing as I did , the entire passage of Venus over the solar disc .
The paragraph is as follows : Looking over the Philosophical Transactions , some time before the transit , I found Mr. Short had observed a small star near Venus , which had the same phasis as that planet .
This gave suspicion that Venus was attended with a satellite .
A corroborating circumstance was added , viz , M. Cassini , in his Elements d ' Astronomy , mentions a like observation .
This I regarded as a favourable opportunity , concluding , that if Venus had a satellite , it must be seen at its transit over the Sun 's disc ; accordingly , I gave notice of this to Captain Barker , of the Company 's Artillery ' ' ( now Colonel Sir Robert Barker ) , ` ` who took the observation at Pondicherry .
I also mentioned it to the Jesuits , who observed at the Great Mount , about 7 1/ 2 miles S. 50~ W. of Madras , but neither of them saw any appearance in the least like a satellite .
I also spoke of it to Governor Pigot ' ' ( now Lord Pigot ) ` ` and Mr. Call , who with myself saw not the least speck attending that planet ; whence we may now venture to affirm , That Venus has not a Satellite .
' ' I am , with great respect , DEARSI R , Your affectionate , humble servant , W. Hirst .
Hh2 XXXII .
Obser-

